Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
#
$$
%
&
#'
(
!
"
"
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
$ %
#
$
"
&
'"
"
#
#
$
#
(
!
"%
%
"
&
-2-
)
'
)
)
#
" ("
'
%
" *
"
(
#
#
"' "
"
#
#
"
(
!# "
%
#
%
+
%
" "
"&
%
"
#%)
)
%
)
%
% "#
#
)#
$
"
,-. ./0123 455/46 -. 57/8/77/3 9: ;,/ 3/8/2342;
0,466/2<-2< ;,/ =>3<?/2; 423 3/07// 34;/3
" ("
-2
6423 A817 97/@-;:
" " 1" *
B;,/ )-7.;
173/7
* 9:
55/664;/
34;/3
-@-6 #>3</
B;,/ 7-46
1>7;CD"
"
-@-6 #>3</
54../3
1>7;CD E,-0, 7/@/7./3 ;,/ =>3<?/2; 423
"' "
33-;-1246
/2-17
'
(
54../3
-2
" " 1"
!#7" 2"& 423 #%)
9:
6423 A817 97/@-;:
,/ 04./ 18 ;,/ 564-2;-88. -. ;,4; ;,/: 47/ ;,/ 1E2/7.
-2 51../..-12 18 6423 9/47-2<
:" 1"(
?/4.>7-2<
407/. 'F
<>2;4. 423 ;,/ E/66 -2 ;,/ .4-3 6423 .-;>4;/3 -2 -2<43466- @-664</
A,/7/-248;/7 ?/2;-12/3 4. G;,/ .>-; E/66HD"
47-=42 423
2/
//7>
4I.,>
434554 ;,/ 84;,/7 18 564-2;-88. 47/ 971;,/7. 423 -2
-3-
;,/ :/47 '*F
423 42 1746 547;-;-12 ;11I 5640/ 9/;E//2 ;,/ .4-3
971;,/7. 423 -2 ;,/ .4-3 547;-;-12 4 6423 9/47-2<
?/4.>7-2<
:" 1"(
407/. E,-0, -. .-;>4;/3 12 ;,/ 217;,/72 .-3/ 18 ;,/
6423 9/47-2<
:" 1"(
;,/ 6423 9/47-2<
,43 8466/2 ;1 ;,/ .,47/ 18
:" 1"(
8466/2 ;1 ;,/ .,47/ 18 ;,/
//7> 423
?/4.>7-2<
407/. 'F <>2;4. ,43
4334554"
>9./J>/2;6: ;,/ .4-3
4334554 ,43 3>< 4 E/66 -2 ;,/ 6423 8466/2 ;1 ,-. .,47/"
1E/@/7
;,/ .4-3
,-@46-2<4554
34;/3 ' "
4.4554
"'*(
466 ?/2;-12/3"
122/ .163
7/<-.;/7/3
//7> ,43 .163 ,-. /2;-7/ 6423 ;1 12/
122/ >23/7 4 7/<-.;/7/3
46/
//3
-2 E,-0, ;,/ 3/.07-5;-12 18 E/66 E4. 21; 4;
12/;,/6/..
;,/ .12. 18 .4-3
,-@46-2<4554
407/. 18 6423 ;1 ;,/ 57/./2; 3/8/2342; >23/7 ;,/
46/
//3 34;/3
"
"'**
012@/:-2< -66/<466: ;,/
7-<,; 18 >./ 18 ;,/ E/66 E4;/7 ;1 ;,/ /K;/2; 18
.,47/ ;1 ;,/ 3/8/2342;"
18 ;,/-7
>9./J>/2;6: ;,/ 3/8/2342; -2.;466/3
5>?5 ./;. ;1 ;,/ .>-; E/66 423 64-3 5-5/6-2/. 817 >./ 18 ;,/
E4;/7"
,/2 ;,/ 564-2;-88. 7/J>/.;/3 ;,/ 3/8/2342; ;1 7/?1@/
,-. " " ./; 871? ;,/ .>-; E/66 ;,/ .4-3 7/J>/.; E4. 21; 400/3/3
;1"
/20/ ;,/ 564-2;-88. E/7/ 012.;74-2/3 ;1 8-6/ ;,/ .>-;"
-4-
"
,-.
E7-;;/2
466/<4;-12."
2 -..>420/ 18 .>-; .>??12. ;,/ 3/8/2342; 8-6/3
.;4;/?/2;
.5/0-8-0466:
/ 012;/23/3 ;,4; -; E4.
