The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
29. 11.2006 was given under section 12 (2) of the Old Act. The amount of compensation was also determined to be Rs. 44,354/including solatium. Thus, it is the petitioner’s failure to accept the notice and the compensation. For failure on his own part, he cannot blame the authorities. The respondents have done wp 10562-2019.odt whatever is required to be done under the Act. No fault can be found with the procedure adopted by the authorities and as a matter of fact, there is no fault in the proceedings. The petitioner has measurably failed to make out a case for receiving compensation under the New Act. The petition also failed on other ground that the land is acquired in the year 2006. The petitioner has approached this Court only in the year 2019 by making out a case that only in the year 2017 when he collected 7/12 extract it came to his knowledge that his land is acquired. This cause of action dated 27.12.2017 is clearly imaginary. Though this Court is of the opinion to dismiss the petition with heavy cost, however, considering that the petitioner happens to be a farmer this Court refrained itself from imposing cost. interference is called for. No Therefore, the writ petition stands dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:32483-DB
wp 10562-2019.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 10562 OF 2019
Yadav s/o Bhaurao Gaikwad
Age : 62 years, Occu. : Agriculture
R/o. Chandola, Tq. Mukhed,
District : Nanded
.. Petitioner
(Claimant)
Versus
1.
The State of Maharashtra
Through Principal Secretary
Irrigation Development Department
Mantralaya, Mumbai.
2.
The District Collector, Nanded
Collector Office, Nanded.
3.
The Special Land Acquisition Officer
ik-r-y-lh-dk- dz-&2 Nanded.
.. Respondents
Mr. G. N. Chincholkar, Advocate h/f Smt. S. G. Chincholkar,
Advocate for the Petitioner.
Smt. S. S. Joshi, AGP for Respondent Nos. 1 to 3.
CORAM : KISHORE C. SANT AND
AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, JJ.
Date on which reserved for order : 14th July, 2026.
Date on which order pronounced : 31st July, 2026.
FINAL ORDER (PER KISHORE C. SANT, J.) :1.
Heard. By consent of the parties taken up for final disposal.
2.
This petition is filed seeking directions to respondent Nos. 1
to 3 to grant compensation to the petitioner in respect of his land
wp 10562-2019.odt
admeasuring 29 R from Gat No. 638 situated at village Chandola,
Taluka Mukhed, District Nanded under the Right to Fair
Compensation
and
Transparency
in
Land
Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter referred to
as “New Act” for the purpose of convenience).
3.
It is the case of the petitioner that, he is owner of land
totally admeasuring 147 R in Gat No. 638. Out of the said land 66
R land was acquired by the respondent No. 3 under the Land
Acquisition Act (hereinafter referred to as “Old Act” for the
purpose of convenience). However, no notice was served under
section 4, 5-A, 6, 9, 11 and 12 of the Old Act. The land was
acquired for construction of percolation tank. The land was
acquired long back in the year 2006. In the year 2017 it came to
his knowledge that the land came to be acquired in the year 2006
on going through his 7/12 extract and the award was passed on
18.03.2006. It is his further case that, since no compensation is
paid to the petitioner, he is entitled to a fresh proceeding and
compensation under section 24 (2) of the New Act.
4.
Learned Advocate Mr. Chincholkar for the petitioner
vehemently argued that the petitioner is entitled to receive
wp 10562-2019.odt
compensation under New Act as the respondents have not made
payment of compensation under the Old Act. He relies upon the
Judgment in the case of Pune Municipal Corporation and Anr. Vs.
Harakchand Misirimal Solanki And Others1 in support of his
submissions that when no compensation is paid to the land owner
prior to 01.01.2014 then the owner is entitled to receive the
compensation as per New Act.
5.
Learned AGP Smt. Joshi vehemently opposes the petition.
The respondents have already filed affidavit-in-reply. She submits
that the land to the extent of 66 R was acquired in the year 2000
itself. The award was passed on 15.05.2000. The compensation is
already paid to the petitioner. The petitioner even thereafter filed
L.A.R. No.636/2003 under section 18 of the Old Act. Later on, a
proposal was forwarded for acquisition of some more land for the
project. Considering the overflow of excess water and for that land
of the petitioner to the extent of 29 R was sought to be acquired
as it was affected by the overflow. In respect of 29 R land section 4
notification was issued in the newspaper on 27.04.2005 and in the
official gazette on 19.05.2005. Section 4 notice was served on
one Madhavrao working in the field of the petitioner. The
AIR 2014 (SC) 982
wp 10562-2019.odt
petitioner at the relevant time was a lecturer working in Mahatma
Gandhi College at Ahmedpur and it is thus the notice was served
upon his servant in the field. The notification was also published
on Chawdi on 04.06.2005. Thereafter a notification was published
under section 6 on 01.12.2005. This notification was also
published in newspaper on 01.12.2005 and in the official gazette
on the same date. Later on notice under section 9 (3)(4) of the
Old Act was also served on the person who was in the field. This
notice was also published on Chawdi. She further submits that the
amount of compensation was also received by the office of Special
Land Acquisition Officer (S.L.A.O.) vide cheque No. 320605 dated
30.08.2006 and it was credited to the account of S.L.A.O. It is
thereafter on 18.03.2006 award was passed and notice under
section 12 (2) was issued to the petitioner on 29.11.2006. She
accepted that there is no record of service of notice under section
12 (2) to the petitioner. Learned AGP thus submits that, when the
amount is deposited in the account of S.L.A.O. there is no question
of petitioner being entitled to receive compensation under section
24 (2) of the New Act. It is also pointed out that the mutation
entry was also taken in the name of respondents on 04.02.2011
and the same is approved on 16.08.2011 being Mutation Entry
wp 10562-2019.odt
No.1437. Thus, she prays for dismissal of the petition. The
reliance is placed on the Judgment in the case of Indore
Development Authority Vs Manoharlal And Other2
6.
