Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 105
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
Date of Pronouncement: 19.11.2026.
Date of Uploading:
21.11.2026.
1. Sanjay Arora,
S/o Late Sh. Roshan Lal
R/O H.No. 64, Sector-2,
Gali No. 5, Delhi-110051.
2. Sangeeta Khanna,
W/o Rakesh Khanna,
R/O. H.No. 419, Ramesh Nagar,
West Delhi, Delhi-110015.
3. Sumit Khanna,
S/O Rakesh Khanna
R/O H.No. 419, Ramesh Nagar,
West Delhi, Delhi-110015.
4. Meena Popli,
W/O Naresh Popli.
5. Naresh Popli,
Husband of Meena Popli,
Both R/O WZ 430-A, First Floor
Nanakpuri, Hari Nagar, South West
Delhi-110064.
6. Vijay Kumar, S/O Raj Dutt.
7. Nirmal Kumari, W/O Vijay Kumar,
Both residents of G-1145, Phase-1,
Budh Vihar, Sultanpuri C Block,
North West Delhi-110086.
8. Ravesh Kumar, S/O Sarban Kumar
9. Shoba Dingra, W/O Ravesh Kumar,
Both residents of 9-B,
Opposite Radhapuri, New Krishna
Nagar, East Delhi-110051.
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
10. Indu Arora,
W/O Ajit Arora,
R/O 64/3, Radhapuri,
Phase-II, Sector-5,
Karan Nagar,
East Delhi-110051.
Through: Mr. C.S. Gupta, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Snigdha Shekhar, Adovcate
vs
1. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir,
through Commissioner/Secretary Home,
Civil Secretariat Srinagar.
.…. Respondent(s)
2. SHO/In Charge, Police Station,
Women Cell, Gandhi Nagar,
Jammu. 180004.
3. Kailash Arora
D/O Late Sh. Inder Kumar Sethi
R/O 3511, Mohalla Paharian,
Jammu. 180001.
Through: Mr. Anuj Dewan Raina, Advocate for R-3.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The petitioners, who are the husband, in-laws and close relatives of
respondent No. 3, have invoked the jurisdiction of this Court seeking
quashment of FIR No. 30/2024, registered pursuant to an order passed by
the learned Sub Judge, Special Mobile Magistrate (Electricity), Jammu, in
exercise of powers under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., for the commission of
offences punishable under Sections 498-A, 109 and 506 IPC. The principal
contention of the petitioners is that the impugned FIR constitutes a manifest
abuse of the process of law, particularly when the parties have been
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
embroiled in matrimonial litigation before different Courts since the year
2011. It is contended that the allegations contained in the complaint, even if
taken at their face value, do not disclose the essential ingredients of the
offences alleged against the petitioners.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that respondent No. 3 has
already instituted several proceedings against petitioner No. 1, including
proceedings under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act
and Section 125 Cr.P.C. It is further submitted that, earlier, when petitioner
No. 1 instituted a petition seeking dissolution of marriage, respondent No.
3, as a counterblast thereto, lodged FIR No. 74/2014 against him and his
relatives. The said FIR was subsequently quashed by this Court vide order
dated 03.06.2017, following an amicable settlement between the parties.
Pursuant to the settlement, petitioner No. 1 withdrew the divorce petition,
whereafter the parties resumed cohabitation and continued their
matrimonial relationship.
4.
