Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:54644
(1)
91wp15584.26
N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.15584 OF 2026
Govindrao Gnyanoba Makne,
Age-60 years, Occu- Agriculturist,
R/o. Chakur, Tq. Chakur,
Dist. Latur
...PETITIONER
VERSUS
1.
Divisional Joint Registrar Cooperative Societies,
Latur Division, Latur, Tq. & Dist. Latur
2.
The Returning Officer,
Latur District Central Cooperative Bank
Ltd, Parbhani, Tq. Parbhani, Dist. Parbhani
3.
Latur District Central Cooperative Bank Ltd.
Parbhani, Tq. & Dist. Parbhani
4.
Santosh Nanasaheb Patil,
Age-55 years, Occu-Agril,
R/o. Shelgaon, Tq. Chakur,
5.
Dharmapal Ramrao Patil,
Age-52 years, Occu-Agril,
R/o. Shivni (M), Tq. Chakur,
Dist. Latur
6.
Pardip Narayan Jadhav,
Age-62 years, Occu-Agril,
R/o. Gharola, Tq. Chakur,
Dist. Latur
...RESPONDENTS
Mr. V. D. Sapkal, Senior Advocate a/w Mr. Rohit Patil a/w Mr. Amit
Gadekar i/b Mr. N. R. Pawade, Advocate for the Petitioner
Mr. V. H. Dighe, Advocate for Respondent No. 2
Mr. S. V. Adwant, Advocate for Respondent No. 3
Mr. D. J. Chaudhari, Advocate for Respondent No. 4
Mrs. D. S. Jape, AGP for the Respondents-State
1 of 25
(2)
91wp15584.26
AND
WRIT PETITION NO.15585 OF 2026
Dharmpal Annarao Devshette,
Age-60 years, Occu- Agriculturist,
R/o. Belsangvi, Tq. Jalkot,
Dist. Latur
...PETITIONER
VERSUS
1.
Divisional Joint Registrar Cooperative Societies,
Latur Division, Latur, Tq. & Dist. Latur
2.
The Returning Officer,
Latur District Central Cooperative Bank
Ltd, Latur & Resident Deputy Collector, Latur
3.
Latur District Central Cooperative Bank Ltd.
Parbhani, Tq. & Dist. Parbhani
4.
Ashish Ajit Rajurkar,
Age-40 years, Occu-Agril,
R/o. Gavhan, Post Atnoor,
Tq. Jalkot, Dist. Latur
5.
Vividh Karyakari Seva Sahakari
Sanstha Maryadit, Belsangvi
Tq. Jalkot, Dist. Latur
6.
Baburao Madhavrao Jadhav
Age-62 years, Occu-Agril,
R/o. Viral, Post. Patoda
Bk., Tq. Jalkot, Dist. Latur
...RESPONDENTS
Mr. V. D. Sapkal, Senior Advocate a/w Mr. Rohit Patil a/w Mr. Amit
Gadekar i/b Mr. N. R. Pawade, Advocate for the Petitioner
Mr. V. H. Dighe, Advocate for Respondent No. 2
Mr. S. V. Adwant, Advocate for Respondent No. 3
Mr. D. J. Chaudhari, Advocate for Respondent No. 4
Mrs. P. V. Diggikar, AGP for the Respondents-State
2 of 25
(3)
91wp15584.26
CORAM : MANJUSHA DESHPANDE, J.
RESERVED ON : 02nd NOVEMBER, 2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 04th NOVEMBER, 2026
ORAL JUDGMENT :
1.
Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith. With the consent
of the parties the Petition is taken up for final disposal.
2.
Since both these writ petitions raise a common issue, it
can be decided by way of a common judgment.
3.
Heard the learned Advocates for the respective parties.
4.
Both these writ petitions raises common issue about the
correctness of rejection of the nomination papers filed by the
respective Petitioners, that
have been rejected on the ground of
default of V. K. S. S. Society, without properly considering the actual
bank transaction and the effect of Government Circular dated 26-112025 and Government Resolution dated 10-10-2025.
WRIT PETITION NO.15584 OF 2026
5.
