Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR AT JAMMU
(through virtual mode)
Pronounced on 25.03.2026
Uploaded on 25.03.2026
HCP No. 58/2025
Abdul Hameed @ Meedhu age 32 years
s/o Late Abdul Rashid,
r/ovill. Dalwas Byepass Peerha, Chanderkote,
Districrt Ramban,
Through his wife Naseema Begum aged 29 yrs
r/o Belicharana, Lange No. 5, 4th Bride
Tehsil & District Jammu
...……….Petitioner(s)
Through:-
Mr.Anil Sethi, adv with
Mr. Dalwinder Kumar, adv.
Vs.
1.Union territory of J&K through principal
Secretary to Government,
Home Department, Civil Sectt. Jammu
2.Divisional Commissioner, Jammu
3.Sr. Superintendant of Police, Jammu
……….Respondent(s)
Through: - Ms. PLriyanka Bhat, adv vice
Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
CORAM:
Hon’ble Mr Justice Mohd Yousuf wani.
JUDGMENT
1.
Impugned in the instant petition, having been filed in terms of Article
226 of the Constitution of India is the order of detention bearing No.
PITNDPS 13 of 2025 dated 15.03.2025, passed by respondent No.2 i.e
the Divisional Commissioner, Rail-Head, Jammu, while invoking
his
powers U/s 3 of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as PITNDPS
Act for short)
r/w SRO-247 dated 27.07.1988, whereby the
petitioner/detenu was directed to be detained and lodged in District Jail
Rajouri, for a period to be specified by the Government with a view to
2 HCP No.58/2025
prevent him from engaging in Illicit Trafficking in Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances.
2.
The petitioner–detenu, through his wife Naseema Begum, aged about 29
years, has sought the quashment of the impugned detention order dated
15.03.2025 by issuance of a writ of habeas corpus, inter alia, on the
grounds that same is violative of his guarantees under Articles 21 and 22
of the Constitution of India. That firstly, there was no legal justification
for his detention on the mere allegations of his involvement in certain
FIRs in which he already stands enlarged on bail and secondly, the copies
of the documents forming the basis of the impugned detention order were
neither furnished nor explained to him in a language understandable by
him, thereby depriving him of his right to make an effective and timely
representation against his detention. That he was not informed by the
detaining authority regarding his constitutional right to make an effective
representation against his detention order. That actually the copies of
order impugned
and grounds of detention
without the supporting
documents came to be handed over to him by jail authorities after some
days of his arrest and detention. That the impugned detention order was
not confirmed by the Government as required under law within the
prescribed period. That even his case was not referred to the Statutory
Board competent to advise the Government regarding any prima facie
ground being made out or not, for detention of the detenu. That the
grounds of detention of the petitioner are stale and have no proximity
with the object sought to be achieved by the impugned detention order.
That the detaining authority has while merely acting upon the dossier of
3 HCP No.58/2025
respondent No.3 hurried to pass the impugned detention order without
application of mind and without
appreciating the fact that the
petitioner/detenu had already been proceeded under ordinary criminal
law in respect of his alleged accusation. That the detention of the
petitioner on the basis of criminal cases which are already the subject
matter of a pending trials amounts to subjecting him to double jeopardy.
That the respondent No.2 i.e the detaining authority has not chosen to
produce the petitioner before the learned advisory board, as he had
already made
a representation to that effect. That the grounds
of
detention are the replica of the police dossier without any application of
mind on the part of the detaining authority. That the petitioner being an
illiterate person cannot be supposed to read and understand the contents
of the impugned detention order as well as the grounds of detention being
in English language that came to be furnished to him after some days of
his detention and lodgement in the jail. That the petitioner was not
furnished the whole material so that he would be able to file an effective
representation to the Government.
3.
The petition has been resisted by the respondents through the memo of
objections on the grounds that same is not maintainable in view of the
fact that detention of the petitioner stands ordered in terms of a valid and
legal order issued by the learned competent authority in exercise of his
powers vested in it u/s 3 (1) of PITNDPS Act.
That the detention order has been passed by the competent authority
upon due application of mind and compliance with the procedure
prescribed under the statute.
4 HCP No.58/2025
That the petitioner has alternate remedy available under the
PITNDPS Act and as such could not have directly invoked extra writ
jurisdiction of this court without proof of violation of any of his
fundamental rights.
That
the order of detention
safeguarding
being a preventive measure
for
the public interest cannot be challenged in the manner
chosen by the petitioner.
That the petitioner is a habitual offender and is involved in series of
criminal cases registered under NDPS Act.