This Court has heard the arguments and seen the petition
paper book. It is seen that, initially the land to the extent of 66 R
was acquired from the land of the petitioner.
So far as this
acquisition is concerned, there is no dispute. The question is only
about 29 R land acquired in the year 2005-2006. The grievance of
the petitioner is that he never received any notice of the
acquisition in the year 2005-2006. It is therefore required to be
seen as to whether the notice was actually served upon the
petitioner. The petitioner is not in a position to deny publication
of section 4 notification in the official gazette as well as in the
local newspaper. He also could not deny the fact of publication of
notice on Chawdi i.e. conspicuous place in the village.
The
respondent has specifically come with the case that notice was
served on a servant of the petitioner namely Madhavrao who was
working in the field.
Mere ignorance of the petitioner about
proceedings is no ground for the petitioner to say that the
acquisition is without giving notice to him. To become entitled to
(2020) 8 SCC 129
wp 10562-2019.odt
get compensation under New Act what is required to be shown is
that the amount is not deposited or paid or sought to be paid to
the owner.
7.
In the case of Pune Municipal Corporation And Another
(supra), the Full Bench of the Hon’ble Apex Court held that the
amount need to be deposited in the Court to avoid liability to pay
the compensation under section 24 (2) prior to the date from
which the New Act came into force. However, the said judgment
is overruled by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Indore
Development Authority (supra) by the Constitution Bench of five
Judges. Paragraph No. 202 in the case of Indore Development
Authority (supra) reads as under :
“202. Section 24(2) deals with the expression where
compensation has not been paid. It would mean that it has not
been tendered for payment under section 31(1). Though the
word “paid” amounts to a completed event however once
payment of compensation has been offered/tendered under
section 31(1), the acquiring authority cannot be penalized for
non-payment as the amount has remained unpaid due to refusal
to accept, by the landowner and Collector is prevented from
making the payment. Thus, the word “paid” used in section
24(2) cannot be said to include within its ken “deposit” under
section 31(2). For that special provision has been carved out in
the proviso to section 24(2), which deals with the amount to be
deposited in the account of beneficiaries. Two different
expressions have been used in section 24. In the main part of
section 24, the word “paid” and in its proviso “deposited” have
been used.”
8.
wp 10562-2019.odt
It is thus clear that, even depositing of the money is also not
expected under section 31 (1) of the New Act. What is material is
that an offer or tender of the amount. In the present case, it is
specifically shown by the respondents that the amount was
actually deposited in the account of respondent No. 3. Thus, the
authority was absolved from its liability to make payment under
New Act. The petitioner was also not right in relying upon the
overruled judgment in the case of Pune Municipal Corporation
And Another (supra).
9.
Going further it is clearly seen that, every attempt was made
to serve the petitioner. As a matter of fact, the servant of the
petitioner was also given the notice for which respondents cannot
be held responsible.
From the material brought on record
alongwith affidavit of the respondents it is clearly seen that the
compensation is deposited with respondent No. 3. Notice dated
29.11.2006 was given under section 12 (2) of the Old Act. The
amount of compensation was also determined to be Rs. 44,354/including solatium. Thus, it is the petitioner’s failure to accept the
notice and the compensation.
For failure on his own part, he
cannot blame the authorities.
The respondents have done
wp 10562-2019.odt
whatever is required to be done under the Act. No fault can be
found with the procedure adopted by the authorities and as a
matter of fact, there is no fault in the proceedings. The petitioner
has measurably failed to make out a case for receiving
compensation under the New Act.
The petition also failed on
other ground that the land is acquired in the year 2006. The
petitioner has approached this Court only in the year 2019 by
making out a case that only in the year 2017 when he collected
7/12 extract it came to his knowledge that his land is acquired.
This cause of action dated 27.12.2017 is clearly imaginary.
Though this Court is of the opinion to dismiss the petition with
heavy cost, however, considering that the petitioner happens to be
a farmer this Court refrained itself from imposing cost.
interference is called for.
No
Therefore, the writ petition stands
dismissed.
10.
It is open for the petitioner to approach the concerned
authorities and to pray for withdrawal of compensation amount
which is already deposited with respondent No. 3 as per law, if not
already withdrawn.
( AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J.)
P.S.B.
( KISHORE C. SANT, J. )
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review