Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:54142
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.14026 OF 2025
IN
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.11824 OF 2024
IN
FIRST APPEAL NO.1400 OF 2024
01.
Amit s/o Rasiklal Kothari,
Age-46 yrs., Occu.-Business,
02.
Shweta w/o Amit Kothari,
Age-45 yrs., Occu,-Business,
Both r/o-Chandrkor, Maniknagar,
Nagar-Pune Road, Ahilyanagar/
Ahmednagar.
...Applicants.
In the Matter in Between :
Excellent Constructions Pvt. Ltd.
11 Indian Mercantile Insurance
Building, 4 ORE, V.B. Gandhi Marg,
Mumbai.
By its duly authorized signatory
Rajan Bulchand Age: 59 years,
Occu.: Service, R/o Nicolas Estevanez 21,
Las Palmas 35007, Spain.
At present having address at 202,
Aspect Tower, Business Bay, Dubai
Versus
1.
Seema Sharad Mutha
Age: Adult, Occu.: Business,
2.
3.
Shilpa Sharad Mutha
Age: Adult, Occu.: Business,
Both R/o 83, Maniknagar,
Nagar-Pune Road, Ahmednagar.
Sharad Mansukhlal Mutha
Gaikwad RD
1 of 13
...Applicant.
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
(Since died on 25.03.2019,
through his Lrs)
3A.
Mangala Sharad Mutha
Age: 68 years, Occu.: Business,
3B.
Nirmal Sharad Mutha
Age: 41 years, Occu.: Business,
3C.
Shilpa Sharad Mutha,
Age: 46 years, Occu.: Business,
3D.
Seema Sharad Mutha
(Original Defendant No.1)
Age: 43 years, Occ.: Business,
4.
M/s Sharad Mutha Housing
Development Ltd.
83, Maniknagar, Nagar-Pune Road,
Ahmednagar By its Directors
4A.
Ashok Bansilal Mutha
Age: Adult, Occ.: Business,
R/o 83, Maniknagar, Nagar-Pune Road,
Ahmednagar.
4B.
Mansukhlal Manikchand Mutha (Deceased)
4C.
Sharad Mansukhlal Mutha (Deceased)
5.
Zarip Khan Wallikhan
Age: Adult, Occu.: Business,
R/o Dinshaw House, 6th Floor,
Above Oriental Bank, Synagogue Stree,
Camp, Pune.
6.
Amit Rasiklal Kothari
Age: 44 years, Occu.: Business,
R/o Chandrakor, Maniknagar,
Station Road, Ahmednagar
Gaikwad RD
2 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
7.
Shweta Amit Kothari
Age: 43 years, Occu.: Business,
R/o Chandrakor, Maniknagar,
Station Road, Ahmednagar.
8.
Saten Champala Gundecha
Age: 48 years, Occu.: Agri. & Business,
R/o Survey No. 131, F-5, Maniknagar,
Chandan Estate Road, Ahmednagar
....Respondent.
——————
Mr. N. B. Khandare, Senior Advocate, i/b. Mr. Ajeet Gholap, Advocate for
Applicants.
Mr. V. D. Sapkal, Senior Advocate, i/b. Mr. Pratik P. Kothare, Advocate for
Respondents.
——————
Coram :
Reserved on :
Pronounced on :
KISHORE C. SANT &
NEERAJ P. DHOTE, JJ.
13th OCTOBER 2026.
4th NOVEMBER 2026.
(Through Video Conferencing)
JUDGMENT : (PER NEERAJ P. DHOTE, J.)
1.
This is an application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (‘CPC’) for modification of the order dated 5 th February
2025 (‘said order’)passed by this Court in Civil Application No.11824 of
2024, allowing the application and restraining the Applicants from
creating third party rights or interest in the land situated at Gat No. 327 at
Village Bhingar, Taluka Ahmednagar, District Ahmednagar, being in two
portions admeasuring 4 Hectare 80 Ares and 1 Hectare 61 Ares, purchased
by the Sale Deeds Nos.2459 of 2021 and 2764 of 2021 registered on 31 st
Gaikwad RD
3 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
March 2021 and 4th May 2021 respectively, with the office of SubRegistrar, Ahmednagar-2.
