Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OA No. 1201 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 26-02-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
OA No. 1201 of 2025
1. V.R. Jaganathan
S/o.C.Ramasawamy, President, Indian
National Trade Union Congress(TN
Branch) 19, T.N.Chinnasamy Avenue,
Rangammal Koil Street, Peelamedu,
Coimbatore-641004 and another
2. Indian National Trade Union Congress
Rep by P.Srinivasan Secretary, INTUC
Residing at 46/1, 3rd Main Road, Baba
Nagar, Villivakkam, Chennai-600049
Applicant(s)
Vs
1. M. Paneerselvam an 9 others
S/o.Munuswamy, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram,
Chennai-600013
2.A.Kalyanaraman
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80,
Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram ,
Chennai-600013
3.S.Lingamoorthy
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80,
Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram ,
Chennai-600013
Page 1
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
4.M.Arumugam
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80,
Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram ,
Chennai-600013
5.M.Nandhakumar
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80,
Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram ,
Chennai-600013
6.D.Dhanasekar
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80,
Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram ,
Chennai-600013
7.J.Mathiyalagan
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80,
Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram ,
Chennai-600013
8.T.Rajasekaran
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80,
Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram ,
Chennai-600013
9.K.Gunasekaran
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80,
Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram ,
Chennai-600013
10.K.S.Thusaliman
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80,
Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram ,
Chennai-600013
Respondent(s)
PRAYER
To grant an order of Ad interim injunction restraining the
Respondents, their men, their agents and anyone claiming under them from
Page 2
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
interfering with the functioning of the working committee under the
presidentship of the 1st Plaintiff, pending disposal of the above suit.
For Applicant(s):
Mr. M.S. Krishnan,
Senior Counsel
For Mr.K.Roopesh
For R1
Mr.Sathish Parakaran,
Senior Counsel
For M/s.D.Ravichandran
Mr.T.Mohan, Senior Counsel
for M/s.K.S.Kamakshi
For R2 to R10
ORDER
This application has been filed by the applicant to grant ad-interim
injunction restraining the respondents, their men, their agents and anyone
claiming under them from interfering with the functioning of the working
committee under the Presidentship of the 1st Plaintiff, pending disposal of the
above Suit.
2. The learned Senior counsel appearing for the applicants would submit
that the 1st applicant is the President of the 2nd respondent’s Tamil Nadu Branch
and the applicants filed the Suit for declaration declaring that the election
conducted by the respondents/defendants dated 16.11.2025 as null and void and
for
consequential
relief
of
Permanent
injunction
restraining
the
respondents/defendants, their men, agents, anyone claiming under them from
Page 3
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
interfering, disturbing with the functioning of the Working Committee under the
Presidentship of the 1st Plaintiff and for costs. The governing body of the
INTUC is the Working Committee headed by the President of INTUC.
2.1. The 1st applicant TN INTUC is one of the Pradesh Branches of TN
INTUC and is governed by the Working Committee of Tamil Nadu INTUC
which is an elected body, headed by the President and shall be the highest
executive authority of Tamil Nadu INTUC.
2.2. The 1st applicant was for the first time appointed as the President of
TN INTUC vide a Notification dated 09.09.2020 issued by the 2 nd applicant
Central INTUC.
As per the said notification, a fresh adhoc Committee
replacing the earlier elected Committee was formed under the Presidentship of
the 1st applicant, V.R. Jaganathan along with 24 office bearers for various
designations. This adhoc Committee was notified to hold office until further
directions from the 2nd applicant Central INTUC were issued. After a period of
two years from the appointment of Ad-hoc Committee, the TN INTUC on
07.08.2022, convened the 27th Delegates Conference at Madurai and the said
conference was convened by the erstwhile Adhoc Committee appointed by the
Central INTUC as there was no working committee of the state INTUC
functioning then.
