Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:15173
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
THURSDAY, THE 6TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 17TH MAGHA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 238 OF 2019
AGAINST THE ORDER IN OA NO.1123 OF 2014 OF CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONER/APPLICANT:
V.PRAKASAN, AGED 64 YEARS, S/O. LATE P. GOPALAN,
ASSISTANT ENGINEER (CIVIL) (RETD.), VANIYATHUR HOUSE,
KAKKODI POST, KOZHIKODE - 673 611
BY ADV R.SREERAJ
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA, REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
SHIPPING TRANSPORT BHAVAN, NEW DELHI - 110 001
THE PAY AND ACCOUNTS OFFICER
OFFICE OF THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONTROLLER OF ACCOUNTS,
INTERNAL AUDIT WING, LDA BUILDING, JAM NAGAR HOUSE,
SHAHJAHAN ROAD, NEW DELHI - 110 011
THE CHIEF ENGINEER AND ADMINISTRATOR
ANDAMAN LAKSHADWEEP HARBOUR WORKS, PORT BLAIR - 744 101
THE DEPUTY CHIEF ENGINEER
ANDAMAN LAKSHADWEEP HARBOUR WORKS, UNION TERRITORY OF
LAKSHADWEEP, KAVARATTI - 682 555
OTHER PRESENT:
Sri.T.C.Krishna (DSGI in charge)
THIS OP (CAT) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 06.02.2025, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
THURSDAY, THE 6TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 17TH MAGHA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 244 OF 2019
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 24.12.2018 IN OA NO.1123 OF 2014 OF
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS IN OA:
UNION OF INDIA, REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
SHIPPING, TRANSPORT BHAVAN, NEW DELHI-110001.
THE PAY AND-ACCOUNTS OFFICER
OFFICE OF THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONTROLLER OF ACCOUNTS,
INTERNAL AUDIT WING, I.D.A. BUILDING, JAM NAGAR HOUSE,
SHAHJAHAN ROAD, NEW DELHI-110 011.
THE CHIEF ENGINEER AND ADMINISTRATOR
ANDAMAN LAKSHADWEEP HARBOUR WORKS-PORT BLAIR-744101.
THE DEPUTY CHIEF ENGINEER
ANDAMAN LAKSHADWEEP HARBOUR WORKS, UNION TERRITORY OF
LAKSHADWEEP, KAVARATTI-682 555.
RESPONDENTS/APPLICANTS IN OA:
V.PRAKASAN, AGED 61 YEARS
S/O. LATE P. GOPALAN, ASST. ENGINEER (CIVIL) (RETD)
VANIYATHUR HOUSE, KAKKODI POST, KOZHIKODE-673 611.
BY ADV Sreeraj R
OTHER PRESENT:
Sri.T.C. Krishna (DSGI in charge)
THIS OP (CAT) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 06.02.2025, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
JUDGMENT
K. V. JAYAKUMAR, J
This judgment shall dispose of two OP(CAT)s.
2.
Tribunal,
in
Aggrieved by the order of the Central Administrative
O.A.No.1123/2014
dated
24.12.2018,
as
well
as
in
R.A.No.14/2019 dated 10.04.2019, the petitioner and the Union of India
preferred two separate OP(CAT)s.
The OP(CAT).No.238/2019 was
preferred by the applicant and the OP(CAT).No.244/2019 was preferred by
the Union of India and its officers. The parties are hereinafter referred to as
the applicant and the respondents as per their rank in the OA.
3.
The facts necessary for disposal of this OP(CAT)s in
brief are as follows:
The applicant, V. Prakasan, joined the post of temporary Overseer
(Civil) in the pay scale of Rs.330-560 on 06.10.1976 in Andaman
Lakshadweep Harbour Works [hereinafter referred to as ‘ALHW’].
Thereafter, the applicant was selected as Direct recruit and joined in the
post of Engineering Assistant on 22.11.1979 in the pay scale of 425-700. On
completion of 5 years service as Engineering Assistant, the applicant, along
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
with certain other Engineering Assistants, was placed in the pay scale of
1660-2660, with effect from 31.03.1994. Vide Annexure-A5 office order,
Engineering Assistant was re-named as Junior Engineers in the pay scale of
1400-2300/-.
4.
The applicant was promoted to the post of Inspector of
Works in the pay scale of 1600-2660, with effect from 31.03.1994 as per
Annexure-A6.
On completion of the combined service as Engineering
Assistant and Inspector of Works, applicant’s pay scale was upgraded to
2000-3500 with effect from 22.11.1995.
5.
As per Annexure-A8, the benefit of time bound
placement was made available to the applicant in the scale of 6500-10500.
On the recommendation of the 5th CPC, the post of Overseer in the prerevised scale of 1200-2040 stood merged with that of Junior Engineer in
the pay scale of 1400-2300 and the post of Junior Engineer was placed in
the revised pay scale of 5000-8000 with effect from 01.01.1996. In addition
to the above merger of Inspector of Works with the Junior Engineer,
acceptance was called from the applicant. The applicant gave his consent.
As per the conditions attached to the merger, his pay was protected.
6.
That as per Annexure-A11, the applicant was promoted
to the post of Assistant Engineer in the pay scale of 6500-10500. The 4 th
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
respondent granted first ACP to the applicant with effect from 09.08.1999
in the pay scale of 6500-10500 which, he was already drawing.
