The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. It is a settled principle of the law of pleadings that an averment made by the appellant is expected to be specifically denied by the replying party. If there is no specific denial, then such averment is deemed to have been admitted by the respondent. In the present case, it is evident that the above noted averments in the writ petition were relevant and material to the case. In fact, the entire case of the appellant hinged on these three paragraphs of the writ petition. It was thus expected of the respondents to reply to these averments specifically, in fact to make a proper reference to the records relevant to these paragraphs. In view of the omission on the part of the respondents to refer to any relevant records and failure to specifically deny the averments made by the appellant, we are of the considered view that the appellant has been able to make out a case for interference. [14] It is prayed that the writ petition be allowed and the respondents be directed to hold a ‘special viva-voce’ for the petitioners as done in similar case, as they scored more than the minimum cut-off mark stipulated by the relevant rules and appoint them as Asst. Sub-Inspectors. [15] Mr. H. Samarjit, learned GA submits that the cut-off mark for UR and OBC is 28 marks and for SC/ST is 20 marks. As the petitioners could not reach the minimum 28 marks in the written test, they were not called for i…
20. 08.2005 [Annexure-A-17] that the cut-off mark in the written test for Asst. Sub-Inspector and Havildar is “24”. The respondents could not produce any document to controvert this fact and have also failed to deny the same in their reply. Accordingly, it is held that the cut-off marks for written test for the recruitment of Asst. SubInspector is ‘24’ as per relevant rules. Since the petitioners scored 27 and 26½ marks in the written test, they ought to have been included in the list of eligible candidates for appearing in the interview. Due to the lapse on part of the respondents, the petitioners’ names were omitted from the list of eligible candidates for interview and their valuable right for consideration for appointment as Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police was violated. [19] In the circumstances, the respondents are directed to hold a special viva-voce for the petitioners for the post of Assistant Sub-Inspectors notified on 24.04.2010 within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and to issue WP(C) NO. 801 OF 2022 necessary appointment order, if their total score in the test is more than that of the last candidate selected. Writ petition is allowed in terms of the above directions. Parties are to bear their own cost. [20] Registry is directed to send a copy of this order to the respondent No.2, the Director General of Police, Manipur for infor…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.801 of 2022
1.
Shri Yumnam Manaoba, aged about
26 years, s/o (L) Y.Budhichandra Singh,
a resident of Bamon Leikai Thangjam
Leirak, PO & PS Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur.
2.
Shri Moirangthem Rishikanta Meitei,
aged about 37 years, s/o M.
Iboyaima Singh of Wangkhei Angom
Leikai, Imphal East District, Manipur.
… Petitioners
-Versus1.
The State of Manipur, through the
Principal Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur,
Imphal, Manipur 795001.
2.
The Director General of Police,
Manipur, Imphal, Manipur, 795001.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioners:
For the respondents:
Date of hearing:
Date of judgment:
Mr. Th. Khagemba, Advocate
Mr. H. Samarjit, GA
04.12.2023 & 04.04.2024.
08.04.2024
JUDGMENT AND ORDER [CAV]
[1]
The petitioners, two in numbers, filed the present writ
petition praying for a direction to the respondents to hold a viva
voce of the petitioners in view of the Gazette Notification dated
WP(C) NO. 801 OF 2022
20.08.2005 [Annexure-A/17] for the post of Asst. Sub-Inspector of
Police (Male/Civil) within a stipulated period and appoint them to the
said post as both of them scored more marks than stipulated cutoff mark for written test.
[2]
Heard Mr. Th. Khagemba, learned counsel for the
petitioners and Mr. H. Samarjit, learned Government Advocate for
the respondents.
[3]
Brief facts of the case are that the Government of
Manipur, vide requisition Notification dated 24.04.2010 notified for
filling up the post of Sub-Inspector of Police, Jemadar for MR/IRB
and Asstt Sub-Inspector of Police (Male/Civil) comprising of 243, 49
and 112 number of vacancies respectively, through direct
recruitment for which the educational qualification was Graduate for
SI and Jemadar and PUC or Intermediate or equivalent for ASI. The
petitioners being qualified applied for the said ASI posts, but in the
Notification dated 25.02.2013, the petitioners could not find their
names in the list of candidates who were qualified in the written
test. In Notification dated 20.08.2005 [Annexure-A17] issued by
Joint Secretary (Home), Govt. of Manipur prescribing detailed
procedures for physical test, written test and viva voce to the post
of Asst Sub-Inspector (Civil Police)/Havildar MR, IRB, cut-off mark
in written test is prescribed as ‘24’.
