Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 1:-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE S.V.BHATTI
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
THURSDAY, THE 23RD DAY OF MARCH 2023 / 2ND CHAITHRA, 1945
WA NO. 545 OF 2023
AGAINST THE ORDER IN WP(C) 2607/2022 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANTS:
PREMARAJ.M.A,AGED 67 YEARSS/O LATE K.V.R. NAIR, H-20, KB
NSS COLONY, MALOORKUNNU P.O., KOZHIKKODE, 673012.
ASOK KUMAR.N,AGED 64 YEARSS/O K. NARAYANAN, FLAT NO. 3 A1, SAMRUDHI ENCLAVE, TKD ROAD, PATTOM P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004
BHAKTHA MEERA .KAGED 63 YEARSD/O SREEDHARAN, SASIPRIYA,
ALUNGAL, THENHIPALAM, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 673636
N.RAMANANDA PANICKAR,AGED 75 YEARSMADHAVA MANDIRAM, CMC 11, CHERTHALA, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 688524
BASHEER.T.MUSTHAFA,AGED 67 YEARSS/O MUSTHAFA, T.C
16/1723(6), T.BEEZ LAND, KALLADIMUGOM, MANACADU PO ,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695009
S.RAVEENDRAN NAIRAGED 70 YEARSS/O SANKARA PILLAI,
JAYANILAYAM, KARIYAM, SREEKAARYAM PO, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
PIN - 695017
RAMACHANDRAN NAIRAGED 73 YEARSTHEKKEVILA VEEDU,
SREEKRISHNA LANE, CHAVADIMUKKU , SREEKAARYAM,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695017
SAKUNTHALA C.,AGED 78 YEARSREVATHI, T.C 30/306-1,
MADHUMUKKU ,AANAYARA PO, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695029
K.S.V NAYAKAM,AGED 76 YEARSS/O K.K.SIVARAMAKRISHNA
PILLAI, AMRUTHAM,T.C 23/364, KOWADIAR GARDENS,B-21, GOLF
INKS, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695003
JAYACHANDRA SARMA .G.,AGED 77 YEARSS/O GOPALAKRISHNA
BHATTATHIRI, MOOTHEDATHU MADOM,PERUVELIKARA PO, KOLLAM,
PIN - 691500
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 2:-
N.VASUDEVAN,AGED 69 YEARSS/O KESAVAN, MAHESH VILLA,
PEROORKARANMA, CHAARUMOODU PO, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 690505
SEBASTIAN T.J.,AGED 73 YEARSS/O JOSEPH T.V, THEKKETHAYIL,
THEJAS, THUMBOLI PO, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 688008
M.SANKAR SEN,AGED 77 YEARSS/O SANKARA PILLAI , 4A,JJ
VISTA APPARTMENT, KANJIRAMPAARA PO, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
PIN - 695030
P.RAMAN PANICKERAGED 78 YEARSS/O PADMANABHAN, RADHIKA
BHAVAN,PLAVODU, PLRA266, KODUNGANNOR PO,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695013
SREELATHA SUKUMAR,AGED 59 YEARSD/O SUKUMARAN AISWARYA,
ORIENTAL ESTATE LANE, KALOOR, ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682017
P.D. PRASADAGED 64 YEARSS/O DIVAKARAN, AISWARYA, ORIENTAL
ESTATE LANE, KALOOR,ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682017
G.S. CHANDRASEKHARAN NAIR,AGED 77 YEARSS/O G. SANKARA
NARAYANAN NAIR, T.C 14/638, NRA-206, VIKAS BHAVAN P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695033
R.GOPINATHAN NAIR,AGED 79 YEARSS/O RAMAKRISHNA PILLAI,
T.C 64/519, KOOTTAPLAVILA VEEDU, EDAGRAMAM, KARUMOM P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695002
G.RAVEENDRAN NAIR,AGED 79 YEARSS/O M.GOPALA PILLAI, N.V
SADANAM, KARAMKODE, NETTAYAM P.O, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN
- 695013
N.G. DIVAKARANAGED 80 YEARSS/O N.GOVINDAN,ASWATHY BHAVAN,
T.C 3/1420, G-6, LEKSHMI NAGAR, PATTOM P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004
K.E PADMANABHAN NAIRAGED 74 YEARSS/O SARASI JANABHA
KURUP, KADAMATTIL HOUSE, CMC-X, KALIKULAM, CHERTHALA P.O,
ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 688524
M. KATHIRKUNJUAGED 69 YEARSPUTHENPURAYIL,
PADINJATTINKARA, THEVALAKKARA, KOLLAM P.O., PIN - 690524
K.S. SASEENDRANAGED 68 YEARSS/O SIVARAMAN, SNRA-101,
MEDICAL COLLEGE P.O, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695011
K.R RAJAGOPAL,AGED 75 YEARSJANAKI NIVAS, SARAS-55,
SREEVARAHAM, MANACAUD P.O, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN 695009
