Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE G. GIRISH
WEDNESDAY, THE 10th DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
ARISING OUT OF THE ORDER OF REFERENCE DATED 07.07.2022 OF
THE DIVISION BENCH IN W.A.NO.139 OF 2022 AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT DATED 14.12.2021 IN WP(C)NO.857 OF 2019 OF THE
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
PETITIONERS/APPELLANT AND SUPPLEMENTAL APPELLANTS 2 TO 5:
VALSALA MILKA.B. (DIED)
AGED 63 YEARS
W/O.CHANDRAMOHAN, RESIDING AT POURNAMI, TC
1/1981-I, POOJAPURA, THIRUMALA VILLAGE,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM TALUK, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
DISTRICT - 695 012.
ADDL APPELLANT NO.2
DR.CHANDRAMOHANAN.S.R.
AGED 68 YEARS, S/O V.S. RAJA,
POURNAMI,T.C.47/2897,POOJAPPURA.P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN 695012.
ADDL. APPELLANT NO:3
MANJUSHA C.V
TC 37/1395-ELENZA, THITTAMANGALAM,
PULARI NAGAR, TRA 274A,
VATTIYOORKKAVU P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695 013.
ADDL.APPELLANT NO:4
REJITH C.V.
POURNAMI, T.C.47/2897,
POOJAPPURA P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695012.
ADDL. APPELLANT NO.2 IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER
DATED
27/11/2024
IN
I.A
NO:1/2024
IN
W.A
NO:139/2022.
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
ADDL. APPELLANT NOS: 3 AND 4 ARE SUO MOTO IMPLEADED
AS PER ORDER DATED 27/11/2024 IN I.A NO:1/2024 IN
W.A NO:139/2022.
BY ADV RAJESH P.NAIR
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT
SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN- 695 001.
THE DIRECTOR OF COLLEGIATE EDUCATION
VIKAS BHAVAN, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695 001.
THE ACCOUNTANT GENERAL (H&E) KERALA
OFFICE OF THE ACCOUNTANT GENERAL (A&E),
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695 009.
THE DISTRICT TREASURY OFFICER
DISTRICT TREASURY, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695 001.
CHRISTIAN COLLEGE
KATTAKKADA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM DISTRICT,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER - 695 572.
THE PRINCIPAL
CHRISTIAN COLLEGE, KATTAKKADA, HIRUVANANTHAPURAM
DISTRICT - 679 572.
BY ADVS.
SABEENA P. ISMAIL, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
SHRI.ASOK M.CHERIAN, ADDL. ADVOCATE GENERAL
T.S.SHYAM PRASANTH, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS ICR (WRIT APPEAL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
27.11.2024 AND THE COURT ON 10.04.2025 DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
“C.R”
ORDER
Anil K. Narendran, J.
This intra-court reference arises out of the order of reference
dated 07.07.2022 of a Division Bench of this Court in W.A.No.139
of 2022 filed by the original appellant-writ petitioner, invoking the
provisions under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High Court Act, 1958,
against the judgment dated 14.12.2021 of the learned Single
Judge in W.P.(C)No.857 of 2019. During the pendency of the writ
appeal, the original appellant died and her legal representatives
are impleaded as supplemental appellants 2 to 4 by the order
dated 27.11.2024.
2.
The writ petition, i.e., W.P.(C)No.857 of 2019, was one
filed by the original appellant, who retired from service on
31.03.2011 while working as an Associate Professor in the
Department of Physics, the Christian College, Kattakada, a college
affiliated with the University of Kerala. The writ petition was filed,
invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, seeking a writ of certiorari to
quash Ext.P6 communication dated 12.02.2018 of the 2nd
respondent Director of Collegiate Education; a writ of mandamus
commanding the respondents to disburse the Death-Cum-
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Retirement Gratuity (DCRG) due to her together with interest; and
a writ of mandamus commanding the 2nd respondent to issue a
non-liability certificate (NLC) forthwith, so as to enable the 4 th
respondent District Treasury Officer to disburse the DCRG amount
due to her.
3.
In the writ petition, the 2nd respondent Director of
Collegiate Education filed a counter affidavit dated 22.02.2019
opposing the reliefs sought for. The petitioner filed a reply affidavit
dated 26.06.2019. By the judgment dated 14.12.2021 in
W.P.(C)No.857
of
and
the
connected
matter,
i.e.,
W.P.(C)No.12996 of 2019, the learned Single Judge quashed
Ext.P6 communication dated 12.02.2018 of the 2nd respondent
Director of Collegiate Education, on the ground that the demand
made therein for refund of salary to the tune of Rs.5,75,258/together with interest at the rate of 12.5% is barred by limitation,
in view of the period of limitation prescribed under Section 18 of
the Limitation Act, 1963. However, the consequential reliefs sought
for, i.e., a writ of mandamus commanding the respondents to
disburse the DCRG amount due to the petitioner, together with
interest; and a writ of mandamus commanding the 2nd respondent
to issue a non-liability certificate in respect of the petitioner to
disburse the DCRG due to her were declined. Feeling aggrieved,
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
the original appellant filed the writ appeal.
4.
On 27.01.2021, when the writ appeal came up for
admission, notice before admission was ordered to respondents 5
and 6 by speed post. The learned Government Pleader took notice
for respondents 1 to 4.
5.
On 07.07.2022, when the writ appeal came up for
consideration before a Division Bench, the learned counsel for the
original appellant submitted that insofar as the learned Single
Judge has chosen to set aside Ext.P6 communication, the
respondents ought to have been directed to disburse the DCRG
payable to the appellant with interest. The learned counsel
contended that Ext.P6 communication is unsustainable in law
since the appellant has no liability to reimburse the pay and
allowances received during the period of deputation, in terms of
the bond that has been executed. The learned counsel placed
reliance on the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in State
of Kerala v. Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1] in support of the
said contention. On the other hand, the learned Government
Pleader submitted that since the appellant failed to successfully
complete the Ph.D programme, she is liable to reimburse not only
the pay and allowances received during the period of deputation
but also the penalty stipulated in the bond. As regards the
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
contention that the liability of the appellant in terms of the bond
cannot now be recovered from the DCRG, the learned Government
Pleader submitted that as clarified by this Court in the judgment
dated 22.08.2019 in W.P.(C)No. 21588 of 2019, the fixation of
liability in terms of the statutory provision is not necessary in a
case of this nature, where there exists a bond.
5.1. The Division Bench noticed that in the judgment dated
22.08.2019 in W.P.(C)No.21588 of 2019, this Court clarified that
the fixation of liability is not necessary in a case where the
pensioner has executed a bond for reimbursement of his/her
liability. In the light of the said decision, the only question which
survives for consideration is the question relating to the extent of
liability of the appellant under the bond. After extracting the
relevant portion of Ext.P2 bond in paragraph 9 of the order dated
07.07.2022, the Division Bench noticed that the terms of the said
bond originally interpreted by a learned Single Judge in Geetha S.
v. State of Kerala [2014 SCC OnLine Ker. 15658] – the
judgment in W.P.(C)No.884 of 2023 - is to the effect that bounden
has no obligation to reimburse the pay and allowances received
during the period of deputation in the event of unsuccessful
completion of the Ph.D programme, if he/she served the
institution for a period of three years after the deputation. As
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
pointed out by the learned Government Pleader, the correctness of
the said decision was doubted by another Single Judge and the
matter was referred to a Division Bench. The Division Bench
answered that reference in Premasukumar v. Secretary,
Higher Education Department [2019 (3) KLT 912], wherein
it was held that a teacher who failed to complete successfully the
Ph.D programme is liable not only to reimburse the pay and
allowances received during the period of deputation but also liable
to pay the penalty in terms of the bond. The view taken by the
Division Bench in that decision is that serving the college without
successful completion of Ph.D programme will not absolve the
bounden from the liability under the bond.