[4]
Thereafter, the petitioners filed applications dated
06.03.2013 and 07.03.2013 under the RTI seeking information as to
the marks obtained by them in the above written examination. The
SP, DGP Control Room-cum-ASPIO, Police Department on 9.4.2013
informed the Special Secretary (Home), Govt of Manipur that the
Police Department, Manipur was exempted from the purview of the
RTI Act, 2005. Since the said RTI information was not furnished,
they filed WP(C) No.685 of 2013 praying for quashing the above
WP(C) NO. 801 OF 2022
said letter dated 9.4.2013 and to direct the respondents to produce
the answer script of the petitioners. The said writ petition was
disposed of on 4.10.2013 by directing the respondents to give the
required information sought by the petitioners. The State filed
Review Petition No.30 of 2013 for reviewing the above order, which
was allowed on 13.11.2013 with a direction to furnish the marks
secured in the written examination of the petitioners within one
month from the date of completion/declaration of the above
selection/recruitment process. The SP, DGP Control Room-cumASPIO, Police Department furnished to the petitioners their written
exam marks on 29.03.2014 after the selection was over and
declaration of the result on 03.04.2014.
[5]
Thereafter,
by
another
RTI
application
dated
25.04.2014 sought for inspection of the answer script of the written
test for recruitment of Asst Sub-Inspector, which was not furnished
to them and the petitioners again filed WP(C) No.47 of 2015. The
said WP(C) No.47 of 2015 was withdrawn on 20.04.2015 as the
Chief Information Commission was appointed and appropriate forum
was available.
[6]
In August 2016, the petitioners came to know that in
one RTI reply, addressed to Shri R.K.Prabir Singh, the Special
Secretary (Home), Govt of Manipur furnished the information with
regard to marks tabulation of the selected candidates. The
petitioners on perusal of the said marks scored by the selected
candidates came to know that even a candidate who scored just 20
marks in the written examination were called for viva voce and the
petitioners who scored 27 and 26 ½ marks in the written exam were
not called for viva voce. The petitioners’ marks in the written exam
are higher than 109 selected candidates who were called for viva
voce.
WP(C) NO. 801 OF 2022
[7]
In similar cases i.e. WP(C) No.760 of 2014 and WP(C)
No.376 of 2014, the petitioners therein scored higher marks than
others who were called for interview but they were not called for
viva voce. That case was for SI recruitment and in that recruitment,
there was no cut off marks as stated by the Addl. DGP (Prisons),
Manipur, Imphal in his letter dated 1.6.2015. The said WP(C)
Nos.760 of 2014 and 376 of 2014 were disposed of on 24.07.2015
with a direction to the respondents to conduct a ‘special viva voce
test’ for the two petitioners within a period of one month, and the
same was compiled by the respondents vide appointment orders
dated 11.05.2016 and 30.08.2016 to the post of Sub Inspector.
[8]
In WP(C) No.306 of 2019 filed by the present
petitioners, this Court in para 20 observed as follows:
“While filing affidavit-in-opposition to the writ petition,
the respondents No.2 and 3 stated that petitioners
failed to secure qualifying marks for ASI written test
i.e. 26 ½ marks was secured by the first petitioner and
27 marks by the second petitioner. The cut off for
Unreserved and OBCs, in which category the
petitioners applied, is 28 marks. Now the petitioners
claim that the first petitioner should be given 28 ¼
marks and the second petitioner should be given 29
½ marks. Though the respondent State contended
that the claim now made by the petitioners is not
supported by any material, equally, the respondent
State has also failed to substantiate their case by
producing documentary proof. Along with the
rejoinder to the affidavit-in-opposition, the petitioners
have produced the question and answer which they
have obtained under RTI Act. On perusal of the same,
prima facie, this Court is of the view that there is
substance in the claim now made by the petitioners.
[9]
The Writ Petition (C) No.306 of 2019 was disposed of
by directing the respondents to re-evaluate the answers of the
petitioners in the light of the order passed in WP(C) No.163 of 2009
dated 17.12.2013 and if upon such re-evaluation, the petitioners are
found to have scored the cut off marks, a special viva voce test be
WP(C) NO. 801 OF 2022
conducted or called for the petitioners for the post of ASI of Police
by applying the ratio in WP(C) Nos.760 and 376 of 2014 decided on
24.07.2015 and 818 of 2016 dated 15.05.2017, within a period of
two months from the date of receipt of the copy of the order.
[10]
In the affidavit-in-opposition filed by respondent No.2,
it is stated that with reference to para No.10 of the writ petition, the
answering deponent submits that the petitioners’ marks in the
written examination is higher than those 109 selected candidates
who are called for viva-voce but the selected 109 candidates belong
to
SC/ST
candidates.
Whereas
the
petitioners
belong
to
OBC/Unreserved candidates whose pass marks for the written test
of ASI is: unreserved and OBC- 28 marks whereas for SC & ST pass
park is 20 marks.
[11]
The petitioners failed to secure the qualifying marks
for ASI written test, 26½ marks was secured by Chest No.433/IE
Shri Moirangthem Rishikanta and 27 marks secured by Chest
No.1579/IE Shri Yumnam Manaoba.
