Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 07
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
ATJAMMU
MA No. 489/2013
Date of pronouncement: 08.07.2026
Date of uploading: 16.07.2026
Union of India
.....Applicant(s)/Appellant(s)
Through :- Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Karan Sharma, CGSC
v/s
Zamindars of Villages, Ladwal and Others
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. Bari Abdullah, Advocate
Mr. Ravi Abrol, Advocate
Mr. Anil Sethi, Advocate
CORAM: HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The Union of India, being the intending party, has challenged the Award
dated 30.12.2011 passed by the learned Principal District Judge, Ramban
(hereinafter referred to as "the Reference Court") in the reference titled
Zamindars of Village Ladwal v. Collector, Land Acquisition, Doda. By
the impugned award, the Reference Court enhanced the compensation for
the acquired land to Rs. 1,00,000/- per kanal uniformly for all categories
of land. The appellant has also assailed the Award dated 08.04.1999
passed by the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Doda, acting as the Land
Acquisition Collector.
2.
Pursuant to Notification dated 27.07.1989, issued for the construction of
the bypass road in the Batote area of the Jammu-Srinagar National
Highway, land measuring 77 kanals and 18 Marlas was acquired,
MA No. 489/2013
comprising 54 kanals and 1 Marla in Village Batote, 23 kanals and 6
Marlas in Village Ladwal, and 4 Marlas in Village Tringla. Consequent
thereto, the Land Acquisition Collector passed the Award dated
08.04.1999, determining compensation at the following rates:
a.
Gair Mumkin land under shops: Rs. 45,000/- per kanal;
b.
Culturable land: Rs. 40,000/- per kanal;
c.
Banjar Qadeem: Rs. 25,000/- per kanal; and
d.
Other Gair Mumkin land: Rs. 10,000/- per kanal.
The aforesaid rates were determined on the basis of the report submitted
by the Tehsildar (Settlement), Ramban, who assessed the average sale
price of land situated within the limits of the Notified Area Committee
(NAC), Batote, at Rs. 44,295/- per kanal.
3.
The appellant contends that the respondent-landowners neither produced
any evidence before the Land Acquisition Collector nor adduced any
evidence during the reference proceedings before the Reference Court. It
is further submitted that the compensation was enhanced to Rs. 1,00,000/per Kanal, irrespective of the nature or classification of the land, without
impleading or issuing notice to the appellant, who was the intending
party. Consequently, the appellant was denied an opportunity of being
heard, rendering the impugned award contrary to law and in violation of
the principles of natural justice.
4.
The appellant further submits that the Reference Court placed reliance
upon sale deeds relating to insignificant extents of land measuring only a
few Marlas, which were neither comparable in nature nor proximate in
time to the acquisition in question. Such sale instances could not have
MA No. 489/2013
formed a valid basis for determining the prevailing market value of the
acquired land. Consequently, the enhancement of compensation is
contrary to the settled principles governing determination of market value
under the Land Acquisition Act.
5.
It is also the appellant's case that the Reference Court failed to determine
the market value of the acquired land with reference to the relevant period
preceding the acquisition, particularly the transactions occurring within
the three years prior to the issuance of the acquisition notification. By
ignoring this settled principle and relying upon irrelevant material, the
Reference Court committed a manifest error of law, rendering the
impugned award arbitrary, perverse, and unsustainable.
6.
Respondents, on the other hand, claim that the award has been rightly
drawn and that the appellant was not a necessary party before the
Reference Court, it was argued that once the Collector had knowledge of
the reference proceedings, the appellant cannot feign ignorance inasmuch
as assessment of market value has been made keeping in view the purpose
for which the land was utilized. Since there were 3 different types of land,
the Collector had for better adjudication of the rights of the parties
proceeded to apply uniformmarket rate of the land which was in
accordance with law.
7.
Heard and considered the record.
8.
A perusal of the record of the Reference Court reveals that the reference
proceedings were initiated on an application filed by respondent No. 1
before the Land Acquisition Collector. Besides the said reference,
MA No. 489/2013
separate applications were also filed by Amanullah and Mohd. Shafi in
their individual capacities seeking a reference to the District Court. The
Reference Court held that the applications preferred by Amanullah and
Mohd. Shafi were not maintainable, whereas the reference filed by
respondent No. 1 was within the prescribed period of limitation and,
therefore, maintainable in accordance with law.
9.
During the course of the reference proceedings, the Reference Court was
apprised of the following registered sale deeds executed between the
years 1992 and 2000:(i) Sale deed dated 27.07.2000, executed by Pawan Kumar in favour of
Raj Nath and Pran Nath, whereby 6 marlas of land were sold for a
consideration of Rs.78,000/-.
