Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT
JAMMU
LPA 70/2022
Reserved on: 15.07.2026
Pronounced on: 11.08.2026
Uploaded on: 11.08.2026
Whether the operative part of full
judgment is pronounced: Full
UT of Jammu and Kashmir through
Commissioner Secretary to Government,
Forest Ecology Department.
Appellant
Vs.
Neeru Pandita
Through: -
CORAM:
…Respondent(s)
Ms Meenakshi Salathia Adv. for
appellant.
Mr. P.N. Bhat Sr. Advocate for respondent.
HON‟BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Chief Justice (A)
PREFACE:
The present Full Bench has been constituted pursuant to an order
of reference dated 11.09.2024 made by a Division Bench of this Court
noticing a conflict of opinion between two judgments rendered by Coordinate
Benches of equal strength regarding the interpretation and effect of Section 5
of the Jammu and Kashmir Civil Services (Special Provisions) Act, 2010
(hereinafter referred to as “the Act of 2010”), particularly the 1st proviso
appended thereto.
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
In LPASW No.29/2019 titled “Abdul Majid Magray v. State
of J&K and others” decided on 18.05.2022, a Division Bench of this Court
has held that regularization of eligible ad hoc, contractual or consolidated
appointees would take effect only from the date of actual regularization and
not from any earlier date, even if such appointees have completed seven
years of service earlier. However, an earlier Division Bench in “Rabia Shah
v. State of Jammu & Kashmir and others”, reported as 2017 (I) JKJ 490
(HC), while considering Section 5 read with Section 10 of the Act of 2010,
has held that once an employee fulfills the statutory conditions for
regularization, he/she becomes entitled to regularization from the date on
which eligibility is acquired and the authorities are required to complete the
process within the prescribed time.
With a view to saving the provision from being rendered ultra
vires the Constitution, the Division Bench of this Court in Rabia Shah's case
(supra) has, by resort to Section 10 in conjunction with Section 5 of the Act
of 2010, held that regularization shall take effect 150 days after the right to
regularization has accrued.
Since both the judgments were rendered by Coordinate Benches
of equal strength and expressed conflicting views on the issue, the matter has
been referred to this Larger Bench for authoritative determination.
QUESTIONS:
In the present reference, the following questions arise for
determination:
(i)Whether the proviso 1 of Section 5 of the Act of 2010 confers
unfettered and unbridled power on the Government to pass order
of regularization of an ad hoc, contractual or consolidated
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
appointee having completed 07 years of service on the appointed
date or thereafter and whether reservation of such unfettered and
unbridled power in the executive by a statutory provision is ultra
vires the Constitution.
(ii) Whether the provisions of Section 10 can be read into
Section 5 of the Act of 2010 to hold that the Government is
under an obligation to complete the entire exercise culminating
in the passing of an order of regularization in respect of an
eligible ad hoc, contractual or consolidated appointee within 150
days from the appointed day and, therefore, the effective date for
regularization would be 150 days after acquiring the eligibility
for regularization.
(iii)Which of the two judgments, namely Abdul Majid
Magray‟s case or Rabia Shah‟s case, lays down the correct
position of law?
STATUTORY PROVISIONS:
In view of the controversy involved, the provisions contained in
Section 5 and 10 of the Act are required to be noticed:
“5.Regularization of adhoc or contractual or consolidated
appointees- Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in
any law for the time being in force or any judgment or order of any
court or tribunal, the adhoc or contractual or consolidated
appointees referred to in section 3 shall be regularized on fulfilment
of the following conditions, namely: (i)That he has been appointed against a clear vacancy of post;
(ii) That he continues as such on appointed day;
(iii) That he possessed the requisite qualification and eligibility for
the post on the date of his initial appointment on adhoc or
contractual or consolidated basis as prescribed under the recruitment
rules governing the services of post;
iv. That no disciplinary or criminal proceeding are pending against
him on the appointed day; and
v. That he has completed seven years of service as such on the
appointed day. her conditions which were laid under special
provision Act, 2010, envisaged as under, now scrapped by the
Government of India:
Provided that the regularization of the eligible adhoc or contractual
or consolidated appointees under this Act shall have effect only from
the date of such regularization, irrespective of the fact that such
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
appointees have completed more than seven years of service on the
appointed date or thereafter but before such regularization;
Provided further that any adhoc or contractual consolidated
appointee who has not completed seven-year service on the
appointed day shall continue as such till completion of seven years
and shall thereafter be entitled to regularization under this Act.
