Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 07TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO.101394/2022 (PAR/POS)
BETWEEN:
VENKATESH S/O. FAKIRAPPA DEVARADDI,
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HOSAYARGUDRI, TQ. GOKAK.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI S.B.HEBBALLI AND
SMT. CHITRA M. GOUNDALKAR, ADVOCATES.)
AND:
1.
KASHAVVA
D/O. SADASHIV SANTI @ RANJANAGI,
AGE: 52 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE & HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. METAGUD, TQ. MUDHOL,
NOW AT MUDALAGI, TQ. MUDALAGI,
DIST. BELAGAVI-590001.
2.
LAXMIBAI W/O. FAKIRAPPA DEVARADDI,
AGE: 72 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE & HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. HOSAYARGUDRI, TQ. GOKAK,
DIST. BELAGAVI-590001.
3.
SRI RUDRAPPA S/O. RAMAPPA SANTI,
AGE: 62 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. METGUD, TQ. MUDHOL,
DIST. BAGALKOT-587101.
MALLIKARJUN
RUDRAYYA
KALMATH
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
4.
SRI SHANKREPPA S/O. RAMAPPA SANTI,
AGE: 57 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. METGUD, TQ. MUDHOL,
DIST. BAGALKOT-587101.
5.
SMT. PADDAVVA W/O. RANGAPPA GANGARADDI,
AGE: 53 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. KAMALADINNI, TQ. MUDHOL,
DIST. BAGALKOT-590001.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI SHRIHARSH A. NEELOPANT, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
NOTICE TO R2 SERVED;
NOTICE TO R3 TO R5 DISPENSED WITH.)
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
100 OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908, PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 05.09.2020 PASSED
IN R.A.NO.1/2019, ON THE FILE OF PRINCIPAL SENIOR CIVIL
JUDGE, GOKAK, MODIFYING THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 15.12.2018 PASSED BY THE COURT OF CIVIL JUDGE AND
JMFC, MUDALAGI, IN O.S.NO.90/2014 (OLD O.S.NO.503/2009)
AND RESTORE THAT OF THE TRIAL COURT IN THE INTEREST OF
JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
This appeal is filed by defendant No.7 challenging the
judgment
and
decree
dated
05.09.2020,
passed
in
R.A.No.01/2019, on the file of Principal Senior Civil Judge,
Gokak (for short, ‘First Appellate Court’), which set aside
and modified the judgment and decree dated 15.12.2018,
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
passed in O.S.No.90/2014 (old No.503/2009), on the file of
Civil Judge and JMFC, Mudalagi (for short, ‘Trial Court’).
2.
The Trial Court has decreed the suit to the effect
that the plaintiff is entitled for half share in the suit
schedule item Nos.1 to 3 properties and 1/3rd share in the
suit schedule item Nos.4 and 5 properties.
3.
The above said decree is modified by the First
Appellate Court holding that the plaintiff is entitled for half
share in suit item Nos.1 to 5 properties and defendant No.3
is entitled for remaining half share in the suit schedule item
Nos.1 to 5 properties.
4.
The Trial Court has held execution of Will by
defendant No.1 bequeathing the properties in favour of
defendant No.7 (appellant herein) is proved, but the First
Appellate Court has reversed this finding of execution of Will
and thus no share is given to defendant No.7. Therefore,
defendant No.7 has preferred the present appeal.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
5.
For
the
purpose
of
convenience
and
easy
reference, ranking of the parties is referred to as per their
status before the trial Court.
6.
The plaintiff has filed suit for partition and
separate possession for claiming half share in the suit
schedule properties and for declaration that the decree
passed in O.S.No.260/1996 dated 16.06.2001, by the Court
of Additional Civil Judge, Mudhol, is not binding on the
share of the plaintiff.
7.
The following are the suit schedule properties.
“1.
Description of suit properties:
The suit properties are the agricultural lands
situate within the village limits of Yargudri village
Tal. Gokak and Mallapur, P.J. Tal. Mudhol, as
detailed below:
Sl.