Page 4
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
In the above mentioned 27 th Delegates Conference at
OA No. 1201 of 2025
Madurai, through a Resolution No.4A dated 07.08.2022, the 1 st applicant
Mr. Jaganathan was elected as President of the TN INTUC with the approval of
the delegates elected including the 1st respondent. The said resolution to elect
the 1st applicant Mr. Jagannathan was announced by the President of Central
INTUC and the same was accepted by all the delegates.
2.3. The Working Committee under the Presidentship of the 1 st applicant
V.R. Jaganathan was initially running smoothly. The 1st respondent along with
his acquaintances started indulging in various unethical activities against the
interest of the trade union.
The defendant M. Pannerselvam and his
acquaintances who were a part of the earlier Working Committee were relieved
from their post and they were not made a part of the newly appointed ad hoc
Committee.
While so, the said M. Pannerselvam along with others have
approached this Court in C.S. No.226 of 2024 challenging the Notification
dated 06.09.2024 and also filed an application to appoint an Election Officer for
conducting the upcoming elections for the Working Committee of the TN
INTUC which was ought to be due in the month of August 2025. This Court
through an order dated 15.07.2025, passed an order that the election ought to be
conducted to the INTUC as the office bearers of the Working Committee
members since their tenure has lapsed and consequently appointed Hon'ble
Mr. Justice S. Vaidyanathan, Former Chief Justice of Meghalaya High Court as
Page 5
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
the election officer to be incharge of conducting the elections.
2.4. While being so, the 2nd applicant, the Central INTUC on 21.12.2024
conducted its 314th Working Committee meeting at U.R.M.U. New Delhi,
wherein a resolution was passed to solve the disputes among the INTUC, Tamil
Nadu Branch. The Working Committee of INTUC taking note of the order of
this Court authorized the President to dissolve the ad-hoc Committee dated
06.09.2024 and as well as the earlier elected Committee of the Tamil Nadu
INTUC. The incumbent President was authorized to appoint a fresh Ad-hoc
Committee and within a period of one year, election must be conducted to form
a new Working Committee from the date of appointment of the Ad-hoc
Committee. On 22.02.2025, a resolution was passed by the INTUC in the 252 nd
Working Committee Conference at Dindigul, wherein the President of INTUC
was empowered to take necessary decisions regarding the upcoming conference.
The earlier order passed by this Court, on 15.07.2025 was challenged through
an O.S.A. No.340 of 2025 and the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court
disposed of the appeal with a direction that in any event of procedural
violations, the aggrieved person was given liberty to approach the competent
forum and the Suit itself was disposed as infructuous and the main order was set
aside.
The earlier Committee was revived by the 1 st applicant with the
consultation of the 2nd applicant and already carried out 90% of election work.
Page 6
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
The 2nd applicant, Central INTUC issued a letter dated 31.10.2025 to the
President of the Tamil Nadu State Branch INTUC approving the Adhoc
Committee dated 06.09.2024 to be valid till the forth coming elections or till
any further directions from the Central INTUC. Pursuant to the order dated
27.10.2025 in O.S.A. No.340 of 2025 and subsequent developments, the TN
INTUC Adhoc Committee, called for an urgent meeting on 31.10.2025, to
discuss on the upcoming elections.
2.5. As per the resolutions passed by the Adhoc Committee, the elections
have to be conducted for TN INTUC on 15.11.2025 at Madurai and also to
appoint national level office bearers as the observers for Tamil Nadu INTUC
elections. On the other hand, the members aggrieved by the actions of the TN
INTUC, unlawfully and illegally formed a separate election Committee
consisting of the 2nd to 5th respondents and in addition, a credential Committee
consisting of 6th to 10th respondents was formed with sole purpose to create
confusion among the delegates and disturb the elections scheduled by the TN
INTUC.
