Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:54624
93WP15587.2026.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 15587 OF 2026
Bharat Tukaram Chamle,
Age. 54 years, Occ. Agri.,
R/o. Yeshwant Co-operative
Housing Society, Udgir,
Tq. Udgir, Dist. Latur.
Versus
1.
The State of Maharashtra,
Through the Secretary,
In the Department of Co-operation,
Mantralaya, Mumbai – 32.
2.
The State Co-operative Election Authority,
Through its Secretary,
Maharashtra State,
Central Building, Pune.
3.
The Returning Officer /
Latur District Central Co-operative Bank
Ltd., Latur, Tq. And dist. Latur and
Residential Deputy Collector, Latur,
Tq. And Dist. Latur.
4.
The Divisional Joint Registrar,
Co-operation Societies Latur.
5.
The Latur District Central Co-operative
Bank Ltd., Latur, Tq. And Dist. Latur,
Through its Managing Director.
6.
Shri. Dhiraj S/o. Vilasrao Deshmukh
Age. 40 years, Occ. Business,
R/o. Babhalgaon, Tq. & Dist. Latur.
…Petitioner
7.
93WP15587.2026.odt
Shri. Sant Shiromani Maroti Maharaj
Sahakari Sakhar Karkhasna Ltd.
Belkund, Tq. Ausa, Dist. Latur,
Through its Representative,
Sachin S/o. Subhash Patil
8.
Shri Keshav Netke
Residential Dy. Collector, Latur
Tq. And Dist. Latur.
… Respondents
...
Advocate for Petitioner : Mr. A.N. Irpatgire
AGP for Respondent No.1:Ms.Dr.Kalpalata Patil Bharaswadkar
Advocate for Respondent Nos. 2 & 3 : Mr. V.H. Dighe
Advocate for Respondent No. 5 : Mr. S.V. Advant
Advocate for Respondent No. 6 : Mr. D.J. Choudhari
…
CORAM : MANJUSHA A. DESHPANDE, J.
RESERVED ON
: 02.11.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 04.11.2026
JUDGMENT :
1.
Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith and heard
finally by the consent of the parties.
2.
The challenge in this Writ Petition is to the
rejection of the nomination of the Petitioner for the membership
of the managing committee of Respondent no. 5 / Bank, by
Respondent no. 3/ Returning Officer vide order dated
19.10.2026 and later on by the Appellate Authority i.e. the
Divisional Joint Registrar Co-operative Societies, who has
93WP15587.2026.odt
exercised his power under Section 152 A of the Maharashtra
Societies Act (for short ‘the MCS, Act’), dismissed the Appeal
vide order dated 29.10.2026.
3.
Learned Advocate Mr. Irpatgire, for the petitioner
submitted that the Respondent no. 3 published the election
programme of managing committee of Respondent no. 5 –
Bank, in view of Rule 18 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies
(Election to Committee) Rules, 2014 (for short ‘the Election
Rules of 2014’). The Petitioner represents the Late Ram
Chandrarao Patil Talegaonkar Shahakari Kharedi Vikri Sangh
Limited, Udgir (for short ‘RCPTSKVSL, Udgir’). Pursuant to
the Resolution passed by the Managing Committee of the
Society, his name is included in the final voters’ list of
Respondent no. 5 – Bank. The Petitioner has submitted his
nomination paper from the processing and marketing Society's
constituency in the election of Respondent no. 5, along with
requisite documents. Respondent no. 6 who is a politically
influential person opposed the nomination of the Petitioner.
During the scrutiny of nomination, Respondent no. 6 has
objected to the nomination of the Petitioner, through
93WP15587.2026.odt
Respondent no. 7. An objection is filed raising a ground that the
Society represented by the Petitioner is not having regular
transaction with Respondent no. 5 – Bank. Therefore, he is
disqualified to contest the election as per Bye-law no. 35.1.B-3,
in spite of bringing to the notice of Respondent no. 3, that the
Society is having a current account in the Bank and has
transaction in the said account. Reliance is placed by
Respondent no. 7 on the certificate issued by the Managing
Director of Respondent no. 5 - Bank. It is submitted that
Respondent no. 3 has wrongly rejected the nomination of the
Petitioner holding that, there are no consistent transaction in the
bank account. Even in the appeal filed by the Petitioner, the
Appellate Authority has not appropriately appreciated the issue
in question and has acted under political pressure while passing
the order dated 29.10.2026.
