Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Arb. P. No.01 of 2016
Vijay Bhushan & Anr. v. State of Sikkim & Anr.
TH E H I GH COURT OF SI KKI M : GAN GTOK
( Civ il Jur isdict ion )
--------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: H ON ’BLE M R. JUSTI CE SATI SH K. AGN I H OTRI , ACJ.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Ar b. P. N o. 0 1 of 2 0 1 6
1. Vij ay Bhushan,
S/ o Lat e Pit am bar Lal,
R/ o 24, Pusa Road, New Delhi- 110 005,
Through aut horized signat ory,
Alok Kum ar Singhal,
S/ o Shri Gokul Chandra Singhal,
R/ o PP House, Naya Bazar,
Word No. 8, 2 n d Floor, Siliguri – 734 005.
2. Pit am bar I nfovision, Pvt . Lt d.,
M/ s Com put el Syst em s & Services,
10 Com m unit y Cent re, Mayapuri Phase I ,
New Delhi – 110 064
… Pet it ioners
ve r sus
1.
St at e of Sikkim , t hrough Direct or,
Direct orat e of Technical Educat ion,
Hum an Resource Dev elopm ent Depart m ent ,
Governm ent of Sikkim , Tashiling,
Gangt ok- 737 103.
2.
Direct or,
Direct orat e of Technical Educat ion,
Hum an Resource Dev elopm ent Depart m ent ,
Governm ent of Sikkim , Tashiling,
Gangt ok- 737 103.
… Respondent s
Pe t it ion unde r Se ct ion 1 1 of t h e Ar bit r a t ion a nd
Concilia t ion Act , 1 9 9 6
Arb. P. No.01 of 2016
Vijay Bhushan & Anr. v. State of Sikkim & Anr.
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. K.T. Bhut ia, Sr. Advocat e wit h Ms. Sarit a Bhusal,
Advocat e for t he Pet it ioners.
Mr. Karm a Thinlay, Sr. Govt . Advocat e wit h Ms. Pollin Rai,
Asst t . Govt . Advocat e and Mr. Bhusan Nepal, Legal
Ret ainer, HRDD for t he St at e- Respondent s.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D ER
( 0 2 .0 9 .2 0 1 6 )
Sa t ish K. Agnihot ri, ACJ
The pet it ioner s m oved t his Court under Provisions of
Sect ion 11 of t he Arbit r at ion and Conciliat ion Act , 1996, seeking
appoint m ent of an Arbit r at or as per clause 21 of t he agreem ent
dat ed 21.11. 2008 bet ween t he pet it ioners and t he respondent s
t o resolve disput es pending t herein.
2.
During
currency
of
t he pet it ion,
learned
Senior
Counsel, appearing for t he part ies, on inst ruct ions, m ade oral
request
wit h
m echanism .
consent
to
refer
t he disput es t o
m ediat ion
Accordingly, t he disput es, involved t herein, were
referred t o t he m ediat ion by order dat ed 01.07.2016. The
disput es hav e been set t led on int er vent ion of t he Mediat or and
agreem ent dat ed 03.08.2016 is duly signed by all t he concerned
part ies as well as by t he Counsel, appearing for t hem .
Arb. P. No.01 of 2016
Vijay Bhushan & Anr. v. State of Sikkim & Anr.
3.
Having considered t he afore- st at ed set t lem ent by
way of m ediat ion, t he pet it ion is disposed of, wherein t he
m ediat ion agreem ent shall form part of t he order, which reads
as under: “ AGREEMENT
This agr eem ent
is m ade t his dat e 3 rd of
August , 2016 bet w een Shr i Vij ay Bushan son of Lat e
Pit am bar Lal, Resident of 24, Pusa Road, New Delhi110 005 and M/ s Pit am bar I nfovision Pr ivat e Lim it ed,
M/ s Com put el Syst em s and Ser vices, 10 Com m unit y
Cent r e,
Mayapur i
Phase- I ,
New
Delhi
r epr esent ed by Shr i Alok Kum ar Singhal, son of Shr i
Gokul
Chandr a Singhal, Resident of P. P. House,
Naya Bazar Ward No. 8, 2 nd Floor Siligur i 734 005,
( her einaft er r efer r ed t o as t he FI RST PARTY) on t he
one par t
AND
St at e
of
Sikkim ,
t hr ough
t he
Dir ector ,
Dir ect or at e of Technical Educat ion, Hum an Resour ces
Developm ent Depar t m ent , Gover nm ent of Sikk im ,
Tashiling, Gangt ok – 737 103 and t he Dir ect or ,
School Educat ion, Hum an Resources Developm ent
Depar t m ent , Tashiling Gangt ok 737 103, ( her einaft er
r efer r ed t o as t he SECOND PARTY) on t he ot her par t.
