The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. Accordingly, the award of the learned Tribunal is modified, and appellantInsurance Company is directed to pay Rs. 8,66,000/- as compensation to the claimants under the following heads: a. Loss of dependency = Rs. 7,56,000/ b. Funeral Expenses = Rs. 15,000/ c. Loss of Estate = Rs. 15,000/ d. Loss of Filial Consortium = Rs. 80,000/ Total: Rs. 8,66,000/-
24. The interest component shall remain the same. Appellant-Insurance Company shall deposit the balance amount within a period of one month from today and upon such deposit, the amount shall be released in favour of claimants after their due identification and deducting the requisite court fee in accordance with law. Mac App No. 30/2021 is accordingly disposed of. The claimants shall furnish the bank account details of their accounts and the amount of compensation be transferred to the said accounts in accordance with the order passed by the learned Tribunal.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on:
Pronounced on:
Uploaded on:
07.08.2026
21.08.2026
21.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced: Full
Mac App No. 160/2020(O&M)
Mac App No. 30/2021(O&M)
United India Insurance Co. Ltd.
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Dinesh Singh Chauhan, Adv.
Ms. Damini Singh Chauhan, Adv.
in Mac App No. 160/2020
Mr. Deepak Mahajan, Adv.
inMac App No. 30/2021
Q
vs
.…. Respondent(s)
Mohan Singh and others
Through: Mr. Deepak Mahajan, Adv.
in Mac App No. 160/2020
Mr. Dinesh Singh Chauhan, Adv.
Ms. Damini Singh Chauhan, Adv.
in Mac App No. 30/2021
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Aggrieved by the award dated 06.11.2019 passed by the Presiding Officer,
MACT Samba (for short „the Tribunal‟) in the claim petition, titled,
“Mohan Singh and another vs. Shamsher Chand and others”, whereby the
appellant/insurance company has been directed to pay the compensation of
Rs. 3,94,000/- to the appellants/claimants along with interest at the rate of
6% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition till the payment
of the award, the instant appeals have been filed by the claimants as well as
the Insurance Company.
2.
In Mac App No. 160/2020, the appellant/insurance company has raised
following issues in the memo of appeal:
Whether the learned Presiding Officer, Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, Samba, was justified in directing the Appellant/United India
Insurance Company ltd. to indemnify the insured, especially when the
driver namely, Shamsher Chand S/o. Mr. Krishan Chand R/o. Village
Badheri, Tehsil and District Samba, who was driving the Offending
“Passengers Carrying Commercial Vehicle” i.e. Bus No. JK-02H
6468, was holding fake and fraudulent “Driving License”?
Whether the learned Presiding Officer, Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, Samba, was justified in closing the evidence of the
Appellant- United India Insurance Company Limited, without
summoning the witness, whose diet expenses stood deposited, as per
the procedure as laid down in Order XVI of Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 and returning a finding to the contrary?
3.
In Mac App No. 30/2021, the appellants/claimants have assailed the award
dated 06.11.2019 on the ground that the compensation under the head of
“Filial Consortium “was wrongly granted to them and further the notional
annual income of the deceased fixed by the learned Tribunal @ Rs.
36,000/- is too meagre.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company reiterated the
submissions made in the memo of appeal. He vehemently contended that
the learned Tribunal did not afford the proper opportunity to the
appellant/insurance company to lead evidence despite the fact that diet
expenses were already deposited by the Insurance Company.
5.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the appellants/respondents-claimants
has submitted that the learned Tribunal has not rightly assessed the
quantum of compensation as the notional income of the deceased
determined by the learned Tribunal is too meagre. He also submitted that
the “Filial Consortium” has also not been rightly awarded in terms of
Mac App Nos. 160/2020 & 30/2021
judgment of the Supreme Court in Magma General Company Ltd. v.
Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram and others, (2018) 18 SCC 130.
6.
Heard learned counsel for both the sides and perused the record, including
the record of the learned Tribunal.
7.