That despite being granted bail in earlier cases he continued to
indulge in Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
especially 8heroin9.
That the detenu is involved in the case FIR No. 53/2024 U/s 8/21/22
NDPS Act of P/S Damana and FIR No. 194/2024 U/s 8/21/22 NDPS
Act
of P/S Nawabad Jammu in both the
case FIRs the petitioner
already stands bailed out.
That the registration of the said criminal cases reveals a constant
pattern of conduct and establish that petitioner is actively engaged in
narcotic trade.
That the detention order dated 15.03.2025 has been passed by a
competent authority on the basis of cogent credible and relevant material.
That
the dossier vide No. CRB/2025/Dossier/05/DPOJ dated
08.03.3035 submitted by the SSP, Jammu including the other connected
documents, surveillance
in-puts and forensic reports contained detailed
report of petitioner9s involvement in the illicit trade of narcotic drugs.
5 HCP No.58/2025
That the detaining authority applied its independent mind to the
material on record and was fully satisfied that the activities of the
petitioner were prejudicial to the interests of society and the State.
That despite invocation of regular criminal law, the petitioner/detenu
after being granted bail in the cases against him continued to indulge in
the activities of trafficking in narcotic substances.
That the normal criminal law could not deter the petitioner/detenu
from continuing his activities of illicit trade in narcotic substances.
That the grounds of detention and all the relied upon documents were
duly communicated to him in the language understandable by him within
the stipulated time.
That the detenu was already informed of his right to make a
representation to the Government and the Advisory Board.
That the procedural requirements under Article 22(5) of the
constitution have been strictly followed and the petitioner has not pleaded
any specific procedural lapse or violation of his rights.
That in view of the petitioner9s continuous and repeated involvement
in Illicit Trafficking in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances, he
was recommended for being detained by the Screening Committee
constituted for the purpose to deter him from continuing his illegal
activities of drug trafficking.
That the petitioner was carrying out his illegal activities in a manner
deliberately designed to evade detection, by employing various methods
to maintain secrecy, and did not afford any opportunity to the law and
order enforcement agencies to apprehend him red-handed.
6 HCP No.58/2025
That there are well founded reasons and apprehensions that if the
detenu will remain at large, he will continue to indulge in expansion of
his drug peddling net work by involving more youths of the area.
That the petitioner needs to be kept under detention so that young
generation of the area could be saved from the evil consequences of his
activities.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties who reiterated their
respective stands already taken in the main petition and the memo of
objections.
4.
The learned counsel for the petitioner in support of the grounds of
challenge made in the main petition, placed reliance on the judgments
cited as <Sushanta Kumar Banik vs. State of Tripura and Ors. Criminal
Appeal No. 1708 of 2022 decided on 30.09.2022; T.A. Abdul Rahman
vs. State of Kerala and Or,; 1990 AIR 225 decided on 23.08.1989;
Muyeed Shafi Ganie vs. UT of J&K and An, WP(Crl) No. 202/2022
decided on 31.01.2024; Mohd. Arief @ Kaka Vs. UT of J&K and Ors
HCP No. 40/2024 decided on 06.12.2024; Asif Sultan Saida Vs. UT of
J&K and Anr. WP(Crl) No. 234/2022 decided on 07.12.2023; Nek Ram
@ Satnam vs. UT of J&K and Ors. HCP No. 11/2025 decided on
24.07.2025; Mudassir Hussain vs. UT of J&K and Ors.WP(Crl) No.
26/2023 decided on 30.12.2023; Adil Hussain Shah vs. UT of J&K and
Ors. HCP No. 380/2024 decided on 14.10.2025.”
5.
The learned counsel for the respondents Ms. Monika Kohli, Ld Sr. AAG
also made reliance on the authoritative judgments cited as <Haradhan
Saha vs. State of W.B (1975) 3 SCC; Anil Sharma vs. UT of J&K and
7 HCP No.58/2025
ors LPA 55/2023 decided on 16.08.2023 & Jahangir Ahmad Dar vs. UT
of J&K and ors LPA No. 12/2023 decided on 12.02.202”.
6.
I have perused the instant petition, the counter affidavit filed by
respondents and have also gone through the detention record furnished for
perusal by the respondents.
7.
I have also accorded thoughtful consideration to the rival arguments
advanced on both the sides.
8.
Keeping in view the aforementioned perusal and the consideration this
Court is of the opinion that the impugned detention order dated
15.03.2025 suffers from illegality. The, <application of mind= of the Ld
detaining authority and the <inevitability of the detention= which are sine
qua non for passing of a detention order appear to have been
compromised in the instant case. Besides the communication of the order
of detention to the petitioner so as to enable him to make an effective
representation to the concerned authorities at an earliest also does not
seem to have been made effectively in the instant case.
