Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:53726
-1BA-1948-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
BAIL APPLICATION NO.1948 OF 2026
VIDESH SURESH MACHARE
VERSUS
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
…...
Ms. Sana Raees Khan a/w Mr. H. P. Randhir, Advocates for Applicant
Mr. K. K. Naik, APP for Respondent – State.
……
CORAM : HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.
DATED : 29th OCTOBER, 2026
ORDER :
1.
The applicant seeks regular bail under Section 483 of
the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, in connection with
Crime No.183 of 2026 registered with MIDC CIDCO Police Station,
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar, for the offences punishable under
Sections 8(c), 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. He was arrested on 10 th April,
2026. The investigation against him has culminated in a chargesheet, registered as Special Case No.256 of 2026. His earlier
application for bail was rejected by the Additional Sessions Judge
on 18th August, 2026.
2.
The prosecution states that on 10th April, 2026, Police
Head Constable Sanjay Mohan Nand received information that a
person of the description furnished by the informant would be
-2BA-1948-2026
present near a white Fiat car behind Kakade Complex, Naregaon,
with ganja intended for sale. The information was conveyed to the
superior officer and arrangements were made for a raid. A police
party, accompanied by two panch witnesses and a mobile forensic
team, proceeded to the place. At about 1.15 p.m., the applicant was
found standing near the white car bearing registration No.MH-20BC-9597. The search of the car allegedly yielded a black sack from
the dickey and two white sacks from the seating portion. The sacks
contained wrapped packets of a greenish, moist, bud-like substance
described as ganja. The aggregate weight recorded at the seizure
was 53.441 kilograms, valued at Rs.26,72,050/-. The material and
the car were seized.
3.
The prosecution further states that the material had
been procured from a person referred to as Reddy of Sambalpur,
Odisha, and was intended to be supplied to Kishor Hatkar, Rahul
Malke and Akash Arun Dahiyekar. Five persons have been
arraigned as accused. The applicant alone has been arrested; the
remaining four have not been apprehended. The charge-sheet
includes the seizure panchanama, statements of the members of
the raiding party and the panch witnesses, the crime-scene report
of the forensic team, the proceedings before the Magistrate, the
forwarding papers and the vehicle particulars. The vehicle
-3BA-1948-2026
particulars record the applicant as the registered owner of the car,
following its transfer to him on 25th January, 2024. The
prosecution also relies upon the chemical analysis report tendered
during the hearing.
4.
Learned Advocate for the applicant submits that the
applicant has been falsely implicated and that his presence near
the car cannot, by itself, establish conscious possession. She
submits that there is no independent electronic or financial
material connecting him with the alleged supplier or the intended
recipients. The investigation is complete and no further recovery is
required from him. He has no criminal antecedents, has a
permanent residence and has been in custody for about six
months. He is willing to abide by stringent conditions.
5.
Learned Advocate for the applicant submits that the
more fundamental difficulty concerns the identity of the seized
substance. The FIR and the seizure panchanama describe moist or
wet ganja, whereas the forensic crime-scene report prepared on
the same day describes dried greenish vegetative material
suspected to be ganja. The Magistrate's certificate describes
blackish knotty leaves. None of these documents expressly records
flowering or fruiting tops. She submits that the subsequent
chemical analysis report, which describes flowering or fruiting tops
-4BA-1948-2026
with brownish-greenish leaves, seeds and stalks, introduces an
essential feature absent from the earlier documents. According to
her, these successive differences cannot be dismissed as variations
in terminology and raise a serious doubt whether the article
analysed was the article seized.
6.
Learned Advocate for the applicant further submits
that the recorded weight includes the sacks, wrapping and parts of
the plant which do not answer the statutory definition of ganja. The
crime-scene
report
expressly
states
that
its
weights
are
approximate and inclusive of the bags. It also refers to fluctuations
in the photographs. No reliable net weight of the prohibited
substance has been established. She submits that the description of
the material as ready for sale does not dispense with proof of
flowering or fruiting tops. Nor can Section 2(iii)(c), concerning
mixtures, convert leaves or other unprohibited parts of a cannabis
plant into ganja without proof that a prohibited form of cannabis
was present. She points out that the accusation concerns
possession under Section 20(b), and not cultivation under Section
20(a).
