Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on : 23.07.2026
Pronounced on: 04.08.2026
Uploaded on: 05.08.2026
WP(C) No.2410/2023
And
WP(C) No.2142/2023
WP(C) No.2410/2023
1. Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir
through Commissioner Secretary to Govt.,
Finance Department, Civil Secretariat,
Srinagar/Jammu
2. Director General Accounts & Treasuries,
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar/Jammu
3. Deputy Director (Central), Accounts &
Treasuries Haft Chinar Iqbal Park
Srinagar Kashmir.
4. District Treasury Officer, Kulgam
Kashmir.
5. Sub Treasury Officer, Qazigund Anantnag
Kashmir.
6. Chief Engineer, PHE Kashmir.
7. Executive Engineer PHE Division Qazigund
Anantnag Kashmir.
....Petitioner(s)
Through:- Ms. Maha Majeed, Advocate vice
Mr. Mohsin Qadiri, Sr. AAG
Versus
Abdul Wahid Dar
S/o: Gh. Ahmad Dar
R/o: Chadder Tehsil Qaimoh
District Kulgam
...Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Shuja ul Haq, Advocate
WP(C) No.2142/2023
1.
2.
Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir
through Commissioner Secretary to Govt.,
Finance Department, Civil Secretariat
Srinagar/Jammu.
Director General Accounts & Treasuries,
WP(C) Nos.2410/2023 & 2142/2023
3.
4.
5.
6.
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar/Jammu.
Deputy Director (Central), Accounts &
Treasuries Haft Chinar Iqbal Park
Srinagar Kashmir.
District Treasury Officer, Kulgam
Kashmir.
Sub Treasury Officer, Qazigund Anantnag
Kashmir.
Executive Engineer PHE Division Qazigund
Anantnag Kashmir.
....Petitioner(s)
Through:- Ms. Maha Majeed, Advocate vice
Mr. Mohsin Qadiri, Sr. AAG
Versus
Abdul Wahid Dar
S/o: Gh. Ahmad Dar
R/o: Chadder Tehsil Qaimoh
District Kulgam
...Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Shuja ul Haq, Advocate
Coram: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Sanjeev Kumar Chief Justice (Acting)
1.
In both these petitions, filed by the Union Territory of Jammu
and Kashmir and five others under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, an order and judgment dated 08.02.2023
passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Srinagar Bench,
Srinagar [“the Tribunal”] in TA No.2314/2021 along with TA
No.3368/2021 titled Abdul Waheed Dar v. State of J&K and
others is under challenge.
2.
By virtue of the judgment impugned dated 08.02.2023 (supra),
the Tribunal has allowed the TAs of the respondent and directed
WP(C) Nos.2410/2023 & 2142/2023
the petitioners herein not to initiate any recovery proceedings
against the respondent for the period w.e.f. 30.04.2013 to
07.06.2017. The respondent has been held entitled to retain the
salary for the aforesaid period on the ground that the respondent
had actually performed his duties beyond his date of
superannuation and, therefore, is entitled to be compensated for
the work which he had done during the period of his overstay in
service.
3.
Briefly stated, facts leading to the filing of these petitions, as
are gatherable from the pleadings of the parties before the
Tribunal, are that the respondent was appointed as Accounts
Assistant in the department of Finance in the year 1989. While
he was in service, a complaint regarding mutilation of date of
birth of the respondent was received by the petitioners in the
year 2013. In the complaint, it was alleged that the date of birth
of
the
respondent,
which
was
04.04.1955
had
been
mutilated/fabricated as 04.04.1958.
4.
With a view to verify the date of birth certificate of the
respondent, the Director Accounts and Treasuries took up the
matter with the J&K Board of School Education [“the Board”].
Vide communication dated 26th March, 2014. The Board
furnished a verification report certifying that the date of birth
certificate forwarded by the petitioners for verification was
genuine. Relying upon the report of the Board conveyed vide
WP(C) Nos.2410/2023 & 2142/2023
communication dated 26th March, 2014, the complaint was
closed.
