The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Further, the First Appellate Court is justified in setting aside the direction to the plaintiff to return 296 bags to defendant No.2 since the cotton seeds are perishable in nature and it is not compensatory for defendant No.2 to receive 296 cotton seeds bags and pay damages to the plaintiff. Therefore, setting aside the direction issued by the Trial Court to return 296 packets of cotton seeds is found to be justifiable. Therefore, on the finding of fact made by both the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court concurrently is based on evidence and therefore, there is no perversity found in the order and much less having no substantial question of law involved. Therefore, the appeals are liable to be dismissed at the stage of admission itself. - 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:643 RSA No. 5777 of 2013 C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013 HC-KAR
16. So far as damages is concerned it is confirmed, but need to make interference as far as order of interest is concerned. The Trial Court has awarded interest at the rate of 12% p.a. It is reduced to 8% p.a. Therefore, both the appeals are allowed in part as far as rate of interest is concerned.
17. In view of disposal of the appeals, pending interlocutory applications, if any, stand disposed of as they do not survive for consideration.
18. No order as to costs. Sd/(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR) CT-AN List No.: 1 Sl No.: 49
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 20TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO.5777 OF 2013 (MON)
C/W
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO.5778 OF 2013 (MON)
IN RSA NO.5777 OF 2013
BETWEEN:
VIJAYANAND ROADLINES LIMITED,
(NOW CALLED VRL LOGISTICS LIMITED)
CORPORATE OFFICE: GIRIRAJ ANNEXE,
CIRCUIT HOUSE ROAD, HUBLI-580029,
REGD. OFFICE AT NH4, BANGALORE ROAD,
VARUR, HUBLI-581207,
REPRESEBTED BY MANAGING DIRECTOR BY
GPA HOLDER SHRI R.B.GADAGKAR.
MALLIKARJUN
RUDRAYYA
KALMATH
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI HANUMANTHAREDDY SAHUKAR, ADVOCATE.)
AND:
1.
M/S. SHRI SAI KRISHI KENDRA,
GANDHI GANJ, BIDAR-585401,
BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI MADIWALAPPA
S/O. VEERASHETTY GANGASHETTY,
AGE: 43 YEARS, RESIDENT OF GANDHI GANJ,
BIDAR-585401.
2.
M/S. EMERGENT GENETICS INDIA PVT. LTD.,
C/O. M/S. B.P.INDUSTRIES PVT. LTD.,
SURVEY NO.479/481, PUDUDAR VILLAGE,
NEAR MUNEERABAD, MANDAL: MEDCHAL,
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
DIST: RANGA REDDY, ANDHRA PRADESH,
BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR.
3.
M/S. MONSANTO INDIA PVT. LTD.,
NO.26, HIREMATH BUILDING,
JAYANAGAR, VIDYANAGAR,
HUBLI-580021.
BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI ANAND D. BAGEWADI, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
NOTICE TO R2 SERVED;
NOTICE TO R3 HELD SUFFICIENT.)
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
100 OF THE CODE OF THE CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908, PRAYING
TO
SET
ASIDE
THE
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE
IN
O.S.NO.348/2007 DATED 16.04.2008 ON THE FILE OF
PRINCIPAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE, HUBBALLI AND TO DISMISS
THE SUIT AND ALSO TO ALLOW THE REGULAR APPEAL
NO.73/2008 BY SETTING ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 18.07.2013 ON THE FILE OF I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
AND SESSIONS JUDGE, DHARWAD, SITTING AT HUBBALLI, BY
ALLOWING THIS APPEAL WITH COSTS THROUGHOUT IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
IN RSA NO.5778 OF 2013
BETWEEN:
VIJAYANAND ROADLINES LIMITED,
(NOW CALLED VRL LOGISTICS LIMITED)
CORPORATE OFFICE: GIRIRAJ ANNEXE,
CIRCUIT HOUSE ROAD, HUBLI-580029,
REGD. OFFICE AT: NH4, BANGALORE ROAD,
VARUR, HUBLI-581207,
REPRESEBTED BY MANAGING DIRECTOR
BY GPA HOLDER SHRI R.B.GADAGKAR.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI HANUMANTHAREDDY SAHUKAR, ADVOCATE.)
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
AND:
1.
M/S. SHRI SAI KRISHI KENDRA,
GANDHI GANJ, BIDAR-585401,
BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI MADIWALAPPA
S/O. VEERASHETTY GANGASHETTY,
AGE: 43 YEARS, RESIDENT OF GANDHI GANJ,
BIDAR-585401.
2.
