Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PREM NARAYAN SINGH
ON THE 17th OF JANUARY, 2024
CRIMINAL REVISION No. 1278 of 2020
BETWEEN:VISHNU PATIDAR S/O CHAMPALAL PATIDAR, AGED
ABOUT 48 YEARS, VILLAGE BITHAIR, KASRAWAD
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI NAVENDU JOSHI APPEARED FOR PETITIONER).
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH STATION HOUSE
OFFICER THROUGH P.S. KASRAWAD (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
( MS.VINITA DWIVEDI PL ).
This revision coming on for hearing this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
Heard on the question of admission.
The applicant has filed the instant revision under Section 397 read with
Section 401 of Cr.P.C. against the order dated 15.01.2020, passed by the
learned Special Judge, NDPS Act, District-Nimad, in NDPS Case No. 09/2019,
whereby the application filed by the applicant for seeking interim custody of
motorcycle bearing registration No. MP-10-MU-7991 on supurdginama has
been rejected.
2.
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 23-01-2024
11:35:17
The applicant is the registered owner of the vehicle bearing
registration No. MP-10-MU-7991 that was seized in connection with Crime
No.470/2019 registered at Police Station-Kasravad, District-Khargone, in
respect of offence punishable under Section 8/20 of the NDPS Act.
3. Learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that the applicant is
the registered owner of the aforesaid vehicle. It is further submitted by the
learned counsel for the applicant that there is no criminal antecedent of the
applicant.The said vehicle which is now kept in the police station, be released
on supurdginama otherwise due to its non-use, the same would be useless after
sometime. There is no need to keep the said vehicle in custody. He further
submitted that learned Judge committed mistake in rejecting the prayer of the
applicant and not giving the said vehicle in custody.
4. On the other hand learned counsel for the State has opposed the
prayer of the applicant and has submitted that the applicant's vehicle was found
to be involved in a serious crime registered under NDPS Act and if the vehicle
in question is handed over, the same would be used for commission of another
offence. Accused/applicant is not entitled to get vehicle on Supurdginama.
Learned counsel for the State also submits that aforesaid vehicle cannot be
given on supurdginama under Section 52(A)(ii) of NDPS Act, in view of the
principle laid down in the case of Union of India Vs. Mohanlal and others,
Criminal Appeal No.652/2012 and Section 52(A) (ii) of NDPS Act.
5. Having considered the rival submissions made by the learned counsel
for the parties and perusal of the record, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the vehicle in question may be handed over to the applicant on
supurdginama as applicant is the registered owner of the said vehicle and
conclusion of trial is likely to take sufficient long time. No purpose would be
served to keep the vehicle in question parked in the police station wherein it
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 23-01-2024
11:35:17
would run that risk of deterioration on account of weather and other facts. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai vs. State of
Gujarat reported in (2002) AIR SCW 5301 has held that the articles seized in
any criminal case are not to be kept for long time at Police Station and in any
case for not more than 15 days to one month and the owner of the article
should not suffer because of its remaining unused or misappropriated at Police
Station. Undisputedly, the condition of the vehicle is deteriorating day-by-day,
as the same is lying open to sky and under the heat of sun and rains. The
vehicle is loosing its value day-by-day due to lack of maintenance, natural wear
and tear and passing of time.
6. There is no provision in the NDPS Act to restrict the power of the trial
Court to release the vehicle in interim custody. It has been held by this Court in
the case of Pandurang Kadam Vs. State of M.P. 2005(2) ANJ MP 351 ,
that notwithstanding the fact that the vehicle is liable to be confiscated under
Section 60 of the NDPS Act, it may be released in interim custody in
appropriate cases. Thus, interim custody should not be denied to the owner of
the vehicle, simply because it is liable to be confiscated under Section 60 of the
NDPS Act. The High Court of Tripura, Agartala in the case of Sri Sankar
Das Vs. State of Tripura (Cri. Petition No.9 of 2018, decided on
16.3.2018) has held in paras 9, 10, 11, 12 & 13 as under :-
"[9] Substantively, directions in Union of India vs.
Mohanlal (supra) are concerned with the storage and
disposal of the narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances. However, in Para-31.2 of the said decision in
respect of storage, the reference has been made to
conveyance as well. Similarly, in the notification dated
16.01.2015 the provision has been made for disposal of
the narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, controlled
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 23-01-2024
11:35:17
substances or the conveyances under Section 52A of the
NDPS Act. Clause 4 of the said notification provides as
under:
"4. Manner of disposal - (1) Where any narcotic drug,
ps yc hotr opi c substance, controlled substance or
conveyance has been seized and forwarded to the officerin-charge of the nearest police station or to the officer
empowered under section 53 of the said Act or if it is
seized by such an officer himself, he shall prepare an
inventory of such narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances,
controlled substances or conveyances as per Annexure 1
to this notification and apply to any Magistrate under subsection 9(2) of section 52A of the said Act as per
Annexure 2 to this notification within thirty days from the
date of receipt of chemical analysis report of seized
narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances or controlled
substances.