V.M CHEKKU,AGED 74 YEARSS/O RAMAN, VADAKKEDATHU ,
CHELANNOOR P.O, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673616
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 3:-
M.SHAJIHAN,AGED 76 YEARSS/O MOHAMMED HANEEFA, BIJIAS
HOUSE, THEVALLY, KOLLAM, PIN - 691009
K.M. JAYALEKSHMI PILLAIAGED 81 YEARSD/O K. MADHAVAN
PILLAI ,LEXMI, SEKT-40, KURUP'S LANE, SASTHAMANGALAM P.O
., THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695010
K.P.ANNAMMA,AGED 65 YEARSD/O PAULOSE, NEDUMPOIKAYIL
HOUSE, MEENADOM P.O, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686516
BY ADVS.G.RAJAN POTAYILV.R.GOPUURMILA.M.G
RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA,REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO
GOVERNMENT, MINISTRY OF FINANCE, GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, NEW
DELHI - 110001
SANJEEV KAUSHIK, IAS(KERALA CADRE), ADDITIONAL SECRETARY
TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF FINANCE, GOVERNMENT
OF INDIA, NEW DELHI. *STRUCK OFF, PIN - 110001
THE EMPLOYEES PROVIDENT FUND ORGANIZATION,REPRESENTED BY
ITS REGIONAL COMMISSIONER, ZONAL OFFICE, BHAVISHYA NIDHY
BHAVAN, P.B NO. 1016, PATTOM PALACE P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004
THE STATE OF KERALA,REPRESENTED BY ITS ADDITIONAL CHIEF
SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS,REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN,
KERALA FINANCIAL CORPORATION, VELLAYAMBALAM,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695033
THE KERALA FINANCIAL CORPORATION,REPRESENTED BY ITS
MANAGING DIRECTOR, KERALA FINANCIAL CORPORATION,
VELLAYAMBALAM, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. *R2 IS STRUCK OUT FROM
THE ARRAY OF RESPONDENTS AS PER ORDER DATED 23/3/23 IN CM
APPLN.1/2023 IN WA 545/23., PIN - 695033
BY ADVS.SHRI.M.R.VENUGOPAL, SC, KFCDHANYA P.ASHOKANS.
MUHAMMAD ALIKHAN
OTHER PRESENT:
ADV DHANYA P ASHOKAN
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
23.03.2023, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 4:-
JUDGMENT
S.V.Bhatti, J.
We have heard Adv.G.Rajan Potayil for the appellants,
Adv.Dhanya P.Asokan for respondents 5 and 6 and Government
Pleader Mr.Bijoy Chandran for the 4th respondent.
2. Writ Petitioners are the appellants. The appellants were the
permanent employees of the Kerala Financial Corporation,
Thiruvananthapuram/6th respondent and admittedly, they
retired from service on different dates of superannuation prior
to 2010.
On 21.01.2022, the Writ Petition is filed for the
following reliefs:
(i) Call for the records leading to cancellation of
Exts.P1 and P2 pension scheme vide Ext.P5 order and
issue an order in the nature of certiorari to quash the
same.
(ii) Declaring that the petitioners are entitled to get
statutory pension at par with 4th respondent
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 5:-
government servants since Kerala Financial
Corporation is included as a portfolio of Finance
Department as item No.9 of ‘D’ of the First Schedule
of Part II, Kerala Government Business Rules by
which the transaction of the business of Government
is governed and also considering statutory pension
granted to similarly situated retired employees of the
Kerala State Housing Board (KSHB) as Government
servants.
(iii) issue an order or writ in the nature of
mandamus or direction directing the Ist respondent
Government of India to implement a viable pension
scheme for the retired employees of 6th respondent
within a time frame to be fixed by this Hon’ble Court
treating the Financial Corporations as Union subject
as item No.43 under Seventh Schedule of the
Constitution of India and also considering 6th
respondent KFC is an exempted institution under
Section 17 of EPF Act.
OR
Issue an order or writ in the nature of mandamus
or direction directing the 6th respondent to
implement Exhibits P1 and P2 pension scheme in a
time bound manner with adequate pension fund.