On
completion of 24 years of service reckoned from 22.11.1979, the respondents
granted 2nd financial upgradation to the applicant on 22.11.2003. On the
implementation of the 6th CPC, the applicant sought 3rd MACP on
completion of 30 years of service.
7.
Prior to his retirement, the applicant submitted a
representation dated 21.03.2014, claiming the ACP benefit which was
granted to the similarly placed employees. The respondents rejected the
said application.
In that background, the applicant approached the
Tribunal claiming the following relief:
“(a) call for the records from the office of
respondent No. 2 to 4 and hold that the impugned orders at
Annexure A-16, A-19, A-33 and A-37 are illegal and invalid
and thus, quash and set aside the same.
(b) declare that the applicant is entitled to the
two ACPs as also the 3rd MACP respectively as on 09-081999, 6-10-2000 and 6-10-2006,
(c) as a consequence to the above, it may further
be declared that recovery of alleged over payment of pay
and allowances to the tune of Rs 11 lakhs plus being effected
by way of Withholding/ adjustment of pension and
insistence of payment of the difference of Rs 1.31 lakhs plus
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
is illegal and quash and set aside orders relating to the
same,
(d) direct the respondents to restore the grant of
first and 2nd ACP,
(e) And, since the applicant is also entitled to the
grant of 3rd MACP w.e.f. 06-10-2006, respondents be
directed to upgrade the grading in respect of the years
2004-05 and 2006-07 as "very good" which is the bench
mark for the post held by the applicant for higher
promotion and then consider the case of the applicant
without taking into account the 'below benchmark grading'
and afford the 3rd MACP by way of increasing the Grade
Pay of the applicant to Rs.7600 and re-fix the last pay
drawn and work out the extent of revised pension and other
terminal benefits on the basis of the same and pay the
difference thereof (both in respect of pay and allowances as
also in respect of pension and attendant terminal benefits)
to the applicant within a time frame that may be calendared
by this Hon'ble Tribunal.
(f) Award interest at a rate that may be
prescribed by this Hon'ble Tribunal on the arrears of pay
and allowances and pension and other terminal benefits.
(g) Award cost as may be felt appropriate.
8.
The respondents contended that the applicant gave his
consent to the proposal for the contemplated merger of Inspector of Works
with Junior Engineer on condition that his earlier pay in the post of
Inspector of Works would be protected. The respondents further contended
that, the grant of 1st and 2nd ACP to the applicant was not correct as per the
observation of Pay and Accounts Officer (ALHW), New Delhi. The Pay and
Accounts Officer (ALHW), New Delhi, has recommended a revisal of pay of
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
the applicant before the re-submission of pension papers. The grading of
the applicant in the ACR for the years 2004-2005 and 2006-2007 had been
reviewed by the reviewing authority and the representation submitted by
the applicant in this regard was also rejected. The Tribunal, noticing the
rival contentions, had disposed of the OA with a direction to the
respondents to constitute a review DPC and consider the case of the
applicant on the basis of the previous ACRs.
9.
The relevant paragraph of the Tribunals order are
extracted hereunder:
“6. Heard learned counsel for the parties at length
and perused the pleadings and records. First the applicant
has raised the issue that the department cannot recover
money in view of the first ACP. According to the applicant,
the ACP was given to him we.f. 25.8.1999 as he had got
promotion to the post of Inspector of Works on 31 March,
1994. Thus, after adding 12 years from 1994, he is entitled
for first ACP. In this regard, we are in agreement with the
stand taken by the respondents that the ACP is given on
account of stagnation in a particular grade, which is not the
case here. The applicant got promotion to the next higher
scale w.e.f. 31 March, 1994. Thus he is not entitled for first
ACP w.e.f. 7.8.1999. The 2nd ACP is due and payable to the
applicant 12 years thereafter. The department has given the
second ACP correctly w.e.f. 12.10.2007 in pay scale of
Rs.10000-25200. On this count, we are of the view that
nothing is found wrong in the action of the respondents in
not granting first ACP and second ACP with effect from
12.10.2007. The applicant was not given MACP on
completion of 30 years of service as envisaged by the 6th
CPC on condition of 10, 20 and 30 years. In this regard, the
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
department has categorically submitted that the applicant's
ACRs were not upto the mark. The Bench mark for the same
was "very good", whereas for his ACR for the period 2005-06
and 2006-07, his assessment was "good" only. Thus the
department has denied the same. The Senior Advocate has
drawn our attention to page No. 102 which is ACR for 200607. The signature of the Accepting Authority is not there in
Annexure A34. The Reviewing Officer and the Reporting
Officer is one and the same, Mr.Bimal Sinha and it is
accepted by the Accepting Authority, Chief Engineer
(Administration) as "good". It is a serious anomaly. The
Reporting Officer and the Reviewing Officer should have
been different. Learned counsel for the applicant further
submitted that this was never communicated to the
applicant. In this regard,, this Tribunal is of the view that in
case the grade awarded to the applicant is below the remarks
earlier given, then it is all the more necessary to
communicate the same to the concerned officer. Thus on this
count, this ACR has to be ignored. As regards ACR for 200607, it was pointed that the Reporting Officer had given "very
good" and the Reviewing Authority had reduced it to "good"
only. The same has also not been communicated to the
applicant. In this regard, Mrs. Sumathi Dandapani has relied
upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Sukhdev Singh vs. Union of India and Ors., in Civil
Appeal No.5892 of 2006, the relevant portion of which is
reproduced hereunder:
......In our opinion, every entry in the ACR of a public
servant must be communicated to him within a
reasonable period whether it is poor, fair. average, good
or very good entry. This is what this Court held in
paragraphs 17 & 18 of the report in Dev Dutt (2008) 8
SCC
a
page
733:
In our opinion, every entry in the A.C.R. of a public
servant must be communicated to him within a
reasonable period, whether it is a poor, fair, average,
good or very good entry. This is because non-
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
communication of such an entry may adversely affect the
employee in two ways: (1) Had the entry been
communicated to him he would know about the
assessment of his work and conduct by his superiors,
which would enable him to improve his work in future (2)
He would have an opportunity of making a
representation against the entry if he feels it is
unjustified, and pray for its upgradation. Hence noncommunication of an entry is arbitrary, and it has been
held by the Constitution Bench decision of this Court in
Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (supra) that
arbitrariness violates Article 14 of the Constitution, Thus
it is not only when there is a benchmark but in all cases
that an entry (whether it is poor, fair, average, good or
very good) must be communicated to a public servant,
otherwise there is violation of the principle of fairness,
which is the soul of natural justice. Even an outstanding
entry should be communicated since that would boost the
morale of the employee and make him work harder."
