Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:54622
95WP15589.2026.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 15589 OF 2026
Shri Bharat Tukaram Chamle,
Age. 54 years, Occ. Agri.,
R/o. Yeshwant Co-operative
Housing Society, Udgir,
Tq. Udgir, Dist. Latur.
Versus
1.
The State of Maharashtra,
Through the Secretary,
In the Department of Co-operation,
Mantralaya, Mumbai – 32.
2.
The State Co-operative Election Authority,
Through its Secretary,
Maharashtra State,
Central Building, Pune.
3.
The Returning Officer /
Latur District Central Co-operative Bank
Ltd., Latur, Tq. And dist. Latur and
Residential Deputy Collector, Latur,
Tq. And Dist. Latur.
4.
The Divisional Joint Registrar,
Co-operation Societies Latur.
5.
The Latur District Central Co-operative
Bank Ltd., Latur, Tq. And Dist. Latur,
Through its Managing Director.
6.
Chandrashekhar Orabhu Dandime,
Age. 56 years, Occ. Business,
R/o. Parivar Society, Khori Galli, Latur,
Tq. & Dist. Latur.
…Petitioner
95WP15589.2026.odt
7.
Baburao Hanmantrao Khandade,
Age. 52 years, Occ. Agri,
R/o. Gangapur, Tq. & Dist. Latur.
8.
Bharat Dnyanoba Gore,
Age. 58 years, Occ. Service,
R/o. Yelamwadi, Post. Dhanora,
Tq. Nilanga, Dist. Latur.
9.
Dharampal Ramrao Patil,
Age. 55 years, Occ. Agri.,
R/o. Shivni (M), Tq. Chakur, Dist. Latur.
10.
Anup S/o. Dnyanoba Shelke,
Age. 48 years, Occ. Agri.,
R/o. Hippalgaon, Tq. Shirur Anantpal
Dist. Latur,
Presently R/o. Hotel Wada,
Ausa Road, Latur, Tq. & Dist. Latur.
11.
Santosh Bhanudas Bembade,
Age. 50 years, Occ. Agri.,
R/o. Dhanegaon, Tq. & Dist. Latur.
12.
Shri Keshav Netke,
Residential Dy. Collector Latur,
Tq. and Dist. Latur.
… Respondents
...
Advocate for Petitioner : Mr. A.N. Irpatgire
AGP for Respondent No. 1 : Ms. V.S. Chaudhari
Advocate for Respondent Nos. 2 & 3 : Mr. V.H. Dighe
Advocate for Respondent No. 5 : Mr. S.V. Advant
Advocate for Respondent No. 6 : Mr. A.V. Hon
…
CORAM : MANJUSHA A. DESHPANDE, J.
RESERVED ON
: 02.11.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 04.11.2026
95WP15589.2026.odt
JUDGMENT :
1.
Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith and heard
finally with the consent of the parties.
2.
The Petitioner is challenging the order dated
19.10.2026, passed by the Returning Officer of Latur District
Central Co-operative Bank, Latur, rejecting the nomination
form filled by the Petitioner, which is confirmed by the
Appellate Authority i.e. Divisional Joint Registrar Co-operative
Society, Latur, vide its order dated 29.10.2026, in Appeal no.
98/2026.
3.
Learned Advocate Mr. Irpatgire, for the Petitioner
submitted that, pursuant to the election programme for the
election of managing committee of Respondent no. 5 – Bank,
was declared by Respondent no. 2. The Petitioner in the
representative capacity on behalf of Late Ram Charadrao Patil
Talegaonkar Sahakari Kharedi Vikri Sangha, Udgir (for short
‘RCPTSKVS, Udgir’), filed his nomination for the part of
member of the Managing Committee. The name of the
Petitioner is already included in the voters’ list of Respondent
95WP15589.2026.odt
no. 5 – Bank. Since the Petitioner belongs to OBC category and
is eligible, he has filled his nomination paper from the reserved
category of OBC constituency with requisite documents.
4.
It is submitted that, Respondent no. 6, filed false
and frivolous objections stating that, the Society represented by
the Petitioner is not transacting the Bank account regularly with
Respondent no. 5 – Bank, and therefore, prayed that Petitoner
be disqualified to contest the elections as per Bye-law no.
35.1.B-3. A reply is filed by the Petitioner responding to the
objection, bringing it to the notice of the Returning Officer that,
the Society is having current account in Respondent no. 5 /
Bank and there are transaction in the said account. It was also
brought to his notice that the certificate issued by the Managing
Director of Respondent no. 5 – Bank, is not having legal
sanctity. Respondent no. 3 – Returning Officer, without
application of his mind has rejected the nomination form of the
Petitioner holding that, the Petitioner incurs disqualification in
view of Bye-law no. 35.1.B-3. Even Respondent no. 4 –
Appellate Authority, has confirmed the same view vide order
dated 29.10.2026.
