Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans
Chandigarh Estate Rules, 2007 – r.5 – Auction – Revisit the auction process for price maximization – On facts, respondent hospital declared highest bidder at Rs.12.58 crores for the nursing home site – Deposit of 25% of the bid amount and subsequently the balance 75% – However, the Chandigarh Administration did not issue the allotment letter for execution of the Conveyance Deed – Administration rethinking on finalising formal allotment in favour of the respondent since the bid amount for the site not “reflective of the market trend”, while the adjacent site auctioned on the same day, fetched Rs.18.25 crores – Administration cancelled the respondent’s bid contract, returning the entirety of the bid amount and indicated its intention to conduct fresh e-auction, in which the respondent could participate – Writ petition by the respondent challenging the letters of cancellation of the bid contract and Agreement to Sell – During pendency, fresh auction held, fixing the reserve price at Rs.18.25 crores – Three participants, including the appellant, qualified for the fresh e-auction and the appellant declared as the highest bidder, at Rs.18.30 crores – However, the respondent did not participate in the fresh e-auction – Subsequently, the High Court allowed the writ petition filed by respondent and set aside the Administration’s letters rescinding the bid contract and cancelling the Agreement to Sell – Correctness: Held: Agreement to Sell contemplated u/r.5(iv) in itself not an enforceable contract u/s.2(h) of the Contract Act, 1872 – As the conveyance deed not yet executed, the Chandigarh Administration would be in a position to exercise its power u/r.5(vi) r/w Explanation I or under Clauses VI(1) and VI(5) of the General Terms and Conditions of E-Auction, reserving its right to “withdraw any site or building that may have been put up for auction” without assigning any reason, and the decision of the Estate Officer, acting for the Chandigarh Administration in this regard, is declared as final – Only restriction against nonissuance of the allotment letter or the conveyance deed would only be a public law restriction on Chandigarh Administration not to act in an arbitrary and unreasonable manner – Conduct of a public authority must be informed by fairness in action and in furtherance of public purpose – However, while dealing with matters relating to sale or lease of public property, the action of a public authority to recall or revisit the auction process would be justified if the decision is intended to maximise the price for the sale/lease of public property – This is permissible as long as the enforceable contract has not been entered into – On facts, the decision of the Chandigarh Administration to revisit the auction was taken before finalization of the allotment letter and the consequential execution of conveyance deed – At this stage, a substantial lower price fetched at the auction can be a relevant consideration for not finalising the contract in favour of a so-called “highest bidder” – Thus, no illegality or arbitrariness in the action of the Chandigarh Administration to revisit the auction process and call for a fresh auction for price maximization – Reasoning drawn by the High Court cannot be accepted, and the judgment and order of the High Court, to that extent, set aside – Furthermore, the difficulty arose because of the reason that the High Court, instead of either dismissing the writ petition at the admission stage itself or granting an interim order staying the cancellation letters, proceeded to permit the Chandigarh Administration to hold a fresh E-Auction – That interim arrangement made by the High Court, opened up a second phase of litigation which continued for more than two years – Having regard to the inconclusive interim arrangement made by the High Court, interests of justice and public purpose would be subserved if Chandigarh Administration is directed to conduct a fresh e-auction of the site, following the due procedure – Judgment and order of the High Court set aside – Chandigarh Administration to hold a fresh e-auction for the site by following the procedure prescribed under the Estate Rules. [Paras 19-28]
As published in the Supreme Court Reports, Supreme Court of India. Headnotes prepared by: Nidhi Jain. Text from the Indian Supreme Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs), CC BY 4.0.
As listed in the Supreme Court Reports. Linked where the judgment is on LegalFirms.in.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review