Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) NO.171 OF 2023
Uttam Kumar Acharya,
Son of Late Gouranga Ch. Acharya,
Resident of Village-Chowmuhani Bazar,
P.O- Suryamaninagar, P.S- Amtali,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799130.
...................Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the
Commissioner & Secretary to the
Finance Department(Taxes & Excise),
Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division- Sadar, District- West Tripura.
2. The Commissioner & Secretary,
Social Welfare & Social Education Department,
Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Sub- Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura.
3. The Commissioner of Taxes,
Finance Department(Taxes & Excise),
Government of Tripura,
3rd Floor, Khadya Bhavan, Pandit Nehru Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
PO- Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Sub- Division-Sadar, District- West Tripura.
4. The Additional Commissioner,
Finance Department(Taxes & Excise),
Government of Tripura,
3rd Floor, Khadya Bhavan,
Pandit Nehru Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
PO- Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District- West Tripura.
5. The Director,
Social Welfare and Social Education Department,
Government of Tripura,
Malacha, Ujan Abhoynagar,
Sub-Division- Sadar, District- West Tripura.
..................Respondents
For the petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. Koomar Chakraborty, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
Date of delivery of judgment
& order
:
:
Mr. D.C. Saha, Advocate
06.12.2023
:
22.03.2024
:
Yes
[
Whether fit for reporting
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The issue falls for consideration in the instant writ petition is
whether the pay of the petitioner should be protected counting his past service
rendered by him with effect from 21.02.2005 to 21.10.2013 in the former post of
Supervisor(ICDS) under the Social Welfare & Social Education Department,
Government of Tripura, pursuant to his subsequent appointment to the post of
Inspector of Taxes, Finance Department(Taxes & Excise), Government of
Tripura.
2.
Before delving into the above issue, the facts not in dispute and
relevant for appreciating the grounds urged in this writ petition are being noted
at the outset.
2.1.
Initially,
the
petitioner
was
appointed
to
the
post
of
Supervisor(ICDS) on 21.02.2005 under the Directorate of Social Welfare &
Social Education Department(SW&SE Department, in short), Government of
Tripura on regular basis with monthly pay of Rs.4,200/- in the pay scale of
Rs.4,200-120-6,000-130-7,300-150-8,650/- and on such appointment he
continued to serve under the SW&SE Department in different places of posting
as Supervisor(ICDS) till the year 2012.
2.2.
In the year 2012, while he was posted in the office of the Child
Development
Project
Officer(CDPO),
Melaghar
ICDS
Projects,
an
advertisement vide No.01/2012 dated 01.01.2012(Annexure 2 to the writ
petition) with a subsequent addendum thereto came to be published at the
instance of the Tripura Public Service Commission(TPSC, in short) for selection
of candidates through Combined Competitive Examination for filling up the
vacant Miscellaneous Posts under different Government Departments of the
State of Tripura.
2.3.
Pursuant to the said advertisement, the petitioner submitted his
application to the Director, SW&SE Department through CDPO, Melaghar
ICDS Projects praying for granting him permission to participate in the
Combined Competitive Examination to be conducted by the TPSC, thereby
requesting to issue „No Objection Certificate‟ for appearing in the above
mentioned examination.
2.4.
In
response
thereto,
the
Director,
SW&SE
Department,
Government of Tripura vide letter dated 10.04.2012(Annexure-4 to the writ
petition) forwarded the application of the petitioner to the Secretary, TPSC
according permission to the petitioner to appear in the said Combined
Competitive Examination and accordingly, the petitioner had participated in the
selection process.
2.5.
Thereafter, being found the petitioner successful in the competitive
examination, the Under Secretary, TPSC vide a communication dated
15.06.2013(Annexure-5 to the writ petition) informed the petitioner that his
name has been recommended to the GA(P&T) Department(Nodal Department)
for taking further necessary steps for his appointment to the post of Inspector of
Taxes.
2.6.
Subsequently, the Commissioner of Taxes, Finance Department
(Taxes and Excise), Government of Tripura vide Memo. dated 23.09.2013
issued offer-of-appointment in favour of the petitioner for the post of Inspector
of Taxes(Group-C, Non-Gazetted) having pay scale of Rs.5,310-24,000/-(PB-2),
Grade Pay Rs.2,400/-(Annexure-6 to the writ petition) with certain terms and
conditions as mentioned in the offer-of-appointment.
2.7.
On his acceptance of such terms and conditions as specified in the
offer-of-appointment, the Commissioner of Taxes, Finance Department(Taxes &
Excise), vide order dated 07.10.2013(Annexure-7 to the writ petition) appointed
the petitioner to the post of Inspector of Taxes.
2.8.
In pursuance of the issuance of the said order of appointment, the
petitioner tendered his „technical resignation‟ dated 08.10.2013 (Annexure 8 to
the writ petition) to the Director, SW&SE with a prayer for transfer of his
service from the SW&SE Department to Taxes and Excise Department and to
release him with lien benefits.
2.9.
Thereafter, vide letter dated 21.10.2013, the Director, SW&SE
Department, accepting the technical resignation released him from the SW&SE
Department with effect from the afternoon of 21.10.2013 to join to his new post
as Inspector of Taxes in the office of the Commissioner, Taxes & Excise, and
accordingly on the same day in the afternoon the petitioner joined to the post of
Inspector of Taxes under the Finance Department(Taxes and Excise),
Government of Tripura.
2.10.
