Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 283 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 21.12.2023 IN OP NO.254 OF
2020 OF FAMILY COURT, PATHANAMTHITTA
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT:
VINU VARGHESE, AGED 30 YEARS
S/O VARGHESE, PAPPALIL HOUSE, PARAVOOR MURI,
MANNAM NORTH, PARAVOOR TALUK,
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN - 683520
BY ADVS.
JOHN JOSEPH ( ROY)
JOSEPH FRANCIS(K/000897/2022)
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
DYNA MERRY ANIYAN, AGED 27 YEARS
D/O SUJA ANIYAN, SANGEERTHANATHIL,
CHOORAKKODU MURIYIL, ERATHU VILLAGE, ADOOR TALUK,
PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT., PIN - 691523
BY ADVS.
MANU RAMACHANDRAN
M.KIRANLAL(K/963/2009)
T.S.SARATH(K/257/2012)
R.RAJESH (VARKALA)(K/78/2000)
SAMEER M NAIR(K/000481/2017)
SAILAKSHMI MENON(K/1518/2021)
JOTHISHA K.A.(K/123/2022)
SHIFANA M.(K/000936/2023)
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
2.04.2025,
ALONG
WITH
Mat.Appeal.895/2024,
4.4.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 895 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN OP(DIV) NO.558 OF 2021 OF FAMILY
COURT, PATHANAMTHITTA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
VINU VARGHESE, S/O PAPPALIL YACOB VARGHESE
AGED 31 YEARS
PAPPALILVEEDU, MANNAM KARA, KOTTUVALLY VILLAGE,
PARAVUR TALUK, ERNAKULAM DIST,PIN - 683520
BY ADVS.
JOHN JOSEPH(ROY)
ANISH VARGHESE
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
DYNA MARRY ANIYAN, W/O VINU
AGED 28 YEARS
D/O ANIYAN MON PAPPACHAN, CHEPPALLIL,
SANKEERTHANAMVEEDU, CHOORAKKODE KARA, ERATHU
VILLAGE, ADOOR TALUK, PÄTHANAMTHITTÅ, PIN - 691551
BY ADVS.
MANU RAMACHANDRAN
M.KIRANLAL(K/963/2009)
T.S.SARATH(K/257/2012)
R.RAJESH (VARKALA)(K/78/2000)
SAMEER M NAIR(K/000481/2017)
SAILAKSHMI MENON(K/1518/2021)
JOTHISHA K.A.(K/123/2022)
SHIFANA M.(K/000936/2023)
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
2.04.2025,
ALONG
WITH
Mat.Appeal.283/2024,
4.4.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN & M.B.SNEHALATHA, JJ.
------------------------------------------Mat.Appeal Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
------------------------------------------Dated, this the 4th April, 2025
JUDGMENT
M.B.Snehalatha.J
By this judgment, we are disposing of Mat.Appeal.No. 283/24
preferred by the husband challenging the judgment and decree of
divorce granted by the Family Court and Mat.Appeal.No.895/2024
filed by him challenging the judgment and decree declining the
relief of restitution of conjugal rights sought by him.
2.
Since the issues involved in both these appeals are
interlinked and intertwined, both these appeals are jointly disposed
of for the sake of convenience and to avoid conflict of decisions.
3.
Parties in this appeal shall be referred to by their rank in
O.P.No.254/2020 as the petitioner and the respondent.
4.
The
petitioner/wife
filed
O.P.No.254/2020
seeking
dissolution of marriage under Section 10(1)(x) of the Divorce Act,
1869 stating that her marriage with the respondent/ husband was
solemnized
on
31.12.2018
as
per
rites
and
ceremonies
of
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
Christians; that at the time of marriage, she was working as a Sub
Engineer at Techno Park, Thiruvananthapuram and the respondent
was doing M S in Mechanical Engineering at United Kingdom of
Britain. She contended that at the time of fixing the marriage, the
respondent had told her and her family that he has got campus
selection in a multi national company and on completion of his
studies, he will get work permit in U.K itself so that he can take the
petitioner also to U.K in spouse visa and it was by believing the
words of the respondent and his family, petitioner and her family
agreed for the marriage. At the time of marriage, she was given 55
sovereigns of gold ornaments and an amount of ₹30 lakhs as
patrimony. Apart from that, 2 sovereigns of gold ornaments were
gifted to respondent and 3 sovereigns of gold ornaments were
gifted to his mother. The respondent did not get any campus
selection in U.K as represented by him and it was a false story
made by him to marry the petitioner. Her further allegation is that
respondent/husband, subjected her to cruelty and pressurized her
to transfer an amount of ₹20 lakhs which stood in her bank
account, to the joint account with him, but she could not oblige to
the said demand.
