Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 19TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE M.I.ARUN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 102513 OF 2023 (MV-D)
C/W
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 103305 OF 2022 (MV-D)
IN MFA NO.102513 OF 2023:
BETWEEN:
Digitally signed
by V N BADIGER
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
DHARWAD
BENCH
1.
SMT. RUKMINI W/O. CHANDRASHEKAR NAIK,
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. SHIVALLI, PANCHALINGA,
TQ. SIRSI-581 355,
DIST. UTTARA-KANNADA.
2.
GEETA D/O. CHANDRASHEKAR NAIK,
AGE: 27 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. SHIVALLI, PANCHALINGA,
TQ. SIRSI-581 355,
DIST. UTTARA-KANNADA.
3.
KUMAR. RAMACHANDRA
S/O. CHANDRASHEKAR NAIK,
AGE: 24 YEARS, OCC. STUDENT,
R/O. SHIVALLI, PANCHALINGA,
TQ. SIRSI-581 355,
DIST. UTTARA-KANNADA.
-
(BY SRI GIRISH S. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
NWKRTC, GOKUL ROAD, NWKRTC,
HUBBALLI-580 020,
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF LAW OFFICER,
CENTRAL OFFICE, HUBBALLI.
APPELLANTS
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
2.
DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER, N.W.K.R.T.C.,
SIRSI, PIN-581 401.
(BY SRI M.C. HUKKERI, ADVOCATE FOR R1 AND R2)
RESPONDENTS
THIS M.F.A. IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF M.V. ACT,
PRAYING TO MODIFY THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 16.10.2021
PASSED IN M.V.C. NO.114/2020 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL
JUDGE AND ADDITIONAL MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL,
SIRSI, AND ETC.
IN MFA NO.103305 OF 2022:
BETWEEN:
1.
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
N.W.K.R.T.C., GOKUL ROAD, HUBBALLI,
REPRESENTED BY IT’S CHIEF LAW OFFICER,
NWKRTC, CENTRAL OFFICE, HUBBALLI,
[OWNER OF NWKRTC BUS NO.K-25/F-3388].
2.
DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER, N.W.K.R.T.C.,
SIRASI.
-
APPELLANTS
(BY SRI M.C. HUKKERI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SMT. RUKMINI W/O. CHANDRASHEKAR NAIK,
AGE: 46 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. SHIVALLI PANCHALINGA, SIRSI.
2.
KUMARI. GEETA D/O. CHANDRASHEKAR NAIK,
AGE: 26 YEARS, R/O. SHIVALLI PANCHALINGA, SIRSI.
3.
KUMAR. RAMACHENDRA CHANDRASHEKAR NAIK,
AGE: 23 YEARS, R/O. SHIVALLI PANCHALINGA,
SIRSI, AGE. 21 YEARS, OCC. STUDENT.
RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI GIRISH S. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3)
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
THIS M.F.A. IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF M.V ACT,
PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE AWARD DATED 16.10.2021 PASSED IN
M.V.C. NO.114/2020 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND
ADDITIONAL MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, AT: SIRSI, AND
ETC.
THESE APPEALS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
JUDGMENT ON 03.02.2026 COMING ON FOR ‘PRONOUNCEMENT’ THIS
DAY, B. MURALIDHARA PAI J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.I.ARUN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI)
1.
The wife and children of Sri Chandrashekar Timma
Naik filed MVC No.114/2020 before the learned Senior Civil
Judge and Additional MACT, Sirsi (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
Tribunal’), under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, seeking
compensation of Rs.35,00,000/- from the respondents. This was
on the ground that Sri Chandrashekar Timma Naik died due to
injuries sustained in a road traffic accident on 28.09.2019,
caused by the driver of bus No.KA-25-F-3388.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
2.
After contest, the Tribunal partly allowed the claim. It
found actionable negligence on the part of the bus driver and
awarded compensation of Rs.14,06,800/- to the claimants along
with interest at 6% per annum from the date of the petition until
realization.
3.
Dissatisfied
with
the
quantum
of
compensation
awarded by the Tribunal, the claimants have preferred the
appeal in MFA No.102513/2023, seeking enhancement on the
ground that the compensation is inadequate and on the lower
side.
4.
Similarly,
the
respondents
have
impugned
judgment
and
award
MFA
in
challenged
the
No.103305/2022,
contending that the Tribunal awarded excessive compensation
under all heads, without considering relevant aspects, and
erroneously fastened entire liability on them.
5.
Parties to these proceedings are referred to by their
rankings before the Tribunal.
6.
Sri Girish S. Hiremath, learned counsel for the
claimants, submitted that the deceased was aged about 54 years
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
at the time of the accident and was earning more than
Rs.25,000/- per month as an agriculturist and coolie. He
contended that even so, the Tribunal adopted an income of
Rs.12,000/- per month for computing loss of dependency. He
further submitted that the compensation awarded under some
heads is on the lower side and that the Tribunal failed to award
compensation under all relevant heads.
