Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND PATHAK
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 10745 of 2023
Between:1.
2.
3.
VIRENDRA SINGH RANA S/O SHRI KARAN SINGH
RANA, AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
PRINCIPAL AT VIVEKANAND SCHOOL, TCP,
TEKANPUR, DABRA R/O BAJRANG GADH KI
PULIYA SIKANDAR KAMPO MADHOGANJ
DISTRICT GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
SHAMBHUNATH DEY S/O LATE SHRI HARIHAR
DEY, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
VICE PRINCIPAL AT VIVEKANAND SCHOOL,
TEKANPUR, DABRA R/O GARHWAL COLONY,
TCP BAIRAGARH, BILAUVA DIST. GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
SHILPI SOLANKI D/O SHRI RAKESH SINGH
SOLANKI,,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION: TEACHER AT VIVEKANAND
SCHOOL, TEKANPUR DABRA R/O GARHWAL
COLONY, TCP BAIRAGARH, BILAUVA DIST.
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI HARSHIT SHARMA -ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
2.
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
POLICE STATION BILLOWA DISTRICT GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
SMT. PHOOLWATI KUSHWAHA W/O SHRI KARAN
SINGH KUSHWAH, AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOME MAKER, R/O VILLAGE
POST RIDHAULI PAWAI TEHSIL ATER DIST.
BHIND CURRENTLY R/O DAUJI KA PURA
KALYANI, P.S. ANTRI, DIST. GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI VEERENDRA SINGH PAL -DY. ADVOCATE GENERAL
AND SHRI ARSHAD ALI – ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
:
29-08-2023
Delivered on
:
24-01-2024
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This petition having been heard and reserved for orders coming on for
pronouncement this day, delivered the following:-
ORDER
1.
The present petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. is preferred by the
petitioner seeking following reliefs:
“1. May it please this Hon'ble Court, the Petitioner
humbly prays for:
a. That this Hon'ble court may kindly be pleased to allow
this Petition and Charge sheet bearing Challan No. 01
filed in relation to the F.I.R. bearing Crime No. 371/2022
registered on 04th November, 2022 lodged at Police
Station Bilauva, District Gwalior, M.P. for the offence
alleged u/s. 306, 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 as
well as all other consequential proceedings arising
therewith qua the present petitioners in relation to the
aforesaid crime number, may kindly be quashed and set
aside.
b. For such further and other relieves as this Hon'ble
Court may deem fit be granted.”
2.
Petitioner No.1 is Principal of Vivekanand School, Tekanpur, Dabra
District Gwalior, petitioner No.2 is Vice -Principal of Vivekanand
School, Tekanpur, Dabra District Gwalior and petitioner No.3 is
Teacher at
Vivekanand School, Tekanpur, Dabra District Gwalior.
Petitioners are taking exception to registration of FIR and trial
conducted as referred above.
3.
Case of the prosecution as disclosed from the details scribed in the FIR
dated 04-11-2022 containing the allegations that the deceased
Mahendra Kushwah alias Rohit Kushwah used to study in Class 12 th in
Vivekanand Higher Secondary School, TCP. Around 10:35 am school
had lunch interval and thereafter classes reassembled. 15 minutes
thereafter, some boys blasted some crackers in the school toilet which
created disturbance in the classes. School management immediately
responded, searched bags and pockets of the students and found
students namely, Mahendra Kushwah, Ritik Raj and Ashish Yadav as
mischievous students. They were taken before the Principal of the
school namely Virendra Singh Rana – petitioner No.1 herein. He
admonished them for their conduct and as alleged petitioner No.2
talked to their parents and asked them to visit the Principal next day, so
that parents may be apprised about the misconduct of their children.
Apparently, this way, a psychological pressure is mounted on students
to behave properly in future.
4.
Being disturbed by such admonition and alleged insult, Mahendra
Kushwah (one of the students) went to his house and in afternoon
around 3:30 pm he committed suicide
by hanging himself. On
complaint, case was registered against the petitioners for offence under
Sections 306 and 34 of IPC.
5.
Matter was investigated in which petitioners were implicated as
accused and after investigation, charge-sheet was filed. The said
charge-sheet is under challenge by way of this petition.
6.