Mr. V. D. Sapkal, learned Senior Advocate for the
Petitioner submits that the petitioner is a duly authorized
representative of the Society. The election of the Board of Directors
of Bank was declared and the election process has commenced in
3 of 25
(4)
91wp15584.26
accordance with the provisions of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies
Act, 1960 and the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies (Election to
Committee) Rules 2014. As per the election program of the District
Central Cooperative Bank, Latur, the Petitioner has submitted his
nomination paper, to contest the election of Board of Directors from
the Chakur constituency. The nomination paper was accompanied by
requisite documents, in support of his eligibility to contest the
election. During the scrutiny of nomination papers on 19-10-2026,
Respondent No. 4 raised an objection to the nomination of Petitioner
alleging that the Society was a defaulting Society as on 16-10-2026
and the Society had failed to satisfy the requirement of byelaw
No.35.1.2 (A-1).
6.
It is submitted that in response to the objection raised by
Respondent No.4, the Petitioner has filed a detailed reply, denying the
objection raised by Respondent No. 4 which was supported by
relevant documentary evidence. It was stated that the society has
regularly paid the interest towards the loan account with the
Respondent-Bank. Further reliance is placed on Government
Resolution 10-10-2025 and Circular dated 26-11-2025 wherein the
Government has granted stay to the recovery of crop loan and also
directed to reconstruct the loan obtained from the Co-operative
4 of 25
(5)
91wp15584.26
Societies. Apart from the defense that the account is regular, objection
was also raised to the genuineness of the certificate issued by the Bank
branding the Petitioner as ‘defaulter’. The certificate of arrears of the
Respondent-Society shows arrears to the tune of Rs.1,25,61,251/7.
It is submitted that this document is not a genuine
document, since it does not bear any outward number, it does not
specify as to what is the period of default, no account number is
mentioned in the certificate and footnote of the certificate contains a
remark that the certificate is subject to the remarks of the Auditor.
Thus, according to him, this is not an authentic document which could
be relied upon to claim that the Society to whom the Petitioner
represent is a defaulting Society. It is submitted that the Returning
Officer solely relying on the certificate issued by the Bank, which
certified the arrears to the tune of Rs.1,25,61,251/- has held that due to
the arrears, Petitioner has incurred disqualification in view of Section
73 CA (i)(f) and byelaw of the bank i.e. byelaw No.35.1.2 (A 1) and
35.1.(b-3). It is submitted that the Returning Officer has relied on two
documents supplied by the Petitioner along with his nomination form,
which are the part of Audit report, which does not disclose any
recovery for the year 2024-25 and 25-26.
8.
The Petitioner has contended that so far as any default is
5 of 25
(6)
91wp15584.26
concerned, they have not received any written communication about
any default committed by them. After recording this, the Returning
Officer has held that the Petitioner has failed to prove with supporting
evidence that, the Society is not a defaulter.
9.
Mr. Sapkal, learned Senior Advocate submitted that the
Returning Officer has cast negative burden on the Petitioner. The
burden of proof is on Respondent No. 4-objector to prove that the
Petitioner is ineligible to contest the election. The Petitioner has
already filed the nomination form supported with necessary
documents about his eligibility. If at all Respondent No. 4 was
objecting to his nomination, it was his responsibility to demonstrate
that the Petitioner is ineligible.
10.
It is further contended that though reliance is placed on
the certificate issued by the Bank, which is bereft of any details, no
communication about the arrears or any notice demanding the arrears
has ever been issued to the Petitioner. The Petitioner relies on the
Government Resolution dated 10-10-2025 to contend that
Government Resolution was issued by the State
this
Government to
provide relief against the natural calamity of excessive rain to the
beneficiaries in Districts and the Talukas affected by rains as
mentioned in the annexure to the Government Resolution. This
6 of 25
(7)
91wp15584.26
Government Resolution has been issued so as to grant relief to the
affected Talukas by providing certain measures of relief, such as (i)
exemption from land revenue; (ii) reconstruction of loans from all the
Co-operative societies; (iii) Stay to the recovery of loans from the
agriculture and allied operations; (iv)
exemption from monthly
electricity bill; (v) exemption from the payment of examination fees
from the students of 10th and 12th standard.
11.
