The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. The applicant is in custody since 12 th February, 2026. The charge- sheet has already been filed and his further custodial interrogation is not required. No recovery is to be effected from him. He has no criminal antecedents. The possibility of his absconding or interfering with the evidence can adequately be addressed by imposing appropriate conditions.
11. Thus, taking into consideration the seriousness of the charge and the material against the present applicant, I am inclined to allow the -7- present application. Hence, the following order: (i) The Bail Application is allowed. (ii) The applicant shall be released on bail in Crime No. 87 of 2026 registered with Ahilyanagar Taluka Police Station, Dist. Ahilyanagar, for the offences punishable under Sections 103(1), 189(2), 190, 191(2) and 191(3) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, on furnishing a personal bond of Rs. 50,000/(Rupees Fifty Thousand only) with one or two local solvent sureties in the like amount, subject to the following conditions: a) The applicant shall attend the concerned police station on the first Monday and the third Monday of every month between 10:00 a.m. and 02:00 p.m. till framing of charge and thereafter shall regularly attend each and every effective date before the trial court. b) The applicant shall not, directly or indirectly, contact, threaten, induce or influence the informant or any prosecution witness and shall not tamper with the prosecution evidence. c) The applicant shall furnish his current residential address and mobile number to the Investigating Officer and the Trial -8- Court within seven days of release, intimate any change forthwith, and attend the Investigating Officer upon prior written notice if further investigation is required. d…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:55039
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
942 BAIL APPLICATION NO. 2077 OF 2026
Javed Chotu Atar
Versus
The State of Maharashtra
….Applicant
…..Respondent
…..
Ms. Sakshi Dushing h/f. Shri. S. B. Dushing, Advocate for Applicant
Shri. S. V. Hange, APP for Respondent – State.
…..
CORAM : HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.
DATED : 04.11.2026
PER COURT :
1.
The present application is filed by the applicant seeking regular
bail in connection with Crime No. 87 of 2026 registered with Ahilyanagar
Taluka Police Station, Dist. Ahilyanagar. The offences alleged against the
present applicant are mainly punishable under Section 103(1) of the
BNS. The applicant came to be arrested on 12 th February, 2026, and since
then, he has been in custody.
2.
The prosecution case, in brief, is that on 6 th March 2025, at about
9:00 a.m., the deceased Mitthu Datt, while under the influence of liquor
and armed with an iron hammer, went to Komal Farsan Mart Hotel, near
the VRDE gate, at Arangaon. He allegedly damaged the glass counter and
other articles in the hotel and threatened the persons present there. The
material collected during the investigation further shows that the
deceased assaulted one Dattatrey Garad and elderly customer who had
arrived there with his wife, by giving him a hammer blow on his head,
-2-
and also damaged his motorcycle. Thereafter, the deceased went towards
his fabrication shop. The women and workers of the hotel had already
engaged in an altercation. It is alleged that the deceased was caught,
brought down and assaulted by the accused persons. He sustained head
injuries and was initially admitted to Pacific Super Speciality Hospital at
Ahilyanagar. He was subsequently shifted to Sassoon General Hospital,
Pune, by his relatives, where he died during treatment on 23 rd March,
2025. The post-mortem report records the cause of death as
complications following head injury. Initially, the prosecution report
suggests that an accidental death bearing A.D. No. 39 of 2025 was
registered on 29th March 2025. The enquiry was subsequently transferred
to the Police Inspector, Supa Police Station. During the course of the
enquiry, two video clips recorded on a mobile phone were secured. On
the basis of the statements of the witnesses, the video clips and the
medical material, the present crime came to be registered on 11 th
February, 2026 against the owner of the hotel, present applicant and
three workers of the establishment.
3.
Learned Advocate for the applicant submitted that the occurrence
was neither premeditated nor the result of any previous enmity. The
deceased himself initiated the incident by damaging the property and
indiscriminately threatening and assaulting persons with the hammer.
The persons present there attempted to disarm and restrain him. It is
submitted that no weapon is attributed to the applicant and there is no
-3-
allegation that he delivered any blow on the head or any vital part of the
deceased. The role emerging from the video recording is that the
applicant and other workers brought the deceased down while the
hammer was being taken away from him.
4.
Attention was invited to the statement of Yogesh Shinde, the
brother-in-law of the deceased, according to whom the deceased slipped,
his foot got entangled near a tree enclosure, and he fell from a cement
slab covering the drain. It was further submitted that co-accused
Bhausaheb, the owner of the hotel, has already been released on bail.
The investigation is complete. Nothing remains to be recovered from the
applicant. He has no criminal antecedents and his further detention is not
necessary.
5.
Learned APP opposed the application and submitted that the live
video and the panchnama show the active participation of the applicant.