10. Empowered Committee.-(1) There shall be an Empowered
Committee consisting of(i) Administrative Secretary: Finance Department
(ii) Administrative Secretary, General Administration DepartmentMember
(iii) Administrative Secretary of the concerned Department-Member
(iv) Director General, Accounts and Treasuries-Member
(v) Director, Codes, Finance Department-Member Secretary;
(2) The Department shall within sixty days from the commencement
of this Act, refer all the cases of ad hoc or contractual or
consolidated appointees eligible for regularization under section 5 to
the Member Secretary for being placed before the Empowered
Committee for scrutiny and verification with regard to their
entitlement to regularization under this Act.
(2-A) The Empowered Committee shall not entertain any case of ad
hoc or contractual or consolidated appointee after the expiry of
period specified in the sub-section (2)
(3). The Empowered Committee shall examine such cases and notify
the names of such ad hoc/contractual/consolidated employees who
have been found eligible for regularization under said section 5 in
respect of each Department within fifteen days period for filing of
objections before the Committee.
(4) The Empowered Committee shall thereafter examine the
complainants, if any, received and make appropriate
recommendation (s) to the concerned administrative department with
regard to regularization in respect of each case on fulfillment of the
conditions specified under section 5 or rejection of the case.
(5) The concerned Administrative Department shall issue orders of
regularization after seeking the approval of the Chief Minister
through the Chief Secretary. in coordination.
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
EARLIER JUDGMENTS:
Before we advert to the issue in controversy, it would be
appropriate to briefly notice hereinafter the views expressed on the issue by
various Single Benches as well as Division Benches of this Court.
(I) Rabia Shah v. State of Jammu and Kashmir and others, ( SWP No.
624 of 2014, decided on 19.05.2015:
In the said case, the petitioner, Rabia Shah, filed a writ petition
seeking regularization of her services under the provisions of the Jammu and
Kashmir Civil Services (Special Provisions) Act, 2010 with effect from
23.06.2006, i.e., the date on which she had completed seven years of service.
The writ petition was allowed by a Division Bench of this Court vide an
order and judgment dated 19.05.2015.The erstwhile State of Jammu and
Kashmir sought review of the aforesaid judgment on the ground that the
direction to regularize the services of Rabia Shah with effect from
23.06.2006 was antithetic to the express provisions contained in Section 5 of
the Act of 2010, which empowered the Government to regularize the services
of ad hoc, contractual and consolidated appointees. While considering the
review petition, the Division Bench proceeded to determine whether the
petitioner would be entitled to regularization only from a date posterior to the
commencement of the Act of 2010 and not from any date anterior thereto
and, if so, from which date. The Division Bench examined the issue in the
light of Sections 5 and 10 of the Act of 2010 and concluded that appointees
like Rabia Shah could be regularized only upon fulfilment of the conditions
stipulated in Section 5 and in accordance with the procedure prescribed under
Section 10 of the Act. It was further held that such regularization could be
made effective only from a date posterior to the appointed day, as the Act of
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
2010 did not have any retrospective application. The Court held that the first
proviso to Section 5 specifically provides that the regularization of such
appointees shall take effect only from the date of regularization irrespective
of the fact that they had completed more than seven years of service on the
appointed day or thereafter, but before such regularization. The Court,
therefore, opined that regularization could not be granted from a date anterior
to the appointed day. Responding to the contention of Rabia Shah that, she
having been found to have completed the prescribed seven years of service
much before the appointed day and fulfilled the conditions stipulated in
Section 5 of the Act, its provisions could not be read in a manner so as to
confer an unbridled discretion on the Government to order regularization as
and when it wished, at its whims and caprice, the Division Bench found the
answer in Section 10 of the Act, which had laid down a timeline for
completion of the process of regularization of eligible employees.