2.
Heard the learned Senior Counsel for the Applicants and the
learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent No.1 (original Appellant/
Plaintiff).
a)
It is submitted by learned senior counsel for the Applicants that,
against the said order dated 5th February 2025, the Applicants had
approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in SLP (Civil) Diary
No.22947 of 2025 and the said SLP was withdrawn by the Applicants with
liberty to move this Court seeking modification of the said order. This
application for modification of the order is made on two grounds: change
in circumstances and undue hardship. The provisions of Rule 4 of Order
XXXIX of CPC provides for modification of the order on the said grounds.
The Applicants had purchased the suit property, as it was the freehold
property. Before purchasing the suit property, due care and caution was
taken by the Applicants. The search of title was made and reports were
sought as to whether there was encumbrance on the suit property and
after ascertaining that, there was no charge on the suit property, the same
was purchased. The civil suit for recovery filed by the Respondent No. 1
was for Rs.3,86,00,000/-. The Applicants raised loan from the bank by
mortgaging the suit property. The bank has sought the copy of the said
Gaikwad RD
4 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
order of injunction passed by this Court. The Applicants made available
the copy of the order of this Court to the bank. The bank have asked for
mortgaging another property against the loan which the Applicant had
taken. Whatever property is with the original Defendants against whom
the suit is filed, was sufficient to protect the interest of Respondent No.1.
The Respondent No.1 was sufficiently protected by virtue of the injunction
order granted against the other Respondents/ original Defendants. The
copy of the Valuation Certificate shows that, the other part of the suit
property, which was with the other Defendants was valued for more than
Rs.Six (6) Crores, which was much higher than the amount of recovery for
which the civil suit was filed. The Applicants were subsequently added in
the first appeal.
The Applicants, after purchasing the suit property,
converted the same into plots and have entered into agreements with
various persons to sell the plots.
Due to the injunction order, the
Applicants were not able to sell the property and are unable to repay the
loan of the bank. The bank will proceed with the Applicants, which will
cause undue hardship to the Applicants. The injunction was an excess
injunction against the claim of the Respondent No.1. After the injunction
order, the Applicants received the notice from the bank and this was the
change in circumstance. The bank is likely to file the proceedings against
the Applicants for recovery of the loan. Even if the injunction is granted
Gaikwad RD
5 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
after hearing the Applicants, under the changed circumstance and due to
undue hardship, the application is filed under the said provision of CPC.
The civil suit filed by Respondent No.1 came to be dismissed and the
injunction is granted in the first appeal. The Civil Court recorded the
findings that nothing was proved.
Considering the change in
circumstances and undue hardship, the application be allowed as
everything has come to a standstill and the Applicants were unable to
develop the property due to the injunction order.
b)
It is submitted by the learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent
No.1 that, the order passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the
aforesaid SLP, which was filed by the Applicants shows that, the matter
was argued at length and thereafter permission was sought to withdraw
the SLP with liberty to file the application for modification before this
Court. This itself shows that, when the Applicants found that it was not
possible to succeed, the said liberty was sought. After the dismissal of the
SLP, the Applicants procured the letter dated 7th November 2025 from the
bank and filed this application. The Applicants had agitated before this
Court that, they had taken loan from the bank, and this Court was aware
of the same when the order sought to be modified was passed. There was
no change in the circumstances. What the provisions of Order XXXIX
requires is a substantial change and not a cosmetic change. The same
Gaikwad RD
6 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
thing is being agitated, which was agitated before this Court when the
order was passed. Paragraph 8 of the order shows that, the Applicants
had filed their detailed reply to the application for injunction and this
Court perused the said Affidavit-in-Reply and after hearing both the sides
passed the order granting injunction. Everything was argued before this
Court, which is now being argued.