It is the submission of learned counsel for the petitioners that
petitioners are teachers of the school where deceased pupil Mahendra
Kushwah was studying. The deceased caused nuisance in the school
with his friends by blasting crackers in bathroom of the school
whereby wall of the bathroom got damaged, then to protect the interest
of other students, deceased was admonished for the same. A call was
made to the house of Mahendra Kushwah at mobile No.9516999146
and parents of other two students and parents were directed to remain
present on the next day to avoid repetition of such event. Therefore,
whole exercise was done as a measure to protect the other students and
to make erring pupil realized their misconduct. School authorities are
meant for this purpose and therefore, there was no element of abetment
as such as per Section 107 of IPC.
7.
It is further submitted by learned counsel for the petitioners that by
admonition, the children were persuaded or even compelled to behave
in proper manner so that they can learn good values from the school
and become good citizen. It is not a case where petitioners
intentionally harboured a notion against the deceased. In fact, no
physical torture or violence is being made. It is a case of simple
imposing social control by way of scolding.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioners argued at length and relied upon the
judgment of Apex Court in the case of Geo Varghese Vs. State of
Rajasthan and another, (2021) 19 SCC 144. According to him, said
case also bears discussion of almost similar set of facts and therefore,
applies in the present case.
He also relied upon the judgment of
Bombay High Court in the case of Ms. Rekha alias Vidhila Faldessai
Vs. State Through PP, 2023 SCC OnLine Bom 271. It is not a case
of even corporal punishment. He further relied upon the judgment of
Apex Court in the case of Sathish Mehra Vs. State of N.C.T. of Delhi
and Anr. 2013 Cri.L.J. 411 and the judgment of this Court in the case
of Ravikant Vs. State of M.P. and another, 2014 (1) MPLJ (Cri.)
282 to submit that at later stage of trial even petition under Section 482
of Cr.P.C. is maintainable.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioners by way of synopsis referred
different types of Social Controls to be exercised over a child and it
includes Shaming also. Therefore, petitioners did not abet or instigate
deceased in any manner.
10.
Learned counsel for the respondent/State opposed the prayer.
According to counsel for the respondent/State, trial will unfold the
truth because nature of culpability is to be seen by way of evidence. He
relied upon the judgment of Apex Court in the case of Central Bureau
of Investigation Vs. Aryan Singh Etc. 2023 SCC OnLine SC 379.
11.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2/complainant also opposed the
prayer and submitted that trial is going on and evidence of some of the
witnesses have taken place. Therefore, at this stage, no case for
interference is made out. Child of complainant committed suicide
because of scolding
of petitioners.
Therefore, being sensitive in
nature, deceased committed suicide. If petitioners would not have
scolded him then he would not have committed suicide. Their role is
apparent for instigation. He relied upon the judgment of Apex Court in
the case of Manik B. Vs. Kadapala Sreyes Reddy and Anr. passed
in SLP No.2924 of 2023. He prayed for dismissal of this petition.
12.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and considered the
documents appended thereto.
13.
This is a tragic case where a young boy committed suicide. Really
painful for the family and for the society when such young life was
consumed by the vagaries of life in such manner.
14.
However still question arises “Whether the alleged act of scolding
and reprimand of a Student by a Teacher would be an Attempt of
Course Correction or would Constitute an Offence”.
15.
In earlier days it is usually called “spare the rod and spoil the child”. In
vernacular school premises, it is gloriously reiterated “NM+h iM+s Nek&Ne]
fo+द vk;s ?kek&/ke^^. In a way corporal punishment was the only mode of
course correction. Earlier Vedic Gurukuls and Jesutis' induced Convent
Schools engaged in giving harsh punishment as they believed in such
measures as the only mode for course correction. But with time, things
changed.
16.
Later on, many other ways of course correction were employed. Now a
days, corporal punishment is banned by virtue of Section 2(24) read
with Section 82 of Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children)
Act, 2015 which provides punishment in terms of fine and disciplinary
action for first offence and for subsequent offence with imprisonment
for three months.
17.
However to correct the deviant nature of individuals specially school
going children, different tools in form of Social Control are devised.
Social Control Theory is one of the facets of Sociology as well as
Criminology which provides ways to correct a deviant nature of
individual by use of various modes. It bifurcates into Formal Social
Control (through law, police, institution, officer, organization etc.) and
Informal Social Control which includes different mechanism.
18.
As per Chekroun, 2008 p. 214 as contained in HelpfulProfessor.com,
Informal Social Control is the sanctioning of an individual by a peer....
or a group member, someone with the same or with a different social
status ….whose specific social role or social function is not to sanction
the transgression of social norms.