(2) After the Magistrate allows the application under
sub-section (3) of section 52A of the said Act, the officer
mentioned in sub-paragraph (1) shall preserve the
certified inventory, photographs and samples drawn in the
presence of the Magistrate as primary evidence for the
case and submit details of the seized items to the
Chairman of the Drug Disposal Committee for a decision
by the Committee on the disposal, and the aforesaid
officer shall send a copy of the details along with the
items seized to the officer- in-charge of the godown."
[10] The question, therefore, emerges is that whether
the Magistrate under sub Section 52A (2) has any
authority to direct disposal?
Bare reading of the said provision would show no such
direct authority has given to the Magistrate. According to
the said notification dated 16.01.2015 power of the Drug
Disposal Committee has been authorized to dispose [see
para-7] but no reference in respect of the disposal of the
conveyance is available except to include the word
'conveyance'. That perhaps be the reason why the special
court has refused to release the vehicle. But the authority
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 23-01-2024
11:35:17
can be derived if Section 60(3) and Section 63 of the
NDPS Act are read for this purpose.
[11] Let us further examine whether the said provision
is self- contained code. From the reading of the entire
notification dated 16.01.2015, it would appear that the
Drug Disposal Committee has no other power except to
act in the mode as prescribed for disposal, as provided in
Para-9(5) (e). The following mode has been provided:
"(e) seized conveyances shall be sold off by way of
tender or auction as determined by the Drug Disposal
Committee."
Such disposal in terms of the Para-9(5)(e) only be
possible after the confiscation proceeding is complete.
Without confiscation, the disposal of the seized
conveyance within the scheme of the NDPS Act, 1985
cannot be visualized and as such, the ancillary question
that emerges is that whether the said notification has
provided a mechanism for disposal without confiscation
inasmuch as Section 60(3) has clearly provided that 'any
animal or conveyance used in carrying any narcotic drug
or psychotropic substance or controlled substance or any
article liable to confiscation under sub Section (1) or sub
Section (2) of Section 60 shall be liable to confiscation
unless the owner of the animal or the conveyance proves
that it was so used without the knowledge or connivance
of the owner himself, his agent if any and the person in
charge of the animal or conveyance and that each of them
had taken all reasonable precautions against such use.
[12] It is thus apparent that Section 60(3) of the NDPS
Act has made provision for protecting the interest of an
innocent owner before confiscating his vehicle. The
procedure of confiscation has been made under Section
60(3) of the NDPS Act which provides that in the trial of
offences under the NDPS Act, whether the accused is
convicted or acquitted or discharged the Special Court
shall decide whether any article or thing seized under this
act is liable to confiscation under Sections 60,61 or 62
and if it decides that that the seized articles or things are
liable to be confiscated it may order confiscation
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 23-01-2024
11:35:17
accordingly. The procedure for confiscation has been
further elaborated under sub Section 2 of Section 63 of the
NDPS Act. A substantive reading of Section 63 read with
Section 60(3) of the NDPS Act would provide that until
the trial is over the confiscation proceeding cannot be
initiated. However, exception has been curved out in
proviso-es to sub Section 2 of Section 63 of the NDPS
Act. The first proviso provides that no order of
confiscation of an article or thing shall made be made
until the expiry of one month from the date of seizure, or
without hearing any person who may claim any right
thereto and the evidence, if any, which he produces in
respect of his claim. The second proviso to sub-Section 2
of Section 63 of the NDPS Act provides further that if any
such article or thing, other than a narcotic drug,
psychotropic substance, controlled substance, the opium
poppy, coca plant or cannabis plant is liable to speedy
and natural decay, or if the court is of opinion that its sale
would be for the benefit of its owner, it may at any time
direct it to be sold.
[13] A conjoint reading of proviso-es as referred above
would certainly allow a prudent person to infer that
immediate disposal would mean the disposal after expiry
of one month and that would apply to articles or things
other than the narcotic drugs, psychotropic substance,
controlled substances, the opium poppy, coca plant or
cannabis plant which are liable to speedy and natural
decay. If the court is of the opinion that sale would be
beneficial for its owner it may any time direct it to be
sold. In that event the Drug Disposal Committee shall
make all arrangements for sale of those things or articles.
