Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2025
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R. KRISHNA KUMAR
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.M. POONACHA
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 100003 OF 2022 (PAR/POS)
BETWEEN:
SHRI. SHIVANAND
CHANDRASHEKARAPPA KALYANASHETTI,
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
OCC. PVT. SERVICE,
R/O. 2ND CROSS,
CHALUKYA NAGAR,
(K.M.PATTANASHETTI ROAD),
BADAMI 587201.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ASHOK R.KALYANASHETTY, ADVOCATE)
YASHAVANT
NARAYANKAR
AND:
1.
SMT. SANGAVVA
W/O. SANGAPPA CHINIVALAR,
AGE: 64 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
BADARI CHAWL,
AT. BADAMI 587201.
DIST: BAGALKOT.
2.
SMT. ANNAPURNA
W/O. SURESH KADAGANCHI,
AGE: 59 YEARS,
YASHAVANT
NARAYANKAR
Location: HIGH COURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
-2NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. NEAR SWAMI SAMADHI,
AKKALKOT, AT. AKKALKOT-413216,
DIST: SOLAPUR,
MAHARASTRA STATE.
3.
SMT. GANGAWWA
W/O. BASAVARAJ SHIRUR,
AGE: 66 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. CHOLACHAGUDDA-587201,
AT. BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT.
4.
BASAVARAJ
CHANDRASHEKARAPPA KALYANASHETTI,
AGE: 54 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. KALLIPETH,
PATTANASHETTI ONI,
AT. BADAMI-587201.
5.
SMT. GEETA
W/O. RAJANNA KORI,
AGE: 52 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. RAJUR-582114,
TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG.
6.
SHRI. BASAVANT
RAMACHANDRA KAMBALE,
AGE: 36 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SINDAGI,
DIST: VIJAYAPUR-586128.
-3NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
7.
SMT. MAHATAWWA
W/O. CHANNABASAPPA ANGADI,
AGE: 78 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. IHOLE,
TQ: BADAMI-587124.
8.
SMT. GIRIJA
W/O. BASAVARAJ KALYANASHETTI,
AGE: 52 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. PATTANADAVAR ONI,
BADAMI, TQ: BADAMI.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. PRAKASH HOSAMANE,
ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3 AND R5;
SRI. R.M.KULKARNI AND
SMT. SHANTA B.PATIL, ADVOCATES FOR
SRI. CHETAN MUNNOLI, ADVOCATE FOR R4 AND R8;
SRI. S.C.HIREMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R6)
(NOTICE TO R7 IS HELD SUFFICIENT)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC AGAINST
THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 22.09.2021 PASSED IN
O.S.NO.34/2013 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND
JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE FIRST CLASS, BADAMI, DISMISSING THE
SUIT FILED FOR PARTITION AND SEPARATE POSSESSION.
THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R. KRISHNA KUMAR
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.M. POONACHA
-4NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R. KRISHNA KUMAR)
This
appeal
by
the
unsuccessful
plaintiff
in
O.S.
No.34/2013 is directed against the impugned judgment and
decree dated 22.09.2021 passed by the Senior Civil Judge &
JMFC, Badami (for short, ‘the Trial Court’), whereby the said suit
filed by the appellants/plaintiffs against the respondent /
defendant for partition and separate possession of his share in
the suit schedule properties was dismissed by the Trial Court.
2.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties are
referred to by their respective ranks before the Trial Court.
3.
Briefly stated, the facts giving rise to the present
appeal are:
(a) The
appellant/plaintiff
is
the
son
of
one
late
Chandrashekarappa Kalyanshetty and late Irawwa, who
expired on 11.12.1981 and 26.09.2005 respectively leaving
behind the appellant/plaintiff and respondents No.1 to
5/defendants No.1 to 5 to succeed to his estate as his heirs
and
legal
representatives.
Defendants
Nos.6
to
-5NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
8/respondents No.6 to 8 are said to be purchasers in respect
of certain portions of the suit schedule properties. According
to the plaintiff, the suit schedule properties were joint family
properties in joint possession and enjoyment of the plaintiff
and defendants No.1 to 5 and since defendant No.4 alienated
some of the properties in favour of defendants No.6 and 8
depriving the plaintiff of his legitimate share in the suit
schedule properties, the plaintiff instituted the aforesaid suit
for partition and separate possession of his alleged share in
the suit schedule properties and for other reliefs.
(b) Defendants No.1 to 5 filed their written statement disputing
and denying the various allegations and claims made by the
plaintiffs. It was contended that item No.1 and 2 of the suit
schedule
properties
were
separate
and
self-acquired
properties of defendant No.4 and that the plaintiff does not
have any manner of right, title, interest or possession over
the same. It is also contended that the suit for partition was
not maintainable and the same was liable to dismissed.
Defendants No.6 and 8 also filed their separate written
-6NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
statement and contested the claim of the plaintiff and sought
for dismissal of the suit.
(c) Based on the aforesaid pleadings, the Trial Court framed the
following issues:
“:ISSUES:
1 Whether the plaintiff proves that all the suit
schedule properties are ancestral, joint family
properties of himself and the defendant No 1 to
5?
2 Whether the defendants prove that Sy. No 288/1A,
288/1B and Sy. No 289 are the self-acquired
properties of the defendant No 4?
Whether the defendant No 6 proves that he is a
bonafide purchaser for valuable consideration of
survey
number
288/1A
and
survey
number
288/1B?
4 Whether defendants prove that survey number
175/ETA of
Yarragoppa village and CTS
No
2909/55 of Badami are self-acquired properties of
defendant number eight?