OR
Issue an order or writ in the nature of mandamus or
direction directing the 4th respondent State to take
over the liability of Exts.P1 and P2 orders or to
implement suitable pension scheme to the
petitioners at par with the Government employees in
a time bound manner with budget allocation of
adequate pension fund.
(iv) Issue order or writ in the nature of mandamus or
direction directing respondents 4 and 6 to implement
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 6:-
Ext.P6 medical scheme for the benefit of the retired
employees of the 6th respondent like the petitioners
who are suffering from acute illness and senility at
the cost of the 6th respondent.
(v) Any other order or direction this Hon’ble Court
may deem fit in the nature of the case and to render
justice considering senility and old ageing of the
petitioners.”
Through the impugned judgment, the learned Single
Judge dismissed the Writ Petition. Hence the appeal.
3. The judgment under appeal recorded the circumstances
preceding the filing of the Writ Petition, the basis for the
reliefs claimed by the writ petitioners and the reasons for
rejecting the prayers. To appreciate the controversy, the
following brief narrative is given.
4. Vide letter No.Psl/3625/2000 dated 24.10.2000, the
Managing Director of the 6th respondent Corporation
requested the Government to accord sanction for the
implementation of a pension scheme for the employees of the
Corporation
with
effect
from
31.03.1998.
By
G.O.(MS)No.669/2001/Fin. dated 5.4.2001, the 4th respondent
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 7:-
approved the request of the 6th respondent Corporation. The
6th respondent initiated steps for framing the rules and
regulations. The 6th respondent/Corporation will have to
make one-time contribution of Rs.3.63 crores to the pension
fund for bringing pension cover to all his employees. The onetime contribution of Rs.3.63 crores is against the initial
estimation of Rs.25 lakhs with which the pension scheme was
conceived for implementation by the 6th respondent
Corporation. By G.O.(MS) No.1174/01/Fin. dated 16.10.2001,
the State Government approved pension regulations and
called upon the 6th respondent Corporation to take steps in
accordance with Section 48 of the State Financial
Corporations Act, 1951.
5. On 10.5.2022, the Board of 6th respondent decided not to
implement a pension scheme in the Corporation.
By
communication dated 3.6.2002 addressed to the Principal
Secretary (Finance), the 6th respondent made the following
request.
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 8:-
“The Principal Secretary (Finance),
Finance Department,
Government Secretariat,
Thiruvananthapuram.
Madam,
Sub: Non-implementation of Pension scheme in Kerala
Financial Corporation-reg.
Ref: G.O.(MS) No.669/2001/Fin.dtd.5.4.2001.
…….
The Government vide the reference cited have accorded
consent to introduce the pension scheme in the
Corporation. However taking into account the present
financial position, the Board held on 10.5.2002 has decided
not to implement pension scheme in the Corporation. The
Board minutes in this regard is extracted below.
The Board considered the Actuarial Revaluation of the
Government approved pension proposal. Considering the
present financial situation of the Corporation further
contribution of 3.63 crores to the Pension Fund is not
feasible. Hence the Board decided not to implement the
scheme and authorised Managing Director to inform
Government accordingly.”
Yours faithfully,
Sd/Managing Director”
6. It is contextual to appreciate that a few of the
employees assailing Ext.P3 communication dated 3.6.2002
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 9:-
moved the Hob’ble Lok Ayukta, State of Kerala. The Lok
Ayukta directed implementation of the decision of the Board
of 6th respondent to pay pension to the retired employees.
The 6th respondent Corporation filed WP(C) No.5046 of 2014
challenging the directives of the Lok Ayukta. By judgment
dated 19.7.2018, the Writ Petition was allowed. The operative
portion reads thus:
9. We must also note that the absence of a finding on
the aspect of delay in filing the complaint before the
Lok Ayukta, more so in the context of a specific
averment in the counter affidavit filed by the
Financial Corporation pointing out the belated
nature of the complaint, also vitiates the
report/order of the Lok Ayukta. When the
contention regarding delay, taken in the context of
examining the jurisdiction of Lok Ayukta, was
brought to its notice, the Lok Ayukta ought to have
examined the said aspect and rendered its finding in
the matter before proceeding further with the
examination of the complaint. We also note that the
directions issued by the Lok Ayukta in paragraph 14
of the impugned report/order are such as would
take it outside the ambit of the term
"recommendation as contemplated under the Lok
Ayukta Act. The decisions of this Court in State of
Kerala v Bernad (2002 (3) KLT 254) and Sudha Devi.K
v. District Collector, Thiruvananthapuram and
others (2017 (2) KHC 850] are authorities for the
view that the Lok Ayukta can only make a report to
the authority concerned, with a recommendation,
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 10:-
and it is not competent to issue positive directions
under Section 12 of the Act. The recommendation
cannot partake the nature of positive directions,
much less peremptory in nature.