WHEREAS,
t he fir st
par t y
filed a pet it ion
befor e t he Hon’ble High Cour t of Sikkim , at Gangt ok
being ARB. P. No. 1 of 2016 ( Vij ay Bhushan &
Sd/ Vij ay Bhushan
Sd/ M. T. Sherpa
Sd/ Alok K. Singhal
Sd/ Raj endra Chhet ri
Arb. P. No.01 of 2016
Vijay Bhushan & Anr. v. State of Sikkim & Anr.
anot her – Ver sus – Dir ect or , Dir ect or at e of Technical
Educat ion and anot her ) for appoint m ent of sole
ar bit rat or t o adj udicat e upon t he disput es bet w een
t he fir st par t y and t he second par t y.
AND WHEREAS, w hile hear ing t he m at t er by
t he Hon’ble High Cour t and on t he agr eem ent of t he
par t ies, vide or der dat ed 01.07.2016 r efer r ed t he
m at t er for m ediat ion bet w een t he par t ies.
AND WHEREAS, t he m ediat ion for t his m at t er
w as fixed for t oday for deliber at ion and set tlem ent .
AND WHEREAS, on not ice t he fir st par t y and
t he second par t y along w it h t he Senior Counsel for
t he fir st par t y Shr i K. T. Bhut ia, Senior Advocat e
assist ed by Ms. Sar it a Bhusal and Ms. Bandana
Pr adhan,
Advocat es
and
Shr i
Bhushan
Nepal,
Counsel for t he second par t y w er e pr esent in t he
deliber at ion of m ediat ion.
AND WHEREAS, Shr i Nar endr a Rai, Senior
Advocat e
has
been
appoint ed
t he
m ediat or
to
negot iat e and set t le t he m at t er t hrough m ediat ion.
Accor dingly,
t he
m ediat ion,
negot iat ion
and
deliber at ion t ook place at t he m ediat ion hall, Dist r ict
Cour t pr em ises, Gangtok, East Sikkim .
AND
WHEREAS,
on
t hor ough
discussion
deliber at ion and negot iat ion, it cam e int o light t hat
t he disput e bet w een t he fir st par t y and second par t y
is in r espect of supply of com put ers, it s allied
accessor ies and t he t eachers for com put er educat ion
t o be effect ed by t he fir st par t y and in view of t he
sam e an am ount of Rs.9,39,53,000/ - ( Rupees nine
cr or e t hir t y nine lakhs fift y t hr ee t housand) only, w as
t o be paid t o t he fir st par t y by t he second par t y.
Sd/ Vij ay Bhushan
Sd/ M. T. Sherpa
Sd/ Alok K. Singhal
Sd/ Raj endra Chhet ri
Arb. P. No.01 of 2016
Vijay Bhushan & Anr. v. State of Sikkim & Anr.
Out of t he said am ount past paym ent w as
m ade by t he second par t y t o t he fir st par ty and t he
pr esent out st anding due com es t o Rs.1,49,68,208/ ( Rupees one cr or e for t y
nine lakhs sixt y
eight
t housand tw o hundr ed and eight ) only, t o be paid t o
t he fir st par t y by t he second par t y.
AND WHEREAS, t he default in paym ent by t he
second par t y t o t he fir st par t y was calculat ed fr om
t he m ont h of July 2012. Dam ages am ount ing t o
Rs.40,00,000/ -
( Rupees
for t y
lakhs)
only,
and
t he int er est at t he r at e of 18% per annum t o t he
unpaid am ount w as also being claim ed by t he fir st
par t y. Thus, t he pr esent claim of t he fir st par t y
am ount s t o Rs.2,97,45,317/ - ( Rupees tw o cr or e,
ninet y seven lakhs for t y five t housand t hr ee hundr ed
and sevent een) only.
