Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.06
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
OWP No. 620/2013 c/w
WP(C) No. 1298/2021
„
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Niranjan Singh
Through: Mr. Karman Singh Johal,Advocate.
vs
State th. Custodian Property & ors.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG with
Ms. Sagira Jaffar, Advocate.
Mr. Ashok Sharma, Advocate.
Mr. K. S. Puri, Advocate.
Mr. Adarsh Bhagat, GA.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
ORDER(ORAL)
19.11.2026
OWP No. 620/2013
1.
The predecessor-in-interest of the private respondents, namely, Mehar
Singh, preferred a revision petition before the Custodian Evacuee Property,
Jammu, challenging the order dated 05.05.1997 passed by the Assistant
Custodian, R.S. Pura, whereby the subject land, measuring 16 kanals
(comprising 1 kanal under Survey No. 902 and 15 kanals under Survey No.
906), situated at Village Chakroi, Tehsil R.S. Pura, was regularized in favour
of the petitioner.
2.
Order dated 05.05.1997 was set aside by the Custodian Evacuee Property,
Jammu in terms of order dated 28.02.2004 and matter was remanded to
Assistant Custodian, R. S. Pura.
3.
The petitioner assailed the order dated 28.02.2004 before the Divisional
Commissioner, Jammu with powers of the Deputy Custodian General and in
OWP No. 620/2013 &
WP(C) No. 1298/2021
terms of order dated 29.12.2006, the said Revision petition too came to be
dismissed.
4.
Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner filed another revision petition before
the J&K Special Tribunal Jammu, which too came to be dismissed in terms
of order dated 25.02.2010. As such, order dated 28.02.2004 has attained
finality.
5.
As the matter was remitted to the Assistant Custodian, Tehsildar, R.S. Pura
in terms of order dated 28.02.2004 passed by the Custodian, Evacuee
Property, the Assistant Custodian Evacuee Property in terms of order dated
27.07.2011 observed that order dated 05.05.1997 being non-existent should
be ignored and directed the handing over of the possession of the subject
evacuee property to the predecessor-in-interest of the private respondents
(who, for convenience, hereinafter shall be referred to as “allottee”).
6.
This order became the subject matter of another revision petition preferred
by the petitioner, but the petitioner remained unsuccessful as the said
revision petition came to be dismissed by the Custodian Evacuee Property in
terms of order dated 20.04.2012.
7.
The order of 20.04.2012 was assailed by the petitioner through the medium
of another revision petition, but yet again the petitioner remained unsuccessful as the said revision petition too came to be dismissed in terms of
order dated 26.04.2013 passed by the J&K Special Tribunal. This is how this
petition has landed before this Court through the medium of which the
petitioner has assailed the order dated 26.04.2013, whereby the order dated
20.04.2012 passed by respondent No. 2 and order dated 20.07.2012 passed
by respondent No. 3 have been upheld.
8.
OWP No. 620/2013 &
WP(C) No. 1298/2021
The order impugned has been assailed by the petitioner primarily on the
ground that respondent No. 4 was bound to take possession within six
months from the date of allotment and failure on his part to take possession
within six months, has rendered his allotment liable for cancellation in
accordance with Rule 5 and 6 of Cabinet order No. 578-C of 1954, but the
authorities below have wrongly held that the protection of Rule 6 was
available to the predecessor-in-interest of the private respondents.
9.
Counter-affidavit has been filed by the private respondents, stating therein
that their predecessor-in-interest i.e. the allottee, was a refugee of 1947,
residing in Village Dhammi Tehsil Palandri, District Poonch and due to
Indo-Pak conflict of 1947, he was compelled to leave his native place and
crossed over to this side of J&K State. As such, he became a refugee of
1947. Being a displaced person, form Alif was issued in his favour by the
PRO, Jammu in terms of the Cabinet order 578-C of 1954. He was allotted
16 Kanals of land situated at Village Chakroi, Tehsil R. S. Pura, District
Jammu as mentioned above and the possession of the same was handed over
to him on 09.09.2011, equivalent to English Calendar year 1954. It is stated
that as the predecessor-in-interest of the private respondents was in Indian
Army, he allowed one Dulla S/o Vadawa Sansi to cultivate the land because
he was exempted from personal cultivation of the land in terms of para 6 of
Cabinet order No. 578-C of 1954. To substantiate this contention, the private
respondents have placed on record the Girdawari of the relevant year. It is
the stand of the private respondents that the petitioner obtained the
possession of the subject land from the tenant of allottee by illegal means in
his absence. And, as such, after his retirement, when he came to know that
the land has been obtained by the petitioner through illegal means and even
OWP No. 620/2013 &
WP(C) No. 1298/2021
got the same regularized in his favour by the Assistant Custodian, R. S. Pura
in terms of order dated 05.05.1997, he assailed the same before Custodian
Evacuee Property, Jammu. The private respondents have mentioned the
history of litigation, which led to the passing of the order impugned by the
learned Special Tribunal.
