Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:24570
1WP9594.2024.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD.
WRIT PETITION NO. 9594 OF 2024
Yuvraj S/o yashwant Maske,
Age : 64 years, Occu. Vanpaharekari,
R/o. Khed, Tq. Lohara, District Osmanabad.
...Petitioner
Versus
1]
Van Parikshetra Adhikari,
Van Parikshetra Karyalaya,
Umarga, District Osmanabad.
2]
Sahsanchalak, Vanikaran,
(Mukhya Van Sanrakshak),
Pradeshik Vibhag, Osmanpura,
Aurangabad (Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar).
3]
Vibhagiya Van Adhikari,
Van Vibhag, Block No. 20,
Central Administrative Building,
Osmanabad.
...Respondents
.....
Mr. B. R. Jaybhay – Advocate for the Petitioner
Mrs. M. L. Sangit – AGP for the State
..…
CORAM :
NEERAJ P. DHOTE, J.
DATED :
22ND JUNE, 2026
ORAL JUDGMENT : 1.
Heard finally with the consent of the parties.
2.
This Writ Petition, filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, impugns the Judgment and Order dated
03.05.2024 passed by the learned Member, Industrial Court, Latur,
1WP9594.2024.odt
whereby Complaint (ULP) No. 253 of 2018 preferred by the Petitioner
came to be dismissed.
3.
The Petitioner filed the said Complaint with the contention
that, he had been working as a labourer on the post of Forest Guard
since 01.07.2000. He was performing his duties at the Range Forest
Office, Omerga, at Mouje Dhanori, and was issued an Identity Card. For
several months, he was not paid his salary. The Ranger used to obtain
signatures on the muster roll and make payment accordingly. His nature
of duty was to protect trees, cutting grass, digging pits, taking away
plants from the nursery, plantation work, watering plants, and
protecting trees from cattle, etc. According to the Petitioner, there are
many permanent labours with the Respondents, who were given the
benefit of permanency. He being a daily wager, was not given the benefit
of permanency though he continuously worked for more than 240 days
in a calendar year. The Petitioner, therefore, sought relief of permanency
along with consequential benefits. There was unfair labour practice and
favouritism by the Respondents and accordingly prayed for appropriate
reliefs in the said Complaint.
4.
The Complaint was resisted by the Respondents by filing
Written Statement. The contentions raised by the Petitioner were
denied. It was contended that, there was no post designated as Forest
Guard in the department and, therefore, there was no question of
1WP9594.2024.odt
appointing the Complainant to such a post. According to the
Respondents, the Complainant was discharging the work through a
contract as per the requirements of the department.
It was further
contended that, the identity card relied upon by the Complainant was
not issued by the competent authority. There was no permanent work
available in their office and that no service muster roll was maintained.
The Complainant was neither a permanent Van Mazoor nor a Forest
Guard and, therefore, there was no question of obtaining his signatures
on any muster roll. It was also contended that, no wages of the
Complainant had been withheld. The Respondents further submitted
that, the Complainant was not entitled to permanency or any
consequential benefits and, therefore, prayed for dismissal of the
Complaint.
5.
The learned Industrial Court framed the necessary issues,
and the parties led their respective evidence. The Complainant filed his
Affidavit of evidence and produced on record copies of his Identity Card,
Aadhaar Card, bank passbook, bank statement, letters issued by the
Range Forest Officer, and a copy of his application. The Respondents
filed an affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief of Sayas Karad and
thereafter closed their oral evidence. Upon appreciating the evidence on
record and after hearing both sides, the learned Industrial Court passed
the impugned Judgment and Order.
6.
1WP9594.2024.odt
Heard the learned Advocate for the Petitioner and the
learned AGP for the Respondents.
[a]
The learned Advocate for the Petitioner submitted that, the
Identity Card issued by the Respondents show the Petitioner
as a Forest Guard, which indicates that, he was duly
appointed. It was further submitted that the Petitioner had
continuously worked for more than 240 days in a calendar
year since 01.07.2000. His wages were withheld from
September 2018, and he was not permitted to sign the
muster roll. In view of the Government Resolutions, the
Petitioner was entitled for permanency. It is, therefore,
prayed that the Petition be allowed.