The record depicts that the claimants, namely, Mohan Singh and Manjeet
Kour, filed the claim petition seeking compensation on account of the death
of their only son, Gurpreet Singh, aged about 13 years, who died in a motor
vehicular accident that occurred on 04.09.2012 at about 3:00 p.m. The
deceased was alighting from the bus at Ramgarh Bazaar when the driver of
the offending vehicle, while driving the bus at a high speed and in a rash
and negligent manner, caused the accident, resulting in his fatal injuries. At
the time of the accident, the deceased was a student of 8th Class.
8.
The respondent-Insurance Company filed its response to the claim petition,
contending, inter alia, that the driver of the offending vehicle was not
holding a valid and effective driving licence authorising him to drive the
said vehicle. It was, therefore, pleaded that no liability could be fastened
upon the appellant-Insurance Company to indemnify the insured-owner of
the offending vehicle. The appellant-Insurance Company also denied the
occurrence of the accident itself.
9.
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 were put to notice but respondent Nos. 1 and 2 did
not cause appearance, as such, they were set ex parte by the learned
Tribunal.
10.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed:
I.
Whether an accident took place on 04.09.2012 at about 3 PM
at Ramgarh Bazar when the deceased Gurpreet Singh was
boarding off the bus but the driver i.e. respondent No. 1 drove
Mac App Nos. 160/2020 & 30/2021
II.
III.
IV.
V.
11.
the offending vehicle No. JK02H-6468 rashly and negligently,
as a result of which fatal accident was caused and the deceased
suffered multiple fatal injuries and died? OPP
Whether respondent No. 1 was not holding valid driving
license at the time of the accident? OPR3
Whether the respondent No. 3 is not liable to pay any
compensation as the offending vehicle was driven in
contravention of the terms and conditions of the Insurance
policy? OPR3
In case issue No. 1 is proved in affirmative, whether
petitioners are entitled to any compensation under Motor
Vehicle Act and, if so, from whom and to what extent? OPP
Relief. OP Parties.
The appellants-claimants, besides examining one of the claimants, namely,
Mohan Singh, also examined Baljeet Singh in support of their claim. On the
other hand, the appellant-Insurance Company failed to produce any witness
despite having been afforded several opportunities. Consequently, the
learned Tribunal proceeded to decide the claim petition and passed the
impugned award.
12.
The appellant/insurance company has asserted that it had raised the issue
with regard to the validity of the driving license of the driver of the
offending vehicle but the learned Tribunal closed the evidence of the
appellant/insurance company without summoning the witness, despite the
fact that the diet expenses were deposited by the company, which
incapacitated the insurance company to prove issue No. 2.
13.
A perusal of the record reveals that the Insurance Company had deposited
the diet expenses for summoning of the witness, Shamsher Chand, driver of
the offending vehicle to prove issue No. 2. The minutes of the proceedings
reveal that the evidence of the claimants was closed on 18.02.2016 and the
matter was posted for the evidence of the respondents. On 09.05.2016, the
respondent/Insurance Company deposited the diet expenses of the witness.
On 05.10.2016, respondent No. 3 therein i.e. respondent No. 1-Shamsher
Mac App Nos. 160/2020 & 30/2021
Chand-witness was present, but his statement was not recorded, as court
time was over. On 08.05.2018, Shamsher Chand was present in the Court,
but he had not brought the original license, and he was directed to produce
the same. Thereafter, on 18.12.2018, the counsel for the insurance company
sought time to produce the witness. Thereafter, again notice was issued to
the witness on 06.07.2019 and the summon was received on 14.08.2019
with the endorsement that the complete address of the said witness was not
available and as such, the appellant/Insurance company was directed to
produce the said witness by taking dasti summons. On 14.08.2019, also
summons issued to the witness was received back with endorsement that
address was incomplete, and as such, appellant-Insurance company was
granted last opportunity to produce the witness after taking dasti summons.
Thereafter, on 17.09.2019, the evidence of the Insurance-Company was
closed. It appears that the appellant-Insurance Company did not get the
dasti summons for effecting service of the witness.
14.
The evidence of the claimants was closed way back in the year 2016,
whereas the insurance company took three years for examining one witness
and despite specific direction of dasti summons for effecting service upon
the said witness, dasti summons was not taken by the appellant/insurance
company.
15.