10.
Respondent No.2 has also filed the response opposing the maintainability of
writ petition.
11.
In rejoinder to the counter-affidavit filed by respondent Nos. 4 and 5, the
petitioner has stated that when the land was allotted, the allottee was not in
the Defence Forces and arguendo, the petitioner was serving in Defence
Forces at the time of allotment/delivery of possession of the land in question,
he was under an obligation to get the said land cultivated through hired
labourer, but the same was not done and, as such, he had forfeited his right
to occupy the land in question.
12.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the material on
record.
13.
There is no dispute that the order dated 05.05.1997, whereby the petitioner's
possession was regularized by the Assistant Custodian, R.S. Pura was set
aside by the Custodian Evacuee Property, and the matter was remanded to
the Assistant Custodian (Tehsildar), R.S. Pura. The said order was
challenged before the Divisional Commissioner and subsequently before the
J&K Special Tribunal, both unsuccessfully. Consequently, the quashing of
the order dated 05.05.1997 attained finality in the earlier round of litigation.
In the subsequent order dated 27.07.2011, the Assistant Custodian
(Tehsildar), R.S. Pura, rightly concluded that no valid order dated
05.05.1997 existed, observing that no such order had been passed by the
OWP No. 620/2013 &
WP(C) No. 1298/2021
Tehsildar and that the entry was instead incorporated into the records in
connivance with the revenue field agency by taking advantage of the
allottee's absence. In absence of any valid order, the petitioner's status
remains that of an unauthorized occupant of evacuee property allotted to the
original allottee.
14.
In this round of the litigation, the petitioner has thrown challenge to order
dated 27.07.2011 passed by the Assistant Custodian R. S. Pura, primarily on
the ground that it was incumbent on the part of the allottee to get the
possession within the period of six months of allotment and having failed to
do so, the order dated 27.07.2011 could not have been passed by the
Assistant Custodian Tehsildar, R. S. Pura.
15.
The counter-affidavit filed by the private respondents reveals that possession
was taken over by the original allottee on 09.09.2011 (Bikrami),
corresponding to the year 1954 of the Gregorian calendar. This fact is duly
substantiated by the possession receipt dated 09.09.2011 (Bikrami) regarding
the handing over of the subject land to the allottee, issued by the Deputy
PRO, Jammu. Further, the Girdawaris for the year 1967 reveal that the land
was being cultivated by the allottee through Dulla as his tenant-at-will, since
the allottee could not personally cultivate the land on account of serving in
the defence forces.
16.
Mr. Karman Singh Johal, learned counsel for the petitioner has tried to
persuade this Court that the allottee was not in Defence Forces and further
the land was not cultivated within a period of six months from obtaining/
delivery of the possession, as such, the order impugned dated 27.07.2011
could not have been passed.
17.
OWP No. 620/2013 &
WP(C) No. 1298/2021
Private respondents have placed on record the Army Discharge Book and
IAF discharge book to establish that the original allottee namely, Mehar
Singh served in the Indian Army from 15.04.1948 to 22.04.66 and in the
Indian Air Force from 01.06.1970 to 30.04.1983. Thus, the petitioner has no
case on merits.
18.
All the contentions raised by Mr. Johal, learned counsel are attractive at first
blush, yet they are noted only to be rejected. These grounds cannot be
invoked to protect an illegal and unauthorized occupation, as it is the
specific case of the allottee and his successors-in-interest that the petitioner
unlawfully took possession of land allotted to the original allottee, more
particularly since the order dated 05.05.1997, pursuant to which the
petitioner's possession was regularized, has already been set aside by the
Custodian, Jammu, and that order has attained finality.
