Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 6
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
ATJAMMU
CJ Court
Case: CRAA No. 47/2012
State of J&K
.....Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through :- Ms. Mehar Bali, Advocate &
Mr. Satvik Gupta, Advocate vice
Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG
v/s
Ravi Kumar and others
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. Gagan Kohli, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
ORDER (ORAL)
05.11.2026
1.
Aggrieved by the judgment dated 28.01.2012 rendered by the learned
Session Court, Jammu (for short ‘the trial court)’, whereby
respondents have been acquitted of the charges for the commission
of offences under sections 307,341,326,/34 R.P.C, the appellant-state
has assailed the same on the grounds that the learned trial court
has not appreciated evidence in its right perspective and despite the
fact, that the appellant had proved the commission of offences by
respondents, has erroneously acquitted the respondents.
2.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that there is a consistency
in the evidence because the injured witness Ashwani Kumar himself
has deposed about the three injuries, which are corroborated by the
eyewitnesses and the injured witness himself. She also submits that
the minor discrepancies, which have been gone into by the learned
CRAA No. 47/2012
trial court, would not demolish the prosecution story. She submits
that the credential story of the prosecution was well-established
because the mother Raj Kumari, along with the brother Ramesh
Chander, who were on the spot and also Asha Devi have clearly
deposed that the injuries have been caused by the three accused
persons while they were carrying arms sword, toka, and khokhri,
respectively. She also submits that the injured witness having been
corroborated by the evidence of the Doctor, is an issue which cannot
be wriggled out by the counsel for the respondents, and the judgment
itself would suffer from an infirmity if the acquittal is allowed to be
sustained. She has also drawn attention of this Court to the
examination of other witnesses, i.e., PW Sudesh Kumari, PW Rattan
Lal, PW Kamal Kumar, PW Raj Kumar, and PW Parshotam Singh. It
is further submitted that the wholesome story of recovery of the
weapons, the injuries being caused, are foolproof and the minor
discrepancies in the statements of Raj Kumari, the mother and
Ramesh Kumar have been given undue importance while giving the
benefit of doubt to the respondents. She, further, submits that the
corroborative evidence along with the medical evidence and the
statement of the injured witness, are sufficient to reverse the order of
acquittal.
3.
The counsel for the respondents, however, submits that the
discrepancies in the statements are such that by any stretch of
imagination, the prosecution story cannot be sustained. He has also
drawn attention of this Court to the fact that even in allegations, there
CRAA No. 47/2012
was no such animosity which could have resulted into such an
incident to have happened, as it was merely an incident of cattle
grazing, which allegedly resulted into the incident. The counsel,
further, submits that PW Raj Kumari was a credible witness of the
prosecution and she had deposed in a manner, where she has created
complete confusion, as she claims to have reached the spot as soon
as the altercation started and has attributed Ram Paul with causing
the blow on the right side of her hand. The counsel submits that such
blow, which she claims in her statement, allegedly resulting into
severing of two middle fingers, absolutely falls flat, because severing
of fingers is an injury which would not go unnoticed in terms of the
medical report or the evidence rendered by the Doctor concerned, or
even the other prosecution witnesses. The counsel further submits
that the description of weapons also does not match between all the
statements because Raj Kumari said that Ram Paul was having a
sword, whereas the other accused were carrying toka and khokhri.
Even in the cross-examination, she could not support the recoveries
and the possessing of the arms sword, toka, and khokhri by the
respective accused persons and the timing also in cross-examination
varied as well from the main deposition. The counsel submits that the
moment the prosecution case was blown out of proportion, it was a
reason sufficient for the learned trial court to disbelieve the
testimony
of
these
witnesses.
The
counsel
for
the
accused/respondents further submits that PW Ramesh Chander was
another star witness of the prosecution, because he lodged the
CRAA No. 47/2012
complaint and also claimed that he was also attacked and Ravi
caused a blow with sword which hit him on the fingers and on his
left hand. He also submits that the mother was also there and
Ashwani, the main injured, was also there. The counsel submits that
such act of Ravi is neither supported by the medical evidence nor by
the Doctor and the stray cattle incident seems to have been blown out
of proportion for the purpose of invoking serious offences, for what
the respondents have been charged with. The counsel for the
respondents further submits that this star witness, Ramesh Chander
also could not sustain the exact possession of the weapons by the
respective accused persons, and seems was not at the spot, but has
come later on to support the case and give evidence in favour of the
facts set up by the prosecution. The counsel for the respondents has
further taken us to the witness of PW Asha Devi, who has also
deposed that she knew the accused persons and again the same
discrepancy arose, where Ashwani was said to be beaten, but, at the
same time Ram Paul was said to have the toka, whereas Ravi was
having a sword, and Sham Lal was having a kai with him, which is a
discrepancy, which is varying from evidence to evidence. The
counsel for the respondents also submits that there was no cause of
deeper animosity which could have resulted into an inimical attack
and the burden of proof falls upon the prosecution to prove the case
beyond reasonable doubt. The counsel further submits that even the
injured witness PW Ashwani Kumar, faltered in his description of
the incident, because his deposition is in variance with the witness of
CRAA No. 47/2012
his brother and the complainant Ramesh Chander as well as his
mother's evidence Raj Kumari, who are said to be the eyewitnesses.
