The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. Perused the record. It appears that, acting on a secret information, PW1 informant intercepted Innova vehicle bearing No.MH-03-BC-2713. PW1 claims that when the vehicle was intercepted, two persons attempted to flee, but were chased and caught hold. Two ladies were found occupying the vehicle. The apprehended persons gave their names as Shersing and Vishal. In search of the vehicle, they were found to be carrying plastic bags from -7- CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026 where strong pungent odor was emanating and on inquiry, accused persons told that the said contraband was Ganja and, therefore, further procedure was undertaken. Thus, primarily, disclosure of contraband seems to be from the accused while in custody of police. Though PW1 claims that two running persons were apprehended, PW10 Investigating Officer, in his cross-examination, unable to name the police officer, who apprehended them while they were fleeing away from the spot. Again, as submitted, the panch witnesses to the seizure have not supported the prosecution. Though, as pointed out, the C.A. report refers to flowering tops, the inventory drawn by the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class refers to dry and wet leaves and seeds, which are dark greenish and brownish in colour. Thus prima facie there are no flowering tops, which constitute Ganja. Therefore, at least there are grounds to be dealt in appeal. Moreover…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:51369
-1-
CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 1998 OF 2025
IN
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 418 OF 2025
Shersing s/o Ambu Indrekar
Age: 36 years, Occu.: Driver,
R/o. Galli No.9, Baluchi Galli,
Naregaon, Aurangabad
… Applicant
Versus
State of Maharashtra
Through Police Inspector,
Police Station, Harsool,
District Aurangabad
… Respondent
...
WITH
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO.4098 OF 2026
IN
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.627 OF 2025
Vishal s/o Chagan Tamchikar
Age: 54 years, Occu.: Labour,
R/o. Baluchi Lane No.09, Naregaon,
Taluka and District Aurangabad.
.. Applicant
Versus
The State of Maharashtra
Through the Officer In Charge,
Harsool Police Station,
Taluka and District Chh. Sambhajinagar
.. Respondent
-2-
CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026
…..
Mrs. Rashmi S. Kulkarni, Advocate for the Applicant in Criminal
Application No.1998 of 2025.
Mr. Hashmi S. Ubaid h/f Mr. Ramankumar G. Dodiya, Advocate for
Applicant in Criminal Application No.4098 of 2026.
Mr. V. V. Jahagirdar, APP for the Respondent-State in both the
matters.
.....
CORAM :
ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.
RESERVED ON : 21.10.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 23.10.2026
ORDER :
.
The present applications seek suspension of sentence awarded
to the applicants in Special (NDPS) Case No.429 of 2020 by the
learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No.6, Aurangabad vide
judgment and order dated 11.04.2025, thereby convicting the
applicants for the offence punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) and
29 of the of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act,
1985 (NDPS Act). The applicants have also prayed for their release on
bail.
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO.4098 OF 2026 :2.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
applicant
pointed
out
that
applicant/accused No.2 was arrested on 01.10.2020. That, as on
today, he has suffered almost six years incarceration. That, learned
trial Court has granted 14 years imprisonment to the applicant.
-3-
CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026
Learned Counsel for the applicant apprised this Court about the story
of prosecution in trial Court and would submit that the applicant was
said to be behind wheels of the vehicle, which was allegedly owned
by PW5 and though said witness deposed that accused No.1 was
driver, there is no iota of evidence to substantiate that there was
employment or engagement of accused No.1 in the capacity of driver
of PW5. Learned Counsel for the applicant next submitted that even
alleged seizure in the gunny bags, according to investigating
machinery, were herbs, which are dark brown in colour having
strong/pungent smell. That, Investigating Officer has admitted that
leaves were wet. That, while drawing inventory before the learned
Judicial Magistrate First Class, there were no fruiting of flowering
tops, which are essential to hold that the contraband was only and
only Ganja. Learned Counsel for the applicant invited attention of this
Court to the definition of Ganja as provided in NDPS Act. She next
submitted that there are no criminal antecedents. She pointed out
that there is prima facie suspicion over inventory drawn by the
learned Magistrate as the inventory panchanama is silent about
fruiting top. Further, it is submitted that independent panchas have
not supported the prosecution rendering the seizure doubtful.
Consequently, it is her submission that there is incorrect appreciation
of evidence as well as law by the learned Trial Court while convicting
-4-
CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026
the accused and as such, there is challenge to the judgment of
conviction, but the appeal being of 2025 i.e. recent one, she urges for
relief of suspension of sentence and grant of bail.
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO.4098 OF 2026 :3.
Learned Counsel for the applicant would submit that the
applicant is arraigned as accused No. 1 and has been falsely
implicated merely on the ground that he was travelling in the vehicle,
which was allegedly seized. He pointed out that the owner of the
vehicle, PW5, merely deposed that accused No. 2 was his driver, and,
as such, the role of the applicant/accused No. 1 is not clear. He
further pointed out that the panch witnesses to the seizure have not
supported the prosecution. He also pointed out that the police
witnesses have given different versions regarding the direction in
which the vehicle in question was proceeding. He further submitted
that the applicant was on bail during the trial and did not misuse the
liberty granted to him during that period. He also submitted that
there are no criminal antecedents against the applicant. He submitted
that the applicant has a good case on merits in the appeal.