Accordingly, it was held that employees who had completed seven years or
more of service on the appointed day were entitled to regularization from a
date atleast 150 days posterior to the appointed day. With these observations,
the earlier judgment dated 19.05.2015 was recalled in review and Rabia Shah
was held entitled to regularization with effect from a date 150 days after the
appointed day. This view thereafter came to be followed by several Single as
well as Division Benches of this Court.
(II) State of Jammu and Kashmir v. Afaq Rasool Gadda and another
(LPASW No. 118/2017, decided on 04.08.2017
In this case also, the actual date from which the regularization
under the Act of 2010 was to operate became the subject matter of debate.
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
The State contended that, in view of the clear provisions of Section 5, the
regularization shall operate prospectively from the date of issuance of the
order of regularization, whereas it was the contention of the respondents,
Afaq Rasool and another, that they were entitled to regularization
retrospectively with effect from the date they completed seven years of ad
hoc service, even if such date was prior to the appointed day. The Division
Bench placed reliance upon Rabia Shah‟ case (supra) and held that the
regularization of the respondents, Afaq Rasool and another, shall take effect
from a date 150 days posterior to the appointed day.
(III) Ghulam Hassan Ganai v. State of J&K and others, (SWP No.
1970/2015, decided on 11.10.2017)
In this petition, the petitioner, claiming to have completed seven
years of continuous service much before the appointed day, i.e., November,
2006, had sought a direction to the State to regularize his services
retrospectively with effect from November, 2006 or, at least, within a period
of 150 days posterior to the appointed day under the Act of 2010, which is
28.04.2010. The petitioner had also laid a challenge to the vires of the Act of
2010 to the extent it provided for regularization prospectively irrespective of
the completion of seven years of service as a consolidated employee much
earlier. A learned Single Bench of this Court disposed of the petition by
placing reliance upon the judgment in Rabia Shah‟s case (supra) and held
the writ petitioner entitled to regularization with effect from a date 150 days
posterior to the appointed day.
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
(IV) State of J&K and others v. Ulfat Ara and others (LPASW No.
39/2019 c/w connected appeals, decided on 27.11.2020)
The view taken by the Division Bench in Rabia Shah‟s case
(supra) was approved, and the Letters Patent Appeals challenging the
judgments of the writ Court passed on the basis of the law laid down in
Rabia Shah‟s case were dismissed. Paragraph 11 of the judgment is
noteworthy and is, therefore, set out below:
“11) We have carefully gone through the judgment of the Writ
Court and do not find any illegality or infirmity therein. We also
feel bound by the judgment rendered by the Division Bench of
this Court in the case of Rabia Shah. Despite great persuasion of
Mr. Chashoo, AAG, we could not persuade ourselves to give a
re-look to the judgment rendered in the case of Rabia Shah nor
could we find any distinctive features in the appeals in hand. It
may be noteworthy that if the arguments of Mr. Chashoo based
on his understanding of Section 5 were to be accepted, the first
Proviso to Section 5 of the Act of 2010 would be rendered ultra
vires the Constitution for it would concede arbitrary and
unbridled power to the competent c/w authority to order
regularization of an eligible ad hoc/contractual/ consolidated
appointee at its whims and on the date of its choosing. But as is
well settled, there is a presumption in the Constitutionality of an
Act of Legislature and the provisions thereof and the Courts are
loath to declare them unconstitutional unless a cast iron case for
such declaration is made out. In the case of Rabia Shah, the
Division Bench acted on such presumption and
interpreted Section 5 in a manner that would save it from being
assailed as unconstitutional. Para 12 of the judgment in Rabia
Shah‟s case deserves to be noticed at this stage and the same
reads thus:
"12. A conjoint reading of the various provisions of the 2010
Act, especially the two above quoted provisos appended
to Section 5 and Section 10 thereof, makes it unambiguously
manifest that such appointees could be regularized only subject
to the fulfillment of conditions stipulated in Section 5 and in
accordance with the procedure prescribed in Section 10, and that
such regularization could be made effective only from a date
posterior to the appointed day. The 2010 Act did not have any
retrospective application. It is specifically provided in the first
proviso appended to Section 5, as quoted above, that the
regularization of such appointees under the Act shall have effect
only from the date of such regularization irrespective of the fact
that such appointees have completed more than seven years of
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
service on the appointed day or thereafter, but before such
regularization, meaning thereby the regularization could not be
ordered from a date anterior to the appointed day. The
requirement of possession and completion of seven years‟
service as such, as provided in Section 5(v) of the Act, is one of
the conditions of eligibility, qualifying and entitling such an
appointee for regularization on or after the appointed day, not
anterior thereto."