The counsel for the respondent also submits that the discrepancies in
the cross-examination regarding the hospitalization and other details
of Ram Paul and other accused persons were also writ large in the
cross-examination. He submits that the Doctor has simply not
supported any injuries of the brother Ramesh Chander and the
motherRaj Kumari, whereas they were very categorical in their
injuries and at best has supported three injuries to Ashwani, who was
the injured witness. The counsel has taken us to the other depositions
of PW Sudesh Kumari, PW Rattan Lal, PW Kamal Kumar, PW Raj
Kumar, PW Parshotam Singh and has pointed out various
discrepancies.
4.
The facts, as noted by this Court, are that FIR No. 48 of 1999 was
registered pursuant to a statement made by the injured-Ramesh
Kumar, and recorded by ASI Purshotam Singh. The statement
recounts an incident of cattle trespass in the victim's paddy fields on
September 1, 1999. It is alleged that Ravi Kumar struck Ashwani
Kumar on the head and arm with a sword, causing multiple injuries.
Further, as per the record, Ram Paul and Sham Lal allegedly dealt
fist blows, and the respondents assaulted Ramesh Kumar and his
mother as well. The investigation was conducted and offences were
found to be made out under Sections 307, 341, 326, 34 of RPC,
307/34 RPC and 4/25 Arms Act, against the accused Ravi Kumar,
Ram Paul, and Sham Lal and the trial commenced. The prosecution
CRAA No. 47/2012
witnesses were examined along with the I.O. and the Doctor, namely,
Dr. Anil Slathia. Learned trial court after hearing the parties,
acquitted respondents.
5.
This Court, after examining the record and evidence and hearing
learned counsel for the parties, finds that the prosecution projected
PW Raj Kumari and PW Ramesh Chander as its two key
eyewitnesses. However, glaring discrepancies exist in their
statements regarding the nature of the weapons carried by the
respective accused. As per Raj Kumari, Ram Paul was armed with
sword and other two accused were armed Khokhri and Toka,
whereas as per Ramesh Chander, Ravi Kumar was armed with
sword. It is worthwhile to observe that Toka and Khkhri were never
seized by the Police.
6.
The collapse of the case did not stop here. This Court takes note of
the fact that both of them have claimed injuries in the endeavor to
show their capacity as eyewitnesses, which are as severe as severing
of two fingers of Raj Kumari and other injuries to Ramesh Chander,
which have absolutely not found place anywhere in the medical
record or the statement of the Doctor. There would have been one
thing if they would not have deposed and the prosecution testimony
had solely relied upon the injured witness and Doctor, which could
have been a sequence, which could go unscratched in terms of
criminal jurisprudence, but the moment the star witnesses or the
eyewitnesses, which have been brought forward by the prosecution,
start giving prosecution story a completely different turn in terms of
CRAA No. 47/2012
injury and the weapons contained, even which are not sustained, then
the benefit of doubt starts entering the array for dealing with the
situation.
7.
PWs Ramesh Chander and Raj Kumar have been cited as marginal
witnesses to the disclosure memo regarding the disclosure made by
accused Ravi Kumar regarding weapon of offence i.e. sword and
recover memo of the same. Both these witnesses are related and
interested/injured witnesses and not withstanding their status, both
these witnesses are not in tandem and not on the same wave length,
as one did not agree with the recovery, whereas the other did agree,
but ultimately this also cast a doubt in the mind of the Court because
despite the presence of residents of the vicinity, they were not cited
as witnesses. Also, PW Ramesh Chander did not prove the disclosure
statement and even denied that any weapon of offence was recovered
in his presence. Though IO stated about the disclosure statement, but
in absence of any cogent evidence regarding recovery of weapon of
offence, the disclosure statement also becomes doubtful and
inconsequential.
8.
This Court also observes that the learned Trial Court conducted a
threadbare evaluation of the evidence, thoroughly considering all
aspects of the case including the specific weapons attributed to each
accused, the injuries inflicted, and the discrepancies emerging from
the cross-examination of the key witnesses, before arriving at a
considered conclusion. It is a well-settled proposition of law that
even where two views are reasonably possible, the Appellate Court
CRAA No. 47/2012
ought not to substitute its own view for that of the Trial Court merely
because another view exists.
9.
In light of the aforesaid mentioned facts, no cause of interference is
being made out. The appeal is dismissed.
(RAJNESH OSWAL) (DR. PUSHPENDRA SINGH BHATI)
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
JAMMU
05.11.2026
Pawan Angotra
Whether the order is speaking? : Yes/No
Whether the order is reportable? : Yes/No
CRAA No. 47/2012
Pawan Angotra
2026.11.16 13:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review