19.
Different Informal Social Controls have been prescribed which
includes Shaming a peer and Praising a student for their hard work.
Following
Informal
Social
Control
examples
are
given
by
SanamVaghefi (Ph.D. Candidate) a peer reviewed by Chris Drew
(Ph.D.) 2023. The said authors referred 16 examples of Informal Social
Control along with definition, they are as under.
1.
Shaming: Shaming is an informal type of social control which is
often applied by someone's peers, social group or society to
discourage their behaviors or attitudes that are seen as socially
unacceptable.
2.
Praising: Praisal is an informal social control strategy which
often takes place in interpersonal contexts to encourage the
continuity of a behavior or a trend.
3.
Gossiping: Gossiping is a collective form of informal social
control which can create social pressure on individuals. Talking
about someone behind their back can lead to their stigmatization
and/or social exclusion from a community.
4.
An Aggressive Comment: Making an aggressive comment can
be an informal social control against unwanted or deviant social
behavior or trends.
5.
A Personal Insult: Insulting is a negative form of informal
social control which is a reaction to deviant or unwanted
behavior.
6.
A Polite Comment: Making a polite comment can be an
informal means of either encouraging or discouraging an attitude.
7.
An Angry Look: Looking to someone in an angry way is a nonverbal reaction which can be considered an informal social
control mechanism as it shows discontent.
8.
A Loud Audible Sigh: Sighing loudly and audibly is a nonverbal way of reacting to an unwanted situation, which can be
classified as a way of informal social control (Chekroun, 2008).
9.
Physical Aggression: In some communities, physical aggression
against someone who behaves in an unwanted or deviant way
can be an informal social control strategy. However in some
other contexts, physical aggression itself can be considered a
deviant behavior too.
10.
Informal Dress Codes: Informal dress codes are unwritten
expectations about how to dress somewhere, which is asserted by
how the majority dresses. These unwritten expectations can be
considered
as
a
type
of
informal
social
control.
11.
Ignoring: Ignoring someone who behaves in a socially
unacceptable way is a form of informal social control which can
be an effective way of discouraging certain behaviors or
attitudes.
12.
Encouraging: Encouraging someone to engage in positive
behaviors or attitudes is an informal social control strategy which
can reinforce desirable behaviors or trends.
13.
Social Support: Social support is a form of informal social
control which can be used to promote positive behaviors or
attitudes, by providing encouragement and reinforcement.
14.
Nonverbal Cues: Nonverbal cues, such as shaking one's head or
rolling one's eyes, can be an informal means of expressing
disapproval or disagreement.
15.
Humor: Humor can be used as a form of informal social control
to discourage unwanted or deviant behavior, by making light of
the situation and defusing tension.
16.
Peer Feedback: When peers, rather than teachers or other
authority figures, give each other negative or positive feedback
about their actions or performance.
20.
According to Sociologist Albert Hunter there are three types of
Informal Social Controls which can be categorized as Private,
Parochial and Public. According to Hunter's categorization, they are as
follows:
i.
Private Social Control is enforced by friends and family.
ii.
Parochial Social Control is enforced by close contacts such as
neighbours and colleagues.
iii.
21.
Public Social Control is maintained by one fellow citizens.
In Sociology we tend to look four types of norms that can affect our
behaviours:
Type
of
Norms
Description
Mode of Enforcement
Folkways Folkways are customs that we Informal Social Control:
Social pressure, social
follow but are often not written inclusion,
gossiping,
down. We learn them through praising etc.
intuition as we grow up.
Mores
Mores are moral norms. If you Informal Social Control:
Ignoring,
shunting,
break them, you would be seen as gossiping etc.
not just in poor taste, but
immoral. They're often linked to
religious rules.
Taboos
Taboos are 'negative norms' - Informal Social Control:
Shock, gasps, group,
things that people find offensive exclusion,
avoidance,
and socially inappropriate if you gossip, parental guidance.
are caught doing them.
Laws
Laws are norms that are actually Formal Social Control:
Fines,
Imprisonment,
defined as being legal or illegal. community service.
The government has decided
these norms are so important that
you could get in trouble for
breaking them.
22.