It is submitted that since the
Society to whom the
Petitioner represent is covered under the said Government Resolution,
assuming that there are any arrears due against the Society, its effect
has been stayed by the Government for a period of one year starting
from 10-10-2025. It is further submitted that in furtherance of the
Government Resolution dated 10-10-2025, circular has been issued
by the Cooperative Marketing and Textile Department, providing for
reconstruction of the loans of the Cooperative Societies and one year
stay for recovery of loans in respect of agriculture allied operations.
The provision is made in the said circular to the effect that the loans
of the agriculturist from the affected Talukas shall be converted from
short-term to long-term loans. So far as the recovery of loans is
concerned, it was directed that the State-level Bankers Committee,
Maharashtra State Cooperative Bank as well as the District Central
7 of 25
(8)
91wp15584.26
Cooperative Bank, shall take appropriate steps for the same and the
Application of the circular shall be scrupulously followed. It is
therefore submitted that since the Government Resolution dated 1010-2025 as well as Circular dated 26-11-2025 has deferred the
recovery of loan from the farmers. The dues of the Societies should
not be treated as a disqualification for the members of such Societies,
who are in arrears of the loans. He submitted that in view of the said
Government Resolution and Circular the certificate dated 16-10-2026
should not have been issued by Respondent No. 3-Bank. He submits
that since the Government Resolution is issued in exercise of Article
162 of the Constitution of India, it is equal to the law laid down by the
legislature. He would attract the attention of this court to the A-Star
given to the society, in its Audit by the certified auditor of the Cooperation department for the year 01-04-2023 to 31-03-2024, 01-042024 to 31-03-2025 and 01-04-2025 to 31-03-2026. He submits that in
view of the A-Star given by the Auditor, the participation of the
Petitioner should have been allowed by the Returning Officer.
12.
Mr. D. J. Chaudhari, Advocate for the contesting
Respondent No. 4 submitted that although the Petitioner is relying on
the A-Star issued by certified Auditor, to the Petitioner in its Audit
report. It is only certified for the period beginning from 01-04-2023 to
8 of 25
(9)
91wp15584.26
31-03-2026, whereas the certificate of arrears is issued by Respondent
No. 3-Bank after the said period is over on 16-10-2026. According to
him, there is nothing wrong with the certificate. It is issued in the due
course of business and this certificate itself is sufficient to show the
status of the Society to whom the Petitioner represents. He further
submitted that the Government Resolution cannot water down the
provisions of laws and byelaws. According to him, as per the
Government Resolution, only certain concessions have been provided
and no exemption is granted based on the said Government
Resolution. According to him, the Government Resolution has been
issued extending the benefits to the individuals and the same cannot
be extended to the Societies. He submits that the Government
Resolution did not extend any benefit to the Society. He further
submitted that although the Petitioner is relying on the extracts of the
account to show that the Petitioners have made some payments from
the bank statement ending up to 30-09-2026, this statement only
reflect that quarterly payment of interest made by the Society and the
principal amount is still in arrears. Therefore, the Society is
undoubtedly in arrears of the loan of Respondent No. 3 -Bank. He
submitted that the powers of the Returning Officer under Rule 25 of
the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies (Election to Committee), Rules
9 of 25
(10)
91wp15584.26
are limited and the Returning Officer has acted within the limits of his
powers under Rule 25 and has rightly taken a decision to hold that the
Petitioner does not qualify in view of byelaw No.35.1.2 (A-1) and as
per Section 73 CA (i)(f) of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act.
Even before the Appellate authority, detail hearing has taken place and
he has passed an order on every ground raised by the Petitioner. He
would submit that Respondent No. 4 has rightly taken into
consideration that the last date for clearing the dues of the bank was
30-06-2026 and due to default in making the repayment of the loan a
demand notice has been issued to the Society on 02-07-2026. Hence
Respondent No.1 has rightly passed an order holding that the
Petitioner has failed to qualify as per the byelaw and as per Section 73
CA (1)(f) of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act. Hence no
interference is warranted in the order passed by the Respondent
authorities. In support of his submission regarding the binding nature
of byelaw, he would rely on the decision in the case of Sambha
Gamgaram Pikale Vs State of Maharashtra reported in 1992 Bom.
C.R. 700 in Dalsing Shamsing Rajput Vs State of Maharashtra and
others reported in 2006 (5) Bom C. R. 691.
