The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
901. WP.10165.26.odt +10 We find substance in the submission of the learned counsel for the respondents that, the fellowships awarded to the petitioners from the autonomous bodies like BARTI and BANRF do not satisfy the test of National Fellowship as contemplated under the Ordinance of 2024 and the notification of UGC. In our considered view, since the petitioners have failed to satisfy the norms prescribed under the Ordinance, Statutes and the UGC Regulations, they have no indefeasible right of seeking admission to the Ph.D. degree solely on the basis of fellowships received by them from BARTI and BANRF. In view thereof, we find that the petitions are devoid of any substance and are liable to be dismissed.
12. In the result, the writ petitions are dismissed. (ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, J.) habeeb/ (NITIN B. SURYAWANSHI, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:43903-DB
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
901 WRIT PETITION NO.10165 OF 2026
Lochana Daulat Khilare
1.
…
PETITIONER
…
RESPONDENTS
VERSUS
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada
University, through its Vice Chancellor,
Aurangabad.
2.
Pro-Vice Chancellor,
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada
University, Aurangabad.
3.
The Deputy Registrar
Ph.D Section, Dr. Babasaheb
Ambedkar Marathwada University,
Aurangabad.
4.
The Dean,
Department of Humanities,
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada
University, Aurangabad.
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6701 OF 2026
Babita Suresh Arak
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6718 OF 2026
1. Usha Narayan Parghane
2. Sandeep Eknath Kamble
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
WITH
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
WRIT PETITION NO. 10344 OF 2026
Sangita Prabhakar Waghmare
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6711 OF 2026
Ramnath Mahadev Gaikwad
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6712 OF 2026
Dashrath Balasaheb Khetri
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6716 OF 2026
Pratiksha Laxman Jagtap
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6717 OF 2026
Sandip Ramesh Khandare
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6760 OF 2026
Aparna Bhaskarrao Magare
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6700 OF 2026
Sonaji Himmatrao Gawai
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6715 OF 2026
Amrapali Shamrao Bankar
Versus
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and others
...
Advocate for the Petitioner/s : Mr. Mahesh S. Bhosale
Advocate for Respondents Nos.1 to 4 : Mr. Sambhaji S. Tope
…
CORAM
: NITIN B. SURYAWANSHI &
ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, JJ.
Reserved on
: 01.07.2026
Pronounced on
: 28.09.2026
FINAL ORDER (PER: ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, J.) :
1.
Since a common question of law and fact is involved in all these
writ petitions, they are being decided by this common order.
2.
By these writ petitions filed under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, the petitioners are seeking directions to the respondents to
constitute a Research Recommendation Committee (for short “RRC”),
so as to enable the petitioners to secure admission to the Ph.D.
programme. Further directions are sought for issuance of provisional
as well as confirmation letter of admission to the Ph.D. by completing
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
the said admission process within stipulated period.
3.
It is the case of the petitioners that they possess requisite
qualifications in the respective subjects as well as having M.Phil
degree. They are also recipients of fellowships awarded by Dr.
Babasaheb Ambedkar Research and Training Institute (hereinafter
referred to as “BARTI”) and Dr.
Babasaheb Ambedkar National
Research Fellowship ( hereinafter referred to as “ BANRF”). On the
basis of these qualifications they registered themselves for admission
to the Ph.D. programme and also paid the requisite fees. The
petitioners further contended that, pursuant to their registration, the
Departmental Recommendation Committee (hereinafter referred to as
“DRC”) held a meeting on 07.01.2025, which is competent to approve
admission of candidates to the Ph.D. degree.
4.
The main bone of contention of the petitioners is that, by virtue
of possessing M.Phil. degrees as well as having awarded fellowships
from BARTI and BANRF, they are entitled to admission to the Ph.D.
degree without undergoing Ph.D. Enterance Test (for short “PET”). The
petitioners, therefore, have approached this Court.
5.
For the sake of convenience, the details of the petitioners are
summarized in the following tabular form:
Sr.
No.