5 Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of all the
properties?
-7NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
6 Whether the plaintiff is entitled for 1/6 shares or
any share in the suit schedule properties?
Whether plaintiff is entitled for the relief of
partition and separate possession as prayed for?
To What order or decree?”
(d) Plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1 and two more witnesses
as P.W.2 and P.W.3 and documentary evidence at Exs.P.1 to
P.40 were marked on his behalf. Defendant No.4 examined
himself as D.W.1, while defendant No.8 and defendant No.6
examined themselves as D.W.2 and D.W.3 respectively and
documentary evidence at Ex.D.1 and D.50 were marked on
their behalf. After hearing the parties, the Trial Court
proceeded to dismiss the suit by passing the impugned
judgment and decree which is assailed in the present appeal.
4.
During the pendency of the present appeal, the
appellant has filed I.A. No.1/2025 seeking amendment of the
plaint which is opposed by the respondents by filing their
statement of objections to the said application.
5.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellant and the
learned counsel for respondents No.4 and 8 as well as the
-8NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
learned counsel for remaining respondents and perused the
material on record.
6.
Learned counsel for the appellant would invite our
attention to the judgment and decree in order to point out that
the Trial Court has failed to consider and appreciate the oral and
documentary evidence in their
proper perspective thereby
resulting in erroneous conclusions. It was pointed out that
though the
appellant produced
Ex.P.34, “M¥ÀàAzÀ
¥ÀvæÀ” dated
16.05.2006 executed between plaintiff and defendant No.4,
which indicates that the plaintiff had contributed funds for the
purchase of items No.1 and 2 of the suit schedule properties, the
Trial Court committed an error in rejecting the said documents
and as such, the said finding rendered by the Trial Court
deserves to be set aside. It is further submitted that since the
Trial Court has recorded a finding that the said contention of the
appellant/plaintiff based on Ex.P.34 dated 16.05.2006 cannot be
accepted due to want/lack of pleadings in this regard, the
plaintiff has filed the instant application i.e., I.A. No.1/2025
seeking amendment of the plaint. It is therefore, submitted that
the application – I.A. No.1/2025 filed by the appellant deserves
-9NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
to be allowed and the impugned judgment and decree passed by
the Trial Court deserves to be set aside and the suit of the
plaintiff deserves to be decreed in his favour.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel for respondents No.4 and
8 would support the impugned judgment and decree and contend
that the Trial Court has correctly and properly considered and
appreciated the entire material on record and has come to the
correct conclusion that the plaintiff was not entitled to a share in
item Nos.1 and 2 of the suit schedule property. Learned counsel
would invite our attention to the amended provisions contained
in Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, in
particular, the proviso inserted by way of amendment with effect
from 01.07.2002 in order to point out that the plaintiff has
neither averred nor established that he had exercised due
diligence in not seeking amendment prior to commencement of
the trial. It is also submitted that thought he suit was initially
filed on 19.07.2013, and the appellant/plaintiff having filed I.A.
No.2 also under Order VI Rule 17 CPC seeking amendment of the
plaint as long as back on 11.08.2014, the plaintiff did not choose
to state anything as regards Ex.P.34 in the original plaint or in
- 10 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
the amended plaint, much less in his evidence that was recorded
on 24.09.2018, which demonstrates that the plaintiff was guilty
of not exercising due diligence in not seeking amendment prior
to commencement of trial. It was also submitted that the
affidavit filed in support of the application for amendment does
not make out valid or sufficient grounds to establish that the
plaintiff could not seek amendment despite exercise of due
diligence before the Trial Court in terms of the proviso to Order
VI Rule 17 of CPC. Under these circumstances, he would submit
that this is not a case to show any indulgence in favour of the
appellant/plaintiff by permitting amendment and the application
– I.A.No.1/2025 is liable to be dismissed. In support of his
submission, learned counsel for respondents No.4 and 8 would
place reliance upon the following judgments:
i)
Basavaraj Vs. Indira and Others1
ii)
The Municipal Corporation of Greater
Bombay v. Lala Pancham and others2,
8.
We have given our anxious consideration to the rival
submissions and perused the material on record.
2024(1) KCCR 869 (SC)
AIR 1965 SC 1008
- 11 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
9.
The following points arise for consideration in the
present appeal:
(i)
Whether the application I.A. No.1/2025 filed by
the appellant/plaintiff under Order VI Rule 17 of
CPC seeking amendment of the plaint deserves
to be allowed?
(ii) Whether the impugned judgment and decree
passed by the Trial Court warrants interference
by this Court in the present appeal?
10.
Before adverting to the rival contentions, it is
essential to advert to the proposed amendment to the plaint
sought for by the appellant/plaintiff which is as under:
PROPOSED AMENDMENT:
“That the defendant No.4 by executing “Oppand
Patra
and
Kabja
Pavati
Besmi”
dated
16.05.2006 on stamp paper dated 16.05.2006
purchased
by
him
has
acknowledged
my
contribution of Rs.1,05,000 out of Rs.1,10,000
towards sale consideration amount to purchase
the two suit lands R.S.No.288/1(2A-20G) and R
S No.288/1B (2A-20G) both of Badami, my right
and interest to the extent of half share on par
with his ½ share therein, and that he will not
alienate or encumber or transfer the said two
- 12 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
lands without my permission as detailed therein
in the presence of plaintiff two witnesses named
therein”.
11.