Subsequent
thereto,
the
Child
Development
Project
Officer(CDPO), Melaghar ICDS Projects vide its communication dated
15.11.2013(Annexure 10 to the writ petition) duly forwarded the Last Pay
Certificate(LPC) of the petitioner addressed to the Commissioner of Taxes &
Excise stating therein his last basic pay as Rs.12,340/-.
However, on joining to the post of Inspector of Taxes, the petitioner
came to know that his initial Basic Pay in the post of Inspector of Taxes has
been fixed at Rs.11,700/- per month, in the pay scale of Rs.5,310-24,000/-(PB-2)
having Grade Pay of Rs.2,400/-, which is lower than the Last Basic Pay he was
drawing while serving in his previous employment.
2.11.
Having noticed that his Basic Pay has been fixed at Rs.11,700/-,
the petitioner had submitted representation dated 08.06.2016(Annexure 11 to the
writ petition) to the Commissioner of Taxes praying for pay protection and also
for fixation of his pay taking into account his past service rendered by him in his
previous employment.
2.12.
In
response
to
his
representation
dated
08.06.2016,
the
Commissioner of Taxes, Government of Tripura vide order dated 18.08.2016
(Annexure 12 to the writ petition) informed him that the Finance Department,
Government of Tripura, concurred his prayer for counting his past service
rendered under the SW&SE Department during the period from 21.02.2005 to
21.10.2013 only for the purpose of pension and pensionary benefits and
accordingly his pay was fixed at Rs.11,700/- as per initial pay of the post of
Inspector of Taxes w.e.f. 21.10.2013.
It is the grievance of the petitioner that the order dated 18.08.2016
was silent in regard to pay protection he was entitled to, since on being selected
he tendered his „technical resignation‟, which was accepted by his previous
employer granting lien benefit.
2.13.
Being aggrieved by the decision of the respondents the petitioner
submitted another representation dated 08.08.2022(Annexure 13 to the writ
petition) inter alia reiterating his earlier prayer for granting pay protection and
the said representation was also disposed of by the Commissioner of Taxes vide
impugned Memo. dated 20.10.2022(Annexure 14 to the writ petition) reiterating
their stand and thus disallowed his prayer for pay protection.
2.14.
The petitioner being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the decision
of the respondents filed the present writ petition in the year 2023 under Article
226 of the Constitution of India inter alia praying for the following relief(s):
“(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, quashing/setting aside the impugned Order dated 18.08.2016 & the
impugned Memorandum dated 20.10.2022(Annexure-12 & 14 respectively supra);
(ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show cause
as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued,
mandating/directing them, to forthwith revoke/rescind the impugned Order dated
18.08.2016 & the impugned Memorandum dated 20.10.2012(Annexure-12 & 14
respectively supra);
(iii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them, to forthwith count the past services, as
rendered by the Petitioner in the former post of Supervisor(ICDS), under the
Social Welfare & Social Education Department, Government of Tripura(i.e. w.e.f.
21.02.2005 to 21.10.2013), for the purpose of pay protection as well as for
pension & other pensionary benefits, pursuant to his subsequent appointment to
the post of Inspector of Taxes, Finance Department(Taxes & Excise), Government
of Tripura, and thereupon, & to fix his initial pay in the said post of Inspector of
Taxes, Finance Department(Taxes & Excise), Government of Tripura(i.e., w.e.f.
21.10.2013), at par with his last Basic pay of Rs.12,340/-[as drawn in the said
former post of Supervisor(ICDS) including one increment and Grade PayRs.2,400/-, alongwith all consequential benefits, including arrears thereof;
..............”
3.
On the aforementioned background facts, I have heard Mr. Samarjit
Bhattacharjee and Mr. K. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner as well as Mr. D.C. Saha, learned State counsel appearing for the
respondents.
4.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner at
the very outset argued that the Last Pay Certificate(„LPC‟ for short) issued in
respect of the petitioner by the CDPO, Melaghar ICDS Projects clearly
stipulates that prior to his joining to the post of Inspector of Taxes i.e. as on
21.10.2013, his last basic pay was Rs.12,340/- per month, but, though on his
joining to his subsequent employment through a process of selection, on being
permitted by his previous employer and on acceptance of his technical
resignation, the Commissioner of Taxes, Government of Tripura most arbitrarily
without protecting his pay counting his past service, had fixed his basic pay at
Rs.11,700/- per month, which is lesser than the last basic pay of his previous
employment under the respondent no.5. In view of the above, it was strenuously
argued by Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel that the respondents ought to have
considered his past service and after protecting his last basic pay ought to have
fixed his initial Basic Pay in his subsequent employment, as the petitioner prior
to applying for the post of Inspector of Taxes, had obtained due permission
and/or „No objection‟ from the competent authority of the SW&SE Department
for participating in the competitive examination. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned
counsel further submitted that in the release order issued by his previous
employer it has been clearly stated that the technical resignation tendered by the
petitioner has been accepted by the respondents and the petitioner has been
allowed to join to his new post under Finance Department(Taxes and Excise),
Government of Tripura, which automatically entitles him to get pay protection
and fixation of pay at par with his last basic pay of Rs.12,340/-.
4.1.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the petitioner referring to the
departmental note received through RTI issued by the Finance Department dated
11.11.2022(Annexure 15 to the writ petition), contended that nowhere in the
contents of the note it was suggested that the Finance Department had ever
opined that the pay of the petitioner would be fixed as per initial pay of the post
of Inspector of Taxes. Rather the note automatically connotes that the Finance
Department accorded pay protection of the petitioner, as otherwise it would have
no implication in the pension and pensionary benefits.
