Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 7
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Uploaded on: 21.11.2026
OWP No. 1825/2013
‘
Nancy Koul and another
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Virender Bhat, Advocate.
vs
.…. Respondent(s)
State of J&K and others
Through: Ms. Sagira Jaffar, Advocate vice
Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
Mr. Dheeraj Sharma, Advocate.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
19.11.2026
1.
The predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners, namely, Sarwanand Koul
was the owner of land measuring 35 Kanals and 15 Marlas (Survey No.
577 and 644) situated at Vessu, Tehsil Doru and 33 Kanals 08 Marlas
(Survey No. 181, 182, 187, 195 and 344) situated at Manigam, Tehsil and
District Kulgam.
2.
The father of the petitioners came to demise on 13.11.2008 at Subash
Nagar, Jammu. It is stated that father of the petitioners submitted an
application for resumption of land to respondent No. 3 under receipt No.
19 dated 12.01.1979, but the application stated to have been filed by the
father of the petitioners remained undecided till his migration from the
valley. After migration, respondent Nos. 5 to 9 started raising construction
over the land under their cultivation as tenants and started alienating the
same. Father of the petitioners submitted an application dated 17.08.1999
OWP No. 1825/2013
with the Financial Commissioner i.e. respondent No. 2. In terms of order
dated 18.08.1999 issued by respondent No. 2, the Tehsildar concerned was
directed to take steps for disposal of the resumption application and ensure
that no alienation of the land takes place.
3.
Tehsildar Qazigund vide communication dated 06.08.2003 intimated the
father of the petitioners that the resumption form was not traceable,
therefore, he was asked to furnish receipt of the resumption application in
support of his claim, which in turn was submitted to the respondent No. 3
by the father of the petitioners vide representation dated 07.02.2007. In the
meanwhile, some land owned by the father of the petitioners, but in
possession of the tenants (19 Kanal 19 Marlas) comprising survey No. 577
situated at Vessu was acquired by the Industries Department and 50% of
the compensation was paid to him. Further, another stretch of land (Survey
No. 644) situated at Vessu was acquired by the National Highway. Then
only the petitioners came to know from their friend that respondent Nos. 5
to 9 were claiming entire compensation on the basis of mutation attested
under Section 8 of the Agrarian Reforms Act. Thereafter, the petitioners
filed appeals against mutation No. 724 claimed to have been attested
under Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act and Mutation No. 817 dated
13.10.2006 attested under Section 8 of the Agrarian Reforms Act
comprising land measuring 16 Kanal 18 Marlas falling under Survey No.
644 situated at village Vessu, Tehsil Duru District Anantnag.
4.
Both the mutations i.e. mutation No. 724 claimed to have been attested
under Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act and Mutation No. 817
attested under Section 8 of the Agrarian Reforms Act were assailed on the
OWP No. 1825/2013
grounds that as the resumption application preferred by father of the
petitioners was still pending, so the issue of ownership could not have
been decided under Section 8 of the Agrarian Reforms Act and mere order
of rejection of the resumption application was solely the result of
connivance of the respondent Nos. 5 to 9 with the Revenue Officials. It
was also contended that as the petitioners were migrants and the property
fell within the ambit of The Jammu and Kashmir Immovable Property
(Preservation, Protection and Restraint on Distress Sales) Act, 1997 and
The Jammu and Kashmir Migrants (Stay of Proceedings) Act, 1997,
therefore, it was not open to the Authorities to deal with any matter
regarding property of the petitioners.
5.
The aforesaid appeals were contested by the respondent Nos. 5 to 9 and
the respondent No. 2, in terms of order dated 17.12.2013, dismissed the
appeals preferred by the petitioners.
6.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners have approached this Court to assail the
order dated 17.12.2013, inter alia, on grounds identical to those set out
above.
7.
Respondent Nos. 5 to 9 have stated that after attestation of mutation
bearing No. 550 under Section 4 of the Act, the land had already vested in
the State and tenant Ahad Shah was declared as prospective owner. The
said mutation was never challenged by anyone. In the year 1985,
Sarvanand Koul started making false claim that he had filed the
resumption application before Deputy Commissioner Anantnag. Detailed
enquiry was conducted by Tehsildar in presence of both the parties and
finally it was found that no resumption form was ever filed. So final order
OWP No. 1825/2013
on mutation No. 615 under section 7 of the Act was passed, which was
duly signed by Sarvanand. The said order was never challenged by anyone
including Sarvanand during his lifetime.
8.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
9.
The main contention raised by the petitioners is that once their father had
filed an application for resumption of property under Section 7 of the
Agrarian Reforms Act and the same was not finally adjudicated, Official
respondents could not have attested mutation No. 817 under Section 8 of
the Agrarian Reforms Act.
10.