The purpose of above discussion in the present case is that all these
Informal Social Controls are those mechanisms (some of them may be
disapproved) by which a person can be kept under control without
resorting to legal procedure. Since teachers in the present case were
having mantle of mentoring students, therefore, they have to resort to
such type or related to such type of Informal ways of control to guide
and mentor the students. Such Informal Social Controls if applied to
guide the students then it can not be said to be Abetment or Instigation.
23.
In society in general type of five means of Informal Social Control are
Shaming, Praising, Gossiping, Physical Aggression and Informal Dress
Codes. Although, some of the Informal Social Controls cannot be
given approval in our societal surroundings.
24.
In sum and substance, children are required to be tutored not only to be
good in academics but they ought to be tutored to become a good
citizen so that they may add to the assets of the society rather than
becoming liability. If corporal punishment is banned and if child out of
his curiosity or ignorance or peer pressure (which is very high in
school days) commits any deviant behaviour or unaccepted way of
pupilship, then he is required to be corrected by measured reprimand or
scolding. Reason is obvious. To take him over the right path so that his
conduct may not become an example for others to follow or a source of
agony for others to suffer.
25.
Section 89 of IPC contemplates a situation where any act done in good
faith for the benefit of any child or insane person by or without consent
of guardian is provided is required to be seen in pragmatic manner.
Since school is a place where children of below 12 years of age are
also getting education, therefore, it is prime duty of the Principal and
other Teachers to maintain discipline and peaceful atmosphere in the
premises so that other children may not suffer adversely and grow
holistically.
26.
Now the controversy is to be seen from this vantage point. In the
present case, allegations against the petitioners are that they scolded
and reprimanded the deceased in such a manner where he committed
suicide. As per CCTV footage (submitted by petitioners but omitted by
Investigation in charge-sheet), it is obvious that the deceased Mahendra
Kushwah, Ashish Yadav and Ritik Raj were present in the school when
crackers blast occurred in the school's bathroom which caused damage
to the wall. Attendance Register is filed in charge-sheet. Concern of
Principal and other Teachers was reflected in immediate response to
the situation and they enquired about the course of event and found the
role of the deceased and other two boys of implicative nature and call
them in Principal room. It is obvious that Principal must have
reprimanded them for their conduct and had to initiate all possible
steps for course correction. As per version of petitioners, immediately
they called parents of all the three boys through their respective mobile
phones. They called parents of Ashish Yadav on mobile phone
No.7415398623, parents of Ritik Raj on mobile No.9713450006 and
parents
of
the
deceased
Mahendra
Kushwah
on
mobile
No.9516999146. It appears that Call Details Record constitutes the
record which tallies with the contact numbers of parents of students
mentioned in the school record, however C.D.R. details have not been
included in charge-sheet. Therefore, it is obvious that the whole course
of events unfolded in a manner as a course correction rather than any
abetment and instigation.
27.
Section 306 of IPC postulates:Abetment of suicide – If any person commits suicide, whoever abets
the commission of such suicide, shall be punished with imprisonment
of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and
shall also be liable to fine.
28.
Moreover essential condition to charge and prosecute the person is
abetment by such person to the commission of suicide. The provision
of abetment as contained in Chapter V of Indian Penal Code deals in
respect of different contingencies. Section 107 of IPC defines abetment
which is reiterated for better understanding:
“107. Abetment of a thing - A person abets the doing of a
thing, who:
First - Instigates any person to do that thing; or
Secondly - Engages with one or more other person or
persons in any conspiracy for the doing of that thing, if an
act or illegal omission takes place in pursuance of that
conspiracy, and in order to the doing of that thing; or
Thirdly - Intentionally aids, by any act or illegal omission,
the doing of that thing.”
29.
The essential three conditions that are necessarily required to be
present individually in the sequence leading to the commissioning of
suicide by a person are as below:
i.
a. Instigation to commit suicide.
b. Conspiracy leading to person committing suicide
c. Intentionally aiding by an act or omission to commit suicide.
30.
If any of the conditions is found present against the person sought to be
prosecuted under Section 306 IPC, such person shall be held
responsible for abetting commissioning of suicide. Per contra in the
absence of the any of the above three conditions, a person cannot be
held responsible for committing crime under section 305 IPC.
31.
In all three cases of instigation, conspiracy or aid, direct and active
involvement of the accused is essential to convict him for abetment of
suicide. The term 'instigation' is not defined in IPC. The instigation on
the part of the accused should be active and proximate to the incident.
