Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 18
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
LPA No. 153/2026
Pronounced on : 28.10.2026
Uploaded on : 30.10.2026
UT of J & K & Ors.
.....Applicant(s)
Through :- Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA
v/s
Gopal Krishan
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. Abhinav Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Abhimanyu Sharma, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Impugned in this intra-court appeal, filed by the UT of J & K and
its functionaries, under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent, is an order
and judgment dated 25.03.2026 passed by a learned Single Judge of
this Court [“the Writ Court”] in WP (C) No. 1776/2020 titled
“Gopal Krishan Vs. UT of J & K & Ors.”, whereby the Writ Court
has allowed the petition filed by the respondent and has set aside
the inquiry proceedings leading to the order dated 20.05.2020
issued by the Commissioner, Jammu Municipal Corporation,
dismissing the respondent from service. There is a further direction
to the appellants to process the case of the respondent for grant of
pension and consequential benefits.
2.
Briefly stated, the facts leading to the filing of this appeal are that
the respondent was appointed as Sanitary Inspector in Jammu
LPA No. 153/2026
Municipal Corporation (JMC). He came to be promoted as
Enforcement Inspector in the year 2016 and was posted, as such, for
Ward Nos. 51, 52, 53 and 54 of Jammu from 07.02.2019 to
31.07.2019. On 18.06.2019, the appellants received a complaint
from one Smt. Jyoti Devi, Corporator Ward No. 53, Trikuta Nagar,
Jammu making serious allegations against the respondent with
regard to his connivance in the unauthorized constructions going on
in Ward No. 53. On the basis of aforesaid complaint, a preliminary
inquiry was conducted by the Assistant Commissioner (Revenue),
JMC, who submitted his report on 27.07.2019 to the Commissioner,
JMC. On the basis of the fact finding report submitted by the
Assistant Commissioner (Revenue), JMC, the respondent was
placed under suspension vide order dated 31.07.2019 issued by
Commissioner, JMC. The Secretary, JMC was appointed as the
Inquiry Officer to look into the allegations against the respondent.
Accordingly, a fresh preliminary inquiry was conducted by the
Secretary, JMC, who, after a detailed inquiry, submitted his report
and recommendations vide communication dated 12.12.2019.
3.
There was another complaint received by the Commissioner, JMC
against the respondent which made the Commissioner, JMC, who
was also the disciplinary authority, qua the respondent, to initiate
formal departmental proceedings against the respondent in terms of
Rule 33 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal)
Rules, 1956 [“the Rules of 1956”].
LPA No. 153/2026
4.
The article of charges and statement of imputations were served
upon the respondent, who was asked to file his written statement
within a period of 07 days. The respondent submitted his written
statement on 22.02.2020 denying all the charges and imputations.
The Commissioner, JMC decided to hold the inquiry herself and
thus, acted as Inquiry Officer in the matter.
5.
Admittedly,
out
of
witnesses
cited
with
article
of
charges/imputation, not even a single witness was examined, rather
the matter was taken up by the disciplinary authority/Inquiry
Officer with the Joint Commissioner (A), JMC to verify the
veracity of statement of defence submitted by the respondent,
particularly in relation to the constructions raised between
February, 2019 to July, 2019 in the Wards under supervision of the
respondent. It seems that the Joint Commissioner (A), JMC
submitted a report in this regard to the Inquiry Officer on
20.04.2020. The Inquiry Officer neither shared this report of Joint
Commissioner (A), JMC with the respondent nor any opportunity
was granted to the respondent to dispute the same.
6.
Be that as it may, the Commissioner, JMC, relying upon the report
of the Joint Commissioner (A), JMC, admittedly prepared at the
back of the respondent, straightaway issued notice of proposed
penalty to the respondent, in terms of Section 30 of the Rules of
1956. The notice of proposed penalty was replied by the
respondent, who in his reply raised the grievance that the inquiry
LPA No. 153/2026
was ex-parte without giving him adequate opportunity to defend.
Upon consideration of the reply submitted by the respondent to the
proposed penalty, the Commissioner, JMC vide order bearing No.
JMC/PS/COM/279 dated 20.05.2020 dismissed the respondent from
service.
7.
The impugned inquiry proceedings including the order of dismissal
dated 20.05.2020 were assailed by the respondent before the Writ
Court in WP (C) No. 1776/2020. The Writ Court, after having
considered the rival contentions and perused the inquiry report,
came to the conclusion that the Inquiry Officer had not adhered to
the principles of natural justice. In the inquiry, an adequate
opportunity to defend was never provided to the respondent. The
Writ Court was of the opinion that the report prepared by the Joint
Commissioner (A), JMC, on the directions of the Inquiry Officer,
could not have been relied upon unless the same was put to the
delinquent i.e. the respondent herein and such delinquent given a
fair opportunity to rebut. The Writ Court has also gone into certain
other aspects of the matter in view of the arguments raised by the
learned senior counsel appearing for the respondent.