5.
Later, the petitioners received another communication from the
Board dated 23.06.2016, certifying that the actual date of birth
of the respondent, as per the Board’s record, is 04.04.1955 and
not 04.04.1958. The Board also declared the certificate of date
of birth forwarded for verification as fake and fraudulent. Faced
with the aforesaid position, the petitioners once again referred
the matter to the Board for re-verification by issuing
communication on 19th September, 2016. The Joint Secretary
Verification of Kashmir Division of the Board intimated vide its
communication dated 02.10.2016 that the verification report
forwarded on 23rd June, 2016 was absolutely correct that that
the date of birth of the respondent was 04.04.1955. In view of
the clear cut report submitted by the Board regarding the actual
date of birth of the respondent, the petitioner-department
decided to proceed against the respondent in accordance with
law. Accordingly, charge-sheet dated 26.10.2016 was served
upon the respondent, who was then working as Assistant
Accounts Officer in PHE Division, Qazigund, Kashmir.
6.
Before the petitioners-department could proceed further, the
respondent hurriedly approached this Court through the medium
of SWP No.1675/2016, which was disposed of by a Single
Bench of this Court vide order dated 08.05.2017, thereby
WP(C) Nos.2410/2023 & 2142/2023
directing the petitioners to follow due course of law before
taking any further action in the matter.
7.
In compliance with the order of this Court passed by a Single
Judge of this Court dated 08.05.2017, a show cause notice dated
23.05.2017 was served upon the respondent giving him an
opportunity of hearing and to present himself before the
authorities. He was also directed to furnish documents, if any,
in his defence. The respondent neither appeared before the
authorities nor did he produce any document in defence within
the prescribed period. The enquiry was, thus, concluded vide
order No.126-Acctts of 2017 dated 07.06.2017. The respondent
was directed to have retired from service on superannuation
w.e.f. 30.04.2013, on the basis of his actual and correct date of
birth i.e. 04.04.1955, as authenticated by the Board vide its
communication dated 02.10.2016.
8.
Order dated 07.06.2017 came to be challenged by the
respondent by way of SWP No.1211/2017. Later on, with a
view to prevent recovery of the salary received by the
respondent during the period of his overstay in service, the
respondent filed SWP No.2588/2018 before this Court. Both the
writ petitions came to be transferred to the Tribunal and
registered as TA Nos.2314/2021 and 3368/2021, which have
been disposed of by the Tribunal in terms of the judgment
impugned.
WP(C) Nos.2410/2023 & 2142/2023
9.
The impugned judgment is called in question by the petitioners
primarily on the ground that the Tribunal failed to appreciate
that the respondent had overstayed in service beyond his actual
date of superannuation on the basis of interpolation/
manipulation made in his date of birth certificate. It is submitted
that once the date of birth certificate, relied upon by the
respondent, was found to be fake by the competent authority i.e.
J&K State Board of School Education and the respondent failed
to defend the same before the enquiry officer, the respondent
could not have claimed the salary he had received by playing
fraud.
10.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent would
submit that the judgment passed by the Tribunal is in
consonance with law, in that, the Tribunal has directed the
petitioners not to recover the salary paid to the respondent for
the work the respondent had actually performed, may be,
beyond the date of his superannuation.
11.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record, we are of the considered opinion that the
judgment passed by the Tribunal is legally flawed and,
therefore, cannot be upheld.
12.
Indisputably, the respondent was liable to be retired on
superannuation w.e.f. 30th April, 2013, as per the actual date of
WP(C) Nos.2410/2023 & 2142/2023
birth recorded in the records of the J&K State Board of School
Education. The respondent relied upon a fake and fabricated
certificate of date of birth, which indicated his date of birth as
04.04.1958 instead of his actual date of birth i.e. 04.04.1955.