The respondents without any authority, issued an unauthorized
election notice dated 01.11.2025. A suit was filed challenging the election
notification to be held in Madurai at Thiruvallur District. Though the Credential
Committee has its official address at Chennai and the place of election is at
Madurai, the Suit was filed at Thiruvallur by the Nethaji Auto Ootunar Pothu
Page 7
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
Nala Sangam under the instigation of the defendants, by suppressing the
material facts. The District Court, Thiruvallur vide its order dated 12.11.2025
granted an interim injunction from conducting election on 15.11.2025. The said
order was not communicated to the applicants and these applicants are not
parties to the Suit.
2.6. Consequent to the interim injunction, the Election Committee of TN
INTUC decided to drop the election through a secret ballot. Instead a general
conference was proceeded with the consensus of the delegates. In the said
conference a resolution was passed unanimously, appointing the 1 st applicant as
the President of INTUC and further resolutions were also passed in giving
powers to the President to choose other office bearers as per the Constitution of
TN INTUC. As per the resolutions passed in the Delegates conference dated
15.11.2025, the 1st applicant was unanimously chosen as the President of TN
INTUC and subsequently he assumed charge as the President of INTUC.
Therefore, the 1st applicant holds the post of the President of TN INTUC.
2.7. For the said election, approval was also granted by the 2 nd applicant,
the Central INTUC through an order dated 17.11.2025. On the very next day,
i.e., on 16.11.2025, the respondents convened an unauthorized and illegal
delegates conference with a participation of a meagre i.e., less than 10% of the
Page 8
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
members of the INTUC and claimed to have elected the President of INTUC,
which is totally absurd and contrary to the constitution of INTUC. The 1 st
respondent by claiming himself to be the Secretary General of the TN INTUC
convened a Working Committee meeting and without any sanction neither from
the TN INTUC nor from the INTUC appointed the election committee and the
credential Committee. The said unauthorized Committee conducted an election
on 16.11.2025 which is incomplete on contravention to the constitution of the
TN INTUC and by virtue of that election, the defendants claimed to be the
office bearers of TN INTUC which is completely absurd. Therefore, they filed
the Suit and now filed this application. The applicants have prima facie case
and balance of convenience is also lying in favour of the applicants and that if
injunction is not granted, irreparable loss and damages will be caused to the
applicants. Therefore, prayed to grant interim injunction to the applicants.
3. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent would submit that the
first plaintiff was unanimously elected as the president and was given power to
nominate other office bearers and the ordinary Working Committee members to
the working committee of the Tamil Nadu INTUC and the first respondent was
appointed by the first plaintiff to the post of Secretary General of the Working
Committee of Tamil Nadu INTUC. The first applicant was unanimously
appointed as the President during the 27 th Delegate Conference at Madurai, the
Page 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
fist applicant misusing his official position and usurping its power as President
of Tamil Nadu had illegally appointed as many as 144 members as members of
Working Committee as against the sanctioned strength of 51 members as
provided under the Constitution of Tamil Nadu INTUC. Further when the first
respondent herein has been successfully elected as the President of Indian
National Engineering Employees Union as Union Affiliated to the Tamil Nadu
INTUC, the first respondent herein had raised concerns and voiced against the
said illegal activities of the fist applicant and his close aids and instituted suit in
O.S.No.99 of 2023 on the file of the learned Principal District Munsif, Ambattur
and the same is pending.
3.1. While so the first applicant colluded with the Central INTUC had
clandestinely over thrown a democratically elected working committee only to
silence the first respondent herein and those people who in support of the first
respondent herein by way of removing them through an illegal notification
dated 06.09.2024 by appointing adhoc committee for an indefinite period. The
said notification dated 06.09.2024 is quite illegal and the same was not issued in
accordance with the strict procedures enumerated under the Byelaws of the
Central INTUC. The first applicant who is also the President of the adhoc
committee was not given power to either add more members to the adhoc
committee or removing the existing members in the adhoc committee. Such a
Page 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
course is quite antithetical to the mandates enumerated under the Constitution
of Central INTUC and also Tamil Nadu INTUC. One suit in C.S.No. 226 of
2024 was filed challenging the notification dated 06.09.2024 issued by the
Central INTUC and for permanent injunction restraining the defendants therein
from interfering with the functions of the plaintiffs therein as respective office
bearers of the Tamil Nadu INTUC and this Court granted interim injunction,
thereby the first respondent herein was permitted to continue to function as
Secretary General of Tamil Nadu INTUC vide interim order dated 27.09.2024.