8.
The appellants are aggrieved of and have challenged the judgment
of the Writ Court, primarily, on the ground that the Writ Court has
failed to appreciate that the respondent was given adequate
opportunity at all stages of inquiry. Learned counsel for the
appellants has submitted that the respondent was associated with
LPA No. 153/2026
the preliminary inquiry conducted into the matter by the Assistant
Commissioner (Revenue), JMC. Copy of the charge-sheet was also
served upon the respondent to which he submitted his detailed
reply.
9.
It is further submitted that the order of dismissal was issued only
after putting the respondent to show cause notice of proposed
penalty. In support of his submissions, he has also produced the
original inquiry record.
10.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record, we are in complete agreement with the
findings of fact recorded by the Writ Court that the inquiry
proceedings in the instant case are vitiated for non-compliance with
the principles of natural justice. We have carefully gone through the
original record produced before us and we find that no inquiry,
worth the name, was conducted after the reply to the charge-sheet
was submitted by the respondent. None of the witnesses, cited in
the article of charge and statement of imputations in support
thereof, were examined nor was there any occasion for the
respondent to cross-examine such witnesses. The entire inquiry
proceedings have been concluded on the basis of the fact finding
report submitted by the Joint Commissioner (A), JMC, who was
tasked by the Inquiry Officer to verify the assertions made by the
respondent in his defence in the reply submitted to the charge-sheet.
11.
LPA No. 153/2026
Interestingly, the report of the Joint Commissioner (A), JMC was
not shared with the respondent nor was he given any opportunity to
dispute the same by producing contrary evidence. Even the
statement of the respondent has not been recorded during the course
of inquiry. Subsequent notice of the proposed penalty on the basis
of such inquiry would not cure the defect in the inquiry, which is
vitiated for non-compliance with the principles of natural justice.
12.
The respondent has been admittedly prejudiced by not providing
him the copy of the report submitted by the Joint Commissioner
(A), JMC which ultimately formed basis of conclusion of inquiry
against the respondent and imposing upon him the major penalty of
dismissal from service.
13.
We, however, do not find any substance in the argument raised by
Mr. Abhinav Sharma, learned senior counsel, representing the
respondent that the Commissioner, JMC being the disciplinary
authority and having served a charge-sheet upon the respondent was
not competent to act as an Inquiry Officer. Sub-rule 4 of Rule 33 of
the Rules of 1956 clearly provides that the competent authority may
inquire into the charges itself or if it considers it necessary so to do,
it may appoint an inquiry officer for the purpose. The competent
authority envisaged under Rule 33 is a disciplinary authority who is
also competent to serve upon the delinquent member of service the
charges and statement of imputation in support thereof.
14.
LPA No. 153/2026
After arguing for a while, Mr. Sharma was fair enough to concede
to this position but would submit that when the Inquiry Officer and
disciplinary authority is one, there is every likelihood of such
authority proceedings with a predetermined mind to punish the
delinquent.
15.
Be that as it may, since the legal position in this regard is not
contestable and, therefore, no detailed discussion on the issue is
required. Suffice it to say that in terms of Rule 33 of the Rules of
1956, the disciplinary authority may either itself inquire into the
allegations against the delinquent or appoint some other officer as
an Inquiry Officer. Simply because the disciplinary authority has
also acted as an Inquiry Officer does not ipso facto vitiate the
disciplinary proceedings unless the specific prejudice is pleaded,
demonstrated and proved.
16.
For the foregoing reasons, we concur with the view taken by the
Writ Court that the enquiry proceedings conducted in this case
after receiving a reply to the charge-sheet are completely vitiated
having been conducted in sheer violation of the principles of natural
justice. While upholding the judgment of the Writ Court on this
aspect, we dispose of this appeal by providing that the appellants
may, if they so choose, can proceed to conduct the disciplinary
proceedings, afresh, from the stage the reply to the charge-sheet
was submitted by the respondent, by strictly complying with the
principles of natural justice and the provisions of Rule 33 of the
LPA No. 153/2026
Rules of 1956 read with Article 311 of the Constitution of India.
The inquiry may be conducted in the manner aforesaid against the
respondent, notwithstanding the fact that the respondent has
superannuated from service. The respondent shall be deemed to be
in service for the purposes of conducting the inquiry afresh.
17.
Having regard to the fact that the allegations against the respondent
pertain to the year 2019, it would be in the fitness of things to direct
the appellants to conclude the inquiry, if continued in terms of the
directions issued above, within a period of six months from today,
failing which, the respondent shall be deemed to have been
exonerated and his case for post-retiral benefit shall be processed
accordingly.
(M.A. Chowdhary)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
JAMMU
28.10.2026
Manan
Whether the order is speaking :
Whether the order is reportable :
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review