Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE RAVI MALIMATH,
CHIEF JUSTICE
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA
ON THE 30th OF JANUARY, 2024
CRIMINAL REVISION No. 1201 of 2019
BETWEEN:VIJAY KUMAR S/O LATE SHRI BANWARILAL
AGRAWAL, AGED 54 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS,
R/O: 9, MAA DURGA NAGAR, THIRD FLOOR, FLAT
NO.302, AMAR PALACE, OPPOSITE NAVLAKHA BUS
STAND, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI RAMESH SONVANE - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
THE
STATE
ECONOMIC
OFFENCE
INVESTIGATION
BUREAU,
M.P.
BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
STATE ECONOMIC OFFENCE INVESTIGATION
BUREAU, INDORE WING, INDORE (MP)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI GAURAV SINGH CHOUHAN - PUBLIC PROSECUTOR)
This revision coming on for admission this day, Hon'ble Shri Justice
Vijay Kumar Shukla passed the following:
ORDER
The present revision is filed under section 397 r/w 401 of Criminal
Procedure Code, 1974 being aggrieved by the order dated 27.11.2018 passed
by Special Judge, Prevention of Corruption Act, Indore in Special Case No.6
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 31-01-2024
19:44:45
of 2011 arising out of Crime No.1 of 2004 dated 05.01.2004 registered by State
E.O.W., Bhopal.
2.
Facts of the case are that in the year 2002 upon certain complaints, the
Mandi Board Headquarter, Bhopal has constituted a committee headed by
Deputy Director vide order dated 12.02.2002 for conducting the enquiry
regarding the illegality and irregularities of the payment of the mandi tax and
other things. The committee has to conduct the enquiries in respect of on
01.04.2002 what arrears of the primary amount in respect of the agriculture
produces, from 01.04.2002 to 31.07.2002, the sale conducted in the mandi area,
01.04.2007 to 31.07.2002 the commercial transactions, 01.04.2002 to
31.07.2002, the licenses for purchasing the commodities granted by the
committee, 01.04.2002 to 31.07.2002 the inspection of account of the traders,
01.04.2002 to 31.07.2002 the licenses obtained from other mandi's, 01.04.2002
to 31.07.2002 the verification of the licenses granted in between the aforesaid
period.
3.
Upon the aforesaid enquiry conducted by the committee, it was revealed
that the public servant concerned with the works and the traders in conspiracy
has obtained the licenses even when the dues of mandi tax was there and
beyond the power of the license, they have the transactions and thus against the
17 firms, the committee has found that mandi fees to the tune of
Rs.1,55,95,711.02 has been evaded.
4.
Upon the aforesaid primary enquiries and FIR bearing No.1 of 2004 dated
05.01.2004 has been lodged, therefore, First Information Report No.117 dated
14.02.2004 for the offences under sections 420, 467, 468 of IPC has been
lodged at the Police Station - Aerodrome Road, Indore against the proprietors
of the 17 firms. Thus, Shivam Trading Company has not been included in the
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 31-01-2024
19:44:45
aforesaid accused party.
5.
Upon the further investigation conducted by the State Economic Offence
Investigation Bureau, it has been found that besides 17 firms the proprietor of 5
more firms have also been committed the offence obviously for the period of
01.04.2002 to 31.07.2002, in respect of the misuse of the licenses and in respect
of the evasion of the mandi fees for the aforesaid period and thus the name of
Shivam Trading Company, Proprietor Banwarilal S/o Pooranmal Agrawal has
been made the accused during the investigation.
6.
After the completion of the investigation, the respondent has filed the
charge-sheet No.10 of 2011 on 22.12.2011 against the 24 persons including the
public servant and the traders for the offences under section 13(1)(d) r/w
section 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and section 420, 120B,
477 of IPC and at the time of filing of the challan at accused No.24 there is a
mentioned by the learned Special Judge, the accused name was given Banwarilal
S/o Pooranmal.
7.