(ii) Sale deed dated 22.05.1992, executed by Mohd. Ashraf in favour of
Mohd. Akram, whereby 10 marlas of land were sold for a consideration
of Rs.50,000/-.
(iii) Sale deed dated 03.08.1994, executed by Mohd. Aslam in favour of
Partap Bhushan Katoch, whereby 5 marlas of land were sold for a
consideration of Rs.25,000/-.
(iv) Sale deed dated 22.05.1992, executed by Mohd. Ashraf in favour of
Mohd. Bashrat Malik, whereby 10 marlas of land were transferred for
valuable consideration.
(v) Sale deed dated 19.09.2000, executed by Anuj Puri in favour of
Tanveer Ahmed Kichloo, whereby 12 marlas of land were sold for a
consideration of Rs.1,10,000/-.
MA No. 489/2013
All the aforesaid sale deeds were registered in the office of the SubRegistrar, Batote, within whose territorial jurisdiction the acquired land
was situated.
10.
Upon consideration of the material placed before it, the Reference Court
observed that although the Land Acquisition Collector had awarded
different rates of compensation depending upon the nature and
classification of the acquired land, the lands covered by the
aforementioned sale deeds were situated in close proximity to the
acquired land and were comparable in nature. The Reference Court
further held that certified copies of the registered sale deeds were
admissible in evidence under Section 51-A of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894, and carried a statutory presumption regarding the genuineness of
their contents. Relying upon the said sale instances, the Reference Court
determined the market value of the acquired land at Rs.1,00,000/- per
kanal, equivalent to Rs. 5,000/- per marla, irrespective of the
classification of the land. The record, however, indicates that the present
appellant, though the intending department, was not impleaded as a party
to the reference proceedings.
11.
Learned counsel for the appellant, placing reliance upon the judgment of
this Court in National Hydro Electric Power Corporation Ltd. & Another
v. Gh. Rasool Hamal & Others, 2000 SLJ 114, contended that since the
appellant, being the intending department, was not impleaded as a party
to the reference proceedings, the award passed by the Reference Court is
not binding upon it and cannot be enforced against it. The respondents, on
the other hand, argued that once the Land Acquisition Collector had
MA No. 489/2013
notice of the reference proceedings, the appellant must be deemed to have
had constructive knowledge thereof. The said contention, however, stands
negatived by the aforesaid judgment, wherein this Court held that the
mere fact that the Collector was a party to the reference proceedings does
not justify the presumption that the intending department had knowledge
thereof. Being an interested party, whose financial liability was directly
affected, the intending department was entitled to notice of the reference
proceedings and an opportunity of being heard.
12.
Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that while making
the reference to the District Court, the Land Acquisition Collector had
intimated the appellant regarding the pendency of the dispute relating to
the determination of the market value of the acquired land and had also
informed it that the amount deposited by the appellant had been directed
to be deposited before the Reference Court. Although the submission
appears attractive at first blush, the record does not substantiate the same.
No material has been placed on record to establish that any such
communication was in fact issued to or received by the appellant.
13.
Learned counsel for the appellant further contended that even assuming,
for the sake of argument, that the appellant had knowledge of the
reference proceedings, the market value determined by the Reference
Court is excessive and legally unsustainable. Reliance was placed upon
the decision reported in 2017 (3) JKJ 101, wherein it was held that where
the market value is determined on the basis of sale deeds pertaining to
small parcels of land, the Court is required to make appropriate
MA No. 489/2013
deductions before applying such rates to a large tract of acquired land. It
was accordingly argued that the Reference Court erred in adopting the
rates reflected in the sale deeds without making any deduction for
development or other relevant factors. It was also submitted that the road
alignment in question had originally been under the control of the local
department and was subsequently taken over by the appellant, which
aspect ought to have been taken into consideration while assessing
compensation.
14.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and upon consideration of
the record, this Court finds that the appellant was not served with notice
of the reference proceedings, nor did the Reference Court take any steps
to ensure that the intending department was impleaded or informed of the
pendency of the reference. Nevertheless, it cannot be overlooked that the
Land Acquisition Collector was acting in his official capacity throughout
the acquisition proceedings and that the appellant, being the beneficiary
Government agency for whose purpose the acquisition had been
undertaken, cannot ordinarily be presumed to have remained completely
unaware of the acquisition proceedings.
15.
Having said so, since the appellant has also assailed the findings of the
Reference Court with regard to the assessment of the market value of the
acquired land, and in view of the submissions advanced by the learned
Deputy Solicitor General of India, the objection relating to non-service of
notice upon the appellant appears to have been given up during the course
of arguments. Accordingly, this Court proceeds to examine the
MA No. 489/2013
correctness of the impugned award on the basis of the evidence that was
produced before, and relied upon by, the Reference Court.
