Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.24
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
FAO (WC) No. 41/2022
CM Nos. 6126-6127/2022
…. Petitioner/Appellant(s)
UT of J&K & Ors.
Through: - Mr.Ravinder Gupta, AAG with
Ms. Mehar Bali, Advocate
V/s
…. Respondent(s)
Balwinder Singh
Through: - Mr. Tarun Sharma, Advocate
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
01.07.2026
(ORAL)
1.
This is an appeal under Section 30 of the Employees' Compensation
Act, 1923 (for short, "the Act"), directed against the award dated
27.10.2021 passed by the Commissioner under the Employees'
Compensation Act, 1923 (Assistant Labour Commissioner), Jammu
(for short, "the Authority under the Act"). By the said award, the
Authority allowed the claim preferred by the respondent, Balwinder
Singh, who claimed to have been working as a driver/machine
operator with the appellants on a monthly salary of ₹6,750/- and to
have suffered injuries during the course of his employment.
Consequently, the Authority directed the appellants to pay
compensation amounting to ₹16,34,124/-. Aggrieved thereof, the
appellants have preferred the present appeal.
2.
Since the appeal has been filed beyond the prescribed period of
limitation, the question of limitation is required to be considered at the
outset. Admittedly, there is a delay of 269 days in preferring the
present appeal.
3.
Learned Additional Advocate General, Mr. Ravinder Gupta,
appearing for the appellants, submitted that the delay in filing the
appeal is neither deliberate nor mala fide, but has occurred solely on
account of unavoidable administrative procedures, as is evident from
the intra-departmental correspondence placed on record. According to
him, the appellants have furnished a day-to-day explanation of the
procedural steps undertaken for obtaining approval from the higher
authorities as well as sanction for filing the appeal. He contended that
the delay has, therefore, been sufficiently explained. It was further
argued that since the appeal under Section 30 of the Act requires a
mandatory statutory deposit, prior sanction from the competent
authority was necessary and it was only after the requisite amount was
sanctioned that the appellants were in a position to institute the appeal.
Learned counsel further submitted that the award itself suffers from
non-application of mind, inasmuch as the appellants had specifically
pleaded before the Authority that the respondent was engaged only on
a need basis and did not possess the status of a regular employee so as
to maintain a claim under the Act. According to him, the Authority
erroneously treated the respondent as an employee of the appellants,
rendering the impugned award without jurisdiction and legally
unsustainable.
4.
Learned Additional Advocate General further submitted that the delay
also deserves to be condoned in view of the orders passed by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court extending the period of limitation during the
COVID-19 pandemic. According to him, the appellants are entitled to
the benefit of the said extension and have thus succeeded in
establishing sufficient cause for condonation of delay. In support of
his submissions, reliance has been placed upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Nagaland versus Lipok AO &
others (Criminal Appeal No. 484 of 2005 arising out of SLP (Crl.) No.
4612 of 2003).
5.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent vehemently
opposed the application for condonation of delay and submitted that
the appeal is hopelessly barred by limitation, having been filed after a
delay of more than 269 days. He argued that even if the explanation
furnished by the appellants is accepted at its face value, namely that
the delay occurred on account of official correspondence and that
sanction to file the appeal was ultimately granted by the competent
authority on 07.06.2022, the appellants have still failed to explain the
further delay of more than three months thereafter in filing the appeal.
According to him, such unexplained inaction is fatal, particularly
when the appellants were fully aware of the statutory remedy
available under the Act, which is a beneficial legislation and cannot be
equated with remedies under ordinary civil law. Learned counsel
further submitted that the memorandum of appeal does not even
contain a whisper that the COVID-19 pandemic had prevented the
appellants from pursuing the matter or communicating with the higher
authorities, except for a bare reference in paragraph 12 to the suo
motu orders of the Hon'ble Supreme Court extending the period of
limitation from 15.03.2020 to 28.02.2022. Reliance has been placed
upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Madhya
Pradesh & others versus Bherulal (Special Leave Petition (C) Diary
No. 9217 of 2020) and the judgment dated 16.08.2021 passed by the
Coordinate Bench of this Court in Executive Engineer, PWD, Doda
versus Ghulam Mohd. Ahtoo and another (CON No. 26/2016 and IA
No. 1/2016). Learned counsel lastly contended that since the
Employees' Compensation Act is a welfare and beneficial legislation,
the provisions relating to limitation must receive strict rather than
liberal construction.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
7.