7.
Learned Advocate for the applicant submits that the
sampling defect is equally serious. The seizure was on 10 th April,
2026, whereas the Magistrate's certificate bears the date 22 nd
-5BA-1948-2026
April, 2026. Three sacks containing 44 packets were produced, but
the certificate records only one sample of 52 grams, marked ‘S’. It
does not identify the packet or sack from which that sample was
drawn, record equal contributions from each packet, or show a
permissible formation of lots and drawing of samples in duplicate.
She submits that the chemical report relating to this sample
cannot establish the nature of the entire bulk. She also questions
its belated production and submits that these defects, considered
together, satisfy the requirement for bail under Section 37.
8.
In support, learned Advocate for the applicant relies
upon Mohammad Jakir Nawab Ali v. State of Maharashtra ,
Criminal Application (BA) No.602 of 2024, decided at Nagpur on
20th September, 2024; the order cited as Akshay Rajendra Kadam
v. State of Maharashtra, Criminal Application (BA) No.737 of
2024, dated 12th September, 2024; Ganesh Prakash Golesar v.
State of Maharashtra, Bail Application No.2469 of 2023, decided
on 7th October, 2023; Hari Mahadu Valse v. State of Maharashtra ,
Bail Application No.2299 of 2019, decided on 29 th July, 2021;
Hanmant Dharma Shinde v. State of Maharashtra , Bail Application
No.1792 of 2022, decided on 11 th November, 2022; and Ibrahim
Khwaja Miya Sayyed alias Raju v. State of Maharashtra, Bail
Application No.1296 of 2022, decided on 17th March, 2023. She
-6BA-1948-2026
submits that these decisions require careful scrutiny of the
composition and weight of the material before treating the seizure
as one involving commercial quantity.
9.
Learned Advocate for the applicant also relies upon
Venktesh Shiva Permal v. State of Maharashtra , 2024 SCC OnLine
Bom 251, and the Aurangabad Bench order dated 3 rd January,
2023, cited during the hearing as Bail Application No.1986 of
2022, to support her objections to sampling and statutory
compliance. She relies upon Manjay Kumar v. State NCT of Delhi,
2026 SCC OnLine Del 1144, for the submission that an
unrepresentative sample and uncertainty about the presence of
flowering or fruiting tops may justify bail notwithstanding a
positive forensic report. She further relies upon Rajesh Sahu v.
State of Chhattisgarh, Criminal Appeal No.3807 of 2025 arising
out of SLP (Criminal) No.10001 of 2025, decided on 1 st September,
2025. As regards Shiv Kumar Mishra v. State of Goa, (2009) 3 SCC
797, to which her attention was invited during the hearing, she
submits that the presence of flowering parts had been established
in that case after evidence, whereas the foundational identity of
the substance remains disputed here.
10.
Learned APP submits that the applicant was found near
his own vehicle with three sacks of packaged material, that the
-7BA-1948-2026
recovery was documented in the presence of panch witnesses and
forensic personnel, and that the chemical analysis report
expressly describes flowering or fruiting tops along with the other
vegetative parts. According to the prosecution, the material was
prepared and packed for sale, rather than being a seizure of
uprooted plants from an agricultural field. Learned APP submits
that seeds and leaves accompanied by the tops are not excluded
from the definition of ganja and also places reliance upon the
provision concerning mixtures. The prosecution opposes bail on
the ground that the seizure involves commercial quantity and the
conditions under Section 37 have not been fulfilled.
11.
Before considering the submissions, it is necessary to
clarify their scope. Although the application contains a ground
alleging that grounds of arrest were not furnished, that ground was
not urged during the hearing. No finding on that distinct question is
therefore being recorded in this order. The principal question
arising from the submissions advanced is whether, on a fair
assessment of the material and the objections raised, there are
reasonable grounds for believing that the applicant is not guilty of
the offence involving commercial quantity. Section 37 requires
more than a reference to the seriousness of the accusation.