7.
Per contra, Sri M.C. Hukkeri, learned counsel for the
respondents, vehemently submitted that the Tribunal erred in
attributing fault solely to the bus driver though the deceased had
dashed his motorcycle against the bus and thereby contributed
to the accident. He contended that the Tribunal ought to have
held the deceased guilty of at least 50% contributory negligence.
He also contended that the compensation awarded by the
Tribunal is excessive and without basis.
8.
Having heard the submissions on both sides and
perused the materials on record, the following points arise for
determination by this Court:
i)
Whether the deceased had contributed for
the accident?
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
ii)
Whether the Claimants have made out valid
ground to enhance the compensation?
Point Nos. i and ii:
9.
It is undisputed that the deceased Chandrashekar
Timma Naik, met with a road traffic accident on 28.09.2019 at
about 4:50 p.m. on Kumta-Sirsi Road, involving motorcycle No.
KA-31-EB-1318 and bus No. KA-25-F-3388. The deceased was
riding the motorcycle at the time of the accident. Admittedly, the
jurisdictional police investigated the matter and filed a charge
sheet against the bus driver under Sections 279 and 304A of the
IPC, which carries presumptive value. The respondents examined
the bus driver as RW-1 to substantiate their plea of contributory
negligence by the deceased. However, apart from RW-1's selfserving testimony, they adduced no corroborative evidence to
support their version. In these circumstances, this Court finds no
valid ground to interfere with the Tribunal's finding holding the
bus driver solely responsible for the accident. Point No. (i) is
accordingly answered in the negative.
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
10.
The Tribunal has awarded a total compensation of
Rs.14,06,800/- to the claimants under the following heads:
Sl.
No.
Heads of
compensation
1.
Loss of
dependency
2.
Loss of
consortium
3.
Loss of estate
4.
Funeral
expenses
Total
11.
Amount
Rs.
Basis
i)
Monthly
income
Rs.12,000/- plus 10%
future prospects as held
13,06,000.00 in Pranay Sethi’s case
ii) Deduction : 1/3
iii) Multiplier : 11
As per
40,000.00 case
Pranay
Sethi’s
As per
45,000.00 case
Pranay
Sethi’s
As per
15,000.00 case
Pranay
Sethi’s
Interest at the rate of 6%
14,06,800.00 p.a. from the date of
petition till realisation
First of all, there is an apparent arithmetical error in
the calculation made by the Tribunal, while determining the
compensation under the head of loss of dependency. The tribunal
has arrived at the quantum of compensation, in the following
manner: “Rs.12,000/- X 12 = Rs.1,44,000/- plus 10% =
Rs.1,58,400/- minus 1/3rd (Rs.39,600/- to be deducted because
of personal expenditure of the deceased) = Rs.1,18,800/- X 11 =
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
Rs.13,06,800/-“. As per this calculation, the Tribunal ordered to
deduct 1/3rd portion of total income towards the personal
expenses of the deceased. The 1/3rd portion of the total income
i.e., Rs.1,58,400/- comes to Rs.52,800/- and not Rs.39,600/- as
shown in the judgment. If we recalculate the amount based on
above figures, the compensation under the head of loss of
dependency works out to Rs.11,16,600/- (i.e., Rs.13,200/- X 12
= Rs.1,58,400/- minus Rs.52,800/- i.e., Rs.1,05,600/- X 11). In
that event, total compensation awarded under the impugned
judgment comes to Rs.12,61,600/- in place of Rs.14,06,800/shown therein.
12.
It was the case of the claimant that the deceased
was earning more than Rs.25,000/- per month as an agriculturist
and coolie.
However they have not produced any revenue
documents or other document before the Tribunal to prove the
actual income of the deceased at the relevant point of time. As
such the Tribunal considered the income of the deceased at
Rs.12,000/- per month based on normal criteria. Admittedly, the
High Court Legal Services Committee, Dharwad has prepared a
chart specifying notional income to be considered for the purpose
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
of settlement of the cases before the Lok-Adalath.
As per the
said chart, notional income of a person for year 2019 is to be
taken as Rs.13,250/-. In view of the same, this Court opines that
for the purpose of arriving at a just compensation, notional
income of the deceased needs to be taken as Rs.13,250/- per
month.
13.
The Tribunal has opined that the deceased was aged
between 54 to 55 years at the time of accident and applied
multiplier of ‘11’ in the case. There is no dispute regarding age
of the deceased or the multiplier adopted by the tribunal.
14.
In National Insurance Company Limited Vs
Pranay Sethi and Others1 Hon’ble Apex Court has held that in
case the deceased was self employed or on a fixed salary and
aged between 50 to 60 years, an addition of 10% of his proved
income should be taken as future prospects, as the necessary
method of computation. Even the Tribunal has adopted this
method for the purpose of arriving at total income of the
deceased.
