Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNA TAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DATED TH IS THE 3 R D DAY OF APRIL 2017
BEFORE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUS TICE S.N. SA TYANARAYANA
M.F.A.NO .2424/2006 (BPT)
BETWEEN:
MALLARI S/O . RAMCHANDRA NIMBALKAR
AGED ABOUT 63 YEA RS, OCC: AGRICU LTURE
R/A T JALAPUR, TQ: RA IBAG
DIST: BELGAUM
... APPELLANT.
(BY SRI ANTHONY R. RODRIGUES , ADVOCA TE, FOR
SRI RAMACHANDRA A MALI, ADVOCATE.)
AND:
1.
LAXMAN RAJU PUJARI
AGED MAJOR
2.
MARUTHI PARSHURAM PUJARI
AGED MAJOR
3.
RAJU SADASHIV PUJARI
AGED MAJOR
4.
APPASAHEB B CHOUGULE
AGED MAJOR
5.
MARUTHI DHONDIBA GOOSARWADE
AGED MAJOR
6.
RAMAKANTH RAMCHANDRA PUJARI
AGED MAJOR
7.
UDAY RAMACHANDRA PUJARI
AGED MAJOR
8.
SUMITRABAI PARASHRAM PUJARI
AGED MAJOR
9.
PRAKASH PARASHRAM PUJARI
AGED MAJOR
ALL ARE R/O. JALALPU R, TQ: RA IBAG
DIST: BELGAUM
10.
STA TE OR KARNA TAKA
R/B ITS SECRETARY
DEPT. OF MUZARAI & HINDU RELIGIOUS
INS TITU TION & CHARITABLE ENDOWMENTS,
A.V.ROAD, CHAMARAJPET, BANGALORE-18
... RESPONDENTS .
(BY SRI SHIVAKUMAR S BADAWADAGI, ADVOCA TE,
FOR R.1;
R.2, R.4 TO R.8 AND R.9 – NOTICE SERVED;
R.3 – APPEAL DISMISSED VIDE ORDER DA TED
21.2.2011;
SRI RAVIKUMAR D. GOKAKAR, ADVOCA TE, FOR R.7;
SRI RAVI V. HOSAMANI, GOVERNMENT AD VOCATE FOR
R.10.)
THIS MISCELLANEOUS F IRS T APPEAL IS FILED
UNDER SECTION 72 (4) OF TH E BOMBAY PUBLIC
TRUSTS ACT, 1950, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE
ORDER
DA TED
8.11.2005,
PASSED
IN
MISC.APPLICA TON NO .96/2001, ON THE FILE OF THE
II ADDL.DIS TRICT JUDGE, BELGAUM, CONFIRMING
THE ORDER DATED 19.5.2001, PASSED IN APPEAL
NO.15/1997,
BY
THE
CHARITY
COMMISSIONER,
BELGAUM, THEREBY REVERSING THE ORDER DA TED
21.6.1997, MADE IN
INQ.NO .277/1994, BY
TH E
ASSISTANT
CHARITY
COMMISSIONER,
BELGAUM,
ETC.,.
THIS
APPEAL
COMING
ON
FOR
FURTHER
ARGUMENTS ON ADMISSION THIS DAY, TH E COURT
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
JUDGMENT
This
appeal
No.277/1994,
is
before
by
applicant
the
in
Inquiry
Assistant
Charity
Commissioner, Belagavi, which was initiated by
him under section 18 of the Bombay Public Trust
Act, 1950.
2.
The proceedings in Inquiry No.277/1994
is by residents of Jalalpur village claiming that
the Yallamma Devi Temple situated in the said
village on property bearing No.201 of Jalalpur
village,
Raibag
taluk,
Belagavi
district
is
the
property belonging to public trust. According to
them all the residents of Jalalpur village and also
other persons who are devotees of Yallamma Devi
Temple have a right to seek a trust being formed
with proper representation of devotees and temple
priest in the managing committee of the said
trust.
3.
The said application was opposed by 6 t h
respondent
Laxman
in
the
Ramu
said
application
Pujari.
It
is
by
name
seen
that
simultaneously two other applications were filed,
out of which one is by a person namely Raju
Sadashiv Pujari, which is registered in Inquiry
No.419/1994 and another by a person namely
Ramachandra
Kashappa
Pujari,
which
is
registered in Inquiry No.38/1995. Incidentally the
applicant in Inquiry No.38/1995 is 5 t h respondent
in
the
first
Inquiry
initiated
in
Inquiry
No.277/1994.