Infuriated by the same, respondent ill treated
the petitioner and subjected her to cruelty both physically and
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
mentally. After completing studies though he came back to Kerala,
he
did
not
take
interest
in
seeking
any
job
here.
Respondent/husband was not affectionate towards the petitioner
and he neglected the petitioner, which caused mental harassment
to the petitioner. After returning from U.K also, the respondent
insisted the petitioner to transfer the amount of ₹20 lakhs to his
account and when she resisted the said demand, he manhandled
her in the presence of his parents on 22.02.2020. Respondent
physically and mentally harassed the petitioner and subjected her
to cruelty and due to his cruelty, petitioner returned to her parental
home on 22.02.2020 itself. Subsequently, on 01.03.2020, the
petitioner along with her parents had reached the house of the
respondent to have an amicable settlement of the issues between
the couple.
But the respondent and his father ill treated the
petitioner and her parents and locked them up in a room and the
petitioner and her family had to seek the help of Police. Due to the
cruelty meted out from the respondent, petitioner does not want to
continue her marital relationship with the respondent. Hence, she
sought for dissolution of marriage.
5. Respondent/husband filed counter admitting the marriage
and denying the allegations of cruelty. He contended that he had
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
not made any misrepresentation regarding the job as alleged.
Respondent did not know how much gold ornaments were given to
the petitioner. The allegations
of cruelty levelled against the
respondent are false and there was no mental or physical
harassment, as alleged. Respondent was treating the petitioner
with love, care and affection. Petitioner was happily residing with
the respondent during the period when they were together. It was
only due to the interference of her parents, she has raised the
allegations of cruelty. Petitioner and her mother had visited U.K for
convocation ceremony of the respondent. When the parents of the
petitioner tried to forcibly took her along with them, there was an
altercation in respect of the same and accordingly the respondent
had to intimate the matter to North Paravur Police Station and the
police had summoned both parties. Thereafter the petitioner went
with her parents.
The allegations of cruelty levelled against the
respondent are false.
6.
In O.P.No.558/2021 filed by the husband, he sought for
restitution of conjugal rights stating that the wife left the
matrimonial home without any sufficient reason.
7. The wife filed objection stating that she left the company of
the husband due to the mental and physical harassment meted out
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
by her at the hands of the husband.
8.
After
trial,
the
learned
Family
Court
allowed
O.P.No.254/2020, filed by the wife and granted a decree of divorce
on the ground of cruelty and dismissed O.P.No.558/2021 filed by
the husband for restitution of conjugal rights.
9. The point for consideration in Mat.A No.283/2024
is
whether the judgment and decree in O.P.No.254/2020 granting
divorce needs any interference by this Court.
10.
Parties are Christians. Admittedly, the marriage was
solemnized on 31.12.2018. It is also an admitted fact that at the
time of marriage, the wife was working at Techno Park in
Thiruvananthapuram and the husband was pursuing his studies in
MS in Mechanical Engineering at United Kingdom of Britain.
11. The case of the petitioner/wife is that prior to the fixing
of marriage, the husband had misrepresented her family that he
has obtained campus selection in a Multi National Company and on
completion of his studies, he can secure a work permit in U.K and
after marriage, he can take the wife to U.K in a spouse visa.
According to the wife, who was examined as PW1, it was a false
representation made by the husband; that he had not obtained any
campus selection as represented and he had to return to India after
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
his studies. Respondent would admit that he did not get any work
visa and he had to return to India after completion of his studies.
The case of the wife is that husband demanded to transfer an
amount of ₹20 lakhs, which stood in her account to the joint
account with him and when she refused to do so, he subjected her
to cruelty both physically and mentally and totally neglected her
and shown disinterest in her. Petitioner has also testified that she
was even denied marital bliss on account of her refusal to transfer
the patrimony amount into the joint account with the husband. She
has also testified that on 22.02.2020, her husband manhandled her
in the presence of his parents. The wife has testified that the
husband behaved in a cruel manner so as to create an impression
that she was totally neglected.
12.
Unlike physical abuse which is easier to prove, mental
cruelty varies from case to case. Pressurizing a wife to transfer
money which stood in her account to the joint bank account is an
economic abuse and it amounts to mental cruelty.
13.
According to PW1, the respondent/husband persistently
pressurized her to transfer ₹20 lakhs which stood in her account
into the joint bank account with him and when she refused, he
subjected
her to verbal abuse, humiliation, mental and physical
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
harassment creating a hostile marital environment.
Husband's
demand to transfer money and his subsequent ill treatment qualify
as economic abuse and it is a form of domestic violence. Financial
coercion or economic abuse is a serious violation of marital rights.