[b]
Per contra, the learned AGP for the Respondents submitted
that, the learned Industrial Court had considered all the
aspects of the matter on the basis of the evidence available
on record. It is submitted that, there was no evidence to
establish that, the Petitioner had continuously worked for
240 days in any calendar year. The Identity Card relied
upon by the Petitioner was not issued by the competent
authority. It was further submitted that, there was no post
known as ‘Vanpaharekari’ or ‘Van Majoor’ and, therefore,
1WP9594.2024.odt
there was no question of appointing the Petitioner on such a
post. No unfair labour practice was committed by the
Respondents. The Petition is devoid of merit and be
dismissed.
7.
Perused the impugned Judgment. As regards the contention
that he had worked continuously for 240 days, the observations in the
impugned Judgment show that there was no documentary evidence to
establish that the Petitioner had worked continuously for 240 days in
any calendar year. Petitioner did not issue any notice to the Respondents
calling upon them to produce the muster roll or any other relevant
documents to substantiate his claim that he had worked continuously for
240 days or more in a calendar year since 01.07.2000. The learned
Industrial Court considered this aspect of the matter and observed that
the Petitioner had miserably failed to prove that he had continuously
worked with the Respondents for 240 days or more in a calendar year
since 01.07.2000.
8.
As regards the claim for permanency based on the
Government Resolution dated 31.01.1996, the learned Industrial Court
observed that, under the said Government Resolution, permanency was
conferred upon those workers who had continuously worked for 240
days or more in a calendar year for a period of five years. Since the
Petitioner failed to establish that he had continuously worked for 240
1WP9594.2024.odt
days or more in a calendar year with the Respondents, he was not
entitled to the benefits contemplated under the said Government
Resolution.
9.
So far as the Identity Card is concerned, the observations in
the impugned Judgment indicate that, the learned Industrial Court duly
considered this aspect of the matter. It is observed that, the copy of the
Identity Card was produced below Exhibit U-34 and that no date was
mentioned thereon. There was no material on record to indicate as to
who had issued the same or whose signature appeared on it. The
learned Industrial Court further observed that, the evidence relating to
the Identity Card was cryptic and shaky in nature. The Petitioner
admitted that, the Respondents had taken back the Identity Card to
verify as to who had issued the same. The observations further show
that, the Identity Card did not bear the seal of the office of the
Respondents and it raises suspicion on the authenticity of the Identity
Card. It was also observed that, the Petitioner failed to produce any
appointment order and therefore, solely on the basis of a suspicious
Identity Card, he could not be held to be an employee of the
Respondents. The observations in the impugned Judgment show that,
the learned Industrial Court considered the documentary evidence on
record and recorded the aforesaid findings.
10.
In respect of the entries in the bank documents, the
1WP9594.2024.odt
observations in the impugned Judgment show that, the learned
Industrial Court perused the same and recorded a finding that, the
wages received by the Petitioner were in respect of work done under the
scheme ‘MGNREGSSFA MAHA’, and further observed that, there was no
material on record to connect the said entries in the bank documents
with the Respondents. The observations further show that, no document
was produced to establish that, the Petitioner had received wages
through the Respondents. The learned Industrial Court also considered
the two credit entries in the passbook dated 25.04.2017 and
16.03.2018,
showing
amounts
of
Rs.15,417/-
and
Rs.8,017/-,
respectively, credited under the head “Forest Labour Payment”, and
observed that these two credit entries were insufficient to establish that
the Petitioner had been serving with the Respondents since 01.07.2000.
On the basis of the evidence available on record, the learned Industrial
Court concluded that the Petitioner had miserably failed to prove that
the Respondents had paid wages to him through the Bank.
11.
The impugned Judgment reveals that, the learned Industrial
Court framed the necessary issues on the basis of the pleadings of the
parties and decided the Complaint on the basis of the evidence available
on record. The learned Industrial Court considered all the relevant
aspects of the matter and assigned cogent reasons in support of its
findings. Nothing is shown that the findings or observations recorded in
the
impugned
Judgment
are
perverse
or
erroneous.
In
the
1WP9594.2024.odt
circumstances, no interference is called for in the impugned Judgment
and Order. The Petition is, therefore, liable to be dismissed.
12.
Hence, the following order:
ORDER
[i]
The Petition is dismissed.
[NEERAJ P. DHOTE]
JUDGE
SG Punde
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review