The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. In view of the foregoing, the petitions are disposed of in the following terms: (i) WP(C) No. 1928/2025 is allowed by quashing the impugned order bearing No. 53/DDC/TSP/BPR of 2025 dated 04.08.2025. The respondents are left free to relocate the Tehsil office at the proposed site, covered under survey No. 107 min in estate Malangam (Gurdal). (ii) WP(C) No. 455/2026 is dismissed, being devoid of merit, as the choice of site lies exclusively within the discretion of the executive and no legal right of the petitioners stands infringed. (iii) Any interim direction operating in either petition shall stand vacated. (iv) Nothing in this order shall preclude the respondents from taking any lawful decision regarding the site in future, in accordance with law and on relevant considerations, should any bona fide administrative need arise. (v) There shall be no order as to costs. (vi) Connected CMs, if any, shall also stand disposed of accordingly.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 17
Regular
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP (C) No. 1928/2025 c/w
WP (C) No. 455/2026
i)
ii)
Inhabitants of Tehsil Aloosa District Bandipora
…Petitioner(s)..
Through:- Ms Asma Rashid, Advocate
Mohammad Shafi Tas (Gojar) and others
Through: Mr B A. Misri, Advocate
v.
Union Territory of J&K and others
Through:- Mr Illyas Nazir, GA
Mr B. A. Misri, Advocate
CORAM:
HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE MOKSHA KHAJURIA KAZMI, JUDGE
ORDER
04.11.2026
01.
Both these petitions arise out of the same decision of the
respondents and raise a common question. They have, therefore, been heard
together and are being disposed of by this common order.
BRIEF FACTS:
02.
The respondents, in exercise of their administrative powers, have
identified and selected a site, at Aloosa, Bandipora, for construction of
Tehsil office for which the administrative approval has been granted in
terms of Order No. 53/DDC/TSP/BPR of 2025 dated 04.08.2025,
hereinafter for short to be referred as ‘impugned order’. The petitioners of
WP (C) no. 1928/2025 had moved a representation to the concerned
authorities for construction of tehsil office at Aloosa, Burdal, which had
been entertained by constituting a committee who had to report within
seven days about the feasibility of the site and its recommendations. During
WP (C) 1928/2025, WP(C) 455/2026
the currency of such prescribed period the impugned order was issued
constraining the petitioners to file a writ petition, registered as WP (C) No.
1928/2025.
03.
On the other hand, the writ petitioners of WP(C) no. 455/2026
are objecting to the site proposed by the petitioners of first writ petition for
construction of Tehsil Office.
04.
In WP(C) No. 1928/2025, the petitioners seek a writ of certiorari
to quash the order No. 53/DDC/TSP/BPR of 2025 dated 04.08.2025 for
being arbitrary and non-speaking, besides seeking writs of mandamus and
prohibition to direct respondents 2 and to 3 to pass a fresh reasoned order
after receiving the committee report and prohibit the respondents from
raising any construction unless proper location is specified and public
interest is evaluated.
05.
In WP(C) No. 455/2026, the petitioners seek a writ of
prohibition restraining the respondents from raising any construction of
Tehsil Office at any site other than the one where the same is existing. The
petitioners have also sought a writ of mandamus commanding the
respondents not to change the present status and nature of Kahcharai land
falling under survey Nos. 107, 111 & 112 situated at Mallengam, Tehsil
Aloosa, Bandipora.
06.
The respondents have filed their reply to the first writ petition
wherein they concede that the proposed land at Aloosa Burdal is more
suitable for the construction of Tehsil office. It would be profitable to
reproduce the relevant portion of the reply herein:
“2. ….It is worth to mention herein the proposed location at Aloosa as
well as the location at Gurdal Malangam are accessible and
WP (C) no. 1928/2025 c/w 455/2026
connected by roads from all sides. It is further submitted that the
matter was examined and in this regard a committee was constituted
with the mandate to recommend the suitable location for the said
construction, besides conducting meetings/ discussions with all the
stakeholders, spot visits conducted by answering respondents
including the respondent No. 02, and keeping in mind the availability
of sufficient space required for future and further establishment of
offices/ accommodations, it has been found that the location at
Gurdal Malangam can be a better choice for construction of the said
Tehsil office building.” (emphasis supplied)
07.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record,
including the reply filed by the respondents.
08.
Ms Asma Rashid, learned counsel for the petitioners in the first
petition submits that the impugned order is bad in law for having been
issued at a time when the representation of the petitioners seeking shifting
of Tehsil Office to Burdal Aloosa was under consideration of the
competent authority and is adequately feasible from all perspectives to
house the Tehsil office; that construction of the tehsil office at the site for
which the funds have been allotted in terms of the impugned order would
cause wastage of public funds.