16.
In 2017 (3) JKJ 101, the Land Acquisition Collector had determined
compensation by awarding different rates for different categories of land,
having regard to their nature and classification. A similar methodology
was adopted by the Collector in the present case; whereby varying rates
of compensation were awarded depending upon the nature and quality of
the acquired land.Aggrieved by the manner in which the Collector had
assessed compensation, the landowners in that case sought a reference
under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The learned
Principal District Judge, by judgment and decree dated 29.08.2008,
enhanced the compensation to Rs. 1,00,000/- per kanal, together with
15% Jabrana (solatium) and interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the
date of taking possession. The said judgment was challenged before this
Court, which observed as follows:"The learned Principal District Judge, Ramban, has assigned no reasons
for enhancing the market value uniformly in respect of the entire acquired
land, irrespective of its nature and classification."
17.
This Court, however, upheld the award after finding that the market value
had been determined by applying an appropriate deduction of 15% to the
value reflected in the exemplar sale deeds, thereby accounting for the
difference between the small parcels covered by the sale transactions and
the larger extent of land acquired under the notification.
MA No. 489/2013
18.
The Supreme Court, in Trishala Jain & Others v. State of Uttaranchal &
Others, AIR 2011 SC 2458, while considering the principles governing
the determination of compensation payable for acquired land under the
Land Acquisition Act, 1894, authoritatively laid down the law regarding
the methodology to be adopted by the Reference Court in assessing the
market value of the acquired land. The Court held as under:
“Under the Act, as settled by various judgments of this Court, there are different
methods of computation of compensation payable to the claimants, for example it
can be based upon comparable sale instances, awards and judgments relating to
the similar or comparable lands, method of averages, yearly yields with reference
to the revenue earned by the land etc. Whatever method of determining the
compensation is applied by the Court, its result should always be reasonable, just
and fair as that is the purpose sought to be achieved under the scheme of the Act.
For attaining that purpose, application of some guesswork may be necessary but
this principle would have hardly any application in a case of no evidence. In
other words, where the parties have not brought on record any evidence, then
the Court will not be in a position to award compensation merely on the basis of
imagination, conjecture etc.
These precedents clearly demonstrate that the Court may apply some
guesswork before it could arrive at a final determination, which is in
consonance with the statutory law as well as the principles stated in the
judicial pronouncements. As already noticed, the guesswork has to be used
for determination of compensation with greater element of caution and the
principle of guesstimation will have no application to the case of „no
evidence‟. This principle is only intended to bridge the gap between the
calculated compensation and the actual compensation that the claimants may
be entitled to receive as per the facts of a given case to meet the ends of
justice. It will be appropriate for us to state certain principles controlling the
application of guesstimate:
(a)
Wherever the evidence produced by the parties is not sufficient to
determine the compensation with exactitude, this principle can be resorted
to.
MA No. 489/2013
(b)
Discretion of the Court in applying guesswork to the facts of a given
case is not unfettered but has to be reasonable and should have a connection
to the data on record produced by the parties by way of evidence. Further,
this entire exercise has to be within the limitations specified under Sections
23 and 24 of the Act and cannot be made in detriment thereto.
Applying these principles to the facts of the present case, we have to take
recourse to the „principle of guesstimation‟ inasmuch as it is essential for
fixation of fair market value of the land which shall be the basis for
determining the compensation payable to the claimants. Now, we will discuss
the evidence led by the parties in that behalf.”
19.
The Supreme Court, after considering the facts and circumstances of the
case, observed that the Reference Court had determined the market value
by applying a deduction of 20% to the exemplar sale price while
awarding compensation. The High Court, however, further reduced the
compensation by increasing the deduction from 20% to 33.33%. The
Supreme Court, taking into account the peculiar facts and circumstances
of the case and applying the principle of a reasonable guesstimate, held
that a deduction of 10% would meet the ends of justice and accordingly
determined the market value of the acquired land on that basis.
20.
Placing reliance upon the aforesaid decision, learned counsel for the
appellant submitted that the same principle ought to be applied in the
present case, particularly since the Reference Court had determined the
market value solely on the basis of sale instances pertaining to small
parcels of land without making any appropriate deduction.
21.