The order, which is sought to be
modified, shows that the suit property was purchased by the Applicants,
when there was injunction granted by the learned Trial Court. Despite the
injunction order not to create third-party interest, the other Defendants
sold major portion of the suit land to the Applicants. Since the transaction
took place, when injunction order was in operation, the sale deed would
necessarily be invalid. Not only this, there is separate order passed against
the other Respondents/Defendants. When the Respondent No.1 came to
know that, the suit property was sold during operation of the injunction,
the Applicants came to be added as parties to the appeal. This Application
is in the form of review. The provisions of Order XXXIX Rule 4 shows that,
the application can be considered only on two grounds: i) if there is a
misleading statement and ii) there is change in circumstance. In every
injunction, there is hardship to the party against whom the order is
passed.
However, it is required to be established that the injunction,
which is granted causes undue hardship. There was no case of undue
Gaikwad RD
7 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
hardship to the Applicants and none of the grounds in the application
satisfies the provisions of Order XXXIX Rule 4 of CPC. As the points,
which are agitated in the application, were already agitated before this
Court and this Court by hearing both the sides have passed the order,
which is sought to be modified, the Application is liable to be dismissed.
In case the order is modified, nothing would remain in the matter. As far
as the aspect of valuation of the property is concerned, this Court already
taken care in the earlier order.
3.
The Applicants are the Respondent Nos. 6 and 7 in the first appeal.
The Respondent No.1 in the application is the Appellant and original
Plaintiff. The brief factual aspects of the matter as incorporated in the
order dated 5th February 2025 passed in Civil Application No. 11824 of
2024 in the First Appeal are reproduced below for reference:
“5.
The special suit (116 of 2002) was filed by “Excellent
Constructions Pvt. Ltd.”, a company registered under the Companies
Act, against Respondent Nos. 1 to 5 herein. It is a suit for recovery
of a sum, little over Rs.43 crores with a further prayer for realisation
of the said amount by sale of the agricultural lands, Gut Nos. 326/1
and 327, mortgaged by the original defendants in favour of the
plaintiff – company for securing a loan of Rs.3 crores raised from
IndusInd Bank. The record indicates the person, who operate or run
the business of the plaintiff – company, was based in foreign country
(Spain). The original defendants / Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 made a
Gaikwad RD
8 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
default in repayment of the loan. The plaintiff – company came with
a case to have repaid the entire loan amount. According to the
company, an agreement dated 02nd May, 1997 was entered into
between the plaintiff – company and the original defendants. It was
agreed that the defendants would pay the plaintiff – company
interest @ 18% p.a. for initial period and thereafter 2.5% p.m.
besides funding charges @ 3% p.m. The transaction took place way
back in 1997. According to the plaintiff – company, since the
amount was not paid, it swelled equal to the amount claimed in the
suit.
6.
Pending the suit, there was injunction order restraining the
original defendants from creating third party interest in respect of
the lands (Gut Nos. 326/1 and 327) (suit lands). Inspite of the
same, the defendants sold major portion of the suit lands to
Respondent Nos.6 to 8 herein. Since the transaction took place
when the injunction order was in operation, the sale-deed would
necessarily be invalid. However, the suit was dismissed on merits.
Meaning thereby, the injunction that was operating, stood vacated.
7.
Against the judgment and decree dismissing the plaintiff’s
suit, the first appeal, wherein the present application has been
moved, came to be filed. We have admitted the appeal. Needless to
mention, the appeal is continuation of the original suit. The sale
transactions that took place were first invalid in view of there being
injunction order and would also be subject to the principle of lis
pendens.”
4.
The Appellant filed the aforesaid Civil Application No. 11824 of
2024 with the following prayers :
Gaikwad RD
9 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
“(b) To grant mandatory / permanent injunction restraining
Respondent Nos. 6 to 9 from creating third party rights or interests
in the land lying and situate at Gut No. 327 at Village Bhingar, Tal.
Nagar, Dist. Ahmednagar being two portions of land admeasuring 4
hector 80 ares and 1 hector 61 ares purchased in view of the Sale
Deeds bearing Nos. 2459/2021 and 2764/2021 registered on
31.03.2021 and 04.05.2021 with the office of Sub-Registrar,
Ahmednagar-2;
(b)-1 Pending hearing and final disposal of the above Appeal, by an
order and/or direction restrain/injunct Respondent No.6 to 9 from
creating third party rights or interests in the land lying and situate
at Gut No. 327 at Village Bhingar, Tal. Nagar, Dist. Ahmednagar
being two portions of land admeasuring 4 hector 80 ares and 1
hector 61 ares purchased in view of the Sale Deeds bearing Nos.