(V) Dr. Muneeb Iqbal v. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir and
others (WP(C ) No. 551/2021, decided on 10.02.2025
In this case, the Division Bench had the advantage of the
judgment rendered by the Supreme Court in SLP(C) No. 8720/2021 titled
„State of Jammu and Kashmir and others v. Mohd. Syed Parray and
others, wherein the Supreme Court, after adverting to the provisions of the
Act of 2010, particularly Section 5 thereof, held that ad hoc, contractual or
consolidated appointees having completed seven years of continuous service
as such on the appointed day were entitled to be regularized only with effect
from the appointed day and not from any date anterior thereto. Clearing the
air around the first proviso to Section 5, the Division Bench, in paragraph 12,
held thus:
“12. In view of clear interpretation of Proviso Ist made by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, it is no more debatable as to whether an
eligible ad hoc, contractual or consolidated appointee who has
completed seven years or more service on the appointed date, is
to be regularized with effect from the appointed date or from the
date a formal order of his regularization is passed”
There was, however, no discussion or interpretation made in respect of
the second proviso. The judgment made a slight departure from the earlier
position settled in Rabia Shah‟s case (supra) that an eligible ad hoc,
contractual or consolidated appointee, having completed seven years or more
of service on the appointed day, shall be entitled to be regularized with effect
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
from a date 150 days posterior to the appointed day. The Division Bench
was, however, of the view that an eligible ad hoc, contractual or consolidated
employee, having completed seven years or more of service on the appointed
day, had an accrued right of regularization from such date and, therefore, his
regularization could not be postponed by 150 days, which was merely a
procedural requirement to complete the exercise of regularization.
(V). Abdul Majid Magray v. State of Jammu and Kashmir and others
(LPASW No. 29/2019, decided on 18.05.2022)
In this case, a Division Bench of this Court, for the first time,
took a view contrary to the one taken in Rabia Shah’s case (supra) and
consistently followed by different Division Benches and Single Benches of
this Court. The Division Bench interpreted the provisions of Section 5,
particularly the first proviso thereof, literally and came to the conclusion that
regularization of eligible ad hoc, contractual or consolidated appointees under
the Act shall take effect only from the date of regularization, irrespective of
the fact that the appointees may have completed more than seven years of
service on the appointed day or thereafter but before such regularization. The
Division Bench did not rely upon Rabia Shah on the ground that the
controversy before the Division Bench in Rabia Shah was only with regard to
regularization of services of the petitioner therein, and the Division Bench,
without noticing the proviso to Section 5 of the Act, had held her entitled to
regularization on completion of seven years of service. It was opined that
there was no controversy before the Division Bench hearing Rabia Shah as to
the date from which the regularization could be made. The Division Bench
thus concluded that since the Division Bench had not considered the effective
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
date of entitlement of regularization of the petitioner therein, the judgment
did not lay down good law to be followed as a precedent with regard to the
effective date of regularization under the Act of 2010.
What was held by the Division Bench in Abdul Majid Magrey’s
case (supra) is summed up in paragraphs 9 and 10 of the judgment, which,
for facility of reference, are set out below:
“9. In view of the unequivocal language employed in the
aforesaid proviso, it is implicit that the regularization has to be
from the date of regularization irrespective of the person having
completed 7 years of service earlier. There is no other statutory
rule or provision which may provide for regularization of the
services of the petitioner-appellant from some earlier date than
the date of regularization. The regularization, as such, cannot be
ordered from any earlier date other than the date of the
regularization.