So far the conveyance [of which ownership has been
claimed] is concerned, its involvement in carrying out the
offence has to be proved in the trial and on such proof, the
proceeding for confiscation may ensue in terms of Section
63(1) of the NDPS Act and the confiscation only be made
after affording a reasonable opportunity of being heard to
the person who has any right or claim over the said
conveyance. Such confiscation can be done only after the
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 23-01-2024
11:35:17
trial is complete and the Special Court decides for
confiscation as the court is to see that the vehicle or
conveyance which was used for commission of offence
under the NDPS Act is not made available to the person
o r persons who indulged in the blameworthy act. If the
owner of the vehicle is not an accused in that case, a
separate and independent proceeding has to be drawn for
confiscation in terms of the express provisions in Section
60(3) of the NDPS Act to protect an innocent owner
before confiscating his vehicle or conveyance. Thus, there
is a right to the owner who claimed within 30[thirty] days
from the day of seizure, his title over the vehicle to have
interim custody of the said vehicle subject to the adequate
security till completion of the trial. In absence of any
contrary provision in Union of India vs. Mohanlal (supra),
this Court is of the view that the vehicle bearing
registration No.TR-01-AT-0341 as seized in connection
with Khowai P.S. Case No. No.2017/KHW/128 may be
released to its registered owner till completion of the
trial."
So, it is evident that trial Court is empowered to release the vehicle on
supurdginama in pending trial.
7. There is no evidence on record to show that applicant has criminal
past and he was involved in similar crimes in the past too. If the seized vehicle
is kept lying at the Police Station, the value of the said vehicle would be
diminished and the parts of the vehicle would be destroyed. Here it is also
pertinent to mention that this vehicle could be subject to confiscation in future
after trial, hence some surety of cash amount is required to be deposited before
releasing of the same. The vehicle is registered in the year 2017, therefore, it
would be appropriate to release the vehicle at Supurdiginama after taking cash
security of Rs.50,000/- along with other security.
8 . Accordingly, the present application is allowed and the impugned
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 23-01-2024
11:35:17
order dated 15.01.2020, passed by the learned Special Judge, (NDPS Act),
District-Nimad, in NDPS Case No. 09/2019, is hereby set aside. It is directed
that the vehicle of the applicant bearing registration No.MP-10-MU-7991 be
released on following terms & conditions :-
1. That, applicant shall furnish Supurdginama in the sum
o f Rs.50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand only) in the
form of fixed deposit in a nationalized bank and
producing the receipt/certificate of the same before
the concerned trial Court with one surety in the like
amount to the satisfaction of the concerned CJM/trial
Court, for releasing the seized said vehicle vide Crime
No.470/2019, registered at Police Station-Kasravad,
District-Khargone, in respect of offence punishable under
Section 8/20 of the NDPS Act. The said amount shall be
subject to the final outcome of the case by the trial Court.
The deposit receipt/certificate so produced by the
applicant shall be endorsed by the learned Judge of the
lower Court to be, 'furnished towards Supurdginama and
shall be subject to the final decision of the case by the
trial Court'.
2. That, the applicant shall produce necessary documents
like original registration certificate, sale-letter etc. before
the trial Court.
3 . That, the applicant shall get the vehicle photographs
showing the registration number as well as the chassis
number of the said vehicle. Such photographs shall be
taken in the presence of the responsible officer, who will
be deputed by the trial Court and to be kept in the file of
the case.
4. That, the photographs of the applicant as well as surety
must have been placed in the personal bond and bond of
surety. Further, the photograph of person identifying him
before the Court must also have been placed in the
personal bond.
The applicant surety and person
identifying shall carry their full residential proof.
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 23-01-2024
11:35:17
5 . The applicant shall undertake not to transfer the
ownership of the vehicle and shall not lease it to anyone
and not make or allow any changes in it to be made so as
to make unidentifiable.
6. The applicant will not allow the vehicle to be used in
any anti-social activities.
7 . In the event of confiscation order of the Court
competent, the applicant shall keep the vehicle present
positively for confiscation.
9. It is further directed that before releasing the vehicle in interim custody
of applicant, the S.H.O. of concerning police station shall get photographs size
18 x 12 inches of the concerned vehicle taken from all sides and also the
photographs showing engine and chassis numbers. Such photographs shall be
filed in the trial Court to be kept along with the record.
With the aforesaid directions, this petition stands disposed of.
Certified copy as per rules.
(PREM NARAYAN SINGH)
JUDGE
VD
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 23-01-2024
11:35:17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review