5.2. In the order of reference dated 07.07.2022, the
Division Bench noticed that in Premasukumar [2019 (3) KLT
912], reliance has been placed on the decision of the Apex Court
in Sant Longowal Institute of Engineering and Technology
v. Suresh Chandra Verma [(2013) 10 SCC 411]. However, in
a later decision, in Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1], another
Division Bench interpreted the terms of the very same bond to the
effect that the bounden has no obligation to reimburse the pay
and allowances received during the period of deputation in the
event of unsuccessful completion of the Ph.D programme, if
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
he/she serves the institution for a period of three years after the
deputation.
5.3. In the order of reference dated 07.07.2022, it was
noticed that as evident from paragraphs 12 to 16 of the decision
in Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1], the Division Bench arrived at
its conclusion following the decision of the learned Single Judge in
W.P.(C)No.884 of 2013, which was overruled in Premasukumar
[2019 (3) KLT 912], after distinguishing the principles laid down
by the Apex Court in Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC
411]. In the light of the apparent conflict of opinions formed by
the Division Benches in Premasukumar [2019 (3) KLT 912]
and Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1] as to the interpretation of the
bond executed by the appellant, the Division Bench found that the
question needs to be resolved by a Larger Bench. Accordingly,
Registry was directed to place the matter before the Hon’ble the
Chief Justice for appropriate orders. After obtaining the orders of
the Hon’ble the Chief Justice, the writ appeal was listed before this
Bench.
6.
By the order dated 15.01.2024, Registry was directed
to serve a copy of the memorandum of the writ appeal to the
learned Standing Counsel for University Grants Commission and
to show his name in the cause list. Along with a memo dated
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
29.01.2024 filed by the learned Government Pleader in the writ
appeal, the orders referred to in Ext.P1 Government order dated
18.12.2001, i.e., G.O.(P)No.166/ 87/H.Edn. dated 04.06.1987;
G.O.(Rt.)No.1560/94/H.Edn.
dated
18.10.1994;
G.O.(Rt.)No.
1216/95/H.Edn. dated 30.08.1995; and G.O.(P)No.124/99/H.Edn.
dated 07.10.1999 were placed on record.
7.
On 02.07.2024, the learned Standing Counsel for
University Grants Commission (UGC) submitted that Faculty
Improvement Programme Guidelines (FIP Guidelines) issued by
the UGC contain a format of the bond that has to be executed by
the teachers before proceeding on deputation to undergo
M.Phil/Ph.D course under the said programme.
8.
Along with another memo dated 04.07.2024 filed in the
writ appeal by the learned Government Pleader, a copy of
G.O.(P)No.166/87/H.Edn. dated 04.06.1987, along with the
appendices, was placed on record.
9.
On 30.08.2024, the learned Standing Counsel for the
UGC filed a statement dated 10.07.2024 in the writ appeal,
producing therewith the approval letter dated 08.03.2013 issued
to the Principal, Government Law College, Cochin for the award of
Teacher Fellowship under the Faculty Development Programme XI Plan period to a Teacher Fellow by name Anusree A., subject to
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
the condition that if the Teacher Fellow fails to complete her
Ph.D/M.Phil programme and leaves it midway, she has to refund
the entire amount paid to her by the UGC during her Teacher
Fellowship. As per the said letter, the Teacher Fellow is required to
give an undertaking that she will complete the research work
within the allotted tenure/plan period, failing which she will refund
the fellowship grant and substitute teacher salary to UGC-SWRO.
The refund of grant-in-aid and interest issued in the prescribed
format, in respect of Government Law College, Ernakulam, on
account of non-submission of Ph.D Thesis within the stipulated
time was also produced along with the said statement.
10.
On 10.10.2024, during the course of arguments, the
submission made by the learned Standing Counsel for the UGC
was that the approval for the award of Teacher Fellowship to the
original appellant under the Faculty Development Programme
during the IX Plan period was based on a similar communication
issued by the UGC to the Principal of the 6 th respondent Christian
College, Kattakkada, specifying the conditions for such approval.
The learned counsel for the original appellant submitted that the
appellant does not have a copy of the approval letter issued by the
UGC. The learned Additional Advocate General submitted that the
2nd respondent Director of Collegiate Education shall make an
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
attempt to get a copy of the approval letter issued by the UGC for
the award of Teacher Fellowship under the Faculty Improvement
Programme to the appellant, from the 6th respondent Principal of
Christian College, Kattakkada.
11.
Along with a memo dated 23.10.2024 filed in the writ
appeal, the learned Government Pleader has placed on record a
copy of letter No.F.FIP99/SWRO/UGC/KLKE040 dated 01.02.2001
of the Regional Head of the University Grants Commission, South
Western Regional Office, whereby the UGC conveyed its approval
for doing Ph.D by the appellant under the IX Plan Faculty
Development Programme, subject to the conditions stipulated
therein. Condition No.6 incorporated in that letter reads thus;
“6. The Teacher Fellows should note that he/she shall have
to submit their M.Phil/Ph.D thesis compulsorily in order to
account for audit as well as for the purpose for which the
grants are paid by the Commission failing which the entire
amount incurred on the scheme will have to be borne by the
Teacher Fellow.”
(underline supplied)
Another letter No.F.FIP99/SWRO/UGC/KLKE040 dated 28.09.2002
issued by the Joint Secretary of University Grants Commission,
South Western Regional Office is also produced along with the
memo, which is one issued in continuation of the earlier letter
dated 01.02.2001, whereby the UGC conveyed its approval for an
extension for doing Ph.D by the appellant under IX plan Faculty
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Development Programme, subject to the conditions stipulated
therein. Condition No.7 incorporated in that letter reads thus:
“7. The Teacher Fellow should note that he/she shall have to
submit their M.Phil thesis compulsorily in order to account for
audit as well as for the purpose for which the grants are paid
by the commission, failing which the entire amount incurred
on the scheme will have to be borne by the Teacher Fellow.”
(underline supplied)
12.
On 07.11.2024, the learned counsel for the original
appellant submitted that the original appellant is no more and that
an
application
to
substitute
her
legal
representatives
as
supplemental appellants in the writ appeal shall be filed within two
weeks. By the order dated 27.11.2024 in I.A.No.1 of 2024 filed by
the husband of the appellant, he was impleaded as supplemental
2nd appellant. By the said order, the children of the deceased
appellant were suo motu impleaded as supplemental appellants 3
and 4.
13.
Heard
arguments
of
the
learned
counsel
for
supplemental appellants 2 to 4, the learned Additional Advocate
General for respondents 1 to 4 and also the learned Standing
Counsel for the UGC.
14.
The learned counsel for supplemental appellants 2 to 5
contended that the original appellant has no liability to reimburse
the pay and allowances received by her during the period of
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
deputation, in terms of the bond that has been executed. In Ajitha
C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1], a Division Bench of this Court, after
distinguishing the principles laid down by the Apex Court in Sant
Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411], rightly interpreted
the terms of the very same bond to the effect that the bounden
has no obligation to reimburse the pay and allowances received
during the period of deputation in the event of unsuccessful
completion of the Ph.D programme, if he/she serves the institution
for a period of three years after the deputation.
15.
