Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
signed
LHAINEI Digitally
by
CHONG LHAINEICHONG
HAOKIP
2023.01.10
HAOKIP Date:
12:55:58 +05'30'
AT IMPHAL
W.P.(C) No. 86 of 2019
Shri Yumnam Sharat Singh, aged about 44 years, S/o Shri Y.
Amuchou Singh, resident of Mayang Imphal Bazar, P.O. & P.S.
Mayang Imphal and District, Imphal West, Manipur.
... Petitioner
-Versus 1. The
State
of
Manipur
through
the
Principal
Secretary/Commissioner/Secretary
(MAHUD),
Govt.
of
Manipur, Imphal, Manipur-795001.
2. The Director (MAHUD), Govt. of Manipur, Imphal, North AOC,
near 2nd M.R. Pin-795001.
3. The Mayang Imphal Municipal Council through the Executive
Officer (MIMC), Imphal West District, Manipur.
... Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLEMR. JUSTICE AHANTHEMBIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Sh. Athoi Singh, Adv.
For the respondents
:
Mr. H. Debendra, Govt.
Adv. & Mr. N. Zequeson,
Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
19.10.2022
Date of Judgment & Order
:
10.01.2023
Judgment & Order
[1]
Heard Mr. Sh. Athoi Singh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, Mr. H. Debendra, learned Government Advocate appearing for
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
Page 1
the respondents No. 1 & 2 and Mr. N. Zequeson, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent No. 3.
The present writ petition had been filed with a prayer for
quashing and setting aside the impugned advertisement dated 17.01.2019
issued by the Director (MAHUD), Manipur only in respect of the post of
Revenue Officer of MayangImphal Municipal Council and for directing the
respondents to consider the case of the petitioner for promotion to the post
of Revenue Officer, Mayang Imphal Municipal Council.
[2]
The brief facts of the present case is that the petitioner was initially
appointed to the post of Revenue Inspector in the Mayang Imphal
Municipal Council on contract basis with effect from the date of his joining
duty and until further order by an order dated 24.11.2003 issued by the
Chairperson, Mayang Imphal Municipal Council. Pursuant to the said
appointment order, the petitioner joined and discharged his duties to the
full satisfaction of his senior officers and he continued to render his service
on contract basis till his service was regularised with effect from
19.12.2016.
[3]
In pursuance of the proposal for rationalisation of the staffing
pattern in Urban Local Bodies of the State, a memorandum for Cabinet
was prepared and placed before the State Cabinet as Agenda No. 24 in its
meeting held on 04.08.2016. Under the said Cabinet memorandum, the
approval of the Cabinet was solicited towards the creation of 226 posts
and for rationalisation of the staffing pattern in the Urban Local Bodies of
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
Page 2
Manipur as contain in Para 11 of the said memorandum for Cabinet, the
said Para 11 is reproduced hereunder for ready reference:“11. Approval of the Cabinet is solicited towards the proposed
retionalisation of the staffing pattern in the ULBs of Manipur as
given in Annexure in D & E and the following:
[4]
“a)
ULBs should regularise all those employees who
had been granted approval by the Government
with conditions and the effective date of
appointment should be from the date of issue of
the order.
“b)
ULBs should regularise all those employees who
had been appointed by the respective Councils. In
case the number exceeds the prescribed staffing
pattern, appointment order should be issued
based on the seniority of the existing staff in each
category of post and issue fresh order from the
date of issue of the Government convey letter
reckoning initial date of appointment without any
financial appointment.
“c)
Fresh appointments shall be made only with the
approval of the Government and following due
process of law.
“d)
Every ULB to issue fresh appointment orders
mentioning the earlier appointment orders issued
by the concerned ULB.
“e)
To down size all the post of Community
Organisers, Revenue Supervisors, FA and Road
Mohorrirs prospectively.”
The State Cabinet approved the proposal at Para No. 11 of the said
memorandum for Cabinet and as per the provisions given by the Cabinet,
the Secretariat (MAHUD) Department issued an order dated 25.11.2016
creating 226 different categories of posts for the Urban Local Bodies
including two posts of Revenue Inspector in the MayangImphal Municipal
Council.