In the affidavit in support of the application, the
appellant has reiterated the various facts and contentions
urged by him in the suit and appeal and the documents
produced by him and stated that in the original/amended
plaint itself, the plaintiff had already stated that he had
contributed money and had half share in item Nos. 1 and 2
of the suit schedule properties. At paragraph 8 of the of the
affidavit in support of the application, the plaintiff refers to
IA No. 5 dated 02.11.2018 filed by him under Order XI Rule
14 CPC for production of exhibit P34 which was allowed by
recalling PW1 and the said P34 was marked as an exhibit
before the trial court, after payment of requisite duty and
penalty. The plaintiff also contends that apart from other
reasons assigned by the trial Court to reject the claim of the
plaintiff based on Exhibit 34, the trial Court also recorded a
finding that Exhibit P34 cannot be relied upon by the
- 13 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
appellant-plaintiff for want of necessary pleadings in this
regard.
12.
The appellant-plaintiff has contended that the
proposed amendment in relation to exhibit P34 was just and
necessary for the purpose of determining the real issue in
controversy between the parties in respect of Item Nos. 1
and 2 of the suit schedule property over which there was
already an averment made in the original plaint/amendment
plaint and that the proposed amendment sought for vide IA
No. 1 of 25 was merely in support of the earlier averments
by way of clarity and basis for the effectual adjudication,
since the documents in this regard had already been
marked in evidence as exhibit P34 on behalf of the plaintiff.
The plaintiff contended that the proposed amendment does
not in any way change or alter the nature or character of
the suit or its causes and that no prejudice would be caused
to the respondents-defendants if the proposed amendment
were to be allowed since they would have an opportunity to
file their additional written statement and the controvert the
- 14 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
averments made in the proposed amendment. It was also
submitted that the proposed amendment is neither barred
by limitation nor does it take away any right having stood
vested in the respondents-defendants by lapse of time and
since the proposed amendment was necessary and essential
to adjudicate upon the issues in controversy between the
parties, it is just and proper to allow the amendment, failing
which the petitioner would be put to irreparable injury and
hardship.
13.
the
In the statement of objections to IA No.1 of 25,
respondents-defendants
would
contend
that
the
proposed amendment is not bonafide in nature and filed
with the ulterior motives/purpose of dragging on the
proceedings. It was pointed out that the existence of
exhibits P11, P12 or P34 are not been pleaded by the
plaintiff in the original plaint/amended plaint and in the light
of proviso to Order VI Rule 17 CPC, which mandates
exercise of due diligence as to why the plaintiff could not
- 15 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
put forth the proposed pleading prior to commencement of
trial, the proposed amendment cannot be accepted.
14.
The
various
contentions
regarding
merits/
demerits relating to the said document as averred by the
plaintiff has been specifically denied by the respondentsdefendants in their statement of objections.
15.
In this context, a perusal of the impugned
judgment and decree will indicate that in addition to
rejecting the claim of the appellant-plaintiff based on exhibit
P34, the trial Court has clearly held that in the absence of
necessary pleadings, it is not permissible for the appellantplaintiff to rely upon exhibit P34. In fact the trial Court
refers to the cross examination of PW1 that since PW1 had
admitted that he had given exhibit P34 to his lawyer at the
time of filing the suit, the same was not pleaded by the
plaintiff in the original plaint. The relevant portion of the
impugned judgment and decree at paragraph No.33 is as
under:
- 16 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
“33. The property purchased in the name of the defendant
No.4 i.e., Sy No.288/1 to an extent of 5 acres, but the plaintiff
has very much relied on Ex.P.34 the prove that he has paid
the amount to the defendant No.4 to purchase the said
property in the name of defendant No.4. Admittedly, this
document is not produced along with the plaint. Even there
was no recital about this document at the initial stage in the
plaint. Even at the time of adducing evidence of P.W.1 there is
whisper
by
the
plaintiff
about
this
document.
But
subsequently, after getting amendment of the plaint the
plaintiff has produced this document in the evidence. He has
categorically, admitted that, this document was in his custody,
before institution of the suit and before adducing his evidence,
under such circumstances, what prevented him to plead and
produced this document. At initial stage of institution of the
suit. This creates suspicious about this document. Even to
prove this document the witness have been examined as
P.W.2 and 3, but, they have not supported to the case of the
plaintiff to prove execution of Ex.P.34. This witnesses are the
subordinate employees of the plaintiff and they deposed that
they does not know about the contents of Ex.P.34. In such
circumstance the probabality of the case of defendant No.4
cannot
be
ruled
out
because
the
defendant
No.4
has
contended that at the time of renewal of the loan in to
Veerapulakeshi Bank he has produced some signed blank
stamp papers to the bank and the plaintiff being the employee
in the said bank has got the said document and prepared the
same according to his wishes. If really this document was in
existence on the date of institution of the suit, no prudent man
will keep quite to plead and produced the document. In the
cross examination of P.W.1, he deposed that, he has given the
said document to his Advocate at the time of filing of the suit,
if that is the case, what prevented the counsel to plead about
- 17 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
this document. Though this is rightly pointed out by the
counsel for the defendant that as on the date of institution of
the suit and even after filing of the chief examination affidavit
this document was not taken birth, but, subsequently came
into existence. The learned counsel for the plaintiff during the
time of arguments has argued that whatever the amendment
taken place to the pleadings it goes to the date of the
institution of the suit and hence, the subsequent pleadings to
be considering from the date of institution of the suit. It is true
that whatever the amendment taken place subsequent to the
suit will consider from the date of institution of the suit. But, if
any suspicious circumstance arises regarding the facts, then
the court has to analise, under what circumstance the
subsequent pleadings came into existence and what was the
document relied on subsequent pleadings. In this case, since,
this document is material document for the plaintiff to
establish that he has paid consideration amount to the
defendant for purchase of the property in the name of
defendant No.4, under such circumstances, no person will
silent to plead this kind of material document. Even as I have
already stated above the witnesses have not supported to the
case of the plaintiff about due execution of the same.”