No.
R.S.No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
123/A
123/2
136/A/2
66/3
Area
A-G
Asst.
Rs.Ps.
6-01
0-07
3-07
3-26
0-01 PK
3-25
11-22
00-31
5-92
2-51
Village
Market
Value
Rs.
Yaragudri
4,00,000
Yaragudri
20,000
Yaragudri
2,00,000
Mallapur PJ 1,00,000
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
5.
66/4
8.
(Out of
1Ac. 32½
Gs.)
1-21
1-06
Mallapur PJ
80,000
Total
8,00,000
The plaintiff has produced the genealogy as
follows:
Mallappa (Dead)
Lakkavva (Dead)
Laxmibai (Plaintiff)
Sadashiv (D1)
Gangavva(D2)
Kashavva (D3)
9.
In the suit, it is the case of the plaintiff that the
suit schedule item Nos.1 to 3 were granted to Lakkawwa
wife of Mallappa, by the Land Tribunal in the year 1981 and
thus Lakkawwa is the exclusive owner of the suit schedule
item Nos.1 to 3 properties. The suit schedule item Nos.4
and 5 are the ancestral properties. The defendant s have
filed written statement admitting the relationship and
nature of the properties.
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
10.
Learned counsel for appellant submitted that
defendant No.1 during his lifetime had executed a Will in
favour of son of plaintiff who is defendant No.7 bequeathing
the properties in his favour and Trial Court upon considering
the evidence on record has held that the Will is proved. The
Will is executed on 15.01.2009. But the First Appellate
Court has reversed the finding on the Will and has held that
defendant No.7 has not proved execution of Will as the Will
is surrounded with suspicious circumstances.
11.
It is submitted that Ex.D.30 is the original Will
and on the basis of evidence of DW.3 and DW.4, execution
of Will is proved. The First Appellate Court has reversed the
finding disbelieving the evidence of DW.3 and DW.4.
Therefore, submitted that the First appellate Court has
taken
recourse
of
hyper
technical
reasons
while
appreciating the evidence of witnesses in proving the
execution of Will. Therefore, the Will is proved and when
the Will is proved, defendant No.7 is entitled for share in
the properties of defendant No.1. Therefore, prays for
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
interference with the judgment and decree passed by the
First Appellate Court.
12.
No.3
On the other hand, learned counsel for defendant
submitted
that
defendant
No.3
is
daughter
of
defendant No.1, but defendant No.1 had executed a Will in
favour of son of plaintiff excluding his own daughter, which
creates suspiciousness in executing the Will. Therefore, the
First Appellate Court has rightly held that the Will is not
proved. Hence, prays to dismiss the appeal.
13.
Having heard the arguments of learned counsels
appearing for both the sides, the following substantial
question of law would arise for consideration.
Whether, under the facts and circumstances
involved in the case, the First Appellate Court is
justified in holding Ex.D.30-Will is not proved and
thus the appellant/defendant No.7 is not entitled for
share in the share of defendant No.1?
14.
The suit is filed for partition and separate
possession for claiming half share in the suit schedule
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
properties. Admittedly the suit schedule item Nos.1 to 3
properties were granted by the Land Tribunal in favour of
Lakkawwa, who is mother of plaintiff and defendant No.1.
This fact is not disputed. Therefore, Lakkawwa had become
exclusive owner of the suit schedule item Nos.1 to 3
properties. Therefore, the plaintiff being daughter has filed
suit for partition and the Trial Court has granted half share
in suit schedule item Nos.1 to 3 properties, as Lakkavva
died intestate, as per Section 15 of the Hindu Succession
Act, the plaintiff who is daughter and defendant No.1 who is
son are entitled for equal share in the suit schedule item
Nos.1 to 3 properties.
15.