5.
95WP15589.2026.odt
Mr. Irpatgire, raises challenge to the said order on
the ground that, the Petitioner has filed nomination from the
reserved category as provided under Section 73 B of the
Maharashtra Co-operative Societies, Act, 1960 (for short ‘ the
MCS, Act’). One member each for scheduled castes or tribes,
other backward class and de-notified tribes and nomadic tribes
or special backward classes, is provided under the said
provision. He submitted that this reservation is provided with, a
particular object of ensuring maximum participation of the
persons belonging to the deprived class of society. Therefore,
the usual disqualifications applicable to the general classes of
constituencies provided under the Bye-laws of the Society
would not be applicable to the reserved category provided under
the provisions of the Act.
6.
He further submitted that, Section 73 C of the
MCS, Act, begins with an non-obstante clause which provides
that irrespective of anything contained in the Act or any Rules
or any Bye-laws of any Society, the State Government may by
general or special order, direct, that three seats shall be reserved
for the three categories mentioned in the said provision. He
95WP15589.2026.odt
would, therefore, submit that since the Section itself provides
that there has to be reservation for each category as provided
under Section 73 B, even if there is any other provision in the
Act, Rules or in the Bye-laws that runs counter this Section, it
will have to be igonered and cannot be made applicable. He,
therefore, submitted that the disqualification i.e. based on the
Bye-law no. 35.1.B-3 is bad in law.
7.
It is submitted that the said Bye-law provides for
eligibility as a member of the Managing Committee of the
Bank, it is necessary that the Society affiliated to the Bank
should maintain a current account with are regular transactions.
According to him, the account of the Society is not dormant
which can be gathered from the account statement of the current
account of the Society for the period 23.12.2023 to 20.10.2026.
The last transaction which deposited an amount of Rs. 2,100/- is
dated 20.08.2026. It is his submission that apart from the
objection of lack of business in the account, it is the grievance
of the objector that, since its date of enrollment, the Society has
not taken any loan for its business with the Bank as compared
to the other members. Therefore, it is not expected that the
95WP15589.2026.odt
member Society which has not transacted with the Bank should
get precedence, in the matter of representation on the Managing
Committee of the Bank. He would submit that as far as this
objection regarding failing to avail the loan facility from the
Bank and thereby, not engaging in the transactions with the
Bank is concerned, the Society has been consistently making
Applications to the Bank Manager of its branch at Udgir as well
as Latur, for extending the cash credit loan facility along with
requisite documents. The Applications addressed to the Bank
Manager dated 01.12.2022 and 06.04.2022 and a complaint to
the Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, has been
relied upon by the Petitioner to submit that the grounds raised
by the Respondent are frivolous, since the request of the Society
has been ignored for extending the cash credit loan facility.
Thus, the Society cannot be held responsible for failing to
transact with the bank. He, therefore, would submit that based
on such frivolous grounds, the Petitioner cannot be deprived of
his legitimate and statutory right of filing his nomination form
to the Managing Committee of Respondent no. 5 – Bank.
8.
Learned Advocate
Mr.
Hon,
appearing
for
95WP15589.2026.odt
Respondent no. 6 / Objector, submitted that the Petitioner incurs
disqualification as provided under Section 73 CA (1) (f) (iv).
According to him, if a candidate incurs disqualification as per
the Bye-laws of the Society, he is ineligible to contest the
elections of the District Central Co-operative Bank, which is a
federal society. Reliance is also placed on Rule 20 of the
Maharashtra Co-operative Societies (Election to Committee)
Rules, 2014 (for short ‘the Election Rules of 2014’). He would
submit that even though, the proviso provides that any
individual member of the Society or any member of a
Committee of a Member Society to be elected, co-opted or
nominated shall be eligible for the nomination as a candidate,
yet fact remains that there is no individual membership of the
Managing Committee of Respondent no. 5 – Bank. All the
members are in the representative capacity of the Member
Societies, hence the disqualifications provided for the
representative of Member Society would be ipso facto
applicable to the candidate who represent such Societies. He
submitted that, the name of the Petitioner is included in the
voters’ list as a representative of the Society. Therefore, he
95WP15589.2026.odt
cannot claim that, he has filled in the nomination form as a
independent member and thus the disqualification attached to
the Society would not be applicable to his nomination. He has
drawn attention of this Court to the various class of
constituencies provided under the Bye-laws of the Bank to
contend that all such are represented by various Societies. There
is no provision for individual membership on the Managing
Committee of the Bank. Thus, according to him, the
disqualification incurred by the Society is applicable to the
representative of such Society.