In view of the above, this Court is of the considered view that once the
appellant/insurance company itself failed to get the dasti summons for
effecting service upon the witness, it cannot be heard to say that proper
opportunity was not granted to the appellant/insurance company to lead
Mac App Nos. 160/2020 & 30/2021
evidence. Accordingly, the appeal of the Insurance Company bearing Mac
App No. 60/2020 being devoid of any merit, is hereby dismissed.
16.
In appeal bearing Mac App No. 30/2021 filed by the claimants, the only
issue raised by the appellants with regard to the assessment of notional
income of the deceased and the grant of filial consortium. Perusal of the
impugned award reveals that the learned Tribunal, while assessing the
compensation, took the notional income of the deceased minor at Rs.
3,000/- per month, applied the multiplier of 18 and, after deducting 50%
towards his personal and living expenses, assessed the loss of dependency
at Rs. 3,24,000/-. The learned Tribunal further awarded a sum of Rs.
40,000/- towards loss of filial consortium.
17.
In Kajal v. Jagdish Chand & Ors., (2020) 4 SCC 413, Hon‟ble the Supreme
Court assessed the notional income on the basis of the Minimum Wages
payable to a skilled workman and opined that the same would be reflective
of the minimum amount which she would have earned on becoming major.
18.
Later, in Master Ayush vs. Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance
Co. Ltd., (2022) 7 SCC 738, the Apex Court while considering the grant of
compensation to the parents on account of injuries suffered by a five-yearold child, relied upon Kajal‟s case (supra) and observed that the notional
income should be calculated on the basis of minimum wages payable to a
skilled worker.
19.
In the year 2012, the minimum wage for skilled workman was Rs. 200/- per
day, as per the notification of Government of J&K dated 22.01.2010. In the
case of Master Ayush, (supra), the Hon‟ble Apex Court observed that in
addition to the Minimum Wages for skilled worker, the Appellant would be
Mac App Nos. 160/2020 & 30/2021
also entitled to 40% for future prospects in view of the judgment
of National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi & Ors, (2017) 16
SCC 680.
20.
Thus the monthly income of the deceased, as per the minimum wages, was
required to be enhanced @ 40%. The learned Tribunal has applied the
multiplier of 18, which as per the Apex Courts‟ decision in Reshma
Kumari vs. Madan Mohan, (2013) 9 SCC 65, ought to have been 15.The
same judgment has been followed by the Supreme Court in “Divender
Kumar Tripathi v.Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd” (2025) INSC 1429.
21.
Thus, the total compensation on account of loss of dependency would be
Rs. 7,56,000/.[Rs. 6000 p.m. + 40% (Future Prospects) = Rs. 8400/- ii. Rs.
8400- 50% (personal expenses) = Rs. 4200/- iii. Rs. 4200/- x 12 x 15 = Rs.
7,56,000/-.
22.
Further, the learned Tribunal was not correct in awarding a sum of Rs.
40,000/ to both the claimants under the head of “Loss of Filial
Consortium”. The sum of Rs. 40,000/ each was required to be paid to both
the claimants under this head.
23.
Accordingly, the award of the learned Tribunal is modified, and appellantInsurance Company is directed to pay Rs. 8,66,000/- as compensation to the
claimants under the following heads:
a. Loss of dependency
= Rs. 7,56,000/
b. Funeral Expenses
= Rs. 15,000/
c. Loss of Estate
= Rs. 15,000/
d. Loss of Filial Consortium
= Rs. 80,000/
Total:
Mac App Nos. 160/2020 & 30/2021
Rs. 8,66,000/-
24.
The interest component shall remain the same. Appellant-Insurance
Company shall deposit the balance amount within a period of one month
from today and upon such deposit, the amount shall be released in favour of
claimants after their due identification and deducting the requisite court fee
in accordance with law. Mac App No. 30/2021 is accordingly disposed of.
The claimants shall furnish the bank account details of their accounts and
the amount of compensation be transferred to the said accounts in
accordance with the order passed by the learned Tribunal.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
Jammu
21.08.2026
Rakesh PS
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
KARAM CHAND
2026.08.20 22:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Mac App Nos. 160/2020 & 30/2021
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review