The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
29. Insofar as a second opportunity post retirement is concerned, we find no reason to interfere with the reason assigned by the Hon’ble Single Judge relying upon the inordinate delay which occurred in the meantime. The judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Anant R. Kulkarni (supra) and G. Vallikumari (supra) relied upon by the learned advocate for the respondent in this regard. Relevant extract of the judgment, being relied upon reads: “36. In the facts and circumstances of the case, as the Tribunal as well as the learned Single Judge have examined all the charges on merit and also found that the enquiry has not been conducted as per the 1981 Rules, it was not the cause of the Management Committee which had been prejudiced, rather it had been the other way around. In such a fact situation, it was not necessary for the Division Bench to permit the respondents to hold a fresh enquiry on the said charges and that too, after more than a decade of the retirement of the appellant.” Considering the long delay in the instant case, the charges being of the order 2011, the repeated failure of the authority to proceed in accordance with law, despite an opportunity granted earlier being disposal of the first writ petition, we are of the view, which is fortified by decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Anant R. Kulkarni (supra) and G. Gallikumari (supra) that the author…
30. In view of our above consideration, we find no reason to interfere with the judgment dated 20.09.2023 passed by the Hon’ble Single Judge passed in W.P.A. 13167 of 2019.
31. The appeal and the application are dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Madhuresh Prasad
AND
The Hon’ble Justice Prasenjit Biswas
F.M.A. 535 of 2024
With
CAN 1 of 2024
West Bengal Gramin Bank & Ors.
Vs.
Phanibhushan Chakraborty
For the Appellants
:
Mr. Baidurya Ghosal,
Mr. Saikat Mukherjee
For the
Writ Petitioner/Respondent
:
Mr. Debabrata Saha Ray, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Indranath Mitra,
Mr. Neil Bau,
Mr. Sankha Biswas,
Ms. Oindrilla Sarkar,
Mr. Avidipta Paul
Heard on
:
23.03.2026
Judgment on
:
23.03.2026
MADHURESH PRASAD, J.:
1. Herd the learned advocate for the appellants and the learned advocate
representing the respondent.
2. The appellant was the respondent before the Writ Court. The writ petition
was allowed by the Hon’ble Single Judge by a judgment dated 20.09.2023.
The Hon’ble Single Judge was pleased to quash the enquiry report, order of
the punishment and allow the writ petition.
3. The appellant has assailed the judgment dated 20.09.2023 by way of the
present Intra Court Appeal.
4. The petitioner while working in a managerial capacity in the Bank was
proceeded against by a charge memo dated 13.05.2011. The charge memo
allege that the petitioner had violated Regulation 18 and 20 of the Bangiya
Gramin Vikash Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulations, 2010
[hereinafter referred to as Regulations]. Five charges were drawn up against
the petitioner which read as follows:
“i) Committing acts detrimental to the interest of the Bank;
ii) Sanction and disbursement of loans violating Rules, Norms and
Lending Policy of the Bank;
iii) Exposing the Bank to financial loss;
iv) Doing acts in negligent and suppressive manner &
v) Committing breach of trust.”
5. The enquiry commenced on 09.08.2011 and concluded on 14.07.2012. The
Bank was relying upon eleven documents as evidence in support of the
charges, which were to be brought home, based on oral testimony of two
proposed witnesses.
6. The enquiry concluded by an order of the Disciplinary Authority dated
17.08.2013 holding the petitioner guilty of the charges. The petitioner was
awarded the punishment of reduction to the lowest scale of pay. The
petitioner preferred an appeal against an order of the Disciplinary Authority,
which was rejected by the Appellate Authority on 10.05.2014.
7. In the above background the petitioner filed the first writ petition bearing
AST No. 188 of 2014. Upon going through the enquiry proceedings the
Hon’ble Single Judge found that the order of the Appellate Authority, as well
as the Disciplinary Authority was without assigning any reasons, passed
mechanically and manifests non-consideration of the charges vis-à-vis the
material. The Hon’ble Single Judge quashed the order of the Disciplinary
Authority dated 17.08.2013 as well as the order of the Appellate Authority
dated 10.05.2014 and remanded the matter to the Disciplinary Authority to
consider the enquiry report, enquiry proceedings and other materials
produced at the enquiry, including the objections raised by the writ
petitioner.
8. Under the circumstances the Disciplinary Authority proceeded to consider
the matter afresh and passed an order on 23.09.2015, again holding the
charges to be proved. The Disciplinary Authority found the petitioner liable
to a punishment of “Reversion from Officer Scale-III to Officer Scale-II, in
the initial stage of time scale of pay (Officer Scale-II) with retention of FPP
and Stagnation increment, if any, w.e.f. 17.08.2013 with cumulative effect.”
9. The petitioner again availed the remedy of departmental appeal. This time,
the Appellate Authority rejected the petitioner’s appeal, thereby affirming
the order passed by the Disciplinary Authority. The appeal was rejected by
the Chairman, Board of Directors of the Bank by an order dated 11.05.2016.
The order of the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority was thus
assailed by the writ petitioner in the second writ petition bearing W.P.A. No.