3/2:-2<
;,/
564-2;
//74554 564-2;-88C. >206/
E,1 ,43 3>< ;,/ E/66 -2 ,-. 6423 423 3/8/2342; 3//5/2/3 ;,/
E/66 423 -2.;466/3
" " ./; ;1 ;,/ .>-; E/66"
; E4. 8>7;,/7
012;/23/3 ;,4; 564-2;-88. E/7/ 7/.-3-2< 4612< E-;, ;,/-7 84;,/7 4;
%>?94- 423 ;,/: 2/@/7 04?/ 1@/7 ;1 ;,/-7 @-664</"
;,/ 3/8/2342;
% !$
&
00173-2< ;1
,/ ,43 19;4-2/3 /6/0;7-0-;: 0122/0;-12 871?
6423 -2 ;,/ :/47 '** 423 -2.;466/3
./; ;1 ;,/ E/66 423 64-3 31E2 '
5>?5
8;" 5-5/6-2/ 871? ;,/ E/66 ;1
,-. 6423 4. .,1E2 -2 ;,/ ,423 .I/;0, ?45 422/K/3 ;1 ;,/
E7-;;/2 .;4;/?/2; 4. .>0, ;,/ 3/8/2342; -. -77-<4;-2< ,-. 6423
.-20/ '**F"
"
; -. 8>7;,/7 012;/23/3 ;,4; -2 7/.5/0; 18 ;,/ 6423 -2
E,-0, ;,/ .>-; E/66 -. .-;>4;/3 ,-..4 5,13- ,4. 9//2 ?43/ 423
)17?
1"'
E4. 57/547/3 400173-2< ;1 E,-0,
<>2;4. 18 6423
-. .,1E2 ./5474;/6: -2 E,-0, ;,/ .>-; E/66 E4. .,1E2 9/-2<
01??126: >./3 9: 91;, 3/8/2342; 423 564-2;-88."
/ 46.1
?/2;-12/3 ;,4; ;,/ ?1;,/7 18 ;,/ 564-2;-88. ,43 .-<2/3 12
,-..4 5,13- 5710//3-2<."
/ 012;/23/3 ;,4; -2 ;,/ :/47 '**
-5-
;,/ .-6; 871? ;,/ E/66 ,4. 9//2 7/?1@/3 4; ;,/ 01??12
/K5/2./. 9: 564-2;-88. 423 3/8/2342; 423 57-17 ;1 ;,/ 8-6-2< 18
.>-; 120/ 4<4-2 ;,/ .-6; 871? ;,/ E/66 ,4. 9//2 7/?1@/3 4; ;,/
=1-2; /K5/2./. 9: ;,/ 564-2;-88. 423 3/8/2342;"
,4. 46.1 012;/23/3 ;,4;
,/ 3/8/2342;
>;46494- E,1 -. ;,/ ?1;,/7 18 ;,/
564-2;-88. E4. 2/0/..47: 547;: ;1 ;,/ .>-; 423 8>7;,/7 ;,/ .>-;
8-6/3 9: ;,/ 564-2;-88. -. ,-; 9: ;,/ 7-20-56/ 18 /.;155/6"
"
,/
7-46
1>7; 48;/7 /K4?-2-2< ;,/ /@-3/20/. 423
?4;/7-46. 12 7/0173 3-.?-../3 ;,/ .>-; 18 ;,/ 564-2;-88. 423 ;,/
)-7.;
55/664;/
3/07// 18 ;,/
1>7; 12 455/46 ./; 4.-3/ ;,/ =>3<?/2; 423
7-46
1>7; 423 ;,/7/9: 3/07//3 ;,/ .>-;"
,/
3/8/2342; 9/-2< 4<<7-/@/3 9: ;,/ .4?/ 57/8/77/3 ;,-. ./0123
455/46"
F"
/473
;,/
6/472/3
01>2./6
;,/
455/6642;. 3/8/2342;. 423 7/.5123/2; 564-2;-88"
("
; -. 012;/23/3 9: ;,/ 6/472/3 01>2./6 817 ;,/
455/6642; ;,4; ;,/ )-7.;
54..-2<
;,/
55/664;/
=>3<?/2;
9:
1>7; ,4@/ <71..6: /77/3 E,-6/
3/07//-2<
;,/
.>-;
E-;,1>;
4557/0-4;-2< ;,/ /@-3/20/. 423 310>?/2;. 12 7/0173 -2 4 7-<,;
-6-
5/7.5/0;-@/"
00173-2< ;1 ,-? 564-2;-88. ,4@/ 21; 5713>0/3 42:
310>?/2;47: /@-3/20/ ;1 /.;496-., ;,/-7 ;-;6/ 1@/7 .>-; E/66"
.5/0-8-0466: 012;/23/3 ;,4; ;,/ 8-7.; 455/664;/
/
1>7; ,4. 84-6/3
;1 4557/0-4;/ ;,/ 3/8/2342;C. 012;/2;-12 ;,4; ;,/ .>-; 18 ;,/
564-2;-88. -. 21; ?4-2;4-2496/ 4. ;,/: ,4@/ 21; 0,466/2</3 ;,/
46/
//3 34;/3
"
"'**
400173-2< ;1 E,-0,
,4. <1; 7-<,; 1@/7 ;,/ .>-; E/66"
)-7.;
55/664;/
3/8/2342;
/ 8>7;,/7 012;/23/3 ;,4; ;,/
1>7; 84-6/3 ;1 012.-3/7 ;,4; ;,/ 3/8/2342; -.