4.
During the course of his submission the learned
Advocate for the Petitioner has drawn attention of this Court to
the certificate issued by the Executive Director of Latur District
Central Co-operative Bank, which certifies that the account of
the Society whom the Petitioner represents is not consistent and
93WP15587.2026.odt
regular. Referring to Bye-law no. 35.1.B-3, it is submitted that
for eligibility as a member of Managing Committee of the
Bank, it is necessary for the Society affiliated to the Bank,
should maintain a current account in with regular transactions.
It is submitted that although a certificate is issued by the
Executive Director of the Bank that there are no regular and
consistent transactions, the documents in the form of account
statement of the RCPTSKVSL, Udgir, from 01.04.2025 to
13.03.2026 discloses that there are regular transaction and the
account is not dormant. There are deposits on 24.09.2025,
30.09.2021, 12.09.2024, 19.03.2025 and 26.03.2026, to the
account of the Society. It is, therefore, submitted that the ground
on which nomination of the Petitioner is rejected is contrary to
the record.
5.
It is submitted by the Petitioner that, although the
nomination of the Petitioner is rejected in view of the Bye-laws,
the Petitioner is only governed by the provisions of the MCS,
Act, more particularly, Section 73 CA (1)(F)(ii) is the provision
that governs the disqualification of member Society, for
contesting elections in the Bank. Since the petitioner is not
93WP15587.2026.odt
disqualified on either of the counts mentioned in the
aforementioned provision, the Bye-laws that are contrary to the
provisions of Act, cannot be made applicable to the Petitioner.
He submitted that if the Bye-laws are contrary to the statutory
provision, the provisions of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies
Act would prevail.
6.
It is further submitted that though the Society to
whom the Petitioner represents had filed Applications to the
Manager of Respondent no. 5 – Bank from 06.04.2022 onward
for grant of cash credit loan facility, no response is received by
the Society. Thus, the Society was constrained to file a
complaint about failure of Respondent no. 5 – Bank, to respond
to the Society on 29.05.2022. The learned Advocate, therefore,
contends that on the one hand Respondent no. 5 - Bank is
claiming that there are no regular transactions by the Society
and on the other hand, where the Society had requested for
making available the cash credit loan facility, no response is
given by the Bank. Thus, the Bank cannot absolve itself, from
the responsibility of failing to respond to the Society and then
claim that there are no transactions with the Respondent no. 5 –
93WP15587.2026.odt
Bank. Even though, this conduct of the Bank was brought to the
notice of the Appellate Authority, even he has failed to
appreciate this fact and held that the Society to whom the
Petitioner represents is not acting in furtherance of the object of
the Bank. Thus, according to him, the objection of the
Returning Officer as well as the Appellate Authority, deserves
to set aside.
7.
Mr. Dighe, learned Advocate for Respondent nos. 2
and 3 submitted that, there is nothing wrong with the order
passed by the Returning Officer as well as the Appellate
Authority. Both the Authorities have rightly taken into
consideration the failure of the Society to transact in regular
business with Respondent no. 5 – Bank and has passed
appropriate orders.
8.
Learned Advocate Mr. D.J. Chaudhary, for
Respondent no. 6, submitted that, objects of Bank is provided in
the Bye-laws and the Bank has to act in furtherance of the
object so as to achieve the objects stated in the Bye-laws. It is
submitted that although the Society to whom the Petitioner
93WP15587.2026.odt
represents is an account holder of the Bank. However, it should
have availed loan in the regular transaction of business from the
Respondent no. 5 – Bank. It is submitted that since its
registration, no loans are availed by the said Society. The entries
of paltry amount do not amount to regular transactions and they
are not beneficial for the Bank. He submitted that the Appellate
Authority has rightly observed in its order that on a demand
made to the Bank, after verifying original record, a certificate is
issued by the Bank on 16.10.2026, which discloses that
RCPTSKVSL, Udgir, does not have regular transactions with
the Bank, except some entries of deposit of paltry amounts.