Section (3) of the PITNDPS Act which confers the power on the
competent authority to make orders for detaining certain persons is
reproduced as hereunder for ready reference:<3. Powers to make orders detaining certain persons. –– (1) The
Central Government or a State Government or any officer of the Central
Government, not below the rank of a Joint Secretary to that Government,
specially empowered for the purposes of this section by that Government,
or any officer of a State Government, not below the rank of Secretary to
that Government, specifically empowered for the purposes of this section
by that Government, may, if satisfied, with respect to any person
(including a foreigner) that, with a view to preventing him from engaging
in illicit traffic in narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, it is
necessary so to do, make an order directing that such person be detained.
(2) When any order of detention is made by a State Government or by an
officer empowered by a State Government, the State Government shall,
within ten days, forward to the Central Government a report in respect of
8 HCP No.58/2025
the order. (3) For the purpose of clause (5) of Article 22 of the
Constitution, the communication to a person detained in pursuance of a
detention order of the grounds on which the order has been made shall be
made as soon as may be after the detention, but ordinarily not later than
five days, and in exceptional circumstances and for reasons to be
recorded in writing, not later than fifteen days, from the date of
detention.=
9.
It is an admitted position, as reflected from the grounds of detention, that
the petitioner-detenu had already been enlarged on bail by the competent
trial courts in both the aforesaid FIRs. It was, therefore, incumbent upon
the learned detaining authority to record its satisfaction as to why the
ordinary criminal law was insufficient to deal with the activities of the
petitioner, particularly when he was already facing prosecution before the
competent courts. There is nothing on record to show that the
petitioner/detenu had violated any of the conditions of bail. It is also not
the stand of the respondents that they had challenged the bail orders
before the higher forum and failed in their attempt. In the absence of such
an exercise, the preventive detention law could not have been invoked as
a substitute for the ordinary criminal process merely on the apprehension
that the petitioner may again indulge in the alleged activities relating to
illicit trafficking of narcotic drugs.
10.
The impugned detention order, therefore, cannot be said to be legally
sustainable and is liable to be quashed.
<In Rekha vs. State of Tamil Nadu, 2011 (5) SCC 244, the Hon9ble
Supreme Court has held as under :<No doubt it has been held in the Constitution Bench
decision in Haradhan Saha's case (supra) that even if a person is
liable to be tried in a criminal court for commission of a criminal
offence, or is actually being so tried, that does not debar the
9 HCP No.58/2025
authorities from passing a detention order under a preventive
detention law. This observation, to be understood correctly, must,
however, be construed in the background of the constitutional
scheme in :16:Articles 21 and 22 of the Constitution (which we
have already explained). Articles 22(3)(b) is only an exception to
Article 21 and it is not itself a fundamental right. It is Article 21
which is central to the whole chapter on fundamental rights in our
Constitution. The right to liberty means that before sending a
person to prison a trial must ordinarily be held giving him
opportunity of placing his defence through his lawyer. It follows
that if a person is liable to be tried, or is actually being tried, for a
criminal offence, but the ordinary criminal law (Indian Penal Code
or other penal statutes) will not be able to deal with the situation,
then, and only then, can the preventive detention law be taken
recourse to.
Hence, the observation in para 34 in Haradhan Saha's case
(supra) cannot be regarded as an unqualified statement that in
every case where a person is liable to be tried, or is actually being
tried, for a crime in a criminal court a detention order can also be
passed under a preventive detention law.=
11.
The impugned detention order has been passed mainly on the ground that
the petitioner-detenu, despite his alleged involvement in a number of
criminal cases and having been enlarged on bail by the competent trial
courts therein, has continued to indulge in the acts of illicit trafficking in
narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances. As per the case of the
competent authority, the last alleged criminal act attributed to the
petitioner-detenu pertains to 06.12.2024. A period of about three months
appears to have elapsed between the said last alleged occurrence and the
passing of the detention order dated 15.03.2025. As such, there does not
appear to be any live and proximate link between the alleged prejudicial
activity and the object sought to be achieved by the detention.
12.
It is a settled legal position that an inordinate and unexplained delay in
passing a detention order from the date of the last alleged criminal activity
of the detenu snaps the live and proximate link between the two and
renders the detention order unsustainable in the eyes of law.
10 HCP No.58/2025
13.