19.
Otherwise also, the grounds urged by the petitioner to protect his illegal
possession can be invoked only by the statutory authorities for cancelling an
allotment, and the petitioner, being a mere trespasser, cannot be permitted to
take advantage of such contentions merely to perpetuate his unauthorized
occupation.
20.
This court has examined the orders passed by the statutory authorities and
the said authorities have rightly determined the controversy, in fact leaving
no scope for interference by this court. Concurrent findings of fact have been
consistently recorded by the authorities below. In exercise of its power of
judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, this Court
cannot sit as an appellate or revisional court, particularly when the statutory
authorities have rightly determined the controversy. It would be apt to take
note of the judgment of the Hon‟ble Apex Court rendered in Central
OWP No. 620/2013 &
WP(C) No. 1298/2021
Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences v. Bikartan Das, (2023) 16
SCC 462, wherein, it has been held as under:
“63. Thus, from the various decisions referred to above, we have
no hesitation in reaching to the conclusion that a writ of certiorari
is a high prerogative writ and should not be issued on mere
asking. For the issue of a writ of certiorari, the party concerned
has to make out a definite case for the same and is not a matter of
course. To put it pithily, certiorari shall issue to correct errors
of jurisdiction, that is to say, absence, excess or failure to
exercise and also when in the exercise of undoubted
jurisdiction, there has been illegality. It shall also issue to
correct an error in the decision or determination itself, if it is
an error manifest on the face of the proceedings. By its
exercise, only a patent error can be corrected but not also a
wrong decision. It should be well remembered at the cost of
repetition that certiorari is not appellate but only
supervisory.
64. A writ of certiorari, being a high prerogative writ, is issued by
a superior court in respect of the exercise of judicial or quasijudicial functions by another authority when the contention is that
the exercising authority had no jurisdiction or exceeded the
jurisdiction. It cannot be denied that the tribunals or the
authorities concerned in this batch of appeals had the jurisdiction
to deal with the matter. However, the argument would be that the
tribunals had acted arbitrarily and illegally and that they had
failed to give proper findings on the facts and circumstances of
the case. We may only say that while adjudicating a writ
application for a writ of certiorari, the court is not sitting as a
court of appeal against the order of the tribunals to test the
legality thereof with a view to reach a different conclusion. If
there is any evidence, the court will not examine whether the
right conclusion is drawn from it or not. It is a wellestablished principle of law that a writ of certiorari will not
lie where the order or decision of a tribunal or authority is
wrong in matter of facts or on merits. (See :R. v. Nat Bell
Liquors Ltd. [R. v. Nat Bell Liquors Ltd., (1922) 2 AC 128
(PC)])”
(emphasis added)
21.
Mr. K. S. Puri, learned counsel appearing for the private respondents is right
in his submissions that there are six concurrent findings recorded by
different
authorities
in
the hierarchy under
the J&K
Evacuees'
OWP No. 620/2013 &
WP(C) No. 1298/2021
(Administration of Property) Act, Samvat 2006, and that the present petition
is nothing but an abuse of the process of law.
22.
In view of the above, though this petition deserves to be dismissed with
costs by taking lenient view of the matter, the present petition is dismissed
without costs.
23.
After this Court dismissed this petition, learned counsel for the petitioner
requested that 15 days‟ time be granted to the petitioner to assail the order
passed by this Court and till date, the parties be directed to maintain status
quo. The request is not opposed by Mr. Puri, learned counsel for the private
respondents.
24.
Accordingly, the parties shall maintain status quo for 15 days from the date
of uploading of order.
WP(C) No. 1298/2021
25.
As the connected petition has been dismissed by this Court, Mr. Ashok
Sharma submits that petitioner be permitted to withdraw this petition to
pursue the matter before the authorities in view of the response filed by
them.
26.
Disposed of accordingly.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
Jammu
19.11.2026
Neha-1
Whether the judgment is reportable:
Neha Kumari
2026.11.21 15:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
YES
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review