Equally, the applicant is not required to establish his innocence by
-8BA-1948-2026
conducting a defence trial at the stage of bail. The Court must
examine whether the prosecution material, read with the
infirmities apparent from the record, permits the statutory
satisfaction. The objections concerning identity, quantity and
sampling therefore require consideration at this stage; they cannot
all be postponed to the trial merely by describing them as disputed
questions.
12.
The relevant definition is Section 2(iii)(b), and not a
separate provision described as Section 2(b). Ganja means the
flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis plant, with seeds and
leaves excluded when they are not accompanied by the tops.
Section 2(iv) separately defines the cannabis plant. Section 20(a)
concerns cultivation, whereas Section 20(b) includes prohibited
possession and other dealings in cannabis. The applicant is
therefore right that possession of unspecified plant material cannot
be equated with possession of ganja merely because it originated
from a cannabis plant. Section 2(iii)(c), which concerns mixtures
with or without neutral material of the forms of cannabis referred
to in the preceding clauses, does not eliminate the need to establish
the presence of a prohibited form of cannabis.
13.
In Shiv Kumar Mishra (Supra), the Supreme Court
rejected the contention that the seeds and leaves had necessarily
-9BA-1948-2026
to be excluded where the seized material included leafy and
flowering parts. The decision also does not support a compulsory
reduction of the seizure weight merely because the substance was
moist. The applicant is correct that the factual finding in that case
followed a trial. That distinction prevents the Court from importing
that factual finding into the present case, but it does not displace
the interpretation of the definition. The enquiry in the present case
here remains whether there is prima facie material showing the
presence of the tops; neither the word ganja used by the police nor
the fact of packaging can supply that requirement by itself.
14.
The chemical analysis report relied during the hearing
is material to this enquiry because the description relied upon by
both sides includes flowering or fruiting tops, brownish-greenish
leaves, seeds and stalks. The report must be assessed with its
limitations, it concerns the sample examined and does not, merely
by being positive, establish that every packet contained the same
substance. Nevertheless, the express botanical description in that
report cannot be disregarded solely because the FIR or the
inventory did not use the statutory expression. Those documents
describe what was observed during the seizure and inventory; the
laboratory report addresses the composition of the article
submitted for examination. The earlier description of a bud-like
-10BA-1948-2026
substance also forms part of the record. Taken together, these
circumstances provide prima facie support for the presence of
ganja in the material sampled.
15.
The differences between moist greenish material, dried
greenish vegetative material and blackish knotty leaves are
relevant, particularly because the first two descriptions were
recorded on the same day. At the same time, a difference in these
general descriptions is not, by itself, affirmative proof of
substitution. The forensic crime-scene report records three groups
comprising 13, 21 and 10 packets. The Magistrate subsequently
records the corresponding groups of 13, 10 and 21 packets in the
two white sacks and the black sack. This correspondence is a
material circumstance supporting continuity of the seized articles.
The forwarding letter dated 23rd April, 2026 and the laboratory
acknowledgment of 27th April, 2026 also record receipt of one
sealed packet with the seal tallying. These papers provide support
for the necessary link.
16.
The question of quantity requires further consideration.
The crime-scene report records approximately 16.625, 21.695 and
15.121 kilograms, inclusive of the bags, aggregating to 53.441
kilograms. The Magistrate's certificate records 16.655, 15.130 and
21.865 kilograms, aggregating to 53.650 kilograms. Thus, there is
-11BA-1948-2026
a difference of 209 grams, and there is an express qualification
concerning packaging in the initial report. The figure of 53.441
kilograms cannot be described as a scientifically established net
weight. Packaging and material which falls outside the statutory
definition cannot lawfully be counted. Equally, the whole weight of
seeds and leaves cannot automatically be deducted where they
accompany the tops. No finding that the entire bulk was segregated
botanically can be drawn from the assignment of the labels A, B
and C; those labels identify the sacks.
17.
The commercial-quantity threshold for ganja is 20
kilograms. The substantial recorded bulk, its division into 44
wrapped packets, the contemporaneous description of the contents
and the reported identification of flowering or fruiting tops provide
prima facie support for the prosecution allegation that the seizure
exceeded that threshold. It is also not based upon an assumed
percentage of tops, moisture or packing. Having considered the
gross-weight qualification and the vegetative material described in
the report, I am not persuaded that those matters presently
furnish reasonable grounds for treating the prosecution allegation
of commercial quantity as untenable.