4.2.
Learned counsel relying upon to Clause (6) of the „Master Circular‟
vis-a-vis „guidelines/instructions‟ circulated through Office Memorandum vide
No.28020/2/2018-dated 27.08.2018(Annexure 16 to the writ petition) issued by
the Under Secretary, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions
(Department of Personnel & Training), Government of India, contended that in
terms of the Fundamental Rules, if a Government servant is subsequently
appointed to another post(on acceptance of technical resignation), pay protection
would be given to him i.e. in case his pay fixed in the new post is less than his
pay in the post he holds substantively, he will be entitled to draw the
presumptive pay of the post he holds substantively.
4.3.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel relied upon the judgment of a
coordinate Bench of this court dated 06.01.2021 passed in WP(C) No.234 of
2020 titled as Tarendra Reang & Ors. vs. The State of Tripura & Ors. and
contended that the coordinate Bench of this Court had an occasion to observe
that the entire past service of government servants shall be protected for the
purpose of pay and allowances and post retiral benefits, in the case of their
appointment to new posts. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel referring to the
observation made in the judgment referred to supra argued with vehemence that
it is impossible to protect the pension of a government servant without
protecting his pay.
4.4.
The next argument advanced by Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned
counsel was that in a similar circumstance the respondents granted the benefit of
pay protection and increment vide order dated 12.08.2008 (Annexure 17 to the
writ petition) to one Sri Ashis Kr. Sarkar who was previously holding the post of
Upper Division Clerk in the Department of Fisheries, Government of Tripura
and on his subsequent appointment to the post of Inspector of Taxes, since it
was noticed that his basic pay in the latter post was lesser than what he was
entitled to draw earlier in the former post, the Government of Tripura had fixed
his existing pay scale by giving him the next increment.
Arguing the above points, learned counsel for the petitioner prayed
for directing the respondents to count the past service of the petitioner for the
purpose of pay protection and to fix his initial pay at par with his last basic pay
of Rs.12,340/-including one increment.
5.
Per contra, Mr. Saha, learned State counsel disputing the
contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner in regard to the „Master
Circular‟(Annexure 16) communicated by the Ministry of Personal, Public
Grievances & Pension(Department of Personal & Training), Government of
India, argued that the said circular was issued by the concerned department of
the Government of India, which is applicable for the employees of the Central
Government and no such instruction regarding applicability of such circular in
respect of the employees of the State Government was/is issued so far to follow
the same. It was further asserted that the petitioner did not produce/adduce any
record or document from which it can be ascertained that the above Master
Circular is applicable for the employees serving under the State Government.
5.1.
The next argument advanced by Mr. Saha, learned counsel was that
the petitioner joined in his subsequent employment through a process of
selection against a post which was filled up through direct recruitment
conducted by the TPSC following the provisions of the recruitment rules for the
post of Inspector of Taxes and it was clearly stipulated in the advertisement
published by the TPSC about the pay scale and grade pay of the post, and as
such his basic pay was fixed at Rs.11,700/- per month which is the initial basic
pay of the post of Inspector of Taxes. The petitioner was well aware of the fact
that the post was a direct recruitment post having pay scale as mentioned in the
advertisement itself and it would be filled up though a process of selection.
Further, since the petitioner having gone through the terms and conditions as
specified in the offer-of-appointment, more particularly the basic pay, had
accepted the same and thereafter joined the post on his appointment, without any
demur or protest, now he cannot claim for such pay protection at this stage. In
view of the above, there was no illegality on the part of the respondents.
5.2.
In respect of the contention of the learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner in regard to pay protection and increment thereto granted to one Sri
Ashis Kr. Sarkar, it was fairly submitted by Mr. Saha, learned counsel that as the
Finance Department allowed pay fixation of Sri Ashis Kr. Sarkar, the same was
granted to him in the year 2008 following due procedure of law prevalent at that
time and his case should not be equated in the facts and circumstances with the
case of the present writ petitioner. Finally, learned counsel representing the
State-respondents urged this Court to dismiss the writ petition.
6.
I have gone through the pleadings of the parties and also considered
the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel appearing for the parties and
also perused the documents enclosed in support of the pleadings made by the
respective parties.
6.1.
From the pleadings and the submissions of learned counsel
appearing for the parties, what is emerged, in a short compass, is that there is no
dispute that while the petitioner was serving as Supervisor(ICDS) under
SW&SE Department, pursuant to advertisement vide No.01/2012 dated
01.01.2012, he had participated in the selection process with due permission of
his employer and got selected for the post of Inspector of Taxes. There is also no
dispute that on such selection he was issued offer-of-appointment for the said
post in the scale of pay of Rs.5,310-24,000/-(PB-2), Grade Pay Rs.2,400/- with
certain terms and conditions and on his acceptance of such terms and conditions
he was appointed vide order 07.10.2013 asking him to join on or before
23.10.2013. Thereafter, the petitioner prayed for transfer of his service from the
SW&SE Department to the Directorate of Taxes & Excise and to release him
with lien benefit and in response thereto the Director, SW&SE Department vide
Memo. dated 21.10.2013 released him and accordingly on the same day the
petitioner joined in the post of Inspector of Taxes. It is also a matter of fact that
the CDPO, Melaghar issued LPC of the petitioner stating his last basic pay in his
previous employment as Rs.12,340/- but the pay of the petitioner in his
subsequent appointment was fixed at Rs.11,700/- by the respondents. To sum
up, it is to be noted that in so far as his subsequent appointment is concerned,
there is no controversy in regard to obtaining permission from the competent
authority to appear in the selection process, tendering technical resignation with
prayer for transfer of service with lien benefit and also joining to his new post
without break in service.