>.-2< ;,/ .>-; E/66 9: -2.;466-2<
/6/0;7-0-;: 0122/0;-12 871?
"
5>?5 ./;. 423 19;4-2/3
% .-20/ 871? ;,/ 34;/ 18
46/
//3 E-;,1>; 19.;7>0;-12 871? 42:913:" 2 .>0, 0-70>?.;420/.
;,/ .>-; 8-6/3 9: ;,/ 564-2;-88 -. 21; ?4-2;4-2496/ 423 400173-2<6:
574:. ;1 4661E ;,/ 455/46 423 3-.?-.. ;,/ .>-; 8-6/3 9: ;,/
564-2;-88"
"
6/472/3 01>2./6 817 ;,/ 7/.5123/2;
.>9?-;;/3 ;,4; ;,/ )-7.;
.>-;"
55/664;/
1>7; ,4. 7-<,;6: 3/07//3 ;,/
/ .>9?-;;/3 ;,4; ;,/ .46/ 3//3 /K/0>;/3 -2 84@1>7 18 ;,/
3/8/2342; -. 2>66 423 @1-3 4. ;,/ @/2317. -2 ;,/ 466/</3 3//3
,43 21 7-<,;
;-;6/ 423 -2;/7/.; 1@/7 ;,/ .>-; E/66 ,/20/
;742.8/7 9: 4 5/7.12 E-;,1>; ;-;6/ </2/7466: 07/4;/. 21 @46-3
-7-
1E2/7.,-5 ;1 ;,/ 9>:/7"
00173-2<6: ,/ 574:. ;1 3-.?-.. ;,/
455/46 57/8/77/3 9: ;,/ 3/8/2342;."
*"
,-.
1>7; 43?-;;/3 ;,/ 455/46 ;1 012.-3/7 ;,/
81661E-2< .>9.;42;-46 J>/.;-12. 18 64E
! " #
$% "
,
( # )*+
$
&'
,
' "
/473 ;,/ 6/472/3 01>2./6 455/6642; 3/8/2342; 423
7/.5123/2;. 564-2;-88. 423 5/7>./3 ;,/ ?4;/7-46. 12 7/0173"
''"
. 01>63 9/ <4;,/7/3 871? 7/0173.
;,/ 564-2;-88.
,4@/ 21; 5713>0/3 42: .4;-.840;17: 310>?/2;47: /@-3/20/ ;1
.>9.;42;-4;/ ;,/ 840; ;,4; ;,/: 47/ ;,/ 1E2/7. -2 51../..-12 18
.>-; E/66" )>7;,/7 ;,/ 7/0-;46 18 K" '* 3-.061./. ;,4; @/2317. 18
3/8/2342; ;742.8/77/3 7-<,; 18 .>-; E/66 E4;/7 ;1 ;,/ /K;/2; 18
1>; 18 ,468 .,47/ -2 ;,/ E/66 ;1 ;,/ 3/8/2342;" @/2 K" '(
7/0173 18 7-<,; 5713>0/3 9: ;,/ 564-2;-88. -2 7/.5/0; 18 6423
-8-
9/47-2<
:" 1"(
?/4.>7-2<
407/. 'F <>2;4. 3-.061./. ;,4;
;,/ 3/8/2342; ,4. <1; ,-. .,47/ -2 ;,/ E/66"
"' -2 ,-. 071..
/K4?-24;-12 ,4. .;4;/3 ;,4; ;,/ 3/8/2342; ,4. -2.;466/3 ;,/ " "
./; ;1 ;,/ .>-; E/66 9: 19;4-2-2< /6/0;7-0-;: .>556: 871?