On the other hand, the learned Additional Advocate
General for respondents 1 to 4 contended that, after taking note
of the law laid down by the Apex Court in Sant Longowal
Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411], a Division Bench of this Court
in Premasukumar [2019 (3) KLT 912] rightly held that a
teacher who failed to complete successfully the Ph.D programme
is liable not only to reimburse the pay and allowances received
during the period of deputation but also the penalty in terms of
the bond, since serving the college without successful completion
of Ph.D programme will not absolve the bounden from the liability
under the bond.
16.
The learned Additional Advocate General and also the
learned Standing Counsel for the UGC pointed out that as per
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Condition No.6 of letter No.F.FIP99/SWRO/UGC/KLKE040 dated
01.02.2001 of the Regional Head of the University Grants
Commission, South Western Regional Office, whereby the UGC
conveyed its approval for doing Ph.D by the original appellant
under the IX Plan Faculty Development Programme, and as per
Condition No.7 in letter No.F.FIP99/SWRO/UGC/KLKE040 dated
28.09.2002 issued by the Joint Secretary of University Grants
Commission, South Western Regional Office, whereby the UGC
conveyed its approval for an extension for doing Ph.D by the
appellant under IX plan Faculty Development Programme, the
Teacher
Fellow
shall
submit
his/her
M.Phil/Ph.D
Thesis
compulsorily in order to account for audit as well as for the purpose
for which the grants are paid by the commission, failing which the
entire amount incurred on the scheme will have to be borne by the
Teacher Fellow.
17.
In Sant Longowal Institute of Engineering and
Technology v. Suresh Chandra Verma [(2013) 10 SCC 411]
the question that came up for consideration before a Two-Judge
Bench of the Apex Court was as to whether the appellant Institute
was justified in directing the respondent therein to refund the
entire amount of Rs.12,32,126/- paid to him towards salary and
other allowances for pursuing Ph.D studies at Indian Institute of
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Technology (IIT), Kanpur, on failure to produce the certificate of
obtaining the Ph.D, for which study leave was granted. The
respondent joined the service of the appellant Institute, as
Lecturer in Mechanical Engineering on 30.08.1993. He applied for
study leave to pursue his Ph.D at IIT, Kanpur. The competent
authority granted study leave for three years, commencing from
24.07.1999 to 22.07.2002. The respondent, after executing
necessary bond, proceeded on study leave on 24.07.1999. The 3year period was completed on 24.07.2002. Due to various reasons,
the respondent could not complete his Ph.D studies. He joined
back in service as a Lecturer in the Appellant Institute in November,
2003. He was asked to produce the completion certificate for Ph.D
course, which he could not produce. Hence, the appellant Institute
demanded refund of an amount of Rs.12,32,126/- paid to the
respondent during the period of study for pursuing Ph.D, as per
the terms and conditions of the bond executed by him. Aggrieved
by the steps taken by the appellant Institute, the respondent filed
Civil Writ Petition No.12555 of 2010 before the High Court of
Punjab and Haryana. That writ petition was allowed by the learned
Single Judge, vide the judgment dated 02.02.2012, quashing the
demand notice and ordering a refund of the amount already
recovered with interest from the respondent. Aggrieved by the
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
said judgment, the appellant Institute preferred LPA No. 363 of
2012 before the Division Bench, which ended in dismissal by the
judgment dated 23.08.2012, on the ground that the appellant
could not point out any term in the bond executed by the
respondent that he had to complete the Ph.D programme within a
period of three years and that the only condition was that the
respondent had to serve for a period of six years after joining
service on the expiry of the study leave. Aggrieved by the
judgment
of
the
Division
Bench,
the
appellant
Institute
approached the Apex Court.
17.1. In Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411]
the appellant Institute contended before the Apex Court that the
High
Court
had
completely
misunderstood the
terms
and
conditions on which the respondent was granted study leave,
which is reflected in the bond executed by the respondent on
05.05.1999. The High Court had completely ignored the salutary
principle of ‘no work no pay’ and that the respondent during the
period of study not only not worked in the appellant Institute but
also was not successful in obtaining the Ph.D. Consequently,
neither the appellant Institute nor the students are benefited so
also the respondent and the public money has been spent for no
use. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
contended that the respondent had completed his course work
required for the Ph.D programme, completed the comprehensive
examination, etc., but the thesis could not be completed due to
the retirement of the guide. The respondent had also made a
written request on 24.05.2002 seeking an extension for 6 months
so that he could complete the thesis work. Another representation
was made on 04.06.2002 and all those representations were left
unattended. Under such circumstances, he had to join duty
without obtaining Ph.D. It was pointed out that a similarly situated
employee, Abanish Kumar Singh, was granted the extension of
time, but the same was not done in the case of the respondent.
Further, there is no condition in the bond that if the respondent
could not complete the Ph.D, then the entire salary and other
benefits could be recovered from him. Therefore, the High Court
rightly interpreted the terms and conditions of the bond and held
that the demand made for the reimbursement of the salary and
other allowances was not justified.
17.2. In Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411],
having gone through the terms and conditions of the bond
executed by the respondent on 05.05.1999 [quoted at para.7 on
pages 415 and 416 of SCC], the Apex Court noticed that there is
no clear-cut provision in the bond either expressly referring to
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Rule 63 of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972 [which
deals with resignation or retirement after study leave or noncompletion
of
the
course
of
study]
forming
part
of
the
Fundamental Rules and Supplementary Rules, Part III framed by
the Constitution of India or strictly imposing a condition that if a
candidate fails to complete the course of study during the period
of sanctioned leave, he will have to refund to the appellant
Institute the total amount of leave salary and other benefits
availed of by him during the period of study leave. Of late, such a
specific provision was incorporated in the bond by the Board of
Governors of the appellant Institute in its 22nd meeting held on
28.06.2002 [quoted at para.9, on pages 416 to 418 of SCC]. The
Apex Court noticed that the question as to whether Rule 63 of the
Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972 [quoted at para.10, on
pages 418 and 419 of SCC] is also applicable to the respondent
was not seen specifically urged by the appellant Institute, either
before the learned Single Judge or before the Division Bench,
hence, the High Court had no occasion to examine its applicability.
If a government servant resigns or retires from service or
otherwise quits service without returning to duty after a period of
study leave or within a period of three years after such return to
duty or fails to complete the course of study and is thus unable to
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
furnish the certificates as required under sub-rule (5) of Rule 53
of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972 [Rule 53 deals
with sanction of study leave], he shall be required to refund the
actual amount of leave salary, study allowance, cost of fees,
travelling and other expenses, if any, incurred by the Government
of India. The Apex Court noticed that the abovementioned
provision has a laudable object to achieve.
17.3. In Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411],
the Apex Court found that a Government servant or person like
the respondent is given study leave with salary and allowances,
etc., so as to enable him to complete the course of study and to
furnish the certificate of his successful completion, so that the
appellant Institute which has sanctioned the study leave would
achieve the purpose and object for granting such study leave. The
purpose of granting study leave with salary and other benefits is
for the interest of the institution and also the person concerned so
that once he comes back and joins the institute, the students will
benefit from the knowledge and expertise acquired by the person
at the expense of the institute. A candidate who avails of leave but
takes no interest in completing the course and does not furnish
the certificate to that effect is doing a disservice to the institute
as well as the students of the institute. In other words, such a
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
person only enjoys the period of study leave without doing any
work at the institute and, at the same time, enjoys the salary and
other benefits, which is evidentially not in the public interest.
Public money cannot be spent unless there is mutual benefit.