M/S. EMERGENT GENETICS INDIA PVT. LTD.,
C/O. M/S. B.P. INDUSTRIES PVT. LTD.,
SURVEY NO.479/481, PUDUDAR VILLAGE,
NEAR MUNEERABAD, MANDAL: MEDCHAL,
DIST: RANGA REDDY, ANDHRA PRADESH,
BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR.
3.
M/S. MONSANTO INDIA PVT. LTD.,
NO.26, HIREMATH BUILDING,
JAYANAGAR, VIDYANAGAR,
HUBLI-580021.
BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI ANAND D. BAGEWADI, ADVOCATE. FOR R1;
NOTICE TO R2 SERVED;
NOTICE TO R3 HELD SUFFICIENT.)
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
100 OF THE CODE OF THE CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908, PRAYING
TO
SET
ASIDE
THE
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE
IN
O.S.NO.348/2007 DATED 16.04.2008, ON THE FILE OF
PRINCIPAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE, HUBBALLI AND TO DISMISS
THE SUIT AND ALSO TO DISMISS THE REGULAR APPEAL
NO.86/2008 BY SETTING ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 18.07.2013, ON THE FILE OF I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
AND SESSIONS JUDGE, DHARWAD, SITTING AT HUBBALLI, BY
ALLOWING THIS APPEAL WITH COSTS THROUGHOUT IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THESE APPEALS COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
Though the appeal is listed for admission, the same is
taken up for disposal with consent of both the sides as the
same is heard on merits of the case.
2.
Defendant No.2 has filed these two appeals being
aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated 18.07.2013,
passed in R.A.No.73/2008 and R.A.No.86/2008, by the
Court of I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Dharwad,
sitting at Hubballi, thereby the judgment and decree dated
16.04.2008, passed in O.S.No.348/2007, by the Principal
Civil Judge (Sr.Dn.), Hubballi, is modified only to the effect
of setting aside direction to the plaintiff to return 296 cotton
seeds packets.
3.
For
the
purpose
of
convenience
and
easy
reference, ranking of the parties is referred to as per their
status before the trial Court.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
4.
The plaintiff has averred in the plaint that he is
an authorized distributor of various seeds manufactured by
defendant No.1 for Bidar District and there was a practice of
defendant No.1 consigning the seeds packets to the plaintiff
for sale and on receipt of the such materials, the plaintiff
used to sell the same to the customers and to repay the
amount to defendant No.1 and in case if any seeds packets
are unsold, the same used to be returned to defendant
No.1.
5.
Further it is pleaded that, the plaintiff has
received 1,000 packets in the month of May 2005 and 704
seeds packets were sold and 296 seeds packets were
remain
unsold,
which
are
worth
of
₹1,42,376/-
and
therefore as usual practice the said 296 cotton seeds
packets were to be transported to defendant No.1 and
accordingly the plaintiff hired service of defendant No.2
transport agency to transport the said 296 bags to
defendant No.1 by booking and payment of freight charges
on 29.12.2005. But the said bags remained in the godown
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
of defendant No.2 till 07.04.2006 and therefore, they were
damaged. Hence, the plaintiff filed the suit for recovery of
money of ₹1,42,376/- with interest at the rate of 18% p.a.
6.
The defendants have filed the written statement
denying all the pleadings in the plaint. It is sum and
substance of written statement of defendant No.1 that the
seeds ought to have been sent immediately, but without
doing so, after lapse of 3-4 months, in the rainy season, the
seeds are damaged. Therefore, defendant No.1 is not liable
to pay damages to the plaintiff.
7.
The defendant No.2 being a transport agency has
stated that when the plaintiff has booked transportation on
29.12.2005, the seeds packets were in damaged condition.
Therefore, they issued notice to the plaintiff. Therefore, the
plaintiff himself is responsible for the damages caused by
defendant No.2. Therefore, defendant No.2 is not liable to
pay damages. Thus, the defendants pray for dismissal of
the suit.
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
8.
The Trial Court, after recording evidence and
hearing the arguments of both the sides, decreed the suit
as against defendant No.2 only and dismissed the suit
against defendants No.1 and 3. The Trial Court has decreed
the suit directing defendant No.2, to return 296 cotton
seeds packets to defendant No.2 and in turn defendant No.2
shall pay damages of ₹1,42,376/- with interest at the rate
of 12% per annum to the plaintiff.
9.
Being aggrieved by this, defendant No.2 has
preferred R.A.No.73/2008 and the plaintiff has preferred
R.A.No.86/2008. The First Appellate Court has dismissed
R.A.No.73/008 filed by defendant No.2 and R.A.No.86/2008
filed by the plaintiff is allowed and so far as the finding that
the plaintiff to return 296 cotton seeds packets to defendant
No.2 was set aside and the remaining findings is confirmed.