13167 of 2019, order of which is subject matter of the present Intra Court
Appeal.
10. After a meticulous consideration of the material on record, the Hon’ble
Single Judge by the judgment under appeal dated 20.09.2023, found that
the order of the Disciplinary Authority was unsustainable. The judgment of
the Hon’ble Single Judge has taken into consideration various infirmities
including non-examination of any witness in support of the charges. The
Hon’ble Single Judge has considered the enquiry report dated 28.12.2012
submitted by the Enquiry Officer and found that the same is cryptic, and
there are no reasons in support of the conclusion recorded by the Enquiry
Officer. The conclusions were found to be without reference to any material
in the enquiry.
11. The Hon’ble Single Judge found that after recording the few dates prior to
passing of the final order, the Enquiry Officer proceeded to hold the charges
proved. The Enquiry Officer did not even record a finding as to which norm
or procedure was allegedly violated by the charge sheeted officer while
sanctioning the loans. The Enquiry Officer proceeded to record finding
prejudicial to the charge sheeted officer by shifting the onus of proof on the
charge sheeted officer. The Hon’ble Single Judge also found that the P.O’s
submission was recorded by the Enquiry Officer verbatim, purporting to be
his own conclusions. Therefore, it is obvious that Enquiry Officer’s order was
mechanical and suffered from the vice of non application of mind. The
enquiry report was found to be unsustainable.
12. In view of such infirmities in the consideration of the Enquiry Officer, the
Hon’ble Single Judge found that the conclusions of the Enquiry Officer, and
consequential order of the Disciplinary Authority were not sustainable. The
order of the Disciplinary Authority and its affirmation by the Appellate
Authority were also found to be unsustainable.
13. The conclusions of the Hon’ble Single Judge in our considered opinion is
based on perusal of the record and on going through the enquiry report,
order of the Disciplinary Authority as well as the Appellate Authority. We
find that the above noted conclusions of the Hon’ble Single Judge are borne
from the record and based on a thorough consideration of the same, which
does not require any interference.
14. The learned advocate for the appellants submitted that since the Hon’ble
Single Judge did not set aside the charge memo. The Hon’ble Single Judge
should have allowed an opportunity to the authorities to proceed against the
writ petitioner from the stage after submission of the charge memo.
15. He has drawn the Court’s attention to Regulation 45 of the Bangiya Gramin
Vikash Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulations, 2010 to submits
that the same permits the continuance/conduct of proceeding against
retired employee even after retirement. The petitioner’s retirement dated
31.05.2014, therefore, did not justify quashing of the entire disciplinary
proceeding against the writ petitioner, without affording an opportunity to
the employer to proceed in accordance with law to establish the charges
made out in the charge memo dated 31.05.2011.
16. The learned advocate representing the appellants relied upon decision of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of The State of Uttar Pradesh and
Others –Vs.- Rajit Singh reported in 2022 AIR (SC) 1551 and a
judgment of a coordinate Bench of this Court in Bangiya Gramin Vikash
Bank & Ors. –Vs.- Debajyoti Roy (MAT 2272 of 2023), copies of
which have been passed on to the Court after serving a copy on the
respondent’s counsel.
17. The learned advocate representing the respondent on the other hand
submitted that the petitioner attained the age of superannuation on
31.05.2014, more than a decade back. The charge memo is dated 31.05.2011
in respect of allegations even prior thereto. At this stage when the
authorities despite an opportunity given pursuant to the earlier order passed
in AST No. 188 of 2014, failed to proceed in accordance with law. Therefore,
now they cannot claim a further opportunity to proceed in respect of the
charge memo issued in 2011.
18. The Hon’ble Single Judge after a threadbare consideration on the merits of
the allegations and the materials on record has found the enquiry report, the
conclusions of the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority orders
to be unsustainable and illegal. Under the circumstances having regard to
the detailed consideration and taking into account the various other factors
such as the inordinate delay, the period of more than a decade since the
petitioner’s retirement, the authority should not be allowed to now proceed
with the matter.
19. In support of his submissions he relied upon decision of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Anant R. Kulkarni –Vs.- Y.P. Education Society
and Others reported in (2013) 6 SCC 515. He has also relied upon
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of G. Vallikumari –Vs.Andhra Education Society and Others reported in (2010) 2 SCC
497.
20. The learned advocate also relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Roop Singh Negi –Vs.- Punjab National Bank
and Others reported in (2009) 2 SCC 570 to support the conclusions in
the Hon’ble Single Judge’s order.
21. We have considered the rival submissions insofar as the submission of the
learned advocate for the appellants regarding an opportunity not being given
by the Hon’ble Single Judge to proceed with the matter afresh based on
these decisions. The decision passed in the case of Rajit Singh (supra)
relied upon, is required to be considered in correlation to the factual
foundations for passing the judgment. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Rajit Singh (supra) was considering an order passed by the Tribunal
wherein the Tribunal quashed the punishment awarded to the charge
sheeted officer based on a submission claiming parity with other charge
sheeted employee, allegedly similarly situated as the petitioner therein, who
had been exonerated.