Further, if the period of study leave was not extended or no
decision was taken on his representation, the respondent could
have raised his grievances at the appropriate forum.
17.4. In Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411],
on the facts of the case on hand, the Apex Court noticed that the
appellant
Institute
had
already
recovered
an
amount
of
Rs.6,50,000/- as monthly instalments from the salary of the
respondent. The appellant Institute has also recovered an amount
of
Rs.1,75,000/-
from
the
salary
of
the
respondent
and
Rs.4,75,000/- from the arrears of revised scales admissible to the
respondent
with
effect
from
01.01.2006
and
as
such
approximately Rs.6,50,000/- has been recovered from the
respondent. Now, the appellant Institute claims a balance amount
of Rs.6,18,000/-. Considering the facts and circumstances of the
case and considering the fact that the bond executed by the
respondent is found to be vague, the Apex Court found no reason
for the appellant Institute to recover the balance amount of
Rs.6,18,000/- from the respondent, but the amount already
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
recovered be not refunded, since public interest has definitely
suffered due to non-obtaining of Ph.D by the respondent after
availing of the entire salary and other benefits. In the judgment,
it was made clear that the Apex Court did so, taking into
consideration all aspects of the matter, and to do complete justice
between the parties. The civil appeal was allowed to the above
extent, and the judgment of the learned Single Judge of the High
Court of Punjab and Haryana dated 02.02.2012 and the judgment
of the Division Bench dated 23.08.2012 were modified accordingly
by ordering that no further amount be recovered by the appellant
Institute from the respondent.
17.5. As already noticed hereinbefore, in Sant Longowal
Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411], at para.7 on pages 415 and 416
of SCC, the Apex Court quoted the terms and conditions of the
bond executed by the respondent on 05.05.1999. Para.7 of the
said decision reads thus;
“7. We have gone through the terms and conditions of the
bond executed by the respondent on 05.05.1999. Some of
the relevant portions of the bond read as follows:
‘Whereas I, Suresh Chandra Verma, am granted (kind of
leave) by the Institute.
And whereas for the better protection of the Institute, I have
agreed to execute this bond with such conditions as
hereunder is written.
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Now the condition of the above written obligation is that in
the event of my failing to resume duty, or resigning or
retiring from service or otherwise quitting service without
returning for duty after the expiry of termination of the
period of study leave or at any time within a period of three
years after my return to duty, I shall forthwith pay to the
Institute or as may be directed by the Institute, on demand,
pay and allowances received by me during study leave, the
said amount of Rs.10,000/- (Ten thousand only) together
with
interest
thereon
from
the
date
of
demand
at
government rates for the time being in force on government
loan.
And upon my making such payment the above written
obligation shall be avoided and of no effect, otherwise it shall
be and remain in full force and virtue.
The bond shall in all respects be governed by the laws of
India for the time being in force and the rights and liabilities
hereunder
shall,
where
necessary,
be
accordingly
determined by the appropriate courts in India.’
17.6. In Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411],
after noticing that there is no clear-cut provision in the bond
executed by the respondent on 05.05.1999 either expressly
referring to Rule 63 of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules,
1972 or strictly imposing a condition that if a candidate fails to
complete the course of study during the period of sanctioned leave,
he will have to refund to the appellant Institute the total amount
of leave salary and other benefits availed of by him during the
period of study leave, the Two-Judge Bench held that a candidate
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
who avails of leave but takes no interest to complete the course
and does not furnish the certificate to that effect is doing a
disservice to the institute as well as the students of the institute.
In other words, such a person only enjoys the period of study leave
without doing any work at the institute and, at the same time,
enjoys the salary and other benefits, which is evidentially not in
the public interest. Public money cannot be spent unless there is
mutual benefit. The Apex Court, considering the facts and
circumstances of the case and considering the fact that the bond
executed by the respondent is found to be vague, found no reason
for the appellant Institute to recover the balance amount of
Rs.6,18,000/- from the respondent. However, the Apex Court
ordered that the amount already recovered need not be refunded,
since public interest has definitely suffered due to non-obtaining
of Ph.D by the respondent after availing of the entire salary and
other benefits. In the said judgment, it was made clear that the
Apex Court did so, taking into consideration all aspects of the
matter, and to do complete justice between the parties. Therefore,
the said direction is one issued in the exercise of the powers under
Article 142 of the Constitution of India, which confers the Apex
Court the power to pass any order necessary for doing complete
justice in any cause or matter pending before it. In the said
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
decision, the Apex Court did not order that the appellant Institute
need not refund the amount already recovered, since the bond
executed by the respondent was found to be vague.
18.
In Premasukumar v. Secretary, Higher Education
Department [2019 (3) KLT 912], based on the order of
reference
made
by
a
learned
Single
Judge
doubting
the
correctness of the judgment rendered by another learned Single
Judge in W.P.(C)No.884 of 2013, the matter came up for
consideration before a Division Bench. The question that arose for
consideration was regarding the liability of a teacher in an aided
College, who was granted a Fellowship by the University Grants
Commission (UGC) for doing Ph.D, to refund the salary and other
benefits received during the Fellowship, on the failure of the
Teacher to acquire Ph.D Degree within the period of Fellowship.
The petitioner therein, while working as Selection Grade Lecturer
at NSS College, Pandalam, was awarded Teacher Fellowship under
the Faculty Improvement Programme of the UGC X plan period.
The period fixed for completing the Ph.D Course was from
01.06.2005 to 31.03.2007. She did not acquire Ph.D within the
stipulated time or even within the extended time. She, in fact,
acquired the qualification only on 31.12.2016, much after her
retirement from service on 31.03.2010. Due to the failure on the
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
part of the petitioner to acquire Ph.D degree within the fellowship
period, proceedings were initiated against her for recovery of an
amount of Rs.3,07,590/-, being the contingency plus substitute
salary paid during the Fellowship period. In the writ petition, the
petitioner challenged the said liability and the consequential
recovery proceedings. She has also sought for a direction to
release the DCRG amount due to her without any deduction. In
support of the said contention, the petitioner relied on the decision
in Geetha S. v. State of Kerala [2014 SCC OnLine Ker.
15658] - the judgment in W.P.(C)No.884 of 2013 - wherein under
similar circumstances, it was held that failure to acquire Ph.D
within the stipulated period, would entail only a penalty of
Rs.7,000/- with interest and not a refund of the entire salary and
emoluments received during the period of Fellowship. For arriving
at such a conclusion, the learned Single Judge had relied on the
terms of the bond executed by the Lecturer on being selected for
the Fellowship.
18.1. In Premasukumar [2019 (3) KLT 912], the Division
Bench noticed that in Geetha S. v. State of Kerala [2014 SCC
OnLine Ker. 15658] interpreting clause 3 of the bond executed
by the lecturer, the learned Single Judge held as follows, at para.8;
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
“8. What could be discerned from above is that the pay and
other allowances given to the petitioner could be recovered
by the Government only if the petitioner fails to join duty
within a period of 3 years from completion of the course.
The respondents have no case that the petitioner has (not)
rejoined duty within the aforesaid period. However, if the
petitioner fails to complete the course successfully within the
grace period, it shall be the duty of the petitioner to pay a
sum of Rs.7,000/- (Rupees seven thousand only) together
with interest at the rates specified therein. The respondents
can quantify the liability only in tune with the agreed terms
in Ext.P3, and the 2nd respondent cannot go beyond the
agreed terms in the bond. Therefore, steps taken by the
petitioner to recover salary and other allowances owned by
the petitioner during the deputation period from the DCRG
are unauthorised and illegal. The same cannot be deducted
from the DCRG.”