This court in its opinion feels fortified with the authoritative judgment of
the Hon9be Supreme Court of India reported in <Rajinder Arora vs. Union
of India and others= AIR 2006 (4) SCC 796, decided on 10.03.2006 . The
relevant para of the judgment is reproduced as under:<The conspectus of the above decisions can be
summarized thus: The question whether the prejudicial activities
of a person necessitating to pass an order of detention is proximate
to the time when the order is made or the live link between the
prejudicial activities and the purpose of detention is snapped
depends on the facts and circumstances of each case. No hard and
fast rule can be precisely formulated that would be applicable
under all circumstances and no exhaustive guidelines can be laid
down in that behalf. It follows that the test of proximity is not a
rigid or mechanical test by merely counting number of months
between the offending acts and the order of detention. However,
when there is undue and long delay between the prejudicial
activities and the passing of detention order, the court has to
scrutinize whether the detaining authority has satisfactorily
examined such a delay and afforded a tenable and reasonable
explanation as to why such a delay has occasioned, when called
upon to answer and further the court has to investigate whether the
causal connection has been broken in the circumstances of each
case. Similarly when there is unsatisfactory and unexplained delay
between the date of order of detention and the date of securing the
arrest of the detenu, such a delay would throw considerable doubt
on the genuineness of the subjective satisfaction of the detaining
authority leading to a legitimate inference that the detaining
authority was not really and genuinely satisfied as regards the
necessity for detaining the detenu with a view to preventing him
from acting in a prejudicial manner.=
14.
The opinion of this Court is also supplemented by another authoritative
Judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court cited as <Sushanta Kumar Banile vs.
State of Tripura & Ors=. AIR, 2022 SC 4175, in which, it has been held that
undue and unreasonable gap between the alleged accusation and the
passing of the detention order snaps the live-link between the two. On the
basis of the afore referred authoritative Judgments, this Court is of the
opinion that the Ld detaining Authority has not applied its mind before
passing the impugned detention order.
11 HCP No.58/2025
15.
It is the case of the petitioner/detenu that he was not furnished with the
copies of the detention order, the grounds of detention, and the material
relied upon by the detaining authority at the time of his arrest and
detention, thereby preventing him from making an effective and timely
representation against his detention. It is also his case that he was not
informed of his right to make a representation to the detaining authority as
well as to the Government. A perusal of the detention record reveals that
the police officer entrusted with the execution of the detention warrant did
not furnish the complete detention record to the petitioner/detenu.
16.
The petitioner/detenu has also averred in his petition, that the contents of
the detention warrant and the grounds of detention were not explained to
him in his vernacular language and he was not also informed that he has a
right to make representation to the detaining authority or to the Govt.
17.
The procedural safeguards as mandated under Article 22 (5) of the
Constitution as well as under Section 3 of the Act appear to have been
observed in breach, and as such the impugned order cannot sustain.
This Court in its opinion is fortified with the authoritative Judgment of the
Hon9ble Apex Court cited as <Shalini Soni Vs. Union of India” (1980) 4
SCC 544: 1981 SCC (Ori) 38, the relevant portion of which is reproduced
as under:<The Article 22 (5) has two facets : (1) communication of
the grounds on which the order of detention has been made; (2)
opportunity of making a representation against the order of
detention. Communication of the grounds pre-supposes the
formulation of the grounds and formulation of the grounds
requires and ensures the application of the mind of the detaining
12 HCP No.58/2025
authority to the facts and materials before it, that is to say to
pertinent and proximate matters in regard to each individual case
and excludes the elements of arbitrariness and automatism (if one
may be permitted to use the word to describe a mechanical
reaction without a conscious application of the mind). It is an
unwritten rule of the law, constitutional and administrative, that
whenever a decision making function is entrusted to the subjective
satisfaction of a statutory functionary, there is an implicit
obligation to apply his mind to pertinent and proximate matters
only eschewing the irrelevant and the remote. Where there is
further an express statutory obligation to 2024:JKLHC-JMU:3904
18 communicate not merely the decision but the grounds on which
the decision is founded. It is a necessary corollary that the grounds
communicated, that is, the grounds so made known, should be
seen to pertain to pertinent and proximate matters and should
comprise all the constituent facts and materials that went in to
make up the mind of the statutory functionary and not merely the
inferential conclusions. Now, the decision to detain a person
depends on the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority.
The Constitution and the statute cast a duty on the detaining
authority to communicate the grounds of detention to the detenu.