2459/2021
and
2764/2021
registered
on
31.03.2021
and
04.05.2021 with the office of Sub-Registrar, Ahmednagar- 2;”
5.
The present Applicants have filed their detailed say to the said
application. After hearing the parties, Application No.11824 of 2024 came
to be allowed in terms of prayer clause (b)-1.
6.
The Applicants have invoked the provisions of Order XXXIX Rule 4
of the CPC. The said provision reads as under :
"Order XXXIX : — Temporary Injunctions and Interlocutory
Orders :
1)....
2)....
3)....
4) Order for injunction may be discharged, varied or set
aside : Any order for an injunction may be discharged, or
Gaikwad RD
10 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
varied, or set aside by the Court, on application made thereto
by any party dissatisfied with such order:
Provided that if in an application for temporary injunction,
or in any affidavit supporting such application, a party has
knowingly made a false or misleading statement in relation
to a material particular and the injunction was granted
without giving notice to the opposite party, the Court shall
vacate the injunction unless, for reasons to be recorded, it
considers that it is not necessary so to do in the interests of
justice:
Provided further that where an order for an injunction has
been passed after giving to a party an opportunity of being
heard, the order shall not be discharged, varied or set aside
on the application of that party except where such discharge,
variation or setting aside has been necessitated by a change
in the circumstances, or unless the Court is satisfied that the
order has caused undue hardship to that party."
7.
The Applicants have prayed for discharge of the said order granting
injunction on the ground of change in circumstances and undue hardship.
The learned counsel for the Applicants tendered the copies of the
communication dated 7th November 2025 written by the bank/cooperative society, communication dated 11th November 2025 written by
the Applicants to the bank/co-operative society and communication dated
19th November 2025 written by the bank/co-operative society to the
Applicants. By the communication dated 7th November 2025, the bank/cooperative society asked the Applicants to provide a copy of the order of
this Court granting injunction. The communication dated 11 th November
2025 is the response by the Applicants to the said letter dated 7 th
November 2025, providing the copy of the order dated 5 th February 2025
Gaikwad RD
11 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
and informing the order of injunction in respect of the suit property Gat
No.327.
By communication dated 19 th November 2025, the bank/co-
operative society asked the Applicants to mortgage another property
against the loan and to repay the loan within a period of two months.
8.
On going through the said communications, they are in respect of
the order passed by this court and in respect of repayment of loan by the
Applicants to the Bank/co-operative society. Another document, i.e., the
valuation report of the suit property.
They cannot be termed as the
change in circumstances, so as to modify the injunction order. The reply,
which was filed by the Applicants to the Civil Application No.11824 of
2024 shows that, the contentions which are raised by the learned Senior
Counsel in support of the present application were agitated before this
Court. The reply shows that, the Applicants had pleaded that, the interest
of the Appellant was sufficiently secured by the unsold property, the
development of the subject property such as construction of concrete
roads, gutters, etc. and recording of charge by the bank/society by way of
mortgage before the date of dismissal of the suit. Paragraph 9 of the order
sought to be modified or varied shows that, this Court considered the
submissions advanced, perused the pleadings and the evidence adduced in
the suit and for the reasons recorded, allowed the application. Further, it
is not the case that only because this Court passed the injunction order in
Gaikwad RD
12 of 13
901-CA-14026-2025-J.doc
the matter, the Bank/Co-operative Society raised the demand to repay the
loan. Repayment of loan in any case is the condition precedent before
advancing the loan. Thus, the ground of undue hardship has no legs to
stand. In this view of the matter, in our considered view, no case is made
out to exercise the power under Rule 4 of Order XXXIX of the CPC and
hence the Application is dismissed.
[NEERAJ P. DHOTE, J.]
Gaikwad RD
[KISHORE C. SANT, J.]
13 of 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review