16.
The aforesaid finding recorded by the trial Court
for the purpose of rejecting the claim of the plaintiff based
on Exhibit P34 will clearly indicate that apart from other
reasons, the trial Court also came to the conclusion that in
the absence of pleadings or amended pleadings in relation
to exhibit P34 which was a material document in support of
- 18 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
his claims, no reliance could be placed by the plaintiff upon
the said document in support of his claims. It follows there
from that pleadings and proof as regards exhibit P34 would
be
relevant,
essential
and
necessary
for
purpose
of
adjudication of the issues in controversy between the
parties, especially when the plaintiff specifically places
reliance upon exhibit P34 to lay a claim over item Nos.1 and
2 of the suit schedule properties, which has been specifically
disputed and denied by the respondents/defendants.
17.
considered
Under
opinion
these
that
circumstances,
we
the
amendment
proposed
are
the
is
relevant and necessary for the purpose of adjudication of
issues in controversy between the parties and the proposed
amendment deserves to be allowed.
18.
Insofar
as
respondents-defendants
the
that
contention
the
urged
appellant
by
the
had
not
exercised/neither pleaded nor proved exercise of due
diligence as to why he could not put forth the present
- 19 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
pleading prior to commencement of trial is concerned, in the
affidavit in support of the application, the plaintiff has
narrated in detail as to how exhibit P34 was not initially
produced by him but produced subsequently along with IA
No.5 under Order VII to Rule 14 CPC for production of
documents
which
was
allowed
by
the
trial
Court,
subsequent to 02.11.2018 pursuant to which, the said
document was permitted to be produced and marked in
evidence as exhibit P34 upon the appellant-plaintiff paying
requisite stamp duty and penalty. In fact, parties went to
trial based on the rival pleadings and during the course of
evidence, the appellant-plaintiff produced exhibit P34 in
relation
to
which
the
respondents-defendants
cross
examined the appellant-plaintiff (PW1) on all aspects
including the said document. It was only subsequently when
the impugned judgment and decree was passed by the trial
Court that a finding has been recorded that one of the
reasons to reject exhibit P34 was the absence of necessary
pleadings in this regard. In this factual matrix obtaining in
- 20 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
the instant case, especially having regard to the production
of exhibit P34, after payment of requisite stamp duty and
penalty and having been cross examined by the defendants
on this document also, it cannot be said that the plaintiff did
not exercise due diligence in not putting forth the necessary
pleadings in this regard. Consequently, the said contention
urged on behalf of the respondents-defendants cannot be
accepted.
19.
In any event, a perusal of the affidavit in support
of IA No.1/2025 is also sufficient to show that valid and
sufficient grounds and cause has been made out by the
appellant to seek amendment of the plaint, albeit, appellate
stage. Viewed from this angle also, we are of the view that
the proposed amendment deserves to be allowed.
20.
Insofar as the contention urged on behalf of the
respondents-defendants that they would be put to prejudice
and hardship if, the proposed amendment were to be
allowed
is
concerned,
the
principles
underlying
the
- 21 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
amendment of pleadings has been reiterated by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of Ganesh Prasad vs Rajeshwar
Prasad3, wherein at paragraph Nos.32 to 48, it is held as
under:
ANALYSIS
32. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for
the parties and having gone through the materials on
record the only question that falls for our consideration is
whether the High Court committed any error in passing
the impugned order.
33. There cannot be any doubt or dispute that the
courts should be liberal in allowing applications for leave
to amend pleadings but it is also well settled that the
courts must bear in mind the statutory limitations brought
about
by
reason
of
the
Code
of
Civil
Procedure
(Amendment) Acts; the proviso appended to Order VI
Rule 17 being one of them. In North Eastern Railway
Administration,
Gorakhpur v. Bhagwan
Das reported
in (2008) 8 SCC 511, the law has been laid down by this
Court in the following terms: (SCC p. 517, para 16)
“16. Insofar as the principles which govern the
question of granting or disallowing amendments under
Order 6 Rule 17 CPC (as it stood at the relevant time) are
concerned, these are also well settled. Order 6 Rule
17 CPC postulates amendment of pleadings at any stage
of
the
2023 SCC Online 256
proceedings.
In Pirgonda
Hongonda
- 22 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
Patil v. Kalgonda Shidgonda Patil [AIR 1957 SC 363]
which still holds the field, it was held that all amendments
ought to be allowed which satisfy the two conditions : (a)
of not working injustice to the other side, and (b) of being
necessary
for the
questions
in
purpose of determining the real
controversy
between
the
parties.
Amendments should be refused only where the other
party cannot be placed in the same position as if the
pleading had been originally correct, but the amendment
would
cause
him
compensated
in
an
injury
which
could
costs.
(Also
see Gajanan
not
be
Jaikishan
Joshi v. Prabhakar Mohanlal Kalwar [(1990) 1 SCC 166].)”
34. In
the
case
of P.A.
Jayalakshmi v. H.
Saradha reported in (2009) 14 SCC 525, the above
observations were reiterated by this Court and in the light
of the same, this Court in para 9 held as under:
“9. By reason of the Code
of Civil Procedure
(Amendment) Act, 1976, measures have been taken for
early
disposal
aforementioned
of
the
suits.