4.
necessary
Pausing for a moment at this stage, it is
to
bring
on
record
that
there
was
already a litigation with reference to the said
temple and with reference to the manner as to the
performance of pooja in the temple should be
carried out, in O.S.No.43/1982, on the file of the
Munsiff
Court,
Raibag.
That
was
a
suit
for
permanent injunction with reference to the right
of
performing
pooja
and
as
well
as
being
in
possession of the temple, which was filed by the
applicant in Inquiry No.38/1995 against the 6 t h
respondent
Laxman
Ramu
Pujari
in
Inquiry
No.277/1994. As could be seen, the said suit
came
to
be
dismissed
by
judgment
dated
31.3.1986, which was subject matter of Regular
Appeal in R.A.No.14/1986, on the file of Civil
Judge,
Gokak,
wherein
the
appellant
Ramachandra Kashappa Pujari was able to get the
requisite order of permanent injunction against
Laxman Ramu Pujari.
5.
others
The defendant Laxman Ramu Pujari and
preferred
a
second
appeal
in
RSA
No.729/1986, on the file of this Court, which
came
to
be
disposed
of
by
judgment
dated
20.9.1990 wherein the judgment in the appeal by
Ramachandra Kashappa Pujari was set aside and
the property namely Yallamma Devi Temple which
was said to be standing on the property bearing
No.201 was held to be the property belonging to
the family of poojaries who are conducting pooja
of the said temple from generations.
6.
In the said judgment at paragraph No.5,
the coordinate bench of this Court has stated as
under:
5. There is also no dispute that the
proper ty is not a tr ust proper ty, either
public
or
pr ivate.
proper ties
have
Neither
ref erred
of
the
to
any
endowment. There is also no evidence to
show that the proper ty was debottar in
the sense that there is any dedication to
the Deity by any person. There is some
evidence
to
villagers
have
ind icate
offered
that
later
lands
to
on
the
temple. In the absence of any evidence to
show that either a debottar or a trust or
a Math came in to existence at any point
of time, the case must proceed on the
basis that the ancestors of the plain tif f
and def endan ts were perf orming pooja in
the temple and had acquired such a r igh t
to perf orm pooja and
appropriate
the
off erings.
7.
This judgment in RSA as stated supra is
rendered on 20.9.1990 and as could be seen from
the
records
the
three
Inquiries,
which
are
initiated in Inquiry Nos.277/1994, 419/1994 and
38/1995
are
subsequent
to
the
judgment
of
co-ordinate bench of this Court observing the
status of Yallamma Devi Temple with reference to
its identification as neither public nor private
trust,
where
the
co-ordinate
bench
has
categorically declared that it is neither public nor
private trust but it is the temple which is run by
the family of poojaries hereditarily to which both
the plaintiff and defendant in O.S.No.43/1982
belong and none of them can claim exclusive right
to conduct pooja of the said temple. At the same
time
in
paragraph
No.4
it
was
categorically
observed that all the offerings that are given to
the deity are taken by the family of poojaries for
the benefit of the family, thereby indicating that
no one of them has absolute right to any of these
including the property on which the temple is
standing.
8.
be
In this background, what is required to
considered
Charity
is
the
Commissioner,
finding
of
who
has
the
Assistant
decided
the
application filed before him under Section 18 of
the Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950. What calls for
interference by this Court has already passed
through several proceedings from the order of
Assistant Charity Commissioner to that of Charity
Commissioner, thereafter before the District Court
and
resting
with
this
appeal
in
this
Court.
Therefore sequentially this Court would like to go
into the matter commencing from the applications
filed under Section 18 of the Bombay Public Trust
Act, 1950, by three persons.
9.
The first of which is by the appellant
herein in Inquiry No.277/1994 followed by the 2 n d
application
in
Inquiry
No.419/1994
by
Raju
Sadashiv Pujari another member of the family of
the hereditary poojaries of Yallamma Devi Temple
and third one by Ramachandra Kashappa Pu jari
yet another member of the very same hereditary
poojari family. The assistant charity commissioner
based on several material placed before him in the
form of oral and documentary evidence proceeded
to frame 14 points for consideration and has given
opinion on them with reference to the right of
applicant
in
Inquiry
No.277/1994
seeking
to
recognize the Yallamma Devi Temple as property
belonging to public trust and then to form the
committee
of
trusties
for
the
so
called
two
Inquiries,
non
existent trust.