13.
Mr. Adwant, learned Advocate for Respondent No. 3-
Bank submitted that the certificate issued by the Bank is in the format
10 of 25
(11)
91wp15584.26
which is maintained by the Bank and such certificates are issued in its
regular course of business. Therefore, there is nothing wrong or
anything suspicious about the certificate issued by the Bank. He
submitted that said certificate has been issued by the authority who is
the appropriate authority to issue such certificate. He submitted that
the loan obtained by the Society was a short term loan for a period of
one year and the Society is under obligation to make repayment of the
same within the term prescribed in the loan agreement. He submitted
that the said Government Resolution and Circular issued by the
Government are not over and above the Act, byelaw and the directions
issued by the RBI. The Government Resolution has been issued as a
relief to the affected persons due to the natural calamity. The rules and
byelaw governing the elections are to be strictly construed. The policy
decision by the Government will not affect the statutory provisions. In
support of his submission, he would rely on the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ram Chandra Choudhary and
others Vs Roop Nagar Dugdh Utpadak Sahakari Samiti Ltd. And
/others reported in 2026 SCC Online SC 583.
WRIT PETITION NO.15585 OF 2026
14.
Mr. Sapkal, learned Senior Advocate submitted that the
Petitioner in this Writ Petition is the duly authorized representative of
11 of 25
(12)
91wp15584.26
V.K.S.S. Society, Belsangvi, Taluka Jalkot, District Latur. The
petitioner submitted his nomination as a representative of VKSS
Society, Belsangvi for the election of Board of Directors of
Respondent No. 3-Bank. The nomination was accompanied by
requisite documents in support of his eligibility. The Petitioner had
filed the nomination from the constituency for the election from
Primary Agricultural Credit and Vividh Karyakari Seva Cooperative
Society and Grain Depositor Cooperative Societies, Taluka Jalkot,
Dist. Latur.
During the scrutiny of nomination papers, Respondent
No. 4 raised an objection alleging that Society represented by the
Petitioner had become a defaulter on 30.06.2026. Hence, the
Petitioner is disqualified under Section 73CA(1)(f)(ii) of the Act and
the byelaw. It was alleged that the bank had sanctioned a crop loan of
Rs.16,18,570/- to the Society on 10-04-2025, repayable by 30-062026, from which an amount of Rs.6050/- remained outstanding after
the due date. The other objection raised by the Respondent was that
the Petitioner was previously serving as a member of the Managing
Committee of the Society. However, due to personal reasons, he had
tendered his resignation from the post of Managing Committee on 0301-2026. Pursuant to which fresh elections were conducted for the
post that has fallen vacant on account of the resignation of the
12 of 25
(13)
91wp15584.26
Petitioner. The election is also conducted by the Taluka Cooperative
Election Officer by declaring the election program on 31.07.2026
appointing one G. S. Munde, Assistant Cooperative Election Officer
and Assistant Registrar Cooperative Societies, to conduct the election.
The minutes of the meeting has been placed on record, which bears
the signature of Mr. Munde. He, therefore, submitted that since the
authority of the Government itself had conducted the election for the
post which had fallen vacant on account of his resignation, this itself
is sufficient to prove that he is no more a member of the Managing
Committee. In spite of that the Returning Officer in his order under
Rule 25 of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies (Election to
Committee) Rules 2014 has held that the Petitioner was a Chairman
of the Society and the day on which the nomination forms were filled
in by the Petitioner, the Society was in arrears of the loan taken from
the Bank. Thus, the
Petitioner suffered disqualification in view of
Section 73 CA(1)(f)(ii) of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act.
Hence his nomination cannot be accepted.
15.