The petitioner filed an application dated 20.07.2017 for discharge from the
aforesaid charges. It is argued that the applicant was not working as Proprietor
of the firm in the period for which the lapse is alleged. His father was Proprietor
of the firm. The petitioner has been inducted as Proprietor later on. Since the
applicant was not Proprietor of the firm and, therefore, no offence is made out
against the applicant. The trial Court has committed an error while rejecting the
application for discharge.
8.
Counsel for the State supports the impugned order of discharge and
submits that prima facie on investigation, it has been found that the applicant
was also involved in commission of the aforesaid forgery and misappropriation
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 31-01-2024
19:44:45
of government money of crores. He has conspired along with the other coaccused persons. The trial Court has made him accused with the aid of section
120B of IPC.
9.
After hearing learned counsel for the parties it is found that the applicant
has been made as accused with the aid of Section 120B of IPC. It is alleged that
he has also conspired along with the other accused persons in commission of
forgery and misappropriation of huge public money. The scope of interference
at the stage of framing of charge has been considered by the Apex Court in the
case of Union of India vs. Prafulla Kumar Samal and Another reported in AIR
1979 SC 366. In the case of Union of India (supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court
has held as under:
"The scope of section 227 of the Code was considered by
a recent decision of this Court in the case of State of
Bihar v. Ramesh Singh(1) where Untwalia, J. speaking
for the Court observed as follows:"Strong suspicion against the accused, if the matter
remains in the region of suspicion, cannot take the place
of proof of his guilt at the conclusion of the trial. But at
the initial stage if there is a strong suspicion which leads
the Court to think that there is ground for presuming
that the accused has committed an offence then it is not
o p e n to the Court to say that there is no sufficient
ground for proceeding against the accused. The
presumption of the guilt of the accused which is to be
drawn at the initial stage is not in the sense of the law
governing the trial of criminal cases in France where the
accused is presumed to be guilty unless the contrary is
proved. But it is only for the purpose of deciding prima
facie whether the Court should proceed with the trial or
not. If the evidence which the Prosecutor pro poses to
adduce to prove the guilt of the accused even if fully
accepted before it is challenged in cross-examination or
rebut ted by the defence evidence; if any, cannot show
that the accused committed the offence then there will be
no sufficient ground for proceeding with the trial".
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 31-01-2024
19:44:45
10.
On this aspect, the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of Chitresh Kumar Chopra Vs. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) reported in
(2009) 16 SCC 605, is relevant to refer here as under :"25. It is trite that at the stage of framing of charge,
the court is required to evaluate the material and
documents on record with a view to finding out if the
facts emerging therefrom, taken at their face value,
disclose the existence of all the ingredients
constituting the alleged offence or offences. For this
limited purpose, the court may sift the evidence as it
cannot be expected even at the initial stage to accept
as gospel truth all that the prosecution states. At this
stage, the court has to consider the material only with
a view to find out if there is ground for "presuming"
that the accused has committed an offence and not for
the purpose of arriving at the conclusion that it is not
likely to lead to a conviction."
11.
Again, in the case of Amit Kapoor vs. Ramesh Chander reported in
(2012) 9 SCC 460, the Hon'ble Apex Court observed as under:“27. .. At best and upon objective analysis of various
judgments of this Court, we are able to cull out some of
the principles to be considered for proper exercise of
jurisdiction, particularly, with regard to quashing of
charge either in exercise of jurisdiction under Section
397 or Section 482 of the Code or together, as the case
may be:
27.2. The Court should apply the test as to whether the
uncontroverted allegations as made from the record of
the case and the documents submitted therewith prima
facie establish the offence or not. If the allegations are
so patently absurd and inherently improbable that no
prudent person can ever reach such a conclusion and
where the basic ingredients of a criminal offence are not
satisfied then the Court may interfere.
27.3. The High Court should not unduly interfere. No
meticulous examination of the evidence is needed for
considering whether the case would end in conviction or
not at the stage of framing of charge or quashing of
charge.
27.4. Where the exercise of such power is absolutely
essential to prevent patent miscarriage of justice and for
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 31-01-2024
19:44:45
correcting some grave error that might be committed by
t h e subordinate courts even in such cases, the High
Court should be loath to interfere, at the threshold, to
throttle the prosecution in exercise of its inherent
powers.