22. The Hon’ble Apex Court took into consideration the settled principle of law
that normally parity cannot be claimed in this regard as individual roles,
duties and evidence/material may differ. The judgment also took into
consideration non-supply of documents to the delinquent therein. The
Hon’ble Apex Court, therefore, was of the view that the punishment order
was interfered with on the ground of procedural lapse. Therefore, it arrived
at a conclusion that it was only proper to allow the authorities an
opportunity to proceed with the matter in accordance with law.
23. The other decision of the coordinate Bench in Bangiya Gramin Vikash
Bank & Ors. (supra) relied upon by the appellants also rests on similar
consideration, which is a binding precedent for this Court. However, such
proposition can apply only in correlation to the facts in which they are
rendered which we find in the present case to be distinguishable.
24. In the present case as taken note of above, there is a thread bare
consideration by the Hon’ble Single Judge of the entire issue right from the
enquiry report, Disciplinary Authority’s orders as well as the Appellate
Authority’s order. On the various grounds which we have already considered
above and need not be restated to avoid repetition, the Hon’ble Single Judge
rightly arrived at a conclusion regarding unsustainability of the enquiry
report, Disciplinary Authority’s order as well as the Appellate Authority’s
order.
25. Insofar as an opportunity to rectify the mistake claimed by the learned
counsel for the appellants, is concerned, we find that the same was granted
to the authorities by this Court when the order was passed in AST No. 188 of
2014. The order in AST No. 188 of 2014 was passed on 04.08.2015 much
after the writ petitioner had retired (31.05.2014). An opportunity was,
therefore, granted to the authorities irrespective of the fact that the
petitioner had already retired.
26. Upon consideration of the entire material the Writ Court rightly found that
the authorities miserably failed in utilizing such opportunity and have
occasioned a gross miscarriage of justice and violation of the principles of
natural justice in the consideration as manifest from the enquiry report,
Disciplinary Authority and Appellate Authority’s order.
27. The order of the Hon’ble Single Judge is limited to consideration within the
scope and limit of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India. The law in this regard is by now settled by catena of judgments of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. The issues and circumstances which may
be looked into were enumerated by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Union of India and Others –Vs.- P. Gunasekaran reported in
(2015) 2 SCC 610. The Hon’ble Apex Court held that in exercise of judicial
review findings in a departmental proceeding may be interfered with when
the finding is based on no evidence, where there is violation of principles of
natural justice and when the authority has allowed itself to be influenced by
irrelevant or extraneous considerations. The Hon’ble Apex Court also held
that an interference may be warranted in exercise of judicial review if the
conclusions on the face of it is arbitrary, capricious and when no reasonable
person could have arrived at such conclusion.
28. The findings of the Hon’ble Single Judge in the present case is in respect of
such circumstances apparent from the enquiry report wherein no witness
appeared to support the case of the department. The enquiry officer
mechanically recorded the submissions of the Presenting Officer, as his own
conclusions, verbatim. Therefore, in the instant case it is glaring that the
Enquiry Officer’s conclusion is based on no evidence, influenced by
extraneous and irrelevant consideration and the findings are arbitrary and
capricious. The procedure adopted by the enquiry officer has also been
found to be violated of natural justice. We, therefore, find that consideration
and conclusions are within the scope of judicial review as stated by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in P. Gunasekaran (supra), leaving no reason to
interfere with the decision of the Hon’ble Single Judge.
29. Insofar as a second opportunity post retirement is concerned, we find no
reason to interfere with the reason assigned by the Hon’ble Single Judge
relying upon the inordinate delay which occurred in the meantime. The
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Anant R. Kulkarni
(supra) and G. Vallikumari (supra) relied upon by the learned advocate
for the respondent in this regard. Relevant extract of the judgment, being
relied upon reads:
“36. In the facts and circumstances of the case, as the Tribunal as
well as the learned Single Judge have examined all the charges on
merit and also found that the enquiry has not been conducted as per
the 1981 Rules, it was not the cause of the Management Committee
which had been prejudiced, rather it had been the other way around.
In such a fact situation, it was not necessary for the Division Bench
to permit the respondents to hold a fresh enquiry on the said charges
and that too, after more than a decade of the retirement of the
appellant.”
Considering the long delay in the instant case, the charges being of the order
2011, the repeated failure of the authority to proceed in accordance with law,
despite an opportunity granted earlier being disposal of the first writ
petition, we are of the view, which is fortified by decision of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of Anant R. Kulkarni (supra) and G.
Gallikumari (supra) that the authorities have rightly allowed any further
opportunity to reconsider the issue based on the charge memo of 2011.
30. In view of our above consideration, we find no reason to interfere with the
judgment dated 20.09.2023 passed by the Hon’ble Single Judge passed in
W.P.A. 13167 of 2019.
31. The appeal and the application are dismissed.
32. Urgent Photostat Certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance with all necessary formalities.
(MADHURESH PRASAD, J.)
(PRASENJIT BISWAS, J.)
B.K.N.
A.R. (Court)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review