He submitted that even the appellate authority without
application of his mind to the record produced before him, has got
confused with the dates and events while recording that the date of
resignation of the Petitioner. The copy of the resignation produced by
13 of 25
(14)
91wp15584.26
the Petitioner discloses date of resignation as 03-01-2026, whereas the
Assistant Registrar of Cooperative Societies has received a resignation
dated 05-10-2026. He submitted that once the election program is
declared by the authority of the Co-operation department and the
elections are also conducted by the authorized authority, there was no
question of causing any confusion about the date on which the
resignation had been tendered by the Petitioner. He submitted that the
Petitioner is very much eligible since he had already tendered his
resignation as a Chairman of the society. According to him, the
disqualification for filing nomination to the election are contained in
Section 73 CA (1)(f)(ii) of the Cooperative Societies Act and only in
two contingencies the representative can be disqualified; (i) if he is a
person who is a defaulter of Primary Agricultural Credit Cooperative
Society; (ii) if he is an office bearer of a defaulting Primary
Agricultural Credit Society. In the present case although it is alleged
that the Petitioner continued to be a Chairman of the defaulting
Primary Agricultural Credit Society, record discloses that the
Petitioner has already resigned and after accepting his resignation
fresh election for the said post has already been conducted. In view
thereof, the Petitioner who is simply a Member of the Bank of the
Society cannot be disqualified on the said ground. So far as other
14 of 25
(15)
91wp15584.26
grounds regarding the default and recovery of loan is concerned, he
would submit that the argument advanced by him as the issue of
deferment of recovery of loan as provided in the Government
Resolution dated 10-10-2025 and circular dated 26-11-2025 would be
applicable in the present case also.
16.
Mr. D.J. Chaudhari, learned Advocate for Respondent No.
4 submitted that the Petitioner has played a fraud which is disclosed
from the record itself. Relying on the document which is part of the
Audit report which contains the list of Members of the Managing
Committee as on 31-03-2026, which contains name of the Petitioner.
He would contend that if the claim of the Petitioner, that he has
resigned on 03-01-2026, is to be accepted, the name of the Petitioner
could not have been the part of the list of Managing Committee as on
31-03-2026. Hence, according to him, the Petitioner has produced a
bogus document to claim that he has resigned, in fact, he has not at all
resigned, which can be supported from the list of Managing
Committee Members as on 31-03-2026. He also submitted that so far
as the applicability of the Government Resolution dated 10-10-2025
and circular dated 26-11-2025 is concerned, he would adopt the same
arguments as advanced by him in Writ Petition No. 15584 of 2026.
17.
In both these writ petitions the objection raised by the
15 of 25
(16)
91wp15584.26
respective objector i.e. Respondent No. 4 is based on the certificate
issued by the bank on 16-10-2026. Both these certificates are titled
as ‘certificate of dues’. It has been issued by the Branch Manager
with a disclaimer that this certificate is issued subject to the remarks
of the Audit report. It mentions the amount that is due from the
Society. However, it is bereft of other details such as the term of
loan, the day on which it became due, when was the default
committed by the Society and the account number of the respective
Societies. Without disclosing material details about the amount such
as the day on which the default is committed and the type of account,
it becomes difficult to rely on such certificate for disqualifying a
candidate who has filed his nomination.
18.
In Writ Petition No. 15584 of 2026 the Petitioner has
been held to be disqualified on account of disqualification incurred in
view of Byelaw No. 35.1.2 (A-1) and Section 73CA (i)(f) of the
Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act. Byelaw No. 35.1.2(A-1)
provides that any member of society who propose to contest the
elections to the Managing Committee should by eligible as per byelaw
No.5 (15) and such Society should be a member of the Bank. So far as
byelaw No.5(15) is concerned, it requires that the affiliated Member
Society of the Bank, should not be in arrears of the loan of the Bank as
16 of 25
(17)
91wp15584.26
well as of any other Society.
19.