Doubting the above reasoning in Geetha S. v. State of Kerala
[2014 SCC OnLine Ker. 15658] an order of reference was made
in W.P.(C)No.14152 of 2016, on 18.09.2018, stating that the said
decision is not in tune with the spirit and purpose of the bond to
be executed if penalty provision is read along with other
stipulations in the bond.
18.2. In para.6 of the decision in Premasukumar [2019
(3) KLT 912], the Division Bench extracted relevant portions of
the ‘X Plan Guidelines for Faculty Improvement Programme’, under
which the petitioner was awarded Teacher Fellowship for doing
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Ph.D. The objective of the programme, as stated in Clause (2) is
as follows;
“The objective of the Teacher Fellowship under the Faculty
Improvement Programme is to provide an opportunity to the
teachers of the Universities and Colleges to pursue their
academic/research activities leading to the award of
M.Phil/Ph.D Degree.”
Clause 3.7 stipulates that the teacher will continue to receive full
salary from the parent institution/college during the period of
Teacher Fellowship. Clause 3.10 deals with the tenure of Teacher
Fellowship. The said clause stipulates that the Teacher Fellowship
for the Ph.D Programme would be for a period of two years. An
extension of one year could be granted based on the justification
and merits of the case. As per Clause 4.3, the salary of the
substitute teacher appointed by the university/college in the place
of a teacher selected for the award of Teacher Fellowship, will be
reimbursed by the UGC. Clause 8.3 stipulates that if a Teacher
Fellow fails to complete his/her Ph.D/M.Phil Programme and leaves
it midway, he/she has to refund the entire amount paid to him by
the UGC during his/her Teacher Fellowship.
18.3. In Premasukumar [2019 (3) KLT 912] the Division
Bench noticed that from a reading of the aforementioned clauses
in the ‘X Plan Guidelines for Faculty Improvement Programme’, it
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
is evident that a Teacher Fellowship is granted with the objective
of providing an opportunity to the teacher to pursue academic
studies or research and acquire further qualification so that it
would inure to the benefit of the students. Therefore, the teacher
is bound to utilise the Fellowship and acquire the Ph.D/M.Phil
Degree within the fellowship period. The Division Bench noticed
that in Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411], the
Apex Court was dealing with a case in which the respondent
therein, a Lecturer in the appellant Institute, had availed study
leave for three years for pursuing his Ph.D. Though the respondent
executed necessary bond, undertaking to complete the course
within the leave period, he failed to do so. The appellant Institute
demanded refund of the amount paid to the respondent during the
period of his study for Ph.D, in terms of the bond executed by him.
The respondent challenged the recovery proceedings initiated
against him before the High Court successfully. Aggrieved, the
Institute filed an appeal before the Apex Court. After careful
perusal of the terms of the bond executed by the respondent, the
Apex Court found that there is no clear-cut provision imposing the
condition that if a candidate fails to complete the course of study
during the period of sanctioned leave, he will have to refund to the
institute the total amount of leave salary and other benefits
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
availed by him during the period. Even after noticing the absence
of a specific clause in the bond, the Apex Court allowed the appeal,
to the extent of allowing the Institute to retain the amounts
already recovered from the respondent. The reasoning of the Apex
Court for arriving at such a conclusion is contained in paragraph
11 of that judgment. The Division Bench agreed with the said
reasoning in the judgment of the Apex Court.
18.4. In Premasukumar [2019 (3) KLT 912], the Division
Bench noticed that the objective of awarding Teacher Fellowship is
to provide an opportunity to do research or pursue academic
studies leading to the award of M.Phil/Ph.D degree. Failure to
acquire the degree would indicate that the teacher has not utilised
the opportunity properly. This recalcitrance on the part of the
teacher is at the cost of the public exchequer and the students.
Therefore, necessarily, the teacher is bound to refund the salary
and other benefits received by her during the course of the
Fellowship which she failed to utilise properly.
18.5. In Premasukumar [2019 (3) KLT 912] the Division
Bench found that, under the bond, the bounden undertakes to pay
back the salary and allowances received by the teacher with
interest thereon, in the event of the teacher failing to serve the
college for a period of three years immediately and continuously
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
after return to duty on completion of the course, and to pay a
penalty of Rs.7,000/- together with interest, in the event of the
teacher failing to complete the course successfully within the grace
period and that upon payment of all such sums, the written
obligation shall be void and of no effect, and that otherwise, the
bond shall remain in full force and effect. The Clause is specific to
the effect that the teacher should serve the College for a period of
three years after successful completion of the course. This Clause
has two limbs; one is successful completion of the course and the
other is serving the college for a continuous period of three years
after such successful completion. Therefore, serving the College
without successful completion of the course will not absolve the
Bounden from the liability under the bond. A Lecturer, who has
successfully completed the course, but, fails to serve the College
would be liable under the bond. The failure to successfully
complete the course within the stipulated period would entail in an
additional penalty of Rs.7,000/-. Hence, the finding of the learned
Single Judge in Geetha S. v. State of Kerala [2014 SCC OnLine
Ker. 15658] that a teacher, who failed to complete the course
successfully within the period, need pay only Rs.7,000/- together
with interest, is contrary to the objective of the Faculty
Improvement Programme as well as the terms of the bond and
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
hence found to be not good law by the Division Bench. The Division
Bench answered the reference by holding that in the event of a
teacher awarded Fellowship for Ph.D course, failing to complete
the course and acquiring the degree within the Fellowship period,
he/she would be liable to refund the salary and other benefits
received during the fellowship period. Before the Division Bench,
the learned counsel for the 3rd respondent brought to the notice of
the Bench Ext.R1(e) undertaking given by the petitioner, wherein
she had affirmed that she would successfully complete the course
and get qualified within the stipulated time and would serve the
College for not less than three years immediately and continuously
after the course, failing which, she would pay the amount with
penalty and interest as specified in the bond.
19.
In State of Kerala v. Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1]
another Division Bench of this Court was dealing with a case in
which
the
husband
of
the
applicant
before
the
Kerala
Administrative Tribunal retired from service on 31.03.2012, as
Associate Professor in Botany from the University College,
Thiruvananthapuram. He later died on 10.04.2017. The grievance
in the original application filed by the applicant, the widow of the
deceased pensioner - Saseendra Babu, was regarding nonpayment of the DCRG due to the pensioner, in spite of the expiry
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
of the outer time-limit of three years, as envisaged in Note 3
appended to Rule 3 of Part III Kerala Service Rules. While working
as a Selection Grade Lecturer in Botany at University College,
Thiruvananthapuram, Saseendra Babu was selected for deputation
to undergo Ph.D under the Faculty Improvement Programme of
University
Grants
Commission
(UGC)
for
the
period
from
02.11.2004 to 02.11.2006. Consequent thereto, he was relieved
from the college with effect from 02.11.2004 AN. The competent
authority in the Higher Education Department sanctioned his
deputation as per a Government order dated 21.02.2005. It
appears that no substitute lecturer/teacher was appointed in his
vacancy consequent to his deputation to undergo the Ph.D as per
the Faculty Improvement Programme. He had earlier executed a
bond in terms of order dated 28.02.2005. According to the
applicant, her deceased husband had fulfilled all the conditions for
submitting the thesis, but he failed to submit the same in time for
reasons beyond his control and as such, he could not secure a
Ph.D within the stipulated time. Later, a further period of 5 months
was also granted to him under the Faculty Improvement
Programme, for the period from 02.11.2006 to 31.03.2007 for
which a supplemental agreement dated 02.02.2007 was also
executed by him. He joined duty in the college on 01.04.2007 FN,
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
after the completion of the Faculty Improvement Programme. But,
he could not secure a Ph.D. Later, he retired from service on
31.03.2012 while working as an Associate Professor in Botany at
University College, Thiruvananthapuram. After retirement, he was
sanctioned
various
retiral
benefits.