10.
In
the
other
basically
they were in the nature of seeking adjudication of
their right with reference to perform pooja interse
between
the
other
members
of
the
hereditary
poojaries families. In the said two applications
though
the
applicants
stated
that
they
are
hereditary poojaries, there is an attempt on their
part to lien in support of the application filed in
Inquiry No.277/1994 in giving an impression that
there is a trust in existence and that they are also
willing to be the trustees.
11.
What is surprising is, the application in
Inquiry No.38/1995, which is by the author of
earlier
litigation
in
O.S.No.43/1982,
which
he
initiated for the relief of permanent injunction
claiming himself to be the exclusive poojari of
Yallamma
Devi
Temple.
The
records
would
indicate that he failed miserably to secure an
order in those lines which has reached up to this
Court in RSA No.729/1986, wherein a coordinate
bench of this Court categorically held that there is
no trust either private or public is in existence
with reference to aforesaid temple which is well
within
the
knowledge
of
applicant
in
Inquiry
No.38/1995.
12.
Here what is seen is his dishonesty in
not bringing the same to the notice of Assistant
Charity Commissioner, instead projecting as if he
is in support of the temple being recognized as a
charitable trust and a committee being formed to
oversee the functions of the temple in which he
wanted a place as trustee i.e., after having failed
to succeed in getting exclusive ownership over the
temple.
Assistant
This
dishonesty
Charity
is
not
seen
Commissioner
while
by
the
deciding
point No.1 and concluded in the common order
dated
21.6.1997
applications
the
rendered
finding
on
at
all
the
the
three
fag
end
Xxx ..xxxx..xxx…xxx I am of
the
of
paragraph No.14 reads as under:
considered opinion that there is no f orce
in the conten tion of the Opponent No.6
th at the Temple is a private property. As
regards
ancient
temple
there
is
a
presump tion that it is a public Trust e ven
though no specif ic evidence is available
regard ing its endowmen t. Hence, I hold
th at in vie w of the said presump tion
available, the temple in question is a
public Trust and it exists. Accordingly,
the
point
No.1
is
answered
in
Aff irmative.
13.
In the light of this finding on first point
he continued to answer the remaining 13 points in
support of the application in Inquiry No.277/1994
and thereby holding that there is a trust, which
finding is diametrically opposite to the view taken
by the coordinate bench of this Court in RSA
No.729/1986. What is disturbing is a party to the
said RSA having participated in the proceedings
and after
suffering an
order
against him
has
suppressed
the
same
the
deliberately
before
Assistant Charity Commissioner and has prevailed
upon
him
to
pass
such
an
order
which
is
apparently inconsistent with the finding already
given by coordinate bench of this Court.
14.
Be that as it may, now coming to the
second round of litigation which are in Appeal
No.13/1997, which is filed by 6 t h respondent in
Inquiry
No.277/1994
and
Appeal
No.15/1997,
which is filed by the applicant Raju Sadashiv
Pujari
and
No.419/1994.
another
They
person
in
challenged
the
Inquiry
order
of
Charity Commissioner in these two appeals which
subsequently came to be disposed of by order
dated
19.5.2001,
wherein
the
Charity
Commissioner
which
was
allowed
filed
the
Appeal
No.13/1997,
by Laxman Ramu Pujari and
dismissed the Appeal No.15/1997, which was filed
by Raju Sadashiv Pujari and another.
15.
As against the common judgment dated
19.5.2001, Miscellaneous Application came to be
filed by the applicant in Inquiry No.277/1994
before the II Addl. District Court, Belagavi, in
Misc.Application No.96/2001, which was under
Section 72(1) of the Bombay Public trust Act and
simultaneously one more appeal is filed by the
applicant in Inquiry No.419/1994 Raju Sadashiv
Pujari
and
another
in
Misc.Application
No.95/2001 under the said provision of law.
16.
These two miscellaneous appeals i.e.,
Misc.Application
heard
Nos.96
by
the
District
dismissed
by
judgment
and
Court
dated
of
and
came
were
to
8.11.2005.
be
The
applicant in Inquiry No.419/1994 accepted his
defeat after successfully losing three rounds of
litigation
in
Inquiry
No.15/1997
and
No.95/2011.
However
No.419/1994,
thereafter
the
in
Appeal
Misc.Application
applicant
in
Inquiry
No.277/1994, who succeeded only for the first
time before the Assistant Charity Commissioner,
continued to pursue his grievance against the
temple and other members of the family of priests
in filing this miscellaneous first appeal in MFA
No.2424/2006, which is filed under Section 72(4)
of the Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950.