09.
Mr B. A. Misri, learned counsel for the petitioners in the second
petition submits that the site sought to be projected by the petitioners in the
first petition for construction of Tehsil Office would be to the prejudice of
the petitioners, the identified land is a Kahcharai land on which the
livestock of the petitioners is wholly and solely depend upon. Learned
counsel submits that the Tehsil office has been in existence at Aloosa for
quite a long time now and its relocation would serve no fruitful purpose.
WP (C) no. 1928/2025 c/w 455/2026
10.
Mr Illyas Nazir, learned Government Advocate submits that the
site projected by the petitioners in the first writ petition for construction of
Tehsil Office is undoubtedly feasible in all possible ways and except for
involving more amount for its construction, the site is perfect for the
purpose keeping in view the availability of State land, accessibility, and the
suitability of the plot for construction; that the choice of location is an
administrative function; and that no legal or statutory right vests in either
petitioner to insist upon a particular site.
Analysis:
11.
The controversy, stripped of its detail, is one of preference as
between two sites. The question for determination is whether this Court, in
exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
can direct the executive to locate a public building at a place of the
petitioner's choosing, or to restrain it from doing so at the place it has
chosen.
12.
The location of a public building such as a Tehsil Office is a
matter that falls within the domain of executive discretion. It involves a
weighing of several considerations, namely the availability and title of
land, the demographic spread of the Tehsil, accessibility, cost, suitability of
terrain, and the existing infrastructure. These are matters on which the
executive is better placed, by expertise and experience, than a writ court.
The Court does not sit in appeal over the wisdom of such a decision, nor
does it substitute its own view for that of the competent authority.
13.
The scope of judicial review in such matters is confined to the
decision-making process and not the decision itself. As held in Tata
WP (C) no. 1928/2025 c/w 455/2026
Cellular v. Union of India, (1994) 6 SCC 651, the Court may interfere
where the decision is tainted by illegality, irrationality or procedural
impropriety, but it cannot examine the correctness of the decision on
merits. The principle was reiterated in Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa,
(2007) 14 SCC 517, wherein it was observed that the Court must not
interfere merely because a different decision was possible or because the
petitioner finds another course more desirable.
14.
Tested on these touchstones, nothing has been shown that would
vitiate the selection of the site. There is no allegation of mala fides, nor is
any statutory provision or binding guideline pointed out that has been
violated. The selected site is Government land, and the respondents have
furnished a reasoned justification for choosing it. The mere fact that
another site may be more convenient to a section of residents does not
render the choice arbitrary or unreasonable. In any public project of this
nature, a measure of inconvenience to some is inevitable, and a preference
for one site over another, however sincerely held, does not translate into a
legally enforceable right.
15.
As regards the petitioners in the WP (C) No. 455/2026, no right,
statutory or otherwise, has been demonstrated to compel the respondents to
establish the Tehsil Office at the alternative site. A writ of mandamus lies
only to enforce a legal duty owed by the authority to the petitioner. In the
absence of any such duty, the relief sought is, in essence, a prayer that this
Court override the discretion vested in the executive, which is
impermissible. The grievance raised is one of policy preference and not of
legal injury.
WP (C) no. 1928/2025 c/w 455/2026
16.
As regards the petitioners in WP (C) No. 1928/2025, the decision
to relocate the Tehsil office at the site proposed by the petitioners has been
found to be in consonance with the stand of the respondents themselves.
17.
In view of the foregoing, the petitions are disposed of in the
following terms:
(i) WP(C) No. 1928/2025 is allowed by quashing the
impugned order bearing No. 53/DDC/TSP/BPR of 2025
dated 04.08.2025. The respondents are left free to relocate
the Tehsil office at the proposed site, covered under survey
No. 107 min in estate Malangam (Gurdal).
(ii) WP(C) No. 455/2026 is dismissed, being devoid of
merit, as the choice of site lies exclusively within the
discretion of the executive and no legal right of the
petitioners stands infringed.
(iii) Any interim direction operating in either petition shall
stand vacated.
(iv) Nothing in this order shall preclude the respondents
from taking any lawful decision regarding the site in future,
in accordance with law and on relevant considerations,
should
any
bona
fide
administrative
need
arise.
(v) There shall be no order as to costs.
(vi) Connected CMs, if any, shall also stand disposed of
accordingly.
18.
A copy of this order shall be kept on each file.
(MOKSHA KHAJURIA KAZMI)
JUDGE
Srinagar.
04.11.2026
Amjad lone, Joint Registrar/Secretary
Whether the judgment is speaking :Yes
Whether the order is reportable
:No
WP (C) no. 1928/2025 c/w 455/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review