27.9. Another very significant caution that the courts
have to observe is that it cannot examine the facts,
evidence and materials on record to determine whether
there is sufficient material on the basis of which the case
would end in a conviction; the court is concerned
primarily with the allegations taken as a whole whether
they will constitute an offence and, if so, is it an abuse of
the process of court leading to injustice.
27.13. Quashing of a charge is an exception to the rule
of continuous prosecution. Where the offence is even
broadly satisfied, the Court should be more inclined to
permit continuation of prosecution rather than its
quashing at that initial stage. The Court is not expected
to marshal the records with a view to decide
admissibility and reliability of the documents or records
but is an opinion formed prima facie.”
12.
In so far as the revisional jurisdiction in examining the orders as to the
framing of charges is concerned, it is condign to quote the following extract of
the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of State of
Rajasthan v. Fatehkaran Mehdu reported in (2017) 3 SCC 198, herein below:
“ 2 6 . The scope of interference and exercise of
jurisdiction under Section 397 CrPC has been time and
again explained by this Court. Further, the scope of
interference under Section 397 CrPC at a stage, when
charge had been framed, is also well settled. At the stage
of framing of a charge, the court is concerned not with
the proof of the allegation rather it has to focus on the
material and form an opinion whether there is strong
suspicion that the accused has committed an offence,
which if put to trial, could prove his guilt. The framing of
charge is not a stage, at which stage final test of guilt is
to be applied.
Thus, to hold that at the stage of framing the charge, the
court should form an opinion that the accused is
certainly guilty of committing an offence, is to hold
something which is neither permissible nor is in
consonance with the scheme of the Code of Criminal
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 31-01-2024
19:44:45
Procedure.”
13.
In terms of the revisional jurisdiction in examining the orders passed by
the trial Court, the following excerpt of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the recent case of Amit Kapoor vs. Ramesh Chandra reported in
(2022) 9 SCC 460 is propitious to reproduce here under:“12. Section 397 of the Code vests the court with the
power to call for and examine the records of an inferior
court for the purposes of satisfying itself as to the
legality and regularity of any proceedings or order
made in a case. The object of this provision is to set right
a patent defect or an error of jurisdiction or law. There
has to be a well-founded error and it may not be
appropriate for the court to scrutinise the orders, which
upon the face of it bears a token of careful consideration
and appear to be in accordance with law. If one looks
into the various judgments of this Court, it emerges that
t h e revisional jurisdiction can be invoked where the
decisions under challenge are grossly erroneous, there
is no compliance with the provisions of law, the finding
recorded is based on no evidence, material evidence is
ignored or judicial discretion is exercised arbitrarily or
perversely. These are not exhaustive classes, but are
merely indicative. Each case would have to be
determined on its own merits.
1 3 . Another well-accepted norm is that the revisional
jurisdiction of the higher court is a very limited one and
cannot be exercised in a routine manner. One of the
inbuilt restrictions is that it should not be against an
interim or interlocutory order. The Court has to keep in
mind that the exercise of revisional jurisdiction itself
should not lead to injustice ex facie. Where the Court is
dealing with the question as to whether the charge has
been framed properly and in accordance with law in a
given case, it may be reluctant to interfere in exercise of
i t s revisional jurisdiction unless the case substantially
falls within the categories aforestated. Even framing of
charge is a much advanced stage in the proceedings
under the CrPC.”
14.
On the anvil of aforesaid enunciation of law if the facts of the present
case are examined, there are specific allegation against the applicant that he had
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 31-01-2024
19:44:45
conspired along with the accused persons including his father, who was
working as Proprietor of the firm in preparation of forged receipt in order to
extend undue benefit to the other accused persons. The allegations of
conspiracy is levelled against the applicant. The trial Court has rightly held that
at this stage, there cannot be appreciation of the defence and the other
documents. On examination of the material, we find that prima facie there is
sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused person.
15.
In view of the aforesaid principles of law and factual matrix of the case,
we do not find any illegality, perversity or infirmity in the impugned order of the
trial Court. The revision is dismissed.
(RAVI MALIMATH)
CHIEF JUSTICE
s
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 31-01-2024
19:44:45
(VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review