7.
In view of the aforesaid dictum, this
Tribunal is of the view that since these 2 ACRs were never
communicated in which grading was reduced, that should not be
taken into account and the applicant should be suitably assessed
taking into account his previous ACRs. In case he is found fit, he
should be considered for grant of 3rd MACP. In view of this, we
direct the respondents to constitute a review DPC taking into
consideration the directions given herein above, within a period of
90 days. Of the receipt of this order. The OA is disposed of with no
order as to costs.”
10.
Aggrieved by the order of the Central Administrative
Tribunal, the applicant preferred OP(CAT) No.238/2019 and Union of India
and its officers preferred OP(CAT) No.244/2019.
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
11.
Sri T. C. Krishna, Deputy Solicitor General of India-in-
Charge, supported the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal. Sri.T.C
Krishna submitted that, the observation of the Tribunal that the grading of
the ACR was never communicated to the applicant is incorrect.
12.
On the other hand, Adv. Sreeraj, the learned counsel for
the applicant submitted that, the action of the respondents in re-fixing his
pay from the date of his initial appointment, belatedly, and that too without
affording him an opportunity of hearing, is illegal to the core. Such an
action of the respondents/Union of India is arbitrary, unjust, unreasonable
and irrational. It was further submitted that, the competent authority was
dancing to the tune, without applying their mind to the facts and
circumstances of the case.
The Pay and Accounts Officer is a mere
recommendatory authority and has usurped the jurisdiction of the
competent authority and dictated the terms. The learned counsel for the
applicant placed reliance on the decisions reported in Maneka Gandhi v.
Union of India [(1978) 1 SCC 248], Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief
Election Commissioner of India [AIR 1978 SC 851], Swadeshi
Cotton Mills v. Union of India [(1981) 1 SCC 664], Olga Tellis v.
Bombay
Municipal
Corporation
[(1985)
SCC
545]
and
Scheduled Caste and Weaker Section Welfare Association v. State
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
of Karnataka [(1991) 2 SCC 604], supporting the proposition that the
person concerned must be given an opportunity of being heard, before any
adverse action is taken against him.
13.
The first submission of the learned counsel for the
petitioner is that the action of the respondents in re-fixing the pay of the
petitioner to his detriment, from the date of his initial appointment, without
an opportunity of being heard is illegal and unjust. The respondents have
no case that, they have issued a notice to the applicant before re-fixing of his
pay, that too, just before his retirement.
14.
The second submission of Adv.Sreeraj is that, due to the
illegal withdrawal of first financial upgradation granted under the ACP
Scheme and the illegal postponement of the date of his second financial
upgradation under the said Scheme and the illegal rejection of third
financial upgradation under the Modified Assured Career Progression
Scheme (MACP), an amount of Rs.11,07,332/- was withheld from the
pensionary benefits of the applicant contrary to the mandate laid down by
the Supreme Court in State of Punjab and others v. Rafiq Masih
(White Washer) and others [(2015) 4 SCC 334]. The learned counsel
for the applicant further submitted that the withholding of retirement
benefits of the applicant is illegal and unjust. It is further submitted that,
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
even though he has pointed out the instance of P.C. Vinod, a similarly
placed
employee,
wherein
the
Tribunal
has
granted
relief
in
O.A.No.276/2016, the Tribunal was not inclined to extend the same relief to
the applicant herein. He further submitted that, Union of India has
preferred appeal against the order in OA No.276/2016, wherein P.C. Vinod
was the applicant, as OP(CAT).No. 141/2017 before this Court and it was
dismissed.
15.
Upon hearing the submissions of both sides and on
perusal of paper book, we are of the view that the withdrawal of financial
upgradation under the ACP Scheme by the department, that too, without
affording an opportunity of being heard in violation of the principles of
natural justice and the same is illegal, unjust and improper. So also, the
respondents have withheld the pensionary benefits to the tune of
Rs.11,07,332/- ignoring the dictum laid down in Rafiq Masih’s case
(supra).
16.
