The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. In the case of Balkrishna Rama Tarle (supra) cited by the petitioner, the Apex Court has delineated on the procedure prescribed under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act for taking physical possession of the secured assets by the secured creditor. The secured creditor is obliged to approach the District Magistrate/Chief Metropolitan Magistrate by way of a written application requesting for taking possession of the secured assets and documents relating thereto and for being forwarded to the secured creditor for further action. The Chief Metropolitan Magistrate/District Magistrate is statutorily obliged to immediately move into action on receipt of such written application under Section 14(1) of the SARFAESI Act and pass order after verification of compliances of all formalities by the secured creditor referred to in proviso to Section 14(1) of the Act. In the said case of Balkrishna Rama Tarle (supra), the Additional District Magistrate had instead of passing a final order under Section 14 to assist secured creditor in getting possession of secured assets and while keeping such application pending, passed orders that only after termination of tenancy rights of petitioner by finance company (secured creditor) by following due procedure of law, further orders regarding possession of mortgage property shall be passed and said application shall be decided. This order of the Additional Di…
9. Having regard to the discussions made hereinabove, we are not inclined to interfere in the matter. The instant writ petition is accordingly dismissed. However, petitioner may have the liberty to approach the jurisdictional Debt Recovery Tribunal against the impugned action.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.682 of 2024
Abdul Mallik, S/o:-Lt. Abdul Barik, Power of Attorney Holder of Chalima
Bibi, W/o:-Lt. Abdul Barik, R/o:-Vill+P.O:-Bhagaban Nagar, P.S & SubDivision:-Kailasahar, District:-Unokoti, Pin:-799279, Aged about:-45 Years
.........Petitioner(s);
Versus
1. Tripura Gramin Bank, represented by its Chief Managing Director, Head
Office at Abhoynagar, P.O:-Abhoynagar, P.S:-West Agartala, District:-West
Tripura, Pin:-799006.
2. The Branch Manager, Tripura Gramin Bank, Gournagar Branch, P.O:Gournagar, P.S:-Kailasahar, District:- Unokoti, Pin:-799279.
3. The Authorized Officer, Tripura Gramin Bank, Gournagar Branch, P.O:Gournagar, P.S:-Kailasahar, District:- Unokoti, Pin:-799279.
4. Md. Abdul Matlib, S/O: Lt. Abdul Rahaman, R/O Vill: Gournagar, P.O &
P.S: Kailashahar, District: Unokoti, PIN:799279
.........Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Prabir Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Order
03/12/2024
Heard Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, learned counsel for the petitioner and
Mr. Prabir Saha, learned counsel for the respondents-Bank.
2.
Petitioner seeks quashing of the possession notice dated
25.09.2024 issued by the Authorized Officer, Tripura Gramin Bank under
Section 13(4) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and
Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 [“SARFAESI Act”, for short]
which, according to the petitioner, is only a symbolic possession of the property
mentioned in the schedule of the mortgaged assets of the petitioner.
3.
Petitioner admittedly was a guarantor to the loan of Rs.13,58,700/-
sanctioned jointly in favour of Md. Saiful Hassan along with his father Md.
Abdul Matlib-respondent No.4 for prosecuting higher education (MBBS) in
Bangladesh by the respondents-Tripura Gramin Bank. Disbursements of loan
amount were made with effect from 23.07.2012 to 19.01.2016 with a condition
to be repaid along with 13% interest in 60 equated consecutive monthly
installments of Rs.22,645/-. The said loan was sanctioned on the basis of
personal guarantee of three persons including Chalima Bibi @ Salima Bibi i.e.
the present petitioner (appearing through her Power of Attorney and her son)
who stood as guarantor by way of a registered mortgage dated 27.07.2012 in
respect of her property situated at Sub-Division- Kailashahar, MoujaBhagaban Nagar, T.K.- Gour Nagar, Khatian No.588, Hal Dag No.1414,
Classification of Land- Tilla, land measuring 1.12 acres with the described
boundage [Annexure-R/1 to the Counter Affidavit of respondents-Bank]. On
failure to timely repay on part of the borrowers, the loan was declared as Non
Performing Asset on 31.07.2017. Thereafter a notice under Section 13(2) of the
SARFAESI Act was issued on 25.08.2021 [Annexure-R/6] both to the
borrower and also to the guarantor. Let it be indicated here that borrower had
approached this Court in WP(C) No.611/2018 which was disposed of with
certain observations and directions which the borrower failed to comply. Such
observations and directions quoted hereunder:
“11.