Writ Petition
Name of
Petitioner
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
Qualification
University/
Fellowship
Subject
Faculty
1. WP/6700/2026 Sonaji
Himmatrao
Gawai
MA Economics
BARTI
Economics Humanities
SC category
16.02.2022
M.Phil. March 2024
Registration for
Ph.D
Admission/Fees
paid 20.03.2024
DRC Meeting
07.01.2025
2. WP/6701/2026 Babita
Suresh Arak
MA Marathi
BARTI
Marathi
SC Category
30.06.2020
M.Phil. 27.07.2022
Registration for
Ph.D. Admission
25.04.2024
fees paid
09.10.2024
DRC meeting
07.01.2025
Humanities
3. WP/6711/2026 Ramnath
Mahadev
Gaikwad
M.Sc. Computer BARTI
Computer
Science
26.07.2024 Science
SC category
M.Phile
27.07.2022
DRC Meeting
07.01.2025
Participated in PET
but not selected
Science
and
Technology
4. WP/6715/2026 Amrapali
Shamrao
Bankar
MA Public
Administration
SC Category
M.Phile
30.07.2024
DRC meeting not
held participated
in PET but not
selected
Humanities
5. WP/6712/2026 Dashrath
Balasaheb
Khetri
MA Marathi
National Marathi
M.Phil 21.10.2023 Fellowship
Registration for
for person
Ph.D Admission
with
23.08.2024
disabilities
DRC meeting
01.04.2018
11.08.2024 letter
to Pro-vs by HOD
30.08.2024
Humanities
6. WP/6716/2026 Pratiksha
Lakshaman
Jagtap
M.Sc. Computer SARTHI
Computer
Science
24.02.2022 Science
Open Category
M.Phil. 03.04.2024
Registration for
Ph.d admission
29.04.2024
Science
and
Technology
BARTI
Public
16.02.2022 Adm.
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
7. WP/6717/2026 Sandip
Ramesh
Khandare
M.Com
BARTI
Commerce Commerce
SC Category
16.02.2022
and
Management
M.Phil. 12.12.2023
Registration for
Ph.D. Admission
22.12.2023
DRC Meeting
01.01.2025 Letter
to Pro-Vs by HOD
01.01.2025
8. WP/6718/2026 Usha
Narayan
Parghane
M.A. Hindi
BARTI
Hindi
SC Category
21.04.2023
M.Phil. 06.04.2024
Registration for
Ph.D. Admission
30.01.2025
DRC Meeting
10.01.2025
Letter to Pro-vs by
HOD 28.01.2025
Humanities
Sandeep
Eknath
Kambale
M.A. Hindi
BARTI
Hindi
SC Category
21.04.2023
M.Phil. 06.04.2024
Registration for
Ph.D. Admission
30.01.2025
DRC meeting
28.01.2025
Letter to Pro-vs by
HOD 24.01.2025
Humanities
9. WP/6760/2026 Aparna
Bhaskarrao
Magare
M.Sc. Information BARTI
Computer
Technology
30.06.2020 Science
SC Category
M.Phil. 05.04.2023
Registration for
Ph.D. Admission
18.03.2024
DRC Meeting
10.05.2024
Letter to Pro-vs by
HOD 16.07.2025
Science
and
Technology
10. WP/
10165/2026
Lochana
Daulat
Khillare
M.A. Sociology
BARTI
Sociology
SC Category M.Phil 21.04.2023
06.04.2024
Registration for
Ph.D. Admission
04.04.2024
DRC Meeting
24.01.2025 Letter
to Pro-vs by HOD
24.01.2025
Humanities
11. WP/
10344/2026
Sangita
Prabhakar
Waghmare
M.A. Philosophy BARTI
Economics Humanities
SC Category
16.02.2022
M.Phil. 03.04.2024
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
Registration for
Ph.D. Admission
03.04.2024
No DRC Meeting
and guide is not
allotted. She made
request by
representation
dated 06.06.2025
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that, considering the
qualifications of the petitioners, they are eligible for being admitted to
the Ph.D. degree. He submits that the University Grants Commission
(for short “UGC”) issued a Notification dated 07.11.2022 prescribing
the Minimum Standards and Procedure for awarding the Ph.D. degree.