We have already considered the similar issue in
OP(CAT) No.141/2017. The relevant paragraphs of the said judgment are
extracted hereunder:
“6. Noticing the rival contentions of the parties,
the Central Administrative Tribunal allowed the claim of the
applicant in the following manner:
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
“16 The PAO office was in existence when
this benefit was extended to the beneficiaries in 2007
and having slept over the matter cannot raise
objection at a later date. At the fag end of their career
when applicants are faced with more responsibilities
on account of family commitments, health, retirement
etc, the PAO awakes from its slumber in January 2016
and orders a recovery on account of overpayment,
when the applicant has been enjoying the benefit
since 9.8.1999 (1st A.C.P) and 16.3.2007 (2 ACP). The
Courts including the Apex Court have on several
occasions held that a person who has been sleeping
over his rights is not entitled to relief sought. On a
similar analogy, the PAO who had been sleeping over
the overpayment, cannot now wake up and order
recovery after eight years of payment, when the
applicant is to retire in October 2016. This is also not
a case where the office of PAO was not in existence in
2007 when the benefit was extended. However. PAO
authorised to order recovery after eight years in 2016.
Applicant also brings to our notice that as per Apex
Court order in C.A 11527/2014 State of Punjab &
Others v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) reported
in 2015 (1) KLT 429 (SC) while summarizing the
situations wherein recoveries by employers would be
impermissible in law had ordered as follows:"12 (ii) Recovery from retired employees, or
employees who are due to retire within one year of
the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of five
years, before the order of recovery is issued."
Under both 12(ii) and (iii) of the Apex Court orders
cited above, the recovery from the applicants is inadmissible.
This is also a case which is covered by the dictum cited at para
12(v) that the recovery made from the employee would be
iniquitous and harsh and arbitrary to such an extent, as would
far outweigh the equitable balance of the respondents' right to
recover. The case of applicant falls under three categories
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
delineated by the Apex Court as non-recoverable and hence
Annexure A-1 order is quashed to that extent.
17.
The original application is allowed.
7.
Before us, the contention of the
petitioners is that the payment to the applicant was made
conditionally and therefore, the dictum laid down in State of
Punjab and others v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer)
and others [(2015) 4 SCC 334] would not apply to the
facts of the instant case.
8.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the
respondent/applicant would submit that the ratio decidendi
in the decision in Rafiq Masih’s case (supra) is
consequentially applicable to the facts of the instant case. In
Rafiq Masih’s case (supra), the Honourable Apex Court
opined that, recovery of an amount paid to an employee in
excess without any fault of the recipient is impermissible. It
may be useful to refer to the relevant portion of the Rafiq
Masih’s case (supra) which reads thus:
“ 7. Having examined a number of judgments
rendered by this Court, we are of the view, that orders
passed by the employer seeking recovery of monetary
benefits wrongly extended to the employees, can only be
interfered with, in cases where such recovery would
result in a hardship of a nature, which would far
outweigh, the equitable balance of the employer's right to
recover. In other words, Interference would be called for,
only in such cases where, it would be iniquitous to
recover the payment made. In order to ascertain the
parameters of the above consideration, and the test to be
applied, reference needs to be made to situations when
this Court exempted employees from such recovery, even
in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 142 of the
Constitution of India. Repeated exercise of such power,
"for doing complete justice in any cause" would establish
that the recovery being effected was iniquitous, and
therefore, arbitrary. And accordingly, the interference at
the hands of this Court.
8. As between two parties, if a determination
is rendered in favour of the party, which is the weaker of
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
the two, without any serious detriment to the other
(which is truly a welfare State), the issue resolved would
be in consonance with the concept of justice, which is
assured to the citizens of India, even in the Preamble of
the Constitution of India. The right to recover being
pursued by the employer, will have to be compared, with
the effect of the recovery on the employee concerned. If
the effect of the recovery from the employee concerned
would be, more unfair, more wrongful, more improper,
and more unwarranted, than the corresponding right of
the employer to recover the amount, then it would be
iniquitous and arbitrary, to effect the recovery. In such a
situation, the employee's right would outbalance, and
therefore eclipse, the right of the employer to recover.
9. The doctrine of equality is a dynamic and
evolving concept having many dimensions. The
embodiment of the doctrine of equality can be found in
Articles 14 to 18 contained in Part III of the Constitution
of India, dealing with "fundamental rights". These
articles of the Constitution, besides assuring equality
before the law and equal protection of the laws, also
disallow discrimination with the object of achieving
equality,
in
matters
of
employment;
abolish
untouchability, to upgrade the social status of an
ostracised section of the society; and extinguish titles, to
scale down the status of a section of the society, with such
appellations. The embodiment of the doctrine of equality,
can also be found in Articles 38, 39, 39-A, 43 and 46
contained in Part IV of the Constitution of India, dealing
with the "directive principles of State policy". These
articles of the Constitution of India contain a mandate to
the State requiring it to assure a social order providing
justice-social, economic and political, by inter alia
minimising monetary inequalities, and by securing the
right to adequate means of livelihood, and by providing
for adequate wages so as to ensure, an appropriate
standard of life, and by promoting economic interests of
the weaker sections.