10.
Being agreed by the judgment and decree passed
by the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court, defendant
No.2 has preferred these two appeals as stated above.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
11.
Learned
counsel
for
defendant
No.2
has
submitted that the plaintiff has booked defendant No.2
transport agency for transportation of 296 cotton seeds
packets, but the packets were in damaged condition, which
is endorsed in Ex.P.7. Therefore, defendant No.2 has issued
legal notice to the plaintiff to take back the packets. But the
plaintiff has not taken back the packets. Therefore, resulting
into the plaintiff himself is responsible for the damage
caused, but not the 2nd defendant. Therefore, it is not
appreciated by both the Trial Court and the First Appellate
Court correctly. Hence, prays to make interference with the
judgment and decree passed by both the Trial Court and the
First Appellate Court.
12.
On
the
other
hand,
learned
counsel
for
respondent/plaintiff submitted that on 29.12.2005 he has
paid fright charges for consigning 296 cotton seeds packets
by
engaging
defendant
No.2
transport
agency
for
transportation of the seeds packets to defendant No.1. But
defendant No.2 without transporting the bags, has kept
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
itself in its godown till 07.04.2006. Therefore, defendant
No.2 had not transported the said packets to defendant
No.1. Thus, defendant No.2 himself is responsible for
causing damages by keeping the goods idle in its godown.
Therefore, it is correctly appreciated by both the Trial Court
and the First Appellate Court. Hence, justified the order
passed by both the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court.
13.
Upon considering the admitted facts that the
plaintiff has booked defendant No.2 transport agency for
transportation of 296 cotton seeds packets to defendant
No.1 in Andhra Pradesh, Ex.P.6 is the invoice of booking
defendant No.2 transport agency for transporting 296 bags
to defendant No.1. But, it is the case of defendant No.2 that
when 12 bags were received, out of them, 3 bags were in
damaged condition. Therefore, it is explanation of defendant
No.2 that when the plaintiff has booked and paid freight
charge of transportation, already the said packets were in a
damaged condition. Therefore, contended that defendant
No.2 is not responsible for damage of the seeds.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
14.
If this being so, if the goods intended to be sent
by plaintiff through defendant No.2 transport agency, the
2nd defendant immediately would have refused to receive
damaged goods and instead received the goods with a
promise
to
transport
the
same
to
defendant
No.1.
Admittedly, the goods were remained idle and kept in the
godown
of
defendant
No.2
till
07.04.2006.
The
2nd
defendant has not transported the said goods to defendant
No.1. Therefore, there is a force found in the defence of
plaintiff that since the said packets were kept idle in the
godown for nearly five months, therefore there are chances
of damage to the cotton seeds, as cotton seeds are
perishable in nature. Therefore, the First Appellate Court is
justified in directing for payment to the plaintiff. But the
question is, at whose instance the cotton seeds were got
damaged? The 2nd defendant without transporting the same
to defendant No.1 for five months, has kept itself in its
godown without making delivery of the same. The cotton
seeds are perishable in nature. Therefore, keeping it idle in
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
the godown for five months attracts damage to the cotton
seeds as they were in the process of rottening. Therefore,
the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court are justified in
holding that defendant No.2 is responsible for causing
damages to the plaintiff.
15.
Further, the First Appellate Court is justified in
setting aside the direction to the plaintiff to return 296 bags
to defendant No.2 since the cotton seeds are perishable in
nature and it is not compensatory for defendant No.2 to
receive 296 cotton seeds bags and pay damages to the
plaintiff. Therefore, setting aside the direction issued by the
Trial Court to return 296 packets of cotton seeds is found to
be justifiable. Therefore, on the finding of fact made by
both
the
Trial
Court
and
the
First
Appellate
Court
concurrently is based on evidence and therefore, there is no
perversity found in the order and much less having no
substantial question of law involved. Therefore, the appeals
are liable to be dismissed at the stage of admission itself.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:643
RSA No. 5777 of 2013
C/W RSA No. 5778 of 2013
HC-KAR
16.
So far as damages is concerned it is confirmed,
but need to make interference as far as order of interest is
concerned. The Trial Court has awarded interest at the rate
of 12% p.a. It is reduced to 8% p.a. Therefore, both the
appeals are allowed in part as far as rate of interest is
concerned.
17.
In view of disposal of the appeals, pending
interlocutory applications, if any, stand disposed of as they
do not survive for consideration.
18.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
JUDGE
MRK
CT-AN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 49
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review