Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
THURSDAY, THE 6TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 15TH PHALGUNA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
AGAINST
THE
ORDER/JUDGMENT
DATED
1.11.2019
IN
OA
NO.20 OF 2019 OF CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,ERNAKULAM
BENCH
PETITIONER:
ZAKEER HUSSAIN M.K
AGED 49 YEARS
S/O.ATTAKOYA P(LATE), FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR,
POLICE STATION, KAVARATTI-682555,
UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP,
PERMANENT ADDRESS MATHIL KADANALLAN, KALPENI
ISLAND, UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHDWEEP, PIN-682557
BY ADVS.
T.C.GOVINDA SWAMY
SMT.KALA T.GOPI
SUDHIR KUMAR B.
RESPONDENTS:
THE ADMINISTRATOR
LAKSHADWEEP ADMINISTRATION,
UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP, KAVARATTI-682555
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP,
KAVARATTI-682555
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
SHRI.A.P.MULLAKOYA
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
KADAMAT-682556 UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.T.HASSAN
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR FIRE STATION,
ANDROTH-682551, UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.P.BASHEER,
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
KILTAN-682558, UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.M.P.MUTHUKOYA
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
KADAMAT-682556 UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.P.P.MOHAMMED ABDUL NAZAR,
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
KAVARATTI-682555 UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.M.ABDUL MUTHALIF,
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
KAVARATTI-682555 UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.C.B ABDULLA,
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
CHETLAT-682554 UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.K.K.KOYA
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
KALPENI-682557 UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.A.K.SIRAJ
FIREMAN DIRVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION
AMINI-682252, UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI M.V.ALIYUL AKBAR,
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR FIRE STATION,
ANDROTH-682551 UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
SHRI.K.ABDUL KADER,
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR FIRE STATION,
MINICOY-682559 UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.P.PSAYED SHAIKOYA
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
AMINI-682252, UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.M.ABDUL KADIRI
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
AMINI-682252, UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.E.C.ANDUKOYA,
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR FIRE STATION,
MINICOY-682559, UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
SHRI.C.G.HAMZAKOYA
FIREMAN DRIVER OPERATOR POLICE STATION,
KALPENI-682557, UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP
BY ADV K.S.PRENJITH KUMAR
SRI K B GANGESH
THIS
06.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
OP
THE
(CAT)
COURT
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
ON
SAME
DAY
THE
HEARD
ON
DELIVERED
THE
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
JUDGMENT
Amit Rawal, J.
1.
Petitioner is aggrieved of the dismissal of
the O.A., filed by him before the Central Administrative
Tribunal, challenging the seniority list Annexure – A1
promulgated in 2018 on account of merger of the cadre of
Fireman with Driver Operator and also on account of
promulgation of new recruitment Rules in 2012.
2.
The feeder cadre to the promotion post of
Leading Fireman, prior to restructuring, was only from
Firemen. However on account of merger, the posts of
Fireman and Driver Operator got merged and both of them
became eligible for promotion. The Rules prevailing before
restructuring, given the chance of promotion to the Fireman
only. The Recruitment Rules came into force on 13.09.2012
and as per paragraph No.2(II), the post having different pay
scale prior to 6th CPC recommendation and after merger if
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
come to lie in the same Pay Band with the same Grade Pay,
the inter se seniority of all the employees will be fully
maintained with the employees in a higher pre-revised pay
scale, being placed higher vis-a-vis an employee in a lower
pay scale. Concededly, the pay scale of the Driver Operators
prior to the merger was Rs.950-1500 whereas that of the
Fireman was Rs.775-1025. On the basis of restructuring, the
pay scale of Fireman and Driver Operator was Rs.520020200 with grade pay of Rs.1900/-. For promotion to the
post of leading Fireman, having a Grade Pay of Rs.2000/with the same pay scale, i.e., Rs.5200-20200, persons
eligible for promotion are Fireman Driver Operator with
three(3)
years
of
regular
service
who
have
passed
departmental test conducted by the department from time
to time. Concededly, the applicant was eligible as he had
three(3)
years
of
regular
service
and
passed
the
departmental test. Respondents No.3 to 17 were working as
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
Firemen and have been promoted as Leading Firemen on the
basis of vacancies occurred prior to the amendment caused
in the Recruitment Rules as per the prevailing judicial
pronouncement. However, in 2018, vide Annexure – A1,
department came out with a seniority list
placing the
applicant below the party respondents. This gave him cause
of action to invoke the jurisdiction of Central Administrative
Tribunal, as the said seniority was not fixed in terms of Rule
2(II) of 2012. Learned Tribunal disposed off the O.A. by
keeping the zone of consideration of the party respondents
from Fireman to Leading Fireman according to the vacancies
existing in the erstwhile Rules, with a further clarification
that the remaining promotions will be as per the new
Recruitment Rules.