The fraud committed by the respondent would have gone
unnoticed and the respondent would have overstayed in service
till 07.06.2017 without anybody asking him any question. This,
however, did not happen as someone, who knew the
manipulation of date of birth by the respondent, made a
complaint to the petitioners in the year 2013. The complaint
triggered enquiry and verification of date of birth certificate
produced by the respondent. The certificate of date of birth
produced by the respondent was forwarded to the competent
authority i.e. Board, which initially found the same genuine, but
later on, upon re-verification came to the conclusion that the
date of birth certificate was fake and forged and that as per their
records, the date of birth of the respondent was 04.04.1955. The
Board even went to the extent of declaring the earlier
communication dated 26.03.2014 issued by the Board also a
fake piece of document.
13.
Be that as it may, the petitioners, after having found the date of
birth certificate relied upon by the respondent fake and forged,
conducted an enquiry into the matter so as to afford an
opportunity of hearing to the respondent. The respondent chose
WP(C) Nos.2410/2023 & 2142/2023
not to appear before the enquiry office nor did he produce any
document in his defence. The petitioners were, thus, left with no
option but to accept the two verification reports submitted by
the Board and conclude that the date of birth of the respondent
was 04.04.1955 and not 04.04.1958, as indicated in the date of
birth certificate produced by the respondent.
14.
The fraud, manipulation and forgery committed by the
respondent or someone on his behalf is not disputed. It is
undeniable that the forgery and manipulation of date of birth
was clearly to the benefit of the respondent and, therefore, it
would not be appropriate to say that the petitioners have not
firmly established that the manipulation of date of birth was an
act of fraud committed by the respondent and the respondent
alone.
15.
The respondent also does not dispute this factual position. The
Tribunal, however, has shown misplaced compassion, sympathy
and benevolence by providing that notwithstanding that the
respondent was liable to be retired on superannuation w.e.f.
30.04.2013 on the basis of his actual date of birth and that he
overstayed in service on the basis of a forged certificate, he
cannot be deprived of the emoluments he had received for the
actual work done by him on the post. We are afraid such
benevolent view in a clear case of fraud is not tenable and is
highly uncalled for.
WP(C) Nos.2410/2023 & 2142/2023
16.
Needless to say that fraud vitiates everything. It is well settled
that if any employee continues beyond his superannuation on
the basis of a forged document or by committing fraud, no legal
right can flow from such fraud and the employer is well within
its right to recover the benefits fraudulently drawn by such
employee. Once it is established that an employee has
manipulated or forged his date of birth and has suppressed the
actual date of birth, his continuation beyond his actual date of
birth is void and salary and allowances and other monetary
benefits drawn by such an employee for the period of fraudulent
overstay are recoverable under the principle of restitution.
17.
We could understand that if an employee draws excess benefits
or payment, which was not payable to him due to an
administrative error during his service career, the employer is
restrained from making recoveries at the fag end of his career or
after superannuation, that too, when such employee is a Class-C
or Class-D employee. However, if the benefit is drawn willfully
by misrepresentation or committing fraud, employee cannot be
permitted to retain such benefit. Allowing such an employee to
retain the benefit(s) fraudulently obtained/retained by him
would be putting premium on the fraud or misrepresentation
committed by him. The Tribunal has not considered all these
aspects of the matter and was swayed away only by a singular
fact that the respondent had actually worked and, therefore,
WP(C) Nos.2410/2023 & 2142/2023
needed to be compensated for the work done. We are afraid
such approach of the Tribunal cannot be countenanced. The
respondent, who had managed his overstay in service by
manipulating his date of birth, is not entitled to reap the benefits
of his fraud.
18.
For the foregoing reasons, both the petitions are allowed. The
judgment passed by the Tribunal is set aside. The TAs filed by
the respondent before the Tribunal are dismissed.
(Mohd Yousuf Wani)
Judge
SRINAGAR
04.08.2026
Vinod, Secy
Whether order is reportable: Yes
Vinod Kumar
2026.08.05 12:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Chief Justice (A)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review