In
parliamentary
furtherance
object,
of
the
further
amendments were carried out in the years 1999 and
2002. With a view to put an end to the practice of filing
applications for amendments of pleadings belatedly, a
proviso was added to Order 6 Rule 17 which reads as
under:
“17. Amendment of pleadings.—The court may at any
stage of the proceedings allow either party to alter or
amend his pleading in such manner and on such terms as
may be just, and all such amendments shall be made as
may be necessary for the purpose of determining the real
questions in controversy between the parties : Provided
- 23 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
that no application for amendment shall be allowed after
the trial has commenced, unless the court comes to the
conclusion that in spite of due diligence, the party could
not have raised the matter before the commencement of
trial.””
35. In B.K.Narayana
reported
following
Pillai v. Parameswaran
Pillai
in (2000) 1 SCC 712, this Court referred to the
passage
from A.K.
Gupta
and
Sons
Ltd. v. Damodar Valley Corporation reported in AIR 1967
SC 96 wherein, it was held as follows:—
“4. This Court in A.K. Gupta & Sons Ltd. v. Damodar
Valley Corpn. [AIR 1967 SC 96 : (1966) 1 SCR 796] held:
“The general rule, no doubt, is that a party is not
allowed by amendment to set up a new case or a new
cause of action particularly when a suit on new case or
cause of action is barred: Weldon v. Neal [[L.R.] 19 Q.B.
394 : 56 LJ QB 621]. But it is also well recognised that
where the amendment does not constitute the addition of
a new cause of action or raise a different case, but
amounts to no more than a different or additional
approach to the same facts, the amendment will be
allowed even after the expiry of the statutory period of
limitation : See Charan Das v. Amir Khan [AIR 1921 PC
50 :
ILR
Cal
110]
and L.J.
Leach
and
Co.
Ltd. v. Jardine Skinner and Co. [AIR 1957 SC 357 : 1957
SCR 438]
The principal reasons that have led to the rule last
mentioned are, first, that the object of courts and rules of
procedure is to decide the rights of the parties and not to
punish them for their mistakes (Cropper v. Smith [[L.R.]
- 24 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
26 Ch. 700 : 53 LJ Ch 891 : 51 LT 729]) and secondly,
that a party is strictly not entitled to rely on the statute of
limitation when what is sought to be brought in by the
amendment can be said in substance to be already in the
pleading
sought
to
be
amended (Kisandas
Rupchand v. Rachappa Vithoba Shilwant [ILR (1909) 33
Bom 644 : 11 Bom LR 1042] approved in Pirgonda
Hongonda Patil v. Kalgonda Shidgonda Patil [AIR 1957 SC
363 : 1957 SCR 595]).
The expression ‘cause of action’ in the present
context does not mean ‘every fact which it is material to
be proved to entitle the plaintiff to succeed’ as was said
in Cooke v. Gill [[L.R.] 8 C.P. 107 : 42 LJCP 98 : 28 LT
32] in a different context, for if it were so, no material
fact could ever be amended or added and, of course, no
one would want to change or add an immaterial allegation
by amendment. That expression for the present purpose
only means, a new claim made on a new basis constituted
by
new
facts.
Such
a
view
was
taken
in Robinson v. Unicos Property Corpn. Ltd. [[1962] 2 All
ER 24 (CA)] and it seems to us to be the only possible
view to take. Any other view would make the rule futile.
The words ‘new case’ have been understood to mean ‘new
set of ideas’ : Dornan v. J.W. Ellis and Co. Ltd. [[1962] 1
All ER 303 (CA)] This also seems to us to be a reasonable
view to take. No amendment will be allowed to introduce
a new set of ideas to the prejudice of any right acquired
by any party by lapse of time.”
Again in Ganga Bai v. Vijay Kumar [(1974) 2 SCC 393]
this Court held : (SCC p. 399, para 22)
- 25 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
“The power to allow an amendment is undoubtedly
wide and may at any stage be appropriately exercised in
the
interest
of
justice,
the
law
of
limitation
notwithstanding. But the exercise of such far-reaching
discretionary
powers
is
governed
by
judicial
considerations and wider the discretion, greater ought to
be the care and circumspection on the part of the court.”
In Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram [(1978) 2 SCC
91] it was held : (SCC p. 93, para 4)
“4. It is clear from the foregoing summary of the
main
rules
of
pleadings
that
provisions
for
the
amendment of pleadings, subject to such terms as to
costs and giving of all parties concerned necessary
opportunities to meet exact situations resulting from
amendments, are intended for promoting the ends of
justice and not for defeating them. Even if a party or its
counsel is inefficient in setting out its case initially the
shortcoming can certainly be removed generally by
appropriate steps taken by a party which must no doubt
pay costs for the inconvenience or expense caused to the
other side from its omissions. The error is not incapable of
being
rectified
so
long
as
remedial
steps
do
not
unjustifiably injure rights accrued.”……”
36. In one of the recent pronouncements of this
Court, in the case of Life Insurance Corporation of
India v. Sanjeev Builders Private Limited, Civil Appeal No.
5909 of 2022 dated 01.09.2022, the position of law has
been explained as under:
“70. ….. (ii) All amendments are to be allowed which
are necessary for determining the real question in
controversy provided it does not cause injustice or
- 26 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
prejudice to the other side. This is mandatory, as is
apparent from the use of the word “shall”, in the latter
part of Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC.