A perusal of the record reveals that mutation No. 724 claimed to have
been attested under Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act was never
formed part of the appeal. Rather it was mutation No. 615 attested on
19.05.1985 pursuant to which claim of father of the petitioners for
resumption of land was rejected. In the order dated 26.06.1985, statement
of predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners was recorded, wherein he had
stated that he had submitted the form with the Tehsildar’s Office, but his
contention was rejected with an observation that he was not entitled to
resumption of land. The said mutation order carries signatures of
predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners i.e. Sarwanand Koul, who came
to demise in the year 2008 and during his lifetime neither he, nor after his
demise, the petitioners assailed this mutation order No. 615 dated
26.06.1985.
11.
Although a feeble attempt was made by the petitioners before the
Appellate Authority, i.e., the Financial Commissioner (Revenue), it
recorded a categorical finding that no substantial evidence had been
OWP No. 1825/2013
produced in support of the denial of signatures on the aforesaid mutation
(supra).
12.
Interestingly, same is the situation before this Court as well. At the cost of
repetition, it is observed that mutation No. 615 was never assailed, as
such, has attained finality. Therefore, there is no force in the contention
raised by the petitioners. Accordingly, the same is rejected.
13.
Lastly it has been contended that once the property fell within the ambit of
The Jammu and Kashmir Immovable Property (Preservation, Protection
and Restraint on Distress Sales) Act, 1997 and The Jammu and Kashmir
Migrants (Stay of Proceedings) Act, 1997, Official respondents were not
competent to attest the mutation under Section 8 of the Agrarian Reforms
Act and more particularly when the Financial Commissioner (Revenue), in
terms of order dated 18.08.1999 had directed the Tehsildar to take steps
for disposal of the resumption application and not to permit any alienation
of land.
14.
This contention might have carried weight with this Court had the
resumption application been pending before the Authority concerned upon
the enactment and enforcement of the Jammu and Kashmir Migrant
Immovable Property (Preservation, Protection and Restraint on Distress
Sales) Act, 1997, and the Jammu and Kashmir Migrants (Stay of
Proceedings) Act, 1997. Since the claim of the petitioners' predecessor-ininterest stood rejected by the order dated 26.06.1985, no resumption
proceedings were pending when the Acts (supra) came into operation,
there is no merit in this contention and accordingly fails.
15.
OWP No. 1825/2013
This Court has perused the order impugned passed by the Appellate
Authority and finds that the Appellate Authority has rightly dealt with the
matter in accordance with law. Needless to say that while exercising
power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, this Court cannot sit
as a court of appeal/revision over the decision recorded by the Appellate
Authority within the parameters of law. It would be apt to take note of the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court rendered in Central Council for
Research in Ayurvedic Sciences v. Bikartan Das, (2023) 16 SCC 462,
wherein, it has been held as under:
63. Thus, from the various decisions referred to above, we have
no hesitation in reaching to the conclusion that a writ of
certiorari is a high prerogative writ and should not be issued on
mere asking. For the issue of a writ of certiorari, the party
concerned has to make out a definite case for the same and is not
a matter of course. To put it pithily, certiorari shall issue to
correct errors of jurisdiction, that is to say, absence, excess
or failure to exercise and also when in the exercise of
undoubted jurisdiction, there has been illegality. It shall also
issue to correct an error in the decision or determination
itself, if it is an error manifest on the face of the proceedings.
By its exercise, only a patent error can be corrected but not
also a wrong decision. It should be well remembered at the
cost of repetition that certiorari is not appellate but only
supervisory.
64. A writ of certiorari, being a high prerogative writ, is issued
by a superior court in respect of the exercise of judicial or quasijudicial functions by another authority when the contention is
that the exercising authority had no jurisdiction or exceeded the
jurisdiction. It cannot be denied that the tribunals or the
authorities concerned in this batch of appeals had the
jurisdiction to deal with the matter. However, the argument
would be that the tribunals had acted arbitrarily and illegally and
that they had failed to give proper findings on the facts and
circumstances of the case. We may only say that while
adjudicating a writ application for a writ of certiorari, the
court is not sitting as a court of appeal against the order of
the tribunals to test the legality thereof with a view to reach
OWP No. 1825/2013
a different conclusion. If there is any evidence, the court will
not examine whether the right conclusion is drawn from it
or not. It is a well-established principle of law that a writ of
certiorari will not lie where the order or decision of a
tribunal or authority is wrong in matter of facts or on
merits. (See :R. v. Nat Bell Liquors Ltd. [R. v. Nat Bell Liquors
Ltd., (1922) 2 AC 128 (PC)] )
(emphasis added)
16.
Before parting, this court would like to observe that father of the petitioners
did not challenge the mutation bearing No. 550 attested under Section 4 of
the Act, and the petitioners without availing the remedy of appeal for the
purpose of assailing the mutation No. 550 attested under section 4 of the
Act, have assailed the same for the first time in the present petition, but
without mentioning any ground as to how the said mutation is bad in law,
which admittedly was attested prior to migration from the valley. This
belated challenge without any ground and availing the remedy of appeal is
clear an afterthought and is mis-conceived.
17.
In view of the above, this Court is of the considered view that this petition
lacks merits and the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
Jammu
19.11.2026
Sahil Padha
Sahil Padha
2026.11.21 16:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review