Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.03.02
TELEN KOM Date:
09:07:07 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.735 of 2019
Victor Thingujam, aged 25 years, s/o Thingujam Borbabu Singh, a resident
of Keishampat Hodam Leirak, Imphal, PO & PS, Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001.
…Petitioner
– Versus –
1. The Agricultural Scientists Recruitment Board, represented through its
Chairman/Secretary,
Department
of
Agricultural
Research
and
Education, Krishi Anusandhan Bhavan-1, Pusa Road, New Delhi110012.
2. The Controller of Examination, the Agricultural Scientists Recruitment
Board, Krishi Anusandhan Bhavan-1, PUSA Road, New-Delhi-110012.
3. The Indian Council of Agricultural Research, represented through its
Chairman/Secretary, Krishi Bhavan, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New
Delhi-110001.
…Official Respondents
4. Nidhi Sharma, M.Sc.(Agriculture) with Major in Agroforestry
5. Suresh Ramanan, S., M.Sc(Forestry) with Major in Silviculture and
Agroforestry.
6. Patel Yuvraj Bharat, M.Sc. in Forestry
7. Arun Sukumaran, M.Sc.(Forestry) with major in Tree Improvement.
8. Shyamili M.S., M.Sc.(Forestry) with major in Wildlife Science.
….Private respondents.
with
MC(WP(C))No.116 of 2022
Victor Thingujam, aged 25 years, s/o Thingujam Borbabu Singh, a resident
of Keishampat Hodam Leirak, Imphal, PO & PS, Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001.
…Petitioner
– Versus –
1.
The Agricultural Scientists Recruitment Board, represented through
its Chairman/Secretary, Department of Agricultural Research and
Education, Krishi Anusandhan Bhavan-1, Pusa Road, New Delhi-110012.
2.
The
Controller
of
Examination,
the
Agricultural
Scientists
Recruitment Board, Krishi Anusandhan Bhavan-1, PUSA Road, New-Delhi110012.
3.
The Indian Council of Agricultural Research, represented through its
Chairman/Secretary, Krishi Bhavan, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New Delhi110001.
…Official Respondents
4. Nidhi Sharma, M.Sc.(Agriculture) with Major in Agroforestry
5. Suresh Ramanan, S., M.Sc(Forestry) with Major in Silviculture and
Agroforestry.
6. Patel Yuvraj Bharat, M.Sc. in Forestry
7. Arun Sukumaran, M.Sc.(Forestry) with major in Tree Improvement.
8. Shyamili M.S., M.Sc.(Forestry) with major in Wildlife Science.
….Private respondents.
With
WP(C)No.416 of 2019
Victor Thingujam, aged 25 years, s/o Thingujam Borbabu Singh, a resident
of Keishampat Hodam Leirak, Imphal, PO & PS, Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001.
…Petitioner
– Versus –
1. The Agricultural Scientists Recruitment Board, represented through its
Chairman/Secretary,
Department
of
Agricultural
Research
and
Education, Krishi Anusandhan Bhavan-1, Pusa Road, New Delhi110012.
2. The Controller of Examination, the Agricultural Scientists Recruitment
Board, Krishi Anusandhan Bhavan-1, PUSA Road, New-Delhi-110012.
3. The Indian Council of Agricultural Research, represented through its
Chairman/Secretary, Krishi Bhavan, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New
Delhi-110001.
…Official Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
:
Mr RK Deepak, Adv.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Th. Modhu, Sr. Adv., Henba, Adv.
Date of reserved.
:
09.02.2023
Date of Judgment & Order :
17.02.2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
W.P.(C) No.735 of 2019 has been filed by the petitioner to quash the order
dated 7.8.2019 passed by the first respondent to the extent all six provisionally
selected candidates are declared as eligible and to direct the official respondents
to declare the respondents 4 and 6 and others who do not meet the qualification
prescribed in the notification dated 24.1.2018 as ineligible and to direct the
official respondents to conduct the interview/via voice test afresh by cancelling
the viva voice on 27.5.2019.
2. W.P.(C) No.416 of 2019 has been filed by the petitioner to direct the
respondents to allow the petitioner to participate the interview/viva voce for
appointment to the post of Scientists in Agricultural Research Services and to
postpone the interview/viva voce scheduled to be conducted on 27.5.2019
without the participation of the petitioner.
