Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans
Writ – Habeas Corpus – On 05.05.2018, the petitioner and respondent no.4 solemnised and registered their marriage in South Brunswick, New Jersey, USA – In the wedlock, a daughter was born – Matrimonial dispute arose between the parties – Respondent no.4 invoked the jurisdiction of the Superior Court of California and preferred a petition seeking dissolution of marriage and custody of the child – The Superior Court of California, after hearing both parties and keeping in mind the best interests of the child, passed an order dated 25.08.2022 granting joint custody and shared parenting to both parents, with an equal 50:50 time share on a 4-3-3-4 schedule – On 08.09.2022, respondent no. 4 left the USA for India with the child, despite the order dated 25.08.2022 – Pursuant thereto, the Superior Court of California, inter-alia, directed the respondent no.4 to immediately return child to the appellant’s physical custody in California – Appellant filed writ petition (habeas corpus) in India, before the High Court – The High Court dismissed the writ petition and concluded that it would be in the best interest of the child to remain in her mother’s custody i.e. the respondent no.4 – Correctness:
Held: It is not disputed that the appellant and respondent no.4 solemnised their marriage in the United States and set up their matrimonial home there – In fact, both the divorce and the custody proceedings in the United States were instituted by respondent no.4 herself – A perusal of the custody order dated 25.08.2022 shows that it was passed after hearing both parties and after taking into account the best interests of the child – Yet, barely two weeks after that order was passed, respondent no.4 brought the child to India, in clear breach of the conditions it contained – Nothing on record suggests that her circumstances were so grave or frightening that she was left with no option but to take the child out of the USA – In these circumstances, the comity of courts, and the principle that a party ought not to benefit from their own wrong, tilt the scales in favour of the appellant – However, the decision does not rest on these considerations alone – The welfare of the child has remained the governing consideration – The welfare of the child would be better served in the USA – Therefore, the child must be returned to the United States into the custody of the appellant – Respondent no.4 cannot insist that child should remain with her in India, or deny the appellant, as her father, the joint custody and shared parenting that are his due – Respondent no.4 has agreed to accompany child to the United States – In view of her statement, respondent no.4 is directed to travel to the United States with the child on or before 31.12.2026 – Appellant would provide respondent no.4 monthly financial assistance of USD 3,200, as ordered by the Superior Court of California and would not take any legal steps against respondent no.4 in respect of the alleged violation of the order dated 25.08.2022 – As a matter of abundant caution, the appellant is directed to furnish security in the sum of Rs.1,00,00,000/- (Rupees One Crore only) by way of a fixed deposit receipt initially for a period of 18 months on an auto renewable basis in the name of the Registrar, Supreme Court of India. [Paras 34-37, 39, 41, 43]
Matrimonial dispute – Child custody – Welfare of child – Order of a Foreign Court:
Held: The welfare of the child is the paramount consideration in every such case, whatever orders the courts of another country may have made – Put differently, a court in this country, when exercising its jurisdiction, cannot blindly follow the order of a foreign court and act merely as an executing court – This position rests on two foundations – The first is that once the court is seized of the matter, it exercises its parens patriae jurisdiction – That jurisdiction obliges it to consider and assess the matter for itself, through the lens of the child’s welfare – The second is that the decision in such cases turns not on the legal rights of the parties but on the welfare of the child – The same emphasis on welfare over legal entitlement runs through our statutes on custody and guardianship – They make clear that a person otherwise entitled to custody or guardianship need not be granted it if that would not be for the welfare of the child – There is thus no ambiguity in the fact that an order of a foreign court must yield to the welfare of the child. [Paras 15, 16]
Matrimonial dispute – Child custody – Order of a Foreign Court – Disobedience by a parent:
Held: The necessary consequence of the paramountcy of the child’s welfare, and of a foreign order yielding to it, is simple – A parent’s disobedience of a foreign order does not, by itself, require the court to give automatic effect to that order – Nor can the remedy of habeas corpus be invoked merely to enforce the directions of a foreign court. [Para 17]
Matrimonial dispute – Child custody – Order of a Foreign Court – When weight to be given:
Held: The paramountcy of the child’s welfare does not mean that the order of a foreign court is to be disregarded – The weight to be given to the order of a foreign court may turn on a few factors, such as: (i) the nature of the order, including whether the foreign court examined the best interests of the child on the merits, whether both parties were heard, and who instituted the proceedings before it; (ii) the time that has elapsed since the order was passed; and (iii) whether circumstances have changed in the interim – No single factor is decisive – It is the combination of these factors that must be considered – Proper weight, therefore, is not a matter of mathematical precision – It is a matter of the court’s considered assessment of how far the foreign order reflects the welfare of the child. [Paras 18, 19] Matrimonial dispute – Child custody – Order of a Foreign Court – Nature of inquiry the court must undertake: Held: The court must independently consider the welfare of the child, and in considering it must assign proper weight to the order of the foreign court – But before the court undertakes that exercise, it must first decide whether the case calls for a summary inquiry or an elaborate one – In a summary inquiry, the court proceeds on the footing that the welfare of the child is best served by following the order of the foreign court – The child is therefore returned to the country from which the child was removed, unless it is clearly shown that such return would be harmful to the child – In an elaborate inquiry, the court does not stop at the foreign order – It takes the order into account, but goes on to examine for itself where the welfare of the child truly lies. [Para 20]
As published in the Supreme Court Reports, Supreme Court of India. Headnotes prepared by: Ankit Gyan. Text from the Indian Supreme Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs), CC BY 4.0.
As listed in the Supreme Court Reports. Linked where the judgment is on LegalFirms.in.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review