The
DCRG
amount
of
Rs.7,00,000/- was sanctioned to him as per the order dated
15.10.2012. However, the said amount was not released. He died
on 10.04.2017. It is thereafter that the impugned order dated
15.10.2018 was issued by the Director of Collegiate Education and
the consequential order dated 26.10.2018 was issued by the
Principal, University College, Thiruvananthapuram, directing the
original applicant (widow of the deceased pensioner) that she is
liable to pay an amount of Rs.8,80,335/- along with interest at the
rate of 18% per annum plus Rs.20,000/- which are the liabilities
towards salary and allowances received by the teacher concerned
during the period of deputation under the Faculty Improvement
Programme as well as the contingency grant received by him, on
the ground that he could not secure a Ph.D after the completion
of
the
Faculty
Improvement
Programme.
The
Kerala
Administrative Tribunal, by the order dated 06.08.2019 in
O.A.No.2210 of 2018, allowed the main reliefs in the OA, on the
ground that the bond conditions do not permit recovery of the
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
amount on the ground that the candidate concerned had not
successfully obtained a Ph.D after completion of the Faculty
Improvement Programme and that, the clauses in those bond/
agreement would only entail payment of an amount of Rs.7,000/as penalty only if the incumbent concerned does not complete the
course. Hence, the Tribunal held that the impugned proceedings
for recovery are liable to be interfered with. Since the alleged
liability fixation process has not been completed by the issuance
of a show-cause notice and hearing Saseendra Babu within a
period of three years from the date of retirement, as provided
under Notes 2 and 3 of Rule 3 Part III Kerala Service Rules (KSR),
the Tribunal held that the impugned proceedings for recovery from
the DCRG amount are illegal and ultra vires. The State challenged
the said order of the Tribunal by filing O.P.(KAT) No.418 of 2020.
19.1. In Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1], before the Division
Bench, the learned Senior Government Pleader contended that the
reliance placed by the Tribunal in the impugned order on the
decision in Geetha S. v. State of Kerala [2014 SCC OnLine Ker.
15658] is not tenable or correct and that, the State is entitled to
succeed in view of the decision of the Apex Court in Sant
Longowal Institute of Engineering and Technology v.
Suresh Chandra Verma [(2013) 10 SCC 411]. On the main
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
issue as to whether the impugned proceedings ordering to recover
the amounts covered therein from the DCRG of the deceased
pensioner is legally tenable or not, the Division Bench noticed that
the teacher concerned retired from service as early as on
31.03.2012 and later he died on 10.04.2017. It is well settled that
even without resorting to the proceedings envisaged in the
operative portion of Rule 3 of Part III KSR, the departmental
authorities can take steps to ascertain the liabilities of the
employee/ pensioner concerned, after affording him a reasonable
opportunity of being heard, and this aspect of the matter is clear
from Note 2 appended to Rule 3 Part III KSR. However, in such
cases covered by Note 2 Rule 3 Part III KSR, the statutory rulemaking authority has made a mandatory provision as per Note 3
thereof that in such cases, the liability should have been duly and
lawfully finalised within an outer time limit of three years on the
incumbent concerned becomes a pensioner. In the instant case,
the statutory time limit of three years, as envisaged in the
mandatory provisions contained in Note 3 of Rule 3 Part III KSR,
expired as early as on 31.03.2015. It is thereafter that the
pensioner/teacher concerned died on 10.04.2017. At no point of
time, either within the outer time limit of three years or at any
time before the issuance of the impugned proceedings dated
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
15.10.2018 and 26.10.2018, the State/departmental authorities
concerned has issued any show-cause notice to the teacher
concerned for taking steps to ascertain the liability fixation process
and then to pass an order fixing the liability within the outer time
limit as mandated in Notes 2 and 3 of Rule 3 Part III KSR. Hence,
on that simple ground, the petitioners are not legally entitled to
recover the said amount covered by the impugned proceedings
dated 15.10.2018 and 26.10.2018 from the DCRG from the
deceased pensioner. The Division Bench found that, on this sole
ground, the original applicant is entitled to succeed and the
Tribunal cannot be faulted in any manner for having arrived at the
said finding.
19.2. In Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1] the Division Bench
then considered the contentions raised by both sides regarding the
bond conditions contained in Annexure A3 agreement dated
28.02.2005 and Annexure A4 supplemental agreement dated
02.02.2007 executed by the deceased teacher. In para.9 of the
judgment the Division Bench quoted the relevant conditions in
Annexure A3 agreement dated 28.02.2005. In para.10 of the
judgment the Division Bench quoted the relevant conditions in
Annexure A4 supplemental agreement dated 02.02.2007. The
Division Bench noticed that a perusal of Annexures A3 and A4
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
would make it clear that in the event of the FIP teacher failing to
serve the Government for a period of three years immediately and
continuously after his return to duty on completion of the course,
he/she shall forthwith pay to the Government on demand, the
amount mentioned therein together with interest from the date of
demand at Government rates for the time being, in terms of the
Government norms and further in case the teacher on FIP fails to
complete the course successfully within the grace period, the
bounden and the surety shall pay to the Government a penalty of
Rs.7,000/- together with interest thereon at the rates mentioned
above, unless the bounden successfully completes the course at
his own expense within 2 years from the date of expiry of the
period of deputation, etc. The additional condition given in
Annexure A4 supplemental agreement only stipulates that the
aforementioned conditions in Annexure A3 would govern the
extended period of the Faculty Improvement Programme. The
Division Bench noticed that the very same bond condition has
been the subject matter of consideration of this Court in the
decision in Geetha S. v. State of Kerala [2014 SCC OnLine
Ker. 15658]. In para.11 of the judgment, the Division Bench
quoted paras.7 and 8 of the judgment in W.P.(C)No.884 of 2013.
The Division Bench noticed that a perusal of the said judgment
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
would make it clear that the relevant condition in the bond
executed by the teacher concerned in the said case is similar and
identical to that as made out in Annexures A3 and A4 in the instant
case. Hence, the Division Bench held that it is in respectful
agreement with the views already rendered by the learned Single
Judge in W.P.(C)No.884 of 2013 - Geetha S. v. State of Kerala
[2014 SCC OnLine Ker. 15658]. The Division Bench noticed that,
in the case on hand, it is common ground that the teacher
concerned,
after
completion
of
the
Faculty
Improvement
Programme, had returned back to the parent college and rejoined
duty and had continued in service for three years. Therefore, the
first limb of the relevant condition of Annexure A3 will not come
into play for the simple reason that the said clause will arise only
if the incumbent/teacher concerned does not join duty after
completing the Faculty Improvement Programme and so for a
period of three years thereafter. Hence, at best only the second
limb of Annexure A3 for payment of the penalty amount of
Rs.7,000/- for not successfully obtaining the Ph.D degree alone
will come into play. Hence, the Division Bench did not find any
cogent grounds to deviate from the view in the judgment of the
learned Single Judge in W.P.(C)No.884 of 2013 - Geetha S. v.
State of Kerala [2014 SCC OnLine Ker. 15658]. Therefore, the
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Division Bench held that the Tribunal cannot be faulted for placing
reliance on the said judgment of this Court.