3.2.The above mentioned interim order granted on 27.09.2024 was later
made absolute vide order dated 12.11.2024. Pursuant to the interim injunction
granted by this Court in C.S.No.226 of 2024, the first respondent successfully
functioned as Secretary General of INTUC. While so, the first respondent called
for working committee meeting on 22.02.2025 at Dindigul without the
concurrence of the first respondent who is the Secretary General of the Tamil
Nadu INTUC and also the first applicant herein had not invited the plaintiffs
therein in the above mentioned suit in CS No.226 of 2024 and thereby they filed
an application in OA No.154 of 2025 in CS No.226 of 2024 for an injunction
restraining the defendants therein from convening working committee meeting
on 22.02.2025 and this Court through order dated 19.02.2025 directed the
plaintiff in CS No.226 of 2024 and also other working committee members to
Page 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
participate in the meeting held on 22.05.2025. The Working Committee meeting
dated 22.02.2025 got disrupted due to mischief and ruckus created by the fist
applicant herein and his supporters. The first applicant herein filed memo in CS
No.226 of 2024 and the same was dismissed as infructuous, on account of the
resolution made in 314th Working Committee meeting of central INTUC held at
New Delhi on 21.12.2024
3.3.The 314th Working Committee held at New Delhi on 21.12.2024 had
resolved to empower President to dissolve the adhoc committee meeting dated
06.09.2024 and also earlier elected committee and to appoint a fresh adhoc
committee to the Tamil Nadu INTUC for a period of one year and the election
has to be conducted within a period of one year of appointment of new adhoc
committee, however, this Court was not pleased to act upon the said memo and
accordingly not dismissed the suit as infructuous. It is also relevant to mention
that it has been alleged in the plaint that pursuant to the 314 th working
committee meeting of Central INTUC held on 21.12.2024, the first applicant
had reappointed the earlier adhoc committee appointed under Notification
dated 06.09.2024 in Working Committee meeting held at Dindigul. Which is
quite contrary to the resolution dated 21.12.2021 and the same is contrary to the
Constitution of Central INTUC.
Page 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
3.4. The plaintiff in CS No.226 of 2024 filed an application in A.No.2203
of 2025 seeking for appointment of Election Commissioner for conducting the
elections for the Working Committee for INTUC and the Election Officer was
also appointed to conduct elections for the post of President alone and it has
been unanimously decided to empower the said elected President to nominate
the other officer bearers. Thus, the parties by way of consensus had chosen to
revive the elected working committee for the purpose of then upcoming
elections that felt due on August 2025. In view of the said consensus, the said
suit was disposed vide order dated 15.07.2025. Thereafter, the election officer
had decided on the eligibility of the Working Committee members and
accordingly shortlisted 139 members in total list of 144 members, furnished by
the first respondent herein.
3.5. The affiliated union of Tamil Nadu INTUC challenging the
consensual order dated 15.07.2025 in OSA No.340 of 2025 and the Division
Bench of this Court allowed the appeal and set aside the consensual order dated
15.07.2025 made in application NO.2203 of 2025 in CS No.226 of 2024
reliving the Election Commissioner appointed therein forthwith. The Division
Bench also observed that the election to the Working Committee of Tamil Nadu
INTUC shall be conducted following the mandate enumerated under the Tamil
Page 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
Nadu INTUC Constituents, scrupulously more particularly clause 11 of the said
Constitution. As per the orders passed in OSA No.340 of 2025, the Working
Committee of the Tamil Nadu INTUC got convened on 31.10.2025 and it has
been unanimously decided to conduct the elections for all the 51 posts by way
of secret ballot. The first respondent as the General Secretary had convened a
meeting with sufficient quorum and election committee was constituted for the
purpose of conduction of election and the election committee had fixed the date
on 16.11.2025 and based on the election notification nominations have been
received and final list of candidates were also published. As only 30
nominations have been received against the sanctioned post of 30 ordinary
working committee members, it has been decided to conduct elections only for
the post of office bearers comprising of 21 posts. Whileso, the first applicant
along with close members/aids had chosen to conduct a parallel elections at
Madurai only to upset the democratic elections conducted by the Tamil Nadu
INTUC.
