Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 21
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case: SWP No. 3143/2015
Date of pronouncement: 05.11.2026
Date of uploading: 06.11.2026
Mohd. Suleman
S/o Sh. Ghulam Hussain,
R/o Village Panjnara,
Tehsil Koteranaka District Rajouri
..... Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through :- Mr. Sourabh Gupta, Advocate vice
Mr. Ankur Sharma, Advocate
Vs
1.
The State of Jammu and Kashmir
Through its Commissioner/Secretary,
Public Health Engineering
Department, Civil Secretariat,
Srinagar/Jammu.
2.
The Chief Engineer,
Public Health Engineering
Department, Jammu.
3.
The Superintending Engineer,
Public Health Engineer Department,
Hydraulic Circle, Rajouri.
4.
The Executive Engineer,
PHE Division, Rajouri.
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Ms. Priyanka Bhat, Advocate vice
Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
ORDER(ORAL)
05.11.2026
1.
Through the medium of the instant petition, the petitioner seeks the
following reliefs:-
2|Page
SWP No. 3143/2015
“Certiorari: Quashing order No. PHER/2424-26 dated 19.09.2014
issued by respondent No. 4, whereby the claim of the petitioner for
engagement in lieu of 1 Kanal of land comprised in Khasra No. 175,
situated at Village Panjnara, Tehsil Koteranka, District Rajouri,
donated by the petitioner to the PHE Department, has been rejected
illegally, arbitrarily and without application of mind.
Mandamus:(i) Commanding the respondents to appoint/absorb the
petitioner in the Public Health Engineering Department in lieu of 1
Kanal of land comprised in Khasra No. 175, situated at Village
Panjnara, Tehsil Koteranka, District Rajouri, donated by him to the
PHE Department for construction of a reservoir/water tank.
(ii) Commanding the respondents to accord similar treatment to the
petitioner as has been extended to other similarly situated persons by
respondent No. 3 vide communication No. SEHR/PHE/GE-20/52-54
dated 09.04.2015, by engaging the petitioner in lieu of the land
donated by him to the PHE Department.”
2.
The specific case set up by the petitioner is that, way back in the year
1995, he donated 1 Kanal of land comprised in Khasra No. 175,
situated at Village Panjnara, Tehsil Koteranka, District Rajouri, to the
PHE Department for construction of a reservoir/water tank, on the
assurance extended by the Department that he would be provided
Government employment in lieu of the said land.
3.
It is further contended that, pursuant to the aforesaid assurance, the
PHE Department initially engaged the petitioner on a need basis in the
year 1996 and conveyed to him that his absorption in the Department
would be subject to approval by the Administrative Department. In this
regard, the case of the petitioner was also forwarded to the
Administrative Department and, pending a decision thereon, he was
permitted to continue on a need basis.
4.
The further case of the petitioner is that he continued under the bona
fide belief that he would eventually be regularized/absorbed in the
Department. However, despite having continued on a need basis for a
3|Page
SWP No. 3143/2015
considerable period, no steps were taken by the Department in this
regard, compelling him to submit repeated representations before the
concerned authorities, but without any tangible result.
5.
The petitioner, in order to substantiate his claim, has placed on record
communication dated 22.05.2007, whereby the Executive Engineer,
PHE, Rajouri, forwarded his case to the Superintending Engineer,
Hydraulic Circle, Rajouri, pursuant to the recommendation made by
the then concerned Minister. However, despite the aforesaid
recommendation, no further action was taken in the matter, leaving the
petitioner to suffer.
6.
Aggrieved of the inaction on the part of the respondents, the petitioner
was constrained to approach this Court by way of a writ petition,
registered as SWP No. 1421/2013, which came to be disposed of vide
order dated 02.07.2013 in the following terms:“This petition is disposed of by providing that respondents shall
consider the case of the petitioner for his engagement in the PHE
Department in the light of recommendations made by the Chief
Engineer. Let this be done within a period of three months from the
date a copy of this order is served upon the respondents by the
petitioner.”
7.
Pursuant thereto, respondent No. 4 issued another communication dated
11.09.2013 to respondent No. 3, wherein it was categorically
mentioned that the petitioner had donated land measuring 1 Kanal,
falling under Khasra No. 175, and approval was accordingly sought for
his engagement on a casual basis in lieu of the land donated by him to
the PHE Department. The petitioner was thereafter directed to produce
4|Page
SWP No. 3143/2015
the requisite land documents, complete in all respects, for the purpose
of consideration of his engagement.
8.
The petitioner claims to have submitted all the requisite documents
pertaining to the land before respondent No. 4. However, despite
submission of the said documents, no action was taken in his favour,
compelling him to issue a legal notice dated 07.11.2013 to respondents
Nos. 2 to 4, seeking implementation of the order passed by this Court in
the first round of litigation.
9.
Since the aforesaid order passed by this Court was not complied with,
the petitioner was also constrained to initiate contempt proceedings.
Upon issuance of notice in the contempt petition, the respondents filed
a detailed compliance report and, along with the same, placed on record
order dated 19.09.2014, whereby the claim of the petitioner came to be
rejected after consideration. The aforesaid order is the subject matter of
challenge in the instant petition.
10.
The petitioner has called in question the aforesaid order of
consideration primarily on the ground that, once the respondents had
directed him to furnish the requisite documents and he had already
donated the land for construction of the water tank, which was raised in
the year 1996, the respondents were under a legal obligation to provide
him employment in lieu of the land so donated.