From what we have said above, it follows that the grounds
communicated to the detenu must reveal the whole of the factual
material considered by the detaining authority and not merely the
inferences of fact arrived at by the detaining authority. The matter
may also be looked at from the point of view of the second facet
of Article 22(5). An opportunity to make a representation against
the order of detention necessarily implies that the detenu is
informed of all that has been taken into account against him in
arriving at the decision to detain him. It means that the detenu is
to be informed not merely, as we said, of the inferences of fact but
of all the factual material which have led to the inferences of fact.
If the detenu is not to be so informed the opportunity so solemnly
guaranteed by the Constitution becomes reduced to an exercise in
futility. Whatever angle from which the question is looked at, it is
dear that "grounds" in Article 22(5) do not mean mere factual
inferences but mean factual inferences plus factual material which
led to such factual inferences. The 'grounds' must be selfsufficient and self-explanatory. In our view copies of documents
to which reference is made in the 'grounds' must be supplied to the
detenu as part of the 'grounds'.=
18.
It is also the case of the petitioner/detenu that he was not informed that
he has a right to make an representation against his detention order to
the learned Advisory Board.
As per the grounds of detention, the petitioner is alleged to be involved in
two FIRs, namely FIR No. 53/2024 under Sections 8/21/22 of the NDPS Act
registered at Police Station Damana and FIR No. 194/2024 under the same
sections registered at Police Station Nawabad dated 06.12.2024.
13 HCP No.58/2025
As itself admitted by the Ld. detaining authority, the petitioner stood
already bailed out in all both aforesaid case FIR(s) and there was no
allegation of misuse of any bail condition by him. There is also nothing on
record evidencing the fact that the Government through prosecution made
any endeavour to seek the cancellation of the bail orders. The detention
order appears to have been passed about 95 days after the registration of the
last case FIR. So, again the delay in passing the impugned detention order
snaps the required live link between the last incident of 06.12.2024 that led
to the registration of the last FIR No. 53/24 against the detenu and the
detention order dated 15.03.2025.
20.
The detaining authority has not also in clear and pellucid manner mentioned
in the grounds of detention as to how the normal criminal law failed to
prevent the petitioner/detenu from repeating the commission of crime. In all
cases of detention which are based on the criminal cases registered against
the detenu, it is incumbent upon the detaining authority to record in the
grounds of detention as to whether ordinary criminal law had not prevented
such person so as to draw satisfaction to order preventive detention. In none
of the cases against the petitioner, as mentioned in the grounds of detention,
a commercial quantity of narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances is
alleged to have been recovered from the possession of the detenu. The same
thing is borne out from the bail orders of the learned trial court. So, the nonapplication of mind and the lack of subjective satisfaction is discernable in
the facts and circumstances of the case.
14 HCP No.58/2025
21.
The preventive detentions need to be passed with great care and caution
keeping in mind that a citizens most valuable and inherent human right is
being curtailed. The arrests in general and the preventive detentions in
particular are an exception to the most cherished fundamental right
guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The preventive
detentions are made on the basis of subjective satisfaction of the Ld.
detaining authority without being backed by an immediate complaint as in
the case of the registration of the FIR and, as such, is a valuable trust in the
hands of the trustees. The provisions of Clauses (1) and (2) of Article 22 of
our Constitution are not applicable in the case of preventive detentions. So,
the provisions of Clause (5) of the Article 22 of our Constitution and the
provisions of Section (3) of the PITNDPS Act requiring for application of
mind, subjective satisfaction, inevitability of the detention order, proper
communication of the grounds of detention and the information of liberty to
make a representation against the detention order are the imperative and
inevitable conditions rather requirements for passing of a detention order.
22.
For the foregoing discussion the impugned detention order No. PIT NDPS
13 of 2025 dated 15.03.2025 appears to be outcome of non application of
mind. The petitioner/detenu appears to have been prevented from making a
representation in respect of his detention order. There also appears to be no
live link between the grounds of detention and the detention order. The
procedural safeguards mandated under Article 22(5) of the Constitution and
section 3(3) of the PIT NDPS Act appear to have been compromised.
15 HCP No.58/2025
23.
Accordingly, the petition is allowed and the impugned detention order
bearing No. 13 of 2025 dated 15.03.2025 passed by respondent No.2 i.e Ld.
Divisional Commissioner, Jammu is quashed with the direction to the
respondents to release the petitioner/detenu from his preventive custody in
the instant case.
24.
The record is ordered to be returned to the office of the learned Sr. AAG
against proper acknowledgement.
25.
Disposed of.
(Mohd Yousuf Wani)
Judge
Srinagar:
25.03.2026.
<ayaz=
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review