In the present case, for the first time before the Appellate
authority, the stand is taken by the Bank that the sanctioned loan was
to be repaid till 30-06-2026, since it is not repaid, a certificate is
issued by the Bank. So far as the arrears / dues of the Bank is
concerned, the Government Resolution dated 10-10-2025 has granted
stay for the recovery of loans disbursed for the agricultural affiliated
operations. This Government Resolution was issued on 10-10-2025,
which was in operation till 10-10-2026. Thus, the day on which
certificate towards the dues was issued by the Bank, considering the
stay to the recovery given by the Government, such certificate could
not have been issued by the Bank to defeat the right of the Petitioner
as a member representing the Society. Although the Respondents have
argued that the Government Resolution is not binding on the Bank, the
circular issued by the Cooperation Marketing and Textile Department
dated 26-11-2025, clearly mandates that the Commissioner for
Cooperation should ensure that the directions issued in the circular are
scrupulously followed. The State Level Bankers Committee,
Maharashtra State Cooperative Bank, and the District Cooperative
Bank have been directed to take appropriate steps for implementation
of the directions issued in the circular as well as the Government
17 of 25
(18)
91wp15584.26
Resolution. Although it is contended that this resolution will be
applicable to the individual farmers, however, it needs to be
appreciated that in view of the stay to the recovery from the individual
farmers who received loan from the Society, the recovery of the
Society is also affected. Similar cascading effect can be seen on the
recovery of loan disbursed to the Society by the Bank and the loan
disbursed in favour of the Bank. If the farmers are granted protection
by way of stay to the recovery, consequently the Society, would not be
in a position to make repayment of the loan obtained from the District
Central Cooperative Bank for distribution to the farmers. Hence, the
directions issued are not limited to the extent of the individual
members, but it equally applies to the Societies and Banks, who are
restrained from making recovery from its Members. Due to the
deferment of recovery of arrears of loan for a period of one year, the
account of the Society cannot be termed as account in arrears of loan.
The effect of the Government Resolution on the recovery of loan from
the Members of the Society and in turn by the Society with the Bank
has not at all been appreciated by the Returning Officer as well as by
the Appellate authorities.
20.
The alleged disqualification of the Petitioner is based on
the so called default of the society, relying on the certificate issued by
18 of 25
(19)
91wp15584.26
the Bank which is titled as certificate of arrears. It is not accompanied
by any notice intimating the overdue arrears. The account no, the date
on which the payment became overdue etc., details are not available.
It appears that the details of the loan account, were not available
before the returning officer, and were made available for the first time
before the appellate authority. In the order of the appellate authority it
is observed that the due date for repayment was 30-04-2026. since the
amount of Rs.1,25,61,251/- and interest thereon is not paid the society
is in default and is disqualified in view of Section 73CA (1)(f)(ii) of
the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act.
21.
The Returning Officer as well as the Appellate Authority
relying on the certificate issued by the Bank has declared that society
is in default of loan and Petitioner being a member of the Managing
Committee of society incurs disqualification.
22.
As observed hereinabove the certificate does not contain
the details of the account, the date on which the loan become overdue,
in absence of necessary details, the certificate cannot be relied to
deprive the Petitioner of his legitimate rights in absence of reliable
and sufficient proof. The Petitioner has alleged malafides against the
contesting Respondents to contend that the certificate issued by the
bank is on the last date of filing nominations. There appears to
19 of 25
(20)
91wp15584.26
substance in the allegations of the petitioner to some extent since, no
document showing default of society prior to issuance of certificate of
arrears is placed on record. Thus on the basis of document that did not
hold authenticity the Returning Officer could not have rejected the
nomination of the Petitioner.
23.
The account statement of the society placed on record
discloses that the society has deposited interest towards the loan in the
account regularly, the last entry towards deposit of arrears to be made
on 30-09-2026.
24.
Hence, the order passed by the Returning Officer dated
19-10-2026 is not a reasoned order and the order dated 29-10-2026
passed by the Appellate authority i.e. the Divisional Joint Registrar
Cooperative Societies, has been issued misinterpreting the provisions
of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act as well as the byelaw
and the same are required to be set aside, since it amounts to taking
away the right of the Petitioner to contest the election as provided
under Section 73CA (1)(f) of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies
Act. Although the Hon’ble Supreme Court has taken a view that the
Court shall not interfere in the election once the election program has
been declared, it has carved out an exception holding that when the
rejection of the nomination is patently illegal permitting such
20 of 25
(21)
91wp15584.26
interference, the present case would fall in those exceptional cases.
25.