6.2.
The cause of action for filing the instant writ petition arose, when
the initial pay of the petitioner to the post of Inspector of Taxes has been fixed at
Rs.11,700/- without protecting his last basic pay of Rs.12,340/- and when his
representations dated 08.06.2016 dated 08.08.2022 were not considered in true
letter and spirit.
6.3.
In the instant case, it is revealed that when the question of counting
of past service and protection of pay of the petitioner came to arise before the
Commissioner of Taxes, the same was referred to the Finance Department,
which on due consideration of the case of the petitioner opined that the past
service rendered by him as Supervisor(ICDS) during the period from 21.02.2005
to 21.10.2013 will be counted for the purpose of pension and pensionary
benefits only and accordingly, the Commissioner of Taxes had fixed the pay of
the petitioner as per the initial basic pay prescribed for the post of Inspector of
Taxes with effect from the date of his joining to his subsequent post. In other
words, he was denied of the benefit of pay protection and fixation of pay
counting his past service.
For the sake of convenience, I deem it fit to extract here-under the
relevant portion of the RTI reply note issued by the Finance Department dated
11.11.2022(Annexure 15), which reads thus:
“.............Finance Department concurs with the proposal of the Department for
counting the past service rendered by Sri Uttam Kumar Acharya „Inspector of
Taxes‟, as „ICDS Supervisor‟ under the SW&SE Department during the period
from 21-02-2005 to 21-10-2013 for the purpose of pension and pensionery
benefits only.....”
6.4.
On perusal of the RTI reply note, it reveals that there is no specific
mention in that note as to on what basis or applying to which rules/regulations or
government instructions, or otherwise, the Finance Department came to such a
conclusion that the past service of the petitioner would be counted only for the
purpose of pension and pensionary benefits. This Court is inclined to note that it
was the obligation of the Finance Department to let the employee know the
reason based on which rule or statutory instruction they came to such a
conclusion.
6.5.
On bare perusal of Clause (6) of the „Master Circular‟ vis-a-vis
„guidelines/ instructions‟(Annexure 16 to the writ petition), it reveals that in
terms of the Fundamental Rules, if a Government servant is subsequently
appointed to another post(on acceptance of technical resignation), pay protection
would be given to him i.e. in case his pay fixed in the new post is less than his
pay in the post he holds substantively, he will be entitled to draw the
presumptive pay of the post he holds substantively.
For fair ends of justice, it would be proper to reproduce here-under
Clause(6) of the Master Circular as under:“6. In cases of appointment of a Government servant to another post in
Government on acceptance of technical resignation, the protection of pay is
given in terms of the Ministry of Finance OM No. 3379-E.III (B)/65 dated the
17th June, 1965 read with provisions of FR 22-B. Thus, if the pay fixed in the
new post is less than his pay in the post he holds substantively, he will draw
the presumptive pay of the post he holds substantively as defined in FR-9(24).
Past service rendered by such a Government servant is taken into account for
reckoning of the minimum period for grant of annual increment in the new
post/ service/ cadre in Government under the provisions of FR 26 read with
Rule 10 of CCS (RP) Rules, 2016. In case the Government servant re-joins his
earlier posts, he will be entitled to increments for the period of his absence
from the post.”
6.6.
I have also perused the judgment rendered in Tarendra
Reang(supra) which was relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner
wherein a coordinate Bench of this Court observed that it is impossible to
protect the pension of a government servant without protecting his pay. While
allowing the writ petition filed by Tarendra Reang it was directed in that
judgment that the entire past service of government servants shall be protected
for the purpose of pay and allowances and post retiral benefits, in the case of
their appointment to new posts. For the sake of convenience, paragraphs 15 and
18 of the judgment rendered in Tarendra Reang(supra) are reproduced here-inbelow:
“15. From the above discussion it can be seen that inter departmental
migration of the employees is not discouraged, be it the Government of India
or the State Government. Specifically Rule 26(2) of CCS (Pension) Rules
protects the past service of an employee of the Government even after his
technical resignation and joining new post. Though this is limited for the
purpose of pensionary benefits of an employee, it is impossible to protect the
pension without protecting his pay.
18. Under the circumstances, all the petitions are allowed. In cases where the
petitioners were already enjoying pay fixations in regular scales, their entire
past service shall be protected for the purpose of pay and allowances
including leave encashment and post-retiral benefits as per their
appointments in new posts. Where the petitioners have not been granted
regular pay scales even after completion of 5 years of service, they would be
first brought over to regular pay scale from due dates. Upon their fresh
engagements as Teachers, their past service similarly shall be protected. It is,
however, clarified that none of the petitioners would have any claim of
seniority in their new engagements because in the new organization they
cannot carry the seniority of the past service so as to jump over the other
existing employees in the cadre.
(emphasis added)
6.7.