(iii) The prayer for amendment is to be allowed
(i) if the amendment is required for effective and
proper adjudication of the controversy between the
parties, and
(ii) to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, provided
(a) the amendment does not result in injustice to the
other side,
(b)
by
the
amendment,
the
amendment
does
not
withdraw
seek
to
parties
seeking
any
clear
admission made by the party which confers a right on the
other side and
(c) the amendment does not raise a time barred
claim, resulting in divesting of the other side of a valuable
accrued right (in certain situations).
(iv) A prayer for amendment is generally required to
be allowed unless
(i) by the amendment, a time barred claim is sought
to be introduced, in which case the fact that the claim
would be time barred becomes a relevant factor for
consideration,
(ii) the amendment changes the nature of the suit,
(iii) the prayer for amendment is malafide, or
(iv) by the amendment, the other side loses a valid
defence.
(v) In dealing with a prayer for amendment of
pleadings,
the
court
approach,
and
is
should
ordinarily
avoid
a
required
hypertechnical
to
be
liberal
- 27 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
especially where the opposite party can be compensated
by costs.
(vi) Where the amendment would enable the court to
pin-pointedly consider the dispute and would aid in
rendering a more satisfactory decision, the prayer for
amendment should be allowed.
(vii)
Where
the
amendment
merely
sought
to
introduce an additional or a new approach without
introducing a time barred cause of action, the amendment
is liable to be allowed even after expiry of limitation.
(viii) Amendment may be justifiably allowed where it
is intended to rectify the absence of material particulars in
the plaint.
(ix) Delay in applying for amendment alone is not a
ground to disallow the prayer. Where the aspect of delay
is arguable, the prayer for amendment could be allowed
and the issue of limitation framed separately for decision.
(x) Where the amendment changes the nature of the
suit or the cause of action, so as to set up an entirely new
case, foreign to the case set up in the plaint, the
amendment must be disallowed. Where, however, the
amendment sought is only with respect to the relief in the
plaint, and is predicated on facts which are already
pleaded in the plaint, ordinarily the amendment is
required to be allowed.
(xi)
Where
the
amendment
is
sought
before
commencement of trial, the court is required to be liberal
in its approach. The court is required to bear in mind the
fact that the opposite party would have a chance to meet
the case set up in amendment. As such, where the
amendment does not result in irreparable prejudice to the
opposite party, or divest the opposite party of an
- 28 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
advantage which it had secured as a result of an
admission
by
the
party
seeking
amendment,
the
amendment is required to be allowed. Equally, where the
amendment is necessary for the court to effectively
adjudicate on the main issues in controversy between the
parties, the amendment should be allowed. (See Vijay
Gupta v. Gagninder Kr. Gandhi, 2022 SCC OnLine Del
1897)”
37. Thus, the Plaintiffs and Defendant are entitled to
amend the plaint, written statement or file an additional
written statement. It is, however, subject to an exception
that by the proposed amendment, an opposite party
should not be subject to injustice and that any admission
made in favour of the other party is not but wrong. All
amendments of the pleadings should be allowed liberally
which
are
necessary
for
determination
of
the
real
controversies in the suit provided that the proposed
amendment does not alter or substitute a new cause of
action on the basis of which the original lis was raised or
defence taken.
38. Inconsistent
and
contradictory
allegations
in
negation to the admitted position of facts or mutually
destructive allegations of facts should not be allowed to
be
incorporated
by
means
of
amendment
to
the
pleadings.
39. In the case on hand, the first suit filed in the
Small Causes Court was
on the premise that the
Defendant as a tenant was in arrears of rent and had
unlawfully inducted sub-tenants in the tenanted premises.
Thus, the Plaintiffs put forward a case, as if, there was a
landlord tenant relationship between the parties. The said
- 29 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
suit came to be dismissed for non-prosecution. Later in
point of time, the present suit came to be filed in the Civil
Court with the prayer that the Plaintiffs be permitted to
redeem the mortgage and take back the possession of the
suit property.
40. It appears that the present suit in which the
courts below permitted the Plaintiffs to amend the plaint
is based on the stance taken by the Defendant in his
written statement filed in the first suit i.e., the Small
Cause Case No. 3 of 2007, which came to be dismissed
for
non-prosecution.
However,
it
appears
that
the
Plaintiffs have not given up their case that the Defendant
is a tenant in the suit property and has inducted subtenants. It is also the case of the Plaintiffs that the
Defendant is in arrears of rent. Thus, the stance of the
Plaintiffs in the present suit is two-fold. First, as regards
the tenant-landlord relationship and secondly, the case of
redemption of mortgage.
41. The pleadings are so poor and pathetic that as a
result, this Court found it extremely difficult to understand
what
the
Plaintiffs
intend
to
say
by
way
of
the
amendment. With lot of effort, ultimately what we have
been able to understand is that the father of the Appellant
Defendant, namely, late Gulab Chand was the mortgagee
of the suit property. The father of the Plaintiffs, namely,
late Harihar Prasad was the mortgagor and he executed a
mortgage deed dated 12.02.1957 in favour of the father
of the Appellant Defendant for a sum of Rs. 700/-. The
grandfather of the Appellant Defendant, namely, late
Laxman Prasad remained in occupation of the suit
property as a tenant from the year 1953 at the rate of Rs.
23 monthly rent and later the father of the Appellant
- 30 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
Defendant occupied the suit property, as a tenant till the
year 2005 i.e., the year of his demise. Thereafter, the
Appellant Defendant became the tenant of the suit
property. What is sought to be conveyed by the Appellant
Defendant is that the grandfather and father of the
Plaintiffs were tenants in the
suit property and a
mortgage deed was also drawn and executed in the year
1957 with respect to the same property. It is also the
case of the Plaintiffs that the Appellant Defendant has
inducted sub-tenants in the suit property.