[12]
It is further stated that, with reference to para No.11
of the writ petition, the present writ petitioners were ASI candidates.
However, WP(C) No.760 of 2014 is of SI Candidates and they are of
different written test. It is pointed out that the present writ
petitioners were ASI Candidates and WP(C) No.818 of 2016 is of SI
candidates as such, they are of different written test.
[13]
Mr. Th. Khagemba, learned counsel for the petitioners
submits that the petitioners scored 27 and 26½ marks in the written
test and as such they were eligible for appearing in the interview
having scored more that the statutory cut-off mark of “24”. It is
pointed out that in their reply, the respondents have failed to dispute
and deny the specific averment of the petitioners that as per
Notification dated 20.08.2005 [Annexure-A-17], the cut-off mark for
written test for ASI is ‘24’. It is submitted that the plea of the
WP(C) NO. 801 OF 2022
respondents to the fact that the cut-off mark is ‘28’ cannot be
accepted. Learned counsel has highlighted that such plea is not
sustainable without furnishing any document and also denying
assertion of the petitioners that cut-off mark is 24 as per rules. He
relies on the judgment in the case of Asha v. Pt. BD Sharma
University of Health Sciences: (2012) 7 SCC 389, it was held
that
17. It is a settled principle of the law of pleadings that an
averment made by the appellant is expected to be
specifically denied by the replying party. If there is no
specific denial, then such averment is deemed to have
been admitted by the respondent. In the present case, it
is evident that the above noted averments in the writ
petition were relevant and material to the case. In fact,
the entire case of the appellant hinged on these three
paragraphs of the writ petition. It was thus expected of
the respondents to reply to these averments specifically,
in fact to make a proper reference to the records relevant
to these paragraphs. In view of the omission on the part
of the respondents to refer to any relevant records and
failure to specifically deny the averments made by the
appellant, we are of the considered view that the
appellant has been able to make out a case for
interference.
[14]
It is prayed that the writ petition be allowed and the
respondents be directed to hold a ‘special viva-voce’ for the
petitioners as done in similar case, as they scored more than the
minimum cut-off mark stipulated by the relevant rules and appoint
them as Asst. Sub-Inspectors.
[15]
Mr. H. Samarjit, learned GA submits that the cut-off
mark for UR and OBC is 28 marks and for SC/ST is 20 marks. As the
petitioners could not reach the minimum 28 marks in the written
test, they were not called for interview. It is also submitted that the
decisions in the recruitment for SI cannot be relied for ASI posts. It
is prayed that the writ petition be dismissed.
WP(C) NO. 801 OF 2022
[16]
This Court considers the materials on record and the
submissions made by the parties at bar.
[17]
It is the case of the petitioners that as per RTI reply
and information furnished by the respondents, they scored 27 and
26½ marks in the written test for the recruitment of Asst. SubInspector and as such they scored more than the cut-off marks of
24 as fixed by Notification dated 20.08.2005 [Annexure-A-17].
Accordingly, they are eligible for appearing in the interview and
since they were wrongly not called for appearing in the interview, a
direction is prayed for holding a ‘special viva-voce’ for them for the
post of ASI and appoint them to the posts. On the other hand, the
case of the respondents is that the cut-off for written test for
UR/OBC is 28 marks and since the petitioners failed to score the
minimum cut-off, they were not called for the interview.
[18]
It is clear from a bare perusal of the Notification dated
20.08.2005 [Annexure-A-17] that the cut-off mark in the written test
for Asst. Sub-Inspector and Havildar is “24”. The respondents could
not produce any document to controvert this fact and have also
failed to deny the same in their reply. Accordingly, it is held that the
cut-off marks for written test for the recruitment of Asst. SubInspector is ‘24’ as per relevant rules. Since the petitioners scored
27 and 26½ marks in the written test, they ought to have been
included in the list of eligible candidates for appearing in the
interview. Due to the lapse on part of the respondents, the
petitioners’ names were omitted from the list of eligible candidates
for interview and their valuable right for consideration for
appointment as Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police was violated.
[19]
In the circumstances, the respondents are directed to
hold a special viva-voce for the petitioners for the post of Assistant
Sub-Inspectors notified on 24.04.2010 within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and to issue
WP(C) NO. 801 OF 2022
necessary appointment order, if their total score in the test is more
than that of the last candidate selected. Writ petition is allowed in
terms of the above directions. Parties are to bear their own cost.
[20]
Registry is directed to send a copy of this order to the
respondent No.2, the Director General of Police, Manipur for
information and necessary compliance.
`
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Priyojit
signed
RAJKUMA Digitally
by RAJKUMAR
R PRIYOJIT PRIYOJIT SINGH
Date: 2024.04.08
SINGH
15:05:35 +05'30'
WP(C) NO. 801 OF 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review