Rule 26(2) of the Central Civil Services(Pension) Rules, 1972
protects past service of a Government employee, being limited for the purpose
of pensionary benefits. Thus, it is practically not possible to protect the pension
and pensionary benefits, without protecting the pay. For the purpose of
protecting the pension and pensionary benefits of the petitioner, which was
purportedly granted vide impugned order dated 18.08.2016(Annexure 12 to the
writ petition), it is very much necessary to first protect the pay and then the
question of pension and pensionary benefits will arise. Counting of past service
for the purpose of the pension and pensionary benefits would be of an empty
formality unless and until his pay is not protected from the initial stage of his
subsequent employment.
7.
I have also gone through the counter affidavit submitted on behalf
of the respondent nos.2 and 5, Social Welfare & Social Education Department
and find nothing which controverts the contentions of the petitioner in his writ
petition.
8.
However, in the counter affidavit filed by the respondents nos.1, 3
and 4, it was stated that the petitioner was appointed to the post of Inspector of
Taxes, which is a direct recruitment post, through a process of selection and as
such his basic pay was fixed at Rs.11,740/- considering the initial pay scale of
the post of Inspector of Taxes and on receipt of representation of the petitioner
dated 08.06.2016, as a routine manner, the same was referred to the Finance
Department for its view/decision and the decision of the Finance Department
was communicated to the petitioner vide order dated 18.08.2016 to the effect
that „Finance Department, Government of Tripura concurs his prayer only for
pension and pensionery benefits‟. It was, however, pointed out in the affidavit
that from August, 2016 to August, 2022 the petitioner chose to remain silent on
the issue of pay protection.
8.1.
To controvert the contention in regard to the RTI reply note it was
stated by the respondents no.1, 3 and 4 that the Finance Department had only
concurred to extend the benefit of his past service to the extent of pension and
pensionary benefits and it was their defence that there was no whisper in the RTI
reply note in respect of granting the benefit of pay protection.
8.2.
In regard to the Master Circular dated 27.08.2018(Annexure 16), it
was stated in the counter affidavit that the same was issued by the concerned
department of Government of India and the petitioner failed to produce/adduce
any record or document in support of his claim that the same is applicable for
the employees serving under State Government.
8.3.
In respect of the contention that a similarly situated employee was
given the benefit of pay protection, it was stated in the affidavit that since the
Finance Department allowed fixation of pay of that employee, the same was
granted to him.
9.
On perusal of the Memorandum dated 23.09.2013[offer-of-
appointment] issued by the Commissioner of Taxes & Excise, Government of
Tripura, it comes to light that the petitioner was duly informed that on his
appointment his pay scale would be Rs.5310-24000/- with Grade Pay Rs.2400/in Pay Band-2 and he would be entitled to draw other allowances at the rates
admissible, subject to the conditions laid down in rules & orders governing the
grant of such allowances in force from time to time and further that other
conditions of service would be governed by the relevant rules & orders in force
from time to time. In the said memorandum there was a further stipulation that
„if the petitioner accepts the offer on the terms mentioned in the offer of
appointment, he should communicate acceptance together with all necessary
certificates/documents to the Commissioner of Taxes & Excise on or before
30.09.2013.‟ For the sake of convenience, Memorandum dated 23.09.2013 is
reproduced here-under in verbatim:
“No.F.IV-2(40)-TAX/11/20634
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF TAXES & EXCISE
P.N. COMPLEX, GURKHABASTI, AGARTALA.
Dated, Agartala, the 23rd September, 2013
MEMORANDUM
On the recommendation of the Tripura Public Service Commission,
Uttam Kumar Acharya is hereby offered to the post of Inspector of Taxes in
Pay Band -2, Rs.5310-24000/- with Grade Pay Rs.2400/- The appointee will
also be entitled to draw other allowances at the rates admissible and subject
to the conditions laid down in rules and orders governing the grant of such
allowances in force from time to time.
2. The terms of appointment are as follows:i) The appointment is purely on a temporary basis and will not confer any title
to permanent employment.
ii) The appointment may be terminated at any time by a month's notice given
by either side, namely, the appointee or the appointing authority without
assigning any reasons. The appointing authority, however, reserves the right
of terminating the service of the appointee forthwith or before the expiration
of the stipulated period of notice by making payment to him an equivalent to
the pay and allowances for the period of notice of the un-expired portion
thereof.
iii) The appointment carries with it the liability to serve in any part of Tripura.
iv) Other conditions of service will be governed by the relevant rules and
orders in force from time to time.
v) The appointee shall be on probation for a period of 2 (two) years from the
date of appointment. He shall also be required to undergo such training and
pass such examination as may be ordered by the Government.
3. The appointment will be further subject to:
i) Production of a certificate of fitness from the Medical Superintendent, G. B.
Hospital / 1.G.M.Hospital/ Sub-Divisional Medical Officer.
ii) Submission of a declaration in the Form enclosed and in the event of the
candidate having more than one wife living, the appointment will be subject
to his being exempted from the enforcement of the requirement in this behalf.
iii) Taking of an oath of allegiance to the constitution of India in the prescribed
form.
iv) Submission of duly filled in ATTESTATION FORM.
iv) Production of the following original certificatesa) Degree / Diploma / Certificates of educational qualifications.
b) Certificate of age.
c) Character certificate from the two Gazetted Officers of the Central/State
Government/ Stipendiary Magistrates in the enclosed form.
d) Discharge certificates of previous employment, if any.
e) Citizenship certificate/PRTC
f) Caste certificate, if any.
g) 3 (three) copies of passport size photographs.