Hence, according to him, the Petitioner has failed to prove that
the Society is in regular transaction with Respondent no. 5 –
Bank, which is a mandatory condition for contesting election of
the Managing Committee of Respondent no. 5 – Bank. He
submitted that along with the provisions of the MCS, Act, even
the Rules of 2014 and Bye-laws are equally binding on the
parties.
9.
Upon hearing the respective parties and perusal of
the record, the short issue involved in the matter is about the
93WP15587.2026.odt
applicability of Bye-law no. 35.1.B.3 of the Bye-laws of
Respondent no. 5 – Bank. Admittedly, the aforementioned Byelaw, provides that the candidate filing the nomination who is
affiliated to the Member Co-operative Society of the District
Co-operative Bank, should hold a current account with regular
transactions with the Bank. It is further provided that, the
affiliated Member Society should have regular transactions in
the Bank account for a duration of one year prior to the
elections. If such account remains dormant, the candidate incurs
disqualification. Thus, there are two conditions; (i) the account
should be in operation one year prior to the date of election and
(ii) it should engage in regular transaction with the Bank. The
account statement placed on record discloses that although there
are meagre amounts transacted through the current account of
the Society, however, it appears that there are certain deposits
made in the account which is disclosed through the account
statements for the period 01.04.2025 to 31.03.2026, 01.04.2021
to 23.12.2023 and 23.12.2023 to 20.10.2026. In all these
account statements, certain small amounts are transacted during
the aforementioned period. Therefore, it cannot be held that the
93WP15587.2026.odt
account has been dormant for the period of one year prior to the
election. Similarly, it cannot be held that there are no regular
transactions in the current
account of the Society. The
documents annexed to the Writ Petition discloses that the
Petitioner representing RCPTSKVSL, Udgir, has consistently
requested the Bank to make available the cash credit loan
facility to the Society. The communications addressed to the
Manager of the Bank dated 06.04.2022, 30.03.2022 and
01.12.2022, are forming part of record, which discloses that the
Society has been consistently making request to Respondent no.
5 – Bank for extending them the cash credit loan facility. Since
Respondent no. 5 – Bank, has failed to accede to their request,
the Society has filed a complaint to the Divisional Joint
Registrar, Latur, on 29.12.2022.
10.
Thus, on the basis of the documents placed on
record, it is disclosed that though Respondent no. 5 – Bank is
claiming that there are no regular transactions in the Bank
account of the Society, yet on the other hand, the request for the
loan facility has not been favourably considered in spite of
persuasion by the Society. Thus, the Respondent no. 5 – Bank,
93WP15587.2026.odt
cannot be allowed to blow hot and cold at the same time. The
Bye-law no. 35.1.B.3 does not disqualify the Petitioner, since
regular transaction are seen in the current account of the
Society, though of paltry amount. On that count the Petitioner
cannot be deprived of to file his nomination to the Managing
Committee of Respondent no. 5 – Bank.
11.
Since this Court has come to a conclusion that
Bye-law no. 35.1.B.3 is not attracted in the present case, it is
not necessary to delve deep into whether the Bye-laws are
applicable and its effect on the MCS, Act, in the present Writ
Petition.
12.
I am well aware of the jurisprudence surrounding
interference under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution in
election matters, as well as the catena of judgments delivered by
this Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court holding the field.
This Court, in Dattatray Genaba Lole and Others Versus
Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies in Writ
Petition No. 5878 of 2021, decided on 26.11.2021, has once
again cautioned against interference in election matters. At the
93WP15587.2026.odt
same time, it has carved out an exception permitting
interference where the impugned order suffers from patent
illegality. In the present case, I find it fit to interfere with the
impugned order, particularly in light of the patent illegality
committed by Respondent nos. 3 and 4. The interference at this
stage is not likely to disturb or hamper the election process,
since the last date for withdrawal of nominations is tomorrow,
i.e., 05.11.2026, and the ballot papers will be printed thereafter.
13.
In the result, the Writ Petition is allowed in terms
of prayer clause ‘B and ‘C’. The order passed by Respondent
no. 3 – Returning Officer dated 19.10.2026 and the order dated
29.10.2026, passed by Respondent no. 4 - Appellate Authority,
are set aside. The Election Authorities are directed to include
the name of the Petitioner in the voters’ list forthwith.
14.
Rule is made absolute in the above terms.
( MANJUSHA A. DESHPANDE, J. )
SPC
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review