42. A three-Judge Bench of this Court in the case
of Firm Sriniwas Ram Kumar v. Mahabir Prasad reported
in 1951 SCC 136 : AIR 1951 SC 177, has held that a
party is entitled to take alternative pleas in support of its
case. Where alternative pleas arose to some extent from
the admitted position of the defendant, such plea is not
impermissible merely because it is inconsistent with the
other plea. It held that a plaintiff may rely upon different
rights alternatively and there is nothing in the CPC to
prevent a party from making two or more inconsistent
sets
of
allegations
claiming
relief
therein
in
the
alternative. It further observed that although, a Court
should not grant relief to a plaintiff in a case in which
there is no foundation in a pleading on which the other
side was not called upon or had opportunity to meet yet
when the alternative case which, the plaintiff could have
made was not only admitted by defendant in his written
statement but was expressly put forward as an answer to
the claim which the plaintiff made in the suit, there would
be nothing improper in giving the plaintiff a decree upon
the case which the defendant himself makes.
- 31 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
43. The view that a plaintiff is entitled to plead even
inconsistent pleas while seeking alternative reliefs was
reiterated
by
this
Court
in G.
Nagamma v. Siromanamma reported in (1996) 2 SCC 25.
In that case, a suit for specific performance of an
agreement of re-conveyance was filed by the appellants.
Later, an application for amendment of the plaint was
sought stating that the transactions of execution of sale
deed and obtaining a document for re-conveyance came
to be a single transaction, i.e., it was a mortgage by
conditional sale. So, alternatively plaintiff sought relief to
redeem the mortgage. The trial court and the High Court
rejected the same on the ground that the suit was filed
for specific performance and that the amendment would
change the nature of the suit as well as the cause of
action. But this Court reversed the said decision and held
that since the plaintiff therein was seeking alternative
reliefs, he is entitled to plead even inconsistent pleas and
that the amendment of the plaint would neither change
the cause of action nor would affect the relief.
44. In Praful
Manohar
Rele v. Krishnabai
Narayan
Ghosalkar reported in (2014) 11 SCC 316, this Court
followed the decision in Firm Sriniwas Ram Kumar (supra)
and
reiterated
the
principle
that
alternative
and
inconsistent pleas can be taken by a plaintiff. In that
case, the plaintiff therein had alleged that the defendant
therein and his legal representatives were occupying the
suit
premises
as
gratuitous
licensees
and
upon
termination of such licence, the plaintiff was entitled to a
decree
for
possession.
The
trial
court
found
that
defendants were tenants and not licensees as alleged by
the plaintiff. The 1st Appellate Court recorded a finding to
- 32 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
the contrary, held that the defendants were let into the
suit property by plaintiff on humanitarian grounds and as
gratuitous
licensees
and
the
license
was
validly
terminated by plaintiff. It thus, negatived the defence of
the defendants that they were tenants. In the plaint itself,
the plaintiff therein had taken an alternative plea that he
was entitled to vacant possession of the premises on the
ground of bona fide personal need, nuisance, annoyance
and damage allegedly caused to the premises and to the
adjoining
garden
land
belonging
to
him
by
the
defendants. This Court held that the alternative plea of
plaintiff and the defence set up by defendants was no
different from each other. The Court held that it was open
to the plaintiff not only to take a plea of license but also
to alternatively plead tenancy in support of his plea for
relief of recovery of possession. The Court held that
defendants therein had specifically admitted that the
property belongs to plaintiff and that they were in
occupation thereof as tenants, and an issue was also
framed whether defendants were in occupation as license
or as tenants, and defendants had full opportunity to
prove their respective cases. So, the defendants cannot
be said to have been taken by surprise by the alternative
case pleaded by plaintiff nor could any injustice would
result to them from the alternative plea being allowed and
tried by the Court. It observed that even if the alternative
plea had not been allowed to be raised in the suit filed by
appellant, he would have been certainly entitled to raise
that plea and seek eviction in a separate suit filed on the
very same grounds.
45. In Revajeetu
Builders (supra),
cited
by
the
learned counsel for the Appellant, a two-Judge Bench of
- 33 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
this Court had an occasion to deal with Order 6 Rule
17 CPC In that case, the judgment of this Court in Usha
Balashaheb
Swami v. Kiran
Appaso
Swami reported
in (2007) 5 SCC 602, was followed. It referred to the
judgment in Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram reported
in (1978) 2 SCC 91, wherein at para 50, this Court
observed that if a plaintiff seeks to alter the cause of
action
itself
amendment
and
of
his
introduces
it
indirectly
pleadings,
an
entirely
through
new
or
inconsistent cause of action, amounting virtually to the
substitution of a new plaint or a new cause of action in
place of what was originally there, the Court will refuse to
permit it, if it amounts to depriving the party, against
which a suit is pending, of any right which may have
accrued in its favour due to lapse of time.
46. In
our
considered
opinion,
the
aforesaid
observations also do not come to the aid of the Appellant
herein, inasmuch as, even in the judgment in Ganesh
Trading Co. (supra), it had not referred to the threeJudge Bench judgment of this Court in Firm Sriniwas Ram
Kumar (supra).
47. In the event, if the pleas sought to be introduced
by plaintiff by way of an amendment is also the plea,
which the defendant has set up in his written statement
and such a plea of the plaintiff is an alternative plea, even
though it is inconsistent with the original plea, since there
is no prejudice caused to the defendant, the Court is not
precluded from allowing the amendment.