This Court having opined need of taking notional
income of the deceased at Rs.13,250/- per month, it requires to
(2017) 16 SCC 680
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
add a sum of Rs.1,325/- (i.e, 10% of Rs.13,250/-) towards
future prospects, so as to arrive at total income of the deceased.
Thus, the total income of the deceased would be Rs.14,575/- per
month.
15.
The deceased has left behind wife and two children.
As such the Tribunal has deducted 1/3rd of the income towards
personal expenses of the deceased, which is also proper. Thus,
net
loss
of
[Rs.19,23,900/-
dependency
(i.e.,
works
out
to
Rs.12,82,600/-
Rs.14,575/-
X
X
11)
minus
Rs.6,41,300/- (i.e., 1/3rd of Rs.19,23,900/-)].
16.
The Tribunal has awarded only a sum of Rs.40,000/-
towards loss of consortium. In Magma General Insurance
Company Ltd. Vs Nanu Ram, reported in (2018) 18 SCC
130, the Hon'ble Apex Court held that "… The right to
consortium would include the company, care, help, comfort,
guidance, solace and affection of the deceased, which is a loss to
his family. With respect to a spouse, it would include sexual
relations with the deceased spouse. .." The Hon'ble Apex Court
further held that "… Most jurisdictions therefore permit parents
to be awarded compensation under loss of consortium on the
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
death of a child and the amount awarded to the parents is a
compensation
for
loss
of
the
love,
affection,
care
and
companionship of the deceased child. …" Thus, it is clear that
compensation
under
the
head
of
consortium
includes
compensation under the head of love and affection.
The
Claimants herein are the wife, daughter and the mother of the
deceased. As such, this Court holds that the Claimants are
entitled for compensation of Rs.40,000/- each under the head of
loss of consortium, i.e. spousal, parental and filial, inclusive of
the compensation under the head of love and affection.
17.
The
Tribunal
has
awarded
compensation
of
Rs.45,000/- under the head of loss of estate and Rs.15,000/under the head of funeral expenses. In view of decision in
National Insurance Co. Ltd vs Pranay Sethi reported in AIR
2017 SUPREME COURT 5157, it is held that the claimants are
entitled for compensation of Rs.15,000/- under the head of loss
of estate in place of Rs.45,000/- awarded by the Tribunal. The
compensation awarded under the head of funeral expenses is not
disturbed.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
18.
The
Tribunal,
relying
General Insurance Company
on
decision
in
Shriram
Vs Smt. Laxmi and others
(MFA No.103557/2016 DD 20.03.2018), held that the Claimants
are entitled for interest on the award amount at the rate of 6%
per annum and that they have not made out valid ground to
order interest on higher rate. This Court does not find any error
committed by the Tribunal in adopting the rate of interest as 6%
per annum. Hence, same is retained.
19.
For the forgoing reasons, Point No.(ii) is answered
partly in the affirmative and held that the Claimants are entitled
for
total
compensation
of
Rs.14,32,600/-
in
place
of
Rs.12,16,600/- awarded by the Tribunal, under the following
heads:
Sl.
No.
Heads
1.
Loss of
dependency
2.
Loss of
Consortium
Amount
Rs.
i)
Monthly
income
Rs.13,250/plus
Rs.1,325/- i.e., addition
of 10% towards future
12,82,600.00 prospects as held in
Pranay Sethi’s case
ii) Deduction : 1/3rd
iii) Multiplier : 11
As
per
Magma
General
Insurance
1,20,000.00
Company case
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
3.
Loss of Estate
As per Pranay Sethi’s
15,000.00 case
4.
Funeral expenses
As per Pranay Sethi’s
15,000.00 case
Interest at the rate of
6% p.a. from the date
14,32,600.00 of
petition
till
realisation
Total
20.
In the result, this Court proceeds to pass the
following:
ORDER
i.
The appeals in MFA No.102513/2023 and MFA
No.103305/2022 are allowed in part.
ii.
The
Claimants
are
entitled
for
total
compensation of Rs.14,32,600/- in place of
Rs.12,61,600/- awarded by the Tribunal.
iii. The enhanced compensation amount shall
carry interest at the rate of 6% per annum
from the date of petition till realization.
iv. The Respondents shall deposit the enhanced
compensation
amount
before
the
Tribunal
within a period of three months from this day.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:2597-DB
MFA No. 102513 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 103305 of 2022
HC-KAR
v.
The Claimants are entitled to withdraw the
enhanced compensation amount on its deposit
in proportion of their share as per the order of
the Tribunal.
vi. The amount deposited if any before this Court
by the Respondents shall be transferred to
concerned Tribunal forthwith.
vii. Draw modified award accordingly.
Sd/(M.I.ARUN)
JUDGE
Sd/(B. MURALIDHARA PAI)
JUDGE
SSP, BVV
CT:BCK
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 2
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review