4. It may please be stated whether the candidate is serving or is under
obligation to serve another Central Government Department, State
Government or a Public Authority,
5. If any declaration given or information furnished by the candidate is found
to be false or if the candidate is found to have willfully suppressed any
material information, he/she will be liable to removal from service and such
other action as Government may deem necessary.
6. If Uttam Kumar Acharya accepts the offer on the above terms, he/she
should communicate acceptance together with all necessary certificates/
documents to the Commissioner of Taxes & Excise on or before 30/09/2013
positively. If no reply is received from the candidate by the prescribed date,
the offer may be treated as cancelled.
7. No T.A will be allowed for joining the appointment offered to the candidate
Enclo:- ATTESTATION FORM (Two Sets)
(Brijesh Pandey, IAS)
Commissioner of Taxes
Government of Tripura.
To
Uttam Kumar Acharya
S/O. Sri Gauranga Chandra acharya,
Vill-Chowmoni Bazar,
P.O. SurjyabMoni Nagar,
P.S. Amtali
Dist. Sadar,
Pin-799130.”
10.
It is a matter of fact that the petitioner being fully aware of the fact
that his pay would be fixed in the aforementioned pay scale accepted the said
offer-of-appointment on his own volition and on such acceptance the
Commissioner of Taxes vide order dated 07.10.2013 appointed the petitioner,
wherein also certain terms and conditions were stipulated and one such
condition was that his pay would be fixed as per rules. It would be apposite to
extract the relevant part of the appointment order dated 07.10.2013, for
convenience:
“ORDER
On the recommendation of the Tripura Public Service Commission and
as per terms and condition mentioned in the offer of appointment the
following candidates are hereby appointed on probation to the post of
Inspector of Taxes at Basic Pay Rs.11,700/-(Rupees Eleven thousand and
seven hundred) only per month in the Pay Band-2, Rs.5310-24000/- with
Grade Pay Rs.2400/- plus other allowances as admissible under the rules in
force in Tripura from time to time with effect from the date of their joining the
post.
1. Sri Saikat Acharji
2. Sri Mithun Kanti Roy
3. Sri Abhijit Biswas
4. Sri Saurav Das
5. Sri Priyankar De
6. Sri Sandip Bhattacharjee
7. SriRaghunath Bhattacharjee
8. Sri Uttam Kumar Acharya
9. Sri Upam Bikash Chakma
10. Sri Manto Kalai
2. The appointment is purely temporary and the appointee may be terminated
at any time on one month's notice from either side.
3. The appointees shall remain on probation for a period of 2 (two) years with
effect from date of joining the post
4. The appointment is made against the existing vacancies of organization.
5. The appointees pay will be fixed as per rules.
……………………..”
11.
On bare perusal of the aforesaid appointment order, it is noticed
that said order stipulates one of the most important conditions that the fixation
of pay would be as per rules. There should not be any quarrel that the
petitioner‟s service unless regulated by any specific rules in general or in
particular, provisions of Fundamental Rules would apply to create right in
favour of the petitioner. At this juncture, the Fundamental Rules 22(1) comes on
to play which provides regulation of the initial pay of a Government servant
appointed to a post on time-scale of pay. The Fundamental Rule envisages
different situations where a Government servant holding one post on substantive
or temporary basis is promoted or appointed in a substantive, temporary or
officiating capacity in some other post. It primarily envisages protection of past
pay on new engagement. It would be apposite to extract here-under the relevant
provisions under F.R. 22(1), thus:
“F.R. 22(1) The initial pay of a Government servant who is appointed to a
post on a time-scale of pay is regulated as follows:(a)(1) Where a Government servant holding a post, other than a tenure
post, in a substantive or temporary or officiating capacity is promoted or
promoted in a substantive, temporary or officiating capacity, as the case may
be, subject to the fulfilment of the eligibility conditions as prescribed in the
relevant Recruitment Rules, to another post carrying duties and
responsibilities of greater importance than those attaching to the post held by
him, his initial pay in the time-scale of the higher post shall be fixed at the
stage next above the notional pay arrived at by increasing his pay in respect of
the lower post held by him regularly by an increment at the stage at which
such pay has accrued or rupees one hundred only, whichever is more.
Save in cases of appointment on deputation to an ex- cadre post, or to a
post on ad hoc basis or on direct recruitment basis, the Government servant
shall have the option, to be exercised within one month from the date of
promotion or appointment as the case may be, to have the pay fixed under this
rule from the date of such promotion or appointment or to have the pay fixed
initially at the stage of the time-scale of the new post above the pay in the
lower grade or post from which he is promoted on regular basis, which may be
refixed in accordance with this rule on the date of accrual of the next
increment in the scale of the pay of the lower grade or post. In cases where an
ad hoc promotion is followed by regular appointment without break, the option
is admissible as from the date of initial appointment/promotion, to be exercised
within one month from the date of such regular appointment.
Provided that where a Government servant is, immediately before his
promotion or appointment on regular basis to a higher post, drawing pay at
the maximum of the time-scale of the lower post, his initial pay in the timescale of the higher post shall be fixed at the stage next above the pay notionally
arrived at by increasing his pay in respect of the lower post held by him on
regular basis by an amount equal to the last increment in the time-scale of the
lower post or rupees one hundred, whichever is more ;”
11.1.