9.
After hearing the Petitioner and the contesting
Respondents for some time the state involved in the Writ
Petition is about the ineligibility of the Petitioner who has filled
in the nomination from the constituency of OBC as provided
under Section 73 B of the MCS, Act, has been rejected on the
ground that he incurs disqualification as per the Bye-laws no.
35.1.B-3. Petitioner has alleged mala fides against the Directors
of the Bank and allegation of corrupt practices under Rule 81
and 86 of the Election Rules of 2014.
10.
95WP15589.2026.odt
Upon perusal of the document which is relied upon
by the Returning Officer to disqualify the Petitioner, it appears
that a certificate has been issued by Respondent no. 5 – Bank on
16.10.2026, declaring that the Society who is member of
Respondent no. 5 – Bank, is not regularly transacting with the
Bank. It is claimed that the Bye-law no. 35.1.B-3 which has a
binding effect provides that, the Society through whom the
representative has filed the nomination, should regularly
transact in the current account of such Society in the Bank.
Such account should not be dormant, one year prior to the
elections. So far as the second part is concerned, the account
statement of the Petitioner with the Bank, discloses that, the
account is operative and functional. As regards the necessity of
regular transaction in the said account is concerned, there
appears to be transactions on 12.09.2024, 03.12.2024,
19.03.2025, 19.03.2025, 24.09.2025, 03.10.2025, 26.03.2026,
26.03.2026 and 20.08.2026. Though these amounts are meager
amounts, the Petitioner has demonstrated from the record that in
spite of consistently requesting the Bank to extend the Society,
the cash credit loan facility by way of Applications dated
95WP15589.2026.odt
01.12.2022, 06.04.2022, upon failing to get positive response to
a complaint is made to the Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Latur, bringing it to his notice that, the
Society is not receiving any response to the Application of the
Bank for the loan facility, thereby the Bank is acting contrary to
the objects sought to be achieved as per its Bye-laws. Hence, in
view of the documents placed on record, it is apparent that
Respondent no. 5 – Bank has refused to act upon the
Applications of the Society for extending them the loan facility.
At the same time objection for failure of regular transaction
with the Bank is raised. The conduct of Respondent no. 5 –
Bank, clearly appears to be in contravention to the object of the
Bank. Based on the account statement where there are regular
transactions but of meager amounts, the Petitioner cannot be
denied opportunity to contest the election by applying Bye-law
no. 35.1.B-3.
11.
Considering the advance stage of the election
programme and in view of the consistent view of this Court as
well as the Hon’ble Supreme Court that once the election
programme is declared, the Court should be slow in interfering
95WP15589.2026.odt
in the same, unless there is a patent illegality on the face of
record which requires interference. I am well aware of the
jurisprudence surrounding interference under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution in election matters, as well as the catena
of judgments delivered by this Court and the Hon’ble Supreme
Court holding the field. This Court, in Dattatray Genaba Lole
and Others Versus Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative
Societies in Writ Petition No. 5878 of 2021, decided on
26.11.2021, has once again cautioned against interference in
election matters. At the same time, it has carved out an
exception permitting interference where the impugned order
suffers from patent illegality. In the present case, I find it fit to
interfere with the impugned order, particularly in light of the
patent illegality committed by Respondent nos. 3 and 4. The
interference at this stage is not likely to disturb or hamper the
election process, since the last date for withdrawal nominations
is tomorrow, i.e., 05.11.2026, and the ballot papers will be
printed thereafter. Presently, the stage of the election
programme is scheduled for withdrawal of nomination, and
thereafter, there shall be final list of nominated candidates.
12.
95WP15589.2026.odt
Thus, in my view even if the name of the Petitioner
is included in the validly nominated candidates’, at this stage, it
is not likely to cause any interference in the election process.
Particularly, in view of the fact that the nomination of the
Petitioner has been rejected on frivolous grounds which is not
supported by any document.
13.
Thus, in the conspectus of the matter, I find that the
Petitioner has made out a case for interference in the order
passed by the Returning Officer as well as the Appellate
Authority in view of the patent illegality that appears on the
face of record. In the result, the Writ Petition is allowed in
terms of prayer clause ‘B’ and ‘C’.
14.
Rule is made absolute in the above terms.
(MANJUSHA A. DESHPANDE, J.)
SPC
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review