The petitioners further contend that it is respondent No. 3 who is unwilling
to resume matrimonial cohabitation and has been levelling false and
exaggerated allegations against petitioner No. 1 and his family members. It
is submitted that, before directing registration of the impugned FIR, the
learned Magistrate had called for a report from the SHO, Police Station
Women Cell, Jammu. The police, upon conducting an enquiry, reported
that the dispute was essentially matrimonial in nature and that the parties
required counselling. The report further indicated that, notwithstanding the
registration of the earlier FIR, respondent No. 3 had resumed matrimonial
relations with petitioner No. 1, who was willing to take her back, whereas
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
she was reluctant to join his company. According to the petitioners, despite
the aforesaid report, the learned Magistrate proceeded to direct registration
of the FIR without adequately considering whether the allegations disclosed
the commission of any cognizable offence. It is, therefore, urged that the
impugned FIR deserves to be quashed.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 3 has vehemently
opposed the petition, contending that the complainant had been subjected to
persistent acts of cruelty and harassment at the hands of the petitioners,
which had earlier compelled her to lodge criminal proceedings against
them. It is submitted that the earlier dispute was amicably settled in the
legitimate expectation that petitioner No. 1 and his family members would
mend their conduct and discharge their matrimonial obligations. However,
according to respondent No. 3, the acts of cruelty and harassment continued
even after the reconciliation.
6.
It is further alleged that petitioner No. 1 has been acting under the influence
of his sister-in-law (Bhabhi), stated to be petitioner No. 2, who has been
interfering in the matrimonial relationship and preventing petitioner No. 1
from discharging his obligations towards respondent No. 3. The
complainant has also attributed her miscarriages in the years 2013 and 2014
to the alleged acts of cruelty and harassment. It is her further case that, even
after resumption of cohabitation, she was not permitted to lead a peaceful
matrimonial life and was subjected to various acts of domestic violence.
The petitioners are also alleged to have demanded an amount of ₹20 lakhs
as dowry from respondent No. 3 and her family members, thereby
compelling her to initiate the present criminal proceedings.
7.
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
Respondent No. 3 has further alleged that the petitioners have been
unnecessarily interfering in her matrimonial affairs and instigating
petitioner No. 1 to subject her to cruelty and harassment. It is contended
that the complaint, read as a whole, clearly discloses the commission of
cognizable offences and, therefore, the learned Magistrate was justified in
directing registration of the FIR under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.
Consequently, it is urged that the investigation ought to be permitted to
proceed to its logical conclusion without interference by this Court.
8.
The background of the matrimonial dispute is, by and large, undisputed.
The marriage between petitioner No. 1 and respondent No. 3 was
solemnised in the year 2011. According to respondent No. 3, she suffered
miscarriages in the years 2013 and 2014 on account of the alleged cruelty
and harassment inflicted upon her by the petitioners. Subsequently,
petitioner No. 1 instituted a petition seeking dissolution of marriage before
a competent Court at Delhi. Respondent No. 3, in turn, lodged FIR No.
74/2014 against petitioner No. 1 and thirteen of his relatives, alleging
commission of offences under Section 498-A IPC. The parties thereafter
arrived at an amicable settlement, pursuant to which petitioner No. 1
withdrew the divorce petition and both sides expressed their willingness to
resume matrimonial cohabitation. Taking note of the settlement, this Court,
vide order dated 03.06.2017, quashed FIR No. 74/2014. Thus, the earlier
criminal proceedings came to an end in the year 2017, whereafter the
parties admittedly resumed cohabitation for some time.
9.
It appears that matrimonial discord resurfaced sometime after the year
2022, leading respondent No. 3 to institute proceedings under the
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act. Petitioner No. 1, on the
other hand, instituted a fresh petition for dissolution of marriage in the year
2023 before the competent Court at Karkardooma, New Delhi. In the said
proceedings, respondent No. 3 moved an application seeking maintenance
pendente lite. She also instituted separate proceedings under Section 125
Cr.P.C. for grant of maintenance, which are stated to be pending before the
Court of the Additional District Judge, Family Court, Jammu.
Subsequently, respondent No. 3 approached the learned Special Mobile
Magistrate by way of an application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., alleging
commission of offences under Section 498-A IPC and other allied
provisions against the petitioners.
10.
