The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. The medical prescription dated 16 July 2026 records an HbA1c value of 11.3 and prescribes insulin. It supports the submission that the -8- applicant requires regular diabetic care, although the material does not establish that treatment cannot be provided in custody. The medical condition is consequently an additional consideration and is not the sole basis for release. As regards the challenge concerning the period preceding formal arrest, the initial remand order records that the objection was raised and considered. Since the applicant is entitled to regular bail on the grounds discussed above, no determination of the legality of that detention is necessary for the present decision. That contention is left open.
13. The learned Special Judge placed considerable emphasis on the applicant being a police constable, the gravity of corruption and the possibility of interference while investigation was pending. Those concerns are relevant, but must be weighed with the steps already completed and the possibility of protecting the investigation through conditions. On an overall consideration, further detention is not necessary for that purpose. The applicant can be released on regular bail with conditions directed specifically at securing his attendance and preventing access to the witnesses and the records. Hence, the following order. (i) Bail Application No.2073 of 2026 is allowed. (ii) The applicant, Vinod Shivaji Masalkar, shall be released on bail in connection with Crime No.1152 of 2026 registered with Pathardi Police -9- Station, District Ahilyanagar, for the offence punishable under Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, on furnishing a personal bond of Rs.50,000/- with one or two solvent sureties in the like amount, to the satisfaction of the Special Court, unless his custody is required in any other case. (iii) The applicant shall attend the office of the Anti-Corruption Bureau, Ahilyanagar, on the first and third Monday of every month between 10.00 a.m. and 12.00 noon for three months or until filing of the charge-sheet, whichever is earlier, and thereafter as and when cal…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:55057
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
BAIL APPLICATION NO.2073 OF 2026
Vinod Shivaji Masalkar
Versus
... Applicant
The State of Maharashtra
... Respondent
…..
Shri N. B. Narwade, Advocate for the Applicant
Shri. V. S. Bade, Advocate for Assist to P.P.
Shri. V. K. Kotecha, APP for the Respondent / State.
….
CORAM : HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.
DATED : 03.11.2026
PER COURT :
1.
The applicant seeks regular bail under Section 483 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, in connection with Crime No.1152 of
2026 registered with Pathardi Police Station, District Ahilyanagar, for the
offence punishable under Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988. He was formally arrested on 20 th September 2026 and is in judicial
custody since 21st September 2026. His application for bail was rejected
by the learned Special Judge (ACB), Ahmednagar, on 30 th September
2026.
2.
The prosecution states that the applicant was serving as a Police
Constable at Pathardi Police Station. Tuship Nizam Shaikh alias Kalya
runs Unique Hotel and Restaurant, where Pratap Salunke alias Bhavdya
worked as a part-time helper. On 14 th September 2026, an incident
involving Pratap, his younger brother and a truck driver led to an assault
in which injuries were sustained. According to the prosecution, on
-2-
th
17 September 2026 the applicant told Shaikh that a serious offence of
attempt to murder and robbery would be registered against the persons
involved and that Shaikh could also be implicated. The applicant
allegedly demanded Rs.5,00,000/-, referring to his superior officer, for
securing registration of a lesser offence, keeping Shaikh's name out of the
case and helping in the investigation. The proposed favour concerned
Pratap and Arbaz Pathan. The demand was allegedly reduced to
Rs.2,15,000/-.
3.
The prosecution further states that the Anti-Corruption Bureau was
initially contacted through Babasaheb Vitthal Ghule, who thereafter
introduced Shaikh as the person having the complaint. The proposed
action on 18th September 2026 did not materialise. On 19th September
2026, Shaikh, Pratap and a panch witness were sent to meet the
applicant with a voice recorder. The prosecution claims that the demand
was verified during this meeting. A trap was thereafter arranged with
Rs.1,00,000/- in currency notes treated with anthracene powder. Near
the water tank adjoining Pathardi Police Station, the applicant allegedly
accepted the amount while seated in Shaikh's vehicle. On the
prearranged signal, the raiding party apprehended him and recovered the
currency lying on his lap. The FIR was lodged by the Deputy
Superintendent of Police of the Anti-Corruption Bureau on 20th
September 2026.
-3-
4.
