Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:52035
CrAppeal-839-2018
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 839 OF 2018
Vitthal S/o. Venkati Kadam
Age : 31 years, Occu.: Agril.,
R/o. Kuntur, Tq.Naigaon,
District Nanded.
….Appellant
(Ori. Accused No.1)
Versus
The State of Maharashtra
Through Police Station Kuntur,
Tq.Naigaon, District Nanded.
…..Respondent
…..
Mr.Madhukar M. Parghane, Advocate for Appellant.
Mr.N.D.Raje, APP for Respondent.
…..
CORAM :
ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.
Reserved on
Pronounced on
: 26-10-2026
: 27-10-2026
JUDGMENT :
1.
This appeal is directed against Judgment and order dated
15-11-2018 rendered by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Biloli on
in Sessions Case No.1400019 of 2013 convicting accused No.1
husband for offence under Sections 498-A and 306 of the Indian
Penal Code (IPC).
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE
2.
Before trial Court, prosecution set up a case that, Parvati was
-2-
CrAppeal-839-2018
married to appellant/accused No.1 in 2008. After initially treating
Parvati properly for a period of one year, accused persons maltreated
her and subjected her to cruelty in the backdrop of demand of
motorcycle as well as money for digging bore well. Whenever Parvati
came for festivals, she used to report about above demand and ill
treatment. Understanding was given to the accused, but there was no
improvement and ill treatment continued and only due to it, deceased
Parvati hanged herself and ended up her life. Therefore, informant
father PW4 approached Police Station, gave complaint Exhibit 25, on
the basis of which, investigation was carried out and it is culminated
into filing of chargesheet followed by trial.
Learned trial court was pleased to appreciate the prosecution
evidence and by above mentioned Judgment and order, accused
Nos.2 to 5 came to be acquitted but accused No.1 husband alone
came to be convicted and it is now he, who is challenging said
Judgment and order dated 15-11-2018.
SUBMISSIONS
On behalf of Appellant :
3.
Learned counsel for appellant would submit that, case of
prosecution is based on evidence of 7 witnesses. According to him,
panchas have not supported prosecution case. That, there is only
-3-
CrAppeal-839-2018
evidence of family members and there is no independent witness.
That, even their evidence does not inspire confidence as according to
him, there are vague, general abd omnibus allegations against all
accused. He pointed out that, regarding demand of motorcycle, how
much amount was demanded is not consistently stated by witnesses.
That, similarly how much amount was demanded for digging bore
well is also not coming on record. Rather, he would point out that,
informant himself had admitted that there was already bore well
existing in the field of accused, therefore, there is no question of
setting up any demand or ill treating deceased in that backdrop. He
pointed out that, there is a gap of almost one month between alleged
demand and alleged suicide and thus, according to him, by no stretch
of imagination, such allegations would constitute abetment to commit
suicide.
He pointed out that, here, on the same set of evidence,
learned trial Court has given clean chit to accused Nos.2 to 5, but
accused No.1, husband is singled out and he is convicted.
Thus,
seeking reliance on the following Judgments of this Court, he prays to
interfere in the impugned Judgment by allowing the appeal.
(a)
Yadavrao v. State of Maharashtra, 2024 SCC OnLine Bom.1205.
(b)
Judgment dated 23-02-2024 in Sunil Bharat Pardeshi v. The State of
Maharashtra in Criminal Appeal No.224 of 2002 .
(c)
Judgment dated 18-03-2024 in Satish and Ors. v. The State of
Maharashtra, Criminal Appeal No.73 of 2003.
-4(d)
CrAppeal-839-2018
Judgment dated 22-07-2024 in Laxman s/o Vishwanath Waghmare
v. The State of Maharashtra in Criminal Appeal No.104 of 2004 .
On behalf of Respondent :
4.
In answer to above, learned APP would point out that, learned
trial Court has correctly appreciated the evidence.
That, there is
evidence on the point of demand as well as ill treatment. He would
submit that, merely because witnesses are related, their evidence
cannot be thrown out, moreover, when it is consistent and inspiring
confidence.
He would point out that, barely before the suicide,
witnesses speak about demand followed by ill treatment and as such,
according to him, no fault can be found in the manner of appreciation
of evidence and for want of merits, he prays to dismiss the appeal.
BRIEF ACCOUNT OF PROSECUTION EVIDENCE IN TRIAL COURT
5.
PW1 Balaji Kadam is Pancha to spot panchanama.
PW2 Deobai Digamber Kadam, neighbour did not support
prosecution as she deposed that she is unable to tell why Parvati
committed suicide.
PW3 Chandrabai Kadam, second neighbour also gave similar
treatment to the prosecution case by deposing in examination-in-chief
itself that she was unable to tell why Parvati committed suicide and
whether there was harassment resulting into suicide.
-5-
6.
CrAppeal-839-2018
PW4 Baburao Vithalrao Thete is the father and informant and it
has come in his evidence that, after marriage of his daughter with
accused No.1, she went to cohabit. That, after marriage till one year,
her married life was good, but subsequent to that, there was ill
treatment by husband, in-laws, sister-in-law on account of demand of
motorcycle and demand of money.