It is not disputed that suit schedule item Nos.4
and 5 properties are the ancestral properties. Defendant
No.3 is daughter of defendant s No.1 and 2. It is the case of
defendant No.1 that during lifetime of defendant No.1,
defendant No.1 had executed a Will dated 15.01.2009
bequeathing his share of properties in favour of defendant
No.7 who is son of the plaintiff. It is borne out from the
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
evidence that defendant s No.2 and 3 who are wife and
daughter of defendant No.1 are residing separately from
defendant No.1. Therefore, during last years of defendant
No.1, defendant s No.2 and 3 had not accompanied
defendant No.1. Therefore, defendant No.1 was constrained
to reside in his sister’s house with plaintiff and therefore, it
is the case of defendant No.7 that defendant No.1 had
executed a Will in favour of defendant No.7. The Trial Court
appreciated the evidence on record regarding execution of
Will that it is proved that defendant No.1 had executed the
Will dated 15.01.2009.
16. The First Appellate Court, while considering the
proof of execution of the Will, assigned reasons that
defendant No.1 had performed the marriage of defendant
No.3 (his daughter) by spending a huge amount and that
she is now residing in her matrimonial home. The First
Appellate Court observed that defendant No.1 had not
assigned any reason for excluding defendant No.3 from the
Will, which, according to it, created suspicion. Further, the
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
Court commented on the depositions of DWs.3 and 4,
stating that they did not know the family affairs of
defendant
No.1,
thereby
creating
suspicion
regarding
execution of the Will.
17.
While analysing the appreciation of evidence
made by DWs.3 and 4, the Trial Court had straightaway
appreciated the Will and held that the execution of the Will
was proved and that defendant No.1 intended to execute
the Will, as defendant Nos.2 and 3, being his wife and
daughter, had deserted defendant No.1 and started living
separately. Consequently, defendant No.1 started residing
in his sister’s house and therefore executed the Will in
favour of defendant No.7. These facts were not disputed by
defendant No.3.
18.
When such being the case, merely because
defendant No.1 did not explain why he executed the Will in
favour of defendant No.7 and excluded defendant No.3, it
cannot be said that the Will is surrounded by suspicious
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
circumstances. Further, the First Appellate Court adopted a
hyper-technical approach in holding that since DWs.3 and 4
did not know much about the family affairs of defendant
No.1, their evidence was unreliable. Merely because DWs.3
and 4 were not fully aware of the internal family affairs of
defendant
No.1,
it
does
not
render
them
suspicious
witnesses. Naturally, outsiders to the family may not be
aware of internal family matters, and that by itself does not
make DWs.3 and 4 false witnesses.
19. Further, the First Appellate Court also approached
the matter from the angle of the type of pen used—whether
it was a liquid ink pen or a ballpoint pen—and found fault
with the execution of the Will on that ground. Such findings,
regarding the use of pen, are nothing but hyper technical
reasoning. Therefore, the First Appellate Court adopted an
overly hyper technical approach while considering the Will.
20.
Whereas, in practice, while preparing a Will and
while considering whether it was written in the natural
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
course of events, minor discrepancies are bound to occur.
Such discrepancies cannot be viewed through a magnifying
glass so as to disbelieve the Will. While considering a Will,
the necessary legal requirements must be examined along
with the evidence on record. In the present case, DWs.3
and 4 have stated that they were attesting witnesses, that
defendant No.1 had requested a school teacher to scribe the
Will, and that after the Will was written, both witnesses put
their signatures. Admittedly, the scribe was a school
teacher and not an advocate or professional scribe. Merely
because the school teacher who scribed the Will did not
maintain formal notes, which does not render the Will
invalid. The discrepancy in the evidence of DWs.3 and 4
regarding the notes is a minor discrepancy and does not go
to the root of proving the Will.
21.
Therefore,
considering
the
appreciation
of
evidence made by the Trial Court regarding proof of the
Will, the approach adopted by the Trial Court is found to be
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
correct. Accordingly, it stands proved that defendant No.1
executed the Will in favour of defendant No.7.