.
In support of above contentions, both learned Counsel for the
respective applicants seek reliance on the following judgments :-
-5-
I.
CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026
Killo Subbarao and others v. State of Andhra
Pradesh, 2025 SCC OnLine AP 2280;
II.
Akshay v. State of Maharashtra and Mithun Pralhad
Chavan
and
Ors.
v.
State
of
Maharashtra,
MANU/MH/3744/2022;
III.
Narcotic Control Bureau v. Lakhwinder Singh,
MANU/SC/0178/2025;
IV.
Mohammad Jakir Nawab Ali v. The State of
Maharashtra, [Criminal Application (BA) No.602 of
2024 decided on 20.09.2024];
V.
Satender Kumar Antil v. Central Bureau of
Investigation and Ors., MANU/SC/0851/2022;
VI.
Sanjay Kesram Pawara and another v. The State of
Maharashtra, [Bail Application No.797 of 2025
decided on 30.06.2025];
VII.
Anil Gujarya Pawara and another v. The State of
Maharashtra, [Bail Application No.1170 of 2025
decided on 17.07.2025];
4.
Per
contra,
learned
APP
would
strongly
opposed
the
applications on the ground that huge quantity of Ganja was found in
possession of accused persons. That, the applicants are main accused.
That, on complete appreciation of evidence, conviction has been
recorded. On the ground of long incarceration, he would submit that
if at all applicants are desirous of conducting the appeals, the
-6-
CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026
prosecution is ready for the same.
5.
Heard. Here is an application for suspension of sentence of
applicant Shersing primarily on the ground that there is long
incarceration. The seizure is comprising of wet leaves and seeds and
there is no description of flowering tops at the time of seizure, which
attracts the definition of Ganja. Thirdly, the inventory prepared by
learned Judicial Magistrate First Class is contrary to the seizure, as it
is silent on the point of fruiting tops.
.
Whereas, applicant Vishal seeks relief of suspension of sentence
and grant of bail on the ground that no role is attributed to him
except for travelling in the vehicle allegedly carrying contraband with
three other persons also in it. He also pressed present application on
the ground of parity, as two ladies are already granted bail by this
Court.
6.
Perused the record. It appears that, acting on a secret
information, PW1 informant intercepted Innova vehicle bearing
No.MH-03-BC-2713. PW1 claims that when the vehicle was
intercepted, two persons attempted to flee, but were chased and
caught hold. Two ladies were found occupying the vehicle. The
apprehended persons gave their names as Shersing and Vishal. In
search of the vehicle, they were found to be carrying plastic bags from
-7-
CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026
where strong pungent odor was emanating and on inquiry, accused
persons told that the said contraband was Ganja and, therefore,
further procedure was undertaken. Thus, primarily, disclosure of
contraband seems to be from the accused while in custody of police.
Though PW1 claims that two running persons were apprehended,
PW10 Investigating Officer, in his cross-examination, unable to name
the police officer, who apprehended them while they were fleeing
away from the spot. Again, as submitted, the panch witnesses to the
seizure have not supported the prosecution. Though, as pointed out,
the C.A. report refers to flowering tops, the inventory drawn by the
learned Judicial Magistrate First Class refers to dry and wet leaves
and seeds, which are dark greenish and brownish in colour. Thus
prima facie there are no flowering tops, which constitute Ganja.
Therefore, at least there are grounds to be dealt in appeal. Moreover,
applicant Shersing is behind bars since six years. Applicant Vishal was
on bail during the trial and there is no adverse remark against him
regarding non-cooperation during trial. There are no reported
criminal antecedents against either of the applicants. Two other
female accused have already been granted the benefit of suspension
of sentence and bail. Therefore, for the aforesaid reasons, the
applicants succeed. Hence, the following order :-
-8-
CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026
ORDER
I.
Criminal Applications stand allowed.
II.
The substantive sentences imposed on the applicant in
Criminal Application No.1998 of 2025 i.e. Shersing s/o
Ambu Indrekar and applicant in Criminal Application
No.4098 of 2026 i.e. Vishal s/o Chagan Tamchikar in
Special (NDPS) Case No. 429 of 2020 by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, Court No.6, Aurangabad on
11.04.2025 stand suspended till the final hearing and
disposal of Criminal Appeal No.418 of 2025 and Criminal
Appeal No.627 of 2025 respectively.
III.
The applicants be released on P.R. Bonds of Rs.15,000/(Rupees Fifteen Thousand Only) each, with two solvent
sureties in the like amount each.
IV.
The applicants shall not indulge in any criminal activity.
V.
The applicants shall remain present before the learned
trial Judge once in six months, till the final hearing and
disposal of the appeals, commencing from the date they
tender their bail papers, and thereafter, the learned trial
Judge shall fix dates for their subsequent appearances.
VI.
In case of two consecutive defaults on the part of the
applicants in remaining present before the trial court, the
trial court shall inform this Court about the same, and in
that eventuality, the prosecution shall be at liberty to file
-9-
CriAppln-1998-2025 and 4098-2026
applications for cancellation of the bail granted to the
applicants.
VII.
Bail before the trial court.
[ ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J. ]
scm
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review