However, in the backdrop of the said submission, this court would direct
the petitioner to submit the undertaking from the said guarantor in the bank
within a period of 15 (fifteen) days from the date when a copy of the order will be
supplied to the petitioner. If that undertaking is accepted by Tripura Gramin Bank
they can waive the procedure of the SARFAESI Act, but that is left to their
discretion. The Tripura Gramin Bank always within its competence to go for
recovery by the provisions of the SARFAESI Act following the procedure, but
since in this case the petitioner and the guarantor will come forward by agreeing
for the auction, the competent authority may also waive the requirement of
issuing the notice. Necessary documentation is, however, to be formalized. But
the Tripura Gramin Bank shall also appreciate the gesture that has been shown by
the petitioner and as such it is advisable that there should be a further consultation
to explore the possibility of an one time settlement taking the petitioner and the
guarantor in confidence. Till such recourse is taken the bank authority shall not
recover any money from the salary account of the petitioner.”
4.
The notice under Section 13(2) was said to be refused both
through registered cover and also through the agent of the Bank [Annexure-R/6
& R/7 are annexed in proof thereof]. Thereafter symbolic possession was taken
on 04.12.2021 [Annexure-R/8]. The Bank had also proceeded for recovery of
installments through letters to the Drawing & Disbursing Officer of respondent
No.4 and other co-borrower as well as to the guarantors on 14.09.2023 and
27.05.2024 with a request to arrange for liquidation of the said loan, but the
efforts of the Bank went in vain. Thereafter, the Bank approached the District
Magistrate & Collector, Unakoti District for taking physical possession of the
said mortgaged property registered in favour of the respondents-Bank. The
District Magistrate & Collector, Unakoti District issued a letter dated
10.07.2024 to the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kailashahar for taking over of the
physical possession of the said mortgaged land. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Kailashahar passed order on 24.09.2024 on the application of the Bank for
handing over the physical possession of the scheduled land to the Authorized
Officer of the respondents-Bank [Page 118 to the Counter Affidavit].
Thereafter, according to the respondents-Bank vide possession notice dated
25.09.2024 [Annexure-5], the physical possession of the mortgaged assets of
the guarantor/petitioner was taken. Petitioner does not dispute the fixation of
the possession notice on his premises. Being aggrieved by the impugned
actions, petitioner approached this Court for quashing the possession notice
dated 25.09.2024 issued by the Authorized Officer, Tripura Gramin Bank under
sub-Section (4) of Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act.
5.
Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that
the notice of possession of secured assets under Section 13(4) of the
SARFAESI Act read with Rule 8 of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules,
2002 is bad in law since petitioner was never served with any notice under
Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act. Learned counsel for the petitioner also
submits that the requirement of taking physical possession of the mortgaged
assets of the petitioner in terms of Section 14 have not been complied with as
there is no taking over of the possession by the District Magistrate or his
subordinate officer and then handing it over in favour of the secured creditor
i.e. the Bank. Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon paragraphs 15,
16 & 18 of a decision of the Apex Court rendered in the case of Balkrishna
Rama Tarle dead through legal representatives & another v. Phoenix ARC
Private Limited & others reported in (2023) 1 SCC 662 in support of his
submissions that the statutory requirement having not followed the entire action
is bad in law and amenable to the writ jurisdiction of this Court. Therefore, the
impugned physical possession notice may be quashed. It is asserted that the
physical possession of the mortgaged assets and documents relating thereto are
still in possession of the petitioner.
6.
On the other land, Mr. Prabir Saha, learned counsel for the
respondents-Bank, has relied upon the contents of the Counter Affidavit to
oppose the prayer. The relevant narration of facts have been indicated in the
opening paragraphs of this order so far as the issuance of loan in favour of Md.
Saiful Hassan and respondent No.4 and the declaration of the said loan as Non
Performing Asset on account of non-payment of installments on regular basis
and issuance of 13(2) notice on 25.08.2021. Learned counsel for the
respondents-Bank submits that petitioner has refused to accept notice under
Section 13(2) both under registered cover with A/D and through the Bank’s
agent which are Annexures-R/6 & R/7. Thereafter, the notice of demand was
issued and on failure by the borrower and the guarantors to repay the loan, steps
for taking physical possession of the mortgaged secured assets of the present
petitioner/guarantor has been taken in accordance with law. The respondentsBank has approached the District Magistrate & Collector, Unakoti District with
an application to take recourse to the provision of Section 13(4) for taking
physical possession of the mortgaged assets. Thereafter, upon order passed by
the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kailashahar on 24.09.2024, physical possession
has been taken by the Bank on 25.09.2024. It is contended that the petitioner
seeks to dispute service of notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act
and also the factum of taking over of physical possession by the Bank under
Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act. These are disputed questions of fact. At
the same time, Section 17 provides remedy to any aggrieved person including
borrower to approach the Debt Recovery Tribunal having jurisdiction in the
matter against any of the measures referred to in sub-Section(4) of Section 13
of the SARFAESI Act. It is submitted that such disputed questions of fact
should not be agitated before the Writ Court when the statute provides
comprehensive alternative remedy in view of the decision rendered by the Apex
Court in the case of United Bank of India v. Satyawati Tondon & others
reported in (2010) 8 SCC 110 and Authorized Officer, State Bank of
Travancore & another v. Mathew K.C. reported in (2018) 3 SCC 85 as well as
in the case of Phoenix ARC Private Limited v. Vishwa Bharati Vidya Mandir
& others reported in (2022) 5 SCC 345. Learned counsel for the respondentsBank also relied upon a decision of the Apex Court in the case of Celir LLP v.