Learned counsel for the appellant placed reliance upon the judgment
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court rendered on 01.04.2005 in State of
Nagaland v. Lipok AO & Others to contend that the expression
"sufficient cause" ought to receive a liberal construction and be
interpreted with a pragmatic, justice-oriented approach rather than by
adopting a hyper-technical scrutiny requiring an explanation for every
day's delay. In the said case, the appeal against acquittal had been
filed with a delay of 57 days, which the High Court declined to
condone. Setting aside the order of the High Court, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court observed that insistence upon a strict standard in
matters of limitation may, in appropriate cases, defeat the cause of
public justice and encourage the skilful management of delay to
frustrate legal proceedings. The Court accordingly held that the
refusal to condone the delay was not in accordance with law.
8.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent relied upon the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court dated 15.10.2020 in The State
of Madhya Pradesh & Others v. Bherulal, wherein the Court declined
to condone an extraordinary delay of about eight years. It was held
that the Department had failed to furnish any proper, acceptable or
cogent explanation for the delay, except merely narrating the
movement of files and mentioning various dates. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court further observed that Government departments, being
fully aware of the prescribed period of limitation and having the
assistance of officers conversant with legal proceedings, cannot claim
a different standard of limitation merely because the matter pertains to
a Government Department.
9.
Learned counsel further relied upon the judgment dated 05.06.2024
passed by a Coordinate Bench of this Court in United India Insurance
Company Limited v. Altaf Hussain Bhat & Others, arising out of an
award dated 29.02.2024 passed under the provisions of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988. In that case, while considering an application
seeking condonation of a delay of 70 days in filing the appeal, the
Court held that the Insurance Company had failed to specifically
disclose when the matter had been referred to its Regional Office at
Chandigarh and when sanction for filing the appeal had been granted.
Upon a closer scrutiny, the Court found the application to be cryptic in
nature and devoid of any plausible or sufficient explanation
warranting condonation of delay.
10.
Reliance was also placed upon another decision of a Coordinate
Bench of this Court dated 16.08.2021 in Executive Engineer, PWD,
Doda v. Ghulam Mohd. Ahtoo& Another. In the said case, arising out
of an award passed by the Assistant Labour Commissioner, Doda, the
Court, following the principles laid down in The State of Madhya
Pradesh v. Bherulal (supra), declined to condone the delay. The
Department had sought condonation on the ground of administrative
exigencies and the time consumed in obtaining the opinion of the Law
Department, while asserting that the injured workman had been
engaged through a contractor and had suffered 40% disability. The
Coordinate Bench held that the explanation offered was casual,
cryptic and wholly insufficient to constitute "sufficient cause" for
condoning the delay, observing that Government departments cannot
presume that the expression "sufficient cause" would invariably
receive a liberal interpretation in their favour.
11.
In the present case, the award was passed on 27.10.2021, and it is not
the appellants' case that the award was rendered behind their back.
The delay in filing the appeal has been sought to be condoned on the
ground that the decision to challenge the award had to be taken by the
higher authorities, due to which the file moved through various
administrative levels, resulting in delay. Admittedly, there is a delay
of 269 days in filing the appeal. Such an explanation cannot be
accepted on its face value unless it is substantiated by cogent and
convincing material.
12.
In the application seeking condonation of delay, it has been averred
that, initially, the appellants intended to comply with the award and
sought the release of funds for its satisfaction. For this purpose, the
Office of the Executive Engineer, Mechanical Engineering Division,
Doda, forwarded a copy of the award along with the brief case history
to the Office of the Superintending Engineer, Mechanical Circle,
Jammu,
vide
communication
dated
09.11.2021,
requesting
administrative approval for the release of an amount of ₹16,34,124/and seeking further necessary action.
13.
The record reveals that the appellants had initially made sincere
efforts to secure the requisite funds for satisfying the award. It was
only in the year 2022 that the Senior Law Officer of the Public Works
Department pointed out certain legal issues, whereupon the Executive
Engineer, MED Doda, addressed a communication dated 02.05.2022
to the Chief Engineer, Jammu, recommending that the award be
challenged. Thereafter, the Law Department accorded sanction vide
Letter No. LAW-LIT7/391/2022-10 dated 07.06.2022. However,
notwithstanding such sanction, the appellants have failed to explain
why the appeal was not instituted until September 2022. Learned
counsel for the appellants vehemently argued that the appeal could not
be filed earlier as it was contingent upon the mandatory statutory
deposit, for which prior financial sanction was required. According to
the appellants, only after the requisite funds for the statutory deposit
were sanctioned could the appeal be instituted.
14.