Clause 5 (2)(i) of the said Notification contemplates that, a candidate
who is a recipient of fellowship / scholarship in UGC – NET / UGC –
CSIR / NET / GATE / CEED is entitled for being admitted to the Ph.D.
degree. He further submits that Clauses (b) and (e) as well as Clause 5
of Ordinance-1009 (herein after referred to as ‘the said Ordinance’) of
the respondent No.1-University also prescribes the same eligibility
criteria. He, therefore, urged that the Writ Petitions deserve to be
allowed.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
submits that the admission process for the Ph.D. degree is governed by
the Ordinance of 2024 and the UGC Regulations 2022, therefore,
reliance placed by the petitioners on the said Ordinance is misplaced.
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
He further submits that holding the M.Phil. degrees and receiving
State fellowships, do not automatically entitle the petitioners to seek
admissions to the Ph.D. degree. The petitioners are required to
undergo the prescribed statutory admission process. He further
submits that, the Fellowships received by the petitioners from the
autonomous bodies like BARTI and BANRF cannot be taken into
consideration, as they do not satisfy the test of National Fellowship.
He, therefore, urged that the petitions are devoid of any substance
and, therefore, deserve to be dismissed.
8.
We have heard learned counsel for the petitioners, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents at length and have perused the
record.
9.
The relevant clauses prescribing the eligibility criteria for
admission to the Ph.D. programme under the said Ordinance read
thus:
“ Eligibility Criteria for admission to the Ph.D. programme.
a)
--
b)
Candidates who have successfully passed the M.Phil. Course
work as per conditions laid down by U.G.C. Regulations,
2009 published in Government of India Gazette, July 11 July 17, 2009, i.e. admitted on the basis of entrance
examination, with at least 55% marks in aggregate or its
equivalent grade B in the UGC-7 point scale or an equivalent
grade in a point scale, wherever grading system is followed,
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
and successfully completed the M/Phil. Degree shall be
eligible to proceed to do research work leading to Ph.D.
degree in the same institute in an integrated programme. A
relaxation of 5% of marks, from 55% to 50%, or an
equivalent relations of grade, shall be allowed as mentioned
in 1.1.2.
A candidate fulfilling the eligibility criteria mentioned in (a)
and who have qualified the UGC-NET (including JRF) /
UGC-CSIR NET (including JRF)/SLET/GATE/GPAT/SET/
teacher FIP holders or have passed M.Phil. programme
(admitted through entrance test) in the concerned subject
from any Statutory University.”
e)
Similarly, Clause 5(x) of the said Ordinance which also provides
for the eligibility criteria, reads thus:
“5. Eligibility :
(x) The maximum allowed gap period for continuation from
M/Phil to Ph.D. under this scheme shall be two years (from
the date of declaration of result of M.Phil to date of
admission to Ph.D.) However, the total tenure of fellowship
shall remain five years excluding the gap period. No
fellowship shall be paid during the gap period.”
10.
Bare perusal of the aforesaid clauses would show that, it merely
prescribes the qualification for the purpose of seeking admission to the
Ph.D. degree. However, the said qualification is always subject to
fulfillment of criteria and norms prescribed under the Ordinance and
the statutes of respondent No. 1/University. Unless the petitioners
undergo the entire admission process prescribed under the Ordinance
and the Statutes framed by the respondent No. 1 including PET, they
cannot claim to have an automatic right to be admitted to the Ph.D.
degree.
11.
901.WP.10165.26.odt +10
We find substance in the submission of the learned counsel for
the respondents that, the fellowships awarded to the petitioners from
the autonomous bodies like BARTI and BANRF do not satisfy the test
of National Fellowship as contemplated under the Ordinance of 2024
and the notification of UGC. In our considered view, since the
petitioners have failed to satisfy the norms prescribed under the
Ordinance, Statutes and the UGC Regulations, they have no
indefeasible right of seeking admission to the Ph.D. degree solely on
the basis of fellowships received by them from BARTI and BANRF. In
view thereof, we find that the petitions are devoid of any substance
and are liable to be dismissed.
12.
In the result, the writ petitions are dismissed.
(ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, J.)
habeeb/
(NITIN B. SURYAWANSHI, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review