It is not in dispute that the Fundamental Rules(Central Rules of
1922) is in force in the State of Tripura with effect from 21.01.1972[adopted
with modification by the Government of Tripura vide Finance Department
Order No.F.1(1)-FIN(G)/72 dated 21.01.1972].
(emphasis supplied)
11.2.
A Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Khokan Debnath
vs. State of Tripura & Ors. reported in (2018) 1 TLR 175 held and observed
that FR.22(1)(a)(1) is not only confined to regulation of pay scale of
Government servant on „promotion‟ but the same would also apply in case of his
„appointment‟ on a post different from one he was previously holding the
Government. Relying upon the decision rendered in Khokan Debnath(supra), a
learned Single Judge of this Court (A. Kureshi, CJ, as he then was) in the case of
Tarendra Reang(supra) addressing the issue of pay protection held thus:
“[8]
Government of India had issued certain instructions under FR.22,
one such instruction dated 17th June, 1965 reads as under:
“(9)
Condonation of resignation for purposes of fixation of pay- The
question whether the benefit of past service for purposes of fixation of pay can
be given to a Government servant who resigns his post before taking up
appointment in the new post in the same or another Department, has been
under the consideration of the Government of India. Normally, the benefit of
past service is given only in those cases where such service has not been
terminated by resignation/dismissal. The President is, however, pleased to
decide that in cases where Government servants apply for posts in the same
or other Departments through proper channel and on selection, they are
asked to resign the previous posts for administrative reasons, the benefit of
past service may, if otherwise admissible under rules, be given for purposes
for fixation of pay in the new post treating the resignation as a „technical
formality‟. The pay in such cases maybe fixed under FR.27.”
[9]
Under instructions dated 22nd January, 1993 it was further
clarified as under:
“
*
**
A question has now been raised as to whether the above benefit is
admissible to Government servants who applied for posts in the same or other
Departments before joining Government service and on that account the
application was not routed through proper channel. The matter has been
examined and it is now decided that the benefit of past service subject to the
same conditions as incorporated in O.M., dated 17-6-1965 above, may be
allowed in such cases also, subject to the fulfilment of the following
conditions:-
(i)
the Government servant at the time of joining should intimate the
details of such application immediately on their joining;
(ii) the Government servant at the time of resignation should
specifically make a request, indicating the dates that he is
resigning
to
take
up
another
appointment
under
the
Government/Government Organization for which he applied
before joining the Government service and that his resignation may
be treated as „technical‟ resignation;
(iii) the authority accepting the resignation should satisfy itself that
had the employee been in service on the date of application for the
post mentioned by the employee, his application would have been
forwarded through proper channel.”
[10]
As per the said instructions dated 17th June, 1965 thus,
Government of India had taken a conscious decision that a Government
servant who resigns from his post in the same or other departments
through proper channel and joins another post on selection after resigning
from his previous post, the benefit of past service, if otherwise admissible
under the rules, will be given for the purpose of fixation of pay in the new
post “treating the resignation as a technical formality”. It is from these
instructions perhaps that the term “technical resignation” has gained
currency. Likewise under the instructions dated 22nd January, 1993 even
in a case where a Government servant takes up another appointment in
another department but for which his application for selection was not
routed through proper channel, the past service would be protected
subject to certain conditions. Both these instructions thus clearly manifest
the intention of the Government of India not to deter or discourage
interdepartmental migration of employees.
[11]
As pointed out by the counsel for the petitioners, a reference also
must be made to the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972
[“CCS(Pension) Rules” for short] which have been adopted by the State
of Tripura under a notification dated 8th August, 1978. Rule 26 of
CCS(Pension) Rules pertains to forfeiture of service on resignation.
Relevant portion of this rule reads as under :
“26(1) Resignation from a service or a post, unless it is allowed to be
withdrawn in the public interest by the appointing authority, entails forfeiture
of past service.
(2) A resignation shall not entail forfeiture of past service if it has been
submitted to take up, with proper permission, another appointment, whether
temporary or permanent, under the Government where service qualifies.”
[12] As is well known, simple resignation leads to forfeiture of past
service. The Courts have clearly distinguished between resignation and
voluntary retirement. However, as specified in sub-rule (2) of Rule 26
of CCS(Pension) Rules, a resignation shall not entail forfeiture of past
service if it is submitted to take up another appointment under the
Government with proper permission. As noted, the term technical
resignation is not reflected in the rules, however, by virtue of
Government of India‟s instructions, noted above and in the context of
sub-rule (2) of Rule 26 of CCS(Pension) Rules the same has gained a
certain well known connotation. It conveys a situation where a
Government servant takes up another post under the Government for
which his parent department has shown willingness and to join the new
post, he has to resign from his past service.”
12.
Again the concept of technical resignation has further been clarified
by an Office Memorandum, dated 27.08.2018 of the Ministry of Personnel,
Public Grievances & Pensions, Government of India where it is stipulated that a
resignation will be treated as technical resignation only upon satisfaction of twin
conditions and the two conditions are, firstly, a Government servant has to apply
through proper channel for the post in the same or some other department and
secondly, the Government servant on selection is required to resign from the
previous post for administrative reasons. When these twin conditions are
fulfilled, then only the benefit of past service can be given, if otherwise
admissible.
13.