3. MC (WP) No.116 of 2022 in WP(C) No.735 of 2019 has been filed by
the petitioner to direct the official respondents to produce the records relating to
the opinions/recommendations of subject experts for determining the eligibility
qualifications of the six candidates i.e. the petitioner and the private respondents.
4. Since the parties and the issue involved is one and the same, both the
writ petitions were heard together and disposed of by this common order.
5. The case of the petitioner is that the official respondents issued a
notification dated 24.1.2018 notifying that Agricultural Scientists Recruitment
Board (ASRB) will hold a combined ARS-2017 (Preliminary) and NET (I)-2018
Examination during 6.4.2018 to 13.4.2018 in Online mode at 23 Centres across
India in a staggered slot-wise examination format as per the Rules and Schemes
of Examination indicated in the notification. Pursuant to the notification dated
24.1.2018, the petitioner has made his application and he was allowed to sit in
the Preliminary Agricultural Research Service (ARS) Examination, 2017. On
being qualified in the Preliminary Examination, the petitioner was also allowed to
appear in the Agricultural Research Services (ARS) Mains Examination which
was held on 24.6.2018. The petitioner was also issued a certificate by the
Agricultural Scientists Recruitment Board on qualifying the National Eligibility
Test conducted by the Agricultural Scientist Recruitment Board on 10.4.2018 in
the
discipline
Professorship.
of
Agroforestry
for
eligibility
of
Lecturership/Assistant
The petitioner qualified in the mains examination held on
24.6.2018 and was short listed for the viva voce test vide result notice dated
30.11.2018.
6. Further case of the petitioner is that in the notice, for Code No.42Agroforestry, the name of the petitioner appeared at Serial No.6. However, when
the Agricultural Scientists Recruitment Board issued the provisional date-wise
list of candidates for viva voce, the name of the petitioner did not appear.
Thereafter, by an e-mail dated 20.5.2019, the petitioner was informed that his
candidatures has been rejected due to non-possession of the prescribed
educational qualification with specialization. In the provisional date-wise list of
candidates for viva voce test to be held on 27.5.2019 for Agroforestry – Code
No.42, the seventh respondent was listed at Serial No.4, who has a degree of
M.Sc. in Forestry with specialization in Tree Improvement.
7. Aggrieved by the omission of the candidature of the petitioner from the
list, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.416 of 2019 to allow him to participate in
the interview/viva voce for appointment to the post of Scientists in Agricultural
Research Services. By the interim order dated 24.5.2019, this Court directed
the official respondents to permit the petitioner to provisionally appear for the
viva voce test scheduled for 27.5.2019. When the ASR Board published the list
of candidates recommended in order of merit for appointment to ARS under the
ICAR on 19.7.2019, the respondents 4 and 5 were recommended against
vacancies earmarked for UR and OBC respectively omitting the name of the
petitioner.
Subsequently, the impugned order was communicated to the
petitioner, which declares that the petitioner is eligible for consideration to be
appointed to the post of ARS. Challenging the impugned order, the petitioner
has filed W.P.(C) No.735 of 2019.
8. Respondents 2 and 3 filed affidavit-in-opposition, inter alia, stating that
after the declaration of the result of ARS-2017 (Mains), the eligibility qualification
of the petitioner was checked by the subject matter expert. Since the petitioner
possessing M.Sc. (Forestry) in Forest Products and Utilisation instead of the
prescribed Master degree in Forestry with specialization in Agroforestry, the
expert found him not eligible and, accordingly, his candidature was rejected and
the rejection was in terms of the provisions of the notification dated 24.1.2018.
9. It is stated that the expert after examining the eligibility qualification for
the respective ARS discipline and declared the eligible candidates. Aggrieved
by the omission of the name of the petitioner, he has filed a writ petition before
this Court and in compliance of the interim order dated 24.5.2019 granted in the
said writ petition, the petitioner was provisionally called for attending the viva
voce and the result was kept in a sealed cover. Subsequently, the subject expert
examined the matter and opined that the qualification prescribed in the
notification created an ambiguity regarding nomenclature of the degree/course
taken by all the six candidates. Due to lack of clarity in the advertisement, the
qualification of all the six candidates be considered eligible as they possess
M.Sc. (Forestry) in common. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 7.8.2019
was issued declaring all the six candidates of the Agroforestry discipline,
including the petitioner to be eligible for consideration to be recommended as
Scientist to the ARS based on the actual marks obtained and the vacancies
notified.