%"
"
,4. 46.1 .;4;/3 -2 ,-. 071.. /K4?-24;-12 ;,4;
3/8/2342; ,4. -2.;466/3 " " ./; ;1 ;,/ .>-; E/66 423 64-3 31E2
'
8;" 5-5/6-2/ 871? ;,/ .>-; E/66" K"
0/7;-8-04;/ -..>/3 9:
% 3-.061./. ;,4; 3/8/2342; ,4. <1; /6/0;7-0-;: 0122/0;-12
;1 " " ./; .-20/ '** "
,>. -; -. 06/47 ;,4; ;,/ 3/8/2342; ,4.
9//2 >.-2< ;,/ .>-; E/66 .-20/ ;,/ 34;/ 18
46/
//3 -"/" '**
E,-0, ,4. 21; 9//2 0,466/2</3 9: ;,/ 564-2;-88." )>7;,/7 ;,/
/@-3/20/ 18
."' ;1
3-.061./. ;,4; ;,/ 3/8/2342; -. 6/<466: -2
>./ 423 /2=1:?/2; 18 .>-; E/66 9: -2.;466-2<
./; ;1 ;,/
.>-; E/66"
' "
2 5/7>.46 18 ;,/ /2;-7/ /@-3/20/ 12 7/0173 ;,/
564-2;-88. ,4@/ 21; 5640/3 42: .4;-.840;17: /@-3/20/ ;1 /.;496-.,
;,4; ;,/ .>-; E/66 E4. 3>< 9: ;,/ 84;,/7 18 564-2;-88
48;/7 547;-;-12 9/;E//2 ,-?./68 423
4334554
//7>" %17/1@/7
;,/
564-2;-88. ,4@/ 21; 5713>0/3 42: 310>?/2;47: /@-3/20/ ;1
/.;496-., ;,4; ;,/: 47/ ;,/ 1E2/7. -2 51../..-12 18 ;,/ .>-; E/66
-9-
4. 012;/23/3 9: ;,/?"
K"
-"/"
/0173. 18
?/4.>7-2<
K"
,/ 564-2;-88. ,4@/ ;1;466: 7/6-/3 12
-<,; 5/7;4-2-2< ;1 6423 9/47-2< (
407/. 'F <>2;4. ;1 /.;496-., ;,/-7 ;-;6/"
1E/@/7
06/476: 3-.061./. -2 1;,/7 7-<,;. 016>?2 ;,/ E173 GE/66H -.
455/47-2<"
3/8/2342;
/@/7;,/6/..
K" '* 423
;,/
310>?/2;.
K." '
5640/3
9:
;,/
;1 ( 06/476: 3/5-0; ;,/
/K-.;/20/ 18 ;,/ .>-; E/66 423 .,47-2< 18 ;,/ E4;/7 9/;E//2 ;,/
564-2;-88. 423 3/8/2342;"
. 3-.0>../3 .>574
K"
46.1 06/476:
7/@/46. ;,4; ;,/ 3/8/2342; ,4. -2.;466/3 5>?5 ./; 4. E/66 4.
% 0122/0;-12 ;1 ;,/ 5>?5 ./; ;,4; ;,/ 564-2;-88. 423
3/8/2342; E/7/ .,47-2< E4;/7 871? ;,/ E/66 /@/7 .-20/ '** "
1 31>9; -2 ;,/
,1E/@/7
46/
//3 18 '*(
;,/7/ -. 21 ?/2;-12 18 E/66
/@/7 .-20/ ;,/ /K/0>;-12 18 '**
.>9./J>/2;
310>?/2;.
3/8/2342; -2 ;,/ E/66"
06/476:
/.;496-.,/3
46/
//3 423
;,/
7-<,;
,>. ;,/ .>9.;42;-46 J>/.;-12. 18 64E
874?/3 47/ 42.E/7/3 400173-2<6:" 2 ;,/ 7/.>6;
5710//3 ;1
54.. ;,/ 81661E-2<
-"
,/
/<>647
/0123
55/46 -.
"
- 10 -
--"
---"
,/ -?5><2/3 =>3<?/2; 423 3/07// 34;/3
" ("
' 54../3 -2
/2-17
-@-6 #>3</
" " 1" *
( 9: ;,/
6423 -. ./; 4.-3/"
,/ =>3<?/2; 423 3/07// 34;/3
"' "
54../3 -2
33-;-1246
" " 1"
9: ;,/
-@-6 #>3</ !#7" 2& 423 #%)
6423 -.
,/7/9: 0128-7?/3"
*&
%
#
'
#
$
-.;
1" '
1" (
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review