9. Before parting with the case, we might add that,
while we have heard elaborate arguments on the
merits of the case, we deem it unnecessary to deal
with the said contentions since we are allowing the
writ petition on the limited finding that Ext.P14
report/order of the Lok Ayukta, that is impugned in
the writ petition, is one that is passed without
jurisdiction. The contentions on merits are left open
to be considered in appropriate proceedings.
The writ petition is thus allowed as above.”
7. The writ petitioners, for that matter, none of the
retired employees has taken recourse in law to assail the
Board Resolution dated 10.5.2002 as communicated by
Ext.P3 letter dated 3.6.2002.
The 4th respondent, on
08.11.2019 issued impugned Government order which
reads as follows:
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 11:-
“ GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
Abstract
Kerala Financial Corporation-Introduction of Pension
Scheme for the employees of the Corporation-Orders
cancelled.
FINANCE (PU-A) DEPARTMENT
G.O.(Rt) No.8842/2019/FIN Dated, Thiruvananthapuram 08/11/2019
Read 1 G.O.(MS) No.669/2001/Fin. Dated 5.4.2001
2 G.O.(MS) No.1174/2001/Fin dated 16.10.2001
3 Letter No.KFC/HO/F&A/475/2019 dated 21.06.2019 from
MD, KFC
ORDER
Managing Director, Kerala Finance Corporation has reported
that the Board of Directors of KFC has approved the introduction of
National Pension Scheme in the Corporation and had earlier decided
not to implement pension scheme as per G.O. cited above. In view of
this, Government are pleased to cancel the G.O. read as Ist and 2nd
above.
The Board of KFC may amend KFC Staff Regulations 1966 for
implementing NPS.
(By order of the Governor)
SANJEEV KAUSHIK IAS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY”
8. The admitted position is that Ext.P5 is dated
08.11.2019 and the decision of the Board as communicated
in Ext.P3 was dated 03.06.2002. The 6th respondent through
letter dated 21.6.2019 informed the inclination of the 6th
respondent Corporation to implement National Pension
Scheme in the Corporation. The National Pension Scheme
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 12:-
could be implemented only upon recalling or cancelling
Exts.P1 and P2. Therefore, it is in the above background,
Ext.P5 is questioned.
9. Adverting to the grounds of challenge to Ext.P5, we
notice that the writ petitioners are substantially reagitating the very grounds which were urged before the
learned Single Judge. The judgment of the learned Single
Judge is under challenge and after going through the
judgment, we do not find a reason to take a different view
against what has been recorded in the judgment under
appeal. We further notice that Ext.P5 has two limbs viz.
takes note of the proposed implementation of National
Pension Scheme to the employees on rolls and necessitates
recalling or cancelling Exts.P1 and P2 Government orders
dated 5.4.2001 and 16.10.2001. The legal grounds urged
against Ext.P5 dated 08.11.2019 independently do not
validly arise at all. The learned single judge has given
sufficient reasons justifying recalling Exts.P1 and P2. We do
not wish to burden the judgment re-iterating the same
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 13:-
contentions and conclusions. The crux of the matter is that
Ext.P3 is a resolution made by the 6th respondent. The
consequential steps taken are either in addition to or in
furtherance of the Board resolution dated 10.5.2002. Ext.P5
lays the path for implementation of National Pension
Scheme to the employees working in 6th respondent
organization. The petitioners are getting confused with
available prayer against Ext.P3 and the consequential steps
being taken by the respondents. Till Ext.P3 holds as a
binding resolution, the decision taken in Ext.P5 by the
Government recalling Exts.P1 and P2 does not warrant
interference. The writ petitioners retired from service long
ago have received the benefits due to them and the present
writ petition is filed without establishing a right to claim
pension in law. The decision to implement pension was
aborted to financial constraints. The communication in
Ext.P5 by itself does not present any cause of action. The
petitioners since are retired from service can’t contend for
implementation of an otherwise unimplementable decision
W.A.No.545 of 2023
-: 14:-
by the 6th respondent. The writ prayers for the reasons
recorded by the learned Single Judge are rightly rejected.
Hence we confirm the order under appeal.
The Writ Appeal, for the reasons stated above, fails
and dismissed accordingly.
Sd/- S.V.BHATTI, JUDGE
Sd/- BASANT BALAJI, JUDGE
css/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review