In addition to the aforementioned observations, in Writ
Petition No. 15585 of 2026 the disqualification of the Petitioner is
allegedly on the ground that he is a Chairman of the Society. The
documents on the record undisputedly disclose that the election to the
seat that has fallen vacant on account of resignation of the Petitioner
has already been conducted by the Taluka Co-operative Election
Officer and Assistant Registrar Cooperative Societies, Latur, which
can be reflected from the order dated 31-07-2026, whereby the
election program for filling up the post vacated by the Petitioner was
declared. Similarly, the minutes of meeting of the Managing
Committee also supports the stand taken by the Petitioner about his
resignation. The authorized officer of the Government clearly holds
that the post which the Petitioner was holding has fallen vacant on
account of his resignation and therefore, it was necessary to conduct
election for the said post and accordingly, the election program has
been declared. Therefore, there remains no doubt about the resignation
of the Petitioner which is accepted and therefore, he has filled in his
nomination simply as a Member of the Society. So far as the capacity
in which the Petitioner has filled in his nomination form he cannot be
said to have incurred disqualification in view of Section 73CA(1)(f)
21 of 25
(22)
91wp15584.26
(ii) which provides that a disqualification shall be incurred if a person
is a defaulter of Primary Agricultural Credit Cooperative Society or is
an Office-bearer of defaulting Primary Agricultural Credit Society.
Since he ceased to be a Member of the Managing Committee, upon
his resignation on 03-01-2026 itself, therefore, there is no impediment
for a Member to represent such Society in the elections to the Member
of Managing Committee of the Bank. Since the disqualification of the
Petitioner is based on conditions of disqualification contained in
Section 73CA(1)(f)(ii), in view of resignation of the Petitioner as a
Chairman of the Bank on 03-01-2026 he continues to be a member
and he does not incur any disqualification this representation of the
society will be in capacity as member, which is permissible and it
does not amount to disqualification. Mr. Chaudhari, learned Advocate
has argued that the statutory provisions of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960, will prevail over the Government
Resolution and the Government Resolution does not bind the bank.
According to him, if any exemption are to be granted, the power to
grant exemption from the provision of the Maharashtra Co-operative
Act, 1960, is provided under Section 157 of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies, Act 196, which empowers the State Government,
to exempt any society or class of society from provisions of the Act or
22 of 25
(23)
91wp15584.26
Rules. Since the State Government has not issued any such directions,
the Government Resolution dated 10-10-2025 and Circular dated 2611-2025, are not applicable to the Elections of the Bank. He further
submitted that the proviso limits the power of State Government, to
issue any order of exemption for issues covered by 73 CB of the
Maharashtra
Co-operative
Societies Act
which
is
regarding
Constitution of State Cooperative Election Authority, its power and
functions. Thus, the powers of State Government are curtailed with
regard to issuing directions to the State Co-operative Election
Authority and his powers.
26.
The
submission
of
Mr.
Chaudhari,
cannot
be
countenanced. It is also not in dispute that the policy of the
Government cannot override, supersede or run counter to the existing
statutory laws. Government Resolution cannot nullify a statute,
however, the gaps can be filed in by a Government Resolution on a
particular issue. The Government Resolution issued on 10-10-2026, is
a mitigating measure taken by the Government to deal with the
unprecedented situation prevailing due to excess rains. Hence, to
tackle the situation, as one of the measures of damage control, and
provide relief to the farmers, the Revenue and Forest Department,
which controls and regulates the finances of the State has issued the
23 of 25
(24)
91wp15584.26
Government Resolution declaring reliefs. In furtherance of the
Government Resolution dated 10-10-2025 a circular is issued by the
Corporations, Marketing and Textile Department on 26-11-2025.
Though the Government Resolutions may not have an overriding
effect on statute, but it certainly can grant relief of reconstruction of
loans, and defer the repayment of loan. This does not in any way take
away the right of the Bank to recover the loans, it is only deferred. It
does not have an overriding effect on the statutory provisions. The
Government Resolution has merely deferred the recovery of loans for
one year.
27.
Thus, in the wake of the observations made herein above,
the order passed by the Returning Officer AS well as the Appellate
authority in both the writ petitions i.e. WP/15584/2026 &
WP/15585/2026 become unsustainable in law and is accordingly
quashed and set aside. Consequently, the writ petitions are allowed in
terms of prayer clause-B & C.
28.
The Respondents are directed to include the name of the
Petitioner in both the petitions in the list validly nominated candidates
forthwith.
24 of 25
(25)
29.
91wp15584.26
Rule made absolute in above terms.
[MANJUSHA DESHPANDE, J. ]
VishalK/91wp15584.26
25 of 25
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review