10. In the case of Mrs.Rabia Shah v State of J&K and
others (SWP No.624/2014), the controvery was simply with
regard to the regularization of the services of the petitioner
therein and the Court without noticing the proviso to Section 5
of the aforesaid Act held that the petitioner is entitled for
regularization on completion of 7 years of service. There was no
controversy before the Division Bench as to the date of
regularization of the petitioner therein. The said Division Bench
has not considered about the effective date of entitlement of
reglarisation of the petitioner thein and, as such, is not a good
precedent to be followed in a case where the controversy is
regarding the effective date of regularization of the
candidate. Since the other decision relied upon by the learned
counsel for the petitioner-appellant is based upon the above
decision of Mrs Rabia Shah (supra), we are of the opinion that
the same will also not be of any assistance to the petitionerappellant rather while referring to Rabia Shah's case (supra) it
clearly mentions that the regularization of appointees under the
Act shall have effect only from the date of such regularization
irrespective of the fact that such appointees may have completed
7 years or more service on the appointed date or thereafter but
before regularization.
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
(VI). Ghulam Rasool Bhat and others vs State and others (WP(C ) No.
175/2020, decided on 19.12.2025)
In this matter, the learned Single Judge noticed the two
conflicting views given by two different Benches of co-equal strength, one
rendered in Rabia Shah’s case and the other rendered in Abdul Majid
Magrey’s case (supra). Relying upon various judgments of the Supreme
Court, the learned Single Judge followed the view taken by the Division
Bench in Abdul Majid Magre’s case on the ground that the said judgment
was more logical and was also later in point of time. Having dealt with the
ratio laid down in the earlier two Division Bench judgments, the learned
Single Judge thus held that the regularization of eligible ad hoc, contractual
or consolidated appointees shall take effect from the date sanction is
accorded by the competent authority for regularization of their services.
DISCUSSION & ANALYSIS:
Noticing the cleavage of judicial opinion on the issue, which
primarily touches upon the true interpretation and effect of Section 5 of the
Act of 2010, a Division Bench of this Court thought it appropriate to resolve
the conflict by authoritative determination by the Full Bench.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties, carefully gone
through the different provisions of the Act of 2010, particularly the
provisions of Sections 5 and 10 thereof, as also the views on the point
expressed by different Single Benches and Division Benches of this Court.
It is an undeniable fact that successive Governments in the
erstwhile State of Jammu and Kashmir had been consistently indulging in
backdoor appointments. Thousands of appointments to Government service
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
were made without issuing advertisement notifications and without
conducting any selection process. The men in power picked up persons of
their choice and appointed them against different posts by giving them
different nomenclatures. Some were appointed as daily wagers, some as
casual workers and some as contractual employees. There were persons
engaged against substantive vacant posts on ad hoc and consolidated basis as
well. These persons, who were brought into Government service on
temporary basis through backdoor means, were later conferred legitimacy by
regularizing their services. One such policy decision to regularize en masse
the daily-rated workers was taken in the year 1994 when the Jammu and
Kashmir Regularization of Daily Rated Workers/Work Charged Employees
Regularization Rules, 1994 were promulgated vide SRO 64 of 1994 dated
24.03.1994. This was followed by Government Order No. 1220-GAD of
1989 dated 11.09.1989, which laid the foundation for regularization of
thousands of backdoor appointees working on ad hoc basis against clear
vacancies, both Gazetted and Non-Gazetted. Thereafter, Government Order
No. 1285-GAD of 2001 dated 06.11.2001 came to be issued, further
extending the process of regularization of such appointees . These were, of
course, policy decisions of the Government. However, for the first time in the
year 2010, the Jammu and Kashmir State Legislature enacted the Act of 2010
with a view to providing for regularization of employees appointed on ad
hoc, contractual or consolidated basis.As per Section 2(c), the date of
commencement of the Act, i.e., 28.04.2010, was declared as the appointed
day for the purpose of giving effect to the various provisions of the Act of
2010. Section 3 of the Act deals with the application of the Act, whereas
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
Section 4 provides for exclusion of various vacancies held by ad hoc,
contractual or consolidated appointees, who had acquired eligibility for
regularization under the Act, from the purview of recruitment agencies.
Section 5 is vital and lies at the core of the controversy raised in the present
matter. Section 5 contains a non obstante clause and, therefore, has an
overriding effect over any law for the time being in force or any judgment or
order of any Court or Tribunal. It provides that an ad hoc, contractual or
consolidated appointee shall be regularised on fulfilment of five prescribed
conditions.