It is not in dispute that, during the pendency of the proceedings before the
learned Magistrate, a report was called for from the SHO, Police Station
Women Cell, Jammu. The report indicated the existence of matrimonial
discord between the parties and suggested that they required counselling.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has placed considerable reliance upon
the said report to contend that the allegations did not disclose the
commission of any cognizable offence, much less an offence punishable
under Section 498-A IPC. It is further urged that the application under
Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. was bereft of specific allegations constituting the
essential ingredients of the offences attributed to the petitioners.
11.
A perusal of the complaint forming the basis of the impugned FIR reveals
that, according to respondent No. 3, the matrimonial relationship became
strained and the parties started residing separately after the year 2022. The
principal allegation levelled against petitioner No. 1 is that he demanded
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
₹20 lakhs as dowry and made her return to the matrimonial home at Delhi
conditional upon fulfilment of the said demand. It is further alleged that, in
June 2020, petitioner No. 1, along with his sister-in-law (Bhabhi),
physically assaulted respondent No. 3 and questioned her failure to arrange
the demanded amount. The complainant has also alleged that, when she
visited Delhi on 22.03.2023, petitioner No. 1 again subjected her to
physical assault, harassment and cruelty within two or three days of her
arrival, while reiterating the demand for ₹20 lakhs. It was in the backdrop
of these allegations that respondent No. 3 returned to Jammu and
subsequently initiated the criminal proceedings in question.
12.
Significantly, apart from the allegations directed against petitioner No. 1
and his sister-in-law, the complaint does not appear to attribute any specific
overt act to the remaining petitioners. Although as many as ten persons
have been arrayed as accused, the complaint does not set out distinct
instances of cruelty, harassment, intimidation or abetment attributable to
each of them. Even the identity and role of the sister-in-law referred to in
the narrative of the complaint are not clearly delineated with reference to
the array of accused. The complainant has further alleged that, following
the death of her elder brother-in-law (Jeth) in June 2020, accused No. 1,
with the assistance of accused No. 2, turned her out of the matrimonial
home for two days, compelling her to spend the said period on the street.
Beyond these allegations, the complaint does not disclose any specific
incident involving the remaining accused persons.
13.
What also emerges from the record is that one of the principal incidents
relied upon by respondent No. 3 is stated to have occurred in June 2020,
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
whereas the complaint invoking Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. was instituted only
in the year 2023. In the intervening period, respondent No. 3 had already
taken recourse to proceedings under the Domestic Violence Act and had
also sought maintenance. The record further indicates that petitioner No. 1
had instituted a fresh petition for dissolution of marriage in the year 2023.
The sequence of these proceedings, the nature and specificity of the
allegations, and the circumstances in which the present complaint came to
be instituted are, therefore, matters requiring consideration while examining
whether the continuation of the impugned criminal proceedings against all
the petitioners is legally sustainable. At the same time, the allegations
pertaining to the incident of March 2023 must be independently examined,
since the mere existence of earlier matrimonial litigation or delay in
reporting an alleged incident cannot, by itself, furnish a sufficient ground
for quashing criminal proceedings.
14.
It is settled proposition of law that the inherent powers of this Court under
Section 482 Cr.P.C. are required to be exercised sparingly and with
circumspection, particularly when the Court is called upon to examine the
legality of criminal proceedings at the threshold. However, where the
allegations contained in the complaint, even if taken at their face value and
accepted in their entirety, do not disclose the commission of any cognizable
offence against the accused, or where the criminal proceedings manifestly
appear to have been instituted with an ulterior motive, this Court would be
justified in exercising its inherent jurisdiction to prevent abuse of the
process of law and to secure the ends of justice.
15.