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
Page 3
[5]
After creation of the said 226 different categories of posts, the
Secretariat (MAHUD) Department wrote a letter dated 19.12.2016 to the
Executive Officer of all Urban Local Bodies conveying the approval of the
Government to the regularisation of 128 employees of the Urban Local
Bodies in various categories of posts as recommended by the Screening
Committee and as per the Cabinet decision taken on 04.08.2016 subject
to the following conditions:“(i)
All
the
Urban
Local
Bodies
shall
issue
fresh
appointment orders mentioning the earlier appointment
orders issued by the concerned Urban Local Bodies.
“(ii)
The regularisation shall be with effect from the date of
issue of this letter.
“(iii)
However, past service reckoned for purpose of
seniority and pensionary benefits.
“(iv)
No arrear shall be paid for the period between initial
appointment and regularisation.”
Pursuant to the aforesaid letter dated 19.12.2016 of the
Secretariat (MAHUD) Department, the Executive Officer, MayangImphal
Municipal Council, issued the order dated 26.12.2016 regularising the
contract service of the petitioner as Revenue Inspector. In the said order, it
is also provided that the regularisation of the petitioner was subject to the
following conditions:“(i)
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
The regularisation shall be effective from 19.12.2016.
Page 4
“(ii)
The past service shall be reckoned for the purpose of
seniority and pensionary benefits.
“(iii)
No arrear shall be paid for the period between initial
appointment and regularisation.”
[6]
The next promotional posts from the post of Revenue Inspector is
the post of Revenue Officer. Under the Manipur Municipality (Revenue
Officer) Recruitment Rules, 1990 (hereinafter referred to as „Recruitment
Rules of R.O‟ for short), the method of recruitment is by promotion failing
which by direct recruitment. In case of promotion, Revenue Inspector
under the Municipal Board having at least 10 years regular service in the
grade are eligible.
[7]
One post of Revenue Officer became vacant in the MayangImphal
Municipal Council with effect from 12.03.2015 due to the promotion of the
Officer who was earlier holding the said post. Subsequently, the Director
(MAHUD), Manipur, issued an advertisement dated 17.01.2019 inviting
applications for selection of candidates for direct recruitments to various
posts of the Urban Local Bodies of Manipur including one post of Revenue
Officer in the Mayang Imphal Municipal Council. Having been aggrieved by
issuance of the said advertisement dated 17.01.2019, the petitioner
challenge the same by filing the present writ petition.
[8]
Mr. Sh. Athoi Singh, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted
that the petitioner has been rendering service as Revenue Inspector in the
Mayang Imphal Municipal Council with effect from 24.11.2003 till date, for
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
Page 5
the last more than 19 years. Even though the petitioner‟s service as
Revenue Inspector was regularised only with effect from 19.12.2006, he is
entitled to count his past service as qualifying service for the purpose of
promotion to the higher post of Revenue Officer, inasmuch as, his service
was regularised subject to the condition that the past service shall be
reckoned for the purpose of seniority and pensionary benefits. According
to the learned counsel, the petitioner is quit eligible for appointment on
promotion to the higher post of Revenue Officer in the Mayang Imphal
Municipal Council and preference had to be given to the petitioner, who is
holding the feeder post, prior to consideration for appointment by direct
recruitment. The learned counsel vehemently submitted that the acts of
the respondents in issuing the impugned advertisement before considering
the case of the petitioner for his promotion as provided under the
Recruitment Rules of R.O. is very much arbitrary and illegal and the
impugned advertisement is liable to be quashed and set aside.
[9]
The learned counsel also submitted that as per section 43 of the
Manipur Municipality Act, 1994, the appointing authority of the Revenue
Officer is the Council and not the Director (MAHUD) and that the Director
(MAHUD) has no power or authority to issue the impugned advertisement.
The learned counsel accordingly submitted that as the Director of
(MAHUD) has no power or authority to issue the impugned advertisement,
the same is liable to be quashed and set aside.
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
Page 6
[10]
Mr. H. Debendra, learned Government Advocate and Mr. N.
Zequeson, learned Advocate appearing for the respondents submitted that
though the petitioner claimed to have been holding the post of Revenue
Inspector continuously with effect from 24.11.2003, the past service
rendered by the petitioner prior to regularisation of his service with effect
from 19.12.2016 was only on contract basis as clearly provided in his initial
appointment order and such prior service on contract basis cannot be
counted as regular service by any stress of imagination. It has also been
submitted that as the service of the petitioner as Revenue Inspector in the
Mayang Imphal Municipal Council was regularised only with effect from
19.12.2016, the petitioner has not rendered 10 years regular service and
accordingly, he is not eligible for promotion to the higher post of Revenue
Officer as he does not possess the requisite eligibility criteria of having
minimum 10 years of regular service in the cadre of Revenue Inspector.