2.
Adv.Kala.T.Gopi, learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the petitioner submitted that there has been a
change in the law with regard to the applicability of the
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
Recruitment Rules on the date when the promotions are
considered. It is the conceded position on record that party
respondents were promoted during the pendency of O.A.
i.e., when the 2012 Rules were already in force. Though we
have not been informed whether his promotion was in
respect of the vacancy which occurred in 2012 but it must
have been on that account alone.
3.
In
Krishnakumar
Union
and
of
India
Another
and
[(2019)
Others
SCC
v.
319]
considering the promotional avenue of Havildars to the post
of Naib Subedars, the structure of Assam Rifles underwent a
change by creation of intermediate post of Warrant Officer
and the persons who were holding the post of Havildars
were to be considered for promotion to the post of Warrant
Officers. The High Court directed that the vacancies which
arose prior to the amendment are to be filled up by the
Rules
prior
to
the
amendment.
However,
the
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
aforementioned direction was not accepted by the Supreme
Court and the judgment of the High Court was set aside by
observing as under in paragraph No.14:
14. In view of this statement of the law, it is evident that
once the structure of Assam Rifles underwent a change
following the creation of the intermediate post of Warrant
Officer, persons holding the post of Havildar would be
considered for promotion to the post of Warrant Officer.
The intermediate post of Warrant Officer was created as a
result of the restructuring exercise. The High Court was,
in our view, in error in postulating that vacancies which
arose prior to the amendment of the Recruitment Rules
would necessarily be governed by the Rules which existed
at the time of the occurrence of the vacancies. As the
decided cases noted earlier indicate, there is no such rule
of absolute or universal application. The entire basis of the
decision of the High Court was that those who were
recruited prior to the restructuring exercise and were
holding the post of Havildars had acquired a vested right
of promotion to the post of Naib Subedar. This does not
reflect the correct position in law. The right is to be
considered for promotion in accordance with the Rules as
they exist when the exercise is carried out for promotion.
4.
Similar is the view of Supreme Court in
State of Tripura and Ors. v. Nikhil Ranjan Chakraborty
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
and Ors. [(2017) 3 SCC
646] in paragraph No.10, the
same reads as under:
10.
The law is thus clear that a candidate has the
right to be considered in the light of the existing rules,
namely, “rules in force on the date” the consideration
takes place and that there is no rule of absolute
application that vacancies must invariably be filled by the
law existing on the date when they arose. As against the
case of total exclusion and absolute deprivation of a
chance to be considered as in the case of Deepak Agarwal
(supra), in the instant case certain additional posts have
been included in the feeder cadre, thereby expanding the
zone of consideration. It is not as if the writ petitioners or
similarly situated candidates were totally excluded. At
best,
they
now
had
to
compete
with
some
more
candidates. In any case, since there was no accrued right
nor was there any mandate that vacancies must be filled
invariably by the law existing on the date when the
vacancy arose, the State was well within its rights to
stipulate that the vacancies be filled in accordance with
the Rules as amended. Secondly, the process to amend
the Rules had also begun well before the Notification
dated 24.11.2011.