22. It is argued that the Will is dated 15.01.2009, the
suit was filed on 31.07.2009, and defendant No.1 died on
17.02.2014. During his lifetime and during the pendency of
the suit, defendant No.1 did not whisper anything about
execution of the Will. Therefore, production of the Will by
defendant No.7 after the death of defendant No.1 is said to
have created doubt regarding its genuineness.
23. Considering
this submission, merely
because
defendant No.1 did not disclose execution of the Will during
his lifetime cannot be treated as a suspicious circumstance.
If the testator discloses execution of a Will during his
lifetime, there are chances of disputes and quarrels among
family members. Therefore, sometimes execution of Will is
not disclosed during the lifetime of the testator. Hence,
non-disclosure of the Will during the lifetime of the testator
itself cannot be treated as a suspicious circumstance.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
Accordingly, I do not find any merit in the submission made
by defendant No.3.
24. When it is proved that defendant No.1 had
executed a Will in favour of defendant No.7, the findings
recorded by the First Appellate Court cannot be sustained.
Defendant No.7 is therefore entitled to his share in terms of
the Will.
25. Defendant Nos.1 and 2 are husband and wife,
respectively, and defendant No.3 is their daughter. Insofar
as suit schedule item Nos.1 to 3 properties are concerned,
the plaintiff and defendant No.1 each are entitled to half
share. Defendant No.3 is the daughter of defendant No.1. It
is stated that defendant No.2 has also died. Therefore, both
defendant No.7 and defendant No.3 are entitled to equal
shares in the half share of defendant No.1, which means
defendant No.7 and defendant No.3 are entitled to 1/4th
share each in suit schedule item Nos.1 to 3 properties.
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
26.
Insofar as the decree in favour of the plaintiff is
concerned, the same is not disturbed and remains intact.
The allotment of 1/4th share each to defendant No.7 and
defendant No.3 is only in respect of the share of defendant
No.1, without disturbing the plaintiff’s half share.
27.
Insofar as suit schedule item Nos.4 and 5
properties are concerned, admittedly these are ancestral
properties. Therefore, the plaintiff is entitled to 1/3rd share,
which is not disturbed. Sadashiva, Gangavva, and their
daughter were entitled to 1/3rd share each. Sadashiva and
Gangavva have died. Therefore, out of the 1/3rd share
allotted to Sadashiva (defendant No.1), both defendant
No.7 and defendant No.3 are entitled to equal shares in the
share of defendant No.1. Accordingly, each is entitled to
1/6th share in suit schedule item Nos.4 and 5 properties.
28.
The above allotment to defendant No.3 and
defendant No.7 is only in respect of the share of Sadashiva
and does not affect the plaintiff’s share as granted by the
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
Trial Court. Therefore, the judgment and decree of the first
appellate Court is liable to be set aside. Therefore,
accordingly, I answer substantial question of law in the
negative.
29. Hence, I proceed to pass the following;
ORDER
i.
The Regular Second Appeal is allowed in
part.
ii.
The
judgment
and
decree
dated
05.09.2020, passed in R.A.No.01/2019, on
the file of Principal Senior Civil Judge,
Gokak, is set aside.
iii.
The
judgment
and
decree
dated
15.12.2018, passed in O.S.No.90/2014 (old
No.503/2009), on the file of Civil Judge and
JMFC, Mudalagi, insofar as for granting of
share to the plaintiff is not disturbed and
modified holding that Defendant Nos.3 and
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:103
RSA No. 101394 of 2022
HC-KAR
7 are entitled for 1/4th share each in suit
schedule
item
Nos.1
to
properties.
Defendant Nos.3 and 7 are entitled for 1/6th
share each in suit schedule item Nos.4 and
5 properties.
iv.
The decree insofar as plaintiff is concerned
granting half share in suit schedule item
Nos.1 to 3 properties and 1/3rd share in suit
schedule item Nos.4 and 5 properties is
kept intact, not disturbed.
v.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
JUDGE
MRK-para 1 to 15.
ASN-16 to end.
CT-AN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review