That, accused used to keep
Parvati starve and even abused her. That, whenever Parvati came for
festival to their house, she informed about above incidents. That, he
and his brother once or twice went to convince accused, but their
efforts went in vain. That, 7-8 days prior to her death, she had come
to their house and told about demand of money for motorcycle and
digging bore well and there to be ill treatment on that count. That,
she was sent back with his nephew Ananda, who was allegedly
questioned by accused No.1 why he brought Parvati to her
matrimonial house and on the next day, it was learnt that Parvati
committed suicide by hanging herself and therefore, he lodged report
at Exhibit 25.
7.
PW5 Maroti Vithal Thite is uncle of deceased and brother of
PW4.
He deposed that after one year, whenever Parvati came to
parents’ place, she narrated about ill treatment and told that her
-6-
CrAppeal-839-2018
family members had asked her to bring Rs.60,000/- for motorcycle
and Rs.1,00,000/- for tube well expenses. That, accused were told
that whenever amount would be available, it would be paid, but there
was no change in their attitude and ill treatment continued and
because of ill treatment, she was brought to parents’ place. That,
8-10 days prior to the incident, his son Ananda left Parvati at the
house of accused, at that time, accused No.1 abused him for failing to
pay the amount for purchasing motorcycle or to bear expenses of
bore well. On the next day, they learnt that Parvati had committed
suicide by hanging herself.
8.
PW6 Ananda Maroti Thete, cousin brother of deceased,
deposed at Exhibit 27 that, prior to 8 days of incident, Parvati had
come to parents’ house and she told that family members are
demanding amount to her but her father and brother telling them that
they do not have amount to pay but promised to pay it later on. That,
he left Parvati at matrimonial house and at that time, accused No.1
asked him whether amount was brought or not and that, he told him
that father of Parvati would be coming in 3-4 days and he came back.
That, on the next day, Parvati hanged herself. According to him, she
had ill treatment at the hands of accused. That, they used to beat her,
not providing food and not allowing to enter in the house.
CrAppeal-839-2018
-7-
PW7
Ashok
Vinayakarao
Chate
(Retired
P.I.)
is
the
Investigating Officer, who narrated all the steps taken by him during
investigation.
ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION
9.
In brief, case of prosecution in trial Court was that, after one
year of marriage, Parvati was subjected to cruelty in the backdrop of
demand of motorcycle and money for digging bore well. Though 7
witnesses are examined, as is emerging from evidence, PW1, PW2 and
PW3 i.e. pancha and immediate two neighbours have not supported
prosecution case. Therefore, evidence that remains for consideration
is of PW4 father, PW5 uncle and PW6 cousin brother of deceased. It
is expected that they lend support to each other on material count of
both demand as well as ill treatment and as such, their evidence is put
to minute scrutiny.
It is noticed that, PW4 informant, who has set law into motion,
merely speaks of ill treatment by husband, in-laws, sister-in-law on
account of demand of motorcycle and demand of money. According
to him, accused used to starve her and abuse her. Thus, as submitted,
he does not speak about the amount of demand raised for motorcycle.
Secondly, he does not speak about demand of money raised for
digging of bore well. Again he raises general allegations against all
-8-
CrAppeal-839-2018
accused i.e. husband, in-laws and sister-in-law. Learned trial Court
has already acquitted accused Nos.2 to 5. Therefore, unless demand
is specifically attributed to accused No.1 husband alone, he ought not
to have been singled out by the trial Court. Moreover, in his crossexamination, informant admitted that, he is unable to give exact date,
month, year when demand of motorcycle was raised. In paragraph 6
of the cross-examination, he admitted that demand of money to dig
bore well was raised prior to one month of death of Parvati, but in the
same paragraph, he admitted that, part demand of accused was met
through one Devidas Patil. But said Devidas Patil is not examined.
He further admitted that, bore well came to be dug in the field, but he
is unable to state when it was dug and further admitted that, accused
dug the bore well when he lastly took Parvati back to his house.
10.
PW5 uncle of deceased and brother of PW4 stated that after
one year, when Parvati came to parents’ house, she narrated ill
treatment. He does not specify which of the accused ill treated in
what manner. He merely speaks that she was telling that her family
members told her to bring Rs.60,000/- for motorcycle and
Rs.1,00,000/- for tube well expenses, but PW4 informant father has
not quoted the amount.
This witness deposed that, his own son
Ananda went to drop Parvati after she stayed for 8-10 days at parents
-9-
CrAppeal-839-2018
house and at that time, it is alleged that accused husband abused him
for failing to pay amount and on next day, news of suicide was learnt.
Omission is brought in his cross-examination that after one year
of marriage of Parvati, demand for motorcycle and bore well was
raised. He admitted that before last visit of Parvati, she had come for
Dipawali, which should be around October-November, but apparently
suicide by Parvati is of 18-01-2013 i.e. after 2-3 months after
Dipawali and it is not even in immediate proximity to the alleged
suicide by deceased.
11.