48. At this stage, we may refer to rely upon the
decision of this Court in the case of State of Madhya
Pradesh v. Union of India reported in (2011) 12 SCC 268.
- 34 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
We quote the relevant observations as contained in para 8
of the judgment:—
“8. The purpose and object of Order 6 Rule 17 of the
Code is to allow either party to alter or amend his
pleadings in such manner and on such terms as may be
just. Amendment cannot be claimed as a matter of right
and under all circumstances, but the courts while deciding
such prayers should not adopt a hypertechnical approach.
Liberal approach should be the general rule, particularly in
cases where the other side can be compensated with
costs. Normally, amendments are allowed in the pleadings
to avoid multiplicity of litigations.”
(Emphasis supplied)
21.
If the application in IA No.1/2025 is examined
bearing in mind the principles enunciated in the aforesaid
judgments, it becomes clear that the proposed amendment
would neither fundamentally change the nature or character
of the suit or its cause of action; nor this proposed
amendment be said to be barred by limitation or have the
effect of taking away a right having stood vested in the
respondents-defendant by lapse of time. So also the
proposed amendment would not have the effect of giving
rise to any fresh claim that would cause detriment to the
defendants. At any rate, all defences available to the
- 35 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
respondents on all aspects of the matter including the
proposed amendment can be adequately safeguarded by
holding that the proposed amendment shall not relate back
to the date of the suit, but shall be recognized/recokned
only from the date of the application and all questions in
relation to the proposed amendment including the plea of
limitation would have to be reconsidered in accordance with
law by leaving all such contentions open. It is needless to
state that the merits/demerits of the proposed amendment
can be controverted by the respondents-defendants by filing
an additional written statement to the amended plaint.
22.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances,
we are of the considered opinion that IA No.1/2025 filed by
the appellant-plaintiff under Order VI Rule 17 CPC deserves
to be allowed and accordingly the same is hereby allowed.
23.
After
having
allowed
IA
No.1/2025
and
permitting the appellant-plaintiff to amend the plaint, the
next aspect that will arise for consideration is the procedure
- 36 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
to
be
followed
by
this
Court
after
permitting
such
amendment. In this context, it is pertinent to note that as
stated supra, one of the reasons for rejecting the claim of
the appellant based on exhibit P34 as assigned by the trial
Court was that there was inadequate pleadings in this
regard. However, having regard to the allowing of IA
No.1/2025
and
permitting
the
appellant-plaintiff
to
incorporate necessary pleadings in relation to exhibit P.34 ,
it is just and appropriate to provide an opportunity to the
respondents-defendants
to
file
their
additional
written
statement to the amended plaint and also permit all parties
to adduce additional oral and documentary evidence in
support of their respective claims and for that purpose, it
would be just and expedient to set aside the impugned
judgment and decree and remit the matter back to the trial
Court for reconsideration afresh in accordance with law as
expeditiously
as
possible
by
leaving/keeping
contentions to be decided by the trial Court.
open
all
- 37 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
24.
As stated earlier, since the proposed amendment
has been allowed and the parties are permitted to file
additional pleadings, it would be appropriate to permit the
parties to adduce additional oral and documentary evidence
in support of their respective claims by setting aside the
impugned judgment and decree and remitting the matter
back to the trial Court for reconsideration afresh in
accordance with law.
25.
Under
these
circumstances,
we
are
of
the
considered opinion that the impugned judgment and decree
passed by the trial Court deserves to be set aside and the
matter is remitted back to the trial Court for reconsideration
afresh in accordance with law. Point Nos.(i) and (ii) are
accordingly answered in favour of the appellant.
26.
Hence, the following :
ORDER
i)
Appeal is hereby allowed.
- 38 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
ii)
IA No.1/2025 filed by the appellantplaintiff under Order VI Rule 17 CPC is
hereby allowed subject to the condition
that the proposed amendment shall not
relate back from the date of the suit
but shall be reckoned/considered from
18.08.2025
on
which
date
the
application IA No.1/2025 is filed by the
appellant-plaintiff;
iii)
The matter is remitted back to the trial
Court
for
reconsideration
afresh
in
accordance with law.
iv)
The parties are directed to appear
before the trial Court on 15.10.2025
without awaiting further notice from
the trial Court.
- 39 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
v)
The
appellant
shall
carry
out
amendment and file amended plaint on
15.10.2015.
vi)
Liberty
is
reserved
in
favour
of
respondent-defendant to file additional
written
statement
to
the
amended
plaint and urge all contentions including
limitation etc.,
vii)
Upon completion of pleadings, the trial
Court shall proceed further and provide
sufficient and reasonable opportunity to
all the parties to adduce additional oral
and documentary evidence and dispose
of the suit in accordance with law as
expeditiously as possible.
viii)
The trial Court is directed to dispose of
the suit and
the
parties shall co-
operate
the
trial
with
Court
for
- 40 NC: 2025:KHC-D:12371-DB
RFA No. 100003 of 2022
HC-KAR
expeditious disposal of the suit and the
trial Court shall dispose of the suit as
expeditiously as possible and having
regard to the long pendency of the suit
and the age of the parties, the trial
Court is directed to dispose of the suit
within a period of 6 months from
15.10.2025.
Sd/(S.R. KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
Sd/(C.M. POONACHA)
JUDGE
KMS-Upto para 9
HMB- Para 10 to end
Ct:vh
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 57
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review