10. In view of the aforestated constitutional
mandate, equity and good conscience in the matter of
livelihood of the people of this country has to be the basis
of all governmental actions. An action of the State,
ordering a recovery from an employee, would be in
order, so long as it is not rendered iniquitous to the extent
that the action of recovery would be more unfair, more
wrongful, more improper, and more unwarranted, than
the corresponding right of the employer, to recover the
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
amount. Or in other words, till such time as the recovery
would have a harsh and arbitrary effect on the employee,
it would be permissible in law. Orders passed in given
situations repeatedly, even in exercise of the power vested
in this Court under Article 142 of the Constitution of
India, will disclose the parameters of the realm of an
action of recovery (of an excess amount paid to an
employee) which would breach the obligations of the
State, to citizens of this country, and render the action
arbitrary, and therefore, violative of the mandate
contained in Article 14 of the Constitution of India.”
17.
Now coming back to the instant case, on perusal of the
order of the Central Administrative Tribunal, it could be seen that the
Tribunal has only considered the issue with regard to the third MACP alone,
but left out two other important issues relating to the withdrawal of
financial upgradation under the ACP Scheme and the recovery of benefits
already conferred on the applicant. We are unable to fathom why the
Tribunal has missed out the vital part of the claim.
18.
On a careful evaluation of the materials on record, we
are of the view that, the impugned order of the Tribunal is legally
unsustainable. We, therefore, hold that, Annexures-A16, A19, A33 and A37
of the respondents are illegal and invalid and liable to be set aside.
Unilateral withdrawal of the benefits under the ACP Scheme and
consequential
withholding
of
pensionary
benefits
are
illegal
and
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
unsustainable. We are of the view that the denial of the MACP to the
applicant is also not justifiable.
In the light of the above discussion, we are of the considered
opinion that the impugned order of the Central Administrative Tribunal is
liable to be set aside. O.A is allowed. Consequently, OP(CAT) No.238/2019
filed by the applicant is allowed. OP(CAT) No.244/2019 filed by the Union
of India is dismissed. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case,
we are of the view that the applicant is entitled to interest @7% per annum
for the amount of Rs.11,07,332/-, the retiral benefits withheld by the
respondents. The respondents/Union of India shall comply this direction as
expeditiously as possible, but not later than two months, from the date of
receipt of a copy of this judgment.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/-
K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
Sbna/
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 238/2019
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P-1
Exhibit P1 (A6)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-16)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-19)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-33)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-37)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-1)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-2)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-3)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-4)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-5)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-7)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-8)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-9)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-10)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-11)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-12)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-13)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-14)
TRUE COPY OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION
NO.1123/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE HON'BLE CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.13/94 DATED
7.4.1994.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
NO.PAO/ALHW/PENSION/2013/1406-07 DATED
10/12.2.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.220/2014 DATED
19.4.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO. PD-25021/2012MP(ALHW) DATD 26.9.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. ALHW/CR/12(1)/2013/888
DATED 26/27.3.2015 OF THE 3RD RESPONDENT ISSUED
TO THE APPLICANT
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO. 210/76 DATED
21.10.1976
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. 168/5806 DATED
30.8.1979
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMORANDUM NO.LHW/1026/7407
DATED 21.11.1979
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO. 706/93 DATED
20.8.1993
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO. 403/94 DATED
28.3.1994
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO. 975/96 DATED
7/8TH NOVEMBER, 1996
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.409/97 DATED 22ND
OCTOBER, 1997
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO. 230/2002 DATED
18.3.2002
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 7.8.2003 BY THE
APPLICANT
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO. 623 OF 2007
DATED 20.8.2007
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. A-12023/1/2004-PE II
DATED 9TH NOVEMBER 2007
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO. 116 OF 2008
DATED 16/17.9.2008
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO. 626/2008 DATED
16/17.9.2008
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
EXHIBIT P-1(A-15)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-17)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-18)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-20)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-21)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-22)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-23)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-24)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-25)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-26)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-27)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-28)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-29)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-30)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-31)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-32)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-34)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-35)
EXHIBIT P-1(A-36)
EXHIBIT P-2
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO. 792/2010 DATED
13.12.2010
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 21.3.2014
TOGETHER WITH THE PENSION CALCULATION IN RESPECT
OF T.P. SAYED MOHAMMED AND SHRI. R.SUBRAMANIAM
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 2.4.2014 FROM THE
APPLICANT ADDRESSED TO THE 1ST RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF THE PAY SLIP OF THE APPLICANT FOR
THE MONTH OF APRIL 2014
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 8.5.2014 ADDRESSED
TO THE 3RD RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 12.5.2014 FROM THE
3RD RESPONDENT TO THE 1ST RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
DCE/KVT/ESTT/PENSION/1767/1678 DATED 4TH JUNE
2014 FROM THE OFFICE OF THE 3RD RESPONDENT TO PAO
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATION DATED
10.7.2014 ADDRESSED TO THE 1ST RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
DCE/KVT/ESTT/PENSION/1504/2080 DATED 19.7.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
DCE/KVT/ESTT/PENSION/1504/2179 DATED 31.7.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO. PAO/GPF/ID-408/606-07
DATED 11.7.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO. 11/2014/V.