PW6 is cousin brother of Parvati and son of PW5 and he in his
evidence, as stated above, has stated that Parvati during her stay of 8
days at parents’ house informed him that her family members are
demanding amount and that her father and brother told them that
they do not have amount to pay and they would pay later on.
According to him, when he left her at matrimonial house, accused
No.1 asked him whether amount has been brought. Therefore, there
is mere demand attributed to accused No.1, however, the fact that on
account of failure to meet demand only, deceased was subjected to
cruelty and thus she committed suicide, is not proved by prosecution
independently because here immediate neighbours namely PW2
Deobai and PW3 Chandrabai flatly denied in examination-in-chief
-10-
CrAppeal-839-2018
that only because of harassment by accused, deceased committed
suicide. In fact these are independent witnesses. Therefore, there is
no independent corroboration regarding visit of PW6 to drop Parvati
at matrimonial house one day earlier to alleged suicide.
12.
For attracting charge under Section 498-A of the IPC, it is
expected of prosecution to demonstrate that accused persons
maltreated deceased only for demand that too in consistent manner.
It is fairly settled position that details of the infliction of ill treatment
are to be supplied. Prosecution version comes under shadow of doubt
when allegations are general and vague.
Law to this extent is
propounded by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Rajesh
Chaddha v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2025 SCC OnLine SC 1094]. The
Hon’ble Apex Court has observed in paragraph 14 as under :
“The term "cruelty" is subject to rather cruel misuse by the
parties, and cannot be established simpliciter without
specific instances, to say the least. The tendency of roping
these sections, without mentioning any specific dates,
time or incident, weakens the case of the prosecutions,
and casts serious suspicion on the viability of the version
of a Complainant. …...”
Likewise, in the case of Manju Ram Kalita v. State of Assam,
(2009) 13 SCC 330, the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed that, it
must be established that the woman has subjected to cruelty
-11-
CrAppeal-839-2018
continuously or in close proximity of time of lodging the complaint.
Here, Informant father’s evidence, as pointed out, is silent
about quantum of demand or manner and nature of ill treatment.
Uncle of deceased seems to have hearsay information.
Therefore,
charge under Section 498-A of the IPC is not proved beyond
reasonable doubt.
13.
For attracting charge under Section 306 of the IPC, it has to be
shown that accused No.1 husband abetted the suicide or he instigated
the suicide. What positive role accused No.1 husband played has not
been demonstrated by the prosecution.
Hence, there is weak
evidence on the point of offence of Section 306 of the IPC.
14.
It is also pertinent to state that, on the same set of evidence,
learned trial Court has acquitted original accused Nos.2 to 5 from all
the charges.
Law is fairly settled that, on the same set of evidence, if coaccused is acquitted then other accused also deserves similar
treatment on the ground of parity. On this proposition, reliance can
be placed on the Judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Javed
Shaukat Ali Qureshi v. State of Gujarat, MANU/SC/1012/2023
CrAppeal-839-2018
-12-
wherein earlier judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Harbans Singh v. State of U.P. and Others reported in (1982) 2 SCC
101, was referred to and it was observed in paragraph 15 as under:
“When there is similar or identical evidence of eye
witnesses against two accused by ascribing them the same
or similar role, the court cannot convict one accused and
acquit the other. In such a case, the cases of both accused
will be governed by the principle of parity. This principle
means that the criminal court should decide like cases alike,
and in such cases, the court cannot make a distinction
between
two
accused,
which
will
amount
to
discrimination.”
Similarly, in another Judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
the case of Yogarani v. State by the Inspector of Police, reported in
MANU/SC/1046/2024, the Hon’ble Apex Court has referred to the
judgment of Javed Shaukat Ali Qureshi i.e. above judgment and
reproduced paragraph 15, which is reproduced in aforesaid
paragraph.
Likewise, again the Hon’ble Apex Court in a recent judgment of
Vaddi
Ratnam
v.
State
of
Andhra
Pradesh
reported
in
MANU/SC/1344/2025 in paragraph 9 reiterated the above law.
In present case also on the same set of evidence, the learned
CrAppeal-839-2018
-13-
trial Court seems to have acquitted accused Nos.2 to 5 from all the
charges and therefore, applying the principle of parity, learned trial
Court ought to have acquitted appellant/accused No.1 also.
15.
Therefore, in view of the above discussion, indulgence and
interference at the hands of this Court is called for.
Accordingly,
following order is passed:
ORDER
I.
The appeal is allowed.
II.
The conviction awarded to the appellant Vitthal S/o. Venkati
Kadam by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Biloli in Sessions
Case No.1400019 of 2013 under Sections 498-A, 306 of the
Indian Penal Code on 15-11-2018 stands quashed and set aside.
III. The appellant stands acquitted of the offence punishable under
Sections 498-A, 306 of the Indian Penal Code.
IV. The bail bonds of the appellant stand cancelled.
V.
Fine amount deposited, if any, be refunded to the appellant after
the statutory period.
VI. It is clarified that there is no change as regards the order
regarding disposal of muddemal.
[ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.]
SPT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review