18.
The sampling objection by the counsel for applicant ,
however, goes beyond a mere complaint about weight. For a seizure
-12BA-1948-2026
in April 2026, the applicable provisions include the Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic Substances (Seizure, Storage, Sampling and
Disposal) Rules, 2022. Rule 10 requires a sample in duplicate from
each package or container, subject to the prescribed conditions for
bunching identical packages into lots. In the case of ganja, a lot
may contain no more than 40 packages. A composite sample
requires equal quantities from each constituent package. The
Magistrate's certificate does not explain how these requirements
were fulfilled in respect of the 44 packets. Neither the number of
packets nor their different recorded weights permits the Court to
presume that one lawful lot was formed. The certificate also does
not identify the source of the 52-gram sample or record its
duplicate. The presence of the Magistrate does not cure these
omissions, and I am not recording a finding of complete
compliance.
19.
The consequence of that deficiency must nevertheless
be assessed with the remaining evidence. In the case of Bharat
Aambale v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2025) 8 SCC 452, the Supreme
Court explained that non-compliance with Section 52A does not
invariably extinguish the prosecution and that the effect of the
breach must be assessed in the evidentiary setting of the case. That
decision does not license disregard of a defect affecting the identity
-13BA-1948-2026
of the bulk. In Narcotics Control Bureau v. Kashif , (2024) 11 SCC
372, the Supreme Court disapproved the grant of bail solely for
belated compliance without the assessment required by Section 37.
Here, the applicant has identified a specific deficiency in
representativeness, and the prosecution must account for it. I have
therefore
considered
that
deficiency
together
with
the
contemporaneous forensic documentation, the corresponding
packet counts, the Magistrate's production record and the sealed
receipt, rather than treating the positive report as conclusive.
20.
The interval between seizure and certification also
requires consideration. The remand papers of 11th April, 2026
refer to obtaining an inventory through the Court, and an
inventory is annexed. Certification and sampling were recorded on
22nd April, 2026, with the forwarding letter issued the following
day and laboratory receipt on 27th April, 2026. This sequence does
not establish full compliance with the requirement of prompt
sampling and dispatch. It does, however, prevent the interval of
twelve days from being treated, without further enquiry, as proof
that the agency first sought judicial proceedings only on the twelfth
day. Nor does the later tendering of a report, without more,
establish fabrication. Its actual date, the sample reference and the
custody link remain matters for proof.
-14BA-1948-2026
21.
The applicant's authorities underline the need for this
scrutiny. In case of Hanmant Dharma Shinde (supra), concerned
with the plants weighed with soil adhering to their roots. In the
case of Mohammad Jakir Nawab Ali (supra), concerned an
inventory and seizure description including several parts of plants
and substantial additional circumstances favouring bail, including
prolonged custody and the applicant's medical condition. The case
of Ibrahim Khwaja Miya Sayyed (supra) concerned a recorded bulk
only one kilogram above the threshold and an express finding that
the sample was not representative after the contents of both bags
were mixed. In Venktesh Shiva Permal (supra), the applicant's
own bag contained 8.655 kilograms, and the accusation of
commercial quantity involved the recoveries from the other
accused as well. The Court granted relief on the combined
deficiencies found there, after explaining the need to assess the
particular sampling violation. Here in present application the
prosecution attributes the three sacks in one vehicle to this
applicant on the recovery and ownership material. These
distinctions do not dispense with representative sampling; they
inform the cumulative assessment explained above.
22.
In case of Hari Mahadu Valse (supra) and Ganesh
-15BA-1948-2026
Prakash Golesar (supra), cannot be distinguished merely by saying
that a chemical report is available here or that the alleged quantity
exceeds 20 kilograms. Those cases also involved forensic
descriptions of flowering parts with other vegetative material and
substantial
recorded
quantities.
They
illustrate
that
the
composition of the bulk and the other circumstances may create
sufficient doubt for bail. They also involved materially longer
periods of custody; in case of Hari Mahadu Valse (supra), the trial
had not commenced after nearly four years. The order dated 3 rd
January, 2023 in Popat Govardhan Nagode v. The State of
Maharashtra, Bail Application No.1986 of 2022, additionally
recorded defects concerning statutory safeguards. These orders do
not require the same result without assessment of the particular
seizure and its supporting records.