10. Assailing the impugned order dated 7.8.2019, the learned counsel for
the petitioner submitted that after dragging the matter for several months, the
ASR Board thought it convenient to declare all the six candidates to be eligible
for consideration to be appointed to the ARS vide impugned order dated
7.8.2019 treating all candidates with M.Sc. (Forestry) as qualified under the
discipline of Agroforestry. He would submit that the Board erred in declaring the
fourth respondent, who was possessing M.Sc. (Agriculture) degree and further
the sixth respondent, who has a M.Sc. (Forestry) without any specialization. The
impugned order was not issued to do justice to the parties, rather it was an
afterthought and aimed at appeasing some interested parties.
11. The learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that the
petitioner is questioning the discrimination shown to him. Further, the petitioner
also questions whether an administrative authority can take an arbitrary and bias
decision to suit certain individuals, instead of applying the rule of law.
12. The learned counsel for the petitioner then submitted that the ASR
Board cannot hide behind the veil of the opinion of the subject expert to justify a
wrongdoing. Even a layman who is not an expert in the field of Forestry would
tell that if a candidate having M.Sc. (Forestry) with specialization in Tree
Improvement is considered as having a specialization in Agroforestry, what
compels the expert to consider the petitioner who has M.Sc. (Forestry) with
specialization in Forest Products and Utilization is not having the said
qualification. There cannot be different yardstick for different candidates and, as
such, the decision is nothing but discriminatory and arbitrary. The action of the
Board in subsequently declaring all candidates, including a candidate who does
not even have a Master’s degree in Forestry as qualified is highly questionable
and a poly to deceive the public and the Scientists of the future who would be
building the nation.
13. The learned counsel next submitted that by its own interpretation and
admission, the ASR Board has violated the established Doctrine of Approbate
and Reprobate, which reflects that a person cannot both approve and reject an
instrument at the same time i.e. one cannot blow hot and cold. Therefore, the
competent authority of ASR Board has no right to approve what is favourable to
it and throw away what is not favourable to it.
14. The learned counsel for the petitioner questioned how many times the
ASR Board is going to change its stand regarding the educational qualification
of the candidates. For instance, if tomorrow another subject expert points out
that none of the six candidates have certificates which mention Agroforestry as
their specializations, is the ASR Board going to declare all of them as
disqualified.
15. Adding further, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that as
per the admission of the official respondents “the qualification prescribed in the
notification created an ambiguity regarding the nomenclature of the degree taken
by all the six candidates” and “due to lack in clarity in the notification, the
qualification of all six candidates be considered eligible, as they possess M.Sc.
(Forestry) in common”.
This statement is erroneous and misleading, as
according to the petitioner, all of they do not possess the degree of M.Sc.
(Forestry).
16. Arguing so, the learned counsel for the petitioner seeks to quash the
impugned order dated 7.8.2019 to the extent all the six provisionally selected
candidates are declared as eligible and further direct the official respondents to
declare only those who meet the qualification prescribed in the notification dated
24.1.2018 as eligible.
17. Per contra, Th. Modhu, the learned counsel appearing for the official
respondents contended that the impugned order was issued after reviewing the
eligibility qualification of the candidates by the concerned subject expert and the
qualification in respect of both the major and minor courses studied by all the six
candidates was scrutinized again and it was found four eligible candidates took
relevant courses required for the post of Research Scientist in the field of
Agroforestry discipline and two candidates who were not considered eligible to
appear for the viva voce also took courses in Forestry, but not much relevant to
Agroforestry. Since the qualification prescribed in the notification created an
ambiguity qua nomenclature of the courses taken by all the six candidates, all
the six candidates are considered by the subject expert as they possess the
degree of M.Sc. (Forestry) in common.
18. The learned counsel would submit that the fourth respondent has got
M.Sc. (Agriculture) degree with specification in Agroforestry and the
recommendation of the subject expert is not arbitrary. He submitted that the
ASR Board observes that since the qualification for Agroforestry discipline in the
notification mentioned M.Sc. in Forestry and does not specifically mandate
specialization in Agroforestry, since all the six candidates can be considered to
be qualified based on either being M.Sc. Forestry or having specialization in
Agroforestry. Based on this, it was decided that all the candidates with M.Sc.