Learned Advocate for the applicant submits that the prosecution
has arisen from the grudge entertained by Babasaheb Ghule, against
whom the applicant had lodged Crime No.750 of 2026 under the
Maharashtra Prohibition Act on 18th June 2026. He relies upon that FIR
and the earlier corruption complaint in Crime No.416 of 2025 to question
Ghule's role in bringing about the present trap. He submits that Shaikh
was interested in protecting his employees and avoiding his own
implication. According to him, the amounts in the recorded conversation
were spoken by Shaikh, while the words attributed to the applicant were
ambiguous and did not disclose a clear demand. He also points out that
the applicant did not call Shaikh on 18 September 2026 and that the
money was found on his lap inside Shaikh's vehicle, rather than
recovered from his hand or pocket. He submits that conscious acceptance
is disputed and that the possibility of the money having been placed upon
the applicant requires consideration.
5.
Learned Advocate for the applicant further submits that the
applicant was only a Constable and was not empowered to decide which
offences should be registered. He points to the interval between the
applicant being taken into custody at 4.04 p.m. on 19 September 2026,
registration of the FIR at 8.59 a.m. on the following day and formal arrest
at 10.08 a.m. He submits that the police custody granted has been
utilised, the voice samples have been obtained, the mobile phone has
-4-
been seized and the applicant has been questioned about his assets. The
remaining investigation does not require his detention. He also relies
upon the medical papers concerning diabetes and insulin treatment, the
absence of criminal antecedents, the applicant's fixed residence and his
willingness to cooperate and accept restrictions against contacting
witnesses.
6.
Learned APP opposes the application on the grounds reflected in
the prosecution's written objections and the submissions recorded by the
Special Court. The prosecution relies upon verification of the demand,
the panch witness, the recorded conversation and recovery of
Rs.1,00,000/- during the trap. It contends that, the applicant misused his
position as a Police Constable to seek money for shielding persons
involved in a serious crime and invoked the name of his superior officer.
The investigation is pending and the Charge-sheet had not been filed
when the application was presented. The prosecution apprehends that
the applicant will use his local contacts and police position to pressurise
Shaikh and other witnesses, destroy evidence and obstruct the
investigation. It also raises an apprehension about his attendance at trial
and submits that release would send a wrong message to society.
7.
I have considered the rival contentions and the material placed on
record. The accusation is serious. It concerns an alleged attempt by a
police constable to obtain money in return for influencing the manner in
which a criminal case would be registered and investigated. The
-5-
prosecution has placed reliance on a verification exercise, a recorded
conversation, a panch witness and recovery of the treated currency.
These circumstances provide prima facie support for the accusation and
cannot be disregarded merely because the applicant disputes the meaning
of the conversation or the manner in which the money came to be on his
lap. At the same time, their ultimate evidentiary value and the defence of
false implication must be examined at trial.
8.
The submission that the applicant was not competent to select the
penal provisions does not, by itself, exclude Section 7. The provision
extends to obtaining or accepting an undue advantage for causing
another public servant to perform or forbear a public duty improperly,
and its explanation covers abuse of position or personal influence over
another public servant. The allegation must therefore be considered in its
entirety. Likewise, the earlier FIR against Ghule establishes the
background on which the plea of animosity rests, but neither that FIR nor
his earlier corruption complaint establishes that this trap was fabricated.
His role, Shaikh's interest in the underlying case and the disputed
conversation are matters for evidence. It is unnecessary to accept those
defences as proved in order to consider whether further custody is
required.
9.
On
that
question,
the
prosecution's
own
reply
dated
30th
September 2026 is material. It records that the applicant was
-6-
interrogated, that his voice sample and those of the complainant and a
witness were obtained before panchas, that a detailed panchanama
concerning the seized mobile phone was prepared and that the
applicant's statement regarding his property was recorded. The currency
had already been recovered. The order dated 21 st September 2026 further
records that the investigating officer herself sought judicial custody. Thus,
the material directly arising from the alleged trap has been secured and
the steps requiring the applicant's immediate custodial participation have
substantially been undertaken. This does not mean that the investigation
is complete or that the charge-sheet has been filed. It does, however,
require the Court to examine what further detention would achieve. The
pending examination of witnesses and collection or scrutiny of records
can proceed with the applicant on bail, subject to his continued
cooperation and effective restrictions.
10.