PRAKASHAN/88100400127/1036 DATED 21.8.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 20.9.2014 OF THE
APPLICANT
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 5.12.2014 OF THE
APPLICANT
TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION CALCULATION SHEET OF THE
APPLICANT
TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION CALCULATION SHEET OF THE
APPLICANT
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. ALHW/CR/12(1)/2013/64
DATED 30.12.2014 OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER,
OFFICE OF THE 3RD RESPONDENT ISSUED TO THE 4TH
RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THIS HON'BLE TRIBUNAL
DATED 22.1.2015 RENDERED IN OA NO. 180/01123/2014
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 27.1.2015
SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT BEFORE THE 3RD
RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT FILED BY THE 3RD
RESPONDENT IN OA 1123/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE
HON'BLE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
ERNAKULAM BENCH
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
EXHIBIT P-2 (R-1)
EXHIBIT P-3
EXHIBIT P-3 (A-38)
EXHIBIT P-3 (A-39(A)
EXHIBIT P-3 (A-39(B)
EXHIBIT P-3 (A-39(C)
EXHIBIT P-3 (A-40)
EXHIBIT P-4
EXHIBIT P-4 (R2)
EXHIBIT P-4 (R3)
EXHIBIT P-4 (R4)
EXHIBIT P-5
EXHIBIT P-5(A-41)
EXHIBIT P-5(A-42)
EXHIBIT P-5(A-43)
EXHIBIT P-6
EXHIBIT P-6 (R5)
EXHIBIT P-6 (R6)
EXHIBIT P-6 (R7)
EXHIBIT P-6 (R8)
EXHIBIT P-6 (R9)
EXHIBIT P-6 (R10)
EXHIBIT P-7
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO. PD-25021/5/2014-MP
DATED 30.4.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER FILED BY THE
PETITIONER IN HIS CAPACITY AS THE APPLICANT IN OA
1123/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE HON'BLE CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
TRUE COPY OF THE STATEMENT
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 4.1.2013
TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER DATED
26.9.2013
TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER DATED
26.9.2013
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 3.11.2015
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY FILED BY THE RESPONDENT TO
THE REJOINDER FILED BY THE APPLICANT
TRUE COPY OF OFFICE ORDER BEARING NO. 838/2007
DATED 15.11.2007
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO. A-12023/1/2004-PE.II
DATED 7.11.2007
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO. PD-25021/5/2014-MP DATED
30.4.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REJOINDER FILED BY
THE APPLICANT IN OA 1123/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE
HON'BLE CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER UNDER THE RTI ACT SENT BY
THE APPLICANT DATED 5.8.2016
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 20.8.2016 FROM THE
4TH RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF THE OM DATED 2.3.2016
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF THE
RESPONDENTS TO THE ADDITIONAL REJOINDER FILED BY
THE APPLICANT
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
ALHW/ADM/2(19)/2013/1512 DATED 28.5.2015
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
ALHW/GENL/5(2)/2016/2853 DATED 18.10.2016
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO. A.12023/1/2004-PE.II
DATED 7.11.2007 OF MINISTRY OF SHIPPING,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
TRUE COPY OF ORDER JO.838/2007 DATED 15.11.2007
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO. PD-25021/5/2014-MP DATED
30.4.2014
TRUE COPY OF MINISTRY OF SHIPPING LETTER DATED
28.9.2004
TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER TO THE EXHIBIT P-6
REPLY FILE BY THE RESPONDENTS
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
EXHIBIT P-7 (A-44)
EXHIBIT P-7 (A-45)
EXHIBIT P-7 (A-46)
EXHIBIT P-8
EXHIBIT P-8 (R11)
EXHIBIT P-8 (R12)
EXHIBIT P-9
EXHIBIT P-10
EXHIBIT P-10 (R13)
EXHIBIT P-10 (R14)
EXHIBIT P-10 (R15)
EXHIBIT P-10 (R16)
EXHIBIT P-10 (R17)
EXHIBIT P-10 (R18)
EXHIBIT P-11
EXHIBIT P-12
EXHIBIT P-12 (RA-1)
EXHIBIT P-13
EXHIBIT P-14
EXHIBIT P-14 (RA-1)
TRUE COPY OF THE FIXATION STATEMENT ORDER DATED
17.7.2008
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF MINISTRY DATED
15.9.2008
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE MEMORANDUM
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REPLY STATEMENT FILED
ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS TO THE EXHIBIT P-7
ADDITIONAL REJOINDER FILED BY THE APPLICANT
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO. DCE/MECH/PF-307/1040
DATED 5/6.5.2015
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.DCE/MECH/E-36/2282
DATED 27/28.10.2016
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REJOINDER TO THE
EXHIBIT P-8 ADDITIONAL REPLY STATEMENT FILED BY
THE RESPONDENTS
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REPLY FILED BY THE
RESPONDENTS TO THE EXHIBIT P-9 ADDITIONAL
REJOINDER
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
ALHW/ADM/2(19)/2013/916 DATED 30.3.15
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
NO.ALHW/ADM/2(19)/2013/1512 DATED 29.5.15
TRUE COPY OF THE REMINDER DATED 2.8.2017
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER OF PAY AND ACCOUNTS
OFFICER (ALHW) BEARING NO.