Upon a careful examination of the record, this Court finds that, of the sale
deeds relied upon by the Reference Court, the sale deeds dated
27.07.2000 and 19.09.2000 were executed subsequent to the passing of
MA No. 489/2013
the final award dated 08.04.1999 and, therefore, could not have been
taken into consideration for determining the market value of the acquired
land. However, the sale deeds dated 22.05.1992 and 03.08.1994, being
proximate in point of time to the acquisition proceedings, constitute
relevant exemplars for determining the prevailing market value.The
acquisition in question pertains to 77 kanals and 18 marlas of land
comprising different khasra numbers situated in three villages falling
within the erstwhile Tehsil Ramban, acquired for the construction of the
Batote Bypass Road. The acquisition was thus for a public infrastructure
project, namely the construction of a road, and not for any residential or
commercial development.
22.
The Reference Court, on appreciation of the evidence on record,
determined the market value of the acquired land at Rs. 5,000/- per
marla, equivalent to Rs. 1,00,000/- per kanal. However, the sale
instances relied upon for such determination pertained to transfers of
merely 5 marlas and 10 marlas of land, which constituted very small and
insignificant parcels in comparison to the extensive tract of land acquired
under the notification.
23.
In terms of Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, one of the
primary considerations for determining compensation is the market value
of the land as on the date of publication of the notification under Section
4 of the Act. The expression "market value" denotes the price that a
willing purchaser would pay to a willing seller for the property, having
due regard to its existing condition, location, potential, and all attendant
MA No. 489/2013
advantages as on the relevant date. The claimants while seeking reference
had sought enhancement of compensation to Rs. 80,000/- to 1.00 lac per
kanals.
24.
In the absence of any oral or documentary evidence relating to the sale of
a large extent of land comparable to the acquired property, the Reference
Court appears to have relied upon sale transactions involving small
parcels of land while determining the market value of the substantially
larger tract acquired under the notification. The claimants did not adduce
any evidence to establish the market value of lands contiguous or
comparable to the acquired land. In such circumstances, sale instances
pertaining to land situated in the same village may furnish a reasonable
basis for determining the market value, provided suitable adjustments are
made after taking into account the positive and negative factors affecting
the comparability of the lands.
25.
In Trishala Jain & Others v. State of Uttaranchal & Others (supra), the
Supreme Court unequivocally held that although the determination of
market value necessarily involves an element of reasonable guesswork,
the authority entrusted with the assessment of compensation is under a
legal obligation to arrive at its estimate on the basis of objective standards
and accepted principles governing valuation of acquired land.
26.
Likewise, in 2017 (3) JKJ 101, this Court upheld the deduction of 50%
applied by the Reference Court while determining the market value on the
basis of exemplar sale deeds. In the present case also, the acquired land
MA No. 489/2013
comprises different categories of land, yet the Reference Court assessed
the market value uniformly without duly considering the nature,
classification, and topography of the acquired land. Once the acquired
land consisted of different categories and classifications, it was incumbent
upon the Reference Court to make appropriate deductions and
adjustments while determining compensation so as to ensure that the
amount awarded was fair, just, and reasonable in the facts and
circumstances of the case.
27.
In the facts and circumstances noticed hereinabove, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the learned Reference Court committed an error
in determining the market value of the acquired land uniformly at
Rs.1,00,000/- per kanal without making any appropriate deduction on
account of the exemplar sale deeds relating to very small parcels of land.
The sale transactions relied upon by the Reference Court pertained to
transfers of 5 marlas and 10 marlas only, whereas the acquisition in
question covered 77 kanals and 18 marlas spread over different khasra
numbers and comprising different categories of land acquired for the
construction of the Batote Bypass Road. The settled principles governing
determination of market value require that where exemplar sale deeds
relate to small developed plots, suitable deductions must be made before
applying such rates to a substantially larger extent of acquired land.
28.
In that view of the matter, placing reliance on Trishala Jain’s case
(supra) and by applying deduction at the rate of 10%, the compensation
for the acquired land is assessed at Rs.90,000/- (Rupees Ninety thousand)
MA No. 489/2013
per kanal and that shall be paid to the claimants. To that extent the
Award stands modified. Rest of the award is maintained enabling the
claimants to receive the compensation in terms of the aforesaid. In case
the awarded amount stands deposited before this Court, the same shall be
released in favour of the claimants. The deficient amount, if any, along
with interest as accrued in terms of the award shall be deposited by the
appellant before the Reference Court within three months enabling the
Reference Court to proceed for release of the awarded compensation in
favour of the claimants. A copy of this judgment shall be notified to the
Reference Court for compliance.
29.
Disposed of.
( Sanjay Parihar )
Judge
JAMMU
08.07.2026
Manik
Whether this order is speaking: Yes
Whether this order is reportable: Yes
Narinder Kumar
2026.07.16 10:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review