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in “State of Haryana and others v. Bhajan
Lal and others”, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335, has laid down the illustrative
categories of cases wherein the extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court
can be exercised for quashing criminal proceedings. One of the categories
contemplated therein is where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint
are so absurd and inherently improbable that no prudent person can reach a
just conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the
accused. Another category relates to proceedings manifestly attended with
mala fides or maliciously instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking
vengeance on the accused. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of
the present case, what assumes significance is that the parties have
admittedly been involved in matrimonial litigation since the year 2011. The
earlier criminal proceedings initiated by respondent No. 3 culminated in the
quashing of FIR No. 74/2014 by this Court on 03.06.2017, pursuant to a
compromise arrived at between the parties. The said compromise was
followed by resumption of matrimonial relations. Thus, insofar as the
allegations relating to the period preceding the said compromise are
concerned, the same cannot, merely by their repetition, furnish an
independent foundation for revival of the criminal proceedings which had
already been brought to an end. This, however, would not prevent
respondent No. 3 from seeking appropriate legal redress in respect of any
fresh offence allegedly committed subsequent to the compromise.
16.
This Court is, therefore, required to examine whether the complaint
forming the basis of FIR No. 30/2024 contains specific allegations of
cruelty or harassment constituting an offence under Section 498-A IPC
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
subsequent to the earlier settlement. A perusal of the complaint reveals that
respondent No. 3 has attributed a demand of Rs. 20 Lakhs to petitioner No.
1 and has further alleged that she was physically assaulted in June 2020 and
again in March 2023. These allegations, insofar as they relate to petitioner
No. 1, cannot be brushed aside merely on the ground that the parties were
already litigating before different Courts or that the complaint was lodged
after the institution of divorce proceedings. The position, however, is
materially different insofar as the remaining petitioners are concerned. The
complaint does not disclose any specific act attributable to each of them
which may constitute cruelty within the meaning of Section 498-A IPC.
The allegations against the relatives of petitioner No. 1 are largely omnibus
and general in nature, without specifying their individual roles, the nature
of the alleged harassment, or the circumstances in which they are stated to
have participated in the commission of the alleged offences. Mere
relationship with the husband, without anything more, cannot constitute a
sufficient basis for subjecting such relatives to criminal prosecution.
17.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in “Geeta Mehrotra and another v. State of
Uttar Pradesh and another”, (2012) 10 SCC 741, has held that mere
casual reference to the names of family members in a matrimonial dispute,
without allegations of their active involvement in the commission of the
alleged offence, would not justify their prosecution. Similarly, in
"Kahkashan Kausar alias Sonam and others v. State of Bihar and
others”, (2022) 6 SCC 599, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has cautioned
against the tendency to implicate the entire family of the husband on the
basis of general and omnibus allegations, observing that such proceedings,
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
in the absence of specific allegations, may amount to abuse of the process
of law.
18.
In the present case, respondent No. 3 has arrayed as many as ten persons as
accused. However, except for the allegations against petitioner No. 1 and
the person described as his Bhabhi, the complaint is conspicuously silent
regarding any specific act of cruelty committed by the other petitioners.
Even with respect to the alleged involvement of the Bhabhi, the identity of
the person against whom the allegations have been made and her
correspondence with the persons arrayed as accused would require to be
clearly established from the complaint and the material accompanying it.
Criminal liability being individual in nature, it cannot be fastened upon a
person merely because of his or her relationship with the principal accused.
It is equally important to notice that Section 498-A IPC contemplates
cruelty of such nature as is likely to drive a woman to commit suicide or to
cause grave injury or danger to her life, limb or health, whether mental or
physical, or harassment with a view to coercing her or her relatives to meet
an unlawful demand for property or valuable security. Every matrimonial
disagreement or instance of domestic discord does not necessarily
constitute cruelty within the meaning of the aforesaid provision. At the
same time, where specific allegations of physical assault and harassment in
connection with an unlawful demand for dowry are made, the same cannot
be discarded at the threshold merely because the parties have a history of
matrimonial litigation.
19.