(Forestry) can be considered to be qualified under the discipline of Agroforestry
and all the six concerned are declared to be eligible for consideration to be
appointed to ARS based on the actual marks obtained by them and the
vacancies notified.
19. The learned counsel further submitted that the petitioner is merely
expressing an assumption regarding the scoring in viva voce.
The Board
conducts ARS (Preliminary), ARS (Mains) examination and viva voce in an
impartial manner and has not faced any complaint in regard to the discrimination
against any particular candidates.
20. The learned counsel urged that the petitioner has got Master’s Degree
(Forestry) with specialization in Forest Products and Utilization, which is quite
different form the prescribed specialization in Agroforestry for Research Scientist
and was declared ineligible by the subject expert. However, based on the
courses opted in Agroforestry by the petitioner in M.Sc., his qualification was
reviewed and he was declared eligible due to lack of clarity in the notification
regarding nomenclature of courses taken by the candidates.
The NET
certificates are issued to the candidates who obtained minimum prescribed
qualifying marks.
The documents in support of their eligibility for NET
examination were not sought from candidates and their eligibilities were not
checked by the ASRB. It is the responsibility of the concerned State Agricultural
Universities to satisfy themselves with regard to fulfillment of the requisite posts
of Lecturers/Assistant Professors, including verifying the authenticity of the NET
certificate in the possession of the candidates before the candidates are formally
appointed.
21. The learned counsel finally argued that the eligibility qualification along
with specialization possessed by the qualified candidates to be provisionally
called for viva voce is always checked by the subject expert concerned and,
further, the viva voce is also conducted by a Committee comprised of outside
experts chaired by the Chairman/Member(s) concerned of the Board and that
the writ petition is not maintainable, as this Court has no jurisdiction to entertain
the writ petition under Section 14 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985,
inasmuch as in view of the notification dated 20.4.1987 published in the Gazette
of India. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the writ petition.
22. This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the
materials available on record.
23. As per the prayer made by the learned counsel for the petitioner, on
23.09.2021 this Court directed the respondents to produce the entire original files
relating to the 6(six) candidates and accordingly the same was produced. This
Court also while considering the case on merits perused the entire original
records pertaining to the selection of 6(six) candidates as produced by the official
respondents.
24. The grievance of the petitioner is that the impugned order is arbitrary,
bias and illegal. The manner in which all six candidates were declared as eligible
is illegal and, in fact, the declaration of all the six candidates as eligible to be
appointed is an afterthought.
25. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that a
candidate who does not have a Master’s degree in Forestry, as in the case of
the fourth respondent, who has a Master’s degree in Agriculture; a candidate
who does not have specialization exclusively in Agroforestry, as in the case of
the fifth respondent, who has M.Sc. (Forestry) with specialization in Silviculture
and Agroforestry; a candidate who does not have a specialization in Agroforestry
as in the case of the sixth respondent, who has M.Sc. (Forestry) without any
specialization; and, a candidate who has specialization in a discipline related to
Agroforestry, as in the case of the seventh respondent, who has M.Sc. (Forestry)
with specialization in Tree Improvement have been considered for appointment.
Thus, the petitioner strongly contended that when all the aforesaid candidates
were treated by the ASR Board as qualified for appearing in the viva voce dated
27.5.2019, what reasons and justifications compelled the ASR Board to treat a
similarly situated candidate like the petitioner differently and declared him
ineligible at the last moment in the earlier occasion.
26. In reply, the learned counsel for the official respondents contended
that the eligibility qualification along with specialization possessed by the
qualified candidates to be provisionally called for viva voce is always checked by
the concerned subject expert in view of the prescribed eligibility qualification for
the respective ARS disciplines as notified in the notification. He would submit
that the concerned subject expert examines whether a candidate possesses
eligibility qualifications for the respective ARS discipline and accordingly
declared as eligible.
27. Pursuant to the notification dated 24.1.2018, the petitioner appeared
in the ARS Examination-2017, which was conducted in combination with ARS2017 (Preliminary) and NET(I)-2018 Examination conducted between 6.4.2018
to 13.4.2018 in Online mode at 23 centres across India in a staggered slot-wise
examination format as per the Rules and Schemes of the Examination.