The applicant was wearing a green coloured T-shirt and along with
another worker, was seen bringing the deceased down. Thereafter, the
deceased was assaulted. Mr. Vinod Sonawane, who is an eyewitness and
who recorded the video of the entire incident, has stated that two or
three persons assaulted the deceased after he was brought down. The
medical material shows that the deceased sustained a serious head injury
and ultimately died as a consequence thereof. The learned APP, therefore,
submitted that the applicant was a member of the unlawful assembly and
-4-
having referred to Section 190 of the BNS, submits that the absence of an
individual overt act would not exonerate him. In addition to above, the
learned APP also submits that transcript of the video recording shows
that the present Applicant was holding some article in his hand and was
seen assaulting. The further recording suggests that the present applicant
handed over the weapon hammer to the other co-accused. The learned
APP thus tries to suggest that, the injuries caused on the face of the
Deceased are the injuries caused by the present Applicant with the aid of
hammer and hence, law of parity will not apply to the present applicant
with the other co-accused who are released on bail. He thus prays that
the Application be rejected.
6.
I have heard the learned Advocate for the Applicant and learned
APP for the State and have also gone through the entire investigation
material. The material at the present stage of bail is being considered for
a very limited purpose. Submission of the learned APP about assaulting
the deceased with the aid of hammer on the basis of transcript of the
video recording is a matter that will have to be ascertained at the time of
trial.
7.
Prima facie, the incident was not planned. The material collected
by the prosecution itself shows that the deceased arrived armed with a
hammer, damaged the furniture and has also threatened the persons
present, and inflicted a hammer blow on the head of an unrelated elderly
-5-
person. The accused persons thereafter followed the deceased and
attempted to take the hammer away from him. The video recording
attributes to the present applicant handing over hammer to Co-accused,
who is identified by the green shirt that he was wearing, the act of
joining another worker in bringing the deceased down is also one of the
circumstance that can be attributed to the present applicant.
8.
There are different versions concerning how the head injury was
sustained. The eye-witness Vinod Sonawane states that the deceased was
brought down and assaulted by two or three persons. On the other hand
Yogesh Shinde, who is related to the deceased and who claims to have
witnessed the occurrence, stated during the accidental death enquiry
that, while the hammer was being snatched, the deceased’s foot got
entangled near the tree enclosure and he fell on the cement slab covering
the drain. He thereafter stated that he had no complaint against anyone
concerning the death. The medical evidence establishes a serious head
injury and is causally connected with the death. However, whether that
injury was caused by a direct act of assault or by the deceased being
brought down, or by an accidental fall during the scuffle is a matter
which will have to be determined at the time of trial. A fall on a cement
surface would itself involve blunt force. At this stage, the medical
material does not attribute the fatal injury to any identified act of the
present applicant. Thus, the applicability of Section 190 of the BNS and
the existence and scope of the alleged common object will necessarily be
-6-
examined at the time of trial. Nevertheless, for the limited purpose of
bail, the circumstances preceding the occurrence and the absence of a
distinct fatal blow attributed to the present applicant are material
considerations which can be taken while deciding the application for bail.
9.
The Co-accused Bahusaheb Nangare who is the owner of the hotel
and the other co-accused Shivkumar Mahato who are also shown in the
video as having participated in the occurrence, have been released on bail
by the learned Sessions Court on 29 th May 2026. Though, parity cannot
be applied mechanically and the role of every accused has to be
separately examined, the release of the co-accused is however, a relevant
circumstance. Even on an independent assessment, the role attributed to
the present applicant does not justify his continued pre-trial detention
after completion of the investigation.
10.
The applicant is in custody since 12 th February, 2026. The charge-
sheet has already been filed and his further custodial interrogation is not
required. No recovery is to be effected from him. He has no criminal
antecedents. The possibility of his absconding or interfering with the
evidence can adequately be addressed by imposing appropriate
conditions.
11.
Thus, taking into consideration the seriousness of the charge and
the material against the present applicant, I am inclined to allow the
-7-
present application. Hence, the following order:
ORDER
(i)
The Bail Application is allowed.
(ii)
The applicant shall be released on bail in Crime No. 87 of 2026
registered with Ahilyanagar Taluka Police Station, Dist.
Ahilyanagar, for the offences punishable under Sections 103(1),
189(2), 190, 191(2) and 191(3) of the Bharatiya Nyaya
Sanhita, 2023, on furnishing a personal bond of Rs. 50,000/(Rupees Fifty Thousand only) with one or two local solvent
sureties in the like amount, subject to the following conditions:
a)
The applicant shall attend the concerned police station on
the first Monday and the third Monday of every month between
10:00 a.m. and 02:00 p.m. till framing of charge and thereafter
shall regularly attend each and every effective date before the
trial court.
b)
The applicant shall not, directly or indirectly, contact,
threaten, induce or influence the informant or any prosecution
witness and shall not tamper with the prosecution evidence.
c) The applicant shall furnish his current residential address
and mobile number to the Investigating Officer and the Trial
-8-
Court within seven days of release, intimate any change
forthwith, and attend the Investigating Officer upon prior
written notice if further investigation is required.
d) The applicant shall not leave the State of Maharashtra
without prior permission of the trial Court and if he possesses
passport, shall deposit the same with the trial Court within
seven days of his release.
e) The applicant shall not involve himself in any offence of a
similar nature while on bail.
f)
Breach of any of the above conditions shall entitle the
prosecution to apply for cancellation of bail.
g)
All observations in this order are prima facie and confined
to the decision of this bail application. The trial Court shall
decide the case independently on the evidence led before it.
(iii)
The Bail Application is disposed of in the above terms.
(HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR)
JUDGE
GGP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review