Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/damodar-valley-corporation-vs-maithan-alloys-limited-ors-20261030/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Civil · Reportable judgment

Damodar Valley Corporation vs Maithan Alloys Limited & Ors.

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Supreme Court of India
Date
30 October 2026
Case No.
Civil Appeal No. 11106 of 2024
Result
Allowed
Bench
J.B. Pardiwala, K. Vinod Chandran
Citation
[2026] 10 S.C.R. 576 : 2026 INSC 1178
Acts & Sections
Constitution Damodar Valley Corporation Act, 1948 Electricity Act, 2003 Central Electricity Regulatory Commission… Tariff Regulations of 2004 Consumer Protection Act, 1986
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.
Supreme Court Reports [2026] 10 S.C.R. 576 : 2026 INSC 1178
Issue for consideration
Whether the review by the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity of its earlier order of the year 2019 is illegal, misplaced and in breach of the principles of judicial discipline, when the very same issue was settled by this Court in Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited & Ors. v. Damodar Valley Corporation & Ors. reported as [2018]

10 SCR 773, based on which, the original order was passed by the Tribunal.
Headnote

Constitution of India – Art.141 – Violation of – Breach of judicial discipline – When – Damodar Valley Corporation Act, 1948 – Electricity Act, 2003 – Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2009 – In the earlier proceedings, for the period 2009 to 2014, the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) fixed the tariff of DVC based on the statutory provisions of the 2003 Act, the DVC Act and the Tariff Regulations of 2009 – The very same issue of whether the ‘Sinking Fund’ which refers to a portion of the profits appropriated for the purpose of redeeming the bonds issued by the DVC, was entitled to be factored in the tariff of the power generated and supplied by the DVC was considered and upheld in Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited & Ors. v. Damodar Valley Corporation & Ors. reported as [2018] 10 SCR 773, a binding precedent – Appellate Tribunal by way of its judgment in 2019 upheld the order of the CERC based inter alia on Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys – Review filed by the 1st respondent, allowed by the impugned order – Interference with:

Read the full headnote (2 more paragraphs)

Held: Impugned order set aside, order of the Appellate Tribunal at the first instance dated 17.05.2019 is restored – Appellate Tribunal’s findings on the issue relating to depreciation and Sinking Fund, were perfectly in order and there was no scope for a review from the order which relied on Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited – There is no room for any doubt that the allowance of depreciation, as juxtaposed with the Sinking Fund also being factored as an item of expenditure, to be recovered through tariff as enabled by s.40, was specifically considered and upheld – The original decision of the Tribunal which is reviewed dealt specifically with the contention of double allowance; allowance one, being on interest on normative loan of at least 70% or more of actual capital cost, depreciation for payment of principal and allowance, two; being contribution to Sinking Fund created for redemption of bonds, which factors both the interest on relevant bonds and the principal amount realized through the bonds issued – In review, the Tribunal sought to draw a distinction between capital assets created with the use of bond funds and those from other sources; depreciation being permissible only insofar the latter one and not with respect to the former – Impugned decision also refers to Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited and expressed erroneously that the concept of duplication or double allowance was not brought before the Tribunal and before this Court, and therefore, the same is alive for consideration in review; overstepping the contours of review – Tribunal went haywire, when the very same issue, for the earlier years, was settled by this Court in Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited, based on which, the original order was passed by the Tribunal – Impugned decision of the Tribunal does not fall under any of the principles on the basis of which the review by the Tribunal is permissible – Review was illegal, totally misplaced and blatantly in breach of the principles of judicial discipline – Judicial system with the hierarchy of Courts thrives on the sanctity of the decisions of the appellate, revisional and supervisory jurisdictions to be given due weightage – As far as Art.141 is concerned it’s a Constitutional imprimatur which ensures the decisions of the highest court of the land to be followed, without which there will be mayhem – Appeal allowed – Cost of Rs.2,00,000/- imposed on the 1st respondent and Rs.1,50,000/- imposed on the Steel Authority of India Limited – Review. [Paras 23-25, 28-31] Damodar Valley Corporation Act, 1948 – ss.40, 32, 37-39 – Electricity Act, 2003 – Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2009 – r.43 – s.40 not inconsistent with the Electricity Act: Held: s.40 is not inconsistent with the Electricity Act, since s.61, which speaks of tariff regulations, empowers the appropriate commission to specify the terms and conditions for determination of tariff by taking into account, inter alia, the factors, which would encourage efficiency, economical use of resources, good performance and optimum investments (clause c); safeguarding of consumers’ interests, and at the same time, recovery of the cost of electricity in a reasonable manner (clause d); the tariff progressively reflecting the cost of supply of electricity and reduces cross-subsidies in the manner specified by the Appropriate Commission (clause g) – In a departure from the accounting principles of allowing depreciation as a first charge on the gross profits and appropriation from the net profits towards general reserves; the ‘Sinking Fund’, which is also in the nature of a reserve fund, constituted only to redeem the bonds, is allowed to be treated as a first charge, thus, making it an expense deductible from the gross profits before arriving at the net profit and consequently enabled to be factored in the tariff as an expenditure for the purposes of generation, transmission and supply of power. [Para 19, 21]