3.6. Already a suit has been filed in O.S.No.812 of2025 on the file of the
Principal District Court, Thiruvallur, in respect of the election at Madurai and
the court also granted interim order in IA No.2 of 2025 in OS No. 812 of 2025.
Thereafter, the first applicant was elected as President giving him power to
appoint other office bearers and ordinary working committee members in the
Page 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
working committee of Tamil Nadu INTUC based upon the powers conferred
upon during the alleged delegate conference dated 15.11.2025 calling upon to
nominate other office bearers and other committee members for approval. When
the applicants herein are making challenge to the election dated 16.11.2025,
they have made only the first respondent as a part to the proceedings and
consciously omitted the other office bearers and other ordinary working
committee members who were elected on the said date. The other working
committee members who were elected on 16.11.2025 are both proper and
necessary parties to the instant application and failure to array them as the
parties in the present application is fatal to the case of the applicants herein and
hence the present application has to be necessarily dismissed on the sole ground
of non-joinder of necessary parties. The respondents 2 to 10 herein are not
residing in the first respondent address. The Central INTUC alone can nominate
working committee as per Rule 25 of the Bye law, therefore, once again the
same President of the INTUC Cannot nominate the persons and the Central
INTUC has proved the list and that list is not in consensus with the order of the
Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court. Therefore, the petitioner is not entitled
for the relief of interim injunction and there is no prima facie case case made
out for the grant of interim injunction and if any injunction is granted the
respondent will be put to heavy loss and damages, therefore, the petition is
liable to be dismissed.
Page 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
4.Heard both sides and perused the materials available on record.
5. The plaintiffs have filed a Suit for declaration declaring that the
election conducted by the defendants dated 16.11.2025 as null and void and for
consequential relief of Permanent injunction restraining the defendants, their
men, agents, anyone claiming under them from interfering, disturbing with the
functioning of the Working Committee under the Presidentship of the 1 st
Plaintiff and for costs. The governing body of the INTUC is the Working
Committee headed by the President of INTUC. The working committee shall
conduct the general administration of the Congress and shall be the highest
executive authority of INTUC and shall have the power to carry out programs
and policies as laid down by the General Council.
5.1. The 1st applicant TN INTUC is one of the Pradesh Branches of TN
INTUC and is governed by the Working Committee of Tamil Nadu INTUC
which is an elected body, headed by the President and shall be the highest
executive authority of Tamil Nadu INTUC. The 1st applicant was for the first
time appointed as the President of TN INTUC vide a Notification dated
09.09.2020 issued by the 2nd applicant Central INTUC. As per the said
Page 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
notification, a fresh adhoc Committee replacing the earlier elected Committee
was formed under the Presidentship of the 1st applicant, V.R. Jaganathan along
with 24 office bearers for various designations. This adhoc Committee was
notified to hold office until further directions from the 2 nd applicant Central
INTUC are issued. After a period of two years from the appointment of Ad-hoc
Committee, the TN INTUC on 07.08.2022, convened the 27 th Delegates
Conference at Madurai and the said conference was convened by the erstwhile
Adhoc Committee appointed by the Central INTUC as there was no working
committee of the state INTUC functioning then. In the above mentioned 27 th
Delegates Conference at Madurai, through a Resolution No.4A dated
07.08.2022, the 1st applicant
Mr. Jaganathan was elected as President of the
TN INTUC with the approval of the delegates elected including the 1 st
respondent. The said resolution to elect the 1 st applicant Mr. Jagannathan was
announced by the President of Central INTUC and the same was accepted by all
the delegates. The above said facts are admitted by the both parties.