Bafna Motors (Mumbai) Private Limited & others reported in (2024) 2 SCC 1.
It is submitted that the writ petition deserves to be dismissed.
7.
We have considered the submission of learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the relevant materials placed on record.
On consideration of the rival submission of the parties, it appears
that petitioner has questioned the taking over of the physical possession of his
mortgaged assets on the ground that the requirement of law prescribed under
Section 13(4) have not been complied with. Petitioner insists that between
24.09.2024 when the order for taking over physical possession was passed by
the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kailashahar and 25.09.2024 when such physical
possession is claimed to have been taken by the Banks, there has been no taking
over of physical possession by the District Magistrate or his subordinate and
handing over of such possession in favour of the respondents-Bank. However,
learned counsel for the petitioner has not been able to show any particular
prescribed format in which such physical possession of the property is to be
taken over by the District Magistrate or his subordinate and in turn handed over
to the Bank in question. On the other hand, Rule 8(1) prescribes form of notice
in Appendix-IV whereunder physical possession of such mortgaged assets of
the borrower or guarantor are to be taken over in course of action taken for sale
of the immovable property of the borrower or guarantor. In any case, this
contention of the petitioner is in the realm of a disputed question of fact which
the Writ Court is neither equipped to go into nor required to. The SARFAESI
Act provides a comprehensive remedy to the aggrieved person including the
borrower to approach the Debt Recovery Tribunal being aggrieved against any
of the measures referred to in sub-Section (4) of Section 13 taken by the
secured creditor or his Authorized Officer under the said chapter. Under
Section 17(2) of the SARFAESI Act, the Debt Recovery Tribunal is obligated
to consider whether any of the measures referred to in sub-Section (4) of
Section 13 taken by the secured creditor for enforcement of security are in
accordance with the provisions of the Act and the rules made thereunder.
Therefore, petitioner has an adequate alternative remedy to raise all issues of
fact and law as regards compliance of the provisions of Section 13(4) of the
SARFAESI Act before taking physical possession of the property in question.
8.
In the case of Balkrishna Rama Tarle (supra) cited by the
petitioner, the Apex Court has delineated on the procedure prescribed under
Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act for taking physical possession of the secured
assets by the secured creditor. The secured creditor is obliged to approach the
District Magistrate/Chief Metropolitan Magistrate by way of a written
application requesting for taking possession of the secured assets and
documents relating thereto and for being forwarded to the secured creditor for
further action. The Chief Metropolitan Magistrate/District Magistrate is
statutorily obliged to immediately move into action on receipt of such written
application under Section 14(1) of the SARFAESI Act and pass order after
verification of compliances of all formalities by the secured creditor referred to
in proviso to Section 14(1) of the Act. In the said case of Balkrishna Rama
Tarle (supra), the Additional District Magistrate had instead of passing a final
order under Section 14 to assist secured creditor in getting possession of
secured assets and while keeping such application pending, passed orders that
only after termination of tenancy rights of petitioner by finance company
(secured creditor) by following due procedure of law, further orders regarding
possession of mortgage property shall be passed and said application shall be
decided. This order of the Additional District Magistrate was interfered by the
High Court and upheld by the Apex Court in the instant judgment. The Apex
Court at para 18 has observed that at the stage of Section 14(1), CMM/DM is
not required to adjudicate the dispute between the borrower and the secured
creditor and/or between any other third party and the secured creditor with
respect to the secured assets and the aggrieved party is to be relegated to raise
objections on the proceedings under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act before
the Debt Recovery Tribunal. Therefore in the facts of the present case, the
instant decision is of no aid to the present petitioner. Learned counsel for the
respondents-Bank has relying upon the decisions of the Apex Court in the case
of Satyawati Tondon (supra) and other subsequent decision rightly submitted
that
the
appropriate
remedy
for
an
aggrieved
person
like
the
petitioner/guarantor is to invoke the jurisdiction of the competent Debt
Recovery Tribunal if he is aggrieved by any of the measures taken by the
respondents-Bank under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act instead of
approaching the Writ Court.
9.
Having regard to the discussions made hereinabove, we are not
inclined to interfere in the matter. The instant writ petition is accordingly
dismissed. However, petitioner may have the liberty to approach the
jurisdictional Debt Recovery Tribunal against the impugned action.
10.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
Pijush/
DIPESH DEB
Date: 2024.12.05 16:03:38
+05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review