11.
Per contra, the respondents have filed their response, wherein a
specific stand has been taken that, insofar as the claim of the petitioner
regarding his engagement as a casual labourer is concerned, there is no
record available with the Department to substantiate the factum of such
5|Page
SWP No. 3143/2015
engagement, as alleged in the instant petition. The respondents have
further contended that the structure in question has been raised over
land comprised in Khasra No. 175, which, in fact, belongs to the
Custodian Department, and the petitioner is not the owner thereof.
Therefore, he cannot claim any right to employment in lieu of the said
land, which does not belong to him.
12.
It is further contended by the respondents that the land documents
furnished by the petitioner were not genuine, as the land utilized by the
Department actually belongs to the Custodian Department. It is also
their specific stand that, as on date, there is no scheme or policy in
vogue which confers upon the petitioner any enforceable right to claim
employment in lieu of the land in question. Though the respondents
have admitted that the case of the petitioner for engagement in lieu of
the land was forwarded to the higher authorities, they have submitted
that, upon scrutiny of the requisite documents, the claim of the
petitioner was found to be unsustainable, as the land over which the
Department had raised the construction/structure belonged to the
Custodian Department and not to the petitioner. Accordingly, his claim
was rejected by virtue of the impugned consideration order.
13.
The respondents have also placed reliance upon the report furnished by
the concerned Tehsildar, who has categorically communicated that the
land utilized by the Department actually belongs to the Custodian
Department and, as such, neither the petitioner nor Mohd. Sadiq has
any proprietary rights over the said land.
6|Page
14.
SWP No. 3143/2015
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well as learned counsel for
the respondents and perused the record.
15.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has fairly submitted that the issue
raised in the instant petition is covered by the judgment passed by this
Court in WP(C) No. 1663/2024, titled Zareena Akhter and Anr. vs.
Union of India and Ors.
16.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further fairly submits that, as on date,
there is no policy of the Government under which the petitioner can
claim an enforceable right to employment in lieu of the land allegedly
donated by him. He, therefore, submits that the instant petition may be
disposed of in the light of the principles laid down by this Court in the
aforesaid judgment.
17.
Learned counsel for the respondents, in addition, submits that there is
no policy of the Government in vogue which confers any enforceable
right upon the petitioner to claim employment in lieu of the land in
question. He further submits that the documents furnished by the
petitioner were found to be not genuine and that the very foundation of
the claim raised in the instant petition stands demolished in view of the
report submitted by the concerned Tehsildar, who has categorically
reported that the land utilized by the Department belongs to the
Custodian Department. It is, therefore, contended that the petitioner has
no locus standi to maintain the instant petition, which is misconceived
and liable to be dismissed, particularly as he has not approached this
Court with clean hands and has suppressed material facts.
7|Page
18.
SWP No. 3143/2015
Learned counsel for the respondents further submits that the water tank
has been constructed over land belonging to the Custodian Department,
therefore, the petitioner cannot claim ownership or proprietary rights
over the said land. Consequently, he has no legal right whatsoever to
seek employment in lieu of land which, in fact, belongs to the
Custodian Department.
19.
It is further submitted that all the aforesaid aspects have been duly
considered
by
the
respondents
after
examining
the
entire
contemporaneous official record, whereafter a detailed consideration
order, which is impugned in the instant petition, came to be passed. It
is, accordingly, contended that the challenge thrown to the said order is
devoid of any merit and the writ petition, being misconceived, deserves
to be dismissed.
20.
Learned counsel for the respondents further submits that the order
passed by the respondents is perfectly legal, justified and in consonance
with the contemporaneous official record. The writ petition challenging
the said order is, therefore, stated to be wholly misconceived and liable
to be dismissed at the threshold.
21.
I am in agreement with the arguments advanced by learned counsel for
the respondents. The petitioner has failed to establish any legal right
over the land in question, particularly when the official report furnished
by the concerned Tehsildar categorically indicates that the land utilized
by the Department belongs to the Custodian Department. The petitioner
cannot, therefore, claim any right to seek employment in lieu of land
over which he has failed to establish any proprietary interest. The claim
8|Page
SWP No. 3143/2015
raised in the instant petition, to the extent it proceeds on the premise
that the petitioner is the owner of the land in question, is not borne out
from the contemporaneous official record.
22.
The petitioner has, therefore, failed to make out any case warranting
interference with the order of consideration passed by the respondents,
particularly when the said order has been passed after taking into
account the relevant contemporaneous official record.
23.
It is also pertinent to note that, when learned counsel for the petitioner
was confronted with the aforesaid position, he fairly conceded that the
issue raised in the instant petition is covered by the recent judgment
passed by this Court and expressed no objection to the disposal of the
instant petition in the light of the principles laid down therein.
24.
Accordingly, having heard learned counsel for the parties and upon
consideration of the contemporaneous official record, this Court finds
no merit in the instant petition. The same is, therefore, dismissed along
with all connected applications, in the light of the judgment passed by
this Court in WP(C) No. 1663/2024, titled Zareena Akhter and Anr. vs.
Union of India and Ors.
(WASIM SADIQ NARGAL)
JUDGE
JAMMU
05.11.2026
Mihul
Whether the order is speaking:
Yes/No
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review