Courts have to protect women's financial independence and dignity
within marriage.
14. The specific case of the wife, who was examined as PW1,
is that since she could not oblige to the demand of the husband to
transfer the patrimony amount to the joint account with the
husband, he treated her with cruelty both mentally and physically.
There is no reason to disbelieve her version that there was
persistent demand from her husband to transfer an amount of ₹20
lakhs which stood in her account to the joint account with her
husband and when she resisted the said demand, respondent
mentally and physically harassed her and subjected her to cruelty.
15.
In Anilkumar V.K. v. Sunila.P (2025 (2)KHC 33) this
Court held as follows:
“15. A behaviour that may be seen as trivial in one marriage
might be deeply hurtful in another. Therefore, cruelty is to be
assessed on a case - by - case basis. What constitutes cruelty in
a matrimonial relationship depends on the unique circumstances,
behaviour and experience of the parties involved. Courts do not
rely on a rigid definition of cruelty but has to evaluate each case
based on its facts. Courts have to analyse whether the conduct
makes out unreasonable for the one spouse to live with the
other.”
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
16.
2025:KER:29653
In Shoba Rani v. Madhukar Reddi (1988(1) SCC 105) the
Apex Court held as follows:
5. It will be necessary to bear in mind that there has been marked
change in the life around us. In matrimonial duties and
responsibilities in particular, we find a sea change. They are of
varying degrees from house to house or person to person.
Therefore, when a spouse makes complaint about the treatment of
cruelty by the partner in life or relations, the Court should not
search for standard in life. A set of facts stigmatised as cruelty in
one case may not be so in another case. The cruelty alleged may
largely depend upon the type of life the parties are accustomed to
or their economic and social conditions. It may also depend upon
their culture and human values to which they attach importance.
We, the Judges and lawyers, therefore, should not import our own
notions of life. We may not go in parallel with them. There may be a
generation gap between us and the parties.
It would be better if we keep aside our customs and manners. It
would be also better if we less depend upon precedents. Because as
Lord Denning said in Sheldon v. Sheldon (1966) 2 All ER 257 "the
categories of cruelty are not closed." Each case may be different.
We deal with the conduct of human beings who are not generally
similar. Among the human beings there is no limit to the kind of
conduct which may constitute cruelty. New type of cruelty may crop
up in any case depending upon the human behaviour, capacity or
incapability to tolerate the conduct complained of. Such is the
wonderful/realm of cruelty.
17.
The evidence on record would show that on 01.03.2020,
when the wife along with her parents came to the residence of the
husband for an amicable talk, there was altercations between them
which led to a complaint to the Police and both parties had been
summoned to the Police Station. The said incident also irresistibly
points to the fact that the parties are at loggerheads and there is
no harmony between the spouses. It is in evidence that the parents
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
of the husband sent Annexures A2 petition to the Catholic Bava of
the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Denomination and to numerous
dioceses falling under the said denomination raising scathing
remarks against the parents of the wife and their beliefs. By
sending Ext.A2 letters to religious heads, the parents of the
respondent attempted to shame, demean, humiliate, insult and to
cause emotional distress to the wife and her parents and it
constitute mental cruelty.
There is incompatibility
between the
spouses and their families.
18.
Forcing incompatible partners to stay together would
cause more harm to both parties.
spouses is no longer viable.
The marriage between the
A marriage without compatibility
losses its essence and it will lead to emotional stress affecting the
well being of both partners. The divorce allows them to pursue a
life that aligns with their happiness and personal growth rather than
being struck in a relationship that does not fulfill them.
19. Therefore this Court find no reason to interfere with the
judgment and decree in O.P.No.254/2020 of the Family Court,
Pathanamthitta granting divorce.
Mat.A No.895/2024
20.
In Mat.Appeal.No.283/2024, we have already rendered a
Mat.A Nos.283/2024 & 895/2024
2025:KER:29653
finding that the wife left the company of the husband due to the
cruelty meted out at the hands of the husband and she is entitled
to get a decree of divorce. Therefore, the husband who is the
appellant
in
Mat.A
No.895/2024
and
the
petitioner
in
O.P.No.558/2021 is not entitled to get a decree for restitution
conjugal rights and we find no reason to interfere with the
judgment
and
decree
of
the
Family
Court
dismissing
O.P.No.558/2021.
In the result, Mat.A.Nos.283/2024 and 895/2024 stands
dismissed.
Parties shall suffer their respective costs in both the appeals.
Sd/DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN,
JUDGE
Sd/M.B. SNEHALATHA,
JUDGE
Mms
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review