[11]
It has also been submitted by the learned counsel appearing for the
respondents that the conditions that the past service of the petitioner shall
be reckoned for the purpose of seniority and pensionary benefits does not
rendered the past services of the petitioner to be on regular basis when it
has been specifically mentioned in the regularisation order that the
regularisation of the petitioner is only with effect from 19.12.2016. It has
further been submitted that as there is no eligible person available for
promotion to the post of Revenue Officer, the vacant post of Revenue
Officer in the Mayang Imphal Municipal Council had been advertised for
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
Page 7
filling up by direct recruitment under the impugned advertisement dated
17.01.2009 as provided under the Recruitment Rules of R.O. and that the
authorities have not committed any illegality or irregularity in issuing the
impugned advertisement and accordingly, the present writ petition is liable
to be dismissed as being devoid of merit.
[12]
I have heard the submissions advanced by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties and also carefully examined the material
available on record. As per the relevant provisions of the Recruitment
Rules of R.O., the method of recruitment to the post of Returning Officer is
by promotion, failing which by direct recruitment. In case of promotion,
only Revenue Inspector having 10 years regular service in the grade are
eligible to be considered for such promotion. As per the order dated
26.12.2016 issued by the Executive Officer, Mayang Imphal Municipal
Council, the service of the petitioner was regularised as Revenue
Inspector only with effect from 19.12.2016. It has also been specifically
stated by the respondent No. 3 in its additional affidavit-in-opposition dated
17.10.2022 that there are only two sanction posts of Revenue Inspector
existing in the Mayang Imphal Municipal Council which were newly created
by the Secretariat (MAHUD) Department, Government of Manipur, under
its order dated 25.11.2016 pursuant to the State Cabinet decision in its
meeting held on 04.08.2016 and that the petitioner was given regular
appointment against one of the newly created post of Revenue Inspector.
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
Page 8
[13]
On careful examination of the memorandum for Cabinet for
rationalisation of the staffing pattern in the Urban Local Bodies of Manipur
which had been approved by the State Cabinet, the Government order
dated 25.11.2016 creating 226 different categories of posts for the Urban
Local Bodies under (MAHUD) Department including two posts of Revenue
Inspector in the Mayang Imphal Municipal Council, the order dated
26.12.2016 issued by the Executive Officer, Mayang Imphal Municipal
Council regularising the service of the petitioner as Revenue Inspector in
the MayangImphal Municipal Council with effect from 19.12.2016 and the
categorical statement made by the respondent No. 3 in the aforesaid
additional affidavit-in-opposition dated 17.10.2022 that there are only two
sanction posts of Revenue Inspector in the Mayang Imphal Municipal
Council which are created under the Government‟s order dated
25.11.2016 and the petitioner had been regularised against one of the said
newly created post, it is clearly revealed that the service of the petitioner
can be regularised only with effect from 2016. The past service rendered
by the petitioner as Revenue Inspector on contract basis cannot be
counted as regular service as there was no sanction post of Revenue
Inspector in the Mayang Imphal Municipal Council to accommodate the
petitioner prior to issuance of the Government order dated 25.11.2016
which created two posts of Revenue Inspector in the Mayang Imphal
Municipal Council. Being faced with such undisputed facts, this Court is
not inclined to accept the submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
Page 9
that the past service rendered by the petitioner prior to his regularisation
can be counted as qualifying service for availing promotion to the next
higher post. In my considered view, such a stand will defeat the provisions
of the Recruitment Rules of R.O.
[14]
With regard to the argument advanced by the learned counsel for
the petitioner that the Director (MAHUD) has no power or authority to issue
the impugned advertisement, it is to be pointed out that there is no
provision under Section 43 of the Manipur Municipality Act, 1994
specifying the authority who can issue the advertisement or prohibiting the
Director (MAHUD) from issuing the impugned advertisement. Accordingly
this Court is not inclined to interfere with the impugned advertisement only
on this ground.
In view of the above facts and circumstances, this Court do
not find any irregularity or illegality having been committed by the
respondents in issuing the impugned advertisement. In the result, the
present writ petition is hereby dismissed as being devoid of merit.
Earlier interim order stands vacated.
Parties are to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Lhaineichong
WP(C) No. 86 of 2019
Page 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review