The
petitioner cleared the preliminary examination and also the main written
examination which was conducted on 24.6.2018 and the provisional list of
candidates qualified for viva voce under 29 disciplines was uploaded on the
website of ARS Board. The petitioner was shortlisted for the viva voce along
with other 5 other candidates.
However, even after the issuance of the
provisional list way back in November 2018, no date for viva voce was intimated.
On enquiry, when the petitioner came to realize that the ASR Board had
published another provisional date-wise list of candidates for viva voce and
knowing that his name was excluded in the newly published list thereby rejecting
his candidature on the ground of non-possession of the requisite qualification,
the petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.416 of 2019. This Court, in its interim order
dated 24.5.2019, directed the official respondents to allow the petitioner to
appear at the viva voce conducted on 27.5.2019.
Thereafter, ASR Board
published list of candidates recommended in order of merit for appointment to
ARS under the ICAR on 19.7.2019. In the said list, two candidates, namely, the
respondents 4 and 5 were recommended against vacancies earmarked.
Subsequently, the impugned order came to be passed declaring that all the six
candidates, including the petitioner are eligible for consideration to be appointed.
28. According to the official respondents, the reason for considering the
petitioner second time for appointment to ARS is that the eligibility qualification
of all the candidates of Agroforestry discipline was re-checked by the concerned
subject expert as it was opined that the qualification prescribed in the
advertisement
created
an
ambiguity
regarding
nomenclature
of
the
degree/courses taken by all the six candidates. It has also been stated that due
to lack of clarity in the advertisement, the qualification of all the six candidates
considered as they possess M.Sc. (Forestry) in common.
Accordingly, the
impugned order was passed declaring all the six candidates of the Agroforestry
discipline, including the petitioner eligible.
29. The petitioner questions the consideration of respondents 4 and 6 and
others not eligible, as they have not fulfilled the prescribed educational
qualification and the subject expert erred in declaring them as eligible.
30. The respondents 2 and 3 filed affidavit-in-opposition stating that due
to lack of clarity in the advertisement, the qualifications of all the six candidates
was considered eligible as they possess M.Sc. (Forestry) in common.
The
aforesaid statement made in the affidavit-in-opposition is completely erroneous
as they do not possess the degree of M.Sc. (Forestry) – the fourth respondent
possesses M.Sc. in Agriculture and the sixth respondent possesses M.Sc. Forest
without any specialization.
31. As rightly argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner, ASR Board
probably on the recommendation of the subject expert, declared that a Master
Degree in Agriculture is the same as a Master Degree in Forestry; M.Sc.
(Forestry) with specialization in Silviculture & Agroforestry and Tree
Improvement are the same as Master Degree in Forestry; candidates who do not
have a specialization in Agroforestry as a Master Degree in Forestry, which this
Court is of the considered opinion is unsustainable in law. The aforesaid
conclusion arrived at by the expert has not been properly justified by the official
respondents.
By its own admission, the ASR Board has violated the well
established doctrine of approbate and reprobate, which could be evident from
the materials available on record.
32. It is to be noted that no valid evidentiary proof has been produced by
the official respondents to prove their case. Furthermore, it is seen that the
eligibility qualifications of all the six candidates were scrutinized in the back drop
of the Court cases filed by two candidates who were disqualified based on their
M.Sc. specialization and when the qualification in respect of both the major and
minor courses studied by all the six candidates were scrutinized again where it
was found that four candidates studied relevant courses required for the post of
Research Scientist in the field of Agroforestry and were declared eligible, while
the two also studied courses in Forestry, but not much relevant to Agroforestry
and were declared eligible is not appreciable for the simple reason that a person
cannot both approve and reject a fact at the same time.
33. The documents produced by the official respondents do not indicate
anywhere that recommendations of subject expert regarding the eligibility of the
candidates were obtained at each stage where the eligibility issue was
considered, in contrast to what the official respondents made to appear. The
only conclusion that can be drawn from the above is that the eligibility of
candidates was decided beforehand by the official respondents at their whims
and fancies only to favour a few candidates and the so called recommendation
was moulded to suit their interest.
34. On overall analysis of the matter on hand and as rightly argued by the
learned counsel for the petitioner, there are several contradictions in the
conclusion arrived at by the ASR Board and the expert and few are summarized
hereunder:
(i)
The ASR Board observed the qualification for
Agroforestry
discipline
in
the
notification
mentioned M.Sc. in Forestry and does not
specifically
mandate
specialization
in
Agroforestry.