Added to what has been discussed here-in-above as regards the
established Rules governing the pay protection of a Government employee, I
may profitably refer to a decision of the Apex Court in the case of Jagdish
Parwani vs. Union of India & Ors. reported in (2018) 15 SCC 591 wherein it
was categorically held that pension is continuing cause of action while issue of
pay protection arises as soon as employee joins new post and whatever is
granted would depend on operating rules/regulations/notification, etc.
governing field. Paragraphs 20 and 21 of Jagdish Parwani(supra) reads thus:
“20. The counsel appearing for the appellant however sought to submit
that to deny the benefit of the Notification dated 28-2-1992 to the appellant
was discriminatory in nature and in support of the said contention the counsel
relied on the decision of this Court in T.S. Thiruvengadam v. Union of India
(Ministry of Finance) [T.S. Thiruvengadam v. Union of India (Ministry of
Finance), (1993) 2 SCC 174 : 1993 SCC (L&S) 495 : (1993) 24 ATC 102] . In
our considered opinion the ratio of the aforesaid decision was rendered in
respect of a case of pension which is a continuing cause of action. Facts of the
said case are clearly distinguishable from the facts of the present case and,
therefore, the ratio of the said decision is not applicable to the case in hand.
21. There is an inherent clear distinction between the two concepts of pay
protection and pension. So far as getting pay protection is concerned, the
said issue arises as soon as an employee joins his new post, where he gets his
new pay scale and if he is entitled to any pay protection that is the stage and
date when it is granted by whatever notifications, memorandums which are
available and applicable at that stage laying down such rules regarding pay
protection. At that stage what was operating in the field was the Notification
issued on 7-8-1989 which was not applicable to the appellant. The appellant
also clearly understood the position and therefore based his entire claim and
right on the subsequent Notification dated 28-2-1992, although appointed to
the post of the Central Government on 23-2-1990.”
[emphasis added]
14.
What emerges on a cumulative consideration of the aforesaid
Rules, and the judgments occupying the field in the present case vis-a-vis the
principles therein is that the simple resignation leads to forfeiture of past service;
however, it shall not entail forfeiture of past service if prior to participation in
the selection process for appointment to another department/service under the
Government, the concerned employee obtains proper permission from his
previous employer in view of the provision embodied in Sub-Rule(2) of Rule 26
of CCS(Pension) Rules.
14.1.
Again, from the Rules quoted here-in-above relating to the subject
in issue and Office Memorandums issued time to time clearly suggest that the
intention of the Government is not to deter or discourage but to promote or
encourage a Government employee to open better avenues and to look for better
job opportunities. Now, it is settled proposition that before appearing in the
selection process if an employee seeks permission and the employer issues “no
objection certificate” allowing such employee to appear in the selection process
to any other department/service of the Government, then, resignation submitted
by such employee at the time of joining in the second service, would be treated
as „technical resignation‟ and in that case, there is no forfeiture of past service
and his pay would be protected under the second employment.
(emphasis supplied)
14.2.
In the instant case, admittedly, the petitioner being a Government
servant under the respondent No.5 had sought for permission for submitting
application for appointment in another department. The said application routed
through proper channel. Thereafter, the respondent No.5, i.e. the previous
employer of the petitioner forwarded the same to the Secretary, Tripura Public
Service Commission according permission to the petitioner to appear in the
Combined Competitive Examination. The petitioner was selected and after
receipt of the appointment order issued by the respondent No.3, at the time of
joining to the department of respondent No.3, i.e. Commissioner of Taxes, he
tendered his resignation. In this circumstance, petitioner‟s resignation is to be
treated as “technical resignation”. It is a mere technical formality required for
administrative reasons. Since it is a mere formality, the past service benefits
including his last basic pay under his previous employer, i.e. respondent No.5
are protected and shall be provided by his subsequent employer, i.e. the
respondent No.3.
14.3.
Thus, the stand of the respondents that the petitioner knowing fully
well about the pay scale mentioned the advertisement applied for the post, and
on his selection accepted the offer-of-appointment with full knowledge in
respect of pay scale, etc., and that he is not entitled to pay protection, in the
opinion of this Court, are not tenable in law for the reasons that neither the
recruitment rules nor the offer-of-appointment can override the service rules,
regulations and statutory provisions. Even otherwise, the advertisement/offerof-appointment, though specifically mentioned that the appointee would be
placed under the initial pay scale for the post, but the same never clarified that
even if the rules and regulations so provide, the past service of a Government
servant having upper pay scale would be wiped out.
14.4.
Pertinently, in the case in hand, no such rule placed on record by
the respondents denying the benefit of past service for the purpose of fixation of
pay in the new post the petitioner had joined after the observance of all
necessary formalities as discussed in the preceding paragraphs.
15.
Since principal issue regarding the benefit of providing past service
the petitioner had rendered under the previous employment is decided in favour
of the petitioner, in my considered view, other arguments advanced by learned
counsel appearing for the parties need no further discussion.
16.
In view of the above discussions on facts and law, it can safely be
held that the petitioner is entitled to get the benefit of pay protection for the
service rendered by him in his previous employment. The impugned order dated
18.08.2016 and the impugned memorandum dated 20.10.2022 are hereby set
aside and quashed. The respondents are directed to fix initial pay of the
petitioner at par with his last basic pay of Rs.12,340/- alongwith all
consequential benefits, including arrears as per law within a period of 6(six)
months on receipt of a copy of this judgment and order.
17.
The instant writ petition, accordingly, stands allowed and thus
disposed of.
JUDGE
signed
SAIKAT Digitally
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2024.03.28
KAR
18:22:52 +05'30'
Snigdha/Nihar
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review