PAO/ALHW/PENSION/2013/1406-07 DATED 12.2.2014
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.662/2008 DATED
19.9.2008
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
PAO/ALHW/C.E/PENSION/2015-16/72-75 DATED 14.5.15
OF THE PAO (ALHW)
TRUE COPY OF THE FINAL ORDER DATED 24.12.2018 IN
OA 1123/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE HON'BLE CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
TRUE COPY OF THE RA 4/2019 IN OA 1123/2014 ON THE
FILE OF THE HON'BLE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 24.12.2018 IN OA
1123/2014
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT FILED ON BEHALF
OF RESPONDENTS IN RA 4/19 ON THE FILE OF THE
HON'BLE CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH
TRUE COPY OF THE REVIEW PETITION NO. RA 14/2019
FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS IN OA 1123/2014 ON THE
FILE OF THE HON'BLE CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 24.12.2018 OF THE
HON'BLE TRIBUNAL IN OA 1123/2014
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
EXHIBIT P-15
EXHIBIT P-16
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 10.4.2019 IN RA
4/2019 IN OA 1123/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE HON'BLE
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED10.4.2019 IN RA
14/2019 IN OA 1123/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE
HON'BLE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,ERNAKULAM
BENCH
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 244/2019
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
EXHIBIT P1(A16)
EXHIBIT P1(A19)
Exhibit P3(A-1)
EXHIBIT P3(A-4)
EXHIBIT P1(A33)
EXHIBIT P1(A37)
EXHIBIT P1(A1)
EXHIBIT P1(A2)
EXHIBIT P1(A3)
EXHIBIT P1(A4)
EXHIBIT P1(A5)
EXHIBIT P1(A6)
EXHIBIT P1(A7)
EXHIBIT P1(A8)
EXHIBIT P1(A9)
EXHIBIT P1(A10)
EXHIBIT P1(A11)
EXHIBIT P1(A12)
TRUE COPY OF THE AMENDED ORIGINAL APPLICATION
NO.180/01123/2014 WITH ANNEXURES (PAGES 11135).
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
NO.PAO/ALHW/PENSION/2013/1406-07 DATED
10/12.2.2014.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.220/2014
DATED 19.4.2014.
TRUE COPY OF THE STATEMENT
TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER DATED
26.9.2013.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.PD-25021/2012-MP
(ALHW) DATED 26.9.2014.
TRUE COPY OF ORDER, BEARING
NO.ALHW/CR/Q12(1)/2013/888 DATED 26/27.3.2015
OF THE 3RD RESPONDENT ISSUED TO THE APPLICANT.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.210/76 DATED
21ST OCTOBER, 1976.
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.168/5809, DATED
30.8.1979.
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMORANDUM NO.LHW/1026/7407
DATED 21.11.1979.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.706/93 DATED
20.8.1993.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.403/94 DATED
28.3.1994.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.13/94 DATED
7.4.1994.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.975/96 DATED
7/8.11.19996.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.409/97 DATED
22.10.1997.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.230/2002
DATED 18.3.2002.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 7.8.2003 BY THE
APPLICANT.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFCE ORDER NO.623/2007 DATED
20.8.2007.
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.A-12023/1/2004-PE II
DATED 9.11.2007.
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
EXHIBIT P1(A13)
EXHIBIT P1(A14)
EXHIBIT P1(A15)
EXHIBIT P1(A17)
EXHIBIT P1(A18)
EXHIBIT P1(A20)
EXHIBIT P1(A21)
EXHIBIT P1(A22)
EXHIBIT P1(A23)
EXHIBIT P1(A24)
EXHIBIT P1(A25)
EXHIBIT P1(A26)
EXHIBIT P1(A27)
EXHIBIT P1(A28)
EXHIBIT P1(A29)
EXHIBIT P1(A30)
EXHIBIT P1(A31)
EXHIBIT P1(A32)
EXHIBIT P1(A34)
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.116/2008
DATED 26/27.2.2008.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.626/2008
DATED 16/17.9.2008.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.792/2010
DATED 13.12.2010.
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
21.3.2014 TOGETHER WITH THE PENSION
CALCULATION IN RESPECT OF T.P.SAYED MOHAMMED
AND SHRI R. SUBRAMANIAM.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 2.4.2014 FROM
THE APPLICANT ADDRESSED TO FIRST RESPONDENT.
TRUE COPY OF THE PAY SLIP OF THE APPLICATION
FOR THE MONTH OF APRIL, 2014.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 8.5.2014
ADDRESSED TO THE THIRD RESPONDENT.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 12.5.2014 FROM
THE THIRD RESPONDENT TO THE FIRST RESPONDENT.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
NO.DCE/KVT/EST/PENSION/1767/1678 DATED
4.6.2014 FROM OFFICE OF THIRD RESPONDENT TO
PAO.
TRUE COPY OF APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATION DATED
10.7.2014, ADDRESSED TO THE FIRST RESPONDENT.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
NO.DCE/KVT/ESTT/PENSION/1504/2080 DATED
19.7.2014.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER
NO.DCE/KVT/ESTT/PENSION/1504/2179 DATED
31.7.2014.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.PAO/GPF/1D-408/606-07
DATED 11.7.2014.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER
NO.11/2014/V.PRAKASAN/88100400127/1036 DATED
21.8.2014.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 20.9.2014 OF THE
APPLICANT.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 5.12.2014 OF THE
APPLICANT.
TRUE COPY OF PENSION CALCULATION SHEET OF THE
APPLICANT.
TRUE COPY OF PENSION CALCULATION SHEET OF THE
APPLICANT.