5.2. According to the applicants, the Working Committee under the
Presidentship of the 1st applicant V.R. Jaganathan was initially running
smoothly, the 1st respondent along with his acquaintances started indulging in
various unethical activities against the interest of the trade union, the defendant
M. Pannerselvam and his acquaintances who were a part of the earlier Working
Page 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
Committee were relieved from their post and they were not made a part of the
newly appointed ad hoc Committee, In the meantime the said M. Pannerselvam
along with others have approached this Court in C.S. No.226 of 2024
challenging the Notification dated 06.09.2024 and also filed an application to
appoint an Election Officer for conducting the upcoming elections for the
Working Committee of the TN INTUC which was ought to be due in the month
of August 2025. This Court on 15.07.2025 passed an order that the election
ought to be conducted to the INTUC since the tenure of the office bearers of the
Working Committee has lapsed and consequently appointed Hon'ble Mr. Justice
S. Vaidyanathan, Former Chief Justice of Meghalaya High Court as the election
officer to be incharge of conducting the elections. The earlier order passed by
this Court, on 15.07.2025 was challenged through an O.S.A. No.340 of 2025
and the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court disposed of the appeal with a
direction that in any event of procedural violations, the aggrieved person was
given liberty to approach the competent forum and the Suit itself was disposed
as infructuous and the main order was set aside.
5.3. While being so, the 2nd applicant, the Central INTUC on 21.12.2024
conducted its 314th Working Committee meeting at U.R.M.U. New Delhi,
wherein a resolution was passed to solve the disputes among the INTUC, Tamil
Nadu Branch. The Working Committee of INTUC taking note of the order of
Page 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
this Court authorized the President to dissolve the ad-hoc Committee dated
06.09.2024 as well as the earlier elected Committee of the Tamil Nadu INTUC.
The incumbent President was authorized to appoint a fresh Ad-hoc Committee
and within a period of one year, election must be conducted to form a new
Working Committee from the date of appointment of the Ad-hoc Committee.
On 22.02.2025, a resolution was passed by the INTUC. The 252 nd Working
Committee Conference at Dindigul, the President of INTUC was empowered to
take necessary decisions regarding the upcoming conference. The earlier
Committee was revived by the 1st applicant with the consultation of the 2nd
applicant and already carried out 90% of election work. The 2 nd applicant,
Central INTUC issued a letter dated 31.10.2025 to the President of the Tamil
Nadu State Branch INTUC approving the Adhoc Committee dated 06.09.2024
to be valid till the forth coming elections or till any further directions from the
Central INTUC. Pursuant to the order dated 27.10.2025 in O.S.A. No.340 of
2025 and subsequent developments, the TN INTUC Adhoc Committee on
28.10.2025, called for an urgent meeting on 31.10.2025, to discuss on the
upcoming elections.
5.4. As per the resolutions passed by the Adhoc Committee, the elections
have to be conducted for TN INTUC on 15.11.2025 at Madurai and also to
appoint national level office bearers as the observers for Tamil Nadu INTUC
Page 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
elections. On the other hand, the members aggrieved by the actions of the TN
INTUC, formed a separate election Committee consisting of the 2 nd to 5th
respondents and in addition, a credential Committee consisting of 6 th to 10th
respondents, and also issued an election notice dated 01.11.2025. A suit was
filed challenging the election notification to be held in Madurai at Thiruvallur
District. The District Court, Thiruvallur vide its order dated 12.11.2025 granted
an interim injunction from conducting election on 15.11.2025. The said order
was not communicated to the applicants and these applicants are not parties to
the Suit.