AND
WHEREAS,
t he
second
par t y
on
negot iat ion adm it t ed t he out st anding sum t o be
Rs.1,49,68,208/ - ( Rupees one cr or e for t y nine lakhs
sixt y eight t housand t w o hundr ed and eight ) only,
and deliber at ed t hat t he Gover nm ent
cannot
be
burdened
Rs.40,00,000/ -
( Rupees
w it h
t he
for t y
lakhs)
of Sik kim
dam ages
only,
of
and
int er est of 18% on t he unpaid cost of t he supplies of
t he fir st par t y.
AND
WHEREAS,
on
t hor ough
discussion
negot iat ion and deliber at ion t he fir st par t y and t he
second par t y cam e t o an am icable set t lem ent on t he
follow ing t er m s and condit ions: Sd/ Vij ay Bhushan
Sd/ M. T. Sherpa
Sd/ Alok K. Singhal
Sd/ Raj endra Chhet ri
Arb. P. No.01 of 2016
Vijay Bhushan & Anr. v. State of Sikkim & Anr.
1. That t he fir st par t y shall not charge 18%
int er est and dam age of Rs.40,00,000/ ( Rupees for t y lakhs) only, if t he paym ent
of
t he
out st anding
Rs.1,49,68,208/ -
( Rupees
for t y nine lakhs sixt y
eight
sum
of
one
cr or e
t housand
t w o hundr ed and eight ) only, is paid on
or befor e 31 st day of Decem ber , 2016
and
for
any
unseen
event
and
cir cum st ances, t hey can wait t ill 31 st day
of Mar ch, 2017 i.e t he last day of cur r ent
financial year .
2. That t he second par t y has agr eed t o pay
t he out st anding sum of Rs.1,49,68,208/ ( Rupees one cror e for t y nine lakhs sixt y
eight t housand t w o hundr ed and eight )
only, t o t he fir st par t y on or befor e 31 st
day of Decem ber , 2016 and incase of
any
unseen
happenings,
t hey
m ay
r elease t he paym ent not lat er t han 31 st
day of Mar ch, 2017 i.e., t he last day of
t he cur r ent financial year .
3. That it is also agr eed by bot h t he par t ies
t hat if in case t he above m ent ioned
out st anding am ount is not paid by t he
fir st par t y t o t he second par t y on or
befor e
31 st
day
of
Mar ch
t he
second par t y w ill be liable t o pay t he
dam ages and t he int er est at t he r at e of
18% on t he ent ir e unpaid am ount fr om
t he m ont h of July, 2012.
Sd/ Vij ay Bhushan
Sd/ M. T. Sherpa
Sd/ Alok K. Singhal
Sd/ Raj endra Chhet ri
Arb. P. No.01 of 2016
Vijay Bhushan & Anr. v. State of Sikkim & Anr.
4. That t his agr eem ent w ill be par t of t he
or der passed in ARB. P. No. 01 of 2016
pending befor e t he Hon’ble High Cour t of
Sikk im and t he fir st par t y and second
par t y w ill subm it about t his agr eem ent
being t he par t of t he pr oceeding befor e
t he Hon’ble High Cour t .
I n w it ness w her eof t he fir st par t y
and
second
par t y
have
put
t heir
r espect ive hands on t he dat e her ein
above fir st m ent ioned.
COUNSEL FOR THE PARTI ES
Sd/ 1. Sar it a Bhusal ( Adv.)
Sd/ dat ed
2. Bhusan Nepal ( Adv.)
PARTI ES
Sd/ 1. Vij ay Bhushan
Sd/ 2. Alok K. Singhal
Sd/ 3. M. T. Sher pa
Sd/ 4. Raj endr a Chhet r i
Sd/ N. Rai
( Mediat or ) ”
4.
I n view of t he disposal of t he m ain pet it ion, no order is
necessary in I .A. No.2 of 2016.
Sd/ Act in g Ch ie f Ju st ice
0 2 . 0 9 .2 0 1 6
pm / t o
I n de x : Yes / N o
I n t e r ne t : Ye s / N o
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review