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.ALHW/CR/12(1)/2013/64
DATED 30.12.2014 OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
EXHIBIT P1(A35)
EXHIBIT P1(A36)
EXHIBIT P2
EXHIBIT P2(A1)
EXHIBIT P3
EXHIBIT P3(A-2)
EXHIBIT P3 (A-3)
EXHIBIT P3(A-40)
EXHIBIT P3 (A-5)
EXHIBIT P4
EXHIBIT-P4(A-1)
EXHIBIT P4(A-2)
EXHIBIT P4(A-3)
EXHIBIT P5
EXHIBIT P5(A-1)
EXHIBIT P5(A-2)
EXHIBIT P5(A-3)
EXHIBIT P6
EXHIBIT P6(A1)
EXHIBIT P6(A2)
EXHIBIT P6(A3)
OFFICER, OFFICE OF THE 3RD RESPONDENT ISSUED
TO THE 4TH RESPONDENT.
TRUE COPY OF ORDER OF THIS HON'BLE TRIBUNAL,
DATED 22.1.2015 RENDERED IN
O.A.NO.180/01123/2014.
TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED 27.1.2015
SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT BEFORE THE 3RD
RESPONDENT.
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT IN
O.A.NO.180/01123/2014, DATED 11.1.2016 FILED
BY THE PETITIONERS.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.PD-25021/5/2014-MP
DATED 30.4.2014.
TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER DATED 18.3.2016
FILED BY THE RESPONDENT HEREIN IN OA
NO.180/01123/2014.
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 4.1.2013.
TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER DATED
26.9.2013.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 3.11.2015.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 3.11.2015.
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY TO THE REJOINDER, THE
PETITIONERS HEREIN FILED ADDL. REPLY DATED
27.5.2016.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER BEARING
NO.838/2007 DATED 15.11.2007.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.A-12023/1/2004-PE.II
DATED 7.11.2007.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.PD-25021/5/2014-MP
DATED 30.4.2014.
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REJOINDER DATED
20.11.2016 FILED BY THE RESPONDENT.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER UNDER THE RTI ACT SENT
BY THE APPLICANT DATED 5.8.2016.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 20.8.2016 FROM
THE 4TH PETITIONER (4TH RESPONDENT IN OA).
TRUE COPY OF THE O.M DATED 2.3.2016.
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY TO THE ADDITIONAL
REJOINDER DATED 7.2.2017.
TRUE COPY FO LETTER
NO.ALHW/ADM/2(19)/2013/1512 DATED 28.5.2015.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER
NO.ALHW/GENL/5(2)/2016/2853 DATED 18.10.2016.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.A.12023/1/2004-PE II
DATED 7.11.2007 OF MINISTRY OF SHIPPING, GOVT.
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
EXHIBIT P6(A4)
EXHIBIT P6(A5)
EXHIBIT P7
EXHIBIT P7(A1)
EXHIBIT P7(A2)
EXHIBIT P7(A3)
EXHIBIT P8
EXHIBIT P8(A1)
EXHIBIT P8(A2)
EXHIBIT P9
EXHIBIT P10
EXHIBIT P10(A1)
EXHIBIT P10(A2)
EXHIBIT P10(A3)
EXHIBIT P10(A4)
EXHIBIT P10(A5)
EXHIBIT P10(A6)
EXHIBIT P11
EXHIBIT P12
EXHIBIT P12(RA-1)
OF INDIA.
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.838/2007 DATED
15.11.2007.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.PD-25021/5/2014-MP
DATED 30.4.2014.
TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER DATED 27.3.2017
FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS/APPLICANTS IN O.A.
TRUE COPY OF THE FIXATION STATEMENT ORDER
DATED 17.7.2008.
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF MINISTRY DATED
15.9.2008.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE MEMORANDUM.
TRUE COPY OF ADDITIONAL REPLY DATED 15.6.2017.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.DCE/MECH/PF-307/1040
DATED 5.6.2015.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.DCE/MECH/E-36/2282
DATED 27/28.10.2016.
TRUE COPY OF ADDITIONAL REPLY STATEMENT DATED
15.7.2017 FILED BY PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS IN
OA
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REPLY STATEMENT
DATED 5.8.2017 FILED BY
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS IN OA.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.ALHW/ADM/2(19)/2013/916
DATED 30.3.2015.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
NO.ALHW/ADM/2(19)/2013/1512 DATED 29.5.2015.
TRUE COPY OF LETTER
NO.ALHW/ADM/2(1)/2014/VOL.III/2300 DATED
2.8.2017.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER OF PAY AND ACCOUNTS
OFFICER (ALHW) BEARING
NO.PAO/ALHW/PENSION/2013/1406-07 DATED
12.2.2014.
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE ORDER NO.662/2008
DATED 19.9.2008.
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
NO.PAO/ALHW/C.E/PENSION/2015-16/72-75 DATED
14.5.2015 OF THE PAO, (ALHW).
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN OA 180/01123/2014,
DATED 24.12.2018.
TRUE COPY OF THE REVIEW APPLICATION NO.4/2019
FILED BY THE RESPONDENT.
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 24.12.2018 IN OA
180/01123/2014.
OP(CAT) Nos.238 & 244 of 2019
2025:KER:15173
EXHIBIT P13
EXHIBIT P14
EXHIBIT P14(RA-1)
EXHIBIT P15
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN REVIEW APPLICATION
NO.4/2019.
TRUE COPY OF THE REVIEW APPLICATION 14/2019
FILED BY THE PETITIONERS (RESPONDENTS IN OA).
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 24.12.2018 OF THE
HON'BLE TRIBUNAL IN OA 180/01123/22014 FILED
BY THE PETITIONERS.
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN REVIEW APPLICATION
14/2019.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review