The report submitted by the SHO, Police Station Women Cell, which
suggested counselling of the parties, is also required to be appreciated in its
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
proper perspective. The said report undoubtedly indicates that the
investigating agency, upon conducting a preliminary enquiry, found the
dispute to be predominantly matrimonial in character. However, the
opinion expressed by the police that the parties required counselling cannot,
by itself, be treated as a conclusive determination that no cognizable
offence had been committed. The Magistrate, while exercising jurisdiction
under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., was required to apply judicial mind to the
allegations contained in the complaint and the material placed before the
Court. In “Priyanka Srivastava and another v. State of Uttar Pradesh and
others”, (2015) 6 SCC 287, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has emphasised
that an order under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. cannot be passed mechanically
and that the Magistrate is required to apply judicial mind before directing
investigation. The jurisdiction conferred upon the Magistrate under the
aforesaid provision is not intended to be exercised as a matter of routine
merely because an application alleging commission of a cognizable offence
has been presented. Nevertheless, the sufficiency of the material for
directing investigation must be distinguished from the sufficiency of
evidence required for establishing guilt at the trial.
20.
In the case at hand, the complaint contains specific allegations against
petitioner No. 1 regarding the demand of Rs. 20 Lakhs and the alleged acts
of physical assault and harassment after the earlier compromise. Whether
such allegations are true or false is essentially a matter of investigation and
cannot appropriately be determined by this Court in exercise of its inherent
jurisdiction. The contention of the petitioners that the complaint was lodged
as a counterblast to the divorce proceedings may be a circumstance relevant
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
to the defence, but the same cannot, in the face of specific allegations
disclosing the ingredients of a cognizable offence, constitute the sole basis
for quashing the proceedings against petitioner No. 1. Insofar as the other
petitioners are concerned, however, the complaint does not disclose
sufficient particulars of their alleged participation in the commission of the
offences. The mere assertion that they were interfering in the matrimonial
life of respondent No. 3 or instigating petitioner No. 1 to commit acts of
cruelty, without disclosure of any specific incident, conduct or overt act
attributable to them, cannot justify their continued prosecution. The
provisions of Section 109 IPC, relating to abetment, also cannot be invoked
merely on the strength of vague allegations of instigation, unless the
complaint discloses facts indicating the manner in which the alleged
abetment took place.
21.
Similarly, insofar as the offence under Section 506 IPC is concerned, the
complaint must disclose allegations of criminal intimidation involving a
threat of injury to the person, reputation or property, made with the
requisite intention contemplated under Section 503 IPC. A general
allegation of harassment or matrimonial discord, without any specific
assertion of a threat constituting criminal intimidation, would not, by itself,
attract the provisions of Section 506 IPC. On the allegations noticed
hereinabove, no distinct and specific act of criminal intimidation has been
attributed to the petitioners so as to justify the invocation of the said
provision merely as an additional penal section.
22.
Viewed thus, this Court is of the considered opinion that the allegations
against petitioner No. 1, particularly those relating to the demand of dowry
CRM(M) No. 613/2024
CrlM No. 1515/2025
and physical assault in June 2020 and March 2023, disclose matters
requiring investigation. The veracity of such allegations cannot be
adjudicated in proceedings under Section 482 Cr.P.C. However, insofar as
rest of petitioners against whom no specific act of cruelty, abetment or
criminal intimidation has been alleged are concerned, permitting the
criminal proceedings to continue would amount to subjecting them to the
rigours of criminal prosecution without adequate factual foundation. The
petition, therefore, deserves to be allowed in part. Accordingly, FIR No.
30/2024, registered for offences under Sections 498-A, 109 and 506 IPC,
and the proceedings emanating therefrom, are quashed insofar as they relate
to petitioners other than petitioner-husband. The prayer for quashing the
FIR insofar as it relates to petitioner No. 1 is declined. Respondents shall
proceed with the investigation and in case offences alleged against
petitioner No.1 is made out than legal action be followed.
23.
Disposed of as such, interim directions if any shall stand vacated.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
Jammu
19.11.2026
Rahul Sharma
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review