17.
When
this
matter
came
up
for
admission, the learned counsel appearing for both
the parties requested this Court to secure the
entire records in Inquiry No.277, 419 of 1994 and
38 of 1995 and other records to go into the same
and thereafter to decide this appeal at the stage of
admission itself, in view of the fact that this
matter is pending consideration before various
Courts from 1994 itself. Accordingly the records
were secured and this matter was heard.
18.
While hearing this matter, this Court
noticed that the beginning of these litigation is
not in the application filed under section 18 of the
Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950, seeking enquiry
into status of the temple which was commenced in
1994. But it is continued from the earlier round of
litigation
in
commenced
O.S.No.43/1982
by
the
applicant
which
in
was
Inquiry
No.38/1995, who lost a bitter fight with other
members of his family to gain supremacy over
others and also absolute right of control over the
temple and its activities. He having miserably
failed in securing favourable order and having lost
his litigation in RSA No.729/1986, which was
disposed of by judgment dated 20.9.1990 has
supported
the
No.277/1994.
case
of
applicant
in
Inquiry
19.
What could be seen from the records
available here is that Yallamma Devi Temple in
Jalalpur village is one of the oldest temples of the
region. The records would indicate that the temple
belongs to the family of poojaries and that the
property on which the temple is standing also
belongs to the family, thereby indicating that it is
a private temple owned by a family who were
allowed
to
perform
pooja
through
the
lineal
descendents of that family. It is seen that some of
the descendents in the said family are none other
than the applicants in Inquiry No.419/1994 and
38/1995
and
also
6th
respondent
in
Inquiry
No.277/1994. How and in what manner they are
required to conduct pooja is not defined in any
proceedings.
However
what
is
decided
in
O.S.No.43/1982 is the nature of the temple and
its
title
with
the
members
of
the
family
of
poojaries who are hereditarily conducting pooja of
the said temple.
20.
As could be seen from the discussion
supra as on the day the inquiry was initiated
before the Assistant Charity Commissioner there
was
already
No.729/1986,
a
judgment
where
at
passed
paragraph
in
RSA
No.5,
the
coordinate bench of this Court has already held
that the temple in question is neither a private
trust
nor
a
public
trust
and
has
further
categorically declared that it is a private property
belonging
to
the
family
of
poojaries
who
are
performing pooja in the said temple from time
immemorial and what is required to be seen is the
right to perform pooja is available to all the
members
of the
family
who
are
living
in
the
there
is
original poojaries family.
21.
In
this
background
when
already a categorical finding, how the Assistant
Charity Commissioner could sit in judgment over
the same after lapse of a period of 7 long years
after the judgment by coordinate bench of this
Court, to hold that the said temple is a public
trust does not stand to reason. Merely because
the
temple
is
an
old
temple,
it
cannot
be
presumed that a trust is created for management
of the same. In fact there is nothing on record to
demonstrate
that
there
was
such
material
available to arrive at a decision to hold that the
said temple is a public trust. The finding of the
Assistant Charity Commissioner is without any
basis except on his own presumption which has
no
support
of
documentary
either
evidence
pleadings
in
any
and
of
oral
the
or
earlier
proceedings to substantiate the same.
22.
Therefore when the said common order
passed by the Assistant Charity Commissioner in
all
the
three
Inquiries
by
its
report
dated
21.6.1997 was taken up in appeal before the
Charity Commissioner, the same is rightly set
aside by him in reversing the finding given in
Inquiry
No.277/1994
which
is
confirmed
by
District Court in appeal filed under Section 70(1)
of the Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950, by its
judgment dated 8.11.2005.
23.
In that view of the matter, this Court
after going through the entire material available
on record find that no grounds are made out by
the applicant in Inquiry No.277/1994 to challenge
the
successive
findings
of
the
Charity
Commissioner in Appeal Nos.13 and 15 of 1997
and that of the District Court in Misc.Application
Nos.95 and 96 of 2001, to be disturbed in this
appeal filed under Section 72(4) of the Bombay
Public Trust Act, 1950. Accordingly this appeal is
dismissed without any order as to costs.
24.
The learned Government advocate Sri
Ravi Hosamani appearing for the Government in
this appeal is permitted to take back all the
original records which are produced by him.
Sd/JUDGE
Mrk/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review