5.5. Consequent to the interim injunction, the Election Committee of TN
INTUC decided to drop the election through a secret ballot. Instead a general
conference was proceeded with the consensus of the delegates. In the said
conference a resolution was passed unanimously appointing the 1st applicant as
the President of INTUC and further resolutions were also passed in giving
powers to the President to choose other office bearers as per the Constitution of
TN INTUC. As per the resolutions passed in the Delegates conference dated
15.11.2025, the 1st applicant was unanimously chosen as the President of TN
INTUC and subsequently he assumed charge as the President of INTUC.
Therefore, the 1st applicant holds the post of the President of TN INTUC.
Page 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
5.6. The said election was also approved by the 2 nd applicant, the Central
INTUC through an order dated 17.11.2025. On the very next day, i.e., on
16.11.2025, the respondents conveyed delegates conference and claimed to have
elected the President of INTUC, the 1st respondent by claiming himself to be the
Secretary General of the TN INTUC convened a Working Committee meeting
appointed the election committee and the credential Committee.
The said
Committee conducted an election on 16.11.2025 and by virtue of that election,
the defendants claimed to be the office bearers of TN INTUC. Therefore, they
filed the Suit and now filed this application.
6. According to the applicant, he was unanimously elected as President of
Tamil Nadu INTUC as per resolution passed in delegate conference dated
15.11.2025 and the said election was also approved by the Central INTUC
through order dated 17.11.2025. While so, on the very next day, i.e., on
16.11.2025, the respondents conveyed conference and claimed to have elected
the President of INTUC. The 1 st respondent by claiming himself to be the
Secretary General of the TN INTUC convened a Working Committee meeting
without any sanction neither from the TN INTUC nor from the Central INTUC.
The Central INTUC appointed election committee and credential committee.
Page 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
7. According to the first respondent, the first applicant appointed the first
respondent as Secretary General and he conducted delegates conference and
convened working committee meeting and appointed election committee and
credential committee . The said committee election was held on 16.09.2025 and
the said elected members are not party to the suit and only the first respondent
alone was added as party. Since both the applicant and the first respondent are
claiming that they are the President of TN INTUC, that issue has to be decided,
after elaborate trial. The applicant/plaintiff filed suit challenging the election
notification conducted by the defendants dated 16.11.2025. The respondents
have not challenged the election of the applicants dated 15.11.2025. Now at this
stage, without any elaborate trial, the merits of the case cannot be decided, at
this stage. The applicant filed suit for declaration of election dated 16.11.2025
by only including few persons and according to the respondent through
election dated 16.11.2025, President, Senior Vice President, Secretary General,
General Secretary, working committee members have been elected for the above
said eight posts and totally 51 persons were elected for various posts. While so,
without impleading those persons, the petition cannot be decided and their
presence is essential to decide the issue. Therefore, there is no prima facie case
made out. According to the respondents already this court upheld the position
of 1st respondent as Secretory General and power of the appointment of working
Page 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
committee members is not vested with the T.N.INTUC President and the central
INTUC President alone has power to nominate the members of working
committee,. As per the order of this court the working committee constituted by
the 1st applicant president of T.N. INTUC was dissolved and again the same
person the 1st applicant selected the same person as working committee member
and the same was approved by the 2 nd applicant Central president of INTUC.
Therefore the said contention of the respondent has to be tested through trial.
Without elaborate trail the disputed facts cannot be decided in the interlocutory
application. Already election was conducted and the competency of the election
can be tested in the main suit and at this stage holding of office by the persons
cannot be tested and there is no sufficient evidence before this Court and
therefore, it is not appropriate to grant interim injunction at this stage, therefore
the petition is liable to be dismissed.
8. In the result, the petition stands dismissed.
26.02.2026
mjs
Index:Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Internet:Yes
Page 23
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1201 of 2025
P.DHANABAL J.
mjs
OA No. 1201 of 2025
26.02.2026
Page 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review