19.3. In Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1] the Division Bench
noticed that as per Clause 8.3 of Annexure R2(a) guidelines issued
by the UGC, if a Teacher Fellow fails to complete his/her
Ph.D/M.Phil programme and leaves it midway, he/she has to
refund the entire amount paid to him by the UGC during his/her
teacher fellowship. Before the Division Bench, the learned Senior
Government Pleader placed reliance on the judgment of the Apex
Court in Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411]. The
Division Bench noticed that a reading of the said decision would
make it clear that the teacher concerned was granted three years
study leave for the period from 24.07.1999 to 22.07.2002 and he
had joined back as Lecturer in November, 2003. The bond
executed by the said teacher is extracted in para.7 of the said
decision, and it was found that the said bond conditions are quite
vague and do not envisage a case of recovery from the full pay
and allowances paid to the teacher concerned if he does not
subsequently secure a Ph.D. However, a reading of para.9 of the
said decision would make it clear that later the appellant Institute
had amended its norms for bond conditions on 28.06.2002, which
appears to be before the expiry of the leave period of the teacher
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
concerned (which was up to 22.07.2002). Moreover, a reading of
para.10 of the said decision would also make it clear that the
explicit statutory rules had governed the field and reference to
Rule 63 of the Rules are contained therein. Rule 63 of the said Rule
considered in para.10 of the said decision of the Apex Court would
make it clear that explicit provisions are provided in the said Rule
for dealing with the contingency in question. The Apex Court after
considering the facts of the case found that though the bond
conditions are vague, the partial refund already effected from the
salary of the teacher incumbent concerned may not be interfered
with and had also specifically ordered that further balance amount
yet to be recovered from the teacher need not be recovered, taking
into consideration the facts circumstances of the case.
19.4. In Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1], on the facts of the
case on hand, the Division Bench noticed that the parties are fully
regulated by the conditions in Annexures A3 and A4 agreements.
Further, there are no provisions akin to Rule 63 of the Rules
considered in para.9 of the decision of the Apex Court in Sant
Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411] in the case on hand.
Rule 99 of Part I KSR deals with study leave. The said Rule has
been deleted from the statute book with effect from 19.02.2007,
vide Gazette notification published on 22.02.2007. After referring
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
to Appendix VI of Part I KSR, which deals with rules for grant of
study leave, the Division Bench observed that if the course is
meant for Ph.D or M.Phil in academic or literary subjects, then
there is no question of invoking Rule 99 or Appendix VI framed
thereto. Further, a reading of the operative portion of Annexure A
proforma agreement framed under Rule 15 of Appendix VI would
make it clear that the liability to pay the amounts to the
Government would occur only in cases where the employee
concerned resigns or retires from service without returning to duty
after expiry of the termination of the period of study leave. Hence,
the Division Bench found that the factual situation prevailing in
the case on hand is substantially different from the case
considered by the Apex Court in Sant Longowal Institute
[(2013) 10 SCC 411]. Moreover, in the said decision, the Apex
Court
has
given
certain
equitable
directions
taking
into
consideration the peculiar facts and circumstances of that case by
ordering that whatever has been recovered from the teacher need
not be refunded to him and that the amounts which are not yet
recovered from the teacher need not be recovered from him.
Therefore, the Division Bench arrived at a conclusion that the
decision rendered by the Apex Court in the said decision has no
application to the facts and circumstances of the case on hand.
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Therefore, the Kerala Administrative Tribunal cannot be faulted for
having taken the view as in the impugned order dated 06.08.2019
in O.A.No. 2210 of 2018.
20.
As
already
noticed
hereinbefore,
the
condition
stipulated in the bond executed on 05.05.1999 by the respondent
in Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411] was that in
the event of bounden failing to resume duty, or resigning or
retiring from service or otherwise quitting service without
returning for duty after the expiry of termination of the period of
study leaves or at any time within a period of three years after
return to duty, he/she shall forthwith pay to the Institute or as
may be directed by the Institute, on demand, pay and allowances
received by him/her during study leave, the said amount of
Rs.10,000/- (Ten thousand only) together with interest thereon
from the date of demand at Government rates for the time being
in force on Government loan. After noticing that there is no clearcut provision in the bond executed by the respondent on
05.05.1999 either expressly referring to Rule 63 of the Central
Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972 or strictly imposing a condition
that if a candidate fails to complete the course of study during the
period of sanctioned leave, he will have to refund to the appellant
Institute the total amount of leave salary and other benefits
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
availed of by him during the period of study leave, the Two-Judge
Bench held that a candidate who avails of leave but takes no
interest to complete the course and does not furnish the certificate
to that effect is doing a disservice to the institute as well as the
students of the institute. In other words, such a person only enjoys
the period of study leave without doing any work at the institute
and, at the same time, enjoys the salary and other benefits, which
is evidentially not in the public interest. Public money cannot be
spent unless there is mutual benefit.
21.
In Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411],
the Apex Court, after considering the facts and circumstances of
the case and considering the fact that the bond executed by the
respondent is found to be vague, found no reason for the appellant
Institute to recover the balance amount of Rs.6,18,000/- from the
respondent. However, the Apex Court ordered that the amount
already recovered need not be refunded, since public interest has
definitely suffered due to non-obtaining of Ph.D by the respondent
after availing of the entire salary and other benefits. In the said
judgment, it was made clear that the Apex Court did so, taking
into consideration all aspects of the matter, and to do complete
justice between the parties. Therefore, the said direction is one
issued in the exercise of the powers under Article 142 of the
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Constitution of India, which confers the Apex Court the power to
pass any order necessary for doing complete justice in any cause
or matter pending before it. In the said decision, the Apex Court
did not issue any direction to the appellant Institute to refund the
amount already recovered, on the ground that the bond executed
by the respondent was vague.
22.
As already noticed hereinbefore, in Premasukumar
[2019 (3) KLT 912] the order of reference was made after
doubting the reasoning of the learned Single Judge in the decision
in Geetha S. v. State of Kerala [2014 SCC OnLine Ker.
15658] that the pay and other allowances given to the teacher
could be recovered by the Government only if the teacher fails to
join duty within a period of three years from the completion of the
course and that, if the teacher fails to complete the course
successfully within the grace period, it shall be duty of the teacher
to pay a sum of Rs.7,000/- together with interest at the rates
specified therein, and hence, the steps taken to recover the salary
and other allowances paid to the teacher during the period of
deputation from the DCRG is unauthorised and illegal.
23.
In Premasukumar [2019 (3) KLT 912], the Division
Bench after referring to the objective and the relevant provisions
of 'X Plan Guidelines for Faculty Improvement Programme' under
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
which the petitioner was awarded Teacher Fellowship for doing
Ph.D, and also the law laid down by the Apex Court in Sant
Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411], noticed that a
Teacher Fellowship is granted with the objective of providing an
opportunity to the teacher to pursue academic studies or research
and acquire further qualification so that it would inure to the
benefit of the students. Therefore, the teacher is bound to utilise
the Fellowship and acquire Ph.D/M.Phil within the fellowship period.
24.
As already noticed hereinbefore, in Premasukumar
[2019 (3) KLT 912] the Division Bench noticed that in Sant
Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411] the Apex Court after
careful examination of the terms of the bond executed by the
respondent, found that there is no clear-cut provision imposing
the condition that if a candidate fails to complete the course of
study during the period of sanctioned leave, he will have to refund
to the institute the total amount of leave salary and other benefits
availed by him during the period. Even after noticing the absence
of a specific clause in the bond, the Apex Court allowed the appeal,
to the extent of allowing the Institute to retain the amounts
already recovered from the respondent. The Division Bench
agreed with the reasoning of the Apex Court, as contained in
paragraph 11 of that judgment, for arriving at such a conclusion.