Learned counsel for the appellants further submitted that the
functioning of the Courts had been severely affected by the COVID19 pandemic, thereby justifying the delay. Attractive though the
submission may appear, a plain reading of the application for
condonation of delay shows that, from paragraphs 1 to 11, there is not
even a whisper that the appeal could not be filed because the
concerned officials were engaged in COVID-related duties or that the
pandemic had prevented the processing of the matter. It is only in
paragraph 12 that reliance has been placed upon the order passed by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the suo motu proceedings extending the
period of limitation from 15.03.2020 to 28.02.2022. The appellants
appear to have merely invoked the benefit of the extension granted
during the pandemic without specifically pleading that the
circumstances arising from COVID-19 prevented them from filing the
appeal. Nor is it their case that the officers involved in obtaining
administrative approval or financial sanction were unable to process
the matter because of the pandemic. Even assuming that a case for
condonation of delay is made out, the appeal, on merits, does not
disclose any sustainable ground warranting interference.
15.
On merits, the appellants themselves admit that the respondent had
been working with them as a driver for over ten years and was
entrusted with the operation of heavy machinery. Yet, they seek to
avoid liability by contending that his engagement was purely seasonal
and did not confer any permanent status. This contention has been
effectively rebutted by learned counsel for the respondent, who
submitted that the respondent had been continuously working with the
department and was being paid monthly wages of ₹6,750/- calculated
at the rate of ₹225/- per day. The Authority under the Act, after
appreciating the evidence, found that the respondent met with an
accident while operating an excavator which overturned due to
imbalance, resulting in the amputation of his left leg below the knee
and causing permanent disability of a severe nature. The Authority
rightly assessed the disability with reference to the respondent's
functional incapacity and concluded that, being a driver and machine
operator by profession, he had suffered a 100% loss of earning
capacity.
16.
Learned counsel for the respondent further invited the attention of this
Court to the provisions of the Act, which clearly extend the benefit of
compensation even to employees engaged on a casual basis. It was
further submitted that the respondent had continuously served the
appellants for more than ten years and had even sought regularization
of his services. Consequently, the plea raised by the appellants that the
respondent was not entitled to compensation is wholly devoid of legal
merit.
17.
I have carefully examined the record of the Authority under the Act
and find that the claimant was 42 years of age at the time of the
accident. There is no dispute that he was employed as a driver.
18.
Section 2(1)(l) of the Act defines "total disablement" to mean such
temporary or permanent disablement as incapacitates an employee
from performing all work which he was capable of performing at the
time of the accident.
19.
In the present case, the respondent suffered amputation of his left leg
below the knee, an injury which effectively disqualifies him from
operating heavy machinery. As a professional driver, the loss of his
limb has rendered him completely unfit to pursue his vocation.
Consequently, he has suffered total functional disability resulting in
complete loss of earning capacity. The Authority under the Act was,
therefore, fully justified in assessing the loss of earning capacity at
100%. The respondent's income was correctly assessed on the basis of
the wages actually being drawn by him, and compensation was
computed accordingly. The Authority awarded compensation of
₹7,22,885/- and, keeping in view the mandate of Section 4-A (3) of
the Act and the settled legal position, also awarded statutory interest
besides directing payment of ₹6.50 lakhs towards medical expenses.
20.
During the course of arguments, learned counsel for the appellants
was unable to demonstrate that any finding recorded by the Authority
under the Act was either perverse or suffered from any legal infirmity.
The only contention advanced was that the respondent was merely a
daily-rated worker. This Court has consistently held in several
pronouncements that the description of an employee as seasonal,
casual, or a daily wager is often a mere nomenclature adopted by the
authorities and cannot be used to defeat the beneficial object of the
legislation. Liability cannot be avoided at the cost of a workman who
has suffered a disabling injury while performing duties under the
control and supervision of the employer.
21.
Having regard to the beneficial nature of the legislation, the appellants
ought to have accepted and satisfied the award instead of challenging
it on technical grounds, particularly when the challenge lacks any
legal substance.
22.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the delay in filing the appeal is
condoned and the appeal is admitted for consideration on merits.
23.
Having examined the matter on merits, this Court finds that the
appellants have failed to raise any substantial question of law or point
out any legal infirmity in the award passed by the Authority under the
Act. The award is fully consistent with the provisions of law and
warrants no interference. Accordingly, the appeal, being devoid of
merit, is dismissed.
24.
The Registry's report dated 27.02.2023 reflects that an amount of
₹16,95,000/- has been transmitted online by the Assistant Labour
Commissioner, Jammu. Further, in terms of the order dated
04.11.2023 passed by this Court, 50% of the awarded amount has
already been released in favour of the respondent. The balance
amount, out of the total sum deposited at the time of filing the present
time-barred appeal, shall now be released in favour of the respondent
after due verification by the Registry.
( SANJAY PARIHAR )
J
JUDGE
JAMMU
01.07.2026
Sunita/Secretary
Whether the order is speaking.
Whether the order is reportable.
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review