5.
reads as under:
Rule 2(II) of the Recruitment Rules, 2012,
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
Where posts having different pay scales prior to Sixth CPC
recommendation and now after merger have come to lie
in the same Pay Band with same Grade Pay, the inter se
seniority of all the employees will be fully maintained with
employee in a higher pre-revised pay scale being placed
higher vis-a-vis an employee in a lower pay scale. Within
the same pre-revised pay scale, seniority which existed
prior to revision would continue.
6.
The seniority list was published in 2018.
Obviously, the applicant who was drawing higher pay scale
than other Firemen was required to be placed senior to the
party respondents. But, since the party respondents have
already been promoted and retired, we are of the view that
while considering the case of the applicant – petitioner for
placing him higher in the seniority list, no recovery would be
effected regarding the pay and pension received by them by
holding the promotional post of Leading Fireman. Therefore,
the petitioner shall be considered for promotion to the post
of Leading fireman.
7.
The department will consider the promotion of
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
the petitioner to the post of Leading Fireman, strictly as per
the Recruitment Rules 2012 if he fulfill the conditions of
three years and clearance of departmental examination. It
is made clear that he will be entitled to arrears/monetary
benefits also.
Petition stands disposed off.
Sd/AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
nak
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 21/2020
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN OA
NO.181/20/2019 DATED 1.11.2019
RENDEREBY HON'BLE CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH
EXHIBIT P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE OA NO.181/20/2019
EXHIBIT P2(A1)
TRUE COPY OF OFFICE ORDERBEARING
F.NO.10/33/2015-AC(F)DATED 22.08.2018
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P2(A2)
A TRUE COPY OF NOTIFICATION RECRUITMENT
RULES BEARING F NO.1/13/91-EST(POL)
DATED 27.01.1992 PUBLISHED BY THE FIRST
RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P2(A3)
A TRUE COPY OF CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY
THE COCHIN PORT FIRE SERVICE UNDER
NO.FS/115/44/94 DATED 18.05.1994
EXHIBIT P2(A4)
A TRUE COPY OF RECRUITMENT RULES
AMENDED AS PER A NOTIFICATION OBEARING
F.NO.10/40/2012-AC(F) DATED 26.09.2012
EXHIBIT P2(A5)
TRUE COPY OF REPLY STATEMENT DATED
26.05.2015 FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS 1
AND 2 IN OA NO.181/0071/2014
EXHIBIT P2(A6)
TRUE COPY OF DOP&T OM BEARING
NO.20020/4/2010-ESTT(D) DATED
13.09.2012
EXHIBIT P2(A7)
TRUE COPY OF THE PROVISIONAL SENIORITY
LIST PUBLISHED BY THE RESPONDENTS AS
PER OFFICE MEMORANDUM BEARING
F.NO.10/33/2015-AC(F)2847 DATED
04.08.2016
2025:KER:21130
OP (CAT) NO. 21 OF 2020
EXHIBIT P2(A8)
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 02.12.2016 IN
OA NO.181/00071/2014 RENDERED BY THE
HON'BLE CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH SENIORITY
LIST BEARING F.NO.10/33/2015-AC(F)DATED
01.08.2018
EXHIBIT P2(A10)
TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED
08.08.2018 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
IN OA
EXHIBIT P3
A TRUE COPY OF REPLY STATEMENT FILED BY
TH SENIOR CENTRAL GOVERNMENT STANDING
COUNSEL FOR 1ST AND THE 2ND RESPONDENT
IN OA EXHIBIT P2
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT FILED
BY RESPONDENTS 3 TO 10, 12 AND 13 AND
15 TO 17
EXHIBIT P4(R3(A)
A TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION PREFERRED
BY THE APPLICANT BEFORE THE 2ND
RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P5
A TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER DATED
19.08.2019 FILED BY THE PETITIONER IN
OA EXHIBIT P2
EXHIBIT P5(A11)
A TRUE COPY OF OFFICE ORDER BEARING
F.NO.10/29/2015-AC(F) DATED 22.02.2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review