It has been held in number of cases that to constitute "instigation", the
person who instigates another person has to provoke, incite, urge or
encourage doing of an act by the other by "goading" or "urging
forward". A mere statement of suggesting the deceased to end his life
without any mens-rea would not come under the purview of abetment
to suicide. Mens-rea is a necessary ingredient of instigation and the
abetment to suicide would be constituted only when such abetment is
found intentional.
32.
Supreme Court in Geo Varghese (supra), while dealing with the
matter wherein a 9th standard student committed suicide and left a note
alleging that his PTI teacher harassed and insulted him in front of
everyone, the Court emphasised two essentials for conviction under
Sec. 306. First, there should be a direct or indirect act of incitement. A
mere allegation of harassment of the deceased by another would not be
sufficient. Secondly, there must be reasonableness. If the deceased was
hypersensitive and if the allegations imposed upon the accused are not
otherwise sufficient to induce another person in similar circumstances
to commit suicide, it would not be fair to hold the accused guilty for
abetment of suicide. Thus, Supreme Court quashed the FIR in the lack
of any specific allegation and material on record as the essentials to
prove the allegation under Section 306 were not satisfied. Here is the
present case, three students were scolded but deceased appeared to be
over sensitive, therefore, committed suicide, whereas other two
students remained grounded. Therefore, it appears that the deceased
was sensitive and being afraid of consequences of his misconducts,
took such drastic and painful decision.
33.
The Apex Court in the case of Sanju alias Sanjai Singh Sengar Vs.
State of M.P. 2002 AIR SC 1998, has acquitted the person and
quashed the chargesheet filed under section 306 of IPC inter alia
holding therein that mere say of the prosecution version will not
subserve the purpose for slapping the charges under section 306 of
IPC. The presence of mens rea is vital and indefeasible ingredient for
to swing the criminal proceeding into the motion. It is a common
knowledge that some of the words uttered during the altercation or
scuffle cannot be assumed to have been uttered with mens rea.
34.
As in all crimes, mens rea has to be established. To prove the offence
of abetment, as specified under Sec 107 of the IPC the state of mind to
commit a particular crime must be visible, to determine the culpability.
In order to prove mens-rea, there has to be something on record to
establish or show that the petitioners herein had a guilty mind and in
furtherance of that state of mind, abetted the suicide of the deceased.
The ingredient of mens-rea cannot be assumed to be ostensibly present
but has to be visible and conspicuous.
35.
Although all Informal Social Controls as discussed above coming out
from different Sociological Theories, cannot be befitting in our social
milieu but it is also to be seen that for betterment of children, some
Informal Social Controls are necessary. Here, calling parents for
counseling was a mechanism which could have given lesson to the
erring students and calling parents cannot be inferred as abetment.
36.
There is no allegation in the charge-sheet regarding abetment qua the
present petitioners. Their role is confined to causing reprimand or
scolding the boy for his act which was the duty of the Principal and
other Teachers as discussed above. They never had any intention in
respect of the deceased boy that he should commit suicide. They tried
to correct him for his alleged wrong doing and at the same time one
cannot ignore the fact that Principal and other Teachers have
responsibility of safety and well being of other students also. Any
misadventure or misconduct of a student can endanger the life, liberty
and progress of other students. Parents hand over the children to the
school with the trust that school will take care their wards as their
parents and therefore, such reposition of trust cannot go in vein with
timidity and fear of backlash. Teachers should be placed over and
above such fear, else they will be failing in their duties in formulating
the future
of mankind. Therefore, on this count also, case of
petitioners deserves consideration and case of prosecution falters.
37.
The prosecution failed to produce clinching electronic evidence in the
case in hand. The attendance register is part of charge-sheet along with
certification by the Principal but CCTV footage and CDR details are
not part of charge-sheet but the same is filed by the petitioners as
Annexure A/5 apparently as defence document. CDR details indicate
that on fateful day telephonic calls were sent by petitioner No.2 to the
parents of erring students. Attendance register indicates that the
deceased and other two students attended class and they are shown in
the CCTV also in classroom and while coming out from bathroom.
Except admonition, no other conduct is being referred by prosecution
to infer abetment. No sign of physical violence or injury found in the
postmortem report or narrated by any witnesses. Therefore, in the light
of Section 114(g) of Evidence Act and the judgment of Apex Court in
the case of Tamaso Bruno and another Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh,
(2015) 7 SCC 178, petitioners' case deserves consideration.
38.