It is, thus, evident that if a person is working in Government
service on ad hoc, contractual or consolidated basis, he shall be regularised
upon fulfilment of certain conditions, including the condition that he has
completed seven years of service as such on the appointed day. The proviso,
which has been understood by different Division Benches in different
manners, lays down that the regularization of an eligible ad hoc, contractual
or consolidated appointee shall have effect only from the date of such
regularization. The expression "such regularization" is of paramount
importance and refers to the regularization provided in the main provision of
Section 5.The main provision of Section 5 clearly provides that an ad hoc,
contractual or consolidated appointee shall be regularized upon fulfillment of
the five conditions enumerated therein, meaning thereby that if such
employee has completed seven years of service on the appointed day and
fulfils other eligibility conditions, he would be entitled to regularization
forthwith. Viewed thus, an ad hoc, contractual or consolidated appointee
acquires the right of regularization on the appointed day itself, provided he
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
has by that time completed seven years of service and meets the other
prescribed eligibility requirements. It does not matter whether a formal order
of his regularization is passed on the appointed day or subsequently after
undertaking the procedure laid down in Section 10 of the Act of 2010.It
needs no emphasis that Section 10 is procedural in nature and lays down a
detailed procedure for processing cases of regularization of employees
covered by the Act of 2010 before the Empowered Committee. A clear
timeline has been prescribed in Section 10 to avoid unnecessary delay in
conferring the benefit of regularization envisaged under the Act of 2010.The
timeline prescribed is not mandatory in nature and may be overstepped in
appropriate cases. We say so because although Section 10 uses the expression
"shall" throughout, it does not prescribe any consequence for failure to
adhere to the timeline provided therein.
We are, therefore, of the clear opinion that the timeline
prescribed in Section 10, i.e., 150 days prescribed for completing the process
of regularization, has nothing to do with the effective date from which a
candidate is entitled to be regularized. As already stated, the main provision
of Section 5 confers upon an ad hoc, contractual or consolidated appointee
the right of regularization immediately upon fulfillment of the five conditions
laid down therein. The first proviso has been added to the main Section only
to make it unambiguous and unequivocal that the eligible ad hoc, contractual
or consolidated appointees shall be given effect of regularization only from
the date of such regularization, i.e., regularization envisaged under the main
Section, irrespective of the fact that such appointee may have completed
more than seven years of service on the appointed day.In other words, all
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
eligible ad hoc, contractual or consolidated appointees having seven years or
more than seven years of service as such on the appointed day shall be treated
on a par and shall be deemed to have fulfilled the requirement of completion
of seven years of service on the appointed day. To make it more clear, there
may be persons who have completed 10 years, 15 years or 20 years of ad hoc
service and there may be some who have just completed seven years of ad
hoc service on the appointed day, yet all of them shall be regularised with
effect from the appointed day. It is with a view to avoid confusion on this
aspect that the first proviso was added. It is true that in the last line of the
proviso, the expression "or thereafter" has been used, but we are convinced
that the expression "or thereafter" has been unnecessarily used and does not
convey any meaning.
20.
As per the principles of statutory interpretation, the doctrine of
surplusage indicates that Courts presume that the Legislature does not use
unnecessary words. Yet, in exceptional cases, words may be treated as
surplusage or read down if giving them their literal meaning would defeat the
object of the statute or lead to an absurd result. The doctrine of reading down
could also be applied if the literal meaning given to a word or expression
renders the entire provision ultra vires the Constitution. The expression “or
thereafter” is not referable to the cases of regularization of those employees
who complete seven years of service after the appointed date. The first
proviso, which carries the expression “or thereafter”, is more explanatory
than an exception to the main provision of Section 5 of the Act of 2010. The
regularization of employees completing seven years after the appointed date
is dealt with by the second proviso. It is, therefore, totally inappropriate to
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
read the first proviso into the second proviso. As a matter of fact, both are
provisos to the main Section and not to each other.
21.