23.
In case of Rajesh Sahu (supra), the Supreme Court
granted bail where the recorded seizure was only a little above
commercial quantity and included material requiring exclusion,
the charge-sheet had been filed and the accused had no
antecedents. That decision must be given full effect, but it does not
prescribe an automatic deduction of every seed or leaf irrespective
of whether it accompanies the tops. Case of Manjay Kumar (supra)
likewise demonstrates that a positive forensic report does not
-16BA-1948-2026
necessarily
overcome
substantial
defects
in
representative
sampling. Its reasoning has been considered. On the particular
combination
of
the
contemporaneous
crime-scene
record,
correspondence of the three packet groups at judicial production,
the reported composition of the sample and the supporting
recovery material in this case, I am unable to reach the favourable
satisfaction sought by the applicant.
24.
On the applicant's connection with the recovery, the
material goes beyond his presence near an unidentified car. The
vehicle particulars record his ownership of the vehicle bearing the
same registration number as that recorded in the seizure
documents, and the seizure witnesses place him beside that vehicle
when the three sacks were recovered. This combination permits a
prima facie inference of knowing control, subject to the defence at
trial. The difference between referring to the car by its make and
recording its model in the vehicle extract does not, at this stage,
displace its identification by the registration number. I have not
considered
applicant's
alleged
confession
to
the
police
as
substantive proof of guilt. The requisitions for telephone records
are
also
not
being
treated
as
proof
of
incriminating
communications. Even if the present material concerning the
wider conspiracy requires further proof, the separate accusation
-17BA-1948-2026
arising from the alleged possession remains for consideration.
25.
The other objections do not presently displace that
material. The recovery relied upon is from the vehicle and its
sacks; the objection under Section 50 concerning personal search
does not invalidate that recovery merely because a notice was
issued.
The
papers
contain
the
recorded
information,
communications to superior officers and a report dated 11 th April,
2026 under Section 57. They do not support the broad contention
that no such steps were taken at all. The panch witnesses'
employment with the transport undertaking does not by itself
establish that they were under police control or that their account
was fabricated. Their credibility remains open to challenge. The
absence of a further recovery during the house search of 14 th April,
2026 does not negate the alleged recovery from the car.
26.
I have considered the contemporaneous recovery and
forensic records, the applicant's connection with the car, the
judicial production of corresponding packet groups and the
reported identification of flowering or fruiting tops retain sufficient
prima facie force that I am unable to record reasonable grounds for
believing that the applicant is not guilty of the offence involving
commercial quantity. This is a limited assessment under Section
-18BA-1948-2026
37 and not a finding that the disputed bulk has already been
proved to be ganja beyond reasonable doubt.
27.
The absence of antecedents, the applicant's residence
and his willingness to comply with conditions weigh in his favour.
The fact that the other accused have not been arrested provides no
parity, but it also does not justify an unsupported prediction that
this applicant will assist them or commit another offence. The two
requirements under Section 37 are cumulative, and the inability to
record
the
first
satisfaction
is
sufficient
in
the
present
circumstances. Completion of investigation does not by itself
remove that statutory limitation. The custody of about six months,
while significant to the applicant, has not on the present material
developed into such prolonged incarceration or demonstrated trial
stagnation
as
would
independently
warrant
release
on
constitutional grounds. Continued detention must remain subject
to a reasonably prompt trial and to reconsideration if material
circumstances change.
ORDER
(i)
Bail Application No.1948 of 2026 stands rejected.
(ii)
All observations concerning the nature and quantity
of the substance, possession, statutory compliance
and the evidentiary link are confined to this
-19BA-1948-2026
application. The trial shall be decided independently
on the evidence, uninfluenced by these observations.
(iii)
The distinct question concerning communication of
grounds of arrest, which was not urged, is left open.
(iv)
This order shall not preclude a fresh application
founded on a material change in circumstances,
including undue delay in the trial.
(HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR)
JUDGE
Tandale
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review