The apprehension of interference deserves particular attention
because the applicant belongs to the police force and the complainant
and other private witnesses are local persons. It would not be correct to
say that all the material witnesses are official witnesses or are beyond his
influence. Nevertheless, the objections placed on record do not identify
any attempt by him to threaten a witness or interfere with the evidence
after
the
trap.
The
investigation
is
being
conducted
by
the
Anti-Corruption Bureau, and the seized currency, recordings and mobile
phone are in the investigating agency's custody. A prohibition against
-7-
contacting the witnesses or entering Pathardi Taluka for a limited period,
coupled with attendance before the Anti-Corruption Bureau, will
sufficiently address the apprehension at this stage. Applicant’s fixed
residence and absence of criminal antecedents, also recorded by the
Special Court, support the conclusion that attendance can be secured by
appropriate conditions.
11.
In Mahesh Chandra Joshi v. State of Rajasthan, 2026 INSC 1141,
decided on 16th October 2026, the Supreme Court reiterated that gravity
cannot eclipse the other considerations governing bail and considered
whether secured evidence and suitable conditions made further detention
unnecessary. That decision involved completed investigation, longer
custody and other circumstances which are not present here in the same
form. The present application is therefore being decided on its own facts,
particularly the steps already recorded by the investigating officer and
the means available to protect the pending investigation. The offence
under Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act carries imprisonment
of three to seven years and fine. The Act does not prescribe a separate
restrictive test for regular bail in this case. The seriousness of police
corruption requires careful scrutiny, but does not create an absolute bar
to bail or justify detention merely to express society's disapproval.
12.
The medical prescription dated 16 July 2026 records an HbA1c
value of 11.3 and prescribes insulin. It supports the submission that the
-8-
applicant requires regular diabetic care, although the material does not
establish that treatment cannot be provided in custody. The medical
condition is consequently an additional consideration and is not the sole
basis for release. As regards the challenge concerning the period
preceding formal arrest, the initial remand order records that the
objection was raised and considered. Since the applicant is entitled to
regular bail on the grounds discussed above, no determination of the
legality of that detention is necessary for the present decision. That
contention is left open.
13.
The learned Special Judge placed considerable emphasis on the
applicant being a police constable, the gravity of corruption and the
possibility of interference while investigation was pending. Those
concerns are relevant, but must be weighed with the steps already
completed and the possibility of protecting the investigation through
conditions. On an overall consideration, further detention is not
necessary for that purpose. The applicant can be released on regular bail
with conditions directed specifically at securing his attendance and
preventing access to the witnesses and the records. Hence, the following
order.
ORDER
(i)
Bail Application No.2073 of 2026 is allowed.
(ii)
The applicant, Vinod Shivaji Masalkar, shall be released on bail in
connection with Crime No.1152 of 2026 registered with Pathardi Police
-9-
Station, District Ahilyanagar, for the offence punishable under Section 7
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, on furnishing a personal bond
of Rs.50,000/- with one or two solvent sureties in the like amount, to the
satisfaction of the Special Court, unless his custody is required in any
other case.
(iii)
The applicant shall attend the office of the Anti-Corruption Bureau,
Ahilyanagar, on the first and third Monday of every month between 10.00
a.m. and 12.00 noon for three months or until filing of the charge-sheet,
whichever is earlier, and thereafter as and when called upon by written
notice. He shall cooperate with the investigation.
(iv)
Until framing of the charge, the applicant shall not enter Pathardi
Taluka, except to attend court and attend the Police station for
attendance. He shall not access or cause alteration of any official record
connected with the case.
(v)
The applicant shall not directly or indirectly contact, threaten,
induce or pressurise the complainant, Babasaheb Ghule, Pratap Salunke,
Arbaz Pathan, the panch witnesses or any other prosecution witness
concerning the case. He shall not tamper with the prosecution evidence
or use his official position or any intermediary to obstruct the
investigation or trial.
(vi)
Before release, the applicant shall furnish his residential address
and mobile number to the investigating officer and the Special Court and
shall intimate any change in writing. He shall not leave India without
prior permission of the Special Court and shall attend the trial regularly
unless exempted by that Court.
(vii) In the event of breach of any condition, the prosecution may seek
cancellation of bail in accordance with law.
-10-
(viii)
The observations in this order are confined to the decision on bail.
The Special Court shall decide the case on the evidence, uninfluenced by
these observations.
(ix)
The Bail Application is disposed of in above terms.
(HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR)
JUDGE
GGP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review