The aforesaid observation contradicts with the
eligibility
qualification
advertisement
i.e.
specified
“Master’s
in
the
degree
in
Forestry/Agroforestry/Botany/Agronomy/Horticult
ure with specialization in Agroforestry”.
(ii)
If the specialization in Agroforestry is said to be
not mandated by the Board and can be ignored,
then on what basis the Board selected the fourth
respondent, who has a Master’s degree in
Agriculture.
In view of the discussions held supra, the fourth
respondent does not have M.Sc. in Forestry.
(iii)
If we apply the same logic adopted by the Board
in accepting the candidature of the fourth
respondent, it is questionable - can a person who
has Master’s degree in Chemistry be accepted
because Chemistry is also a Science stream and
also related to Forestry or Agroforestry.
The ASR Board is bound to accept the
candidature of the person illustrated because just
like the fourth respondent as she does not have
a Master’s degree in Forestry and specialization
in Agroforestry is not mandatory as per the Board.
(iv)
After the recruitment process started, the Board
has changed the rule and changing the rule after
the process started is impermissible in the eye of
law.
35. The issue of relevancy of courses becomes significant in the context
of what the Board states – while two candidates studied courses in the Forestry,
but not much relevant to Agroforestry, they were declared ineligible. Where the
seventh respondent, who obtained M.Sc. (Forestry) with specialization in Tree
Improvement is found eligible, the petitioner who possess M.Sc. (Forestry) with
specialization in Forest Products and Utilization is found ineligible by the Board.
The conduct of the subject expert in arriving at the conclusion in respect of the
petitioner not eligible at the earlier stage is unacceptable. There appears to be
a discrimination as rightly argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner.
36. It is apposite to note that the sequence of events leading to the
declaration of all the six candidates as eligible demonstrates a mala fide intention
on the part of the official respondents to help some candidates at the cost of
others. This Court is also of the view that declaring the petitioner as eligible, only
after the viva voce test was conducted and after two candidates were
recommended for appointment, is merely a ploy to eliminate the petitioner.
Therefore, declaring all the six candidates as eligible vide impugned order is
contrary to the qualification prescribed in the notification dated 24.1.2018 and
the Board cannot give different meanings to the qualification so prescribed which
is specific and unambiguous and also it is imperative on the part of the Board to
declare only those who meet the qualification prescribed in the said notification
as eligible.
37. Declaring even ineligible candidates as eligible reduced the chances
of those who are eligible as per the notification from being recommended for
appointment. There is also no convincing reasoning coming forth from the side
of the official respondents for declaring candidates with no specialization as
eligible.
38. As stated supra, the petitioner is a Post Graduate in M.Sc. Forestry
with major in Forestry Products and Utilization. The specialization in Forestry
Products and Utilization is so closely related to a specialization in Agroforestry.
In other words, as per the subject expert himself, the two may mean the same.
Recognizing the similarity between the two, the petitioner was also awarded NET
qualification in the discipline of Agroforestry by the Board itself. Therefore, this
Court is of the view that the petitioner has fulfilled the qualification required for
the post in question compared with others.
39. For all the reasons stated above, this Court is of the considered view
that the petitioner has made out a case in favour him and the impugned order to
the extent all the six provisionally selected candidates declared as eligible is
liable to be set aside. Thus, the official respondents are duty bound to declare
only those who meet the qualification prescribed in the notification dated
24.1.2018.
40. In the result,
(i)
W.P.(C) No.735 of 2019 is allowed.
(ii)
The official respondents are directed to declare only those who
meet the qualification prescribed in the notification dated 24.1.2018
as eligible. Inasmuch as the petitioner was found eligible based on
his qualification, the official respondents shall decide as to whether
he needs to be subjected to fresh viva voce again. The impugned
order stands quashed to the extent indicated above.
(iii)
The official respondents shall consider the candidature of
respondents 4 and 6 and others afresh and decide whether viva
voice needs to be held or not.
(iv) The said exercise is directed to be completed within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
(v)
In view of the participation of the petitioner in the viva voce held
earlier, W.P.(C) No.416 of 2019 stands closed.
(vi) Consequently, MC (WP) No.116 of 2022 in WP(C) No.735 of 2019
is dismissed.
(vii) No costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review