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
The Division Bench noticed that the objective of awarding Teacher
Fellowship is to provide an opportunity to do research or pursue
academic studies leading to the award of M.Phil/Ph.D degree.
Failure to acquire the degree would indicate that the teacher has
not utilised the opportunity properly. This recalcitrance on the part
of the teacher is at the cost of the public exchequer and the
students. Therefore, necessarily, the teacher is bound to refund
the salary and other benefits received by her during the course of
the Fellowship which she failed to utilise properly. The Clause is
specific to the effect that the teacher should serve the College for
a period of three years after successful completion of the course.
This Clause has two limbs; one is successful completion of the
course and the other is serving the college for a continuous period
of three years after such successful completion. Therefore, serving
the College without successful completion of the course will not
absolve the Bounden from the liability under the bond. A Lecturer
who has successfully completed the course, but fails to serve the
College would be liable under the bond. The failure to successfully
complete the course within the stipulated period would entail in
an additional penalty of Rs.7,000/-. Hence, the finding of the
learned Single Judge in Geetha S. v. State of Kerala [2014 SCC
OnLine Ker. 15658] that a teacher who failed to complete the
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
course successfully within the period need pay only Rs.7,000/together with interest is contrary to the objective of the Faculty
Improvement Programme as well as the terms of the bond and
hence found to be not good law by the Division Bench. In
Premasukumar [2019 (3) KLT 912], the Division Bench
answered the reference by holding that in the event of a teacher
awarded Fellowship for Ph.D course, failing to complete the course
and acquiring the degree within the Fellowship period, he/she
would be liable to refund the salary and other benefits received
during the fellowship period.
25.
The subsequent decision of the Division Bench in
Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1] is one rendered without noticing
the law laid down by the Division Bench in Premasukumar
[2019 (3) KLT 912]. In the said decision, the Division Bench
after taking note of the law laid down by the Apex Court in Sant
Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411] answered the
reference holding that in the event of the teacher failing to
complete the course successfully within the grace period and that
upon payment of all such sums, the written obligation shall be void
and of no effect, and that otherwise, the bond shall remain in full
force and effect. The Clause is specific to the effect that the
teacher should serve the College for a period of three years after
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
successful completion of the course. This Clause has two limbs;
one is successful completion of the course and the other is serving
the college for a continuous period of three years after such
successful completion. Therefore, serving the College without
successful completion of the course will not absolve the Bounden
from the liability under the bond. Therefore, the finding of the
learned Single Judge in Geetha S. v. State of Kerala [2014 SCC
OnLine Ker. 15658] that a teacher who failed to complete the
course successfully within the period needs to pay only Rs.7,000/together with interest is contrary to the objective of the Faculty
Improvement Programme, as well as the terms of the bond, and
hence not good law.
26.
In Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1] the Division Bench,
after referring to the decision of the Apex Court in Sant Longowal
Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411], distinguished the same stating
that a reading of para.9 of the said decision would make it clear
that later the appellant Institute had amended its norms for bond
conditions on 28.06.2002, which appears to be before the expiry
of the leave period of the teacher concerned (which was up to
22.07.2002), and that a reading of para.10 of the said decision
would also make it clear that the explicit statutory rules had
governed the field. The reference to Rule 63 of the Central Civil
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
Services (Leave) Rules, 1972 considered in para.10 of the said
decision of the Apex Court, would make it clear that explicit
provisions are provided in the said Rule for dealing with the
contingency in question. The Apex Court, after considering the
facts of the case on hand, found that though the bond conditions
are vague, the partial refund already effected from the salary of
the teacher incumbent concerned may not be interfered with and
had also specifically ordered that further balance amount yet to be
recovered from the teacher need not be recovered, taking into
consideration the facts circumstances of the case.
27.
As already noticed hereinbefore, in Sant Longowal
Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411], only after noticing that there is
no clear-cut provision in the bond executed by the respondent on
05.05.1999 either expressly referring to Rule 63 of the Central
Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972 or strictly imposing a condition
that if a candidate fails to complete the course of study during the
period of sanctioned leave, he will have to refund to the appellant
Institute the total amount of leave salary and other benefits
availed of by him during the period of study leave, the Two-Judge
Bench held that a candidate who avails of leave but takes no
interest to complete the course and does not furnish the certificate
to that effect is doing a disservice to the institute as well as the
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
students of the institute. In other words, such a person only enjoys
the period of study leave without doing any work at the institute
and, at the same time, enjoys the salary and other benefits, which
is evidentially not in the public interest. Public money cannot be
spent unless there is mutual benefit. Therefore, the decision of the
Apex Court in Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411]
is not one rendered, either in the context of the provisions
contained in Rule 63 of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules,
1972 or the specific provision later incorporated in the bond by the
Board of Governors of the appellant Institute in its 22 nd meeting
held on 28.06.2002. In that view of the matter, conclusion is
irresistible that the Division Bench in Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC
1] went wrong in arriving at a conclusion that the decision of the
Apex Court in Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411]
was on a factual situation substantially different from the case
considered by the Division Bench.
28.
In the instant case, the original appellant was awarded
Teacher Fellowship for doing Ph.D, under IX Plan Faculty
Development Programme of the UGC, vide letter dated 01.02.2001,
which was followed by the letter dated 28.09.2002 granting
extension of time. As already noticed hereinbefore at paragraph
11, the award of Teacher Fellowship as well as grant of extension
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
of time was subject to the specific condition stipulated in those
letters that the Teacher Fellow shall have to submit his/her Ph.D
Thesis compulsorily in order to account for audit as well as for the
purpose for which the grants are paid by the UGC, failing which
the entire amount incurred to the Scheme will have to be borne
by the Teacher Fellow.
29.
The Division Bench of this Court in Premasukumar
[2019 (3) KLT 912], after taking note of the law laid down by
the Apex Court in Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC
411], rightly answered the reference by holding that in the event
of a teacher awarded Fellowship for Ph.D course failing to complete
the course and acquiring the degree within the Fellowship period,
he/she would be liable to refund the salary and other benefits
received during the fellowship period and that serving the college
without successful completion of Ph.D course will not absolve the
bounden from the liability under the bond. Therefore, the law laid
down by the Division Bench in Ajitha C.K. [2021 (2) KHC 1],
which is contrary to the objective of the Faculty Improvement
Programme, the terms of the bond, the law laid down by the Apex
Court in Sant Longowal Institute [(2013) 10 SCC 411] and
the law laid down by the Division Bench in Premasukumar [2019
(3) KLT 912], is declared as not good law.
ICR (WA) NO.13 OF 2025
30.
The question referred to the Full Bench, by the order of
reference dated 07.07.2022 of the Division Bench in W.A.No.139
of 2022, is answered as above.
31.
Registry is directed to place the writ appeal before the
Division Bench as per roster. The 1st respondent State shall file an
application in the writ appeal, invoking the provisions under Order
XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 to mark the
documents produced along with the memo dated 23.10.2024, as
additional documents in the writ appeal. The supplemental
appellants 2 to 4 shall file an application in the writ appeal to
implead the University Grants Commission as an additional
respondent.
Sd/-
ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/-
VIJU ABRAHAM, JUDGE
Sd/G. GIRISH, JUDGE
Drgn/bkn/AV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review