Other aspect raised by complainant is status of trial but in the light of
the judgment Sathish Mehra (supra) it is no longer res integra that
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. can be invoked
at any stage of trial if it furthers the cause of justice. Here in the present
case, in view of nature of allegations and alleged role of the petitioners,
it is required that they should not be prosecuted by procedure, because
pendency of case itself is punishment for a common man specially
teacher. Undue suffering through prosecution and procedure deserves
to be avoided. Therefore, this is a fit case to invoke extraordinary
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 482 of Cr.P.C.
39.
The Apex Court in the matter of State of Haryana and others Vs. Ch.
Bhajan Lal and others, AIR 1992 SC 604 laid down the different
exigencies under which interference under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. can
be made. Following exigencies are as under:
“(a) where the allegations made in the First Information
Report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their
face value and accepted in their entirety do not prima
facie constitute any offence or make out a case against
the accused;
(b) where the allegations in the First Information Report and
other materials, if any, accompanying the F.I.R. do not
disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation
by police officers under Section 156(1) of the Code except
under an order of a Magistrate within the purview of
Section 155(2)of the Code;
(c) where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR or
'complaint and the evidence collected in support of the
same do not disclose the commission of any offence and
make out a case against the accused;
(d) where the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a
cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable
offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer
without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under
Section 155(2)of the Code;
(e) where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are
so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of
which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion
that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the
accused;
(f)
where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the
provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which
a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and
continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a
specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act,
providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the
aggrieved party;
(g) where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with
mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously
instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance
on the accused and with a view to spite him due to private
and personal grudge.”
The case of petitioners falls within exigencies (a), (b), (c) and (e)
of the judgment.
40.
In the case of Rajiv Thapar and others Vs. Madanlal Kapoor (2013)
3 SCC 330 the Apex Court has given guidance, under which
circumstances, documents relied by the accused can be considered in a
petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. which reads as under:
“30. Based on the factors canvassed in the foregoing
paragraphs, we would delineate the following steps to
determine the veracity of a prayer for quashing, raised by an
accused by invoking the power vested in the High Court
under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C.:(i) Step one, whether the material relied upon by the
accused is sound, reasonable, and indubitable, i.e., the
material is of sterling and impeccable quality?
(ii) Step two, whether the material relied upon by the
accused, would rule out the assertions contained in the
charges levelled against the accused, i.e., the material is
sufficient to reject and overrule the factual assertions
contained in the complaint, i.e., the material is such, as
would persuade a reasonable person to dismiss and
condemn the factual basis of the accusations as false.
(iii) Step three, whether the material relied upon by the
accused,
has
not
been
refuted
by
the
prosecution/complainant; and/or the material is such, that
it
cannot
be
justifiably
refuted
by
the
prosecution/complainant?
(iv) Step four, whether proceeding with the trial would
result in an abuse of process of the court, and would not
serve the ends of justice?
If the answer to all the steps is in the affirmative,
judicial conscience of the High Court should persuade it to
quash such criminal proceedings, in exercise of power
vested in it under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. Such exercise of
power, besides doing justice to the accused, would save
precious court time, which would otherwise be wasted in
holding such a trial (as well as, proceedings arising
therefrom) specially when, it is clear that the same would not
conclude in the conviction of the accused.”
41.
On the basis of attending facts and circumstances of the case and the
discussion
made
above,
it
appears
that
no
element
of
Abetment/Instigation/Conspiracy exists qua petitioners. It is really
painful for the family but for their pain and agony, others cannot be
penalized.
42.
Accordingly, the petition stands allowed. FIR registered at Crime
No.371/2022 on 04th November, 2022 at Police Station Billowa,
District Gwalior for the offences under Sections 306, 34 of IPC and all
other consequential proceeding are hereby quashed. Petitioners are
discharged from all the charges/allegations.
43.
Petition stands allowed and disposed of.
(Anand Pathak)
Judge
Anil*
ANIL
KUMAR
CHAURA
SIYA
CHAURASIYA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR, ou=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=8512f40a1a9eaa50b6802d0
68b51dae27e84c266b09d283f0799e
67cdc7df50f, postalCode=474001,
st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=EC534CBB3B245F050
119F06F4A296DD83C765A1E2ACC6
EC7D8BD8CBCC9C2446E, cn=ANIL
KUMAR CHAURASIYA
Date: 2024.01.24 19:46:49 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review