Damodar Valley Corporation Act, 1948 – Electricity Act, 2003 – Contention raised in the earlier round that the proviso giving effect to the provisions of the DVC Act, which are not inconsistent with the Electricity Act, having been introduced under s.14, specifically referring to grant of licences, is restrained or confined in this effect to licenses: Held: Said argument cannot be accepted since the grant of licence is the first step in transmitting, distributing and undertaking trading in electricity as distinguished from generation of electricity in Part III – Hence, the proviso, while deeming the DVC to be a deemed licensee under the Electricity Act, not requiring to obtain a licence under the Act by the very same proviso, set at naught the provisions in the DV Act, which were inconsistent with the Act of 2003 and enabled the other provisions to continue in its application to the DVC – Thus, making the Electricity Act applicable to the DVC on all other aspects including tariff determination, despite DVC not being required to specifically obtain a licence – Licence is the sine qua non for engaging in transmitting, distributing or trading in electricity, which alone can enable inter alia a generator who carries on any of these functions to approach the appropriate Electricity Regulatory Commission for tariff determination – Hence, ss.61, 62 & 64 and s.79 have overriding effect and the DVC could not have determined its own tariff u/s.20 of the DVC Act – However, the present reasoning does not enable a different conclusion from the earlier judgment on the provisions of the DVC Act having effect even after the Electricity Act came into force, to the extent they are not inconsistent with the provisions of the Electricity Act and hence, there is absolutely no reason to doubt the earlier decision – Also, the finding insofar as the effect of fourth proviso to s.14, is in tandem with the decision in Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited – Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited, is also concurred with, insofar as finding the proviso to s.14, in its second limb, to be a substantive provision, especially considering the background of the constitution of the DVC. [Paras 14, 15] Damodar Valley Corporation Act, 1948 – s.58 – Electricity Act, 2003 – 4th proviso to s.14; ss.173, 174 – Legislature, as abundant caution, brought in the 4th proviso, which though is a proviso to the provision providing for licences emphasises that the provisions of the DV Act prevail, which are not inconsistent with the provisions of the Electricity Act: Held: s.173 gives overriding effect to the provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, Atomic Energy, 1962 or the Railways Act 1989 as against the provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003 and any rule or regulation made thereunder or any instrument by virtue of the Act of 2003 – s.174 clearly provides that the provisions of the Electricity Act of 2003 will have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent in any other law for the time being in force; which would normally include the DV Act of 1948, which was enacted long before the Act of 2003 came into force – Despite s.58 of the DV Act, in which the absence of the words ‘any other law for the time being in force’ is striking and patently obvious, s.174 would nullify the provisions in the DVC Act which are inconsistent with the Act of 2003, but it would not repeal the DVC Act and those provisions which are not inconsistent with the Act of 2003 remains in force – However, the legislature, presumably as abundant caution, brought in the 4th proviso, which though is a proviso to the provision providing for licences emphasises that the provisions of the DV Act prevail, which are not inconsistent with the provisions of the Electricity Act – It is to ensure that the DVC Act prevails, that the proviso was brought under the provision with the nominal heading ‘Grant of Licence’; which proviso by the first limb, exempted DVC from obtaining a licence under the Act of 2003 and deemed it to be a licensee under the Act and in the second limb, declared the continued application of the DVC Act, to that Corporation to the extent they are not inconsistent with the Act of 2003; which s.174 also does not detract from. [Paras 12, 13]

Keywords: Article 141 of the Constitution of India · Principles of judicial discipline · Breach of judicial discipline · ‘Sinking Fund’ · Depreciation of assets · Double benefit · Duplication · Double allowance · Damodar Valley Corporation · Review illegal · Section 40 of the Damodar Valley Corporation Act, 1948 · Regulation 43 of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2009

As published in the Supreme Court Reports, Supreme Court of India. Headnotes prepared by: Divya Pandey. Text from the Indian Supreme Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs), CC BY 4.0.

Ask LexAI about this judgment What was decided, on what reasoning, and which later cases follow it. Answers name the judgments they rely on. Ask

Cases cited

As listed in the Supreme Court Reports. Linked where the judgment is on LegalFirms.in.

  • Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited & Ors. v. Damodar Valley Corporation & Ors. [2018] 8 SCR 773 : (2018) 10 SCC 281 referred to
  • State of West Bengal and Others v. Kamal Sengupta and Another [2008] 10 SCR 4 : (2008) 8 SCC 612 referred to

Full Judgment Text

Judgment K. Vinod Chandran, J. It is not often, but we do come across orders akin to the one impugned, which is in blatant breach of judicial discipline and in clear violation of Article 141 of the Constitution of India. It raises serious doubts in our minds about independence vis-à-vis accountability. We cannot but recall the sagacious words of Justice Benjamin Cordozo that a judge “… (He) is not a knight-errant roaming at will in pursuit of his own ideal of beauty or of goodness. He is to draw his inspiration from consecrated principles” (sic-The Nature of the Judicial Process)”. However,
Full text available to subscribers
Subscribe to access complete judgment text, daily digests, and AI-powered legal research tools. For informational and research purposes only.
View plans →
Annual plans from ₹799 + GST.

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All SC judgments →