If we interpret the provision literally, as has been done by the
Division Bench in Abdul Majid Magray’s case, it would mean that the
effective date of regularization of an eligible ad hoc, contractual or
consolidated appointee shall not be definite but shall depend upon the whims
and caprice of the Government. And that would render the provision ultra
vires the Constitution, inasmuch as it would be left to the choice of the
Government to regularize persons from a date of its choosing, thereby
creating discrimination between similarly situated employees. A person
whose case is cleared within 150 days would be regularized earlier than a
person whose case takes years to be cleared by the Empowered Committee,
and such delay could occur for various reasons not attributable to the
employee. Such an interpretation would not only result in discrimination
between similarly situated persons but would also suffer from the vice of
arbitrariness. It is a well-established rule of statutory interpretation that when
a literal reading leads to absurdity, anomaly, inconsistency or manifest
injustice, the Court may adopt a purposive construction to correct it. A
similar view has been taken by the Division Bench in Rabia Shah, wherein
the vires of proviso is sought to be saved by importing the concept of 150
days from Section 10 of the Act. We, however, look at the issue from a
slightly different angle. When we reconcile the first proviso with the main
provision, we clearly find that the right of regularization accrues to an
eligible ad hoc, contractual or consolidated appointee immediately upon
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
fulfilment of the prescribed five conditions, and the process of regularization
followed by a formal order of regularization may take some time.
At this stage of discussion, we also need to take note of the
second proviso to Section 5, which provides that an ad hoc, contractual or
consolidated appointee who has not completed seven years of service on the
appointed day shall be allowed to continue till he completes seven years of
service and thereafter shall be entitled to regularization under the Act. This
proviso has been put at the end of Section 5. The expression which has been
totally misunderstood and misinterpreted, i.e., "appointed day or thereafter",
used in the first proviso, has nothing to do with the second proviso. The
second proviso also makes it abundantly clear that an ad hoc, contractual or
consolidated appointee who may not have completed seven years of service
on the appointed day may complete the requisite period in subsequent
year(s), and he too shall be entitled to regularization immediately upon
completion of seven years. There is thus no question of postponement of the
effective date of regularization depending upon when the competent authority
passes a formal order of regularization. The date on which the right of
regularization is acquired is different from the date on which a formal order
of regularization is passed by the competent authority. The date of acquisition
of the right of regularization is statutory in character and does not depend
upon the choice or discretion of the authority, whereas the latter depends
upon the choice, convenience and even the whims of the authority designated
to pass the order of regularization.
In view of the above discussion, we answer the questions
referred to this Full Bench as under:
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
(i) The first proviso to Section 5 of the Act of 2010 does not
give the Government an unfettered power to decide the date of
regularization of an eligible ad hoc, contractual or consolidated
appointee. It has to be read together with the main provision of
Section 5 and cannot be interpreted to mean that the Government
is free to choose any date of regularization at its own discretion.
(ii) Section 10 is only procedural in nature. It lays down the
procedure and the time-frame for processing cases of
regularization. However, the period of 150 days cannot be read
into Section 5 for deciding the effective date of regularization.
The right to regularization arises as soon as an employee fulfils
all the conditions prescribed under Section 5 and cannot not be
postponed till the expiry of 150 days.
(iii) Accordingly, neither Abdul Majid Magray nor Rabia Shah
states the correct legal position in its entirety. Judgment in Abdul
Majid Magray’s case is overruled to the extent it holds that
regularization takes effect only from the date on which the
formal order of regularization is issued. Judgment in Rabia Shah
is approved insofar as it holds that the Government cannot
postpone regularization at its own will and that the right to
regularization accrues on fulfillment of the statutory conditions.
However, it is overruled to the extent it holds that regularization
becomes effective only after the expiry of 150 days by reading
Section 10 into Section 5.
The reference is answered accordingly. The matter be placed
before the appropriate Division Bench for disposal in accordance with the
law laid down in this judgment. The Judgment shall have prospective effect
and shall apply to pending and future cases. The cases already settled or
finally disposed of shall not be reopened.
(MOHD. YOUSUF WANI)
JUDGE
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
(SANJEEV KUMAR)
CHIEF JUSTICE(A)
Jammu
11.08.2026
Sanjeev
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
11.08.26
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review